Letter of mission from Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, addressed to Mr. Brice Hortefeux, Minister of Immigration, Integration, National Identity and Co-development, on the priorities regarding immigration policy, July 9, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

9 July 2007

Context
Sarkozy addressed a formal letter of mission to Minister Hortefeux outlining immigration policy priorities following France's 2007 presidential and legislative elections.
Main themes
Immigration policy, national identity, chosen immigration, family reunification, integration of immigrants, economic immigration targets, migratory flow management, co-development, European immigration policy, foreign students, ministerial reform, state administration coordination
Duration
~18 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,212
62nd percentile
Sentences
72
47th percentile
Readability
25
9th percentile
Grade
17.3
91st percentile
Syntax
3.20
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
62nd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 45%42%
  • Social 23%21%
  • Geopolitical 14%13%
  • Economic 14%13%
  • Ceremonial 5%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

72 sentences in 25 paragraphs

Mr. Minister,

The results of the presidential election and the legislative elections that have just taken place in our country show the extent of the demand for change expressed by the French people. By electing a large presidential majority to Parliament, they wanted to give the government, without any possible ambiguity, all the necessary tools for the success of its mission. This government, to which you belong, now has only one duty: to implement the presidential program and, beyond that, to reconcile our fellow citizens with political action by proving to them that it can still change things and restore to our country control over its destiny.

Throughout the campaign, commitments were made in the area of your ministerial responsibilities. It goes without saying that we expect you to uphold them. The purpose of this letter of mission is to specify the points that, among these commitments, we consider priorities and on which we ask you to achieve results quickly.

Immigration is a crucial issue for our nation and a major global challenge. The commitment made during the presidential campaign to bring together immigration and national identity in the same ministry is because it is as irresponsible to believe that immigration has no impact on the future of our nation as it is to think that immigration has not contributed to shaping our identity. The heart of the presidential project regarding immigration is to recognize the interest for our country and for the countries of origin in allowing a certain number of immigrants to settle in France, while requiring them to respect our values and controlling the scale of migratory flows.

You have a major tool for this: the creation of a ministry dedicated to the issue of migratory flows, bringing together under your responsibility all the relevant administrations. We ask you to act quickly and decisively to structure this ministry, equip it with appropriate methods and working tools, and ensure that all the administrations attached to you work together in the same direction. We also place great importance on a strong mobility of state agents between the responsibilities of managing migratory flows in the prefectures and exercising comparable responsibilities in the consulates.

Beyond this fundamental structural reform, the core of your mission will be twofold: to strengthen and deepen the chosen immigration policy, as it has begun to be implemented since 2002, and to convince our partners to engage in defining a policy for managing migratory flows at the European and international levels.

France must remain an open country to immigration. It must honor its tradition of welcoming persecuted people from around the world. And it can only be enriched by the contribution of foreign populations, as its history has shown for over a century. But this immigration must be compatible with our capacity to welcome and our major social balances. We ask you to reaffirm and ensure France's legitimate and absolute right to determine for itself who has the right to settle on its territory or not.

You will set annual immigration ceilings according to the different reasons for settling in France, and you will aim for the objective that economic immigration represents 50% of the total flow of entries for permanent settlement in France. Our country must obviously respect everyone's right to live with their family, but it must also ensure the successful integration of the people it welcomes and take into account its economic interests and those of the countries of origin. To this end, it must welcome foreigners to whom it can offer work, who need to train in France, or who meet its economic needs. You will draw inspiration in this regard from the policies undertaken by some of our partners, such as Canada or Great Britain, which examine immigration applications based on a number of criteria, including geographical origin, and determine priorities accordingly.

If family reunification is a right, it must be done in compliance with procedures and guarantee that the individuals admitted to settle in France are motivated and have real chances of integration. To this end, family reunification must be conditional on having adequate housing and sufficient income to support one's family. Furthermore, it must be subject to a test of learning our language and culture before entering France. The draft law that you have already prepared and which will soon be submitted to one of the Assemblies clearly guarantees these objectives.

In connection with the Minister of Higher Education and Research, you will work to profoundly change the policy for welcoming foreign students in France. You will ensure a diversification of their origins and recruit more students in scientific disciplines. We want to take responsibility towards the poorest countries, which need France to train their elites, but we also want France to become a country that attracts the best students from around the world. To do this, it must change its reception modalities.

Our country cannot accept that foreigners who do not respect our values and who have no desire to integrate are allowed to settle in France. You will make the reception and integration contract a more binding instrument with a denser content. How could France instill love for its values, culture, language, history, and identity if it does not take the trouble to make them known? Anyone wishing to live in our country must thus commit to mastering French and respecting the fundamental principles of the Republic, particularly equality between men and women, respect for French marital laws, the obligation of education and schooling for children, secularism, and freedom of conscience. You will pay particular attention to ensuring that immigrant women have all the necessary tools for their integration and that their rights are respected, which implies that they are aware of them and are assisted in asserting them.

Correspondingly, you will ensure to facilitate the lives of foreigners who have been living with us for a very long time and who respect our values by creating for them a permanent residence card. You will do the same for foreigners who have stayed in France during their studies or at the beginning of their professional lives and who only wish to remain in contact with our country, by creating for them permanent visas allowing for back and forth travel and facilitating business life.

Moreover, there cannot be controlled immigration if our country is not capable of combating illegal immigration. You will therefore strengthen the technical means put in place since 2002 to combat clandestine immigration, particularly biometrics. You will continue the policy of fighting against illegal immigration networks and clandestine work, and you will take the necessary measures to significantly simplify removal procedures. You will set demanding objectives in terms of border returns. Regularizations will be implemented on a case-by-case basis, exceptionally, only if humanitarian reasons justify them.

The chosen immigration policy is one that takes into account the interests of both the countries of origin and the host countries. France cannot plunder the elites or the workforce of countries that need all their strength to develop. However, this issue arises differently depending on the countries involved, and you will therefore act distinctly towards emerging countries like India or China, or towards countries that are more in difficulty.

With the least developed countries, particularly in Africa, you will strive to establish partnerships aimed at jointly regulating migratory flows in the interest of both parties. The countries of origin will inform us of their needs and commit to helping us combat illegal immigration, in exchange for which we will welcome a certain number of their nationals and train their elites, who will then be responsible for putting their training to the service of their country.

In the long term, development is obviously the only solution to controlling migratory flows. That is why, in connection with the Minister of Foreign Affairs and European Affairs, you will ensure, as head of the mission, that the development aid policy in the countries that are sources of immigration is thought out in light of the issue of controlling migratory flows, and you will give a new impetus to the involvement of foreign nationals living in France in the development of their country of origin. Development aid will be part of the concerted immigration agreements that you will sign with the countries of origin.

Alongside your actions at the national level, you will take the necessary measures for the European Union to resolutely engage in a common policy for managing migratory flows. France will advocate for the establishment of a single asylum procedure, the creation of a single consular network for issuing visas, and the generalization of biometric visas allowing for tracking entries and exits. You will act in favor of implementing a genuine European border police, strengthening cooperation in terms of removals, and developing a European immigration pact that includes commitments for the member states of the European Union, particularly in terms of removing their illegal immigrants and prohibiting massive regularizations that create pull factors for all European countries.

Beyond that, you will initiate the necessary consultations for the development of a multilateral treaty that will define the rights and duties of states in managing migratory flows, particularly the obligation for countries of origin to readmit their nationals in an illegal situation on the territory of another state, and the prohibition for host countries to encourage brain drain or the workforce necessary for the development of poor countries. An international migration agency would be responsible for ensuring compliance with this treaty.

You know that the presidential program must be implemented while scrupulously respecting our desire to preserve the future of generations to come through rigorous management of public finances, in line with our European commitments and an essential component of the impeccable democracy we wish to establish.

Successfully implementing the reforms expected by the French people and stopping the spiral of debt are by no means incompatible, but are, on the contrary, two complementary objectives as long as it is decided to abandon policies that do not work in favor of policies that do. Distributing scarcity is as cowardly and ineffective as allowing public debt to run rampant. If we want to profoundly change the structures and modes of intervention of public administrations, it is so that every euro spent is a useful euro and that the invaluable human potential of our administration is much better valued.

Starting this summer, a general review of public policies, similar to that carried out by Canada in the mid-1990s, will therefore be undertaken. It will be conducted, under our authority, by the Secretary General of the Presidency of the Republic, the Director of the Prime Minister's Office, the Minister of Budget, Public Accounts and Civil Service, the Secretary of State in charge of Forward Planning and Evaluation of Public Policies, as well as qualified individuals from the public and private sectors, and parliamentarians. The purpose of this general review of public policies will be to review, with the collaboration, of course, of the relevant ministers, each of the public policies and interventions implemented by public administrations, to evaluate their results, and to decide on the necessary reforms to improve the quality of service provided to the French people, to make it more effective and less costly, and above all to reallocate public resources from unnecessary or ineffective policies to the policies that are necessary and that we want to undertake or deepen. It is within the framework of this general review that the presidential commitment to hire one civil servant for every two retiring will be implemented and that our public finance objectives over five years will be pursued and achieved (reducing public debt to less than 60% of GDP, achieving budgetary balance, and as quickly as possible reducing mandatory levies with the goal of a four-point reduction over ten years).

We ask you to personally and wholeheartedly engage in this exercise, which in no way should undermine the mission that this letter entrusts to you. The first major reforms resulting from the comprehensive review of public policies will take place as early as the preparation of the budgets for 2008. We emphasize that a good minister will not be recognized by the increase in their budget, but by their results and their contribution to the realization of the presidential project, including in financial terms.

On all the points of this mission letter, you will propose outcome indicators for which monitoring will be joint. We wish that among these, in particular, the rebalancing of economic immigration flows compared to other reasons for immigration, the evolution of the number of new entries, the social and professional integration of legally residing immigrants, the dismantling of clandestine immigration networks, the fight against illegal work, and the increase in the number of deportations, the signing of concerted immigration agreements, the strengthening of development aid in countries of origin of immigration, the promotion of real equal opportunities, and the fight against discrimination are included. You should not hesitate, for this purpose, to create a statistics department within the ministry that you are tasked with building.

We will review the progress of your mission in a year and any adjustments that may be necessary.

In renewing our trust in you, we ask you to believe, Mr. Minister, in the assurance of our best sentiments.