Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. Luiz Inacio Lula Da Silva, President of the Federative Republic of Brazil, on Franco-Brazilian relations, in Saint-Georges de l'Oyapock on February 12, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

12 February 2008 · Joint press conference of Nicolas Sarkozy and Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva on Franco-Brazilian relations · Saint-Georges de l'Oyapock, France

Context
Sarkozy and Lula held a joint press conference in Saint-Georges de l'Oyapock on February 12, 2008, to announce Franco-Brazilian strategic cooperation and the Oyapock bridge construction.
Main themes
Franco-Brazilian strategic partnership, Oyapock bridge construction, Amazon biodiversity and environmental preservation, G8 expansion to G13, Brazil's UN Security Council membership, bilateral cooperation in defense and diplomacy, development and environmental balance in the Amazon, Ingrid Betancourt release, French Guiana border relations, biodiversity research collaboration
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,107
77th percentile
Sentences
182
87th percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
9.4
15th percentile
Syntax
2.68
12th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

182 sentences in 37 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

Dear President Lula,

I would like to express how happy France is to welcome, as a neighbor, the President of Brazil. We have made a number of important decisions with President LULA.

The first is this famous bridge that has been talked about for eight years without seeing its realization. Construction will begin this year for an inauguration in 2010. The Treaty has been ratified, and the declaration of public utility has been launched to realize the five kilometers of road that we need on the French side. It is in the same spirit that President LULA and I wish to develop the strategic partnership between Brazil and France. We want to put concrete actions into this strategic partnership: in military terms, in political terms, in diplomatic terms, in education, and in environmental matters. A high-level delegation will travel to Brazil to discuss the content of the plan, and I will go to Brazil at the end of 2008 to sign this strategic partnership.

Finally, I want to say that the world needs Brazil to take its rightful place in international institutions. I want to reiterate with the utmost strength that the G8 must transform into a G13, and that at a minimum, we need, at the next summit in Tokyo, an important moment of discussions that is not in the G8 format but in the G13 format.

And I want to reiterate that France wishes for Brazil to be a member of the Security Council, a permanent member of the Security Council. On all international issues as well as bilateral issues, Brazil and France are in agreement.

I would also like to thank President LULA for his contribution to the efforts for the release of Ingrid BETANCOURT.

PRESIDENT LULA - First, I would like to greet President SARKOZY and acknowledge the entire French delegation accompanying him.

It would be important for us to mark this history that the governor of Amapá is by my side and that the governor of French Guiana is next to President SARKOZY. This photo has a reason to exist, of course. The two governors have listened carefully to what President SARKOZY has said. Our Ministers of Transport are here. We do not wish for the bridge to begin construction in 2009. We want the bridge to begin construction in 2008. Ultimately, the cost of this bridge, 38 million euros, when we combine the GDP of France and Brazil, represents very little considering how long we have taken to build it.

This photo is also for these two governors to demand it from both presidents, because other photos have already been taken here, because speeches have already been made here, and the bridge still does not exist. President SARKOZY will return to inaugurate this bridge at the end of my term, in 2010.

The second point that I find really important is President SARKOZY's first visit to his longest border outside of Europe. This border is larger than the largest border he has in Europe. The privilege of France is to have a border with a region that is today viewed by everyone as one of the pillars for saving the planet, the Amazon. This gives France, I would say, a certain status: to be the only European country that can speak about the Amazon because it belongs to the Amazon. This is no small matter; it is a lot.

For this, we have discussed. We will create a high-level bilateral commission with a date to start this work and a date to finish this work so that we can, during President SARKOZY's visit in December 2008, as President of the European Union, sign not an abstract strategic agreement but a strategic agreement with strategic content that we commit to realize.

One thing that delights me, and that also delights President SARKOZY on the French side, is the idea of starting to discuss together the issue of biodiversity, and there we could involve all the countries that have borders belonging to the Amazon region. So that we can involve the scientific community, so that it can research in a much bolder, much stronger way, everything that the Amazon can offer with its resources to help humanity. We are not among those who defend the Amazon as a sanctuary for humanity. On the Brazilian side, there are almost 25 million inhabitants who wish to work, who wish to eat, who wish to have a car, who wish to have access to the material goods that humanity produces.

The challenge before us is how to account for a development policy for the entire Amazon while taking into account environmental preservation. How to leverage, for the good of humanity, the extraordinary biodiversity of the Amazon, which is very little known to mankind. Furthermore, I also think it is important that President SARKOZY has accepted an invitation that I extended to him to participate, alongside me, next year, on September 7, 2009, in the parade during the anniversary of Brazil's independence.

I told President SARKOZY that we have only one unique fundamental divergence with France that is not easy to resolve: it is France's supremacy in football during the World Cup in 1998 and 2006. We will try to revise this situation!

Regarding Ingrid BETANCOURT, I told President SARKOZY that Brazil is willing to participate in any effort so that, in a humanitarian act, we can free all hostages. Of course, we must take into account the political sensitivity of the people. Everything that is within our reach must be done with the agreement of the Colombian government; otherwise, everything becomes more difficult.

President SARKOZY, welcome to your first trip to French Guiana, 1,000 meters from Brazilian Amazon. You have not yet been bitten by any mosquito, and you certainly will not be. This is proof that it is not as inhospitable as they say!

QUESTION - Mr. President, a question about the bridge that will connect Brazil to French Guiana. Brazilian products coming from Brazil and arriving in French Guiana will need to be placed in containers, receiving a stamp from the European Union in order to reach the other side. Brazilians who want to arrive in French Guiana must pay more than 200 reals to obtain a visa. There is no reciprocity: the French can enter simply with their passports without having to pay anything. Will this bridge change the reality of the situation in the region? Will the more than 50,000 Brazilians who live here illegally in French Guiana and work every day receive different treatment once Brazil is brought closer to French Guiana through the European common market and the bridge?

THE PRESIDENT - Let things be clear, I told our friends from French Guiana that they should look towards Brazil and not just towards the metropolis, that the economic development of French Guiana depends on collaboration and openness with Brazil. First remark.

Second remark. With President LULA, and each has their own problems, we need to lay out a number of issues that require, for their solution, collaboration between Brazil and France. I think of the fishing issue, I think of the gold mining issue, I think of the immigration issue. Let things be clear for us: we will be totally firm against trafficking and traffickers. France's policy is openness to Brazil, openness to Brazilians, and friendship with Brazil.

Moreover, I do not believe in the sustainability of a system that consists of charging for entry, because with such a system, we complicate the lives of those who want to do business or see their families, and we are totally ineffective in the fight against illegal immigration. So, from the bridge, we will strengthen our collaboration to work hand in hand, Brazilians and French, against all traffickers. There too, we are ready to lay out all our rules because we need each other.

PRESIDENT LULA - We have an agreement from 1976. That's right. It has been twelve years. As the two cities grow, so do the problems. According to some estimates, we have 20,000 Brazilians here in French Guiana. But there are about 20,000 to 30,000 Brazilians who enter and exit illegally. Of course, we want to work so that all Brazilians who enter another country do so legally, and reciprocally, all those who return to Brazil do so legally. If there has been an agreement, over time, this agreement has produced a failure in our relations; it is only fair that after this meeting, the foreign ministers of Brazil and France begin to propose a revision of this agreement. Once we are closer, we will transit much more between our two countries. When the construction of this bridge begins in 2008, the wisdom of Brazilian and French diplomacy, I imagine, will have already allowed for the construction of a draft agreement that can avoid any kind of problems for the traffic of French from Guiana to Brazil and Brazilians to French Guiana.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you just spoke of openness, but will it be beneficial for both parties? The Brazilian economy is booming, a commercial boom that the department does not have; is Guiana at risk of being overwhelmed by this Brazilian giant? My second question is about security. Will collaboration be effective in combating both illegal immigration and crime?

PRESIDENT LULA - France advocates free trade. Brazil advocates free trade. If Brazil succeeds in producing quality products at a lower cost than products in France, in Europe, it is only fair that the French in Guiana buy cheaper and quality Brazilian products. Ultimately, free trade allows for the possibility of choosing the best product of the best quality at the lowest price. And, of course, we know France's technological potential. France has investments in Brazil amounting to 14 billion dollars, while the trade balance between Brazil and France currently represents 7 billion dollars per year. This means that we should have no fear, no concern regarding the growth of trade between French Guiana and Brazil. Because thanks to French Guiana, France can have more ease in selling good cheeses, good wines to Brazilians who love wine, cheese, and other French products. We do not run that risk.

Of course, not only in French Guiana and Brazil but everywhere in the world, we must be concerned about crime, drug trafficking, and arms trafficking. The more we are together, the more our police will work together, and the more the services of both countries exchange information, the better we will be able to combat drug trafficking, smuggling, and organized crime.

THE PRESIDENT - You have the strategic data in mind: French Guiana is the territory of Portugal with 210,000 inhabitants. It is not a sufficient market for endogenous economic development. Brazil is a country whose area is 40% larger than the entirety of Europe with 27 countries. Its needs are immense, and its growth is 7%. When you have 700 kilometers of border with such a giant, it is an opportunity, not a risk. I do not intend to put French Guiana under a bell jar.

Do you think that in Southeast Asia, China, which is a giant of one billion three hundred million inhabitants, is an economic problem for its neighbors? Do you think that India, which has a billion inhabitants, is an economic problem for its neighbors? That is false. It is an opportunity because an economic giant attracts all other countries. It is a chance for Guiana.

How do you expect us to effectively fight against traffickers and trafficking if we do not work hand in hand with Brazilians? This is the first time that two presidents are strongly committed to the fight against trafficking and traffickers. This is good news. It is the opening of Guiana. It is in the interest of France and Brazil, and what we are going to sign is historic. It is the only solution for strong development in Guiana.

QUESTION - Have there been any advances in discussions in the field of defense? Beyond the sale of fighter jets and submarines to Brazil, is France ready to transfer technology to Brazil so that Brazil can develop its equipment?

THE PRESIDENT - Yes. I told the Brazilian President that, on the issue of submarines, we were ready for a Scorpène submarine to be manufactured in Brazil. On the issue of combat aircraft, such as helicopters, we are ready to organize technology transfers so that helicopters and combat aircraft — I am thinking particularly of the Rafale — can be manufactured in Brazil. But I told him that we wanted this global partnership to be framed in a way that is not exclusively aimed at the delivery of military equipment. Our ambition is greater. We want to act together, think together, build together, intervene together. And, to be absolutely clear, there are no taboos. Brazil is a great democratic power that is reflecting on the conditions of its security; that is its absolute right. Brazil is a friend of France. We are therefore fully willing to work with Brazil in complete transparency with our allies and friends. There is no difficulty, no secret. You are witnessing the willingness of two great countries to work and think together. In service of what? In service of peace in the world. That is exactly what we discussed.

PRESIDENT LULA - I think it is important to have a broader understanding of this new phase that France and Brazil wish to build. Since my transformation into a political activist, I have begun to discover how many people in Brazil love France. It was great Brazilian intellectuals who embraced France; it was leftist political activists who went to France as exiles. I have also heard that the French love Brazil, and I had proof of this during the Year of Brazil in France. I participated in the event, and I could no longer distinguish between Brazilians and French people because they were all dancing the samba! Over time, trustful relationships have been built between the two countries. Brazilian researchers go to France. French researchers come to Brazil.

For this partnership that we wish to build, we want to sign the agreement by the end of this year. We are thinking of a very broad agreement. We have already agreed to democratize multilateral bodies. We agree that the UN needs to be democratized and should not maintain this 20th-century model. We are convinced that an institution such as the International Monetary Fund must think much more about development and less about fiscal adjustment. We are convinced that the G8 must go beyond the G8. There are countries that are rising: Brazil, South Africa. They have influence on the world stage like the G8 countries. I track the Brazil risk every day on my computer. It is rising. The risk of emerging countries. It is rising. But with the American crisis, why is the Brazil risk increasing?

I believe that Brazil and France can make an extraordinary contribution to building a new thinking on the issue of security, the issue of peace. After all, Brazil has all of South America with it. We have the African continent 6,000 kilometers away from us. These are places that are rising, evolving. In about thirty years, Africa will have one billion three hundred million inhabitants, and if it has three hundred million consumers, we will have a stronger need for more efficient transportation. With President SARKOZY, we are building stronger foundations than we have had so far so that the builders who come after can erect a good architecture. So that France and Brazil can contribute more to the world, with scientific and technological knowledge in the fields of defense and education.

This is what strategic relations are about, going beyond the buying and selling of products.

THE PRESIDENT - I would like to say from this point of view that I find it unbelievable that one could imagine discussing the great issues of the world without inviting a single African country and a single South American country to the discussion table, as if these two continents did not exist. I truly ask my colleagues to reflect on this. I say it as I think. South America matters. Africa matters. India and China matter. The idea that there would be a directorate of the world that would exclude two and a half billion inhabitants is not a very reasonable idea. That is why I will continue to advocate for convincing my friends that we need to have Brazil, to have India, to have China, to have Mexico, to have South Africa, and probably an Arab country as well. That is how we can tackle the great issues of the world. Otherwise, it would give the impression to all parts of the world that they do not count. The conception that we have, Brazil and France, is that one human being is worth one human being. I believe that is very important.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you are about to return to the mainland in a few moments, where your majority is going through a tense political situation. We would like to know your state of mind.

THE PRESIDENT - I do not know if Oyapock is quite the place for a political press conference, but it is quite normal for me to answer questions. You know, I do not think one becomes President of a country by chance. It takes a lot of experience, having gone through many difficulties, overcoming many trials. All governments, all majorities, all presidents, go through more or less easy moments. And it seems that there are difficulties. Difficulties must be faced with composure, with humility, and we must continue to work, because my appointment is the end of my term. I made commitments to the French people, and I will keep them. I call on everyone to remain as calm and composed as possible. The French elected us to implement the policy I committed to. That is what I am doing. That is what I will continue to do. I do not believe, to put it plainly, that agitation leads to any solution to problems. I draw your attention to the fact that in Guyana, I have not left France. It is President LULA who crossed the river. Well, if to please you, I must cross it in the other direction, I am fully prepared to do so. I will indeed have the opportunity, in the coming weeks, after the municipal elections probably, perhaps even before, to explain myself on a number of subjects so that there is no misunderstanding. I thank you all.