Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. David Cameron, Prime Minister of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, notably on Franco-British military cooperation, in London on November 2, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

2 November 2010 · Joint press conference on Franco-British military cooperation · London

Context
Sarkozy and Cameron held a joint press conference in London on November 2, 2010, following the signing of two landmark Franco-British defense and nuclear cooperation treaties.
Main themes
Franco-British defense cooperation, bilateral defense treaties, counterterrorism, nuclear deterrence cooperation, joint expeditionary force, aircraft carrier interoperability, defense budget austerity, national sovereignty, NATO, equipment sharing, cybersecurity, Yemen security threat
Duration
~33 min
85th percentile
Words
3,968
85th percentile
Sentences
210
90th percentile
Readability
56
78th percentile
Grade
10.1
22nd percentile
Syntax
2.90
35th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

210 sentences in 52 paragraphs

The events of the last 72 hours have reminded us that our societies and our security have never been so intertwined, and that as soon as terrorist threats, from cyberspace, from nuclear proliferation cross borders, our response must also be cross-border. We must therefore cooperate more closely between partners, between allies. Our experts must work hand in hand on Yemen, our transport specialists must share their information. Terrorists think that the fact that our societies are open, that we are open to the world and connected, is a weakness. They are mistaken. Nicolas and I are determined and resolute to show that it is, on the contrary, the source of our strength, of our solidarity, and that it is this strength that will enable us to win against terrorism. Thus, we are opening a new chapter in security and defense relations between Great Britain and France.

We have signed two treaties: one commits our frontline forces to work more closely than ever, and the other concerns cooperation in nuclear safety. The result is that our citizens will be safer, more secure, and better protected in this era of uncertainty that we are experiencing. This will also help us maintain and strengthen our defenses at a time when budget austerity is in place.

First of all, I would like to reject a number of preconceived ideas or myths. This is not, as some suggest, about diminishing French or British sovereignty, it is not about establishing a European army, it is not about sharing our nuclear deterrence. I want to be very clear on this: Great Britain and France are and will always remain sovereign nations, capable of deploying their own armed forces independently, according to our national interest, whenever we see fit. But let us not forget that the only times British forces have deployed alone in the last 30 years were in Sierra Leone and the Falklands. The bulk of our operations - Bosnia, Kosovo, and Afghanistan in particular - have been conducted together, jointly with our allies.

So I will tell you what this Franco-British defense treaty contains. It is about defending our national interests, it is about implementing practical and well-understood cooperation between our countries, it is about distributing and sharing the costs of development, support, avoiding duplication, coordinating logistics, adjusting programs. If we do all this, then we can extend our sovereignty in terms of capability, but at a time of budget austerity. France and Great Britain are natural partners; we are 4th and 5th in the world in defense spending and we are permanent members of the UN Security Council. We both have the will and the capacity to play our role on the world stage. President SARKOZY has shown his sense of leadership by bringing France back into NATO's command, and I commend him for that, and it is another reason why France is logically, practically, and obviously a natural partner for Great Britain in defense.

You will be able to find the details by referring to the treaty. This is the beginning of something new; it is not the end of a process. I would just like to emphasize a number of specific points.

First, we will create a joint inter-army expeditionary force; this is about deploying quickly on joint operations if we wish, but we will retain the capacity to deploy separately.

Second, we will cooperate on aircraft carriers. The last government ordered aircraft carriers that could not easily operate with our partners -- France and the United States -- that was madness. Thanks to the decision we have made, we will adapt our aircraft carrier capability to be able to operate with France and the United States. And by the time the new aircraft carrier arrives, at the end of the decade, we will have the capacity to deploy integrated Franco-British naval air forces, so that there will always be an aircraft carrier available for operations.

Third, we will cooperate on equipment. We will work together on the purchase of the A400M transport aircraft and we will share our logistical support. There will also be drones and cybersecurity technologies.

Fourth, even though we will always maintain an independent nuclear deterrent, we need to seek more efficiency in the infrastructure necessary to develop and support our two deterrents. So rather than doing the same thing separately, an effort that would be costly for the security of our means, we will share our knowledge, our expertise, and thus save millions of pounds.

Our history is common with two world wars; our brave troops fight every day side by side in Afghanistan. I will conclude by saying that this is a treaty based on pragmatism, not just feelings, and I thank Nicolas for having, with me, made these courageous and important decisions that, in my opinion, will make our sovereign nations safer.

Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT -- Thank you, David. I would also like to say how happy the French delegation and I are to be the guests of our English friends, how much we want to work hand in hand with you, and how much we admire the courage and vision of David CAMERON and his government.

All the conditions are in place for an absolutely exceptional relationship between Great Britain and France. Two permanent members of the Security Council, two nuclear powers, two high-performing defense industries, and together, we English and French represent half of the defense budget of all of Europe. The evidence of collaboration, friendship, and trust between us is clear.

We have decided to launch military nuclear cooperation. This is an unprecedented decision. It is a level of trust between our two nations never before seen in history. We will therefore share a simulation facility in France related to our nuclear deterrents and an associated research center.

We have signed a defense treaty that will allow us to establish a joint expeditionary force, which will be able to conduct high-intensity operations in times of crisis. I thank David CAMERON for choosing to put catapults on the English aircraft carriers. This will allow us, and this is very important, to deploy a truly integrated naval air group around our aircraft carriers. This is an extremely important decision on the part of our English friends.

Drones: apart from small tactical drones, there are no European drones; this cannot continue. We are launching today the work for a future surveillance drone within the next ten years.

Industry: we will unify the Franco-British missile sector with new missile programs.

Cyber defense: we will develop cooperation in cyber defense, which is a major issue.

The list is long, which will create new interdependencies -- I accept this -- while respecting our sovereignty. And you know, my dear English friends, in France, sovereignty is as crucial a question as it is in England. But together, we will be stronger. Together, we will do better. Together, we will better defend the values that are ours. Moreover, we have a common point between the French government and the British government, which is that we believe that the security effort must not be relaxed, whatever the constraints in the dangerous world we live in.

I also add that at a time when it is fashionable to say that Europe is experiencing a certain strategic contraction, we, English and French, are showing that this is not the case. So, each of us has our way of talking about Europe; I respect that, and it is only natural. But still, England and France allying to this extent and putting their capabilities to the service of a common defense policy is a historical fact that will also allow us to achieve a number of savings.

Of course, if we are doing this, it is because we agree on the major issues of international security. We will go to the NATO summit with a shared vision of the future of the alliance. I have always defended, in France, the idea that France's place is at the heart of NATO, precisely to have more influence. And if this decision has brought the English and the French closer together, all the better. What are we waiting for? To be divided? Who will gain anything? England? France? Certainly not. We have common commitments, and we will fulfill them together.

I would also like to, in front of the ministers, Christine LAGARDE, Hervé MORIN, Bernard KOUCHNER, Eric BESSON, commend the other areas of collaboration. Immigration, having had to manage Sangatte as Minister of the Interior, I am pleased that we have decided to have joint teams to combat this odious trafficking that is based on human misery and that brings so many immigrants blinded by promises made by true modern-day slave traders to Western Europe.

I also want to say how happy I was with our collaboration, dear David, last weekend with Angela MERKEL on the European budget. Who could understand that we would be led to stabilize our budgets or reduce them, to go to Brussels and decide to vote for a 6% increase in the budget? And when David raised this issue with us, we immediately said: "but of course, it is obvious."

And I place great importance on the collaboration we will have with David CAMERON in the context of the French Presidency of the G20 and the French Presidency of the G8. We intend to involve Great Britain in our work, in our initiatives, to work hand in hand, convinced as we are, both of us, that at the dawn of this 21st century, new ideas are needed and that we will not solve the problems of the 21st century with the ideas of the 20th century, that we will solve them with the ideas of the 21st century, that we must provoke these changes, that we must drive these changes, that we need a vision and that we need great ambition.

Today, I am very happy, with the British Prime Minister, to be able to say that contrary to appearances, the clocks of France and England are marking exactly the same hour.

Thank you.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, imagine a situation where Great Britain is facing a crisis, for example in the South Atlantic, and the Prime Minister calls you and says: "Can I use your aircraft carrier?" And, Prime Minister, imagine that the same thing happens with a crisis in an African country for France and you would receive the same request. What would you respond? Mr. President, you mentioned the issue of the European budget. You are side by side today; will you take the same step to support the request for the renewal of the British contribution?

Mr. David CAMERON -- We will only deploy forces together if we agree on the mission, but the idea is to have forces that are trained and exercise together. This is a very good idea because there are many places in the world where we work together, for example in Afghanistan, for example in the Balkans, in the Middle East. So I believe there are many opportunities for cooperation, but in any case, this can only happen if there is a political agreement for it to happen. But what we are announcing today is that the two largest defense budgets in Europe understand that if we come together, if we work together, we can not only increase our joint capacity but we can also increase our own sovereign capacity, to ensure that we can do just as well alone as together.

THE PRESIDENT -- If I understood your question correctly, if the British Prime Minister, the British government decided to send its aircraft carrier, imagine the seriousness of the crisis! To send the aircraft carrier! Do you honestly think that our English friends could be faced with a crisis as significant as that which involves sending an aircraft carrier, without France feeling concerned? What idea do you have of France?

Imagine conversely that the French Government decides to send a French aircraft carrier because there is a major crisis; would that not concern the English? Do we not live in the same world? Are we not allies? Do you think I imagine that a great democratic country like Great Britain is capable of having a government that, for fun, sends an aircraft carrier?

I could evade your question by saying that we would see, that we would analyze. No. You must understand one thing: there are certainly many issues that differentiate us; we are not the same, and I know that there is the "Channel" between us, but our values are the same, our interests are shared.

I have spent my entire political life advocating for a rapprochement between London and Paris. This has been a constant in my commitment since I entered politics. This does not mean that I forget the Paris-Berlin axis, and I am pleased that Prime Minister David CAMERON has invited Mrs. MERKEL to Chequers.

So if you were, my English friends, faced with a major crisis, should France sit in its corner, wash its hands, and consider that it does not concern it? But my first reaction would be to try to understand why such close allies find themselves in such a serious crisis? And to see how I could help them? This does not prevent the English government’s decision from being perfectly sovereign and the French government’s decision from being completely sovereign. But sovereignty does not mean isolation. When one is isolated, one is no longer sovereign; one is fragile.

If you want me to say that there are friendships between France and England, yes, I confirm. If that was the sense of your question, I have no doubt about it.

Then, I thought there was a very small, slightly insidious question, just a little bit... David CAMERON and I agree that the overall European budget should be limited in its increase, of course. Does that mean we are absolutely in agreement on all the chapters within it? Was that the question? No, we have discussions, we have even talked about it, but we agreed on one thing: to talk about the problems to find solutions together and present them together.

I know perfectly well that the Common Agricultural Policy is not the most popular element in Great Britain. And I will let you in on a secret, the British cheque is not the element that spontaneously drives the French people towards England. All the more reason for us to talk about it as allies, as friends, as responsible people. I see Mr. CAMERON's red lines; he sees the red lines of the French government. Within that, we have decided to talk about it, and instead of making them elements of opposition, to understand each other and propose common solutions. Isn’t that in the interest of Great Britain as well as in the interest of France? That is what we have decided. Thank you for allowing me to clarify that.

QUESTION -- We have a question for the Prime Minister. In what way do you think this pragmatic choice will first impact your relationship with Washington, and secondly, to what extent will it affect or change the British vision of European defense?

David CAMERON - Regarding the relationship we have with Washington, which is of course a very strong relationship, a very particular relationship, Washington wants European countries like France and Great Britain to come closer and share their resources in terms of defense, so that we have greater defense capabilities. Often, the Americans and other NATO partners act together to try to use resources, training, etc., rationally. So I believe this will be very well received in Washington.

Now, concerning European defense, our position is known. For us, NATO is the most important organization for ensuring security and safety. We applaud France's decision to return to NATO's command, but I believe that today it is about recognizing what Great Britain and France can do together when they decide to act in France and at the same time understand that this improves our individual capabilities.

So it is not about agreeing on a small number of things, a training project here, a little cooperation for drones there. It is a much more substantial menu that ranges from the most difficult things: nuclear cooperation, the most sensitive issue on which nations can decide to cooperate, to the question of how we can have joint command systems in logistics for aircraft.

And so we have decided to do something that goes far, that is radical. The question was directed at me, wasn’t it? So I believe we may move on to the next question.

QUESTION -- We are told that this is a treaty for the next 50 years. But it is already difficult to have a horizon beyond 5 years. Are you sure you can trust the French, the treaty, and events for the next 50 years?

And now a question for the President: how does this treaty make France and Great Britain truly competitive compared to America? We will have 2 aircraft carriers; they have 13. Do we really measure up?

David CAMERON -- Listen, regarding nuclear cooperation, I believe we can really see the common interests between our two countries. We have independent nuclear deterrent forces that we consider very important. It is the ultimate guarantee of our security; it is truly the ultimate insurance policy. But for countries of our size, it is a considerable financial commitment, a financial burden for the next 10, 20, 50 years, and nuclear deterrence requires us to plan 10, 20 years in advance. We do this in England, and everything we can do to share, to jointly bear the costs of our nuclear deterrent with our French allies is in our interest. We will build this facility in France, which will be jointly managed, and there will also be a facility in Aldermaston, and for me, that is the perfect example.

It is true that this is a step that goes far because it is about strengthening cooperation, but it also has a very significant impact on the costs of something that is very important, that is dear to both of us: nuclear deterrence, not just for today but also for the future.

THE PRESIDENT -- You ask whether we can trust the French for the next 50 years? Start with the first 5 years; those are the only ones that count; after that, you will see. Regarding nuclear, David CAMERON and I must look beyond the democratic limits of our governments. We must think in terms of duration. Can you imagine what investments in nuclear represent? There are continuities, regardless of the opposition, the majority, the left, the right, the liberals; there are continuities. If we can only reason, think in terms of our own mandate, then where is the vision? If General de GAULLE had reacted like that, there would not have been a nuclear program in France either.

Inevitably, we have risen above political alternations and contingencies, betting on common sense. France and Great Britain are neighbors and will not change their address. And regardless of the political opinions of those who will succeed us, they will be confronted with the following reality: Great Britain is France's closest neighbor; that is a reality. You say: "the Americans have more aircraft carriers than you." We could say: "the Russians do too." We are the only ones in Europe to have aircraft carriers, the English and the French. Isn’t it smart, while there is an English aircraft carrier in the Atlantic, for a French aircraft carrier to be in the Mediterranean? Does Great Britain have no interests in the Mediterranean? And does France have none in the Atlantic? Don’t you see the obviousness of working together? Must we absolutely send our respective naval groups for every crisis, ignoring what the other is doing, to ensure that the English taxpayer pays twice and the French taxpayer pays twice? Do you think that, in a number of crises where we share exactly the same analysis, it is not logical to send the same naval group? And when French soldiers are deployed somewhere, considering that an English aircraft carrier is an allied aircraft carrier to which they can have access, is that not an advantage? And vice versa.

I am convinced that this choice will not be reversed by anyone. Finally, one last point: it is not about asking Mr. VAN ROMPUY or Mr. BAROSSO to lead the English army or to lead the French army. No one has that idea. Who would even come up with that idea? It is about the two great military powers in Europe combining their efforts, complementing their efforts. It is the benefit of Great Britain, it is the benefit of France, and it is the benefit of Europe. Yes, it is also the benefit of Europe because when Great Britain succeeds, I will tell you one thing, it is a success for Europe. And when France succeeds, it is a success for Europe. I come here with pleasure to say this, as I have always been convinced that Europe deeply needs Great Britain. And let me say that I think Great Britain needs Europe, just as France needs Europe. This credo, I have always defended, and yet I am not a technocrat; I cannot be in favor of bureaucracy, and I may sometimes have frank debates with a number of European authorities. That is what I think, and it is our duty to act this way. I believe it is in everyone’s interest.

QUESTION -- What is your assessment of the terrorist threat against Europe and against France and Great Britain today, after the events and various threats we have heard in recent days from Al-Qaeda? And what can be done to counter this threat if you believe it is growing? And more specifically, Mr. President, what can you tell us about the letter bomb that was addressed to you, and have you recently received other threats of this kind, letter bombs or otherwise directed at you?

Mr. David CAMERON -- We believe that the threat we face in terms of terrorism is very serious. We regularly assess our alert level. We do not intend to change the level of threat we have currently assessed. It is a very high alert level. Regarding the threat, we know that we must work with our allies to combat it at all levels, just as we operate in Afghanistan to prevent that country from becoming a sanctuary for terrorists. We are also working hard with the Yemeni government to ensure that Al-Qaeda does not have a presence on the Arabian Peninsula. We must work at all levels: diplomatic, security, in terms of aircraft security as well. We must ensure that the necessary mechanisms are in place. There is not a single answer or a single response; we must have a response at all levels. We had a very good Cabinet meeting this morning. I chaired the Cobra Committee meeting yesterday, and with economic growth, this is also a subject I face every day. We must truly have the most robust, solid response possible.

THE PRESIDENT -- No comment on the letter bomb case. The Greek police and the French police communicate very well. I have nothing to say, and I do not intend to give publicity to those who act this way. Regarding the threat, as David CAMERON said, it is extremely serious. Our vigilance is total. We work with our allies; I would not even say on a daily basis but hour by hour, we exchange information, we cross our intelligence, and we try to harmonize our responses. I will personally hold a meeting of security officials tomorrow, Wednesday, in Paris.

Thank you.