Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. José-Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission, on European construction, notably the simplified European treaty, in Brussels on May 23, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

23 May 2007 · Joint press conference of Nicolas Sarkozy and José Manuel Barroso on European construction · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy addressed a joint press conference with European Commission President Barroso in Brussels on May 23, 2007, discussing EU institutional reform and the simplified treaty.
Main themes
Simplified European treaty, European institutional reform, EU decision-making efficiency, democratic legitimacy, European construction, France-EU relations, intergovernmental conference mandate, European Commission cooperation, parliamentary ratification, European Council June 2007
Duration
~53 min
95th percentile
Words
6,389
95th percentile
Sentences
361
97th percentile
Readability
59
85th percentile
Grade
9.4
14th percentile
Syntax
2.80
22nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
17th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

361 sentences in 50 paragraphs

MR. BARROSO - My first words today are to thank President SARKOZY. This is the first time that, just at the beginning of his term, the President of the French Republic has come to Brussels to meet with the European Commission. This is a gesture of great significance. A gesture for Europe. A gesture of constructive commitment to our Europe. I would like to sincerely thank him for this gesture.

We had a working meeting. We will continue, after this press conference, with a working dinner. In any case, I would like to tell you that, for the moment, we have focused on the issue of the treaty. We need a resolution for the institutional questions in Europe. I want to emphasize that President SARKOZY, before taking on this responsibility, was the first to suggest the idea of a simplified treaty. Today, we see that a consensus is forming around this idea.

We, the European Commission, are doing our best to help the Member States find a solution. For us, the essential thing is to strengthen Europe's capacity to act. That we can have institutions that give Europe the means to provide the answers that Europeans want from Europe, in terms of more efficiency, decision-making processes, more democracy, and also more coherence on the external front. These are the aspects that are essential for us. You know that we have always supported the constitutional treaty project. It is true that it cannot be ratified. Therefore, we need a solution, and this solution must, in our opinion, respond to these priorities: more efficiency, more democratic legitimacy, and more coherence on the external front.

It is evident that Europe with 27 cannot have the same rules as Europe with 6, 9, or 12. We need a solution. A solution that is found as quickly as possible. We hope that the European Council on June 21 and 22 will be able to reach an agreement among the heads of state and government on a precise mandate for an intergovernmental conference that can provide a solution for a more democratic, more efficient, and more coherent Europe.

I want, once again, to thank President SARKOZY for the contribution he has made to this debate and to commend his commitment to unlocking this problem, this institutional problem that, on certain occasions, has prevented Europe from doing more and moving faster. This was the essential subject of our conversation. Now, there have been others. Undoubtedly during the questions and answers, we will be able to respond to your questions. But, once again, thank you for this visit, and I want to tell you that I count a lot on President SARKOZY, on France, to give a new dynamism to Europe. We need the European Union as a political project more than ever if we want to face the great challenges of the 21st century.

THE PRESIDENT - I would first like to say that my presence here was a way to thank President BARROSO for whom, as everyone knows here, I have a lot of friendship, a lot of esteem, and great trust. We are used to talking and working together. I know the place he holds in Europe. And it is not by chance that I wanted to meet with President POTTERING, because the European Parliament matters in European construction. I wanted to come here to work with President BARROSO before an extremely important European Council on June 21 and 22.

I came accompanied, and I thank them, by the Minister of Foreign and European Affairs, Bernard KOUCHNER. I want to express the pleasure I have in working with him, and with Jean-Pierre JOUYET, Secretary of State for European Affairs, who is a man who knows the European intricacies very well and with whom I have worked. To clearly show the importance we attach, that France attaches to European questions, I also asked the Secretary General of the Elysée, Claude GUEANT, to be here, and I thank him, and my special advisor, Henri GUAINO, to join this delegation.

What is our position in a few words, Mr. President BARROSO? I am convinced that Europe cannot remain motionless. That we cannot stay in the situation of relative paralysis - because the Commission has continued to work, of course - but at the level of the Member States in which we find ourselves. We need to unblock the situation. It is not a matter of crying over spilled milk. The work of Valéry GISCARD d'ESTAING was remarkable, but it turns out that France voted no, that another country voted no, and that the situation, as it is today, is one where everyone is condemned to immobility. I do not resign myself to this immobility.

I told President BARROSO that I campaigned in France with a concern for transparency and frankness, meaning that I indicated that I was asking the French, the French people, for a mandate to ratify a simplified treaty through parliamentary means. This means that there is room for negotiation on the part of France to unblock the situation. I also want to express my conviction that we have lost too much time, that we must now move quickly and, if possible, do it well.

The simplified treaty is the only possible solution. It goes without saying that this simplified treaty cannot be a new constitution. Because the constitution, the French said no, and others also said no. But we need to equip Europe with institutions that achieve consensus. I am thinking particularly of the Presidency of the Union. Europe must also be able to move forward. I am thinking of enhanced cooperation. I am thinking of the majority so that certain areas move from unanimity to majority, particularly regarding immigration issues. We have often talked about this possibility of moving things forward, Mr. President, together. And I see with great joy, after having seen Mrs. MERKEL, that around this idea of a simplified treaty, not everything is resolved, but we are making progress.

For France, the priority is that the European Council on June 21 and 22 is a success. And it will be a success if all partners agree on the idea of a simplified treaty with few articles, even if I am fully aware that the drafting of these articles is certainly complex given the references to the previous treaty. It would be about making a Nice treaty. But a more effective Nice treaty to unblock the situation in Europe. This is the priority of French diplomacy.

I come as a convinced European and I would like to end with this. I deeply believe in Europe. But I also come saying to our European friends that what happened in France could have happened in many Member States. Do not believe that what happened in France is due to a Franco-French climate. Europe must think of the European people. Europe must protect and not worry. Europe must prepare for globalization and not be experienced as the "Trojan Horse" of globalization. Europe must be a political Europe. The French have said things. The Dutch have said things. We must take this into account. I am convinced that around these ideas, we can unblock the situation. That is what we have come to say.

I know that 18 countries voted yes. So, we need to find a compromise. A compromise so that Europe moves forward together in step. That is what I have come to do here with the delegation that accompanies me to work with President BARROSO. We need everyone. We need him and the Commission. I told President POTTERING that we will need the Parliament and all the groups. Because, fundamentally, Europe will only succeed if it knows how to combine the dream of a continent that has been torn apart, that has achieved peace and must not forget that, and at the same time the sense of realities and pragmatism, because we cannot build Europe on the anxieties of the peoples. Europe is there to protect.

I would like to defend these ideas with our partners. France does not want to give any lessons. France simply wants to share this experience. I voted yes and I was elected in a country that voted no. I still want everyone to understand that. I was elected without making any concessions, without lying, without distorting the truth, speaking of my European commitment, but indicating a number of problems.

I add, if President BARROSO allows me, that I was very happy to see the Belgian Prime Minister and to tell him how much the concern to equip the Eurogroup or Euroland with a real economic government is a priority for us. I respect the concern for the independence of the European Central Bank. It is not a matter of calling it into question. But after all, we have created the second currency in the world. Now we need to equip ourselves with an economic government. We need to carry a real economic policy in the euro zone. We will take initiatives in due course to advance this file as well.

You see, I come here to Brussels without taboos but with real convictions. It is about Europe. We open up to Europe by changing our way of seeing things, by having a will and a political commitment. France is ready for that.

QUESTION - For the President of the Republic. Regarding economic governance, you talk about initiatives. Specifically, what type of initiative do you think you will take? Is it, for example, asking for a chapter on economic governance in the treaty something that is conceivable?

THE PRESIDENT - Listen, we talked about it with Bernard Kouchner and Jean-Pierre Jouyet, France has a priority: the simplified treaty, to make things clear. And for us, I told President Barroso, all other questions can be dealt with all the more easily once we have resolved this issue of the simplified treaty. So to tell you the truth, I even had the idea for the initiative, I even had the idea for the calendar and maybe we will take it, but I think it would not be reasonable to announce it and say it before a European Council that is already loaded. Seeing your room so full, I think President Barroso is lucky: so many journalists, is it like this every day for you?

MR. BARROSO - Yes.

THE PRESIDENT - Really, then I will come to take lessons.

MR. BARROSO - You are always welcome.

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, thank you. Such an audience, what a joy. I will speak to you very simply and very freely. France wants the European Council to succeed, and that is already quite a challenge and quite a bet. On the simplified treaty, if we multiply initiatives before this European Council, then we risk complicating everything while I want to simplify everything. And I think that is a viewpoint we share with Bernard Kouchner and Jean-Pierre Jouyet. They will tell you themselves. So, it is not a matter of being secretive, it is not a matter of holding back, it is simply a matter of organizing things by priorities. We need to obtain the simplified treaty. Then we will address all the questions, but I announce an initiative on the Eurogroup, on economic governance to move things forward. And the very great difficulty is that our compatriots expect answers on everything, right away, and we must prioritize. This does not mean that it is less important; it means that if we do not agree on institutions for Europe, I do not see how we can agree on economic governance.

QUESTION - A question for each of the presidents, Mr. President Barroso: you spoke of President Sarkozy's contribution regarding institutional reform; could you tell us what you expect from the new French President on other important issues for Europe such as climate change, the fight against poverty, and also a global trade agreement? A question for Mr. Sarkozy, President of France: a month ago, France, along with other EU members, promised to continue reducing the budget deficit. However, today, your budget minister said that it was not an immediate priority for France; could you tell us if France is backtracking on the promise made a month ago at the Ecofin Official and also why you are doing this at Bercy?

MR. BARROSO - If I may begin. On the concrete questions you have asked me, what I expect from the President of the French Republic. I want to commend the fact that President Sarkozy has placed the fight against climate change at the heart of his priorities, as evidenced by the very composition of the new Government. I heard President Sarkozy say that this would be the first priority of this century. We will soon have the opportunity at the G8 Summit in Heiligendamm, Germany, to see if our other partners, the United States and others, can join Europe in this ambitious policy: the fight against global warming, the fight for sustainable development. I truly expect a new impetus for this issue. The second question was aid to Africa. You know how dear this subject is to me, and this is the traditional policy of France, so I expect, of course, from President Sarkozy this commitment to development aid, particularly for Africa, which must be the primary recipient of our development aid. We say that this is our flagship project in terms of development aid. And I expect, of course, President Sarkozy's enthusiasm in this area. On the question of multilateral trade negotiations, I am aware of the concerns that exist in France, particularly regarding agriculture. I hope that these concerns will not jeopardize a solution in the trade negotiations. We must, and we are negotiating, in respect of the mandate that the Commission received from the European Council regarding agriculture within the framework of the Common Agricultural Policy reform decided unanimously. At the same time, it is very important to explain to our fellow citizens that Europe cannot close itself off, that Europe is the world's largest exporter and the second largest importer, and that, of course, to export, one must also import, and allowing Europe to shut itself off would be bad for our economy, for our workers, for all our economic sectors, for France. I can say this because France is one of the world's major exporters. So we also need a trade agreement in terms of the export of goods and services: we need a balanced agreement, and above all, now everyone must make a little more effort. We told President Bush that it was necessary for the Americans to make a little more effort regarding agricultural subsidies so that we can reach a conclusion in the negotiations. But ultimately, what I expect from the President of the Republic, since you asked me, and I say this in front of him, is above all one thing that goes beyond all this, it is his enthusiasm, his energy, his willfulness, this pleasure in politics that he has and that you have observed today. I am sure he will put it at the service of France. But I hope he will also put it at the service of Europe. We need that in Europe; we need national leaders who can put all their enthusiasm and this energy at the service of a Europe with political ambition. That is what I expect from President Sarkozy. And of course, I especially expect the modernization of France, because a more modern France, a France with confidence, greatly strengthens Europe's self-confidence. We need that in Europe if we want to have a fearless attitude towards globalization while being rather prepared to face it with our values and in defense of our interests.

THE PRESIDENT - If you allow me, I will respond to you very frankly and very freely, because it has been a long time, and I told President Barroso that I think the European debate is constrained, under the pretext of complexity and sometimes hypocrisy. In the end, everything is complicated and nothing is simplified. And that explains a lot of the disaffection for the European idea among the peoples that make up the European Union. So I said that Europe could not be condemned to immobility. It is a bit unfair because, particularly on the issue of energy and climate change, there have been advances, significant advances, and the commitment of the President of the Commission has been quite remarkable in this regard. France is a country that has committed to nuclear energy; France will not renounce what is an asset for it, but France wants to engage in renewable energies with the same enthusiasm. We have a great ambition; we want to be fully committed to nuclear energy because, thanks to General de Gaulle, France has made a considerable technological advance. But France wants to do the same with the same ambition in renewable energies. It is not one or the other, and we will push in this direction. Nevertheless, the world's leading power, the United States, cannot exempt itself from the ecological balances of the planet; it is not possible, it is not acceptable, and therefore President Barroso will have France truly engaged in this fight. On the question of WTO negotiations, which will be part of the agenda, I do not know if you will put that as an appetizer, main course, or dessert; I have not received the menu communication, it will depend. On the WTO, I can say things very freely: I am for free trade; globalization does not scare me, but I will not let myself be trapped in a negotiation framework where I have the choice between naivety or refusal of openness. I want reciprocity and clarity. Europe must open up, yes, but others must do so as well, at the same time and under the same conditions. You want us to open up; no problem, then you open up too. Second remark, I believe that Europe's food independence is very important; I believe that food security is very important, and I have not received a mandate to defy the interests of European agriculture or French agriculture. And I do not want to be told that it is services against agriculture. There is a lot of technology in agricultural production as well; we are ready to discuss, and I do not want us to be unable to do what the Americans, who are our friends, do. This is called reciprocity. In any case, my vision is that I am so European and so committed that I do not have the vision of a Europe where we would no longer have the right to have farmers in exchange for opening up to services, but we could no longer build planes in Europe because the Euro rate is such that it gives the hope of productivity gains that are completely fictitious. So we had social dumping, fiscal dumping, environmental dumping, and now here comes monetary dumping. I am European, and I have taken enough risks in the French campaign due to my European commitment to say this. Now, if the other parties - I think of India, I think of Brazil, I think of Mexico, I think of the United States - want to make concessions and efforts for there to be an agreement, I tell President Barroso that an agreement is better than a disagreement, but an agreement based on reciprocity, equity, and we say goodbye to naivety. Naturally, I will be completely ready to nourish this interesting conversation with lived examples. A word on deficits. I was Minister of Finance. I know the rules that are the European rules. I believe that I will have the pleasure, by the way, of meeting at dinner this evening, Commissioner Almunia, who is a man of great quality whom I have known and who is in charge of all budgetary affairs.

France will meet the challenge of reducing deficits and debt. Simply, Madam, we are trying to think about something. In a budget, there are two columns. The "expenditures" column, which should not be increased too much, and the "revenues" column. If you reduce the "expenditures" column and do not increase the "revenues" column, you reduce your deficit little and even less your debt. What is the problem of France and, moreover, of the eurozone? It is that we have 1% less growth, for the past 10 to 15 years, than other regions of the world. I am obliged to think about a real economic and fiscal shock so that France can conquer that point of growth it is missing. The question is: can we do this by reducing the deficit? Madam, it is because we will do this that we will reduce the deficit. I have a dynamic vision of economic policy. I cannot simply have a sacrificial vision of economic policy.

President BARROSO said: we must modernize France. He is right. That is what we are going to do. We will unleash the forces of labor. We will pay for overtime. We will allow the French to work more. I can announce to you that there will be, at the extraordinary summer session, an extremely ambitious economic and fiscal project that we discussed this morning at the Council of Ministers. I ask to be judged at the end of my term on debt and deficits. This cannot be resolved simply week after week. President BARROSO knows well that when I was Minister of Finance, we reduced the deficit by 10 billion euros. This led the Commission to lift the threat of a sanction at the time. I simply ask that I be credited for what I have done in the past.

QUESTION - A question for the President of the Republic. During your term, will you continue to defend the principle of maintaining the monthly plenary sessions of the European Parliament in Strasbourg, or has this become negotiable?

THE PRESIDENT - No. I do not see why the only thing that would be negotiable would be Strasbourg. That is fantastic then! And Brussels, is that negotiable! It is extraordinary! I am European. I am told to respect the treaties. Perfect! When was Strasbourg fixed? Where is it provided? I do not see why someone would come to tell me that Strasbourg is negotiable; it would be the only negotiable point. Well, no. But I do not feel that I am being given a gift by being recognized for this. It is simply what is provided. It is provided in the treaties, to my knowledge, by the way. I do not see, on what grounds, the entirety of the treaties: nothing would be negotiable, and the only point that would be, would be Strasbourg.

Ask this question like this - not you, Sir, I would not allow myself, it is very dangerous for European balances. Because that means that what forms the basis of Europe, then, everything can be discussed. In that case, good luck! But what will remain of Europe if we put everything, like that, on the ground? I want to respond to you in the clearest way. Strasbourg is not negotiable for a simple reason. It is because it is part of the founding balances, and I do not see on what grounds these founding balances should be modified.

QUESTION - Mr. SARKOZY's proposal for a mini treaty, we knew it. But we also know that not all governments support it. My first question will be for Mr. BARROSO. Should we understand that today the President of France, on the mini treaty, has convinced the President of the Commission?

For Mr. SARKOZY, if he would be willing to express himself. I would like to know if he did not speak today about Turkey, when he plans to do so, and with what proposals, if he would be willing to say?

MR. BARROSO - On the question of the treaty, you know, probably, that immediately after the vote in France, in the Netherlands, I said that, unfortunately, the Constitution, as such, would not be ratified. At the time, by the way, this was misunderstood. Some almost wanted to say that I was against the Constitution. Not at all. I was for the Constitution. But for me, it was obvious from the beginning that when France said no and the Netherlands said no and they said they would not resubmit the same treaty, we would not have the same treaty.

I have been working for a long time with the Member States to find a solution that is acceptable to all, because that is the rule. We are not discussing an ideal treaty. We are discussing a treaty that can be signed and ratified by all Member States. That is why, for a long time, in my public communications and in my contacts with heads of state and government - because ultimately, it is their responsibility; it is a treaty that will be signed by them - I say to work for something that can be accepted by all Member States while strengthening the capacity of the European Union to act. That is what is important from the perspective of the European Commission as a typically community institution.

I have never used the expression "mini treaty." I understand the idea of a simplified treaty, a more compact treaty. By the way, one of the criticisms made of the constitutional text was that it was too long. But the danger in the expression mini is that it can suggest less ambition. And that, I do not agree with. I am for a Europe with ambition. A political Europe. A strong Europe. A Europe with more effective, more legitimate institutions from a transparency perspective and more coherent on the external front.

It is not a matter of seeing who convinced whom. It is about a consensus that clearly emerges for a solution that is ambitious but also realistic, which can have the support of all member states, of the 18 that have ratified, of those who voted no, and of those who have not yet expressed themselves. This is the path of realism, and I believe that Europe is like this: ambition and realism. As I often say: a dream, but a lucid dream. This is the position that the Commission has already defined in several meetings time and again. And that is why, now, I urge all heads of state and government, as I did in Berlin, to work in a constructive manner so that we can have an institutional settlement.

You know, a few weeks ago, I organized in Sintra, with the current presidency of the Council, Mrs. MERKEL, the Portuguese Prime Minister, Mr. SOCRATES, the Slovenian Prime Minister, Mr. DRNOVSEK, the upcoming presidencies, and the President of the European Parliament, an informal seminar where our conclusion was precisely that: to work for a simplified treaty. It is true, I believe it is fair to recognize it: President SARKOZY, long before he became President of the Republic, had already spoken about it. It is true. I believe he deserves to be recognized as someone who has made a significant contribution to this debate, because, ultimately, he is helping us all to unblock an issue that has weighed negatively on the entire European construction. Now it is important, indeed, that this issue be unblocked with a solution that is as ambitious as possible.

THE PRESIDENT - I readily acknowledge that a mini-treaty had a certain lack of ambition. That is why I proposed the expression simplified treaty. You see, after discussing it with President BARROSO. It is serious, our complicity is therefore old; I do not know if it was necessary to admit it now.

THE PRESIDENT - You know that in Europe, we must speak with partners. If we are European, we must speak, agree to speak, because I do not see how we can solve problems if we do not talk. Mr. BARROSO is a great European.

The question of Turkey, a question on which I have expressed myself many times. I would like to tell you, Madam, that I have not changed my mind, and I do not see how I could be a candidate with one opinion and a President with another. That is not how we renovate political life, especially on a question of this nature. For me, I have said it for a long time, I do not think that Turkey has its place in the European Union. This is a question on which I have not changed my mind. However, we have a European Council on June 21 and 22 and a simplified treaty for which we need to gather a consensus. I do not see the usefulness, for the European I am, of raising this question when it is not on the table now and when we have so much to do. So, it would really seem to me to give the impression that we want to block things when, on the contrary, I want to contribute to unblocking them. I have not renounced my convictions in any way. We will have this debate. This debate is, it seems to me, unavoidable. The question is whether we should have it now? Should we have it later? Obviously, since nothing definitive is happening today, it would be counterproductive to have it today.

I would like to make two final remarks on an important subject. I told President BARROSO, because I believe it was honest to say it and clear, that if we manage to agree at the European Council on a simplified treaty, there would very likely be an intergovernmental conference. It seems to me that this intergovernmental conference should bring together the member states of the Union and not the candidate states. In the same way, I would like to remind you that only the member states of the Union participated in the drafting of the Treaty of Nice. I believe it is legitimate to say this.

Subsequently, what I wish is that we can calmly, deeply, and sincerely debate the European idea. Should Europe have borders or can Europe be a concept? European political integration: how far can we go? I add that the principle that has been defended of the capacity for absorption - I do not know if that is the exact expression; I did not invent it - is a principle that is on the table of European councils. Can we give it some precision? Can we go a little further on the subject?

This is how we have addressed this question, and I believe it was important to be able to do so transparently. Priority to the simplified treaty. I do not dismiss any other question. I do not renounce my convictions in any way. Simply, we are putting a bit of order in the discussion so that there is no blockage and so that we can move towards the construction of a Europe that brings us all together.

QUESTION - Mr. President SARKOZY, you mentioned the need for Europe to move forward, including through the path of enhanced cooperation. Do you prefer a Europe that advances through small groups instead of a Europe that aligns itself to the ambition of the least ambitious and to the lowest common denominators?

And for President BARROSO, you heard Nicolas SARKOZY talk about Europe's food security, take a firm line on negotiations at the WTO, criticize the strong euro during the campaign, he strongly criticized the independence of the European Central Bank - or the European Central Bank. Are you afraid that France will take a protectionist line and are you afraid that Nicolas SARKOZY will be a formidable President?

THE PRESIDENT - I hope he fears that I will be a formidable President. He is divine. Madam, if you allow me, it is extraordinary; first of all, I have never contested the independence of the European Central Bank, but pardon me for saying it, if having an opinion is contesting the independence of the European Central Bank, I wonder why you are even asking me a question. So you take the issue of monetary policy out of the issue of exchange policy and interest rates, a domain that is naturally of no interest, and you forbid any elected person from having an idea about it? Only bankers have an idea, and any other person who is not a banker does not have the right to have an idea on the subject? Interesting as a conception of democracy. I even wonder why I am being asked questions on the subject since by definition we do not have the right to respond, or else we are a protectionist who calls into question the independence of the central bank! Excuse me, I do not have the feeling that Gordon Brown - whom I know well - calls into question the independence of the Bank of England when he discusses English growth. I do not have the feeling that the Federal Reserve Bank sees its independence called into question when the Secretary of the Treasury discusses two to three times a week with the central banker. I do not have the feeling that China, when it uses the yuan, or Japan, when it talks about the yen, these are debates that are illegitimate. And by the way, if it were illegitimate, explain to me a little why we planned for the presence of the President of the ECB at the famous dinner of the Eurogroup finance ministers? Why is he there if we are not allowed to talk about it? Unless he is there with a special status, just to listen. I participated in the Eurogroup dinner which, as you know, always precedes the ECOFIN meetings. If the central banker is there with the finance minister, it is perhaps because they have things to say to each other. Otherwise, why plan for their presence? So, I contest the idea that because one is a minister, one does not have the right to talk about this. There you go, I wanted to tell you that. So, so excited, the other part of the question, was it not for me? It must be the red banner, madam, that confused me.

QUESTION - The question because the previous answer was supposed to come from President Barroso. The question for you was about enhanced cooperation; do you prefer a two-speed Europe instead of a Europe without ambition?

THE PRESIDENT - You have a wonderful way of asking questions. Listen, Madam, let us state things as they are. To my knowledge, - let us speak under the control of President Barroso. - How many enhanced cooperations are there? Zero, Madam. Perhaps the current system is not the most relevant: there is not a single one, Madam. Finally, one could consider, unless one considers that the Eurogroup is a cooperation, but that does not fall within this capacity, so that does not work. The position I will defend in the simplified treaty is as follows: I would like to defend the rule of unanimity under the treaty, under the Luxembourg compromise of 1962, meaning that no country should be able to be imposed something that would undermine a fundamental interest. But on the other hand, the unanimity that consists of the one who does not want to move forward being able to prevent others from moving forward, I cannot understand that. We urgently need a common immigration policy, for example. I do not blame anyone, but we have made Schengen and we find ourselves with countries that regularize and others that do not regularize. I am talking about global regularizations: what is the point? When the Spaniards regularize, it is their right; I remind you that someone who has the right to reside in Spain immediately has the right to be in the Schengen area. We need a common immigration policy; why is there none? Because of the rule of unanimity. There is always one country that blocks. So my answer is very clear: I prefer a Europe that moves forward through enhanced cooperation, because I am wary of circles, because there are always those who think they are in the first division, others in the second division, and with that, we do nothing at all. But a Europe that moves forward through enhanced cooperation rather than a Europe that stagnates because we have to wait for the last one to agree.

MR. BARROSO - Regarding the question you asked me, I am for a Europe that protects; I am against a protectionist Europe. There you go, that is what is important. I agree that there is a need to respond to certain concerns of Europeans, but protectionism is not the solution for that. Regarding this question of enhanced cooperation, I would also like to tell you our position. We supported in the text of the constitutional treaty enhanced cooperation. Enhanced cooperation to give more flexibility to Europe, we are in favor. The stratification of Europe, the differentiation into first and second class countries, we are against. We believe it would be a great mistake to have a sort of division of Europe, that the response to current problems be a sort of stratification of Europe. But enhanced cooperation to solve concrete problems: yes. By the way, it is already provided for in the constitutional treaty. Unfortunately, we have not yet had the opportunity to apply them. I would like to say one more word about Turkey, earlier. Because President Sarkozy clearly explained his position. I respect his position. From the Commission's point of view, I want to say it today because my silence could be misunderstood, that we are in favor of continuing negotiations with Turkey and that we will defend the continuation of these negotiations. It is up to the member states to take their responsibilities. I believe that now, as President Sarkozy said, our absolute priority is the treaty, it is the resolution of the institutional question, that is why we must focus on that: the Council on the 21st and 22nd. That said, we think. Do not overload our agenda now with a suspension of negotiations with candidate countries, I want to say this because my silence could be misunderstood.

Thank you.