Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mrs. Angela Merkel, Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany, on Franco-German relations within the European framework, notably the issue of the euro and the governance of EADS, in Toulouse on July 16, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

16 July 2007 · Joint press conference of Nicolas Sarkozy and Angela Merkel · Toulouse, France

Context
Sarkozy and Merkel held a joint press conference in Toulouse on July 16, 2007, following a Franco-German Blaesheim summit and visit to Airbus factories.
Main themes
Franco-German relations, European Central Bank independence, euro and monetary policy, EADS governance, international monetary imbalances, G8 presidency, European economic and industrial policy, foreign investment regulation, Kosovo, Union for the Mediterranean, Blaesheim summit cooperation
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,914
74th percentile
Sentences
157
82nd percentile
Readability
59
86th percentile
Grade
9.4
14th percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

157 sentences in 35 paragraphs

MADAM ANGELA MERKEL - Thank you for the hospitality you have shown me, dear Nicolas. In this more traditional part of the Blaesheim summit, with the Foreign Ministers, we addressed a number of important issues for our future cooperation. First of all, the Franco-German Ministerial Councils will be organized in a somewhat more dynamic way. In the autumn, we will have the Ministerial Council in Berlin. At this Ministerial Council, we will be able to focus particularly on the theme of integration in our countries, around a number of events. The Ministers will be on site, and we will have discussions on this subject, which is also important for our two countries.

Next, we asked ourselves how France and Germany could drive the debate in Europe, and we exchanged views on two themes.

First, we discussed the issue of the European Central Bank. It is clear to us that the independence of the European Central Bank is an essential point for the eurozone. Germany still holds the presidency of the G8 until the end of the year, and in this capacity, I added something important to our discussion. I added that the issue of international financial and monetary balances is a very important point that naturally impacts exchange rates. Member States of the G8 must work to compensate for imbalances and converge situations, so that exchange rates do not come under pressure in certain countries, as we see, for example, between the dollar and the euro. But the same goes for the Chinese currency. We must keep this in mind. And we will need to have discussions, particularly transatlantic ones, on the issue of deficits and monetary balances. But the independence of the European Central Bank has been recognized and highlighted by both of us.

Thirdly, the point we discussed today, which makes me very happy: we will propose to the Portuguese presidency and the European Commission to organize, in the autumn and at the next Lisbon Council in March 2008, a discussion to see how Europe should arm itself and prepare for the emergence of new parameters of economic competition, with, for example, the emergence of public investment funds from China or other countries. We must avoid choosing purely national regulations. This is being discussed in Germany, in France, there are provisions regarding these strategic industrial sectors. We need to see how, in Europe, we can create open competition while ensuring the principle of reciprocity towards countries outside the Union, which are less open than we are to international investments.

Furthermore, we addressed various issues of international policy. We are particularly thinking about the solution to the Kosovo problem, which is close to our hearts, without forgetting, of course, the Middle East.

In summary, I would say that it was a friendly, open, and extremely constructive meeting. Our next Blaesheim meeting, at the Franco-German Ministerial Council this autumn, is a very promising prospect for me. Through our visit to Airbus, on the one hand, and this Blaesheim meeting, on the other hand, we are showing that Franco-German cooperation is on an excellent path. We are addressing the issues frankly.

Thank you very much, I am happy that we were able to meet here.

THE PRESIDENT - Thank you, Angela. To begin, I am pleased with how this working day has unfolded. I was happy that Angela MERKEL came to the AIRBUS factories, and that I myself will be able to visit the AIRBUS factories in Germany in the future, when we work for the people. It was very important for me that we could express ourselves in front of the workers. As you can see, on a subject we have been discussing for years without finding a solution, we have found a solution.

It is true, we talked about the euro. This allowed for a great convergence of views. What does Germany want? The independence of the ECB. France supports the independence of the ECB. What does Germany want? A euro that is in the tradition of the German conception of money, that is to say, in the tradition of a strong currency. What does France want? To put an end to monetary dumping that leads a number of currencies in the world to be managed according to criteria that have nothing to do with the market. And it is very important that Germany, which is presiding over the G8, puts this issue on the agenda.

I would add that I am very sensitive to what Madam MERKEL has just said. Europe at 27 will reflect on what our economic policy should be, our industrial policy, to combat relocations and to ensure that competition is fair.

On all the other files, the Union for the Mediterranean in particular, there has been a very great convergence of views between the two of us.

At heart, there is a desire from France and Germany to really work together, but to work concretely, to tackle the problems and find solutions, as we did for EADS. I must say that working with Angela is becoming easier and easier, because we speak frankly, simply, without detours. I try to understand her position. I believe I can say that she tries to understand what our position is, and we find compromises that allow for a win-win system for both Germany and France.

The EADS file is very important because it illustrates a desire from both Madam MERKEL and myself, not to circumvent problems, but to confront problems to provide solutions that are in line with the interests of our two countries. Together, we are stronger than alone. I believe that everything we have done today shows that.

QUESTION - Madam Chancellor, Mr. President, you have just mentioned your converging views on the euro. But are you both satisfied with the current exchange rate of the euro?

MADAM ANGELA MERKEL - The question is what means or paths we consider most appropriate regarding exchange rates. There are interventionist approaches that say that the European Central Bank needs to change its interest rate policy. For me, that is not the right path. The other path is to discuss openly and to say yes, we know the causes of a strong euro and a weak dollar, and these causes also relate to monetary imbalance. That is why I spoke about our role in the G8, and I believe we must refrain from inappropriate interventions that do not change the underlying causes of exchange rates. Indeed, an exchange rate reflects an economic situation, and if a particular economic sector is facing difficulties, we can think about measures we can take to help that sector, but that should not justify economic interventionism. That is why it was right and not at all problematic to say that the European Central Bank conducts an independent policy. We must first highlight the objective of stability of this policy. Indeed, for ordinary people who do not have assets, inflation is one of the most terrible forms of impoverishment, and we must avoid that in Europe. I see that we agree on this. That does not mean that we cannot discuss certain issues from a political perspective.

THE PRESIDENT - I deeply believe that the problem is not the value of the euro but the value of other currencies. This is a point of agreement between us that is very important. Secondly, just a remark to all those who might be surprised that we are discussing this, I would like to remind you that Article 111 of the treaty provides that the council can formulate, I quote, "the general orientations of the exchange rate policy." It is therefore not illegitimate for us to have a discussion on a subject that does not undermine the independence of the European Central Bank. I would even say that it does not undermine the level of the euro but rather the monetary dumping practiced by other regions of the world. There you go, I believe it was very important to clarify this and to find a common path. What the President of the G8 has just said about her willingness to raise these questions shows that there is a problem, but with other currencies that everyone knows.

QUESTION - Madam Chancellor, have you also discussed a capital increase at EADS, since it is said that the French State would be ready to increase its stake, which could lead to a new imbalance? Have there been any advances on this issue, or is this file postponed for now? When can we expect a decision?

MADAM ANGELA MERKEL - Today, it was not discussed. The question has been examined by the shareholders, and I believe there is an agreement that it will not be addressed today. It could be discussed one day, and DAIMLER has said that as a shareholder, the company could go in that same direction, so the question of an imbalance is not currently on the agenda. We did not talk about it today because it was not the current issue. We have settled the governance issue, and that is a crucial step for the efficiency of the company.

THE PRESIDENT - We can say that there is a reflection among the shareholders within a working group so that we can, in a few months, discuss this issue among others. The discussion is not over on this subject. I would like to emphasize that a very important step has been taken today. Other questions still need to be clarified, and we will address them within a working group.

The right of preemption, potential developments, these are not taboo questions. We did not discuss them today because today we established governance and chose leaders. This question is subject to an agreement among the shareholders to discuss it calmly. We have given ourselves two or three months to meet again and make progress on these issues.

QUESTION - Madam Chancellor, Mr. President, you say that you have entered into a win-win mode. Specifically regarding EADS, what does France believe it has gained that was important to it, and what does Germany think it has gained?

THE PRESIDENT - France believes it has gained, for the company, a normal and effective governance mode. France wants, with all its might, for EADS to succeed, and that is exactly Germany's position. How do you expect a company that is under dual command at all levels and has dual nationality at all levels to succeed? We told ourselves that, fundamentally, we cannot remain like this. We need a governance mode. For all the employees who are there, having governance, like everyone else, and the fact that we were able to agree on a scheme with alternation - which clearly shows that this was not a question of France or Germany - are very good news for the company. France did not win over Germany, and Germany did not win over France; it is EADS that has gained a governance system and high-quality leaders.

MADAM ANGELA MERKEL - Ultimately, we are convinced that we have contributed to improving competitiveness and, consequently, we have contributed to jobs and security in this company. When we see all these employees, young and old, and this collective work between the French and Germans in Toulouse - I did not know that there were more than 1,000 Germans in Toulouse who work without any complexes with the French, who also exchange at the training level - we say that it is our political responsibility to work for these jobs. I believe we have succeeded, and that our two countries will benefit. We have, in our two countries, many young people who depend on work at EADS and AIRBUS.

QUESTION - The question was about the capital increase, so I don't think there is anything to add.

MADAM ANGELA MERKEL - First of all, I wanted to say that I expressed myself on the capital increase by saying that it is not a current issue but a problem that could arise in the coming years, that the French State indicated that it was ready, if necessary, to participate in the capital increase, and that DAIMLER said the same thing. On such a point that has not been discussed, I cannot deduce that it would result in an imbalance. In any case, we have clearly stated that a working group will address these shareholder issues.

QUESTION - Is a compromise conceivable, where one could imagine that the French State buys EADS's stake in DASSAULT, which would allow money to be given to the company without increasing the capital? Are such solutions conceivable?

MADAM ANGELA MERKEL - For my part, I repeat, we did not discuss this today; it is not on the current agenda, but the spirit in which we resolved the governance issues is indicative of positive solutions to other questions that will arise with many interesting possibilities. But I cannot comment on that today.

QUESTION - Some analyses say that the agreement you announced today has failed to overcome national rivalries with the order of nationalities, with the Franco-German balance and the fact that the announcement was made by both of you today. What do you respond to that? Similarly, some union leaders say that this will not change much, that it is the same heads that run the company. What do you think? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - If the same heads had left, we would have been criticized for destabilizing the company. I add that the French State being a stakeholder in the capital, it is not absurd for the representative of the shareholder to take care of the agreement and the good management of a company in which it is a shareholder. Does being a shareholder make us incapable of expressing our opinion? When you saw the welcome that the employees of the company gave us, both to Mrs. MERKEL and to myself, when they said to us: "we are counting on you, do not let us down," do you believe it would have been better viewed by the so-called analysts if Mrs. MERKEL and I had said that it was not our concern, that we would not take care of it? Do you always want us to take care of things when it is too late? On the contrary, it is very good news. We took care of it with the other shareholders Daimler and Lagardère. We took care of it with the consensus of everyone. I believe it is good news, including for the analysts.

MRS. ANGELA MERKEL - I believe that if we look at the personalities of these leaders, it is clear that the responsibility for this company has paved the way for certain decisions. I find it remarkable that Mr. LAGARDERE said: "I am willing to take a step back to allow these decisions." We had said that we were ready for a formula of alternation so that he could regain this responsibility. All of this was done in a true spirit of camaraderie. Mr. GRUBE said how good his cooperation with Mr. LAGARDERE was. But everyone acknowledges that it is a single-headed structure. The French and the Germans share responsibilities. But we could very well reverse the terms after the alternation. I believe this is the best formula. So, let us give a chance to those who are here. We are convinced that we have opened the door to a better structure today.

QUESTION - Louis GALLOIS says that the "Power 8" recovery plan will be maintained. What is your opinion, Mr. President, on this issue?

Another question concerns the shareholder pact. You would have liked a quicker overhaul, you talk about a reflection of two or three months, Mrs. MERKEL talks about several years, what is it?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, the "Power 8" plan, I support it, just as I support Mr. GALLOIS who is the new CEO of EADS. Regarding the shareholder pact and shareholding, as Mrs. MERKEL has very well said, the question of capital increase does not arise for several months, even several years. And the very fact that our German friends agree to talk about it, to discuss it and to think about the developments is already very good news. I really do not see what would have led us to decide on it today. Today, we are dealing with governance and people. In three months, we will have a reflection on shareholding, capital increases, and the pact. Listen, this is exactly what we wanted.

MRS. ANGELA MERKEL - I believe we need to distinguish between the shareholder pact on one hand, and on the other hand, what other future configurations could be. We need to talk about it. You know that the 7.5% was taken over by a consortium of investors in Germany. We need to discuss it. For that, we will have the recommendations of the working group that will meet in the coming months. And to talk concretely about a capital increase, it will be relevant when it is relevant for the company. But the shareholder pact and the capital increase are two separate things. There is a legal question and an economic question. We need to judge these questions when they actually arise. But what is important is that this should not concern us. Daimler Chrysler has said that it could very well imagine such a path, so this question will not be a source of friction between Germany and France.

Thank you.