Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. Jean-Claude Juncker, Prime Minister and Minister of Finance of the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg, on France's commitment to reduce its budget deficit in 2010 or 2012 under the Stability and Growth Pact, in Brussels on July 9, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

9 July 2007 · Eurogroup meeting · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy addressed the Eurogroup alongside Luxembourg PM Juncker at a Brussels joint press conference on July 9, 2007, presenting France's economic and budgetary reform program.
Main themes
Budget deficit reduction, Stability and Growth Pact, French economic reforms, Eurogroup engagement, Lisbon agenda, fiscal sustainability, structural reforms, public finance commitments, Franco-European responsibility, growth and deficit targets
Duration
~22 min
70th percentile
Words
2,627
70th percentile
Sentences
127
74th percentile
Readability
60
87th percentile
Grade
10.0
20th percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
30th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

127 sentences in 24 paragraphs

MR. JEAN-CLAUDE JUNCKER - This evening, we had the pleasure, joy, and honor of welcoming to the Eurogroup a visitor of the evening, as they say in Paris, who insisted, which underscores his commitment and European responsibility, on presenting to us the French economic and budgetary program. We discussed it openly and frankly. He chose to inaugurate this tone, which did not surprise me at all since I have known him for a very long time. I was not surprised by the offensive nature of the ideas presented.

I will immediately give him the floor to briefly comment on what he has told you. You must understand that the President is young but works a lot. He must therefore return to his home at a reasonable hour.

THE PRESIDENT - I would like to thank Jean-Claude JUNCKER, who has a lot of experience and who has remarkably chaired this session. I would like to say that it is important for the Eurogroup because the approach I have taken is a deeply European one: that of a President, a head of state, going to present to his Eurogroup partners the economic policy that is being pursued. I emphasized the reforms that France will implement, reforms that correspond to the Lisbon agenda. The Commission, like the European institutions, has been waiting for a long time for France to implement them. I believe I can say, under Jean-Claude's supervision, that this has provoked a fairly general consensus of satisfaction from all the finance ministers who considered that we would implement these reforms immediately and not later. From this point of view, I believe it was received as good news.

The second element: I indicated that I believed in a pact, in the necessity of this pact, and that I wanted, of course, to align myself with the logic of this pact. It is not about reducing the deficit to please the Commission. It is about reducing the deficit because it is better to have a country that is not in debt than to have a country that is in debt.

The third element: I made a number of commitments. To be at 2.4 points of deficit in 2007, instead of 2.5. To be below 2.4 points in 2008. I indicated that I was not sure I could be at 1.8. Moreover, those who made that commitment at the time were not any more sure they could achieve it.

The fourth element: I indicated that if the psychological threshold of confidence we create allowed for higher growth, then we could meet the target for 2010. We will make every effort for that, but I had to be realistic, honest, and transparent. If we do not succeed, then I will ask to meet the target for 2012. 2012 is not an implausible date since it is a date that has been set by all the finance ministers. That is exactly the debate we had.

With Commissioner ALMUNIA and in discussions with Jean-Claude JUNCKER, we will see how I can propose an updated program that we will submit in September, so that it is as brief as possible. I also pointed out that it was difficult for me to make commitments in Brussels before having made the decisions on these commitments in Paris in the preparation of the 2008 budget. Essentially, we agree on the need to make reforms and, at the same time, to continue the effort for sustainability. The question - and many ministers understood this - is that it takes a little time for reforms to generate savings. You cannot ask me for immediate results with reforms made immediately, and it is this pragmatism that I asked to be taken into account to appreciate the spirit of the stability pact. France is embarking on an unprecedented reform movement. I had actually presented them to President BAROSO just before the meeting with Jean-Claude. I am not asking for delays to defer an effort to control public finances; I am simply asking for an intelligent and dynamic application of the stability pact because France will implement the reforms that Europe has been waiting for it to implement for so long. I believe it was very important to come and discuss this with the finance ministers of the area. I ask you to excuse Christine LAGARDE, who remained in session.

MR. JEAN-CLAUDE JUNCKER - I would like to add two or three considerations to the President's remarks. First of all, at the Eurogroup - and this is essential - we are pleased to see France engaging in a phase of profound and substantive reforms. This is good news for Europe. France will never again be the country of immobility. I will never say that it was, but I observe a dynamization of all the energies, of all the French talents to make this country the country of reforms in Europe. In terms of future growth, not only for France but also for Europe, this is a driving factor that we applaud.

The President of the Republic, with the verve that is his and the strength of conviction he knows how to demonstrate, explained to the President of the Eurogroup and his colleagues that, for him, there is no contradiction between engaging in a process of deep structural reforms - those, by the way, that he had explained to the French citizens before the decisive Sunday of the presidential election - and budgetary consolidation.

The President stated before my colleagues that, of course, France will remain deeply rooted in a philosophy of budgetary consolidation and that the 2008 budget will reflect this compared to the expected accounts of 2007. There is therefore no pause, no general halt to budgetary consolidation in France.

The President has been the messenger of the opposite of what has been written in newspapers that are not always very aware of the exact intentions of the new French authorities and especially those of the President. We have noted his commitment and that of the government to do everything possible to achieve the 2010 target. To allow us to form an accurate idea of this intention, the President and his government will introduce, at the European level, an updated stability program in September, whereas it had been planned for December. We are therefore grateful to the French President for wanting to be accountable, verifiable at the European level for what he intends to do after announcing it during the presidential campaign in France.

This is the first time that a government and a head of state have agreed to anticipate procedures by updating the ongoing stability program. The expectation of the Eurogroup is, of course, that following the structural responses that will be engaged by the President and his government in a verifiable manner, we can see that this program of reforms leads to an increase in France's growth potential and, consequently, to good results on the revenue side. The President committed himself without us having to push him to do so.

I emphasize that all additional cyclical revenues that would be realized beyond the budgetary forecasts will be allocated to debt reduction and deficit reduction. We believe that, in a few weeks, we will be able to achieve a good intersection between the President of the Republic's willingness to reform and the budgetary consolidation expectations that are ours. It was a good meeting, and by coming to the Eurogroup, the President of the Republic showed his European spirit, which I had already had the opportunity to observe during a recent European meeting in Brussels. He was able to demonstrate to his colleagues that he had not forgotten everything he learned during his time as the occupant of Bercy! It was a good meeting from both the Eurogroup's perspective and from a broader European perspective. We witnessed this evening a beautiful lesson in the collective and solidarity management of the single currency. I remind you that the President is young, works a lot, and must return early!

QUESTION - A question for both of you. Do you think that postponing the return to balance by two years affects France's credibility in any way?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, I did not say that it was a matter of postponing by two years. I said that we would make an updated program. If we have more growth, we will allocate all the surpluses from growth to reduction, and then we can achieve it. But I could have said, "2010 is far away." You know, the question is not about making commitments for three years. The question is about keeping them, and I also said that if we do not have results for growth, then we will be at 2012. It was a European duty of honesty and transparency. So, I will make every effort to be in 2010. Depending on the results of growth and the allocation of revenues from that growth to deficit reduction, if we do not manage to meet 2010, then we will be in 2012, and I will be the first to regret it. It was not an absurd date since it was the one set by all the finance ministers. That is what we will discuss in the updated program with a double scenario based on growth prospects. By the way, what did the renegotiated pact in 2004 and accepted in 2005 mean? Why was it done? The more growth there is, the more the deficit is reduced. I am completely in line with the logic of this pact. I add one last point: there is not a single country that can tell me that the year in which reforms are made, it is not necessary to put money to support this reform process. There you go, and the good news - President JUNCKER said it - is that France is making reforms and is doing them right away. This was also one of the elements of the discussion with Mr. ALMUNIA on the theme of the commitment to include the list of reforms in the updated program. Naturally, I commit to this list of reforms.

MR. JEAN-CLAUDE JUNCKER - There are three important elements. First, we say yes to this ambitious program of structural reforms in France. We care a lot that no kind of contradiction is established between the willingness to reform and the willingness to consolidate. The President told us that the deficit in 2008 would be lower than the projected deficit for 2007. We said in Berlin on April 20 that great efforts must be made for all countries to meet their medium-term objectives by 2010. The President told us that he would make every effort to achieve that. We want to believe that the program of reforms he will undertake will translate into more growth. If I may quote the French Prime Minister regarding this point of growth that is lacking in France: he said, in the National Assembly, that France would be on track by 2012 at the latest. The President reassured us a lot about his willingness to be there in 2010. The important thing is the relief we feel to see France committing to a path of reforms that will be of the greatest benefit not only to the French people but also to all of Europe. So, the message this evening is: yes to reforms, yes to the President's intention since it corresponds to our expectation of being at the medium-term objective in 2010. Reforms and consolidation should not be seen as contradictory concepts because if we gave that impression - which the President did not do this evening - it could very well slow down the consolidation efforts in other countries. The President explicitly encouraged other countries to stay on the same path.

QUESTION - You mentioned the proposal to hold a Eurogroup Summit. Did you discuss it this evening, and what will its usefulness be? Secondly, you also mentioned the need to stimulate European exports through the euro's exchange rate. How exactly will you go about doing that?

THE PRESIDENT - I did not want to mix all the subjects. We already had a good topic with what we discussed this evening. For the Eurogroup, at the level of heads of state and government, I spoke about it with President BAROSO. He would prefer it to be an ECOFIN summit, that is, annexed to a European Council meeting. I see only advantages in that. Jean-Claude, in any case, is at all the meetings. He has managed well; he is the perfect multitasker. He has been managing this since 1976 with a skill that always impresses me! President BAROSO would prefer it to be all the heads of state and government who are concerned with reflecting on economic policy, and I will gladly go along with that. Regarding monetary policy, I briefly discussed it with my friend Jean-Claude TRICHET. We are not exactly on the same wavelength, but I trust his great abilities for understanding, listening, and adapting. Therefore, we have set a date for another time because that was not the subject. You understand that we could not address such important topics at the same time as I was explaining France's economic policy. That would not have been reasonable, but I remind you that I am elected for five years, and if God grants me life, I will have the opportunity to carry other debates at other times.

MR. JEAN-CLAUDE JUNCKER - Having good relations, as a Christian Democrat, with the Good Lord, since I operate within a vertical logic, I can tell you that the President's health will be such that we will have to return to these subjects. That said, many of our colleagues - the President having said otherwise - stated that, of course, no one questioned the independence of the Bank. This independence does not mean the absence of dialogue or controversies, it being understood that these controversies can take place in rooms darkened by shutters that prevent others from looking closely...

QUESTION - I would like to know if you have discussed the issue of the European candidate for the IMF?

THE PRESIDENT - I did not mention it in the session, but I believe I can say that there are two people who support Dominique STRAUSS-KAHN's candidacy: Jean-Claude JUNCKER and myself! We are, from this point of view, on the same wavelength. I have toured all the finance ministers and I discussed this subject, before leaving for Brussels, with Gordon BROWN. I confirm that Dominique STRAUSS-KAHN will, in full agreement with him, be the candidate of France first and, what I especially wish, the candidate of Europe for a position that was held by a European. He is, moreover, a man of very high quality and I have always supported Rodrigo RATO, Jean-Claude can testify to that. He is certainly one of the best finance ministers Europe has ever had and I want to pay tribute to him.

MR. JEAN-CLAUDE JUNCKER - On this point, I will specify that we have been in agreement for at least ten days. You will have noted that the fact that the President of the Republic supports Dominique STRAUSS-KAHN's candidacy is more important than the support I can provide him, but my modest contribution has been decisive.

THE PRESIDENT - That is not accurate: the credibility of Jean-Claude JUNCKER goes well beyond, if I may say so, the mere limits of his country. It is true that we talked about it about ten days ago and I want to pay tribute to Jean-Claude. We are working on this file, as on others, absolutely hand in hand, with a single idea: that he be the best European candidate that can be selected.

Thank you.