Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, Mr. Dimitri Medvedev, President of the Russian Federation, and Mr. Jose Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission, on Euro-Russian relations, particularly regarding the Russo-Georgian conflict, security issues, and the future of the international financial system, in Nice on November 14, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

14 November 2008 · Joint press conference on Euro-Russian relations, EU-Russia summit · Nice, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed a joint EU-Russia summit press conference in Nice on November 14, 2008, alongside Medvedev and Barroso to discuss Georgia, security, and global finance.
Main themes
EU-Russia relations, Russo-Georgian conflict, pan-European security, missile deployment concerns, OSCE summit proposal, ceasefire and troop withdrawal, international financial system, European unity, diplomatic dialogue, observer deployment in Georgia
Duration
~47 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,620
93rd percentile
Sentences
332
96th percentile
Readability
56
78th percentile
Grade
9.4
15th percentile
Syntax
2.75
18th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

332 sentences in 59 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

President BARROSO and I were very pleased to welcome today, in Nice, the President of the Russian Federation, Dmitry MEDVEDEV, for this summit between the European Union and Russia, which was also attended by High Representative Javier SOLANA, Ms. Benita FERRERO-WALDNER, Minister Bernard KOUCHNER, Jean-Pierre JOUYET, Mr. Sergey LAVROV, and a significant Russian delegation. We had, with President MEDVEDEV and President BARROSO, an extremely useful discussion, very frank as usual, and I hope, positive.

Summits are opportunities to talk together, to discuss all topics in order to try to advance peace, security, and development. You know my conviction: Europe and Russia have a mutual interest in working together. It is in Russia's interest and it is in Europe's interest. There is the history of the world in which we find ourselves. At this moment in the history of the world, we really do not need conflict. We really do not need confrontation. We really do not need divisions. We really do not need war. We need gathering and unity. That is why, together with President BARROSO, we wanted this summit. We thank President MEDVEDEV for participating.

Does this mean that there are no disagreements? That is absurd. It would be absurd, if we realize, it is precisely to talk and, when we talk, it is not simply about topics of agreement, it is also about questions of disagreements to try to find the best ways to overcome these disagreements. I would like, moreover, to understand how to overcome disagreements if we do not talk. There are already enough sources of misunderstanding in the world not to add those that would consist of not talking, of not dialoguing.

I am happy about this new contact with President MEDVEDEV who is a man with whom one can talk. What did we talk about? First, of course, about the subject that has strained relations between Europe and Russia, which is the question of Georgia. I had the opportunity to say publicly that in my eyes, as in the eyes of President BARROSO, the Russian Federation has fulfilled a very large part of the commitments it had made. First, there was the ceasefire, August 12 in Moscow. Then there was the withdrawal, which has been largely carried out - I say largely - but it is honest to say that it has been carried out. This is what we negotiated with Javier SOLANA, President BARROSO, and Bernard KOUCHNER, I believe it was on September 12. There was the deployment of observers, which took place and it is, finally, painful certainly - but who could think it would not be painful? - the start of international discussions in Geneva. I had the opportunity to tell President MEDVEDEV that there needed to be progress regarding the withdrawal of Russian forces in two particular places in Ossetia. I am thinking of the Akhalgori valley in South Ossetia and the village of Perevi, outside South Ossetia. We therefore discussed this issue and President MEDVEDEV told me that he would do his utmost to find solutions and that we would try to move forward so that there would be no more irritants, the usual diplomatic formula, between the European Union and Russia. This is the first element.

The second element, we talked at length about all security issues, pan-European security, as they say, and Javier SOLANA and Ms. FERRERO-WALDNER and President BARROSO participated in this. There was President MEDVEDEV's speech in Berlin with a number of proposals. There were statements about the potential deployment of Russian missiles. I indicated to President MEDVEDEV how concerned we were about these statements and how there should be no deployment in any enclave until we had discussed the new geopolitical conditions of pan-European security. As President of the European Council, I propose that in mid-2009, we meet in a framework that could be the OSCE to lay the foundations of what future European security could be. We all have an interest in this security on the continent and a little beyond the continent because this would involve the Russians, the Americans, and the Europeans, within the framework of the OSCE in mid-2009. This will not be a conclusive summit but we could lay the foundations of what an agreement between us could be and, until then, let us not talk about the deployment of shields, missiles, which bring nothing to security, which complicate matters, which rather push them back.

I believe I can say that President MEDVEDEV - he will say what he thinks - welcomed this proposal favorably. It goes without saying that this is a proposal for which we will consult with our American allies. It so happens that there will be a NATO summit in April, that this NATO summit will be held in Kehl and Strasbourg, and that it will be a perfect opportunity to prepare what could be an OSCE summit on these issues, for example in June or July.

You see that in this summit we did not evade any problem. I would also like to say, under the supervision of Javier SOLANA, that Europe has been very pleased with the Russian initiatives for Nagorno-Karabakh, initiatives in favor of peace, and that I encouraged the Russian Federation since it concerns the Caucasus and since it concerns peace, to draw inspiration from this very positive action on Nagorno-Karabakh, to address the question of Abkhazia and Ossetia with the same openness and the same concern for peace.

We also talked about the Washington summit since we will leave after lunch. I believe I can say, there too, that the Russian technical, financial, and economic proposals were of high quality and that they are very close to European proposals. I do not say they are of quality because they are close to ours. They are of quality in their own right. And I am very pleased to see that there is a willingness from the Russian Federation that strong decisions come out of the Washington summit. I say it again: this must not be a summit for nothing. I say this without aggression towards anyone. We are in the same boat, it is globalization. The financial crisis is of great severity. The measures we have taken have stabilized things. We are not out of it yet. But we need to change things. We need to change them durably, structurally, strongly. Just because there is a lull does not mean we can consider that we can start again as before. Let things be very clear on this.

Finally, other files on the four areas between Russia and the European Union. But President BARROSO will speak for himself, who will hold a summit of the Commission and the Russian Federation in January because it is very important.

Finally, last point, I remain convinced that we have every interest in working, the Russian Federation and Europe, on a common economic space that would create interdependencies that would ensure that any form of confrontation would be definitively banned because it would undermine common interests.

I also wanted to tell you that, of course, we asked the Russian Federation to be very open in discussions with the Baltic countries and notably Lithuania, which will have to close its nuclear power plant for energy supply this winter. This request was also met with much openness by President MEDVEDEV.

I apologize for having perhaps been much too long. I have summarized things as I have seen them. President BARROSO and President MEDVEDEV will, of course, give their opinions.

Mr. DMITRY MEDEVEDEV - Ladies and Gentlemen. As a guest, I must naturally thank the French President for the warm welcome, for the wonderful organization of this meeting in such a beautiful place, and for the informal, friendly atmosphere of this meeting. Our negotiations have, as always, been open, direct. We have discussed all the issues that concern us and this is the guarantee that we can reach conclusions, solutions. On all the complicated questions, the French President has already spoken about the agenda, the issues we discussed, but I will allow myself to comment on a few questions. I start with the subject that concerns us all, which is the neutralization of the negative influence of the global economic crisis. Right after this press conference, practically right after - perhaps we will not be refused lunch! - but we will leave afterwards for America and we will discuss this subject which is not easy. And here, our positions, with my colleague Nicolas, with other colleagues, are practically common positions. We must provide an adequate, comprehensive response, not just statements, not just photographs but an action program. We must insist on a serious agenda, on serious solutions because generally, the positions of all states are the same. The positions of France, the European Union, and the Russian Federation are very close regarding the global crisis. That is why the reform of the international financial system is a question that has been discussed in detail and we have talked about what needs to be done after Washington. Naturally, we cannot immediately sign new agreements: which institution needs to be reformed? What remains, etc. We are not going to create a new Bretton Woods in Washington but we must take an important step in this direction. That is why I absolutely support the idea of planning another summit after Washington, in the near future. Regarding these questions, we will be ready to communicate with Europe. I had preliminary consultations, I spoke on the phone with Nicolas, with other European colleagues and our positions are very close and sometimes they converge. We have the common agenda that is traditional for this summit: issues of economic contacts, cultural exchanges, etc. Yesterday, I met with businessmen. We have done well over the last few years. Trade between the European Union and the Federation is increasing, these are huge sums. The share of trade of our country with the European Union is over 50%, these are hundreds of billions of euros. We must take this into account when we talk about our cooperation. And the four common spaces remain the same: freedom, justice, security, culture, research, education, etc. Naturally, we do not progress in the same way in all these areas but we have opportunities to thaw cooperation in several sectors. This is important for the Russian Federation and for the European Union. There are unresolved problems that my colleague, Mr. SARKOZY, spoke about. We discussed these problems, we are trying to find solutions.

One of the subjects, which was not a dominant subject, but one of the subjects was the consequences of the aggression of Georgia in South Ossetia. I would like to thank once again our European colleagues and personally the French President for their participation in the resolution, in the search for solutions, in a very difficult period. And this coordination that was developed at that time demonstrated that there is no alternative to direct, open negotiations. It does not exist. The negotiations of this period have demonstrated that the security mechanisms in Europe are not perfect. That is why we have returned to this idea of a comprehensive treaty. I see that this idea is starting to please a growing number of elected officials in the European Union. Regarding the participation of all parties in this pan-European security space, this would be the working principle for the future, the rules for the future. We talked about the OSCE summit. I formulated this idea some time ago and I would like to thank the French President for supporting this idea. We said that we could do it not only towards the end of 2009 but in mid-2009. NATO and the European Union, the CIS and other organizations need to be able to meet and discuss all these questions. In this context, I absolutely agree that before signing a special comprehensive agreement on security, we must all refrain from unilateral measures that would influence this security. Russia has never made unilateral decisions. All the decisions we have prepared, including the decisions I spoke about recently, are a reaction to the measures of some European states that, without consulting anyone, agreed to deploy means in their territory. But if you are ready to cooperate, then it must be done. And the European Union can play a very constructive coordinating role. We discussed other questions on the traditional agenda. They are not too numerous regarding the three common spaces and I believe that we could continue this discussion in Moscow very soon and our colleague BARROSO could talk about it.

MR. JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - You know very well that the Commission has supported, in fact it has proposed the continuation of negotiations between the European Union and Russia. We believe that these relations should be strengthened within the framework of the notion of positive interdependence. That is why I am particularly pleased with the results of this very important summit. President SARKOZY and President MEDVEDEV have already highlighted the main issues. Allow me to simply emphasize one or two, particularly in the economic field, as I have reviewed the evolution of our economic relations, which is truly impressive. We support Russia's entry into the World Trade Organization. We welcome President MEDVEDEV's remarks regarding the evolution of the Russian economy, specifically his intention to join the World Trade Organization. We also believe it is very important to deepen our dialogue on energy. We recently approved an energy security strategy and we want to cooperate with Russia in this area, and specifically, I believe this summit has allowed us to clarify some important principles in this matter.

The fundamental political question for the future between Russia and the European Union is as follows: this future must be built through the economy, not through missiles. This future must be built through exchanges and dialogue, not displays of force. Through partnership and multilateralism, not unilateralism. Through engagement and leadership on global issues, particularly the financial crisis, and here we also spoke about this financial crisis and we commend Russia and President MEDVEDEV for their commitment to seeking global solutions for global issues. We also want to work with Russia on issues such as combating climate change. This is a question so closely associated with our energy dossier.

I have mentioned a few concrete issues on the economic front. For example, I welcomed the Russian decision to postpone the increase in export duties on certain forest products. This is very important for some of our member states. I believe we should find a definitive solution. We also discussed the need to ensure energy transport between Russia and the European Union. President SARKOZY said it: we addressed the specific problem of Lithuania, while noting that there has been progress in terms of European access to the Russian energy network. We believe that a stronger, more consolidated framework needs to be established, also in the energy field.

What I can tell you is that there are very, very extensive economic, trade, and investment relations between Russia and the European Union, and it is precisely for this reason that I announced that we would be able to respond positively to the invitation extended to me by Russian Prime Minister Mr. PUTIN to restore executive-to-executive contacts, that is, between the government of the Russian Federation and the European Commission. We are ready at the beginning of next year to go to Moscow, and I also thank President MEDVEDEV for his invitation for me to meet the President of the Russian Federation on that occasion.

There is immense work to be done, sometimes on quite concrete technical issues that are difficult, but I see, I say this very sincerely, I see that there is, on both sides, a willingness to find solutions to create and strengthen this notion of positive interdependence between Russia and the European Union.

THE PRESIDENT - Ladies and gentlemen, as Dmitri MEDVEDEV reminded us, we must leave for Washington quite soon, and I understand that the Russian President is keen on his lunch, so I propose four questions, perhaps two from the European press and two from the Russian press.

QUESTION - Russian television NTV. The question to the three presidents is this: it is the first summit after the events in the North Caucasus, and Mr. MEDVEDEV spoke about the role of France and the European Union in resolving this conflict, and in Russia, you said, Mr. SARKOZY, Mr. President, you do not see Europe, and the European Commission, it seems, would be ready to deepen relations with Russia. Did you concretely discuss a new agreement between Russia and the European Union? Is there a green light, and when can we expect its signature?

MR. JOSE MANUEL BARROSO - We have just decided to continue the negotiations. I cannot commit at this stage to a date and a signature. It is an agreement of strategic importance. We consider it strategic for the European Union, and I believe Russia thinks the same for Russia. It is extremely complex due to the scope of the areas we will be addressing. The Commission now has a mandate to negotiate on behalf of the entire European Union for this agreement, and we will put forth our best effort. I am convinced that if there is goodwill from both parties, we can make significant progress in this partnership agreement between Russia and the European Union.

MR. DMITRI MEDVEDEV - I could just add a few words because indeed we have seen a pause in the work on this document. We were not in favor of this pause. That is why we were able to get through it. I am convinced that we will soon begin negotiations on this document. We believe it should be well filled out, and on the other hand, it should be very strict in its structure, which will provide frameworks for work for the coming years. When will we finish this work? I do not know, but I hope in the not-too-distant future. In any case, we have a document on the basis of which we are working. We will move towards the new document as quickly as possible, and we are ready to work on this document.

THE PRESIDENT - There has never been a suspension; there has been a postponement. Why was there a postponement? Because there was a strong disagreement. We do not agree with the unilateral recognition of the independence of Abkhazia and South Ossetia; that is one point. From that moment on, how do we overcome this disagreement? For some, it is necessary to stop talking. For us, it is necessary to dialogue, and through dialogue, we obtained the ceasefire, the withdrawal. There are still demands that I have presented on behalf of Europe. I do not see how we can present these demands if we do not meet to discuss. But there has never been a suspension, because if there had been a suspension, it would have had to be taken unanimously to resume. That is why, together with José-Manuel BARROSO, we proposed the postponement. That is exactly what we did. I apologize if this may seem a bit Jesuitical, a bit legalistic, but it has a meaning. Because I have always thought that it was necessary to maintain the thread of dialogue and that dialogue was not a sign of weakness. It is the convinced people who engage in dialogue and have the courage to do so, and how can one stop a war if one does not engage in dialogue? And that is why we conducted this operation. The disagreement remains. The Russians have recognized the independence of South Ossetia and Abkhazia. We do not recognize it because we are committed to the territorial integrity of Georgia, and we are discussing how we must overcome this; that is it. All those who told me: "You should not have come, you should not have discussed, that is not how problems are resolved." In any case, Russia and the European Union - I remind you - are geographically neighbors, and countries that change addresses are quite rare.

MR. DMITRI MEDVEDEV - Indeed. It may seem paradoxical.

QUESTION - This is a community question developed by several. It is a sort of kolkhoz that we have created to pose a single question.

THE PRESIDENT - Kolkhoz. It is a European Union of journalists.

INTERVENOR - Exactly.

QUESTION - So, the suspension of negotiations - this question is addressed to you, Mr. President - the suspension of negotiations on the partnership agreement was the only weapon that the European Union had against Russia to obtain a return to normalcy in the Caucasus. By resuming negotiations, are we not definitively burying, in Nice, the principle of the territorial integrity of Georgia?

Question to Mr. MEDVEDEV: Are you ready, one day, to recognize the territorial integrity of Georgia, or is this a question that does not arise?

THE PRESIDENT - Allow me to say that, regarding the role of the European Union in the matter of the war between the Russian Federation and Georgia, fortunately, we did not content ourselves with suspending or postponing; we were there right away. Because if there was indeed one party that was a factor for peace, I thank Dmitri MEDVEDEV for saying it, it is the European Union. At least that is a point of agreement on both the Georgian and Russian sides. As President of the Council, I have never brandished the military threat, unlike others. I am not sure that the military threat would have advanced matters. I have always said that we needed to engage in dialogue and that Europe had, at the heart of its convictions, peace. Europe has tried to be a factor for peace between Georgia and the Russian Federation. I apologize, it is Europe that achieved this; it is a great novelty, and it was not so simple.

It is not because we are naive that we do this; on the contrary, it is because we were very determined, first point. Second point. Allow me to tell you that the problem of South Ossetia, the problem of Abkhazia did not start on August 8, 2008. I would like to remind you, since there are United Nations deliberations on Ossetia and Abkhazia. There were even Russian soldiers under a United Nations mandate in Ossetia before the events began. I would like to remind you of this. Thirdly, I have never been ambiguous, nor has Mr. BARROSO on this matter. Mr. MEDVEDEV, Mr. LAVROV can testify to this. I have always defended the idea of the territorial integrity of Georgia and the non-recognition of Ossetia and Abkhazia. Fourthly, I have said that the Russian Federation has fulfilled most of its commitments. I said this, Mr. QUATREMER, for a simple reason: if you want to be a factor for peace, you must be a good faith and honest interlocutor, honest between both parties, to gain the trust of both parties. It is the truth to say this, including regarding Russian participation in the Geneva discussions. If the problem did not arise, why would the Russians participate, as Mr. MEDVEDEV committed to do on September 12? This was indeed a famous discussion. This does not bury anything at all. There is a disagreement; this disagreement is there, and we must find ways to resolve it. But I think that when there is a disagreement, it is better to talk about it and discuss it. I met with the Georgian President. I explained to him what the strategy of Europe was. It seems to me that he understands as well. Because between the strategy of some of Georgia's friends and the European Union, I think that the strategy of the European Union, you see, was more effective and has brought more. You who follow things closely know this perfectly well. The agitations in a nearby sea with military ships, I do not see what that has brought.

We can continue to threaten each other between Europe and Russia with shields, naval missiles, etc. This will bring nothing to Russia, nothing to Georgia, and nothing to Europe. That is not our conception of things. I am fully prepared to be held accountable for this. It seems to me that I am supported by the vast majority of European states. If Europe had not been present at the moment hostilities broke out... I also remind you that in the European decision, we spoke of Russia's disproportionate reaction. But words have meaning; I explained this to Mr. MEDVEDEV. Reaction. This meant that there was a prior action, the word reaction. This word reaction was adopted unanimously by the 27, Mr. QUATREMER. Disproportionate is always what I have thought. I said this to the President of the Russian Federation. I believe that Mr. BARROSO and I have been perfectly honest in this matter. I have not changed my conviction. We have tried to achieve results. But if you lose the trust of one of the protagonists, how can you be a factor for peace?

I maintain that this summit was necessary. I do not regret it at all. I maintain that the Russian Federation has fulfilled most of its commitments. This allows me to tell you that there are still commitments to be fulfilled and that we must make progress.

This is how peace is made. I think that bluster and threats bring nothing to anyone, especially in this part of the world. I was very pleased that you asked me this collective question.

MR. DMITRI MEDVEDEV - I will also respond. I will say only three things. Russia absolutely recognizes the territorial integrity of Georgia, taking into account the recognition of South Ossetia and Abkhazia as subjects of international law.

On the other hand, I believe that the MEDVEDEV-SARKOZY plan has been fully implemented. I would like to thank my European colleagues for this.

Thirdly: we are ready to continue in a constructive spirit the discussion of all issues concerning the Caucasus. We will do so. We are ready to discuss this directly during all our meetings, eye to eye, despite the fact that sometimes details emerge afterwards that did not occur. But Russia will continue to work with its partners. Thank you.

QUESTION - There was a briefing from your aides, and it was said that everything would depend on the negotiations in Geneva, on the meeting of the delegations regarding Abkhazia and South Ossetia. But how do you assess the events of August? There was a version that Russian troops wanted to enter Tbilisi, and there are OSCE observers who said, who warned of Georgian aggression, but no one listened to them, and currently the Western press says that in closed briefings, it is said that it was Georgia that struck the first blow. This is a question for both presidents.

Mr. DMITRI MEDVEDEV - Regarding the coordinate system, it is very easy to answer. We are still in the same coordinate system. We are conveying the same ideas that we had before and after August. We have always wanted the problem of the Caucasus, concerning the relations between Georgia and South Ossetia and Abkhazia, to be resolved peacefully. Unfortunately, on August 8, this coordinate system was unilaterally overturned by the Tbilisi regime. There was a reaction from Russia. We were compelled to defend the lives of people, and it was simply necessary to defend the right to existence of ethnic groups and to prevent a humanitarian catastrophe.

Our intervention was compact and necessary. We reacted based on international law standards, including the UN Charter and the right to self-defense. After these events, we were forced to recognize new subjects of international law, and we still hold this position. I can repeat it once again, and this decision is final. It is not an opportunity for games, and we will build a relationship with these new subjects of international law.

Regarding our relations with the European Union and my personal relations with the French President, I believe that the European Union played a constructive role at the necessary moment. It intervened during this conflict, it had peacekeeping functions, and it helped restore the rule of law.

But even our first meeting with my colleague Nicolas SARKOZY took place after I made the decision to stop our intervention. You know the results and the settlement that exists.

I would like to repeat once again in this room that we are pleased with these negotiations, and I believe that all points of the MEDVEDEV-SARKOZY plan have been implemented, accomplished, thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - The course of this war, even though I saw in the American press, on the front page of a major newspaper, the result of an independent investigation, unambiguously analyzing the causes of the conflict, it is not for me, I am not a historian, it is not for me to redo it. What matters now is that we find a solution or solutions.

First, there are points on which Europe is very keen to obtain satisfaction. I said it: the Akhalgori Valley, Perevi, the observer mission. We still have work to do.

And then, afterwards, international discussions must continue in the most peaceful manner possible. We do not resolve things in the Caucasus, nor in any region, by force. We resolve them through politics, through dialogue, through diplomacy.

That is our position. I add that those who tell me that we should not meet are probably the same ones who did not want us to go there. When Bernard KOUCHNER, whom I thank, was the first to leave, and I decided to go to Moscow, the first time I was with Bernard, and we decided with Mr. BARROSO, I remember very well the call from a number of prestigious heads of state who told me that we should not go there. And they even told me that we should not hold the summit. We should not go there, we should not negotiate, we should not dialogue, we should not hold the summit.

I remind you that Russian troops were then 40 kilometers from Tbilisi. And the analysis of everyone was that they were heading towards Tbilisi. Was it better to dialogue or to do nothing? These are the same people who tell me that we should not hold the summit.

Allow me to say that I do not regret holding the summit. We discuss, that’s it. And when we have problems, we discuss them. We exchange. People who discuss, once again, are not weak people. They are, on the contrary, strong people. We see what it leads to in the world not to discuss, not to think, not to talk to each other. We find ourselves in inextricable situations.

Of course, the situation is difficult in the Caucasus, but it has not been difficult since August 8, allow me to tell you. It has been difficult for a bit longer.

The question is: does Europe want to play a role or does it not want to play a role? If it wants to play a role, it must engage in dialogue. It must take initiatives, it must assert convictions. And that is what it has done. If it does not want to play a role, then it is better to let people talk over an ocean, to not understand each other.

Europe exists politically, Europe is present, Europe plays its role, it was its duty. For that, it is necessary to take risks. In this case, I believe that what we did with President BARROSO was necessary. I do not regret it at all, even if I see the extent of what remains to be done as work. I say this without concession, without weakness, without feeling that I am losing my convictions. I think that President MEDVEDEV is exactly in the same state of mind.

One last question?

QUESTION - A question for the President of the European Council: you announced to us yesterday that you would meet the Dalai Lama on December 6 in Poland. The Chinese immediately reacted by saying that this constituted a problem for Franco-Chinese relations. Do you also consider this a problem, and will you discuss it with President HU Jintao in Washington this weekend?

THE PRESIDENT - If it is a problem, it would be an opportunity for more dialogue. The same jurisprudence. You know, sir, I try to do what I say. Because I believe in what I do. I have done enough for the understanding of one another. I was delighted to be in Beijing the other day with President BARROSO. I think that the Chinese decision to relaunch, as they have decided, is an extremely important decision. I think we need China to resolve the affairs of the world. I am delighted to go to Poland, and you will see, there will be other appointments than this one, other decisions that I will announce in Poland since we have made good progress on a subject that is extremely difficult, which is the energy-climate package, with the Polish Prime Minister. Sorry, it is also a subject that requires me to travel. It is an extremely important subject. We discussed in detail with the Polish Prime Minister, and I will also meet in Poland with other European heads of government to talk about these issues. I will have a busy agenda. Moreover, it is December 6, my name day. I hope you will not forget.

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you.

I would also like to thank Christian ESTROSI, the Mayor of Nice, for his welcome, and to tell him how happy we are to be in his city.