Joint press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission, notably on the common strategy of Europeans ahead of the G20 Summit in Washington on the consequences of the international financial crisis, in Brussels on November 7, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

7 November 2008 · Joint press conference ahead of the G20 Summit in Washington on the international financial crisis · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy addressed a joint press conference with Barroso in Brussels on November 7, 2008, outlining Europe's unified strategy ahead of the G20 Washington Summit on the global financial crisis.
Main themes
G20 Washington Summit preparation, European common position on financial crisis, financial system reform, economic policy coordination, transparency and regulation, fight against tax havens, rating agencies reform, short-termism, entrepreneurial capitalism, EU unity, transatlantic diplomacy
Duration
~47 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,646
93rd percentile
Sentences
305
95th percentile
Readability
55
76th percentile
Grade
10.1
21st percentile
Syntax
2.88
31st percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
15th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

305 sentences in 47 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - This meeting aimed to define a common strategy, a common position, a common set of beliefs among Europeans before the Washington Summit on November 15, which will address the consequences to be drawn from the unprecedented financial crisis that the world has experienced. This informal meeting allowed for a very broad debate, a very wide-ranging overview. Almost all states spoke, and I can say that there is a fairly detailed common position of Europe before the Washington summit. We will defend a common position in Europe, a vision of Europe for the rebuilding of our financial system. All countries agree on this necessity. All agree on the requirement - words have meaning - for strong, ambitious, operational decisions at the Washington Summit, which must not be merely a meeting to exchange or analyze the causes of the crisis. We must, starting from the Washington Summit, provide answers to the financial crisis. These answers can be found in the fairly detailed text that the Presidency has presented on the necessity of transparency, on changes to standards, on the necessary fight against tax havens, on the end of off-balance-sheet notions for banks, on the necessity that all financial institutions be supervised or controlled, on the issue of rating agencies, and on the issue of short-termism. That is to say, this madness of short-term thinking that is akin only to speculation, while we want to think, in economic terms, about the medium and long term to favor an entrepreneurial capitalism. Whatever the differences around the table, we have agreed on the text that will be distributed to you. This text has been the subject of a consensus. So, some, depending on their sensitivity, are more or less insistent on certain areas. We do not want to move from a lack of regulation to too much regulation, but we want to change the rules of the financial game.

This is the foundation. Europe will therefore go to Washington with the will to defend a line, that of transparency and rebuilding.

The second point of agreement: the concern of all European states regarding the seriousness of the economic situation, and all, I say all, are convinced of the necessity to take economic initiatives after the financial initiatives. All agree to ask the Commission to propose an economic strategy as early as the formal summit in December, and all agree on the absolute necessity of coordinating economic policies in Europe. Words have meaning. Coordination does not mean that we all have to do the same thing because our situations are not the same for everyone, but that we must go in the same direction: coordinate our economic policies as we have coordinated our financial policies. This is the will of the 27 states. This is the decision we made today. There you go, it was an extremely rich discussion, long, nearly 3 and a half hours, intense, unusual, informal, therefore extremely free, but which allowed us to outline a corpus for a European position. I would like, before giving the floor to José-Manuel, after wishing him a happy birthday, he is not yet 50 years old of course, but the organization he presides over was celebrating its 50th anniversary. Everyone is complacent in their own way... I would like to say that I had the opportunity, yesterday, to discuss the Washington Summit in detail with President BUSH, to tell him that we wanted ambitious and operational decisions and that I would do everything in my power with President Barroso to ensure that Europe has a common position, that this should not be seen as aggression towards anyone, that it should not be seen as a risk of rigidity of opposition. This is not an imperative mandate since it is an informal council, but that we must now get used to a political innovation: political Europe speaks with one voice and that everyone must be aware of this novelty. And I spoke, before the Council, more particularly about these issues with Gordon Brown. We find ourselves, which will not surprise anyone, on the same line. I also want to pay tribute to Gordon's creativity and contribution. With Angela Merkel, I want to say that we share exactly the same point of view on the preparation for the Washington Summit and on the consequences to be drawn from it, and with Jean-Claude Juncker, we also noted a very great convergence of views, which was confirmed by Jean-Claude Juncker's remarks during this summit. And then I also mentioned the summit, if only out of courtesy and because it is important, with the elected President, Barack Obama, to indicate to him the state of mind in which we, Europeans, were going to the Washington Summit. It seemed important to me since, in any case, there will be another summit, at a minimum. And everyone understands well, it is not for me to decide, or to know, what the conclusions of the meeting between President Bush and President Obama on Monday will be. It is the Americans' problem to see how they are represented, but, in any case, presumably the second summit on global governance and on the follow-up to what should be drawn from Washington will take place with President Obama. It was entirely normal that we talked about it, and I had this conversation in detail at 10:00 PM last night with President Obama. It was entirely normal for Europeans to explain what their positions would be.

JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - To respect linguistic diversity, especially the minority language, I will speak in English. Why not? I will see for the questions. Europe will convey a common, clear, strong message at the Washington meeting. In unison with President Sarkozy, I will represent the common interests of the 27 member states of the European Union. We will put forward concrete proposals with our national partners based on the terms of reference that have been the subject of a complete, total agreement today, concerning these terms of reference that will be distributed very shortly. Such terms of reference are extremely important. Once again, I would like to pay tribute to President Sarkozy's role in managing to forge a consensus around the terms of reference. I intend to continue working with him as well as with the Czech Presidency in order to continue working on the basis that will have been built. The Washington meeting cannot afford to fail. This was one of the messages in today's discussion. This meeting must be a truly historic meeting, that we do not just agree on general principles but that we also give birth to concrete decisions. Beyond purely financial issues, we also agreed - which is also important - that reforms of the international financial system must already be able to integrate all the major challenges of the beginning of the 21st century, challenges that we are determined to meet: food security, the fight against poverty, the fight against climate change, and the promotion of free trade through a swift and successful conclusion of negotiations. I believe it is extremely important to understand and emphasize this. It must be understood that this is about the financial system, it is true, but ultimately what this is about is launching a process of reforms of global governance where, together, we, Europeans, would truly propose to the rest of the world some common principles, some common rules that will allow us to tackle these major global challenges: trade, development, and also the fight against climate change.

We also agreed - and on this, the agreement was unanimous - that we must go beyond the financial crisis, to address the economic crisis. That is why I am pleased to have noted the support for the ideas developed by the Commission on the need to move towards a coordinated European response. You know, last week, we already talked about this after our meeting. After this meeting, we highlighted some general concepts regarding a general European framework that went from the financial crisis to economic recovery. And we have now received a clear mandate to put forward clear proposals at the meeting in December that would address the real economy. Now, the idea that we have, and this while working closely with the French Presidency and with ECOFIN, is that we intend to explore the possibilities that would allow us to take advantage of the synergies between the European and global dimensions. The conclusions are also very clear from this point of view. The European summit asked us, the Commission, to present a European strategy based on the Lisbon strategy as well as on the Stability and Growth Pact, including principles of action as well as specific measures that will allow us to face the economic slowdown and maintain growth and employment. This is of essential importance and it is our most immediate task. There you go, I am therefore very pleased with the results of this summit and I think that President SARKOZY and the French Presidency have once again made a significant contribution to this most important idea. That is to say, the idea is much stronger when we can act in unison. This is important for us here in Europe, for our fellow citizens, but I think it could also be important for the rest of the world. And from there, there is a real possibility in working with our American partners but also in working with others, and it is clear that the institutions of the 21st century will never be the same as those we had in the 20th. The world has changed, and that is why the European Union has primarily supported the idea of working with emerging economies. With President SARKOZY, we made it clear at the ASEM Summit a few days ago. We have not forgotten the poorest in the world, the developing countries. These developing countries are also already suffering from the negative impacts of this crisis, and it is our duty to live up to our commitments to them. I think of food security, I also think of the Millennium Development Goals. I believe there is a real historic opportunity here, and I am pleased to see that Europe wants to seize this opportunity.

QUESTION - Mr. President, Mr. President of the Commission, hello. 48 hours after the election of Barack OBAMA, what is your message to Barack OBAMA, the European Union, and France? And what do you expect from the new American administration? What are the expectations of the European Union?

THE PRESIDENT - The choice made by the American people fills with pride all friends of the United States of America. This America that has spoken is the great America, the open, generous America that has chosen the future, diversity, which has made a choice that many doubted it could make, and we love America when it lives up to the dreams it has inspired; that is the reality of the matter. And what do we expect from President OBAMA? That he helps us bring more justice to world affairs, to change global governance, to put the environment at the heart of the world's priorities, as President BARROSO has very well said. Who can think that we can achieve the revolution of sustainable growth without the United States of America? That is the first thing we expect from him, that is the first thing that seems crucial to me: that the United States of America be at the rendezvous of preserving the planet. We expect the American President to be by our side so that the crisis does not sacrifice the interests of the poorest developing countries that will suffer more than others from the crisis, and therefore, that we, together with the United States of America, meet the Millennium Goals.

There are three areas: the reform of global governance, the revolution of sustainable development, green growth, and the respect of commitments on the Millennium Goals. This is what Europe wishes. To work hand in hand with the United States of America as two allies, as two friends, as two partners who share the same convictions, the same values, and who must be at this rendezvous. We have a lot of work ahead of us, and that is what we discussed with President OBAMA last night. That we wanted to work together, to look to the future in the same direction, and to be fully aware of all the hopes that have been raised and that must not be disappointed.

QUESTION - Two questions: I would like to have a bit of detail about the delegations that will go to the G20. Rumor has it that France would give up its seat to Spain, that you would take Czechs with you. Will Mr. JUNCKER be part of the trip? Can you clarify this, if it has been specified?

The second question is more technical: in the reform that you are advocating, will the IMF have any oversight or authority over central banks?

THE PRESIDENT - I must understand that the first question is not technical... First of all, regarding the role of the IMF, everyone around the table is aware that we need to rethink the responsibilities of the various international organizations. The IMF in particular, but others as well, such as the World Bank. How should we organize all of this within the multiplicity of international organizations that, by multiplying, have lost clarity and strength? It is too early to say what agreement there will be on what the proper reform of the IMF should be. For some, it should be the central bank of central banks. For others, it should have a significant investment and stabilization fund. For others still, it should warn countries that deviate from a certain line. We cannot conclude the summits before they have taken place. But it is clear that the question of the IMF's accountability will be clearly raised.

Regarding participation, this is an important issue. It is not solely for me to decide. From the moment we gather the G20, it is certain that the more people there are in Washington, the more we open Pandora's box of participation. Finally, speaking for myself, I want to say that it seems difficult to explain that the eighth largest economy in the world, I mean Spain, does not have its place in the meeting of the 20 largest economies in the world. This is not an ideological problem; it is a matter of common sense. However, it happens that France has two seats, one as a Council member and the other as a G8 member state, so it poses no problem for Spain to occupy one of these two seats as Spain, without taking France's place. I think this argument has been easily argued to President BUSH, the inviting power, and it seems quite normal to me, and I have indicated this with President BARROSO to the 27. Because we are working hand in hand and transparently.

Secondly, there are still a number of issues to resolve. That of the Netherlands, which, to my knowledge, is the 16th largest economy in the world. If we are talking about the 20, the question is not whether there are enough Europeans or too many Europeans, but whether the Netherlands has a role to play in this debate. I am among those who believe they do. The problem is not resolved, but I have said it in front of the 27, haven't I, Jose Manuel? I will advocate for their participation. I forget nothing, Mr. Leparmentier, especially when I am responding to you!

Regarding the Eurogroup, the problem is a bit more complicated. If the Eurogroup is only the meeting of finance ministers, the Washington Summit, to my knowledge, is not a meeting of finance ministers. Therefore, there is no reason for the President of the finance ministers to be in Washington since the presence of finance ministers in Washington will only happen alongside heads of state and government. If the Eurogroup were to evolve, which some in Europe wish, to become a body, how to say, of heads of state and government, then, obviously, the question will have to be raised. So, it is all a matter of the conception we have of the Eurogroup.

Do we want to give it an exclusively economic and financial dimension, or do we want to give it a political dimension? At that moment, yes. The question is all the advantage of Jean-Claude JUNCKER, both finance minister and head of government, who should not fear such an evolution and who should, indeed, even wish for it. I take this opportunity to say, contrary to what I have read in the press, that I am not asking for a systematic meeting, before each Council, of the Eurogroup in the formation of heads of state and government. That would have no meaning, no utility. It would actually go against what I want to do. That is to say, when there is a serious problem, heads of state and government need to be able to meet. I have spoken about this with Jean-Claude JUNCKER, who is someone I appreciate, who has a very great experience in European affairs, who is very useful, who has been, moreover, a man of consensus and compromise in the best sense of the term throughout this crisis. It is in this sense that we must evaluate the presence, in future summits, of the presidency of the Eurogroup as a political institution.

As for the Presidency of the Commission, the problem has not arisen since the Commission is a member of the G8 and the G8 is a member of the G20, so there is no problem.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you said there is perfect convergence of views with Ms. MERKEL. Does this also concern the economic governance you mentioned? Secondly, to return to Mr. JUNCKER, you also say you want to talk about currencies at this meeting. Is there not a certain inconsistency that the current representative of the Eurozone does not participate when it comes to currency?

THE PRESIDENT - I must say that we are preparing the Washington summit with Ms. MERKEL and her collaborators absolutely hand in hand. I do not know what to do because I tell you, you do not believe us, and yet, this is the reality. I can tell you that there is not a shadow of a disagreement on the preparation of the Washington summit with Ms. MERKEL and her team. Moreover, Angela MERKEL has supported the Presidency's document and has been, at all points of the discussion we have had, an element that has pushed towards consensus.

On economic governance, fundamentally, there is no disagreement. I was very pleased to see Ms. MERKEL who considered that, one, there is a need for economic stimulus, and two, there is a need for economic coordination. I speak under the control of the President of the Commission. I do not believe I am distorting the truth by saying this. However, the words may have a different meaning on one side of the Rhine and the other. I readily acknowledge that. If by economic governance, we mean a federal Europe, even economic policy in each country, that is not what I defend as an idea. That is not what I advocate. If we mean coordination, to use Angela MERKEL's expression: toolbox, which she had used, you may remember, in Colombey regarding the financial crisis. No, there is no disagreement. I know well that in Germany you are in a coalition, that the finance minister does not quite agree with the Chancellor, that he is sometimes less amiable. But I do not respond because, for me, the friendship between France and Germany must rise well above these little pettiness.

A word on currency. Currency is a very important point and that is, moreover, what brought Gordon BROWN into our discussion. I completely agree: how can we talk about the financial consequences of the crisis without talking about currency, without talking about the relationships between currencies, without talking about the monetary system, without talking about the fact that we are moving into a world, the 21st century, where there will not be a single currency? Bretton Woods was built around a single currency, the dollar. Today, that is no longer the case and it should no longer be the case. We all agree on the need to talk about it. Regarding the President of the Eurogroup, I refer you to Mr. LEPARMENTIER's quite precise response. I would see only advantages to the presence of the President of the Eurogroup. This would mean, at that moment, that the Eurogroup is therefore institutionalized as a meeting, from time to time, of heads of state and government since the Washington meeting is a meeting of heads of state and government. You see, we sometimes take different paths but we arrive at the same result!

QUESTION - The first question concerns the fact that Barack OBAMA may not be present at the first meeting even if, indeed, he will be present at the second. Does this not seriously limit the exercise of the G20 summit in Washington? Second question: do you think it is wise or appropriate for the G20 to call for a revival of the Doha cycle with possibly the launch of an inter-ministerial conference before the end of the year?

THE PRESIDENT - It is not for us Europeans to decide who should be present. But what was the other solution? The other solution was, we talked about it with Mr. BARROSO, we talked about it with President BUSH at Camp David, to wait for the installation of the elected President. Remind me: the end of January. I believe it is January 20. Do you think we could wait between the beginning of November, the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers was on September 18, could we afford to wait three months for the world's leading economic power to have a President? I am sorry: the world is multipolar. We cannot only wait for the United States, of which I am a friend, to act. We could also say: wait, Germany is going into elections, Great Britain has elections. There are always elections in the world. So, President OBAMA and President BUSH have people of sufficiently high quality to have the responsibility to think that these are the United States of America working together. I imagine that the collaborators will intertwine and that they will find the best solution.

On Doha, we all agreed that protectionism would be a disaster and no one around the European table wants a return to protectionism. Therefore, the revival of the WTO process, we all agree on what a free global trade can represent as a chance for growth. So, after that, there may be disagreements, and at some point, will we not have to ask the question of reforming the conditions for negotiating a WTO agreement? Because after seven years, we have not reached an agreement. Perhaps there is a procedural problem that arises.

QUESTION - One of the fundamental principles for which Europe has agreed today is the principle of transparency. However, there are countries in Europe and outside the European Union but in Europe - I am thinking of Switzerland - that practice banking secrecy, which seems, a priori, rather contradictory to the basic principle of maximum transparency. Do you think banking secrecy is destined to disappear? Should it disappear? Should we put in place the elements to make it disappear in the European Union and in Europe?

THE PRESIDENT - To my knowledge, Switzerland is not yet a member of the European Union. It is not a signatory of this text. I even understood that among the Swiss authorities, these banking issues weighed in the repeatedly expressed desire not to integrate into the European Union.

Second remark on banking secrecy: in relation to whom? I am for banking secrecy when it comes to protecting individuals' privacy. Everyone has the right not to have their bank account exposed. That is why we have advocated for transparency, which goes quite far, particularly regarding tax havens. We are not naive enough to say that it is enough to decide to eliminate tax havens. However, we can certainly impose on our banks that when there is a transfer from a bank to a tax haven or from a tax haven to a bank, that transfer be reported to the supervisory and control authorities. Therefore, to the notion of banking secrecy, I prefer the notion of banking transparency. Because banking transparency implies the refusal of secrecy towards regulatory and supervisory authorities but guarantees secrecy for the individuals that we all are. From this point of view, I believe there is a very strong common commitment, including in Europe. Everyone seems to have integrated that these reservations towards stronger regulations that may have been expressed in the past are no longer relevant and are no longer timely.

QUESTION - I was wondering, Mr. President, every time, I have the impression that you seize the opportunity to remind the Polish President of the Lisbon Treaty. Did you do so this time? Do you consider that the Treaty plays an important role in the European response to the crisis?

For the two Presidents, what is your reaction to the position of the two Polish and Lithuanian Presidents who oppose resuming negotiations with Russia regarding the new partnership?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, no, I did not speak again to the Polish President even though I will be in Poland on December 6. I attach great importance to the continuation of the Lisbon process. I do not believe that an institutional crisis would bring anything positive to Europe.

Regarding Russia, I remind you that these negotiations have never been suspended. Never. Because in Europe, words have meaning. If there had been a suspension, a unanimous decision from the European Council would have been needed to resume them. With President BARROSO, we simply postponed the date. I want to state this as simply as possible. We asked the Russians for four commitments.

First commitment: the ceasefire. Has it been made? Yes.

Second commitment: the withdrawal of Russian forces to the pre-crisis borders of August 8. Has this been respected? Yes. I am sorry, yes, Madam. I am following things quite closely.

Third commitment: the deployment of observers. Have the observers been deployed on the ground? Yes.

Fourth commitment: the opening of international negotiations on the future status of Abkhazia and South Ossetia, which are today Georgian territories. Are these discussions very difficult? They have started, with difficulty. Yes.

So, with that, should we also create a Europe-Russia crisis? That does not seem very reasonable to me. For the rest, I have had the opportunity to express my significant reservations about the recent statements of President Medvedev regarding the deployment of missiles. I add that to express reservations and to show disagreements, it is better to meet and talk. It is still better to be heard than to ignore each other and refuse to talk.

Mr. Barroso - I would like to say what I say to Poland and Lithuania. Moreover, this is the meaning of the communication that the Commission has approved. This week we were conducting a sort of audit of relations with Russia and we recommended to the Member States to continue negotiations because you know that we have received the mandate to negotiate this agreement with Russia. And what I say to my Polish and Lithuanian friends is the following: it is better for you to have a united position from Europe when it speaks with Russia, a position that may not be 100% what you would have liked, than to have 3 or 4 positions from Europe when talking with Russia. This is, in my opinion, the most important point for us to understand the relationship with Russia.

It is obvious, let us be clear and absolutely frank. Among us, there are different sensitivities in Europe regarding Russia. It would be strange if everyone, if 27 states, with very different histories, had exactly the same sensitivity. There are different sensitivities. But what is our interest? What is the interest of Poland, Lithuania, France, Portugal, Germany, or any country? It is the interest, after all, of being able to benefit from the contribution of the European Union which, by speaking with one voice with Russia, undoubtedly has much more influence to defend its interests, to promote its values, and also to discuss the most difficult issues. Including the issues where we do not agree with the Russians. There are quite a few issues where we have differences with our Russian partners.

So, here is the message I am sending to Poland and Lithuania. Perhaps it is not exactly 100% your position, but it is still better for you to be together with all the other Member States than to have an expression where some would make agreements with Russia, while others would not make agreements with Russia.

Because let us also be clear: if there is no negotiation of the European Union as a whole with Russia, can anyone think that there would be Member States that would not have to see these negotiations? Would that be in the interest of Poland or Lithuania? To have bilateral agreements with other states, without being able to have an overview of what is happening?

That is the message, and it is very important in terms of the European message. Sometimes it is better to have a solution that is not perfect than to have no solution at all.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you spoke of the shared concern regarding the economic situation. Did you mention the very pessimistic forecasts from the International Monetary Fund that were published yesterday? Were you not surprised by the difference between those forecasts and those made in various European countries, which are less pessimistic? Do you expect a dialogue or even a rather tough confrontation with the Americans at the Washington Summit? Will you propose a work schedule for the months to come?

THE PRESIDENT - Forecasts, I have not commented on them for a long time. What matters in forecasts is not the decimal, Jean-Marc Sylvestre, it is the direction in which they are going. All forecasts are more or less pointing towards an economic crisis. We must take that into account. Europe must be reactive. We do not have time to lose. After that, should we be more pessimistic, less pessimistic? What does that change? Everything leads to the analysis of an economic crisis. So we must react immediately. Quickly, and all Member States agree.

With the United States, there will be a dialogue, of course. Confrontation, why? There is a dialogue; we come with our convictions. I am not coming to participate in a summit of social niceties. We Europeans will not be satisfied with a few vague principles. We will propose a method, a second summit, 100 days to implement the principle decisions that will have been made. That seems to me to be a good agreement. One that does not confuse speed with haste.

Naturally, we cannot make decisions at the level of heads of state and government immediately. Especially on such technical matters. It seems to us that 100 days to hold a new summit and for that new summit to start with the analysis of the implementation of the decisions that were made at the first is a good method. We go there with a sense of compromise, with friendship, with this historical friendship between the United States and Europe, but we go there with our convictions. After all, it is not about designating scapegoats, but we know why we are here. If there are those who will quickly forget, we will not forget. The crisis is global, but we know very well where it started. It is not about designating a single culprit, and certainly there are responsibilities in many places. But, after all, it started over there.

So, the solution must be found with them. But we will not do and we will not accept: "move along, there is nothing to see." Once the crisis has passed a little, we act as if nothing has happened. I say this in the clearest way: we cannot accept that.

Nothing leads me to think, by the way, that this is the idea. But if ever this idea had crossed the mind of some advisor, it must be quickly retracted. Because, behind it, there is the fate of millions of people. When the crisis that we are still managing occurred, the heads of state and government, we took responsibility for the consequences. Those who have taken responsibility are entitled, at the table, to say: we ask to be listened to, heard, and quickly. Because the time when there was one currency, one direction, one line, and where we gave the impression of knowing everything, that time is over. It ended very precisely on September 18 when a responsibility was taken without asking for our opinion. From the bankruptcy of a major banking institution with all the chain consequences that followed. I say this without being the least bit suspect of anything other than being a sincere friend of the United States of America. Moreover, the American people, in their aspiration for change, I think they too received the message. And that, like the European peoples, they would not accept being told that nothing happened.

This is something that is very clear, and we are mandated for this message. So, after that, it can take different timelines, different methods, but the objective is indeed that. Ladies and gentlemen, I fear that we are tiring you, Mr. Barroso and I. We wish you a good evening.