Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission, notably on the European Union's response to the international financial crisis, in Brussels on October 16, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

16 October 2008 · Joint press conference on the European Union's response to the international financial crisis · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy and Barroso addressed a joint press conference in Brussels on October 16, 2008, following a European Council meeting focused on the financial crisis and EU policy priorities.
Main themes
International financial crisis response, European Union coordination, global financial system reform, European Council outcomes, immigration policy, climate and energy package, financial sector supervision, EU-Russia relations, Felipe Gonzalez think tank, French EU presidency
Duration
~46 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,473
93rd percentile
Sentences
292
95th percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
9.7
18th percentile
Syntax
2.82
25th percentile
Vocabulary
1.96
6th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

292 sentences in 55 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

A very brief presentation. Regarding the financial and economic crisis, I confirm that all the information we provided to you with the President was unanimous. For us, now, the priority is the summit on Saturday evening with the President of the United States to prepare the global summit that the world needs, to rebuild a capitalist system, a financial system, a monetary system. We have, with President Barroso, a mandate from the 27.

As for the rest, all the measures I announced to you have been taken, including the initiative we undertook with the Commission on the economy. The study requested on the European industry, the mechanism for supervising the financial sector has been somewhat boosted. Everyone is well aware that we must no longer leave a single institution in Europe without supervision.

This morning we adopted the European Pact on Immigration. You know that this was one of France's priorities. This pact was adopted unanimously. Europe is equipping itself with a genuine immigration policy, which was expected, which was essential.

I want to particularly commend, dear François, the work of Brice Hortefeux, who skillfully led the various councils that prepared this pact. On the climate package, we also achieved unanimity.

I therefore confirm that the objectives remain the same, the timeline the same. It is up to President Barroso, for myself, to find solutions for the countries that have expressed their concerns.

Regarding Russia, relations with Russia, the council adopted the proposals of the Presidency. And finally, the think tank chaired by Felipe Gonzalez - the group of wise men - has been accepted with 9 members. As for the French member of this group, it is Nicole Notat. It was important for me that she accepted, and I simply specify that the Secretary-General who will lead this group alongside President Felipe Gonzalez will be a Slovenian.

Here too we obtained unanimity. 9 members, unanimity among 27 members, you can imagine that it was not so easy to achieve.

Mr. Jose Manuel Barroso - I would like to sincerely congratulate President Sarkozy for the exceptionally competent way in which he has led the work of this European Council. Because, let’s be clear, there were extremely difficult issues on the table and without great determination, great energy, it would have been impossible to reach a consensus while respecting the schedule.

As I usually do at the end of a European Council, I will check my checklist to see if the objectives I had were met or not. So, you will allow me to do this very briefly.

I came to this European Council with 6 major objectives: to consolidate and strengthen the consensus around the principles and actions that have been jointly undertaken to stabilize the financial sector, that is done.

To provide a perspective for the renewal of the European financial system in the longer term, notably through the commitment of member states to quickly adopt the initiatives of the Commission that have already been submitted and those that are forthcoming, that is done.

To lay the groundwork for a renewal of the financial system on a global scale, that is done.

To affirm our common determination to address the consequences of the situation in the daily lives of citizens and businesses, that is done.

To reaffirm in all this the key role of the internal market and the Euro, that is done.

To confirm a deadline for the adoption of the energy/climate package, so that our policies do not fall into short-termism, but remain oriented towards responsible solutions for the future of the planet, for the future of future generations, that is done.

In the coming weeks, the Commission will fully play its role, of course in close coordination with the French Presidency.

Based on the work of Mr. de Larosière's group - by the way, the conclusions of the European Council commend the initiative to create this group - the Commission will put forward more ideas to strengthen the European supervisory system and deepen the existing avenues for a new financial architecture on an international level.

In terms of economic policy coordination, we must continue to build a closer and more effective coordination, notably through the renewed Lisbon strategy. We will not back down in the fight against climate change; it is illusory to believe that one can choose between solving the financial crisis and solving climate change; both go hand in hand.

And I am especially satisfied, with the confirmation also clear, you will see in the conclusions that will be distributed, of the deadline of the European Council in December for an agreement among heads of state and government.

We made a very important commitment today. Because let’s be clear, before this European Council, there was a question: will the heads of state and government confirm now that there is this financial crisis with the same objectives, the same ambition, that they had decided a year ago, when the situation was different? And the answer is yes, we confirm it. We confirm the major objectives, we explicitly state in the conclusions the same level of ambition and we confirm the date. There, of course, there will be immense work still to be done. I do not want to underestimate the difficulty of the task. There, we will do it, President Sarkozy and I, the French Presidency and the Commission, we will do it to try to find specific solutions to specific problems.

But frankly, I believe it is important to highlight the commitment, the confirmation of the commitment of our heads of state and government, to move forward on this path.

I also find it very important what has been said about industry. The recognition that there is a need to have a modern, sustainable, greener industry in Europe, capable of conquering the markets of the future as a pioneer. We will fight to make it clear that we want a future for industry in Europe, and the Commission has been invited to present some proposals in this area.

Frankly, I am extremely satisfied with the results of this European Council. Once again, my sincere thanks to President Sarkozy and to all his team: the diplomats, the ministers, the experts, who have done remarkable work. I believe, in any case, that we must be honest, the work is far from finished. There is still much to be done. The commitments that have been made now by the heads of state and government must be confirmed at the level of the other Councils and all the concrete decisions we must take in the coming weeks and months.

THE PRESIDENT - Thank you, José Manuel.

QUESTION - I have a question concerning concerns about the real economy. We see that today again, financial markets have fears or even a fear regarding perhaps a recession. You have entrusted the Commission with a reflection on industry. Could you give us some more concrete ideas on what can be done at the European level to revive or, at least, to ensure that the real economy does not fall into recession?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, what we are trying to do is to get out of the financial crisis. The Prime Minister had the opportunity to tell Parliament that we are not out of it yet, and he is absolutely right. I believe we have made the right decisions. The decisions that have been made in Europe, all parts of the world are now drawing inspiration from them. But there is a whole job to inspire transparency, moralization, efficiency. That is our priority. Naturally, we can see the economic crisis that is here. And the question I posed as President of the Council to the heads of state and government: if we were able to provide a coordinated response to the financial crisis in Europe, should we not provide a coordinated response to the economic crisis in Europe? There was a vicious circle. We take a virtuous circle. Well, let’s continue it!

By January 1, France will take initiatives in this area. There is a European Council in December. We have asked the Commission to work on the question: how do we support growth and how do we support employment with a more particular reference to industry? Why? For two reasons: the Americans have just decided on $25 billion in subsidized loans for their three automakers who are in the situation you know. We must be concerned in Europe about the conditions of competition. But there is something else. Can we ask the European automotive industry to produce clean cars, to change the industrial apparatus in a few months without giving them a helping hand? That is the whole work of the study we have asked the Commission.

You know, the French Presidency, we fought not to let go of the objectives, the ambitions, and the timeline of the energy-climate package. Let no one doubt it, it has not been so easy. I can tell you that I put all the weight of France into the balance. I believe that the climate meeting is so important that we cannot, on the pretext of the financial crisis and the economic crisis, let it fall.

This is what we will work on. I add that we will certainly have a whole work of coordination among the four European G8 members, notably with Gordon Brown, Angela Merkel, Silvio Berlusconi to present a united front at the summit. But I am also thinking about how we will be able to ensure information and coordination in the euro area, and probably among the 27, to prepare for this summit, because we will be much stronger if we speak on behalf of the 27. And then, the emergence of this economic government of Europe that we have been waiting for so long, which started in Paris last Sunday, must not be stopped. Countries that have the same central bank, the same currency, must try to coordinate their economic policy. I have several ideas in this regard; it is not the time, it is not the place to put them forward. What has worked recently? It is unity, it is coordination, it is the will to move forward. We will not let down in the face of the crisis. This is all that has been the subject of our discussions. Each country, in the face of the economic crisis, will be obliged to make a number of decisions. It is up to us to ensure that there is maximum coordination. There, we are in the financial crisis, in full swing. But we know that the meeting is coming up soon. We do not have the right to disappoint.

QUESTION - The crisis for the real economy is happening immediately, and the financial crisis, the heads of state and government managed in ten days to present a rescue plan. Do you not think that we should act as quickly to help the real economy? Secondly, for the international conference you want to hold in the near future, could you give us some lines of thought on which you want to direct to establish a new international capitalist system? A question for both Presidents, Mr. Sarkozy and Mr. Barroso.

Mr. Jose Manuel Barroso - For the second question, I find it essential, indeed, the meeting we will have on Saturday with the President of the United States. Let’s be clear, there can be no solution to the major global financial issues without the active participation of the United States. That is why I attach the greatest importance to this meeting. We believe that now there is a willingness, and frankly, there was not some time ago, for us to look together at these issues, not just with our American friends but also with the major emerging countries because one thing that is evident, and this was confirmed yesterday in the analysis presented to you by Jean-Claude Trichet and also in our own analyses: this crisis is already affecting the major emerging economies. Let us not think that this is simply a few issues that may be important for Europe or for the United States, for the economies considered normally the most industrialized; there is also an effect.

And there, I believe that in the conclusions, you will find the major principles. We have already mentioned here the major principles; it is supervision across borders. It is certainly a fundamental principle of transparency. You have there a list of the major principles that we would like to be the basis of a new international financial regime, what is now often referred to as Bretton Woods 2, including, why not, also a reform of international financial institutions. I emphasize this point because it is something that the Commission has been fighting for a long time; for example, Europe, as such, does not have a real presence, a real representation, neither Europe nor the euro area.

Only a few months ago, the Commission was admitted to the Financial Stability Forum. Because the truth is that the member states are represented, but not as the eurozone, as Europe. There, I believe that there will be work to be done on governance, that we need to reform the governance of the system. These are the main lines on which we will work, and I believe that the initiative proposed by President SARKOZY, which we supported from the very beginning, of this international summit, the meeting we will have this Saturday, and after the consultation with all our partners will allow us to make very significant progress. If not now, when? This is really where we have the conditions to see a comprehensive reform. And it is with great satisfaction, I must tell you, that I saw there unanimity. There was no position of reluctance regarding this. There was a strong commitment from the heads of state and government in this direction.

THE PRESIDENT - The expression "real economy," I understand it well, but I am a bit wary of it. Behind the support plan for banks, what are we defending if not the savings of savers? In the guarantees for loans, what are we defending? The possibility of putting loans at the service of companies that want to invest. I am a bit wary, as if we were playing Monopoly. We are not playing Monopoly. Behind it, it is real economy. That a German citizen can continue to borrow to finance his apartment or that a Spanish company can invest and obtain credits from its bank. That is what we are doing; it is indeed real economy. This supposed "should we have the same coordination for economic policy as for the financial crisis," from the perspective of the French Presidency, the answer is yes, yes, yes. There it is. Is there unanimity at the moment? No, no, no. There it is. We cannot say it better.

But I want to say that we have made gigantic progress. Listen, you know, for me, I speak under the control of François FILLON who was by my side, seeing the President of the ECB discuss with the heads of state and government of the eurozone without anyone feeling their independence threatened. Finally, I wanted to say: finally! Mr. TRICHET has done remarkable work. It is a well-known secret that we have not always been exactly in agreement on everything. I think we need to work together. It would be a shame if, on top of that, we displayed divisions.

I found it useful to have a discussion, José Manuel BARROSO was also there, between the heads of state and government of the same zone and the President of the ECB. No one felt insulted in their responsibilities.

And this economic governance that we have been calling for so long, we could see that it was taking shape. It must not stop. It will undoubtedly fall to the French Presidency to take other initiatives.

On the international conference, a few topics. I spoke last night about tax havens. François FILLON mentioned it himself. Would it be normal for a bank to which we would guarantee loans or to which we would grant equity, without necessarily having all or part of the capital, to continue to operate in tax havens? Answer: no. Secondly, can it or can it not have a financial institution without a supervisor? Answer: no. Thirdly, what do we do with the famous hedge funds? And what is the difference between a hedge fund and a sovereign fund? How do we find the balance? It seems to me that these are indeed subjects for global reflection. Fourthly, the role of international institutions. Clearly, I want to raise the question of the IMF, its future, and its role. Excuse me, this is something that needs to be addressed. Little by little, the IMF has drifted into a development aid body that rated a number of countries in difficulty and gave its approval or refusal for the granting of loans. I am not saying it was useless. But the original ambition at the time of Bretton Woods for an international regulatory institution, the question deserves to be asked. I discussed it with Dominique STRAUSS-KAHN. I sincerely hope that we will reflect on the future role of the IMF, which is less of a more specialized international organization and more of a responsible one.

Fifth, the rating agencies. We can say that they are a triumph. The question: do we keep them? What do we replace them with? Should they only be American? Who should own the capital? We observe absolutely unbelievable things. The rating agencies that rate a number of actors in the stock market are sometimes owned by the same actors. Is it possible to continue like this? The extremely important question in my eyes: the remuneration of operators in the market. This is really an international problem, that is to say, the madness of bonuses at all costs that pushes to take all risks under any conditions. Here too, I think there is material to discuss.

Another subject: the world of tomorrow, the major currencies, how many should there be? What should be the agreement between these major currencies? Should we organize a discussion? Does a country like India, one day, have the vocation to have a world currency? We have tried everything in the world: snakes, fluctuations, fixed rates, no rates at all. These are subjects that need to be discussed. I deeply believe that all these subjects must be on the table, that we must prepare an ambitious agenda, that we must establish initial conclusions for a summit that I would like to take place in November, and perhaps we continue a substantive work to achieve it in several stages. I think we do not have the right to let slip the chance and opportunity to build the organization of the 21st century. It is absolutely significant. And it is in this context that we are mandated to discuss with the President of the United States and lay the foundations for this summit, which is the last expectation to respond to the financial crisis. It is to see if, now, the major regions of the world are determined to go in the same direction to restore confidence because Europe, we have done what needed to be done, the United States have done what needed to be done. Now, it is the emerging countries that are affected, and they will have to do a number of things, and then, all these blocs, we must come together to ensure coordination, unity, and complementarity of all this and finally take globalization into account.

QUESTION - I would like to ask a question to President BARROSO. You paid tribute to the work done by Nicolas SARKOZY, but I would like to ask you a question. Do you not think that the crisis we have just gone through shows the absolute necessity of a stable presidency of the Union, and what will happen on January 1st?

Mr. JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - With all my wishes, I call for the ratification of the Lisbon Treaty. You know very well, not for January 1st unfortunately, that is not possible, but you know very well, and let us be very frank, there were people who had doubts. Would the Commission not be jealous that there is a President of the Council? And I have always told you: I am in favor of having a stable President of the Council. What interests me most is the strength, let us say, of the European Union, Europe as a whole. And we need, in Europe, a President of the Council who does not change every six months. In the same way, I believe it is important that the High Representative is also Vice-President of the Commission so that we can bring together the classic intergovernmental diplomatic skills that our member states undoubtedly have - here, I speak as a former Minister of Foreign Affairs as well - but with the community skills that the Commission and the European institutions also have.

I believe that this is absolutely important. And I can tell you one thing: in my conversations with the heads of state and government - especially in recent months - I have seen that there is a much sharper awareness of the need for the Lisbon Treaty. Notably thanks, to a large extent, to the initiative of President SARKOZY, what we have been able to do under his initiative - and I am very happy to be associated with this - in Georgia and Russia. Now, on this financial crisis, it shows that it is essential for Europe. The Commission can do its job; it is doing it. We are not perfect, but I believe we are doing our job well. But it is essential for a Europe of 27 that there is also leadership from the governments themselves. Because Europe is not simply the European institutions. I always say, Europe is not just Brussels. Europe is all of us. And so, to lead the member states, we need a very strong presidency.

Well, I do not know if we are in a position to propose to President SARKOZY that he be President of the European Council; I believe he does not want it, after the experience of these months. In any case, I would vote for it, of course!

THE PRESIDENT - I believe, as always, that from a crisis, we can make an opportunity. And, as President BARROSO has very well said, I remain convinced that Europe needs a stable presidency, which takes its responsibilities, which does a number of things. We cannot work like this by changing every six months. Do you realize the importance of subjects, for example, the implementation of the agreement that with Bernard KOUCHNER, we negotiated between the Russians and the Georgians? We know every half-comma. We also know the ambiguities, and, of course, you know, when we are in a crisis situation, some ambiguities allow us to find a way out. But it is certain that there is a somewhat frustrating side to carrying something like this and then, inevitably, not managing it. Finally, it is not just frustrating; there is also "good luck to the others."

But it is something that we have not forgotten since in December, I will have to put a proposal on the table regarding Ireland. And, frankly, the paragraph we drafted on this issue is a bit of boilerplate language, and I readily admit it, but it is for a good cause. As long as we are not ready to put a solution on the table, it is not worth reopening the Pandora's box of divisions. But it is progressing, and I am hopeful that in December, all countries will have ratified. I will also go to Poland on December 6, and at that time, we will propose a roadmap to establish institutions, and then there is also the problem of the European elections. We have all this well in mind. Finally, everything in its time; there is a council in December, we will see if we need to hold other meetings before then, but really, of course, this is an issue. I believe that it has advanced, that in Europe, everyone understands that we should not fear a stable presidency of the European Council, that we need it, that Europe is not simply the lowest common denominator, that is to say, that we agree on insignificant things to better push back the difficult things that we pass from presidency to presidency. It is not possible; it must change. It is changing, and I believe that at least this crisis gives this opportunity, perhaps, to reconcile Europeans with Europe. I am ready to take a bet that from the crisis, the image of Europe can emerge strengthened. Europe that threatened, that worried, I observe, in different European public opinions that people say: "deep down, if Europe agrees, it can protect us," and really, I find that it is an extremely positive evolution. And until then, I am sure that all the presidencies that will succeed, the Czech, the Swedish, and then the Spanish, will be keen, as long as we have not adopted Lisbon, to continue on the same path. You know, do not be mistaken, no one will be able to go back.

QUESTION - Inaudible

THE PRESIDENT - I have no doubt about that. You know, I think that regardless of the individuals - and Mr. TOPOLANEK is a very respectable person - well, there are institutions that have their own logic, and everyone will be keen to live up to the institution they preside over. You know, in the face of the crisis, Europe had to take its responsibilities. I do not think anyone will allow Europe to return to a pre-crisis situation and that, ultimately, things will go very well, and it is not because one is not President of the Council that one cannot say anything in Europe. France, when there is something to say, I do not know, we may always have the right, right?

QUESTION - A question for President SARKOZY and President BARROSO. Given your busy schedule and your fatigue, I have some questions about the appropriateness of the visit to the American President on Saturday. In particular, for the reason: what is still his power? Second reason, you say, Mr. SARKOZY: "we want to refound the capitalist system" - Mr. BARROSO did not say that -. Mr. BUSH's views are rather neoliberal or even very liberal. And, third reason, you are going to ask the American President to attend the burial almost of the American empire, of the dollar empire. That is a lot to ask of the Americans.

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, I interpret your concern about our fatigue as sincere tenderness and perhaps it cost you, but know that it touches me and really, honestly, it’s nice. What is his power? I would like you to really understand our reasoning because it has not escaped me that there are elections in the United States. But think about it. The President of the United States is elected in early November, he will be installed in early January, but the newly installed President, I would be surprised if his first temptation is to rush to a summit without having reviewed all the files, even before having installed all his ministers, that the first thing he will say is: "I’m going to the summit." So, if we wait for the new President, that means that in the best case we meet, let’s say, in the spring. I am telling you that this is far too late and it is not acceptable for two reasons. Either things get worse and in that case, who would understand that we wait? Or, sir, things get better and in that case, I am as wary as the plague of those who led us here who will immediately say: "but why get upset, things are better? It’s done, sleep peacefully good people." In any case, it would be a very bad idea, so Europe wants the summit before the end of the year. Europe wants it, Europe demands it, Europe will get it. Now, regarding President BUSH, I have spoken several times with him, President BARROSO as well, his successor will have already been elected but he will still be President of the United States. There is a continuum of states and he can perfectly come to the summit accompanied by the economic team of the new President. On the contrary, it will have much more strength. And for Europe, it will not be disadvantageous either. And we will agree on two more very important things: the agenda. There it is, we have obtained the principle but the agenda is not nothing. The composition, we Europeans have to assert a number of ideas, for example, we said from the beginning that there was no question of not having the Russians. But there is also the question of the major emerging economies. And then, what do we expect from this summit? Europe will fight for this summit to result in concrete decisions and not just principles. Just for that, it is worth making the trip.

MR. JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - I would simply like to add that yesterday, you probably noticed, there was a statement from the G8, that is to say the 8 member states of the G8 and the European Commission which marks a very important point because it is, I believe, the first time that at the level of the heads of state and government of the 8 member states of the G8, plus the Commission, we assume a concrete responsibility on major international financial issues. Regarding your reference to the fact that I do not normally speak of the reform of capitalism, it is true for a very simple reason. It is that the word capitalism, in my opinion, has a very strong ideological charge and not very pleasant in some of our countries, particularly in mine which has experienced a revolution. And so, I prefer to speak of the reform of the global financial system. But it is obviously the same thing we are talking about. It is a question of semantics, do not see a fundamental difference there. I believe I can tell you that President SARKOZY and I share exactly the same desire for a profound reform of the international financial system. We believe a lot in the market economy, we are for the market economy but a market economy with rules. Ultimately, the European model, that is the European model, it is not unbridled capitalism, it is what is called in some of our states a social market economy. An economy that is a market economy but that has rules and that has, moreover, a goal of social inclusion. That is the model. So, do not see a ideological difference there, see perhaps a difference of semantics for reasons, I would say, linguistic.

QUESTION - Mr. President, as we listen to you speak, the stock markets continue to plummet despite the strategy set by the Eurogroup and the European Union, despite the plans put in place in the United States. Why is this not working? Why do the stock markets continue to plummet after having had a slight rebound and what does this ongoing decline inspire in you?

THE PRESIDENT - I told you yesterday, I will not comment every day on the stock market. When you say: "it is not working," we were looking with the Prime Minister - you can imagine how we follow this - the question of the resumption of interbank lending, the rates inside what is called Inaudible. It is decreasing, it is extremely important and the banking system is starting to function again. I am not saying that it is wonderful but finally, that was our goal. We have known for a long time that we would have a problem with the stock market for two reasons among others. The first is that a number of hedge funds, heavily indebted, must sell to deleverage, so there is downward pressure from that point of view and the second is that a number of economic indicators, particularly in the United States, which are not good, lead investors to anticipate worse results from the various listed companies than they might have imagined. But for us, the priority was to restore the banking system, so that banks could do their job, that there would be liquidity again and new lending possibilities.

There you go, we knew perfectly well that it was not easy, your question confirms it. Thank you for your lucidity, thank you all.