Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero, President of the Government of the Kingdom of Spain, on Franco-Spanish relations, particularly regarding illegal immigration and terrorism, in Paris on January 10, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

10 January 2008 · Joint press conference of Nicolas Sarkozy and José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero on Franco-Spanish relations · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy and Zapatero held a joint press conference in Paris on January 10, 2008, summarizing outcomes of the Franco-Spanish bilateral summit.
Main themes
Franco-Spanish bilateral relations, fight against terrorism and ETA, European Union Mediterranean policy, immigration and European immigration pact, French EU Presidency cooperation, European growth initiatives, transport interconnections and high-speed rail, European energy policy, common defense policy, Lisbon Treaty simplified treaty, national education agreements
Duration
~42 min
91st percentile
Words
5,023
91st percentile
Sentences
240
92nd percentile
Readability
51
67th percentile
Grade
11.2
35th percentile
Syntax
3.00
47th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
24th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

240 sentences in 52 paragraphs

First, we have a common vision of what the evolution of Europe should be. We proposed to Spain to work hand in hand during the French Presidency of the European Union. We have a common vision of what the organization of the Union for the Mediterranean should be. We have decided to undertake joint trips to the Mediterranean, at the level of foreign ministers as well as prime ministers and heads of state, to advance the project of the Union for the Mediterranean and prepare for the Paris summit.

We have common concerns regarding the issue of growth in Europe. There will be a supported Spanish initiative for France so that we can discuss the best ways to bolster European growth.

On the most sensitive political issues, we have decided to further strengthen our collaboration in the fight against terrorism. This is the work of Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE and our friend RUBALCABA. I want to say in the most solemn way, speaking on behalf of the French government and the Prime Minister, that France will always stand by Spanish democracy in the face of the cancer of terrorism, whether it is internal or external terrorism. Regarding the fight against terrorism, against ETA, France has long chosen its side. Its side is that of democratic Spain. Everyone must understand that this is a strategic decision that goes beyond the alternations in France, as in Spain.

We have decided to powerfully strengthen our teams. It will not be the terrorists who have the last word; it is democracy and the rule of law. On immigration, we have decided to work together and to carry together the hope of a European pact on immigration. Thus demonstrating that immigration is not a problem of the left or the right, that we are in favor of regular immigration, particularly labor immigration, but that we want to fight against irregular immigration. We have decided to work together.

And finally, on transport interconnections, both Atlantic and Mediterranean, or energy to cross the Pyrenees, we have made very important decisions. Mario MONTI is the European coordinator in this matter. We want to strengthen the presence of rail transport to avoid the accumulation of millions of heavy trucks, and we want to enable Spain to have the energy supply it needs. We have decided to create a joint body to solve these problems, which will ensure that major Spanish cities and major French cities will be just a few hours apart by high-speed train.

We are embarking together on what could be a European energy policy. This is no small matter. These are commitments we made with François FILLON, as early as May, which are now being realized. Regardless of the reflection on defense, we have decided to think together about what the content of a common defense policy, Spanish and French, could be, making available to Europe the fruit of a common reflection. We have also signed agreements in the field of national education. And, on all subjects, I believe I can say that relations between Spain and France are in excellent shape.

Finally, one last point. I would like to thank the Spanish delegation and the President of the Council for the decisive role they played when it was necessary, at the Brussels summit last summer, to decide on the adoption of the simplified treaty. Spain, I speak under the authority of Bernard KOUCHNER and Jean-Pierre JOUYET, took, through our friend MORATINOS and President ZAPATERO, its responsibilities to advance the simplified treaty.

I say this to the Spaniards: we are a country that voted "no" in a referendum, you are a country that voted "yes" in a referendum. I believe it was courageous to take the positions you took that allowed the situation to be unlocked.

But what do you want me to say to the journalists? Everything is going very well between Spain and France. Everything is going very well between the French government and the Spanish government. We can even say that, personally, things are going quite well.

PRESIDENT ZAPATERO - Thank you very much, President SARKOZY. I would like to express my satisfaction. I find myself here at the Elysée, in Paris, at this bilateral summit, and it is a source of satisfaction for me. A satisfaction that is always the same when there is this opportunity to hold summits between France and Spain. Two countries that are brothers, that are neighbors, that are pro-European countries, that are two great European powers, also global ones. Countries that have a lot of relations in terms of trade, culture, and also social matters.

Normally, summits between France and Spain have always been positive summits held in a framework of great cordiality, at least as far as I am concerned since I have been President of the government. But I must say that now, cordiality is at its peak with President Nicolas SARKOZY. On the occasion of this bilateral summit, I can say there has never been a precedent of such cordiality, such excellent relations, such understanding, and such a desire to do things together.

As you know, the President of the Republic and a President of the government always have a very busy agenda, with many summits to attend. Therefore, efforts must be made. But on the other hand, for these summits between France and Spain, well, I believe that we both always come with a lot of enthusiasm, and these summits are held in an atmosphere, in a truly privileged climate.

The atmosphere between France and Spain is a privileged atmosphere, an atmosphere that is always encouraged by President SARKOZY. I want to emphasize this because President SARKOZY will always be held in my highest regard. I want the Spaniards to know this, but also the French.

Moreover, this was a summit where we made decisions, we set objectives, decisions, particularly regarding two issues that are of great importance to Spain.

The first of these two issues: France has always been engaged for a very, very long time in the fight against terrorism, against ETA terrorism. France's collaboration is vital. We all know this, especially the law enforcement forces of our country and also of France.

Today, we have taken a further step that we had already begun to take during the summit that took place in Lisbon between the European Union and Africa. We have just signed an agreement on the establishment of permanent investigation teams for the prevention and prosecution of terrorism. This agreement between Spain and France particularly targets ETA terrorism.

This agreement means that the General Directorate of Police in France and the General Directorate of Police and the Civil Guard in our country will have a permanent structure for collaboration, will be able to expand their staff, and of course, our law enforcement forces will be able to act with full support, with all guarantees in this joint work on French territory. Of course, French law enforcement forces will be able to act similarly in our country. It is very difficult for two sovereign countries, although united through the European Union, to have this capacity for agreement to reach an accord of this nature to share on the ground, a delicate area, that of security. It is difficult to achieve the sharing of such effective and well-integrated means.

Today, we have made decisive progress. I would like to once again thank President SARKOZY, and through him, France for its collaboration in the fight against terrorism. I would like to thank the efforts made by the Police for the pursuit and arrest of two of the three terrorists who assassinated two Spanish civil guards in Cap Breton.

We know that all means have been deployed. We know, of course, that efforts will not be spared to arrest the third terrorist responsible for the irreparable harm caused to two young Spanish civil guards.

The second decision, also of significant importance: electrical interconnection. I would first like to thank Mario MONTI for his work, as European coordinator, to give a definitive boost to electrical interconnection, which is of great importance for our electrical supply, particularly for Catalonia, for Girona, and also for Barcelona.

Today, we have made decisions that, following the roadmap suggested by Mario MONTI, consist of creating a 50% joint venture between the two counterpart companies in Spain and France, which will execute the project and have the support of an intergovernmental group to carry out this project.

I can tell you that the final route is precise. From the point of view of deadlines and execution, all of this will be communicated before June 30. This is a route whose study is already very advanced. We wish to have the greatest possible support, of course, all the necessary dialogue with the local authorities of both countries that will be on the route of this electrical interconnection. We have reached a decisive moment for the execution of this electrical interconnection, which will double Spain's electrical interconnection. This will allow us to further increase it in the future.

A decision and shared objectives in the field of immigration have also been established. With three ideas: first, we must build a comprehensive European immigration policy through a grand pact. This comprehensive European immigration policy, which has gradually started in recent years, will carry the Franco-Spanish leap. It will have the momentum provided by France and Spain.

Secondly: a decisive commitment, decided regarding illegal immigration. Irregular, clandestine immigration has no place in the European Union and in countries like France and Spain. We must, of course, work together to combat illegal immigration and to ensure that the principle that immigration must occur in accordance with the laws, must be linked to work and the regulations in force in each country, is guaranteed. All of this must be scrupulously respected. Those who do not find themselves in this situation cannot remain in our respective countries.

We have also agreed to give a new impetus to collaboration in terms of joint repatriation. We already have experience in this area. We are absolutely determined that, within the framework of this immigration policy, as a third principle, we establish increasingly clear cooperation between France and Spain regarding co-development policy, the policy of diplomatic rapprochement towards the countries that are the main countries of origin of this irregular immigration.

Because, of course, regular and legal immigration has its place. It is possible. But for the appropriate channel for this regular immigration to function, there must be a development policy, cooperation towards countries, particularly in North Africa, as well as sub-Saharan countries.

And then, regarding the objectives, President SARKOZY mentioned them, I will conclude very quickly. The next bilateral summit between France and Spain must have and will have European defense policy as its fundamental and central theme.

Secondly, we are working in favor of the Union for the Mediterranean. This is one of the obligations and the most important dimensions of a European policy, a policy for France and for Spain. Of course, we will also engage through this joint tour in the Mediterranean between the French and the Spaniards. Of course, we are very grateful because President SARKOZY has expressed his interest in ensuring that the French Presidency of the European Union finds a particular sensitivity in Spain. Of course, we are grateful for this and we can assure France of our constant, solid, and completely loyal support regarding this French Presidency of the European Union during the semester starting on July 1. As President SARKOZY said, there will also be an important element on the agenda of this Presidency, namely expectations regarding growth, economic growth for the euro area and the initiatives we will launch in this area, which can be realized. So, a very, very warm hospitality that has been reserved for us here, of course, a privilege to have this easy communication, this sincerity that presides over relations between France and Spain, a summit where important executive decisions have been made, important for Spain, and shared objectives regarding what our vision, our outlook on Europe is. We want an active, dynamic Europe, attentive to the world, particularly in the field of immigration and of course in the field of the Union for the Mediterranean. Thank you.

QUESTION - You have clearly stated common positions on immigration. France has established, at least for the current policy, the goal of expelling undocumented foreigners as a central axis. Does Spain also support an immigration policy focused on quantified expulsion targets?

PRESIDENT SARKOZY - If José Luis allows me, I will clarify the French immigration policy. It's not that I don't trust you, but after all, it’s better that I explain it myself and then we will ask Mr. Zapatero if he agrees. The goal of French policy is not to expel; France is a state of law, Spain is a state of law, France is a democracy, Spain is a democracy. Sir, what do we say? Those who have papers are welcome in France. Those who do not have papers will be escorted back home. If we treat those who have papers the same way as those who do not, then why, Sir, should we bother to ask for papers when one does not have them? It is not an objective to expel people, Sir; it is the reality of a state of law. To enter our countries, one needs papers; when one does not have them, one is escorted back home, first point.

Second point, we consider that immigration is notably labor immigration. It is necessary, more necessary in Spain than in France, but it is necessary, and we are so convinced of this that we want to establish quotas, quotas by profession, quotas by region, and debate each year the number of foreigners we welcome. Why, Sir? Because we want to integrate the foreigners we welcome, so we think carefully before welcoming them about how many we can integrate.

Third element, we want a major development policy because there are 450 million young Africans under the age of 17, and we share this goal.

Last element, as we established Schengen, we committed to consulting each other before any decision regarding immigration.

And finally, the last point, but one that exists, we will combat illegal immigration, because failing to combat illegal immigration is to be complicit with those who exploit the misery of the world and turn people into modern-day slaves, and we will never accept that. And it is on this basis that we built an agreement with Mr. Zapatero. And one last word, there have been misunderstandings between us. We had to talk a lot to understand each other; it is not an easy subject, and I fully understand Mr. Zapatero's position, who is trying to find solutions with 700,000 undocumented immigrants and the needs of the Spanish economy. We took the time to sit around a table and talk to understand each other. We did something rare: listen and understand each other, and he himself, I believe I can say, understood France's position, which was to say that since there is Schengen, those you accept in Spain are as if we accept them in France, and those we accept in France are as if we accept them in Spain. This is not a whim that crossed our minds; it is not a partisan reflex; we tried to reason as statesmen in the face of one of today's great problems. Immigration, how can we manage this together? That is how we arrived at a common position after starting, I admit quite willingly, from assumptions and perhaps even misunderstandings, which would have brought nothing to Spain and nothing to France if it had continued.

PRESIDENT ZAPATERO - President Sarkozy has explained things very well; I will limit myself to adding two small things. First of all, we completely agree on the principles, namely how immigration should be conducted. Immigration must be regular, legal; it cannot be otherwise because the obligation of Presidents and Governments is to ensure that the laws are respected. The laws in Spain, the laws in France state that one can only work in our countries with the guarantee of a work contract. From there, each country makes every possible effort to prevent the presence of undocumented immigrants, and I can assure you that the Spanish government is doing so and has fought against illegal immigration. It has tried to prevent entry and, of course, it has also tried to apply the deadlines we have for repatriating those who try to settle in our countries irregularly, often aided by mafias that profit from it. I believe it was yesterday that the Minister of the Interior spoke of a reduction of more than 50% in the arrival of irregular immigrants, thanks to political efforts made over the past year and also thanks to the capacity for return and repatriation that we have put in place. On these issues, we have always worked together because, without a doubt, it is a problem we share.

Second reflection, the President spoke of different opinions regarding the origins of regularization processes. It is true that when I explained to President Sarkozy the situation I found, the assessment we could make was different. Why? Because each country is faced with its own circumstances. Regarding immigration, France is a country that has had immigration for decades, even a century. Immigration in Spain, on the other hand, is a more recent phenomenon that dates back barely a decade, and the situation is quite different. But we agree on the principles. We agree on the objectives, and what we need to do is to pool the means, the instruments at our disposal to implement this immigration policy, which includes, and this is a fundamental task for foreign ministers, a priority focus on Africa. We have committed to Africa in all areas to ensure that there are regular, first legal, migratory flows, as we encourage from Spain with agreements with sub-Saharan African countries, with Morocco, with Algeria. There is still much to be done in this area.

And of course, we must always be politically and diplomatically engaged with all these countries. All these countries, their peoples suffer; they suffer, I repeat, from this irregular immigration, primarily because it represents for many of them the only way out, the only hope, even if it is a somewhat vague hope, of having a somewhat dignified life, and secondly because they are exploited by the mafias.

QUESTION - I have a question about the agreement concerning the fight against terrorism. Expressions such as: "individual likely to collaborate with terrorism," "preventive actions," do you not think that a slightly different language should be used for this kind of document? Is this not a step taken in the fight against terrorism, and in what direction then? And a concrete question for President Zapatero, President, when you learned, when you were in the Chamber of Deputies, when you announced that you had given the order to initiate a dialogue, the terrorist group was ordering the attack on terminal 4 of the airport, did you feel deceived?

PRESIDENT ZAPATERO - The agreement that was signed today is a fundamental agreement. It is about preventing, and the means to more effectively avoid terrorist attacks and violent actions is prevention. Prevention through investigation is what we have always done, and I must say here that I have a bit of difficulty understanding the scope of your question because it applies entirely to what is done in the context of fighting crime and, consequently, against terrorism. What we now have, fortunately, is more permanent coordination between our two police forces to maximize the protection of freedom, life, security, and safety of citizens.

As for your second question, I have said it several times. ETA has ended the ceasefire. ETA, with this break, has lost twice. The first time because ETA missed the opportunity offered by democracy to reach a negotiated end without violence, and secondly, ETA has lost because it is weaker today, and I can assure you that it will become increasingly weaker. The rule of law will become stronger and democracy will become stronger.

And secondly, ETA has lost because it is weaker today, and I can assure you that it will become increasingly weaker. The rule of law will become stronger and democracy will become stronger. Those who will lose, who have already lost and who, given their trajectory, have proven once again that they are incapable, regardless of the situation, of setting aside violence, bombs, horror, weapons, are the members of the terrorist group ETA. But I can assure you that the rule of law is never called into question, certainly not by the terrorist group ETA. The democratic government has explored, as it has explained several times, the possibility, the eventuality of a negotiated end. ETA has proven that its intentions were very different, no matter when, no matter who made the decision, and I can assure you that the consequences will be evident for the fate of this terrorist group.

PRESIDENT SARKOZY - I congratulated Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE and the French Police for the work done; I told President ZAPATERO, these two young Spanish police officers assassinated on the territory of the French Republic is unacceptable. And for us, they were not just Spaniards; we acted as if they were French. And believe me, the instructions given to the French police would have been exactly the same regarding Spaniards as for French. These are human beings who were doing their duty, who were doing their job, who were assassinated, and those who did this will have to answer for it. Two of the alleged assassins have been found, and we will make every effort to find the third. And we will not allow the assassination of officials, police officers, or military personnel of a democratic state called Spain to go unpunished on the territory of the French Republic. So, I do not know if you were shocked by the word we used in our statement; what shocked me was that one could cold-bloodedly assassinate two young people. That is the position of France. It is a band of assassins; a band of assassins should not be allowed to act, neither in France nor elsewhere. And Spain has paid a heavy enough price, the heaviest in Europe, to terrorism. So that Spain can count on the support of France, whatever the case, José-Luis knows, the Spanish government. This is not a political matter; it is a matter of state, in the sense of a democratic state.

QUESTION - Hello, a question on an economic issue, the conflict between SACYRE VALLEHERMOSO and EIFFAGE. Your economic advisor, Mr. ZAPATERO, said this morning in the column of Les Echos that it was disturbing Franco-Spanish relations. I wanted to know if you addressed this issue this morning and especially if you made progress towards a solution that satisfies both companies and is likely not to be challenged by the courts in a few weeks?

PRESIDENT ZAPATERO - First of all, I must tell you that this does not disturb relations between France and Spain at all. Secondly, it is a business matter; it involves a Spanish company and a French company, and to the extent that governments could contribute to finding a solution, of course, they will strive to do so. But it is essentially a business matter, which does not at all affect the brilliant, excellent relations between France and Spain.

PRESIDENT SARKOZY - If there is a matter that is not Franco-Spanish, it is this one. To my knowledge, SACYRE is not the Spanish state, and EIFFAGE is not the French state. To my knowledge as well, the position of the market regulatory authority regarding the takeover bid that SACYRE should "trigger" is not a decision of the French state. The French state does not refuse Spanish investments in any way, and the Spanish state does not refuse French investments in any way. These are private matters; the only thing we can wish for, our two governments, is that an amicable solution is found as quickly as possible. And if we can help, all the better, but believe me, this is in no way protectionism from either the French side or the Spanish side. In no way.

QUESTION - Hello, a question for both Presidents. Have you made a conjecture, in a way, so that we know the route of the high-voltage line before June 30, since there will be municipal elections in France and general elections in Spain? Can we expect a new delay depending on the results of these elections? And then, a concrete question for President ZAPATERO, the Mayor of Barcelona has asked you to issue a call for tenders for the high-speed train works at Segrera, will you do this before the end of the legislature, since all the reports are ready, it just lacks your order in a way?

PRESIDENT ZAPATERO - Thank you very much, the agreement on electrical interconnection commits us to knowing the route and what the entire planning of the project represents by June 30. I told you earlier that the project route is very advanced, that we will take advantage of the good advice and good offices of Mario MONTI to have the greatest possible support at the local level in France and Spain. But by June 30, we will know the route and of course, we wish and absolutely want the works to be carried out as soon as possible, regardless of the outcome of the elections, because there are almost always elections. If they are not municipal elections, they are general elections in another country, regional or autonomous elections, we cannot be at the mercy of elections. Yes, the project will be subject to a tender of course, when we have the opportunity to do so, as soon as all the conditions have been set, my will is for it to be as soon as possible. This is not a conspiracy, it is a mobilization, we did not conspire, we wanted it. I would like to say to our friends, to our compatriots whose regions are crossed that this is, to my knowledge, one of the first times that such a burial program has been decided. This is no small matter. It costs, roughly speaking, 50% more. And how did we find the solution? It is because we created a 50-50 company with the Spaniards and decided to share the costs and share the benefits in the end. But yes, the conspiracy was rather to do nothing. And on that side, if we had not worked hard, rest assured, nothing would have happened. We have even worked very hard and then, it must come to fruition. There you go. It is a will. Spain is at the extreme south of Europe, it needs energy and there are the Pyrenees, we must cross them. Well, that is a European energy policy, the same distribution networks, the same needs, the same ambition, that is Europe. We are not going to be blamed for doing European energy between the Spaniards and the French before others. That is exactly what we need to do and that is what will show that Europe is useful for the daily lives of people.

QUESTION - Mr. President, Mr. Prime Minister, my question is about collective flights for the repatriation of undocumented migrants. I just wanted to know, from both of you, to have clarification on the logistics. How do we organize group flights or collective flights to repatriate illegal and undocumented immigrants?

PRESIDENT ZAPATERO - Spain is carrying out a continuous work of repatriation of people who try to settle in our country irregularly. Different ministries are working on this task. I stated earlier that there have already been collective or group flights, coordinated between Spain and France, for the repatriation of illegal immigrants. There have been 6. I suppose that the logistics involve, of course, considering different flight alternatives, planning different stops, and assuming shared responsibility regarding security, the itinerary, the route. These are highly technical aspects, of course. The political dimension is simply to act together, ensuring that the repatriation of all these immigrants is done on the basis of individual files, and that it can be done collectively regarding the flights.

PRESIDENT SARKOZY - I agree and it is rather reassuring, it seems to me for the journalists you are or the observers you are, that on such a sensitive, human, and difficult issue as immigration, statesmen of different political sensitivities and from different countries reason not based on partisan interests, but based on their duty towards these scandalously exploited human beings and towards the obligations we have regarding the rule of law. And rather than worrying about it, we should be pleased. That we are able to rise above our partisan interests to think about the horizon of 20 years on such a structural issue, capable of understanding, agreeing, and working together. That seems more positive to me than blaming each other for the attitude that each of our countries may have had at different times in their history. So, it is true, we are working together, this should reassure all democrats and I am sure there are many in this room. Listen, we have a very busy schedule, Mr. ZAPATERO and I, we have to go to lunch.

QUESTION - On GMOs, yesterday, the High Authority on GMOs issued a negative opinion on Monsanto 810. Will you decide that France invokes the safeguard clause of the European Union to prohibit the cultivation of this corn in France?

PRESIDENT SARKOZY - This is the Franco-Spanish Summit. So just one answer. Mr. Prime Minister and I have already started working, we can say, late last night on this issue. I made extremely precise statements in my press conference, and we will have the opportunity to announce a decision in the very near future. I thank each of you and especially the Spanish journalists who made the trip unless they are correspondents, but we thank them anyway.