Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. Silvio Berlusconi, President of the Council of Ministers of the Italian Republic, notably on Franco-Italian relations, military intervention in Libya, the issue of illegal immigration, and nuclear energy, in Rome on April 26, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

26 April 2011 · Joint press conference of Nicolas Sarkozy and Silvio Berlusconi · Rome, Italy

Context
Sarkozy and Berlusconi held a joint press conference in Rome on April 26, 2011, addressing Libya, immigration, Syria, and bilateral cooperation.
Main themes
Franco-Italian bilateral relations, military intervention in Libya, illegal immigration and Schengen, Syrian crisis, EU solidarity on Mediterranean migration, nuclear energy cooperation, Tunisian immigration flows, civilian protection in Libya, NATO operations
Duration
~48 min
94th percentile
Words
5,812
94th percentile
Sentences
283
95th percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
10.3
24th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
22nd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

283 sentences in 36 paragraphs

MR. SILVIO BERLUSCONI -- Good morning everyone. I would like to extend a warm welcome in Rome and Italy to all our friends from the French press and television. Today, a summit was held -- I can say without fear -- very positively. From our discussions, a strong convergence emerged between Italy and France on all the topics we addressed. As you know, we were able to discuss various issues: the situation in Libya first, the situation in the Mediterranean, immigration, and economic and industrial cooperation between our two countries.

If Mr. President SARKOZY allows me, I would like to say something that concerns Syria above all. We talked about it, we are very concerned about the evolution of the situation in that country, the many victims, and we jointly call on the authorities in Damascus to end the violent repression of peaceful demonstrations, and we ask both parties involved to act with moderation. We renew our invitation to the Syrian authorities for immediate follow-up on the important reforms that have been announced.

Regarding Libya, we had the opportunity to speak on the phone with the President of the National Transitional Council in Benghazi, Mr. JALIL. We took stock of the situation. He thanked me for the decision we made to increase the operational flexibility of our aircraft. Italy was already providing significant support by making its bases available and implementing a series of other important operations, intervening with its aircraft, ships, etc.

But all our allies, as well as the United States of America, have urgently requested us to also deploy our aircraft on military targets when we can exclude with certainty the possibility of causing harm to the civilian population. This approach on our part is a logical continuation of the decision made at the United Nations Security Council. We felt that this was something we could not shy away from because we believe that this is an intervention on our part that is truly needed. We therefore made this difficult decision, because you know our colonial past in Libya. You also know the friendship treaty we concluded with the Libyan people. Nevertheless, we assessed and we believe that, given the current situation, we had to do it. I want to make it clear that this is not about bombings. The Italian press seemed to say this morning that we were preparing to bomb: that is not the case, it is about very targeted and precise interventions on military objectives, moving equipment, and other situations of that kind. This has nothing to do with interventions on civilian centers or places where there could be civilian casualties. The objective of what we are doing is, let us be clear, essentially to protect the civilian population. And therefore, it would be a contradiction for our military actions to endanger the lives of the civilian population.

We also signed a joint declaration and we also decided to appoint two personalities, President SARKOZY and the Italian Prime Minister, namely myself, to address immigration issues by developing the treaties that already exist. I would like to say a very clear sentence about the relations we have with France regarding the reception of Tunisian immigrants by France, immigrants who come to Italy and who do not have the right to asylum because there is no civil war in Tunisia. France has welcomed more than 50,000 immigrants each year. Italy, on the other hand, has welcomed an average of 10,000. I would therefore like to confirm here to President SARKOZY that France's effort has been 5 times greater than that made by Italy. And we are fully aware of this. I say this clearly: without any intention of accusing France of behaviors that did not occur, I say very frankly, things must be settled between friendly countries based on existing treaties, based on existing international law.

We talked about Schengen. No one can deny Schengen, but in exceptional situations, we believe that there must be modifications, variations to the Schengen treaty on which we have decided to work together. We also drafted a joint letter to President VAN ROMPUY and President BARROSO, in which we request greater collaboration from the countries on the southern shore of the Mediterranean, greater solidarity from all our European partners. And I think this is due because at the last Council of Heads of State and Government, we expressly introduced, after thorough discussion, this principle: the countries on the southern shore of Europe must not be left alone when massive immigration phenomena occur. There must be an absolute principle of solidarity among the 27 countries of the European Union. And this is what we have jointly requested, and we have also decided to work together regarding our relations with the Tunisian government.

We want the government to collaborate with us in monitoring the coasts, the territories along the coasts, so that there are no such migrations, migratory flows. In this regard, Mr. SARKOZY said that he shared the psychological deterrents we have implemented by returning immigrants to their countries, trying to make these decisions known through television, so that those who want to come to Europe, to the European paradise, question whether it is worth spending 1,000 euros or even more to reach Europe and then be sent back to their country of origin. We believe that this psychological deterrent is very important.

We obviously talked about economic cooperation, about what is happening between our companies. I have a personal position on this: I have a long experience in the business world and I believe that the economy must be free. States can intervene when it comes to sectors that endanger their security or internal order. In all other areas, competition must be free. France, recently, has made interventions regarding Italian companies. In France, large companies are strong, are important. This is not the case in Italy where our strength lies in small and medium-sized enterprises. And our small and medium-sized enterprises are numerous in France: more than 1,800 work there, are appreciated, for example my group, Mondadori France, which works very well with the French public. We must also remember that Italian exports to France exceed French exports to Italy.

I therefore think that based on this factual situation, we must take into consideration the phenomena that the market presents to us. Our common wish, our common desire is to create large international Franco-Italian, Italo-French groups that can position themselves well in global competition, based on the friendly relations that have always existed between our two countries and our peoples.

I apologize, Mr. President SARKOZY, if I have been a bit long, but it was I who, as the host, had this task from the outset.

THE PRESIDENT - Mr. President, Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers, Mr. Prime Minister. It is always a joy to be back in Italy. As the French president, I want to tell our Italian friends how much Italy is in the heart of every French person. I do not know if you realize this, but every French person feels close to Italy. Every French person, when they think of Italy, thinks of a civilization, a way of life, and economic know-how. Italy has great significance in France.

I called President BERLUSCONI a few days ago to tell him: "there are tensions between Italy and France, they should not exist." It does not matter whose fault it is, they should not exist. France and Italy are linked by history, by culture, and by a way of life that is so similar. If you ask the French, they will certainly tell you that the only country where it is as good to live as in France is Italy. And besides, when we are in Italy, we who have such a strong Mediterranean tradition, we French, feel so good that we do not feel like we are in a foreign country, we feel close. And we decided, with President BERLUSCONI, to organize this summit with the French Prime Minister and the main ministers, the Minister of State, Alain JUPPE, the Minister of the Interior, the Minister of Finance to discuss the problems we have between us – and what did we find? It is that there are solutions to all these problems. First on Libya: we welcome Italy's decision to send its aircraft. We need Italy's participation – and by the way, Ladies and Gentlemen, who could understand that Italy would not participate in the coalition's work to allow Libyans to live free after 41 years of dictatorship, when you yourselves, Italians, have been so close, through history, to Libya? And so, the fact that President BERLUSCONI and the Italian government have recognized the CNT, have received the president of the CNT and decided to deploy aircraft in service of democracy in Libya, is excellent news. We will work hand in hand and our agreement is total.

I share President BERLUSCONI's remarks on Syria, where the situation has become unacceptable. Speaking under the control of the French Minister and the Minister of State for Foreign Affairs, there cannot be double standards. There is an aspiration of the Arab peoples for freedom and democracy, expressed peacefully. You do not send tanks, the army, against demonstrators, you do not shoot at them. Brutality is unacceptable.

On immigration, the two ministers have done excellent work. What do we want? We want Schengen to live. And for Schengen to live, Schengen must be reformed. We wanted the single currency with the euro and we reformed the economic governance of Europe. Well, we want the same for Schengen. Schengen, what is it? It is a number of countries that say: "come on, we entrust the defense of our borders to each of the countries, together. We trust each other." We want to strengthen its text, we want to strengthen evaluations, we want more resources so that the borders of the Schengen area are guaranteed and we say that there is no reason not to mention the safeguard clause. If a country fails to guard the borders of others, what do we do? It is precisely because we believe in Schengen that we want a profound strengthening of Schengen. I pointed out to President BERLUSCONI that I fully understood Italy's problems, but in terms of solidarity, that France is the country in Europe that welcomes the most refugees in Europe. I say this to our Italian friends, President BERLUSCONI rightly said: 52,000. So, the question of Schengen is not about passing the problems back and forth, but that together we manage the problems. And I am very happy that we are making a joint letter, President BERLUSCONI and I, to President BARROSO and that this will be one of the major topics of the European Council in June.

On the economy, once again, I would like to say to our Italian friends: we are each other's second trading partner. The second. And let us pay tribute to the dynamism of the Italian economy. Do you know, you Italians, that the trade balance between France and Italy is in deficit for France, and in surplus for Italy? I want to tell you this because sometimes I wonder if the figures, if the reality, are known. Let us pay tribute to your entrepreneurs. You have a network of SMEs that command our admiration and that have many clients in France. But the deficit between Italy and France is paid by France. It is up to us to be more dynamic, but in a certain way, economically, the debate is settled. It is well known, President Berlusconi is right to say it, you have the best SMEs and we have powerful large groups; therefore, there is no need to wage a war between one another. You know, for us, Italy is more than Europe; it is a brother country. We are creating large Franco-Italian groups, which will be to the advantage of Italy and to the advantage of France. Do you believe that France can alone create large groups of global dimensions? And you, do you think you can do it alone? So of course, we should not be offended; the President knows well that there can be conflicts of interest, there can be difficulties. Let’s talk about it. Even in the Lactalis-Parmalat case that we discussed, Lactalis is the largest buyer of milk from Parmalat. We are compelled to find a solution, and we have therefore decided to entrust two of our collaborators, in agreement with François Fillon -- it will be the Secretary General of the Elysée for us, who will see, in full agreement with the ministers, Christine Lagarde, in whom I have complete trust, and Giulio Tremonti, whom I have known well and appreciated a lot in other roles -- to find solutions. We have the railways, we have energy, we have Parmalat, but the proposal that France makes to you is: let us combine to create large Franco-Italian groups. We need each other.

I take this opportunity to say, with the agreement of the Minister of Finance, that France will be very happy to support an Italian for the Presidency of the Central Bank, Mario Draghi, whom I know well. We do not support him because he is Italian; we support him because he is a man of quality. But it happens that he is also Italian, and this will be a very beautiful signal to all Italians who might doubt their place and role in Europe that an Italian holds such a responsibility. And I was very happy, dear Christine, to hear President Berlusconi say that, of course, he would support the candidacy of a Frenchman in the context of the ECB's executive board.

So to summarize things in one word: it was an extremely useful summit; we were able to talk among friends, frankly, about subjects that are not simple, but for which, one after the other, we found solutions or at least a working method to arrive at these solutions. One last word to say that the European defense policy, which is a priority for us and which was discussed by the two foreign ministers, is something that has a lot of future between Italy and France, because Italy has a major role to play in the Europe of defense that is being built.

Thank you.

Mr. Silvio Berlusconi - Thank you, Mr. President, I believe we have reached an agreement. Two questions from Italian journalists and two questions from French journalists.

QUESTION - Questions to both Presidents Berlusconi and Sarkozy: how far should the revision of the Schengen agreements go, and could we know a bit more about this joint letter you sent to Brussels? And then another question about Syria: should we intervene in Syria in support of the civilian population, how to do so currently in Libya? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, if the President agrees, we could publish the letter to President Barroso in a few minutes as a courtesy to President Barroso before it is sent. Before we publish it, but it is not a secret, in this letter there are very simple things: we are asking for a strengthening of joint work, a common assessment of the situation, an exchange of best practices, the strengthening of Frontex; one very simple thing, very simple, that I knew as Minister of the Interior: who manages Schengen? I apologize for asking the question -- I am not blaming anyone -- is it the Interior Ministers? In that case, then, let them really manage it, because in the meetings of the Interior Ministers, it is not true that we manage Schengen. Is it a dedicated team that should specifically manage Schengen? This is not a subject -- and then, I mentioned a word about the safeguard clause, which is a difficult question, but we need to reflect on it. So, it is because we believe in Schengen that we want to evolve Schengen. And by the way, for all European questions: do we really think that Europe at 27, tomorrow Europe at 32 or 33, can be managed as it was when we were 6 or 9? Is not the adaptation of European institutions the rule? Was not Schengen a change compared to what existed before the Schengen meeting? It is perfectly natural, and, in essence, those who refuse any evolution of Schengen are those who do not want Schengen. There you go. And we believe in the freedom of movement of people, but we believe in the rule of law and in respecting a certain number of rules.

On Syria, I would like to remind you that, before an intervention in Côte d'Ivoire as in Libya, there was a resolution from the Security Council, and it cannot be a question of anything as long as there is no resolution from the Security Council. And France has a certain experience in this matter; I speak under the control of Alain Juppé, who has done remarkable work. It is not so easy to hold, but it remains that on Syria, I maintain that the situation is unacceptable. There has been a historic change, Madam, and clearly France, as -- I have understood -- as Italy, we stand by the Arab peoples in their aspiration for democracy and freedom. It is a historic choice; it is a major turning point in our country's foreign policy, and it is a turning point for which we assume each of the consequences. This does not mean, however, that we will intervene everywhere in the world and that all situations can be duplicated; in no case, and everyone must understand this.

Mr. Silvio Berlusconi -- The answer was complete; I completely agree.

QUESTION -- A question to Mr. Berlusconi and Mr. Sarkozy. To Mr. Berlusconi: regarding the new phase of the Italian military intervention in Libya, you said it would not involve bombings, but targeted interventions. However, within the majority, there seems to be some perplexity; I am not only referring to the Northern League but also to the Catholic wing of the PDL. How do you plan to overcome this perplexity, and do you think there will be a parliamentary pathway for this intervention in Libya? To Mr. Sarkozy: regarding the intervention in Libya, you were the first to call for it, but at the moment the fighting is struggling. How do you think this will end, how will the international community get through this, and do you think that, apart from air intervention, a ground intervention will be necessary in the future?

Mr. Silvio Berlusconi -- Regarding the question addressed to me, I must say that the decision of our government was not easy. I plan to discuss it further with the allies of the Northern League who shared my position. So, aware of our past as a colonizer and also aware of the friendship treaty we concluded a few years ago with the Libyan people, through Mr. Kadhafi, this is something that created some difficulties for us from the start in joining the allies. But in view of the situation and its evolution -- there are about 10,000 victims of the civil war -- in view of all the initiatives that our allies have undertaken -- the United States with John Kerry, who was sent by President Obama to meet me, France, etc. -- all the allies were aware that an Italian intervention, in addition to the other interventions, could better defend the Libyan population and accelerate the solution to the Libyan problem -- we accepted, in a very specific form, to intervene on targeted military objectives in order to absolutely exclude the possibility of civilian casualties. This solution is one that we had to take while respecting the position of our allies in the Northern League; I called Mr. Maroni, Mr. Calderoni, and Mr. Bossi last night, and we agreed that we would talk about this even today. I felt it was necessary to do this because I did not want Italy to be seen as a participant that would not be a full participant. Parliament had given the green light to the initiative we took with the new arrangement of our bases. We believed that the internal opposition would have exploited this against us. There was an episode, which everyone remembers, of a triangular, so to speak, telephone call initiated by President Obama, with the countries participating in the offensive against military targets. We were not participating; we were excluded from this triangular. Some took advantage of this to say that Italy did not count for anything and that President Berlusconi was not being considered. These are partly the reasons that led us to make this decision. The Ministers of Defense and Foreign Affairs are at the disposal of Parliament to provide all necessary information. I would like to remind you that this decision is made within the framework of the mandate of the United Nations Security Council and the vote of parliamentary committees.

THE PRESIDENT -- Just three brief remarks. The first: if we had not intervened in Benghazi, there would have been thousands, even tens of thousands of certain deaths. No one loves war, and no one gives an order to their country's military to intervene lightly. I ask you to reflect on this. Benghazi has nearly a million inhabitants. Mr. Kadhafi had said that his revenge would be terrible, and we can credit him when he says this. Tens of thousands of deaths have been avoided, and I can tell you, it was a matter of hours, not even days, and no one can contest that. And that today, Italy and the Italian air force are alongside democracy and civilian victims, I rejoice for the idea I have always had of Italian democracy. This is the first remark. The second remark: if we are making these strikes, it is to achieve peace. It is precisely because there is this intervention, which strikes military targets, that there is a chance to achieve peace in Libya. Who can believe, who would dare to say that Mr. Kadhafi would have come to discuss the future of Libya if there had not been these strikes on military targets? Therefore, it is not military objectives or peace; it is because there are military objectives -- and, again, thank you to Italy for participating in this -- that we have a chance to have democracy and peace. It is not one or the other; it is one and the other. And then the third remark on ground troops: Madam, no. Why? Because we have a rule. This rule is the resolution adopted by the United Nations, and the resolution adopted by the United Nations does not provide for the intervention of ground troops. So, we can discuss the intervention of intelligence agents or experts, but military intervention on the ground is not provided for by the United Nations resolution. And our rule is the application of the United Nations resolution. I apologize for stating this with great force, but that is how it will happen. And in Côte d'Ivoire, we the French did exactly the same thing; I mean, respecting the United Nations resolution. There you go.

QUESTION -- Beyond the somewhat general statements about economic relations earlier, do you consider that the takeover bid launched this morning by Lactalis on Parmalat is a hostile act, and do you hope that a consortium of Italian banks will be able to make a counter-proposal to this takeover bid on Parmalat? I wanted to know what you thought about this particular case, Mr. President. And then, just to follow up on my Italian colleague's question regarding Libya, how many months do you think the international coalition can maintain pressure as it is doing today on Libya, how many months or even how many years, knowing that in some countries we have been engaged for several years?

MR. SILVIO BERLUSCONI -- I must tell you that I do not consider the takeover bid to be a hostile takeover. It is quite singular that this takeover bid was launched this very morning, on the very day of this Summit, between Mr. SARKOZY, myself, and the other ministers. But I can certainly exclude that the French government was aware of this overlap between the takeover bid and the Summit. As for the future, I repeat that we have already said together that it seems to us that there is a path to follow, which is to create large Franco-Italian and Italian-French international groups. And we hope that Italian entrepreneurs will put forward proposals so that we can not carry out this takeover bid but establish an agreement, an Italian participation with Lactalis, which, as Mr. SARKOZY mentioned, is the largest buyer of Parmalat products.

THE PRESIDENT -- Sir, Parmalat and Lactalis are two private groups, and President BERLUSCONI and I, as well as our two governments, believe in the market economy. France and Italy are two founding countries of Europe. And all of us, throughout our political lives, have repeated a creed: that we believe in the future of European groups. So, there will always be a period of tensions, because it is not so simple to reach an agreement, for the groups to come to an agreement; and what we have proposed, the two governments, is that to facilitate discussions around the private groups, one of our close collaborators on each side will do everything possible to try to bring the positions closer together. There you have it, that is exactly what we have decided. You say: "somewhat vague statements"; but Mr. BERLUSCONI is not the president of Parmalat, I am not the president of Lactalis, what do you want me to say? That we do the managers' work for them? We simply note that there are two groups that have sometimes different visions on this point. If we can try to bring them closer together, all the better, and we have both said that a Franco-Italian group is a positive objective for Italy, positive for France, and positive for Europe.

Finally, on Libya, I want to say one thing: contrary to what I sometimes read, we are optimistic. Why? Because the Libyan opposition is showing great courage, great mastery. And every day on the ground, we see them fighting with more effectiveness. And these are people who have lived through true martyrdom. And I do not recognize myself in the words "quagmire." So now, how long will this last? One cannot read tea leaves. Simply, we intend to allow the Libyan people to express their desire for freedom. And that is what will work, and that is what we are doing. And you know, those who are on the side of freedom always end up winning. But that is a great lesson from History.

QUESTION -- A question for Mr. SARKOZY. Exactly one year ago, you congratulated Italy for our country's decision to enter into nuclear energy, the decision to use French technology, that of the EPR, to create nuclear power plants in Italy. In light of Italy's decision to suspend this project, do you feel a certain disappointment? And now a question for Mr. BERLUSCONI. I wanted to ask him: in light of the agreement today regarding the requirement to create large Italian-French, Franco-Italian groups that are able to be competitive in the international market, do you think that an Italian provision against foreign raids should be taken into consideration?

MR. SILVIO BERLUSCONI -- I would also like to clarify the meaning and reason for the moratorium we have introduced regarding nuclear energy in Italy. We are fully convinced that nuclear energy is the future for the entire planet. We were the first in the world to discover the possibility of producing energy from the atom. It was an Italian. We were at the forefront in the construction of nuclear power plants in the 1970s. We know well what happened. Leftist environmentalism intervened, and Italy had to halt work on power plants that were almost completed. Since then, we have had to buy all the energy we consume from abroad. This represents a considerable cost that weighs on the entire economy and on all Italian households. The cost is around 30-40%, even 50% compared to the cost that households and businesses in France pay following the French decision to have built, if I am not mistaken, 60 nuclear power plants safely. It even seems to me that when a decision is made to build a power plant among the various communities, there is competition for the power plant to be built in that community, which clearly shows the deep conviction of French citizens in this regard. In Italy, this is not the case. The events in Japan, as shown by the surveys we conduct among public opinion, have frightened our citizens. If we had organized this referendum today, nuclear energy would not have been able to be realized for many years to come in Italy. The government wanted to introduce this moratorium to avoid nuclear energy at this moment, to clarify the situation in Japan, and so that in 2 or 3 years we could again have a public opinion that is aware of the need to return to safe nuclear energy. This Japanese power plant was built on land where no nuclear power plant construction was supposed to be planned. French power plants are so safe that they can even withstand a nuclear attack. And with France, we have signed many ENEL contracts with the French company. Contracts that are not canceled, that continue. We are in the process of deciding to advance several aspects of these contracts, for example, training, which is a very important aspect. So, that is the position of the Italian government, a position of common sense, not to have rejected for an unknown period the possibility of realizing what is, in my opinion, an inevitable destiny. This decision propels us further towards renewable energies that can reach percentages of the total energy needed that are of lesser importance. Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT -- Naturally, I do not have to judge the decision that the Italian government has made sovereignly, and we understand the reasons for it. But allow me to say two or three things to the Italian public opinion. The first is that the Chernobyl accident was a nuclear accident with a reactor that malfunctioned and was not installed according to safety rules. The tragedy of Fukushima is a tragedy related not to the earthquake, but to the tsunami. The Fukushima plant dates back to the 1970s, the earthquake was at level 9, the plant held up perfectly, and even the reactor stopped when the earthquake occurred. It was the tsunami, of incredible proportions, that ravaged the pumping systems and stopped the flow of water to cool both the fuel and the reactor. So, the lessons learned from Fukushima are not lessons learned about nuclear energy, they are lessons learned about tsunamis. Second remark: in France as in Italy, we do not have gas, we do not have oil. And thanks to a man, a visionary, General de Gaulle, France today is self-sufficient for 80% of its electricity. We have about sixty nuclear power plants that have been operating for nearly 50 years under safety conditions that make the French trust. But why? We did not only choose nuclear energy in France, we also chose renewable energies. But who can think that solar or wind energy will be enough to compensate for nuclear energy? We have all signed agreements to stop greenhouse gas emissions that create a hole in the ozone layer; nuclear energy does not produce CO2 or greenhouse gas emissions. And therefore, the real debate to be had is the debate on what level of nuclear safety. And France has recently lost -- we were talking about it with the Prime Minister -- contracts abroad to build power plants. Why did we lose them? Because our plants are more expensive because they are safer. And the real debate to be had, following what happened, is: what level of safety? And, dear Mr. President, we say this here because we are close to Italy, and the question of the safety of our plants is also a question for our neighbors. And by the way, a large meeting will be held in June in Paris of all the independent nuclear safety authorities to achieve the highest possible level.

I listened with great interest to what President BERLUSCONI said. Know that the day our Italian friends decide to return to nuclear energy, France will be a welcoming and friendly partner. That is what we want to simply say to Italy. Because all those who stir up fears forget one thing, which is that our compatriots, in Italy as in France, they want to be enlightened, they want to be heated, they want to have energy for their businesses. Look at the cost of fossil fuels today, look at the events happening all over the world, look at the price of Brent crude, which was around 125-126 this morning. When we are told: "we need to create jobs, we need to create growth," if there is no energy, how do we create them? So, it is not nuclear and nothing else, it is nuclear plus all renewable energies. That is the choice for us. It is the choice we are faced with. We respect the decision of the Italians and we remain truly willing, the day they decide, to work with you and, in any case, know that for all our plants we are at your disposal to answer all questions about nuclear safety with us. There are no other solutions than transparency. There you have it. And we say this to a friendly country and a neighboring country. We do not consider this to be our sovereignty. Of course, it is our sovereignty, but sharing information on safety is something we will share with you. Thank you all.

MR. SILVIO BERLUSCONI -- Thank you very much. I thank President SARKOZY, I thank Prime Minister FILLON, I thank all the ministers, both French and Italian. Thank you all, it is always a pleasure to have you here. I hope that this pleasure can be renewed several times. I believe that we will work well together, as we always have, taking into account the interests of our countries, of our peoples, and trying to make our democracy, our freedom something that can contribute to the wind of freedom and democracy that has blown over the southern shore of the Mediterranean, which we are closely following and to which we will try to provide significant assistance, including on the economic front, so that these peoples can know democracy, freedom, and, thereby, economic well-being.

Thank you all, thank you Nicolas.