Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. Naoto Kan, Prime Minister of Japan, on France's support for Japan after the earthquake of March 11, 2011, and on nuclear safety, in Tokyo on March 31, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

31 March 2011 · Joint press conference of the President of France and the Prime Minister of Japan · Tokyo, Japan

Context
Sarkozy held a joint press conference with PM Naoto Kan in Tokyo on March 31, 2011, to express solidarity following Japan's devastating March 11 earthquake, tsunami, and Fukushima nuclear crisis.
Main themes
France-Japan solidarity, Fukushima nuclear disaster, nuclear safety standards, earthquake and tsunami aftermath, G8 Deauville agenda, IAEA nuclear safety discussions, G20 nuclear debate, French technical assistance, Japan-EU trade agreement, international disaster response
Duration
~24 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,835
73rd percentile
Sentences
123
73rd percentile
Readability
55
78th percentile
Grade
10.8
30th percentile
Syntax
3.09
59th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

123 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

We will now begin the joint conference of the two heads of state and government of France and Japan.

First, we will ask Mr. KAN to speak.

Mr. NAOTO KAN - Mr. President of the French Republic, Mr. SARKOZY, came to Japan at a time when we are suffering from earthquakes and the damage from the nuclear power plant. We are very happy to welcome him and we are very touched that he wanted to express international solidarity. I would like to deeply thank him and I am very pleased to welcome him. The President told us that the Japanese people are experiencing a very difficult situation, the hardest trial since 1945. He told us that our Japanese people are facing it with great courage. The President saluted this courage of the Japanese and also assured us that Japan can certainly be resurrected. For my part, I spoke to him about the situation of the tsunami, the earthquakes, and also what is happening at the Fukushima plant, and we were able to exchange views on this matter. In this context, Mr. President SARKOZY told us that for the G8 meeting in Deauville, he wished to give me the floor at the beginning, so that I could address the issue of the nuclear power plant accident, and that this theme would be included on the agenda. That was Mr. SARKOZY's proposal and I responded that I would be very happy for it to be so.

Mr. SARKOZY also proposed that I make an official visit before the summit, but given the current situation, I told him that I would like to see what the situation would be at that time before responding to him. At the same time as the G8, in May, there will be the G20 meeting where we also wish to have opportunities to discuss the nuclear issue. Also, in June, within the IAEA, the President proposed that we discuss nuclear safety. Indeed, the experience we have had in Japan in this area is a very hard trial, but to ensure that this does not happen again, it is necessary to disseminate information very precisely to other countries around the world. We believe that this is a duty that we owe, which is why we will be very supportive of discussions on safety standards for all nuclear power plants in the world and we welcome the President's proposal. What we must do is lay out for our interlocutors all the experience we have.

Also, France being known as very advanced in the nuclear field, including in the area of robots and equipment, has kindly agreed to provide us with support. We have already received a lot of help but we will also be able to benefit from the expertise and equipment coming from France. We therefore want to discuss this subject with France.

Not only did we talk about the earthquake issue, but there is also the issue of the agreement between Japan and the European Union. We want to thank the President of the Republic for his very favorable position in promoting this agreement. In any case, we want to emphasize that we are on the same page. He spoke to us of a proverb: "When it rains, a friend who comes on a rainy day is a true friend." This is to say how grateful we are for the visit of Mr. President of the Republic who was willing to come in such a situation.

THE PRESIDENT - Mr. Prime Minister, I would like to tell the Japanese people how close France feels to them, how much the French have admired the dignity, courage, and solidarity of the Japanese in the face of the greatest catastrophe since 1945. The images of your martyred country, Mr. Prime Minister, have traveled around the world but they have deeply moved my compatriots. Japan is a country that, when there is a disaster in the world, is the most generous and responsive. The world knows this, the world knows this generosity. Well, today, it is the world’s turn to return this generosity and solidarity to you. Japan must know that it is not alone in this catastrophe, that all the countries of the G20, which France is presiding over this year, are at Japan's disposal to concretely express our solidarity.

With the Prime Minister - first, I want to thank him for the very lucid analysis he presented to us regarding the situation at the Fukushima plant. France offers Japan robots that can intervene in contaminated areas. France offers its expertise and experience regarding the decommissioning of plants, radiation measures, and our teams are currently working to strengthen this solidarity. And Nathalie KOSCIUSKO-MORIZET, who will remain in Japan until Saturday, is tasked with contacting her counterparts, members of your government, Mr. Prime Minister, so that France's concrete assistance is as efficient as possible.

Regarding the G8, I proposed to the Japanese Prime Minister to be the first to speak and we will prepare a statement from the heads of state and government of the G8 on nuclear issues, in agreement with our Japanese friends. Furthermore, we must remedy the incongruity that there are no international safety standards in nuclear matters. France has proposed, and I thank the Prime Minister for accepting it, that all the independent nuclear safety authorities of the G20 countries be gathered in Paris, by Nathalie KOSCIUSKO-MORIZET, to prepare and provide elements for the very useful IAEA meeting that will take place in June. There is no opposition between the work of the G20 and the work of the G8, and on the contrary, there is complementarity. What matters is that before the end of the year, there are international safety standards.

So, Ladies and Gentlemen, I would have preferred to come to Japan under different circumstances, but it seemed to me, as President of the G20, to be my duty to bring solidarity, the testimony of solidarity from the 19 other member countries of the G20. So it is not just France but the 19 other countries of the G20 that say to Japan our confidence in the future. You will rise from this catastrophe, even stronger.

And I would like to conclude by saying how moved we have been by the heroism of your rescuers, and the solidarity of all those who, having lost everything, found a way to make themselves available to their fellow citizens.

Know, my dear Japanese friends, that in this dreadful catastrophe, the world is watching you and the world admires you.

The images we have received have profoundly shocked the Cartesian and reasonable minds of the French. This unleashing of nature of which you have been a victim has upset both emotionally and at the same time rationally, one wondered if such violence and such unleashing were possible. And fundamentally, this must lead us to show great humility in the face of the power of nature, which should not be opposed to progress. But we must look at all this with lucidity and draw all the consequences, that will be our duty.

Thank you, Mr. Prime Minister.

QUESTION - A question for Mr. KAN. Since the earthquake, the Prime Minister has mainly devoted his efforts to finding solutions regarding the plant, but after this experience, how do you want to review energy policy? During the meeting with the Secretary General of the Communist Party, you mentioned a revision of energy policy, but I would like to know a bit more concretely how you want to review this policy. Furthermore, we must also talk about the reconstruction and recovery of the country, we need to organize for that. How will you organize the structures and ministers to address this?

Also a question directed to Mr. SARKOZY: France is known to be a very advanced country in nuclear matters, a country that is capable of providing us with a lot of expertise and advice, but after this accident, there is a certain mistrust developing in the world. Within the G8 and G20, you said you would work to establish international safety standards. But in your opinion, what is the priority, what is the priority action that should be taken in this context?

Mr. NAOTO KAN - What I have done during these three weeks, after the earthquake and tsunami. There were victims, we had to save these victims, one more life to save and provide maximum support to these victims.

That was the top priority and at the same time, there was this accident that occurred at the nuclear power plant. I had to work on these two fronts.

I do not want you to think that I have only worked to find solutions for the nuclear power plant. In this context, regarding the accident at the plant, the severity was evident from the very first moment, I recognized it immediately, and that is why I wanted to invest as much as possible to address this problem as much as to save the victims.

You spoke of revising energy policy, but for now, we must first work to contain the damage that the plant could cause. We must deploy all our efforts to resolve this accident issue, and when we reach a more stabilized stage, we will then need to begin the analysis work and reflect on the reasons that led us to this. It is after this analysis and verification that we can find solutions. Moreover, we discussed this with Mr. SARKOZY; I think we should launch an international debate and discussion on what could have caused this accident. And in our energy policy, we want to integrate the reflection that will have been conducted on this accident and we must resume the discussion to review Japan's energy policy.

Regarding the issue of recovery, of rebuilding our country: given that today is March 31, the end of the budgetary year and that tomorrow is the first day of the new fiscal year, we have been able to vote on the budget amendment for the next fiscal year. But between the time we proposed the finance bill and now, many things have happened, the priority is no longer the same. That is why we will need to shift from support for the victims to the path of reconstruction, so we will need to chart a course in that direction.

In April, we will try to carry out clearing work. We will need to vote on another budget amendment for that and at the same time, to prepare for reconstruction, we will receive various proposals from experts, set up commissions or working groups with these experts to examine the paths of reconstruction. Moreover, we have already begun to work in this direction; starting tomorrow, I will attend a press conference and perhaps, tomorrow, I can tell you a bit more about this.

THE PRESIDENT - Listen, for us, Madam, it is the feedback on what happened in Japan. Our duty, we who made the choice of nuclear power, a long time ago, a choice that we confirm, is to ensure the most important safety standards in the world. So we have decided to have feedback on what you experienced and to apply it to a systematic audit of all our plants in France. And the plants that do not pass the test of this audit will be closed.

For us, the choice is simple: nuclear power and safety. And the whole world must understand that nuclear power is only possible with exceptional safety and security standards. This is the choice that France made many years ago and it is the choice that we confirm.

QUESTION - Together with my colleagues, I would like to express to Prime Minister KAN the condolences of everyone for the difficulties and pain of the Japanese people. I still wanted to ask you a question after this catastrophe, Mr. Minister. Do you consider that nuclear power has a future or not? And how can you restore or not restore the trust of the population after the criticisms regarding the lack of transparency and the use of nuclear power by private companies?

To Mr. President SARKOZY: you want international standards, but should these international standards be the same in a country like Japan, which is in a seismic zone subject to tsunamis, or in calmer countries like, for example, France? Thank you.

Mr. NAOTO KAN - First of all, I would like to thank you for the sympathy you have shown us. The accident we experienced this time is the most serious, the hardest we have ever known. Why did we arrive at this state, at this severity? Well, it must be examined thoroughly. After this in-depth analysis, we must reflect on the modalities of using nuclear energy. For humanity, nuclear energy is in some way a fruit of human wisdom, but at the same time, this energy can also cause accidents like this one. Therefore, we must ensure that there are no more accidents caused by the use of nuclear energy. Nuclear power must reach a maximum level of safety both in Japan and internationally.

You spoke about private enterprise. Indeed, in Japan, Japanese electric companies take the form of private corporations. For the moment, since we have not yet managed to resolve the issue of the plant, we believe it is too premature to discuss the terms, the status of these operators, but when we have finished with this accident, we may examine the status of these operators, including their future, their survival.

THE PRESIDENT - It will be up to independent authorities and experts to determine the international standard, and if that standard needs to be strengthened in certain geographical or climatic situations, it is for them to say. What we wish for is an international standard, because the planet - not simply due to globalization - but because the planet is a village, what happens here in Japan can have consequences elsewhere, and so it is not simply a question of a particular country, it is a question of the security of the world. Perhaps these experts will determine more significant standards based on seismic or climatic risks.

I draw your attention to the fact that the problem that occurred came not from the earthquake but from the tsunami, not from nuclear energy but from the wave that destroyed the generator system intended to cool the water. The building withstood the earthquake. The engines, as the Prime Minister told me, shut down, the reactors shut down automatically when the disaster occurred and then there was the tsunami. Indeed, we must review our protections in light of the tsunami risk. I say this in Japan, and how could there not be an intense emotion, in Japan as elsewhere, indeed! But we must look at all this with a cool head so that such a catastrophe does not happen again. And at the same time, we must take into account the fact that we have all made commitments to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, all of us. And to fulfill these commitments, there are not 150 solutions, there is nuclear energy.

You see, in my mind, I say this and I say it in Japan, the problem is more about raising safety standards than about the choice of nuclear energy for which there is currently no alternative, given the importance it has taken in a number of developed countries. France itself has made commitments - I speak under the authority of Nathalie KOSCIUSKO-MORIZET - very significant commitments to the development of renewable energies. We ourselves, Mr. Prime Minister, have not chosen only nuclear energy; we have chosen nuclear energy and renewable energies.

I say this: by mobilizing all our will in the service of renewable energies, we do not compensate, and we will not compensate, for this very case of nuclear energy. The question, it seems to me, is rather about safety, it is nuclear and safety, because if tomorrow we were to decide to shut down all the nuclear plants operating in the world, with what energy would we replace them? And as you yourself said, the plants are not of the same age, they are not the same technologies. I would like to say that the latest plants we are building in France, the EPR plants with the double hull in particular, have a level of safety far superior to what was built 40 years ago. This is really an audit that we need, but we, Mr. Prime Minister, the audit we are going to conduct is not so much about the choice of nuclear energy, which is a choice that has been confirmed for decades - and by the way, is it really a choice? Is there another solution? - it is the feedback on what you have experienced, you Japanese, to ensure maximum safety. The debate should focus on the issue of safety. I believe that is where the debate could be most useful.

Thank you.