Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on the results of the G20 in London regarding the regulation of the international financial system, in London on April 2, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

2 April 2009 · G20 London Summit · London, United Kingdom

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference at the G20 London Summit on April 2, 2009, presenting France's assessment of landmark agreements on global financial system reform.
Main themes
G20 London summit results, international financial regulation reform, hedge fund regulation, trader compensation principles, rating agency transparency, accounting and prudential standards reform, securitization traceability, bank capital definition harmonization, off-balance-sheet items, global economic crisis exit strategy, Bretton Woods comparison, procyclicality provisions
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,678
90th percentile
Sentences
224
91st percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
10.2
23rd percentile
Syntax
2.99
47th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
30th percentile

G7 / G20 Summit Communiqués Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

224 sentences in 59 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - I apologize for my delay, which is due to the length of the discussions that occupied us for part of the night and, of course, since this morning without interruption. I am in a position to present the results to you; Gordon BROWN will, of course, make public the final communiqué that we agreed upon at lunchtime and during part of the afternoon.

The Heads of State and Government of the G20 have therefore decided to profoundly reform the international financial organization, which has never been done to this extent since the Bretton Woods agreements in 1945.

We have agreed on an exit strategy from the global economic crisis, which is the most serious in the last 70 years. In Washington, we approved principles, and we agreed that the decisions were for the London summit.

The first type of decisions we made is the commitment of the Heads of State and Government to strengthen the regulation and supervision of financial activities. This was a priority for Germany and France; this priority is included as one of the key objectives, number two for the Heads of State and Government, and is the subject, as you will see in the documents that will be released, of a solemn and specific declaration regarding financial regulation. Regulation is therefore a priority of the G20 and is the subject of a solemn declaration that you will see is quite detailed. You will see, in particular, that in paragraph 10 of the communiqué, there is mention of serious failures in the financial sector and serious failures in regulation as the origin of the crisis. It is now established that it is the failure of regulation that is at the origin of the financial crisis, which in turn is the origin of the economic crisis.

We have achieved results on hedge funds, which today represent 1.2 trillion dollars in investments; they will now be regulated, they will be subject to a reporting obligation, mandatory registration, transparency in fund management rules, and control of banks' commitments to these funds. This is unprecedented. Until now, hedge funds were not subject to any obligations.

Regarding traders' compensation, we have adopted common principles. The declaration details what responsible salary policy will be. And those who have risky policies will bear the cost in terms of capital requirements. To be clear, supervisors will be able to impose on banks that do not have a reasonable trader compensation system, obligations in terms of increasing their capital. Again, this is unprecedented.

On rating agencies, a code of good conduct will be established to avoid conflicts of interest and will require rating agencies to be transparent, particularly regarding their dual role of rating and investing.

On accounting and prudential standards, there are many advances. We have agreed on a declaration that provides for a review of accounting principles when the market reference does not make sense and for long-term investments. In truth, this is a challenge to the notion of "fair value," which has been the bible until now.

There will be systems for setting aside bank profits during periods of growth that must constitute provisions so as not to have to tighten requirements when precisely credit is needed for the economy. This is the whole debate on procyclicality.

We have also decided that a portion of the risk arising from securitization will be retained on banks' balance sheets. I apologize for the technicality, but this is the entire question of the traceability of securitization that is retained by the G20. There was a debate on the percentage. We were almost able to agree on 5%. We fought less on this because I think we will need to go beyond 5%. To give you an idea of the countless debates we had. The idea is that a hedge fund that engages in securitization or a bank that engages in securitization must retain a portion of the securitized loan on its balance sheet. But we did not set the 5% in the communiqué. Germany and France, we would like to go beyond that, but what is retained is the principle. You understand that while there are many people around the table, the principle of traceability of securitization is established. It is retained.

It is also retained that the definition of banks' capital will be harmonized before the end of the year. You see the interest in all this; it is that competition among banks will no longer be based on lowering security requirements since we will have a definition. Again, we did not agree on the content of what will or will not be capital; the G20 Finance Ministers will work on this, but we agreed that there would now be an international standard that will define capital. Again, this is unprecedented.

Finally, on the last point, there are many others in this chapter, we have decided to reintegrate off-balance-sheet items. You know what I think about off-balance-sheet items in the calculation of capital requirements set by supervisors. To be clear, supervisory authorities will require capital commensurate with the banks' balance sheets - what they have lent - to which off-balance-sheet items will be added.

That our Anglo-Saxon friends have accepted all this is a tremendous progress; I believe that never in a meeting of this nature have we been able to progress so much.

On tax havens - which have been the subject of debate until just a few minutes ago - in the communiqué, you will see a sentence that I quote: "the era of banking secrecy is over." I say, it is a principle, "the era of banking secrecy is over," signed by the twenty countries around the table. A list of sanctions is provided, I am talking about non-cooperative jurisdictions, tax havens, in the declaration. They range from increased administrative burdens to prohibiting international organizations from placing funds in these states. A range of sanctions must be defined by the Finance Ministers, even if a number are provided in the declaration.

Furthermore, we contacted the leaders of the OECD during the meeting to publish the list of tax havens. A publication today, within two hours, since Gordon BROWN spoke to them on the phone. And the communiqué takes note of the list of tax havens published by the OECD. I must be truthful in saying that it was a very frank discussion. Everyone around the table wants to put an end to tax havens; there was no divergence in this regard; everyone is aware of the need to sanction them. The only technical problem we had was this: a number of countries around the table are not members of the Global Forum. It is honest to say that we cannot ask them to comply with rules when they are not yet in the forum. They have a deadline to join the Global Forum, but all have agreed that an explicit reference to the list of tax havens as defined by the OECD would be included in the communiqué. I add that it is better for the organization that monitors tax havens to publish the list rather than the G20, which does not have a general secretariat and is not specialized in this issue.

As for the rest, I will go much more quickly before answering questions. There is an unprecedented increase in the resources of financial institutions, particularly the IMF, which will amount to 500 billion in loans. We will provide an additional 850 billion dollars to financial institutions, 500 billion in loans for the IMF, which will see its resources triple, not double. 250 billion in special drawing rights, 100 billion for development banks, and we have secured the sale of IMF gold for poor countries. In particular, there will be a doubling of IMF loans for poor countries, especially Africa, which I mentioned during my trip to Brazzaville.

I apologize, you will see the communiqué; this is only to present the main points.

Finally, of course, on the stimulus, we broadly agreed on everything we had done, that if the crisis were to worsen, we would be ready to do more.

Ladies and gentlemen, it is unprecedented that we have been able to reach an agreement of this nature. I must say that the Franco-German axis has worked well. I want to say that Gordon BROWN has been a particularly intellectually honest G20 president, and it has been a pleasure to work with him. He has prioritized his presidency over more traditional positions - to put it briefly - of the Anglo-Saxon world. President OBAMA has truly helped to find consensus. He himself did not focus at all on the stimulus. He was, as much as we were, committed to better regulation, and it was even he who helped me convince President HU Jintao of the reference to the list of tax havens on the OECD, and I want to thank him for that. We have also decided, I proposed it and it was accepted, that the third G20 summit would take place after the General Assembly, or during the United Nations General Assembly in September in New York. Since we are all there, we might as well take advantage of it. The first G20 summit, the principles, Washington; the second G20 summit, the operationalization; the third G20 summit, the evaluation of everything we have decided.

The last point, which was not on my paper, is that we have also decided to create a true global financial organization tasked with proposing crisis plans. We will replace the Financial Stability Forum with a global financial organization. This is very important, and it is important because this global financial organization, which we will call the Financial Stability Council - we will move from the Financial Stability Forum to a Financial Stability Council - and what is very important is that this will allow us to immediately include the major emerging countries in the Financial Stability Council, which is crucial since, naturally, this will allow China, India, and other countries to play their role.

I also want to say - I apologize, my presentation is perhaps a bit disjointed because we just came out and until the last moment, all this was the subject of discussions - the cooperation between supervisors is considerably strengthened, as the various national supervisors will set up the missing colleges to monitor multinational banks. There are national supervisors, even regional ones, and there are regional banks, even international ones; this cannot work. Well, now national supervisors will meet in committees to supervise international banks.

Honestly, to tell the truth, this is beyond what we could have imagined. We are all aware that alone we can do nothing. We are all aware that new rules are needed, a rebuilding of the system; this is what we have done, and I am really happy with the result. I believe we are all happy with the result, and it was even quite moving to see such different countries as China, India, South Africa, Saudi Arabia, Germany, France, and of course the United States agree on such precise measures to address the crisis. Our idea, to conclude, is that to turn our backs on the economic crisis, trust must return; for trust to return, there must be new rules to put an end to the financial crisis.

I say this to Christine LAGARDE, whom I truly thank for her work, her presence, and her collaboration; the G20 Finance Ministers will have a lot of work to do. I also want to pay tribute to Mr. STEINBRUCK, the German Finance Minister, not just because he offered me stamps, which was a kind gesture, but because he helped us a lot in the work.

You will see that all the measures we have decided upon have a method, a timeline, and a responsible party. I will not go into detail because there are many things you will see. Here is the result, and of course, if you have questions, I will be happy to answer them before returning to France.

QUESTION - Regarding the OECD, is the fact that the OECD is tasked with publishing the list a way to circumvent the fact that China, Brazil, and others do not want to associate with the publication of this list? Is there a process that will define the countries that are on the blacklist, the countries on the gray list, and how this will evolve in the future, because you say there is a process for everything?

THE PRESIDENT - Brazil did not pose a problem; the issue simply arose from the fact that to not be on the OECD's blacklist, one must, I speak from memory, have signed information exchange agreements between the target country and twelve other states. I apologize for going into detail again, because all this is quite precise, and for technical reasons, and not at all political, Brazil, to my knowledge, has signed two. That is the problem, but Brazil did not have any difficulty in referring to the OECD list.

China, I will be very honest, we met very late with President Hu Jintao, both for bilateral reasons and also for this issue. It is a traditional position of China not to accept the rules of organizations in which it does not participate. Frankly, this can be understood. But ultimately, following a discussion among the three of us, President Hu Jintao, President Obama, and myself, we reached an agreement. The OECD is publishing the list today and the G20 is taking note of it. It may seem a bit intellectual to you, but I remind you of the difference in positions at the outset. However, if the G20 had published the list directly, it would have been the OECD's list, since the G20 has no administration; whether the OECD publishes today or the G20 publishes today, the result is the same, since, as you know, the G20 would have only taken the OECD's list. What is very important, I believe, is that this is the first time that China has agreed to refer to an organization of which it is not a member.

This is where we have arrived. The work continues since the finance ministers will be in the general assembly of the IMF in 15 days, and the G20 finance ministers are responsible for completing the arsenal of sanctions against tax havens, against non-cooperative jurisdictions in addition to those we have decided upon, that is what we have retained.

So obviously when there are 20 heads of state and government and our sherpas, we went into as much detail as possible, but the exact list of sanctions, the G20 finance ministers are mandated to implement it, and finally, as a result of the evaluation, we are in April, September in New York, G20, independently of the United Nations General Assembly, and in September at the G20, the G20 finance ministers will present to us the details of the sanctions and procedures regarding tax havens. The era of banking secrecy is over.

QUESTION - inaudible

THE PRESIDENT - There were tensions at the summit until half an hour ago, but who can think that such different cultures, sometimes such divergent interests... The world, since Bretton Woods, has lived on a financial model - it is not for me to criticize the Anglo-Saxon model which has its advantages - clearly today, a page has been turned, and that must be done through frank discussions, yes. The question you are asking is whether, if Germany and France had not demanded results of this nature, would they have been given to us spontaneously - a man as experienced as you, in your opinion? But I must also be honest: Gordon Brown played the game, really, President Obama, I must say, it is the truth, helped me on this issue of tax havens, we were numerous enough in the room for you to have the details of what happened and you will see, it is so. I must also say that President Hu Jintao, who has a rather firm position until the end, was willing to consider that referring to the publication of the OECD list in the communiqué was making a link that was, for me, mandatory, and of course, Ms. Merkel, whose ideas I defended.

QUESTION - This is President Obama's first international meeting, how did you find him, how do you compare him to his predecessor?

THE PRESIDENT - Even with your delightful accent, frankly I will not compare them, they each have their qualities. I found him to be an extremely open man, perfectly in line with what we want, which is for politicians to take their responsibilities. It was too much the domain of experts, including on accounting standards. And frankly, it went very, very well. We are going to do good work together. I look forward to welcoming him tomorrow morning in Strasbourg.

QUESTION - Mr. President, do G20 members have a timeline for exiting the crisis? Have they examined a number of scenarios?

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, of course. Dominique Strauss-Kahn, as head of the IMF, spoke about his forecasts and the figures you will see in the communiqué, in terms of job creation, there was a long debate: should we put in numbers or not? These are the analyses of international organizations. We had the President of the World Bank, the Director-General of the WTO, the Director-General of the IMF. They themselves told us what models they were working on for an exit from the crisis during the year 2010.

But for us, of course, it is important, we want to exit the crisis as soon as possible, but what matters is to make decisions. So afterwards, you comment on them, experts will talk about them, but we must make decisions right away. What was the reasoning we put forward? The financial crisis led to an economic crisis, it is not the economic crisis that led to the financial crisis. It is the financial crisis that led to an economic crisis. This financial crisis was caused by the absence of rules. And the absence of rules created a lack of trust. So, we say: we are putting new rules in place to resolve the financial crisis, to recreate trust, and to restart the economy. So afterwards, when will it restart? There are very good figures, for example in France regarding the automobile sector, they are excellent. There are here and there in the world some figures, a few small good news. But when will this lead to results? We hope as soon as possible.

I must also say that our Chinese friends are putting on the table, I believe, 570 billion, if my memory serves me right, dollars. You see, around the table, if I recall the conditions of my meeting with Mr. Barroso at Mr. Bush's at Camp David, it has really advanced a lot. President Hu Jintao is putting 570 billion dollars on the table for stimulus, of course that matters.

We all tried to move forward understanding that we need stimulus and that we need regulation. That on regulation it involved quite profound changes.

QUESTION - Mr. President, where do you place the situation of Switzerland: black? gray? Knowing that Switzerland (inaudible) complementary to not abandon it?

THE PRESIDENT - Listen. I tell my Swiss friends it is not for me to classify. I am not a specialist, I am not an expert. France is part of the Global Forum which is the slightly broader organization than the OECD, because I was too quick, there is the OECD which is the backbone and there is what we call the Global Forum which is a bit broader than the OECD and which deals with the specific issue of tax havens, it is up to that organization to say.

So, there are actually three lists. A white list, a gray list, and a black list. The white list is countries like France that have clarified their position regarding the rules of the Global Forum of the OECD. Switzerland, you are on the gray list because you announced a movement which, if you complete it, will move you up to the white list, and if you do not complete this movement, you will drop back to the black list.

But this is not a judgment from Ms. Merkel, Mr. Sarkozy, or Mr. Obama. There are rules, they are the same for Luxembourg, they are the same for Monaco, they are the same for Andorra. I take, sir, examples that concern France, so that you can be assured of my perfect objectivity. I had Prince Albert, I told him that the commitment he made on behalf of Monaco was moving him towards the white list. But naturally, it will have to be translated into action.

QUESTION - You have spoken several times about China. What is your impression of this meeting with the Chinese President, that both parties agreed to restore bilateral relations, and what is the importance of this result?

QUESTION - Is it true that China asked you never to receive the Dalai Lama again in exchange for your reconciliation?

THE PRESIDENT - No. You know, the Chinese are extremely pragmatic, it would not occur to them to ask for things they would not obtain. To be clear, the meeting with President Hu Jintao was extremely important for me because I care a lot about the strategic partnership with China. It is in everyone's interest that China takes all its responsibilities in the international concert. I have always considered that Asia is crucial and that the partnership with China, the leading power in Asia, is absolutely fundamental.

Throughout my political life, I have considered, like what General de Gaulle decided in 1964, that there is only one China, one only. I have always defended this idea, I have always considered that Tibet is part of China, an idea that I have always defended, as Mr. Chirac defended it, as Mr. Mitterrand defended it, as Mr. Giscard d'Estaing defended it, as General de Gaulle, when he recognized China in 1964, recognized China, Tibet. Moreover, the Dalai Lama himself does not ask for the independence of Tibet. There you go, we have cleared up misunderstandings, I am extremely happy about that. There is no hidden agreement, if that was the question.

QUESTION - Mr. President, regarding the format of the G20, this is the second meeting, there will be a third. Do you think this format is suitable or do you sometimes feel it is too heavy as a structure?

THE PRESIDENT - Really, as you know, it is France as President of Europe that had the idea for the Summit. I was more in favor of a G14 and it is a compromise with Mr. Bush that led to the G20, to be historically accurate.

I think we need a bit of flexibility. First of all, it was not possible not to have a third Summit as long as we are not out of the crisis. I believe we all agree that the G20 must continue at least as long as there is a crisis. Does it have a vocation to last afterwards? I will not make any bets, but at least during the crisis.

But - at France's proposal, by the way, because there is a whole commitment to refuse protectionism, etc. - I indicated that we would not say more than in Washington. Yet we needed to have results. So I proposed that there be a meeting of heads of state to find an agreement. You know very well that this is an idea I have defended from the beginning, a change of method. We agreed that, in Magdalena, in fact for the G14, we would talk about the WTO.

Not to replace, of course, the WTO, Mr. Lamy, but to try in July, in Sardinia, to resolve the India-United States, Europe-United States issues so that Mr. Lamy can then resume the discussion. So, you see, we make a decision at the G20, we will try to make a G14 operational before sending it back to the forum of 177 or I don't know how many countries of the WTO. That is the system we are trying to implement.

QUESTION - For all the French, Europeans, and inhabitants of the planet facing the crisis, concretely what does the G20 bring, that is what they want to know? And then, the second question is where are we on the road to the refoundation of capitalism that you are calling for?

THE PRESIDENT - There, you are being harsh because I thought I had explained a bit anyway. What I am announcing to all of you who have been following these issues for a long time is an absolutely considerable change. But not just the decisions, the simple fact that we are talking about it. Moreover, we have talked about it and made decisions. If that is not a refoundation!

Listen, agreeing with the Americans and the British on an international system for compensating traders and on reasonable compensation, if that is not the moralization of capitalism, what is it? Putting hedge funds under the control of supervisors, if that is not the refoundation of capitalism, what is it? Publishing the list, the same day we make decisions with sanctions to back them for tax havens. Listen, 62% of hedge funds are located in tax havens, we are right in the middle of it.

Where I agree with you, of course, it is probably my fault, it is both technical, precise, but to say: will this give me a job? Obviously, controlling hedge funds does not create a job in textiles, but at the same time, the madness of the abuse of the hedge fund system led to an economic crisis. We cannot agree that the financial crisis impacted people's daily lives by creating unemployment, and not consider that new financial rules will have no impact on people's lives.

Am I making myself understood? We cannot say: the financial crisis created unemployment - take the means to put an end to the crisis and turn the page on the madness of those years of complete deregulation and say that this will have no impact on people's daily lives. What do you want me to say?

I would like to add that all the efforts for recovery that are being made, the willingness to see the WTO agreement through to the end, is still extremely important. Frankly, I tell you, there have been moments of some tension, but honestly, we never thought we would achieve such a broad agreement. It is not the victory of one camp over another, of one vision over another. It is the realization by everyone that the world must change. I think that is the most interesting part. Of course there are tensions, of course there are power struggles, of course there are interests, but even our Anglo-Saxon friends are now convinced that reasonable rules must be established. But we, Mrs. MERKEL and I, do not want to go from a lack of rules to an excess of rules. I want that to be clear.

QUESTION - My question is about protectionism; it was not mentioned in Mr. Gordon BROWN's introductory remarks. Did you discuss support for Barack Obama's request?

THE PRESIDENT - No. I do not know if Gordon BROWN did not mention it, but the freedom of trade and the rejection of protectionism are the subject of several paragraphs and a specific declaration. What do we all have in mind? The crisis of '29. Not that it is the same, not at all. Not that it is of the same nature, but in '29 all parts of the world retracted into themselves and that worsened the crisis. So we do not want to do the same thing. I spoke to you about Magdalena and what we are going to do. Listen, thank you in any case for following this summit with great attention.