Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. Mariano Rajoy, President of the Spanish Government, on Franco-Spanish relations, the loss of France's triple A rating, policies in favor of growth and employment, and the tax on financial transactions, in Madrid on January 16, 2012.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

16 January 2012 · Joint press conference with the President of the Spanish Government · Madrid, Spain

Context
Sarkozy and Rajoy held a joint press conference in Madrid on January 16, 2012, covering Franco-Spanish relations, economic reforms, and ETA counterterrorism cooperation.
Main themes
Franco-Spanish bilateral relations, budgetary consolidation and deficit reduction, structural economic reforms, labor market reform, financial system restructuring, financial transaction tax, European Union membership and institutions, ETA terrorism and rule of law, European Central Bank representation, liquidity and credit availability, growth and employment policies
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,149
87th percentile
Sentences
213
90th percentile
Readability
60
87th percentile
Grade
9.5
15th percentile
Syntax
2.90
35th percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
7th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

213 sentences in 53 paragraphs

We are not here to waste our time, neither in Spain nor in Europe, and indeed nowhere in any country of the European Union. We agree that we must continue the process of budgetary consolidation and work to reduce the public deficit of the various countries in the European Union. Spain has already made important decisions last month, as you all know. We made decisions concerning our public deficit, a decision that involves 15 billion euros. And we have repeatedly said that we want to present a state budget during this quarter with our very important objective of continuing to reduce the public deficit. We also agree that it is not enough to reduce the public deficit; we must therefore work for budgetary stability but also consider reforms for the economic growth of our country. During this quarter, we will present, I hope, and once again I call on the social partners, we want to implement a labor market reform because we believe this is crucial for job creation. Very briefly, we will present a plan for the restructuring of our financial system, a plan that will mean transparency; assets must be valued at their fair value, new mergers will take place in our financial system, and the key objective is that there is credit in Spain, particularly for small and medium-sized enterprises and for households. During this quarter, we will also implement a reform of the public sector, and we will agree on these points with the autonomous community to reduce the number of public bodies, public entities in the autonomous communities and in the central administration. We agree that we must carry out structural reforms so that our countries grow and create jobs. We agree on this point. I want to clarify that today we need liquidity. Budgetary consolidation, control of the public budget, and structural reforms for greater economic growth must be accompanied by the necessary liquidity. Without this liquidity, the significant efforts we are making, which we will continue to make in the future, will have much less impact if we do not have liquidity than if we do.

I also want to add, as I have already said to President SARKOZY, that we support him on the financial transaction tax. It is true that we need to study some details, and above all, we do not want consumers to have to pay, but Spain will support this tax; it was a subject that was studied in Parliament, there is a community directive, but Spain supports the financial transaction tax, something that was presented a long time ago and is Mr. SARKOZY's battle horse.

We also both agree that Spain must continue to hold its position in accordance with its GDP within the executive committee of the European Central Bank. Indeed, the mandate is coming to an end; the current advisor representing Spain, Mr. Gonzalez PARAMO, will have to leave his position, but he should be replaced by another Spaniard, we have discussed this.

We have also said that Spain must be more at the heart of the European Union, and I told President SARKOZY that Spain would participate, that Spain would be at the heart of the European Union in the position that is rightfully its own due to its GDP, due to the strength of our country, and we will therefore contribute our opinions and help build this common project, a gigantic project that is Europe. And I commit to ensuring that Spain occupies the position that belongs to it, and we must also have institutions that are faster, more flexible, and that respond more quickly to the needs of citizens.

Finally, I thanked the President of the Republic for his support, the support he has always given us, always in the fight against ETA. Just a few hours ago, as you know, new arrests of ETA members took place in France, and I would like to say something very clearly; you know that I have already stated that the definitive cessation of ETA is something that seems very good to me, I have already said it and I repeat it. But the rule of law in France, as in Spain, is still there, and as long as ETA exists, ETA is a terrorist organization, and its members are members of a terrorist organization. These people who were arrested had weapons, explosives, pistols, so the rule of law continues to be in effect, and it is up to ETA to take a definitive step, the step that Spanish society demands, the step that decency and respect for citizens require. ETA must announce its dissolution as a criminal gang. In Spain, we are very proud, very happy about the ceremony that took place this morning at the Royal Palace where the President of the French Republic was awarded the Golden Fleece by His Majesty the King in recognition of his friendship towards Spain, his help in the fight against terrorism, his efforts to improve bilateral relations, and in his capacity as one of the most important political representatives on the planet. All former prime ministers were present, and the son of President Adolfo SUAREZ was also present at this ceremony, and the state institutions were also represented at this ceremony. Thank you very much, Mr. President of the Republic.

THE PRESIDENT -- Thank you, Mr. President. I would like to say how happy I am to be once again in Spain, this great friendly country of France, to meet President RAJOY, whom I first met in Rome at the first conference of European interior ministers, which I had the opportunity to attend at that time.

We are used to working together. The decisions just announced and taken by Mr. RAJOY's government are courageous. France wants to continue working with Spain, and personally, I hope to be able, with the trust that binds us, to do this good work together in the service of European construction. Europe needs Spain.

We are facing an unprecedented crisis that requires us to reduce our spending, reduce our deficits, and find the path to new growth by solving Europe's competitiveness problems.

This is all the work we are doing, and Mariano RAJOY will contribute his part. I want to tell him that France fully supports the presence of a representative from Spain in the executive bodies of the European Central Bank.

I add that there is a very great harmony of views; Mariano RAJOY's support for the principles of the financial transaction tax matters. We have exchanged views on all the major political and economic issues, and there is a very strong identity of views.

Finally, I want to tell the Spanish people that in the fight against terrorism, France will naturally remain by their side. The recent arrests on our territory are of great importance to us because I remind you that a man has died, that he was killed, and that we have elements that lead us to believe that, in one way or another, those who have been arrested have explanations to give to justice.

I would like to express how touched I am by the honor done to France by the Golden Fleece and how much I admire this Spanish democracy that can bring together all the former prime ministers Felipe GONZALES, José Maria AZNAR, José Luis ZAPATERO, Mariano RAJOY without anyone feeling offended in their political identity.

It is the same maturity of Spanish democracy that allowed Mariano RAJOY, at the time president of the PP, Partido Popular, to vote alongside the socialist government of Mr. ZAPATERO for the adoption of a golden rule.

This is a proof of maturity. When you are in opposition and know, in the interest of your country, how to make a gesture towards your country's government, you grow. And from this point of view, there is undoubtedly something to learn from Spanish democracy. It was, for me, an honor to be at the Royal Palace, alongside your sovereign, in the presence of all those who have mattered in the democratic life of the last 40 years in Spain.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, do you consider the loss of France's triple A to be a failure? Is this drop compared to Germany likely to reduce France's influence in Europe and at the same time increase the cost of the European Stability Fund? And in this context, why postpone the three-way summit in Rome that was scheduled for Friday?

THE PRESIDENT -- You may not have had the latest information. So can you ask me another question with the latest information?

QUESTION -- The question of whether you consider the loss of the triple A to be a failure and whether you think this drop compared to Germany is likely to reduce...

THE PRESIDENT -- I confirm: you have not had the latest information. So if you ask me a question about the latest information, I will answer it. If you ask me a question about what happened on Friday, that was Friday.

QUESTION -- Well, MOODY's then. What do you think...

THE PRESIDENT -- No, formulate a question. Moody's doesn't mean much.

QUESTION -- Do you think that Moody's, after Standard and Poor's, is hanging a sword of Damocles over French policy?

THE PRESIDENT -- I do not understand the question, excuse me. I do not understand this question, excuse me. If someone wants to ask me a question that I understand, I would be happy to answer it. I do not understand your question.

QUESTION -- Good evening, my congratulations on the Fleece. Thank you, Mr. President. I wanted to talk to you about the downgrade of the sovereign debt of some European countries by certain rating agencies. And I am thinking of France and Spain. I know that today another agency said that the French economy is on the rise, but I would like to know if this downgrade of sovereign debt for some countries could imply or suggest more austerity measures, particularly in Spain. Mr. RAJOY, could this imply some relaxation regarding the fight against the public deficit?

THE PRESIDENT -- If with the permission of President RAJOY, having understood the question, I will try to answer it. It is better to understand the questions. First, Madam, in France, and I suppose in Spain, it is not the rating agencies that should define the economic policies of the respective countries. On Friday, one agency downgraded the triple A, and on Monday, one agency confirmed that France retains the triple A. Two agencies out of three. We must react to these decisions with calmness and perspective. In essence, my conviction is that this changes nothing. We must reduce our deficits, we must reduce our spending, we must improve the competitiveness of our economies to find the path to growth. That is what we need to do. Just allow me to point out the lack of calmness of all those who were so talkative and agitated on Friday and who are so silent on Monday. Depending on what one agency says or what another agency does not say. The economic policy of a great country is not defined by jolts. I do not intend to take into account what some say and others do not. I must take into account the real economy. Too many deficits, too much spending, not enough growth. That is the problem for the whole of the European zone.

I add, to say a word about Spain: if Spain were not to succeed, we would all be impacted. If Italy were not to succeed, we would all be impacted. The interconnection, Madam, of the French economy with the Spanish economy, as with the Italian economy, means that we are in solidarity. But you asked me a question about Germany: the interconnection of the German economy and the French economy is such that if there were to be a problem in France, there would be a problem in Germany.

We have an interest in the success of Mr. MONTI's government, just as we have an interest in the success of President RAJOY's government. Because our economies are intertwined, because we belong to the same continent. I call on everyone to be measured, to remain calm, not to panic or agitate, because a particular agency made a particular comment. These are interesting elements that we must take into account, but on which we should not overreact.

Regarding Italy, just a word: I will have Mr. MONTI on the phone this evening. If we decided, Mr. MONTI, Mrs. MERKEL, and I, to postpone the meeting we had decided to February, it is for a very simple reason: Mrs. MERKEL received Mr. MONTI, I myself received Mr. MONTI. There was no need, ten days later, to do what would have been perceived as a summit, even as we are already being criticized for the accumulation of summits and we already have an appointment with Mariano RAJOY and the other heads of state and government on January 30 in Brussels.

We are united; there is a path that has been charted: less spending, less deficits, more growth, and more competitiveness. Whatever the agencies say, this path does not change.

If I observe the spreads today, as the Prime Minister said very well in an interview on Sunday: the situation is stable.

Mr. MARIANO RAJOY -- We are vigilant, of course, and we are paying attention to everything that is happening. The result of last Thursday's bond allocation pleased us. The downgrade by Standard & Poor's was less pleasing, of course. Today, we have seen that there have been significant changes regarding the spreads. But what is important is that, on the one hand, Europe must act quickly and realistically, but each country must choose its own path. Our government has chosen its path; we will reduce the public deficit, we will implement structural reforms for growth. I spoke earlier about the reform of the labor market, the reform of the public sector financial system. And that is what we will do. Things are clear for us; we will defend the general interests. This is what we have been saying for a long time. Of course, everything else interests us; some news is good, others less so. But if, in the end, the countries of the European Union respect and fulfill their duties, and if the European Council works quickly and realistically and sensibly, then we will overcome this crisis, and quickly.

QUESTION -- Mr. President of the Government, the Spaniards are coming out of an election year, the French are entering one, and many have observed your campaign and noticed that you did not announce before your election the details of the measures you took afterward. Does the crisis force politicians to no longer make promises? To put it another way, is this the only way to win elections in these turbulent times? And you, Mr. President SARKOZY, do you plan to ask as much of the French as Mr. RAJOY asks of the Spaniards, and what do you say to those who believe you are taking too many political risks at the beginning of this election year?

Mr. MARIANO RAJOY -- What you are saying is that the way to win elections today is to say nothing, is that what you told me? I must say that I have demonstrated that there are other ways to win elections. You must say what you think and what you are going to do. It is not only during the election campaign; for years, even when this country had a budget surplus, I am talking about a budget surplus, I was already saying that public spending needed to be reduced in Parliament. We have defended this idea for years, even when there was growth, even when there was employment. Everyone knew that the Popular Party would reduce the public deficit and that the Popular Party would respect its commitments to its European partners. On the one hand, because commitments must be respected, and then because it is our conviction. There is no Spaniard who does not believe that reducing the deficit is the battle horse of the Popular Party.

We are also betting on structural reforms. In Spain, there have been two labor market reforms in recent years. We are not opposed to any of these reforms. We abstained, and that is why these reforms were approved. But they did not seem sufficient to us. To create jobs, we believe that an effective labor market reform is necessary. We presented 70 amendments to the Socialist Party's bill in Parliament. None of these amendments were accepted. Among these 70 amendments, there are many proposals that correspond to what we want to do now in Spain.

I have asked the unions, privately and publicly. I have also spoken with the employers, for them to make an effort. This is not a problem of the Popular Party; it is not the problem of five ministers of the government, but it concerns the whole nation. In difficult times, even if it is the governments that bear the greatest responsibilities, we must all row in the same direction. We must all move forward to defend well-being and growth.

I have told the Spaniards that we are going to restructure the financial system; I have always repeated it. We supported the measures of the previous government. But once again, these reforms seemed a bit timid to us. It is true that the government has made great strides, but we believe that we must go further. People cannot be surprised that today I say that I am against the public deficit, that I want us to fulfill our commitments, that I want to implement structural reforms. It is ridiculous to ask those in their positions whether they will reduce a budget item by 1 euro or 5 euros.

I believe that everyone knew what the general objectives of the government I now preside over were.

THE PRESIDENT -- I would like to remind you that Mariano RAJOY did not just say what he was going to do. When he made the decision to vote for the golden rule proposed by Mr. ZAPATERO's government, it was a risk; it was not necessarily popular, but it served the general interest of Spain. How can one reproach someone who, in opposition, had the courage to vote for an unpopular measure just weeks before the elections for having concealed his program? I refer you to the French situation; has there been a single political opposition party that has accompanied us on the path of pension reform? And has there been a single opposition parliamentarian who had the courage to say that he would vote for the golden rule? What Mariano RAJOY did in Spain, not a single opposition leader did for France!

Finally, the crisis that Europe is experiencing is an extremely serious crisis. Decisions must be made. We have made them, for the most part, regarding the reduction of deficits. I would like to remind you that, for the 2011 deficits, France will do better than it had committed to. Better, significantly better.

The work now must focus on growth and competitiveness. The problems of Europe and France will not be solved solely by reducing spending.

The day after tomorrow, there will be a Summit on the crisis with social partners. And before the end of the month, with the Prime Minister and the government, we will announce very important decisions to support growth, to improve our competitiveness, and to respond to all those who are currently unemployed. Do you believe that someone who is unemployed today can afford to think, imagine, or say: "the president and the government are not making decisions because the elections are in 4 months"? Four months lost! That is the real risk. And I say this, fully aware of the problem of our Spanish friends who have an unemployment rate of 22 to 23%; we are at 9. But for someone who is unemployed, do you think he has the time to wait for the election campaign, or should we act right away? I believe we must act right away. And that is what we will do, calmly and coolly.

This is the difference between those who comment and those who act; it is normal. Those who comment can let themselves go in excessive commentary. Those who act do not have that right. One can, when in opposition, or when commenting, say things that one forgets the next day. When one is in government, one does not have that right because one is leading a country, and there is a lot of suffering within that country. We cannot afford that kind of agitation. That is the difference.

QUESTION -- Good evening, I wanted to ask the President of the Spanish government: you said you are in favor of a financial transaction tax.

Mr. MARIANO RAJOY -- I agree with the financial transaction tax; I have already told you that. And I do not believe there is a divergent viewpoint between Mr. SARKOZY and Ms. MERKEL because Mr. SARKOZY wants to move faster, and Ms. MERKEL would like an agreement. I believe that what we all want is to discuss the subject, reach an agreement, and implement it immediately. Because often, decision-making takes a lot of time, and often after the adoption of these decisions, it takes a long time to implement them.

And I believe, therefore, that we want to make decisions on this point; already within the Spanish parliament, we have talked about it; also within the European parliament, there is a proposed directive, and I believe that, as with many things, the faster we go, the better it will be. And I believe that the two viewpoints are perfectly reconcilable.

Regarding the increase in income tax, how do I believe this has been received by the voters of the Popular Party? I was going to say I suppose, but no, I will not say I suppose; I am convinced that they did not like it. And they are right.

But we made this decision because we find ourselves in a very complex situation. Because the other solution was to do nothing and thus send a very bad message and not try to solve Spain's problems.

This decision was very difficult for me, personally. Because I do not believe in high taxes: I think that money is better in the hands of taxpayers, but we had no choice. And I can tell you that this decision is a temporary decision, for 2 years, and I am convinced that this decision, as well as other decisions we have made and others we will make soon, will allow Spain to regain its position, its economic growth. We will create jobs, create wealth, and then we can lower taxes.

You ask me if in the next state budget we will plan for a tax increase? No, I believe we have already increased taxes enough. That said, I think we can reduce the public deficit without further increasing taxes. I tell you this now, but I must also tell you that one cannot say never. I do not believe that we will be able to lower taxes soon, but in the future, yes.

THE PRESIDENT -- Just a word perhaps on the financial transaction tax? I know well the opinion of Ms. MERKEL. There is no disagreement between us. And I am, like Mariano RAJOY, convinced that it is much better to have a financial transaction tax that concerns the entire euro area, the entire European Union, and even the whole world. Do not bother to explain to me that a global tax is better than a tax that would only affect a few countries.

But that is not the question, if you allow me. If we have to wait to implement a financial transaction tax until others start, what do we do if they do not start? Do we wait? And do we not implement it?

In Spain, Mariano RAJOY just said: there are tax increases. On what grounds could we tell citizens, consumers: "you, you can have tax increases, but financiers, financial transaction taxes, should not exist?" So the idea of France is very simple: that there be a group of leading countries that adopt the financial transaction tax so that everyone adopts it.

Finally, the last point, I believe there is never a risk in telling the truth to the country for which we are responsible. People are clear-sighted, very intelligent; they understand everything. If we ever wanted to hide anything from them, what they anticipate is generally much worse than what the leaders would want to hide. So, you see, the truth and courage, in times of crisis, is really the least risky path.

Thank you. Mr. MARIANO RAJOY -- Thank you very much.