Joint press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. José Manuel Durão Barroso, President of the European Commission, notably on the European Union in the face of the international financial crisis and on the energy-climate package, in Brussels on October 15, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

15 October 2008 · Joint press conference by Nicolas Sarkozy and José Manuel Durão Barroso · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy and Barroso held a joint press conference in Brussels on October 15, 2008, during an EU Council meeting addressing the global financial crisis and other European issues.
Main themes
International financial crisis, EU coordinated response, global financial system reform, Lisbon Treaty, banking accounting standards reform, European financial supervision, crisis management mechanism, energy-climate package, G20 summit proposal, European unity
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,733
90th percentile
Sentences
242
93rd percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
10.1
21st percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

242 sentences in 39 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

President BARROSO and I would like to report, at least provisionally, since the conclusions will be adopted tomorrow, but out of concern that you can do your work as well as possible. You will be able to take, in a way, a progress report.

We first talked about the Lisbon Treaty. We heard the presentation from Prime Minister Brian COWEN, and the Council agreed to revisit this issue at its December meeting, with a view to defining, in December, the elements of a solution and a common path forward. I will have the opportunity, both legally and politically, to make proposals and, no doubt, I will have to return myself to Ireland.

Regarding the financial crisis and its economic consequences, we are moving, I say this cautiously under the control of President BARROSO - tomorrow we will reread the minutes of decisions - towards the following results: first, I believe I can say that all of Europe, without exception, approves the measures of the coordinated action plan adopted last Sunday in Paris. In the face of an unprecedented crisis, the 27 countries of Europe now have a united response, a massive response with a clear employment doctrine. These are, moreover, the principles defined by the member states of the euro area, the United Kingdom, Denmark, Sweden, and others, which now inspire the measures taken in other countries around the world, particularly in the United States.

The second result: the Commission - and I want to pay tribute to its work, once again - decided today, after agreement from Parliament, I want to say, as I said to President PÖTTERING, how important it was for Parliament to decide quickly. Let us pay tribute to the speed of decision-making of the European Parliament; it is exceptional. In 24 hours, they decided to approve the following: the Council also approved it: the modification of the accounting standards applicable to banks so that the principle of market valuation no longer applies blindly to their assets, I add sometimes absurdly. This was one of the decisions from the Paris summit last Sunday; well, it is being implemented today with the agreement of all and will therefore be applicable from the results of the third quarter of 2008. Even if this may seem technical, I draw your attention to the fact that the member states, Parliament, the Commission, all together, have gotten to work on this and it will be applicable from the results of the third quarter of 2008. This is a speed of decision-making that we have rarely seen in this area. I must say that President BARROSO played a decisive role.

The third result, the Council has agreed to adopt the creation of the crisis management cell that the euro area states called for a few days ago. This will be a light operational mechanism that, of course, is not intended to replace existing institutions, but this small cell will facilitate the exchange of information between states, provide advice if needed, and coordinate actions among us. We will finalize tomorrow the details of the mechanism that will be put in place in the coming days.

The fourth result: a large number of heads of state and government emphasized the need to strengthen supervision of the European financial sector, particularly for transnational groups. We have therefore recognized the need for significantly enhanced coordination among national supervisors. Some states have even asked us, both Mr. BARROSO and myself, to be more ambitious. This shows that ideas are progressing and that everyone sees the necessity of doing this.

Fifth, we are unanimous in saying that we must go further than emergency measures, and thus unanimous in Europe in calling for the re-founding of the global financial system. Let me be clear: Europe will not let this crisis go without consequences. It is very clear; we have experienced the crisis of emerging countries, we have experienced the internet bubble crisis, and now we have this massive crisis. We are determined that consequences will be drawn regarding the financial system, the monetary system, and the re-founding of capitalism. And this now, I believe I can say under the control of President BARROSO, is unanimous. We do not want the same causes to produce the same effects tomorrow. And we are unanimous in saying that this re-founding must be global. This means: no financial institution should escape regulation or oversight, transparency for all financial actors, without exception, a remuneration system that must be completely overhauled to avoid promoting blind risk-taking, and leaders and directors who must be held accountable for their decisions. And really, I was pleased to see this unanimity.

I add that everyone agrees on the necessity of holding, in the near future, a global summit on this subject and perhaps on others. Together with President BARROSO, we will carry this message to the United States, on Saturday, in response to the invitation from President BUSH at Camp David.

We will carry and defend the ideas of Europe. We will carry the message of Europe, and Europe no longer wants the same causes to produce the same effects. Europe will not accept that those who, around the world, have led us to where we are, are the ones who manage the crisis and return to the old routine. Things, I believe, are perfectly clear from this point of view, and we will both represent Europe to prepare for an international summit for a new Bretton Woods. Understand that we are in the realm of re-founding, and we want this summit to take place before the end of the year. And we think that November is the best time.

Finally, we all agree in saying that in the face of the financial crisis, from which we have not yet emerged and from which we must emerge, the economic crisis - I want to say this personally - even if we have begun to lay the groundwork, we can emerge from the financial crisis through unity, but we will need to apply the same rules for the economic crisis. Here too, Europe cannot tell the world: "do not return to the bad habits of pre-crisis." I say to Europe: let us not return to the bad habits either, that is, not talking about issues, not coordinating, dividing ourselves, and therefore, we are fully aware that we also have an economic issue, and with the help of the Commission, we will work on it. Then, at dinner, we talked extensively about energy security and the energy-climate package. I have supported with all my strength, because I believe it is absolutely essential, the Commission's energy-climate package. I have argued that we cannot go back on the "3 times 20" objective. This is not something we can accept. Moreover, the timeline matters, and we need to find a solution before January. We will be mandated, President BARROSO and I, to find this solution. I am convinced that we will manage to find it, and we have a very in-depth discussion. We must take into account the specific problems of some of our colleagues, but the environmental issue is absolutely essential; it is a historical responsibility. I am among those who believe that the crisis should not diminish our ambitions, but rather, we must move beyond the dilemma of growth or environmental protection. We will demonstrate that clean growth is a possibility for a rebound in growth.

I do not hide from you that there have been discussions, positions taken, but we will find solutions. I think there are points of flexibility, but my conviction is that it is not more difficult to find an ambitious agreement than a very small agreement. I mean that compromises for a small agreement risk satisfying no one. We will focus on finding a compromise for a large agreement.

Mr. BARROSO - Very briefly, a few points I would like to emphasize, of course, supporting all the remarks made by President SARKOZY, as President of the European Council. On the economic question, four points, in my opinion, are essential. First point: unanimous confirmation by the 27 member states of the line that was defined at the Eurogroup summit. This is very important; Europe is unique, it has a plan, it has a doctrine. It has a plan that takes into account the diversity of national situations but that commits member states to take these measures within the framework of certain principles that are defined together. This, in my opinion, was already very important. Then, an agreement, I can also tell you, unanimous to work together, to review everything that is happening in Europe in terms of regulation and supervision. There is now a consensus among our member states that we can do much more in this area. We have given examples of some initiatives that have been taken by the Commission, whether it is the revision of the "capital requirement" conditions, the conditions of own resources of banks, whether it is the directive that we approved today, the proposal to the Commission regarding deposit guarantees, whether it is the change in accounting standards that we also adopted today after a procedure initiated by the Commission with the participation, of course, of the European Parliament and the Council, whether it is also a proposal that we have been preparing for some time regarding the regulation of rating agencies, or our commitment to review some principles regarding executive remuneration in this type of institution. Here are some concrete aspects, in addition to a more medium-term reflection on supranational or cross-border supervision among our countries in financial matters.

Thirdly, I believe this is the most innovative point in this European Council compared to others: we agree to move forward on a global initiative. Financial markets today are integrated markets, global markets, so Europe is essential for a global response, but the only European response is not enough. That is why there was unanimous support for the proposal that President SARKOZY had already made to the United Nations General Assembly for a global summit on this matter. President SARKOZY and I will meet the American President this weekend to work with the Americans. It is essential; I insist that Europe and the United States must work hand in hand for a new international financial system and to engage other emerging economies as well. From the analysis presented to us today by the President of the European Central Bank, it is evident that this crisis will also have effects, not just in the United States, in Europe, but also in the large emerging economies. We are beginning to see some of these effects.

In my opinion, these were the main conclusions regarding finance. But there was a conclusion regarding the real economy, if I can use this distinction, that is to say, we will work together to revive the European economy because this financial crisis is already beginning to have effects on the economy of households and businesses. We need to find ways to revive this European economy, particularly to see what the main challenges are regarding threats to employment. We have discussed some aspects and we will come up with some concrete proposals.

On climate change, I tell you my conviction that we will find a solution during the French Presidency. Let us be clear and totally frank: it is difficult now because in a situation of economic and financial crisis, naturally, there is a lot of pressure on different governments to become more cautious. There has been a very open, very frank debate where everyone presented their difficulties, but I believe I can tell you that there has been a great consensus around the objectives of the package presented by the European Commission, namely a 20% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions, 20% for renewable energies, 20% for energy efficiency, all by 2020. Of course, within these objectives, which some have called red lines, we can discuss some mechanisms of flexibility. There is now a mandate for the Council Presidency and the European Commission to work with the different member states to try to find specific solutions for their specific problems but with a commitment. Because I had the opportunity to say, this is a fundamental choice, the one that all heads of state and government will make, a choice between the short term and the ethics of responsibility. We have a responsibility that goes well beyond this moment. We have a responsibility to the future of our planet and to future generations. I believe the European Council has started very well. I hope that tomorrow these guiding lines will be confirmed unanimously.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you mentioned the many points of agreement among the 27 heads of state and government. There is one where you did not mention unanimity, and that is regarding the European supervisor. Clearly, there have been hesitations concerning the creation of a European supervisor. Could you tell us more about that? Second question on the environment, do you not feel that ultimately, the financial crisis risks having a disastrous effect on global warming?

THE PRESIDENT - Regarding the European supervisor, I had seen that before the Council, there were different positions, but I find that at the Council, those who expressed themselves were mainly those who felt we lacked ambition and that we needed to develop at least a coordination of European supervisors. We will try, tonight, in drafting the texts, to find the right formula. But the will is that no institution should be without a supervisor, that all institutions should be required to be transparent, and that there should be at least a coordination of national supervisors; I think I can say that there was unanimity, at least as I understood it. There may have been concerns from smaller countries, but it seems to me that everyone understood the stakes. The crisis can be a revealing factor for those who were the least dynamic in terms of environmental concern. I think it can strengthen their prevention or their lukewarmness. I mean, if there had not been a crisis: we would still have had problems. Since all of you who follow these issues with passion and care had said well before the systemic crisis we are experiencing that there would be difficulties. So, let us not hide behind the crisis. Global warming, whether there is a financial crisis or not, is here. The ambition and boldness of the European Commission on the package were the same before the crisis.

I do not give up on the objective and the timeline. Moreover, I was very struck to see that among those - we must understand them, since there are countries that come from further away - who have a longer way to go, none said that we should give up on the objectives, and as for the timeline, I said that I would not accept that we give it up.

Therefore, we have found an agreement: we have two and a half months to find a solution. Allow me to say: a short time helps to find a good compromise. That is the argument I put forward. If we are not able in two and a half months to find a good compromise! We are not going to do as before, that is to say, we pass it to the next Presidency, which passes it to the next Presidency, which itself passes it to the next Presidency. We will deal with it now. Everyone will take their responsibilities in December. In any case, we, both of us, will have put in the effort to get this package adopted.

There are margins of flexibility because I am convinced of the necessity of great environmental ambition for Europe. What is it about? Is Europe capable of having an impact in the world on such an essential issue? Yes or no? If Europe wants to have an impact, Europe must be exemplary. If Europe's first decision, due to the crisis, is to lower its ambitions and its timeline, Europe will not have an impact. If some want Europe not to have an impact, let them say so. In any case, that is not the policy of the French Presidency. That is not the policy of the Presidency of the Commission. Therefore, the choice will be very clear. But it will not be the choice of flexibility on the Commission's package. It will be the choice: do we want a Europe that matters or do we want a Europe that does not matter? I believe that it has been long enough that we have experienced a Europe that does not matter for us to experience a Europe that does matter. This requires effort. We will get to work with the President of the Commission. We will find flexibilities. In the communiqué, we will say that we must take into account a number of particular situations; perhaps we have not taken them into account sufficiently. But on the overall objective, we really agree; we want to do this.

QUESTION - Next week, there will be a meeting in Paris on tax havens. In terms of transparency and control, what can we expect from this meeting? And the second thing: what will happen with Russia? Will there be negotiations for a strategic partnership in light of what happened today in Geneva where the negotiations were not very positive? There were no negotiations; it was postponed.

THE PRESIDENT - To respond regarding tax havens, this will be part of the package of discussions on Saturday night in Washington and then at the summit. For example, could we accept that banks whose loans we guarantee, to whom we provide equity, continue to work with tax havens? That is a question that arises. It is unnecessary, and it is very clear; this can also be part of the behavioral rules. That is enough now. We have entered a new world; it is 2008. It is time to realize that we are in the 21st century. That is one of the proposals.

It is not for me to decide; it is for President Barroso, but it is a subject that we will clearly put on the table. Clearly. And immediately. This is part of the discussion on Russia. We did not talk about it. I mentioned it just at the end of dinner; I will reiterate my conviction that in terms of energy security and the energy-climate package, it seems to me more interesting and more intelligent to discuss with our Russian neighbor in a positive, transparent, and responsible manner. I am thinking of a number of subjects: the issue of Lithuania, for example, which, in its accession treaty, I remind you, committed to closing its nuclear power plant. This is part of the subjects I would like to put on the agenda of the European Union-Russia with President Barroso. As, for example, the energy supply of Lithuania. But how can we put this subject on the agenda if we do not discuss? So, we will discuss, and I am in favor of this discussion and this frank and, at the same time, friendly dialogue.

You tell me that the discussions in Geneva started painfully. Frankly, the opposite would have been very surprising. It is very surprising. I remind you that the Georgian crisis began on August 8, and we are now on October 15. We are two months later. I am willing to accept that not everything is perfect, that is for sure, but, after all, if we had not done this, where would we be? And have we seen a ceasefire achieved in less than two months? A withdrawal of the Russian army achieved in less than two months? Discussions on the status of Abkhazia and South Ossetia - Georgian territories. But, after all, the problem was raised before August 8, since it was the subject of UN resolutions; that it engages in pain, I am convinced. But that does not mean we should give up, and if, moreover, we create the conditions for a Europe-Russia confrontation, in the difficulties in which the world is struggling, I really wonder if that would be reasonable. In any case, that is not the policy we have followed, so, within the framework of this summit, we will talk about everything, including energy security.

QUESTION - I have two questions. The first is: could you enlighten us on the supervision of large financial institutions? Is it only about European financial institutions or about global financial institutions, and in that case, how do you integrate the Chinese into this effort?

Second question: do you envision that everything you are doing, all the efforts you are making, might not work? Do you have a plan B?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, this supervision that we want with President Barroso concerns primarily Europe. Because if I observe the difficulties we have had, it is not about giving lessons to the whole world and not looking at what is happening at home. But at the same time, this supervision would make no sense if it were not global as well. And after talking about tax havens, I want to talk about hedge funds, all those who were very happy to make fortunes by borrowing from anyone, in any way. We are not going to start that again. We are not going to go around again.

So, obviously, this supervision, this transparency, must be as we have done for accounting standards. What do we do in accounting standards? We also try to put our financial institutions on an equal footing with what is happening in the United States.

We cannot have some being super-supervised, others super-not supervised, all in a world where everyone is interconnected. That would not make sense.

You say: "and the Chinese?" But it happens that next week, with President Barroso, we are in Beijing. I am sorry; it is not for tourism... I see the bad spirit that reigns in Brussels! There is the summit, after all, which is very important for all European countries and all Asian countries. With, at the forefront, China, of course, which will co-chair with Europe and, at the same time, India. And perhaps this will be the opportunity - even surely - to talk about the subject we will discuss on Saturday in Washington. I tell you things. I am very happy because I had launched the idea of the summit in agreement with President Barroso since I was speaking on behalf of Europe at the United Nations podium at the end of September. I had launched the idea of this summit, and in my mind, it was absolutely clear that it was at least a G8. I would like someone to explain to me how the Russians could not participate, and I had the opportunity to tell President Medvedev in Evian a few days ago how attentive I was to his natural participation. But, of course, and I had said it right from the speech at the United Nations - that the question of the major emerging economies, Madam... China, which is a monetary power, which is a financial power, must participate. But would I dare to say that in my mind: and India? And, by the way, in the G8 declaration that came out a few hours ago, we talk about a summit that is not simply that of the G8.

It is not up to President Barroso and myself to set the boundaries, but I observe that things are progressing. We started from "no summit," then to a G7, then to a G8, and now we are in the "G8 Plus."

Is it a G8 that should stop at G13? A number that resonates well for me because I have always thought it was very important. Some think it should go up to a G20. We will discuss it; it is the subject of our discussions, but it goes without saying that this crisis is so important that it must concern all parts of the world, that no one should feel excluded from what we are in the process of rebuilding. But I reiterate: Europe will present a common vision and an ambitious vision. We do not want this to happen again. We want the consequences to be drawn from what we know. We are already having enough trouble finding the right solution to restore confidence, to restore calm. We are really determined to go to the end of this absolutely necessary rebuilding.

QUESTION - Were there any comments around the table about the nervousness of the financial markets today? Does this mean that despite the measures taken on Sunday, there is difficulty in regaining confidence?

THE PRESIDENT - Mr. Bachy, neither Mr. Barroso nor I will comment every day on the stock market, even if we would be lying to you if we said we do not watch it. Moreover, the President of the ECB participated in all our discussions, and we ensure, the President of the Commission and I, that everything we do, we do it together. All the institutions, the President of the Eurogroup, the President of the ECB, we work, we push together.

There have been bad figures that have come out regarding the American economy, and we know very well that the process we have initiated is an extremely difficult process, that it is not enough to snap our fingers for everything to be resolved. But we believe that we have put in place the right strategy. It is not the expression "plan B" that I would use. The last one who used it in France is hardly still there to carry it, his plan? Frankly, we have not seen many ideas that nourish plan B. If I had a plan B to find, I would try to put a little more substance into it. I truly believe that what we have done was absolutely necessary. Will it need to be supplemented to improve it further? Certainly, Madam, certainly. But I believe that the objective, which is to allow financial institutions to do their job, to put money back into the economy so that households and businesses can borrow, I believe that is perfectly necessary. We must show a lot of composure, a lot of perseverance in managing this crisis, which is undoubtedly one of the most difficult the world has faced in many years.

QUESTION - Mr. President, our Prime Minister, today, Mr. BERLUSCONI said that he was ready to veto the climate-energy package if his concerns are not heard by the Council. What could you do to convince him to say yes?

THE PRESIDENT - First, I greatly appreciate Italy... and I have proven it! And I also greatly appreciate the President of the Italian Council. He intervened with arguments that were very relevant and that consisted of saying: we already have the problem of relocations, we cannot put too much on our industries, we must be careful. It is not just the problem of Eastern countries, I apologize. There is also the problem of industrialized countries. He is right to raise the questions in these terms, and we cannot blame him for that. He is doing his job by doing so. But I also think that we have a historical responsibility: European leaders, in the face of the environmental objective. We cannot postpone it any longer. I am convinced that with Silvio BERLUSCONI, we will find a good agreement, and I can say one thing that I deeply believe: he is not a man who blocks processes; he is a man who, at the beginning of the discussion, calls attention to the convictions he has or the interests he wants to defend, but he is a man I know well and who, at the end of the discussion, has always prioritized a European dimension and with whom it has always been possible to find a compromise.

I want to say this because it is true. It has nothing to do with politics, no, he has always made sure that Italy, when he was in charge, was a factor of unity. At the beginning of a discussion, we each have positions and sometimes they are a bit heated. But, in the end, I have no doubt that he will contribute to the compromise we are going to seek. Thank you all.