Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. José Luis Rodriguez Zapatero, President of the Government of the Kingdom of Spain, notably on the simplified European treaty and on Franco-Spanish relations, in Madrid on May 31, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

31 May 2007 · Joint press conference of the President of France and the President of the Government of Spain · Madrid, Spain

Context
Sarkozy and Zapatero held a joint press conference in Madrid on May 31, 2007, shortly after Sarkozy's election, to discuss European treaty reform and bilateral relations.
Main themes
Simplified European treaty, Franco-Spanish bilateral relations, Mediterranean initiative, European Union reform, Pyrenees rail connection, anti-terrorism cooperation, immigration and security, European dynamism and leadership, Franco-Spanish economic relations, North Africa cooperation
Duration
~41 min
91st percentile
Words
4,928
91st percentile
Sentences
252
93rd percentile
Readability
56
78th percentile
Grade
10.1
21st percentile
Syntax
2.89
33rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
24th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

252 sentences in 57 paragraphs

MR. ZAPATERO - Thank you very much. Good afternoon to everyone.

First of all, I would like to extend the warmest welcome to the President of the French Republic, Mr. Nicolas SARKOZY. He has shown me the courtesy of coming to Spain shortly after his brilliant election as President of the French Republic. In doing so, he acknowledges that we are one of his priorities in foreign policy, and we are grateful for that.

In many areas, Spain and France have intense, deep relations. We are neighboring European countries, friends, who share much due to our history. But our countries also have many common interests for which we work together. That is why I wish to express my satisfaction and tell you how convinced I am that the relations between France and Spain, between President Nicolas SARKOZY and the Spanish Government, will be even better than before, and that is the impression I have.

We have common objectives on which we must work; there is an understanding between us, and beyond that, there is a desire, a political will to serve Europe and our two countries. I believe this is fundamentally important.

The themes that have been at the center of our dialogue are related to Europe, to Spain, to France, and their projection towards the South, primarily towards the Mediterranean and North Africa. The President of the Republic has conveyed to me - and this is an idea we completely share - the desire to move forward to reach an agreement on the European Treaty as soon as possible. We can no longer afford to waste time, and we must concentrate all our energy, all our will to set Europe in motion, to make it function, and for the 27 to regain initiative and leadership in the face of challenges. We must demonstrate to the world that this is a continent and a political union that is the most dynamic, the most innovative, with the greatest capacity for wealth and job creation, and capable of facing the challenges of security and cooperation.

France has overwhelmingly rejected the Constitutional Treaty by referendum. Spain held a referendum in which the same constitutional text was approved by a large majority. If France and Spain agree, we will have taken a decisive step towards the treaty we wish for. Spain wants to have a foundational treaty, a treaty that maintains its essential content but allows all countries to integrate into the progress of the European Union, into the progress of the 27.

We wish, ladies and gentlemen, to reach an agreement under the German Presidency, with an active role from France and Spain, and today we see that we want to find an agreement as soon as possible for this Treaty that will inject new dynamism into the European Union.

Now, regarding a subject that concerns Spain and France, we have welcomed the proposal from Nicolas Sarkozy regarding a new scenario, a new dynamic to be injected into the Mediterranean. He will elaborate on his idea in more detail shortly.

The third axis we have studied is the bilateral relations between two neighboring countries that share many economic interests. Among them, I would like to emphasize a particular point. He knows this point on which I insist, and I know his sensitivity; it is the issue of connections between France and Spain through the Pyrenees. This is an essential theme for which we must reach a solution, namely a rail connection through the central Pyrenees. It will allow for freight transport and relieve existing pressures. It is an indispensable project for Spain.

In terms of anti-terrorism policy, we have recalled the quality of collaboration between our governments. The French government has always provided Spain with - and this is something I want to highlight, - the best way to thank you - exemplary collaboration, especially when Nicolas was Minister of the Interior. I want to thank him for that. This cooperation will, of course, continue. You know it is fundamental for our country.

Between France and Spain, we are determined to accelerate the European Union to achieve measures that will make Europe function. We are committed to advancing this Mediterranean approach for cooperation, security, immigration issues, and we want to intensify our economic relations.

Nicolas, welcome. I want to congratulate you again on your election and wish you full success in your mandate for France, for Europe, for all of us, and I want to tell you that I am convinced we will have an excellent relationship on both a political and personal level, and that is important.

Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - I would like to say things very simply and very quickly. What happened during this lunch and this working meeting is, in my eyes, very important. A country that voted yes, a country that voted no, today share the same analysis and the same will. What analysis and what will?

First, we both believe that Europe must move forward, that it cannot remain still.

Second, we must act quickly; Europe has already lost too much time. And third, we need a new treaty, the content of which we are extremely close to, in order to unblock the situation. I would like to say how crucial a role Spain has to play in Europe. Spain, thanks to the work of the Spaniards, has become a major player in Europe. I came with Bernard KOUCHNER, Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE, Jean-Pierre JOUYET to express France's willingness to work hand in hand with Spain. I am convinced that together, under the German presidency, we can unblock the situation, and I thank President ZAPATERO for what he said about the need to move forward and to move quickly. This is a subject on which we will work hand in hand.

The second element is the Union for the Mediterranean. This is a subject that also concerns Minister MORATINOS. We have, I believe we can say, Mr. President, the same analysis. We must do in the Mediterranean what the Europeans had the wisdom to do sixty years ago for Europe. Therefore, we have decided to propose, with our Italian friends, a meeting of the eight European countries - eight because Slovenia will soon hold the presidency of the European Union - to see how we can propose a common initiative to the southern Mediterranean countries. Spain and France will work hand in hand, of course with Italy and, of course, with our other partners.

The third issue is that of the Pyrenees. Of course, Spain needs to be unblocked geographically, but it is also in the interest of the South-West of France to benefit from Spanish growth. We have therefore decided to make this subject, the crossing of the Pyrenees, as well as the motorways of the sea, an important topic for the next Franco-Spanish summit in France in the autumn of 2007.

I would like to tell President ZAPATERO that I have great confidence in him, that we had lunch together at La Moncloa four months ago, and that I know that working with him will be easy. What do we want? To make fewer speeches and achieve more results. He wants it in Spain, we want it in France. Spain and France must work together.

Of course, on the terrorism issue that I discussed with Mr. RUBALCABA, to whom I want to reiterate my friendship, it goes without saying that Spanish democracy can count on the total and determined support of French democracy. It is not the terrorists who will drive a wedge between our two democracies, and in the face of terrorist organizations, Spain can count on France's support. And believe me, these are not empty words; it is a deep commitment, considering all the costs that Spain has paid for years and years to this terrorism. Spain is the country in Europe that has been most affected by bloody terrorism.

And so, I want to reiterate to President ZAPATERO my trust, my friendship, my support, and France's desire to work with him and his team.

QUESTION - Does the French text seem to you to be the most serious avenue today for getting Europe out of the impasse? What is acceptable or not in Mr. SARKOZY's proposal? Mr. President of the Republic, are you satisfied with the reception your proposal has received?

THE PRESIDENT - I would like to say one thing, and I speak under the supervision of Bernard KOUCHNER and Jean-Pierre JOUYET. Europe has its codes. Europe is a will, an ambition, but it has its codes. There can be a French idea, but there is no French text. I apologize, because all this is complex, and in the spirit of France, as I believe in that of Spain, it is up to the Presidency to put a text on the table. That is what I clearly told Mrs. MERKEL, and that is what we agreed upon.

There is a French idea, and then there can be Spanish and French concerns. These concerns include a strong and stable Union presidency, we agree. It is a Minister of Foreign Affairs, and it is President ZAPATERO who brought it to the table, and he is right; it is the possibility of having more areas under qualified majority rather than unanimity. These are essential points for us, and I believe this marks a great willingness between Spain and France.

I thank President ZAPATERO for understanding that, on our side, we, the French, said no to the Constitution, and therefore, we cannot have a transposition of Title 1. I wanted to clarify that this is not a French text; the text will be that of the Presidency. So, we can enrich it, and it will be a strategic idea. This strategic idea, moreover, is no longer ours; it is that of all those who share it, because what matters is that we get Europe out of immobility.

MR. ZAPATERO - Thank you very much. I believe it will be a consensual text, crafted by all, at the initiative of the Presidency. It will be possible based on the facts and reality regarding the Constitutional Treaty.

For us, there are essential elements of the text that must be in the treaty: qualified majority, reform of the functioning of the Council, the Minister of Foreign Affairs. These are points you know perfectly. It is also necessary to recognize the legal value of the treaty, and other points as well. The scenario of the agreement must lead to a more simplified, shorter treaty, and that is possible.

What concerns us is the content, the substance. If it is focused, it can be a text that achieves the same result. But everyone will have to give up something. These are the foundations of democracy, and it is the very essence of Europe. We must ensure that we can all move forward, but we must move forward immediately.

QUESTION - Did the Spanish President ask for your support to resume the peace process in the Basque Country? And, regarding terrorism, can you tell us why two ETA members in France had the phone number of one of your directors at the Ministry of the Interior? For the Spanish President: do you think the government will order the imprisonment of the Basque you know, JUANA CHAOS?

MR. ZAPATERO - I will not speak here about internal matters. I have already expressed my views; I have answered some questions, and for the one about JUANA CHAOS, I refer you to the Minister of the Interior and the decisions that will be made in the future, if necessary. This is not the place today for this type of question. When the time comes, of course, I will be at your disposal on this matter.

I would like to tell you that the anti-terrorist policy has always been able to count on the cooperation of the French government and within the framework of the political initiatives implemented by the Spanish government in the fight against terrorism and the peace process. We have total cooperation, and that is why I have expressed my gratitude.

On this subject, the Spanish government can only thank the French government and the President of the Republic, who was, I remind you, Minister of the Interior. And the questions he raised at the time were addressed by the Spanish Minister of the Interior, who is competent in anti-terrorist policy.

THE PRESIDENT - ETA is a Spanish problem, and we have always ensured in France that it is not a French problem. We have always considered that it is up to the Spaniards to indicate to us what their policy is. Whether it was the government of Mr. GONZALES, the government of Mr. AZNAR, or the government of Mr. ZAPATERO, the only thing we asked at the time was to be informed of the entire dossier, and that has always been done.

As for the rest, regarding such a complex problem that puts the lives of officials or military personnel at stake, you will allow me not to make further comments, except to say that we have always ensured that the clock of the French government marks the same time as that of the Spanish government regarding the fight against terrorism.

Never, you hear me well, will we make this state issue a subject of domestic politics, neither in France nor in Spain. It is not for the French government to designate the Spanish government. The problem of terrorism is an extremely difficult problem. We have simply asked to be informed. We have been informed, and the Spanish government knows it can count on our support.

You know, in the face of terrorism, there is only one policy for democracies: unity, day and night. And I can tell you one thing, we are united, and this has nothing to do with men or women, whether it is Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE or me, Mr. ZAPATERO or someone else, it has everything to do with state affairs.

QUESTION - We talk about a qualitative leap or continuity. If it is a qualitative leap in bilateral relations, how would that be reflected? On the other hand, regarding the fight against terrorism - this is a question for Mr. SARKOZY - you met this afternoon with Mr. RAJOY. You know that he has made the fight against terrorism his main opposition issue in Spain. There is the key question of negotiation with ETA, which is a problem that greatly divides the government and the opposition. I would like to know your opinion on this, whether Madrid has the right to engage in negotiations with ETA, or if France has a differing opinion on this?

THE PRESIDENT - That is a very clever way of asking me the same question. It happens that even when I was invited to the congress of the Popular Party, I did not speak on this issue, because to my knowledge, the policy of Spain is implemented by the Spanish government, and I do not have to take another position. These are too serious matters. After that, there is the Spanish political debate, and that is the debate of all democracies. I respect that debate, but I do not have to take part in it, neither as Minister of the Interior and president of a political party, nor even less as President of the Republic.

I worked with Spain when it was Mr. AZNAR, in total trust, and we discussed it with Mr. ZAPATERO when he received me. Well, I work with Spain in total trust on such a serious and difficult issue with Mr. ZAPATERO, and I will not say a word more, for a simple reason: it is not to be unpleasant with journalists, it is because I know very well who would benefit from it. I do not want terrorists to think that we, the democrats, whether from the right or the left, can be divided. Let the message be well received, in Spain and in France: there is no hope on that side, ever. The only hope we have is to strengthen our effectiveness. So after that, negotiation or not, that is the problem of the Spanish government. Moreover, when ETA had sent a letter to Jacques CHIRAC, he replied, with my agreement, that we did not want to be part of these negotiations. Not because we contested the principle of negotiation, but because I assert that the problem of ETA is the problem of Spain. It is not the problem of France, even if there may be collateral consequences.

Regarding the qualitative leap, we do not want to be unpleasant to anyone, but if we manage to find an agreement on crossing the Pyrenees, it would be a considerable qualitative leap. If we manage, thanks to our agreement, to set an example for Europe for a treaty that allows us to unblock the situation, let me tell you that it would be a qualitative leap not just for bilateral relations between Spain and France, but a qualitative leap for all of Europe.

It happens that Mr. ZAPATERO and I believe in Europe. It happens that there are foreign ministers who are deeply European. Well, our duty is to overcome the divergences between our two countries in their votes to find the right solution. If that is not a qualitative leap, what is it?

If on June 21-22 we manage, together, to convince that we must overcome disagreements to find a way out around a new treaty, we will have shown that Spain and France, allies, can move Europe along with others. I believe that is our responsibility. The responsibility of our two countries, the responsibility of our generation, even if Mr. ZAPATERO is, alas, much younger than me. And then, it may also be the responsibility of a socialist leader, I am not one, of a country that said yes, while I am at the head of a country that said no. That is Europe: being able to go beyond oppositions to create a common policy.

I look at the things that have evolved in recent days. By multiplying contacts, we manage to make things move, and I clearly told President ZAPATERO that Europe needed him. And that I myself had taken a great risk in France by indicating that there would be no referendum, but that I expected our partners to respond to this call as well, by making an effort. Mr. ZAPATERO could have told me: "Well, we voted yes, we leave it at that." No, he told me: "We cannot leave it at that, we must move forward," and I tell the French: "We cannot leave it at that, we must move forward, this is how we build Europe, and this is, it seems to me, how we try to live up to our responsibilities."

QUESTION - I would like to know if you have managed to eliminate the differences regarding immigration policies following your respective statements? Did you talk about this issue, have you eliminated these differences? Mr. President, I would like you to tell us if in Spain there was an incorrect interpretation regarding the fact that the lack of support from Spain for the principle of the simplified treaty could affect the fight against terrorism. You clearly said no, but was it a misunderstanding?

Mr. ZAPATERO - Listen, there are incredible interpretations. I saw the headlines in France, it is a misunderstanding, a mistake, but it is quite unusual to think that the anti-terrorism cooperation policy that France has maintained towards Spain would be conditioned by anything. I cannot imagine that a President of the French Republic - even less Nicolas SARKOZY, who has already demonstrated his willingness to cooperate when he was Minister of the Interior - could condition this collaboration on anything. During our lunch and the subsequent meeting, we clearly saw that one of the objectives for which we must conclude this basic treaty is precisely immigration policy. Because if there is a more European immigration policy, decided by qualified majority and equipped with the appropriate mechanisms, there will be no more differences between us. I see these differences as conjunctural. It could have been the opposite. A regularization in France, as we are going to do in Germany, as has happened in Spain, is conjunctural. We need to have shared common instruments in immigration matters, and I am convinced that for legality in immigration, for cooperation in development, the principle of linking legality with a job or jobs will receive a basic agreement throughout the European Union.

THE PRESIDENT - We talked about it very freely and very simply. I could not reproach Spain for doing what France had done. I am talking about regularizations. I had the opportunity to discuss it on the phone with President ZAPATERO, we explained ourselves; what matters today is to look to the future. And what did we notice? We created the Schengen area. When you allow someone to enter Spain, they have the right to enter France. When we allow someone to enter France, they have the right to enter Spain. We both conclude that it is better to have the same immigration policy. That is what we are trying to do. And that is why we want institutional reform so that immigration policy is no longer conditioned by unanimity but by majority. And, from that moment on, we have outlined lines of agreement on this issue, including, I believe I can say, for people in an irregular situation who do not have the vocation to stay either in Spain or in France. We talked about it, and I believe I can say that we understood each other. Moreover, who can imagine after the dramas that Spain has experienced, like those that Italy has known, who can imagine that we do not need to work and collaborate together? It is absolutely essential, and that is why we need European cooperation.

QUESTION - Mr. President of the Republic, you mentioned your common analyses, your common wills, so why is there ultimately no agreement today, and on the other hand, are the bilateral files you mentioned several times, such as the Pyrenees, conditioned?

THE PRESIDENT - There is an agreement between us, and I speak under the control of the President. You will simply observe that it is not enough for us to agree between the two of us; there are twenty-five others. So imagine a little the signing of an agreement between Mr. ZAPATERO and me, even with the support of Messrs. KOUCHNER and MORATINOS, I fear that it may not be quite enough. What we want is to succeed. We do not want to give the impression that we are agreeing between us at the expense of others, but there is an agreement between us. It is very clear. And, regarding the Pyrenees, it is quite rare for countries to change addresses, Mr. DARMON. Simplified treaty or not, the Pyrenees will remain between us, and we will have to cross them. I tell my fellow citizens that it would be so much better to have rail transport to cross the Pyrenees than to have only trucks. I tell them that it would be so much better to have sea highways with containers rather than trucks. I do not see on what grounds we should oppose the interests of Spain and the interests of France. Spain has experienced strong growth for many years. Good, let’s take advantage of it. In any case, it is not necessary to say that France has in its assets a central geographical location to consider that the Pyrenees should remain an insurmountable barrier. And so there is no conditionality. Moreover, I would like to tell President ZAPATERO that we came to talk about problems as friends. Sooner or later, there may be disagreements. There will be disagreements, what do you want me to say? But that does not undermine the fundamental friendship between two greats of Europe. We do not condition the resolution of an important problem for the other on the opening of a negotiation on another problem. We try to understand each other, to agree, to add up and to move forward together.

QUESTION - Good evening, I would like to ask a question to the President of the Government. He just spoke about the search for a consensual treaty as much as possible that satisfies everyone. What are the points on which Spain does not want to give up? Mr. SARKOZY supports a reform of this treaty following the French no. The President of the Spanish Government will have to explain to the majority that voted for a more ambitious text. Mr. President, your project for a Mediterranean Union, does it not cancel the Barcelona process, does it not reduce it? And what about this criticism that you want to provide compensation to Turkey for which you are closing the doors to entry into Europe?

Mr. ZAPATERO - I believe that Spanish citizens understand the situation very well. Eighteen countries have ratified the constitutional treaty, among them Spain, by referendum. There have been countries that have not ratified this Constitution, and some by referendum. This does not prevent us from reaching an agreement if we want to advance in our European project, if we want a Europe that works better with twenty-seven members, that provides faster, more effective, more European responses to many problems.

We will go as far as possible with this European ambition that Spain has. We will work with the parliamentary groups, the political groups that supported the constitutional treaty, and we will try to convince them of the new text. I am thinking of the Popular Party, which supported and called for a yes vote in the referendum. We will explain all this to the citizens. We wish to arrive at a basic text with the essential elements that satisfy everyone. Obviously, we will submit it to parliamentary ratification.

THE PRESIDENT - For the Barcelona process, our idea is to integrate it into the Union for the Mediterranean. Regarding Turkey, which is a vast subject, on which I have not changed my mind, the matter of the Union for the Mediterranean has nothing to do with it. Turkey is undeniably a great Mediterranean power. As for the rest, the question of the borders of Europe and the accession process, we will have the opportunity to discuss it another time because this subject would deserve a press conference all by itself.

QUESTION - This year, France, like Switzerland, is working towards the release of individuals held by the FARC in Colombia, particularly the French-Colombian citizen, Ingrid BETANCOURT. Currently, there are many things happening in the country. We know that President SARKOZY has spoken to President URIBE several times. The release of two hundred guerrillas is planned. We would like to know if President SARKOZY has intervened. He has appointed a delegate; are the contacts with the FARC progressing? Mr. ZAPATERO, I would like to ask you how you see this process and what role Spain could play in trying to free the hostages in Colombia?

THE PRESIDENT - Indeed, I have spoken several times on the phone with President URIBE, and I have received Mr. Luis Carlos RESTREPO, his special envoy. The last time I spoke with President URIBE was two days ago. Discussions are ongoing, and it is extremely complicated, extremely sensitive. The main thing is that there are discussions, and all influences are welcome, that of President ZAPATERO at the forefront, that of all the leaders of the G8, that of President LULA, whom I spoke with on the phone yesterday, to draw his attention to the situation. But you will understand that it is difficult for me, while we are in the midst of discussions, to say more. There is still the life of this woman who has been a prisoner for five years and four months at stake. There are other hostages as well, Americans and others. I do not forget them, and believe me, with Mr. KOUCHNER, we are concerned about all of this, but it is a very complex file on which no mistakes should be made. Things are progressing; that does not mean they are easy, that does not mean we are optimistic, but already, there are discussions, and believe me, that alone is already great news.

As for the rest, will they lead to results? I look at the statements from the FARC, I look at the statements from Mr. URIBE, and we try to do things as best as possible. We must be both patient, vigilant, and swift. Believe me, this is not the simplest file.

Mr. ZAPATERO - I could add that Spain is at the disposal of France, to the extent that it can contribute and collaborate. We have done so over the past few years to try to achieve the release of Ingrid BETANCOURT and, in general, to address the entire tragedy that Colombia is experiencing regarding violence. We have done it, and we will continue to do so. This morning, and I spoke about it with the Minister of Foreign Affairs, we need to establish a dialogue for all these issues of violence and the security of individuals. We must be very cautious; we need a real state policy, and, of course, we are doing this with the French government and the Colombian government with whom we have very good collaboration. It is a very difficult task that President URIBE must undertake.

Thank you very much.