Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. Edouard Balladur, former Prime Minister, on the modernization and rebalancing of the institutions of the Fifth Republic, in Paris on July 19, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

19 July 2007 · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy held a joint press conference with former PM Balladur in Paris on July 19, 2007, launching a committee to study modernization of France's Fifth Republic institutions.
Main themes
Constitutional reform of the Fifth Republic, institutional modernization, presidential responsibility, role of Prime Minister, voting system reform, committee on institutional reform, balance of power, democratic accountability, presidentialization debate, trust in public institutions
Duration
~19 min
63rd percentile
Words
2,246
63rd percentile
Sentences
107
66th percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
10.5
27th percentile
Syntax
2.85
27th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

107 sentences in 18 paragraphs

MR. EDOUARD BALLADUR - Mr. Prime Minister, Mr. President, I would like to thank you, as I mentioned earlier on behalf of all the committee members, for having entrusted us with the important task of studying a very significant issue, that of the functioning of our institutions, which have ensured the stability of power in France for half a century, but which must necessarily be adapted to current developments.

You have asked us to study a very large number of subjects. We will, of course, do so, with a spirit of freedom that you have also encouraged us to adopt and exercise. This freedom will first manifest itself in the proposals we will make, and then perhaps in other proposals that may appear essential to us as our reflections progress.

We will now get to work, and I hope that we will be able to meet the deadline you have set for us, that is, by the end of October, to present a report that would address a number of modifications, constitutional and otherwise, to certain texts that are not constitutional and that will need to be amended. I know, for example, that you want us to consult on the voting system. A difficult subject, and I would almost say perilous. We will, of course, do so. There you have it, Mr. President, I have not much else to add except that we are all very sensitive to the trust you have placed in us and that we will be keen to meet your expectations.

THE PRESIDENT - Thank you, Mr. Prime Minister, Mr. President. The text I presented to the committee is available to journalists. I would like to say to those who might be surprised by the diversity of the committee's composition that the Constitution is the concern of all French people, but not of the majority against the minority. Therefore, it would have been curious to have a committee composed of people who think the same way on all subjects. The Constitution is everyone's business. I would like to make a second remark: this reform that I have asked the committee to consider is not a reform of opportunity. The majority does not need it for political, tactical, or opportunistic reasons. It simply seemed to me that it was my duty to reflect on the coherence of our institutions and to see if they are still adapted to the realities of 2007. I add that we have experienced enough crises in France: the presence of Mr. LE PEN in the second round, repeated abstentions, distrust of public speech and politics, to question the relevance of our institutions. Finally, in my mind, this is not about changing the Republic, but within the framework of the Fifth Republic, to see how we can be more modern. Being more modern means being more responsible. The question of responsibility is at the heart of the reform. Who decides? Why does he decide? What result does he achieve? How can the sovereign people extend their trust, renew their trust, or withdraw their trust? That is, in truth, the central question of the reform of the institutions of the Republic.

Are there any questions you would like to ask us?

QUESTION - The possible abolition of the position of Prime Minister, is that part of the reflections? Are you open to such a proposal?

THE PRESIDENT - To the abolition of Mr. FILLON, in no case. Prime Minister Edouard BALLADUR has indicated that we wish for a great freedom of proposals. The question of presidentialization is clearly posed. I do not see why it would be raised in all existing debates except within the committee that is reflecting on the coherence of our institutions. I am in favor of maintaining the Prime Minister, but I have noted that Jack LANG has indicated that his participation in the committee does not mean adherence to all my proposals. It is the confrontation of different viewpoints that will enrich this committee. Jack LANG has been reflecting on institutions for a long time; he is himself a professor of public law, and he has every right to have his opinion; it is not illegitimate. What would be illegitimate is not to reflect on the consequences of the inversion of the calendar, the coincidence of legislative and presidential elections, and the five-year term. The only thing that seems illegitimate to me is to say: it changes nothing, so we do not reflect. That there are people who reflect and propose is rather good news.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you speak of the responsibility of elected officials; you wish to express yourself before Parliament; you plan to do so to defend your record, explain your actions, but at the same time, you are not responsible since Parliament has no blocking power. Is this not a responsibility that only goes in one direction?

THE PRESIDENT - This is a subject that is raised; I even indicated it to the Prime Minister. I would simply like to remind you that today the President of the Republic has the right to express himself before Parliament in the form of a message read by a third party and heard by standing parliamentarians who have no right to comment. I thought that this provision, slightly obsolete in the 21st century, could be updated. If the updating could go a little further than just updating, it seems to me that it would not be a very great revolution.

QUESTION - Mr. President, we know what sometimes happens to the work of such commissions; they have sometimes remained dead letters in the past. We will see what happens after November 1. Can you give us some elements of a timeline regarding the follow-up of a possible reform or possible constitutional modifications? Does this mean it will be settled before the municipal elections? We know it is never easy to make significant changes during an election period or after the municipal elections of 2008.

THE PRESIDENT - The committee set up will work until November. I will solicit the political parties in quality to share their proposals with us; perhaps the committee will wish to hear them. The idea that we have with the Prime Minister is that, in any case, the reform must be voted on before the municipal elections. This is not a committee to produce academic documents; it is a committee to help a government make decisions and undertake a reform. Let it be very clear: the reform will take place. At the end of 2007 or the beginning of 2008. There is also the issue of the simplified treaty that must go to Congress. At that time, everyone will take their responsibilities since if it is a revision, it requires a majority of 3/5ths, so the government will have to take its responsibilities. The majority and the opposition, and the diversity of the representation of the committee, it seems to me, refer to the diversity of the support necessary for the reform to go all the way. This seems quite coherent to me.

MR. EDOUARD BALLADUR - Regarding the consultation of elected officials and parties, the President himself met yesterday with a number of party leaders. We will also contact the Presidents of parliamentary groups, the Presidents of several Committees, and the Presidents of the Assemblies. We plan to conduct a number of hearings starting now and continuing until the end of September. Then we will present our report. I remind you that in our institutional system, the President is not responsible before Parliament. But the President can dissolve the Assembly that overturns a government. So, it is a fairly balanced system in the end, but it does not prevent the President from speaking a little more easily and simply to parliamentarians.

QUESTION - Mr. President, what will your margin of maneuver be?

THE PRESIDENT - The margin of maneuver is between the part of my convictions and my ability to convince: it is one thing to have convictions, but one must know how to convince. I wish for the powers of the President of the Republic to be framed; I wish for there to be more transparency in the Presidency of the Republic; I wish that once and for all we stop talking about the necessary strengthening of the powers of Parliament and actually do it; I wish to clarify the issues related to justice on a number of subjects, such as the composition of the Superior Council of the Judiciary, and then on principle issues, as I told the committee, such as the abolition of anonymous denunciations, which has deeply shocked me for years, we can go quite far. For the rest, if you want me to say that there will be proposals that, if they are consensual, do not receive my support, I will go in the direction of consensus. The President of the Republic, who is the guarantor of the institutions, does not mean that the institutions belong to him. He is in charge of making them function; that does not mean that only his opinion counts, and I believe that this is very important. I would like to conclude by saying that for me, the characteristic of France is a synthesis, and everything that goes in the direction of this synthesis will seem good for the country, and then the majority will have to accept it, and the opposition will have to be convinced. It is a tough task we are undertaking, but it is an exciting one. I think there is less risk in setting things in motion than in waiting immobile, as we have done so many times in our history, for outdated institutions to be overturned through a crisis, whether political, institutional, economic, or social, because in truth, that is what it is about. Making the reform in cold blood so as not to suffer it in hot blood one day or another. I am not talking about my five-year term; I am looking at the evolution of the institutions of the Republic. Every time there has been an evolution, it has always been at the heart of a crisis. Let us be an exemplary, wise, and peaceful democracy; let us make the evolution before the sovereign people demand it through events that always come at a high price in our country. That is the challenge; believe me, I am ready to go quite far to meet this requirement and this set of specifications.

QUESTION - By proposing this reform yourself, you seem to have quite firm ideas about what you want. Would you be willing to make concessions, to give up certain things?

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, it is quite curious to ask the President of the Republic not to have convictions about anything. At the same time, I have understood well, and I challenge anyone to look at the speech I delivered in Epinal or the brief introductory remarks before the committee; I have tried to find a way through. I cannot also tell the committee, I speak under the control of the Prime Minister, listen, it turns out that I have no idea on the question; could you give me some? Conversely, if I were to say, here are all the ideas I defended during the campaign; I ask you to apply them without saying anything, they would tell me, "why did you bother us?" There are subjects on which I hesitate, such as the question of the exception of unconstitutionality. I challenge anyone to tell me that it is a simple subject. I would be very happy to be enlightened by the committee on such a subject. I take another example, Article 16; it is not because it has not been used for a long time that the only solution for us is to keep it as it is, slightly obsolete, or to abolish it. It seems to me that there may be room to draft things differently.

The 49-3, we talk about it, we talk about it, and once we have talked about it, we reflect on it. The only characteristic is that we do not act. The Prime Minister and I would be very happy to have the committee's reflections on the subject. We cannot say that we abolish it if at the same time we do not have a responsible opposition. These are not trivial subjects. I confess I do not have firm ideas on all these subjects. The composition of the Superior Council of the Judiciary, I would like someone to tell me that it is a simple subject; it is an extremely complex subject. What is certain is that I do not see what the President of the Republic is doing presiding over the Superior Council of the Judiciary, given that the evolution means that when the President of the Republic speaks before the CSM, we are on the verge of scandal. The best thing is that he does not preside over it.

The limitation of the number of presidential terms: during the campaign, I was thinking of two consecutive terms. We can have other opinions, but it seems to me that it is something necessary to allow French democracy to breathe. A question like the presence of parliamentarians. Should we provide for a certain number of days of mandatory presence? This is not an anecdotal question for the French to regain trust in institutions. There would be so many other examples.