Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. Gordon Brown, Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, notably on Franco-British relations and the issue of Darfur, in Paris on July 20, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

20 July 2007 · Joint press conference of Nicolas Sarkozy and Gordon Brown · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy and Brown held a joint press conference in Paris on July 20, 2007, addressing Franco-British cooperation on environment, Darfur, and security.
Main themes
Franco-British relations, Darfur crisis and UN resolution, environmental protection and clean products VAT, counter-terrorism cooperation, climate change and carbon emissions, European initiatives, defense cooperation, Entente Cordiale centenary, joint ministerial committees
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,663
83rd percentile
Sentences
194
88th percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
10.0
21st percentile
Syntax
2.90
35th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

194 sentences in 29 paragraphs

We discussed many issues with our British friends. I will summarize them in a few words before Gordon himself shares his thoughts and answers your questions.

First, we want to take very strong initiatives for environmental protection and respect for the balances of our planet. As you know, this has been a long-standing fight for Gordon BROWN, and we will ask the British and French Finance Ministers to go to the Commission as soon as possible to propose to our European partners that all clean ecological products benefit from a reduced VAT rate. I will give you an example: it is quite abnormal that a polluting car costs less than a non-polluting car. This is a Franco-British initiative that allows us to set an example in a concrete case. I would also like to say that we will act on the issue of Darfur, which Gordon is extremely committed to, as is France. We will defend the same draft resolution before the United Nations, and we will ask our two Foreign Ministers to carry the same message. This message is simple: the situation can no longer continue; there is urgency. People are dying and suffering; it must stop. Gordon will explain the details of this resolution. I would like to say that we are even ready, if the resolution is passed, to go to Darfur, Chad, and Sudan together.

We will also create a joint committee that will meet quarterly to exchange information on counter-terrorism efforts. We want to strengthen our working methods and our cooperation.

Finally, we will work on defense issues in anticipation of the upcoming British-French summit that will be held this autumn in the United Kingdom, before the end of 2007.

As you can see, we have worked well together. We communicate by phone almost every week, and I can tell you that on all the issues discussed, we have a common will to work together, to strengthen the ties between the United Kingdom and France, and to take initiatives to move Europe forward.

Gordon BROWN - I would like to first say that it is a tremendous privilege to come to Paris so soon after taking office as British Prime Minister, to renew the bonds of friendship with President SARKOZY, to congratulate him on all he has done for France, for Europe, for the rest of the world, and to say, like him, that the relations between our two countries will continue to improve in the years to come. It has been 103 years since the Entente Cordiale was signed between France and Great Britain. I believe we are entering a second century of cooperation on a wide range of issues on which we will be able to advance not only our countries but the whole world. Nicolas SARKOZY has been a brilliant Finance Minister, and I have greatly enjoyed working with him on a wide range of international issues and on the question of strengthening the prosperity of our economies. He has also been a truly brilliant Interior Minister, and he is now a remarkable President who, I believe, has a huge impact on all our countries through his commitment to tackling the great challenges of the future.

Indeed, we have talked about several areas in which our countries can work more closely together to meet challenges not only for the benefit of our countries but for our entire region and the whole world.

First, we talked about issues of terrorism and security. Together, we are forming a working group to exchange information regularly and to address the causes and consequences of terrorism and the threats to the security of our two countries. I believe this is one of the great challenges we must face, not just in the years but in the decades to come, and I am convinced that it is indeed fundamental for our two countries to pool their experiences and work hand in hand to combat this scourge.

The second area in which our cooperation will be immediately strengthened is the economy and the environment. France has made a significant contribution to the debate on climate change. We look forward to working together to achieve a global agreement on reducing carbon emissions that allows us to meet the targets we have set. Today, we talked about an initiative that sends a very strong message about what we think of pollution, about what we can do concretely, right away, to improve the environmental situation on our continent. We will each send our Finance Ministers to the Commission to explain that we can no longer wait. Consumers must be encouraged to buy clean products, good for the environment, which do not harm the environment. We have therefore proposed to reduce the VAT rate on clean products, whether they are refrigerators or other products that could be less harmful to the environment. We hope that this initiative can be supported by all other European countries. We will present this initiative both to the Commission and to the European Council of Ministers. I am convinced that in the future, the contribution of science, heavier and more significant investments, carbon trading, and emissions permits will be initiatives that will allow us to advance the debate on environmental protection.

The third area in which France has already taken the lead is the humanitarian tragedy in Darfur. 2 million people have been displaced, 4 million people are suffering from the threat of famine and are entirely dependent on food aid. 200,000 people have already died in this war-torn country, where war is endemic in a way. Future generations will ask us questions; we will be accountable. We will be responsible to future generations, and we will have to answer the question of why we did not act and whether we did everything we could to resolve the ongoing problems in this region. I support the initiatives taken by President SARKOZY, and we believe that by working together, hand in hand, we can first obtain a United Nations resolution that will allow the hybrid force of the African Union and the United Nations to arrive quickly in the region. We believe that this resolution must be adopted quickly, and that is why we will send our two Foreign Ministers to New York as soon as possible to express the importance we attach to this resolution and to a ceasefire. Regarding the ceasefire, we will focus on it right now. We are also ready to commit substantial amounts in the form of economic aid as soon as a ceasefire allows us to effectively redevelop and rebuild the region. We will be firm. We will say that if there is no real and tangible progress, it will be necessary to tighten a number of sanctions to compel the authorities of the country to act. As President SARKOZY said, once the United Nations adopts the resolution, we will be ready to go personally to Darfur to ensure that the peace process moves forward, to say that we will contribute to economic reconstruction, and to make it clear to the government that the international community expects action to protect human lives and to rebuild the country. This is indeed one of the great humanitarian tragedies of our generation. At this very moment, as we speak here in this room, the tragedy continues. It is important that we act. We intend to work with other countries within the European Union, with the United States and China as well. We must act urgently.

President SARKOZY and I, as you will have understood, have much in common and share the same views on what needs to be done to meet the great challenges of our time. We will work together to strengthen our economies. We will cooperate in the fight against terrorism, and we will work together to see if we can finally create a more prosperous, safer world, a world of peace. We understand that France and Great Britain have a real duty to the rest of the world. It is a privilege to be here with President SARKOZY today.

QUESTION - Mr. BROWN, you told Mrs. MERKEL that you were considering the possible adoption of the single currency by Great Britain. Are you thinking about it? What exactly is the situation?

Gordon BROWN - We have been having a debate about the single currency for some time now. A few years ago, I had to make a recommendation to the British Parliament on whether it was in our interest to join the eurozone. At that time, we decided that it was not good for the British economy given the convergence criteria. It is clear that we are continuously considering it. I cannot say that there are specific proposals to adopt the single currency in the immediate future. I can say that our cooperation on economic and environmental matters strengthens the ties between Great Britain, France, and Europe. If we can indeed take measures that strengthen and make our economies more prosperous, if we can adopt a reduced VAT that makes a number of criteria more flexible, then we can consider it. I think the intergovernmental conference will focus in particular on how to strengthen the European economy to make Europe a fully-fledged player on the global stage. This is part of a whole: the reform of the internal market, how to achieve more growth through greater flexibility in the future. In this regard, we can prosper and consider several possibilities in the coming months.

QUESTION - My first question is for the Prime Minister. It seems clear today that no one will be convicted in the case of the funding of British political parties (cash for honours inquiry). I would like to have your reaction on this subject. Do you think it is time to reform the funding methods of political parties in Great Britain?

My second question is for President SARKOZY. It appears that Prime Minister Gordon BROWN and you do not share the same vision of globalization and the issue of competition. What do you think about that?

Gordon BROWN - I remember very well the day President SARKOZY came to Great Britain to talk about the issue of competition and to defend the interests of the French, French companies, as well as British companies. We talked, as you have been told, about VAT, the environment, and prosperity. I think we have a lot in common. Of course, there is the issue of trade, and I think, I especially hope, that we can reach an agreement within the WTO that will be positive for the global economy and for our national economies. I cannot really respond to your question about the ongoing investigations, precisely because they are ongoing, so it is not for me to comment. I know this is a very serious matter, and I hope that after months of speculation, we can put this issue behind us. Regarding party funding, a number of proposals have already been made, and I hope we can move quickly on this issue in our country.

Nicolas SARKOZY - I would like to reassure our British friends, I have nothing against competition. We are, in fact, implementing reforms that will make the French economy more efficient and modern. But it is true that I have fought for competition to remain a means and not an end. This does not undermine the benefits of competition, but I simply want to remind you that the goal of Europe is full employment, growth, and the creation of wealth. Competition is a means to achieve that, just as trade is. Like Gordon BROWN, I believe in globalization; I believe in free trade. But, Madam, I will tell you very simply: I believe in fair trade, not unfair trade. I believe in fair competition, not unjust competition. Europe cannot be the only part of the world that plays by the rules while other parts of the world adopt different rules. I will give you examples. We want, with Gordon, to respect the balance of the planet. We therefore ask that all parts of the world respect the balances of the planet. We want to open our markets, so we ask that all parts of the world open their markets. Competition, yes, but fair competition. Openness, yes, but based on reciprocity. I am in favor of a strong European discourse on this matter.

QUESTION - Mr. Prime Minister, Mr. President, did you discuss the joint construction of an aircraft carrier?

Nicolas SARKOZY - Naturally, we talked about defense issues together. We discussed them in the perspective of the upcoming Franco-British summit that will take place in England. We need to work quietly, discreetly, to achieve a number of results. I myself need to review all of the French defense programs to make a number of decisions. Our willingness to work with the British is total, and the credibility of European defense rests on the collaboration between the United Kingdom and France. So, we talked about it, and we are working very well together. There are prospects. We have a timeline, but I believe that for now, the less we say, the more chances we have to make progress in the coming weeks.

Gordon BROWN - The issue of public procurement in France is entirely in the hands of the French authorities. If an order is placed, it is their sovereign decision. We would welcome a decision that goes in that direction, but it is a decision that belongs to the French authorities. If, indeed, we could have a joint and common project, we would be delighted.

Nicolas SARKOZY - We have common ambitions. There is even an excellent idea on the table, which you mentioned, the aircraft carrier. I simply need to carry out a reform of the Ministry of Defense with Hervé MORIN and make some budgetary choices. With Gordon BROWN, we agreed that we could make announcements at the time of the Franco-British Council.

QUESTION - Mr. President, Mr. Prime Minister, the environment, Darfur, and the economy: all these major issues you just spoke about are linked to China. What do you think of doing with China to resolve all these problems? What do you think of the current relations between China and France, and between China and Great Britain? Furthermore, can you tell us a few words about the relationship with Russia?

Gordon BROWN - You know that we had to make difficult decisions regarding the LITVINENKO case. We do not accept a situation where a British citizen is assassinated on British soil. Our judiciary has identified a person we wish to bring to justice, and we cannot do so because the Russian authorities are currently refusing to extradite him to Great Britain. That is why we have made the decisions we have made, the measures we have taken, which are primarily aimed at protecting our citizens and restoring public order in our streets.

Regarding China, we have excellent relations with the Chinese authorities and with China. We have indeed had a conversation with Chinese leaders on a number of issues, discussions that were very useful. On Sudan, when you have 2 million displaced people, 4 million people who may die of hunger if we do not provide them with food aid, I think it is urgent that we all act. I hope that China, the European Union, the United States, and other countries will work together to recognize that there is an urgent need to act quickly. We came here to discuss many issues. You know, when a humanitarian disaster occurs before our eyes, and when we can even calculate the number of people who risk dying day after day, we have a duty to act. I hope that we will have a United Nations resolution, which will be supported by China, by the United States, and by all the other same members of the Security Council. Indeed, we will put the necessary pressure on the Sudanese authorities to act. We are ready to provide economic aid to allow the people who have suffered so much to rebuild their country. This aid will be provided by several countries, but we cannot stand idly by and simply watch this tragedy without acting. I think that the fact that Mr. KOUCHNER has already been to Darfur, as has our own British Minister for International Development, shows how seriously we take this situation. We will send our Foreign Ministers to New York so that this resolution can be adopted as quickly as possible. As the President said, we are ready to go to Darfur ourselves, physically, to ensure that this suffering stops.

Nicolas SARKOZY - You know how supportive France has been of our British friends. It is a matter of principle; we have been supportive of them. I believe in the solidarity of democracies when there is a problem of this nature. We could not do otherwise, and I do not regret this choice of solidarity.

Regarding China, I want to say that we need China. As Gordon said, in Darfur, China can have a decisive influence to enforce peace. We want to work with the Chinese. I also want to emphasize how much I believe in the importance of the Beijing Olympic Games. It is a global event, and I am sure that the Chinese will be keen to organize this event under the best conditions. We have two issues with China. The first is the value of the yuan. This is a matter I wish to discuss with our Chinese friends because it is an important issue regarding how currency parity is organized. Secondly, an empire, a great country like China must participate in respecting the planet's balances. This is an essential question. It is not about lecturing anyone, but who can imagine that China, India, Indonesia, and the major emerging countries would be absent from such an important issue as global warming? You know, if sea levels rise due to global warming, the first countries that will face hundreds of thousands of victims will be those countries. So we must continue the dialogue with them to advance this cause. Naturally, the United Kingdom and France are not going to solve the problem of climate change and planetary balances on their own. Perhaps one last question?

QUESTION - Mr. Prime Minister, do you not have reason to think that the Sudanese authorities will once again procrastinate after entering the process? A British Prime Minister has already been to Sudan, he spoke to the Sudanese authorities, thought he had an agreement, and in the end, nothing happened.

Gordon BROWN - I think we attach so much importance to this issue that we are ready to prepare a real strategy for the future. We should not limit ourselves to telling the Sudanese authorities that they must act. We are talking here about a much more comprehensive strategy that consists of successfully adopting a United Nations resolution and obtaining a ceasefire on the ground. Our strategy also includes real economic aid for the reconstruction of the country to restore order, security, and prosperity. We are fully prepared to consider sanctions through the United Nations to ensure that the actions we are requesting from the Sudanese authorities are indeed undertaken. This is not simply a request; it is a plan of action that will be defended by our Foreign Ministers at the United Nations. I think this is the first time it has been announced that a Prime Minister and a President will go to the region to talk concretely about the problems that arise there. I would like to say that after several years of conflict, with an entirely unacceptable number of victims and almost 2 million displaced people, it is urgent to act. We can no longer wait. We cannot wait more than a month for the United Nations to adopt this resolution. We do not have that luxury. We must act quickly for the situation to improve significantly and clearly. That is the action plan that we hope will be implemented quickly and with the determination of our two countries.

Nicolas SARKOZY - Just because it hasn't worked doesn't mean we should give up. Just because we are going doesn't mean it will necessarily work, but I would like someone to explain to me how it will work if we do not take care of it? Secondly, the actors, even on the ground, are telling us to increase the pressure. I met yesterday with the Chadian President, Mr. Idriss DEBY, who told me that we need to increase the pressure now, not just on the states in the region, but also on the rebels who are numerous in the area. In any case, what we are saying with Gordon BROWN is that we cannot remain idle. People are dying. There is truly a large-scale humanitarian catastrophe. Of course, it is difficult, but if we do nothing, what responsibility do we take? And what do we expect of ourselves? To simply watch the images on television, saying that it is a shame? No. We cannot resign ourselves to this catastrophe. We say that things must change, that it must move. We want to do this by helping with reconstruction, by helping to establish a hybrid force. As Gordon said, if there are people who do not want to understand that we cannot play with human lives, we will impose sanctions and take sanctions. Those are the responsibilities we are taking. We do not want to manage African affairs in their place. And we would gladly do without having to worry about this issue. But at the same time, perhaps there need to be people of good will who say that enough is enough. That is what Bernard KOUCHNER has done with my full support. That is what we are trying to do: mobilize energies, even from the Chinese, to achieve results. We cannot guarantee success, but we have decided to act.