Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. Lech Kaczynski, President of the Republic of Poland, notably on Franco-Polish relations, the French budget deficit, and the increase in oil prices, in Warsaw on May 28, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

28 May 2008 · Joint press conference with the President of Poland · Warsaw, Poland

Context
Sarkozy addressed a joint press conference with Polish President Kaczyński in Warsaw on May 28, 2008, ahead of the French EU Presidency.
Main themes
Franco-Polish relations, French EU Presidency, Lisbon Treaty, Franco-Polish strategic partnership, EU budget deficit, oil prices and VAT proposal, Poland's role in Europe, Ukraine-EU relations, Common Agricultural Policy, European integration, Brussels Commission relations
Duration
~13 min
44th percentile
Words
1,514
44th percentile
Sentences
83
54th percentile
Readability
60
88th percentile
Grade
9.3
14th percentile
Syntax
2.80
22nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
30th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

83 sentences in 17 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - I would like to thank President KACZYNSKI for his welcome, if I may also thank him for his friendship and for his support in view of the upcoming French Presidency. I wanted to come to Warsaw before the French Presidency because I have always believed that Poland is a great country in Europe. Poland is one of the six great countries of Europe, and it has always been a constant for me to want to associate Poland with the heart of European affairs. When I was Minister of the Interior, I proposed transforming the G5 into a G6, which was done, to welcome the Polish Minister of the Interior.

The same goes for the French Presidency; we will do everything to involve Poland in the proper functioning of Europe. And I know that Poland's support will be decisive for the success of the French Presidency.

I would also like to add that this is an opportunity for me to sign the Franco-Polish strategic partnership, as our common interests are numerous. I think of the Common Agricultural Policy, I think of Poland's economic success. Today's Poland is a modern economy, and France has strong economic interests there. Poland is experiencing a growth rate of 6.5%. With 38 million inhabitants, it is a major factor in the success of the integration of the eight new Eastern countries, even though Poland's influence extends beyond Eastern and Central Europe.

With President KACZYNSKI, we have taken stock of all international issues, particularly those that concern us. Regarding Ukraine's association with Europe, I will have the opportunity, as President of the Union, to organize the Ukraine-European Union summit next September and to propose an ambitious partnership to our Ukrainian friends.

Finally, I would like to thank President KACZYNSKI for the personal role he played in the compromise we reached during the adoption of the Lisbon Treaty. Things were not easy, but we found a compromise, and I am grateful to our Polish friends for ratifying this Treaty. Thanks to them, Europe has emerged - let us await the Irish result - from institutional stagnation. You can see that I am visiting a friend and that Poland is a great country that we will need in the context of the French Presidency.

PRESIDENT KACZYNSKI - Thank you very much for these thanks. Regarding the Brussels compromise, it was indeed only finalized in Lisbon, but I must say that the signing of the Lisbon Treaty would not have taken place if there had not been discussions in Brussels where President SARKOZY played a key role. Thank you once again.

QUESTION - Mr. SARKOZY, you will take over the Presidency of the European Union in a month, the Brussels Commission must or has already issued a reprimand or warning to France regarding the deficit overshoot, and you proposed yesterday an initiative on VAT on petroleum products that was received rather coolly in Brussels. Do you consider that, at least on certain issues, Brussels can be a brake on action or progress?

THE PRESIDENT - France's position regarding Brussels is to work hand in hand with President BARROSO, whom I spoke with on the phone just yesterday. We do not have the same understanding of reprimands since the translation is advice; "advice" is advice, it is not a reprimand.

Secondly, the Commission has very often encouraged and congratulated France for the reforms that are being carried out, and they are being carried out. We have a difference of interpretation regarding the Commission's figures related to Mr. ALMUNIA's statements. You know very well that the Commission's figures have been scrupulously contradicted by the figures just published by INSEE, which is an independent body. The Commission's assumptions are based on figures that are not verified and have even been contradicted. The Commission was counting on a growth rate, if I remember correctly, of 1.8% in 2007. As you know, it is 2.2%. Regarding a marked slowdown in 2008, the growth figures are 0.64% in the first quarter of 2008. Nevertheless, France has efforts to make to reduce deficits, deficits that are difficult to pin on me since I have been President of the Republic for 13 months and France has been voting on deficit budgets for 35 years. We should be able to make a proportional calculation. We will continue these efforts, notably by not replacing one civil servant out of two.

Regarding the proposal I made, I have experience in European affairs, and you will have noted that as soon as someone proposes an idea in Europe, skepticism prevails first. I remember very well when I proposed the simplified Treaty. Ultimately, it was adopted. When I proposed the Council of Sages, it was ultimately adopted.

So the question is very simple: France is not the only country facing rising oil prices. There is a double taxation, the TIPP which is a tax on volumes, we will not touch that, and VAT which is a tax on prices, proportional to prices. It is not an absurd idea to say that the price of oil continues to rise. It is currently at 130 dollars. It was, when I was Minister of Finance, in 2004, at 42. All specialists say that this will continue. Should we apply the same proportional taxation to prices with a barrel that has doubled in one year and tripled in three? It is still a question that is not absurd to ask. I would add that, in doing so, I am not proposing a new VAT rate but simply the non-application from a certain level. I would also add that this does not worsen the deficit since it concerns opportunity revenues, as they are due to the increase in the barrel price.

Finally, this would allow us to say to all European citizens: certainly, oil continues to rise for reasons mainly related to the imbalance between supply and demand and also to speculation to a lesser extent, but not because of taxation. Raising this question is a normal question. I would add that this is a proposal, and I expect it to be studied before being rejected.

That is what I said. I stand by it. But you know, I said the same thing about corporate tax and VAT. That a number of countries bring their corporate tax to 0%, I have nothing to say. But I do not see why what can be done on one tax would be heretical on the other. When I proposed to consider a differentiated VAT, I initially provoked the greatest skepticism. Today, it is the Commission that is working on a new rate between 8 and 10%. It should not have been so stupid to propose a reflection. Since they are working on it, I want to tell them one more little effort, and we might just get there.

QUESTION - We have heard that France is preparing to open the labor market to Poles. When will France be ready to do so? Why have you delayed so long? And a question for President KACZYNSKI: how does he view this decision to open up?

THE PRESIDENT - I will speak about this in the Polish Parliament in a few hours. France has decided to lift all barriers starting July 1 because France believes in the freedom of movement of people and goods within Europe. I have therefore indicated this to the President, and I will confirm it to the Prime Minister. Why was this not done? Well, it is better for you to listen to those who, at the time, made those decisions. There were certainly transitions to be made. Today, I believe that Poland is a great country in Europe, that it is a member of Europe, that Europe is based on the freedom of movement of people and goods, and that there is no reason to have restrictions with Poland, especially since Poland is our strategic partner. Therefore, I announce and confirm to you that all barriers will be lifted starting July 1 of this year. That is, one year ahead of what was initially planned. I cannot be committed to Europe and not make decisions that are consistent with this political commitment. I believe in Europe, and I am trying to demonstrate it today in Warsaw.

PRESIDENT KACZYNSKI - This is indeed an important decision from the Polish perspective for two reasons. First, we want to be a full partner of the countries of the European Union. From the standpoint of this equality, the French decision is extremely important. What is very important is that this concerns all professions. We have a significant group of highly qualified workers, particularly in the field of software, as well as in other areas such as computing and high technology. We have very qualified people, and this offers them the opportunity to deepen these qualifications.

As for those who go abroad, my opinion is that they should go and then, after a certain time, return but leaving behind a good impression and not the opposite. Thank you, and this is where we will conclude.