Letter from Mr Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr Silvio Berlusconi, President of the Council of Ministers of the Italian Republic, addressed to Mr Herman Van Rompuy, President of the European Council, and Mr José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission, on a new partnership between the European Union and the countries of the Southern Mediterranean and on strengthened security within the Schengen area, 26 April 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

26 April 2011

Context
Sarkozy and Berlusconi jointly addressed EU Council and Commission presidents in April 2011, urging coordinated EU action on Mediterranean migration and Schengen security reform.
Main themes
Schengen area free movement, migration crisis in the Mediterranean, EU-Southern Mediterranean partnership, illegal immigration control, Frontex and border management, asylum system reform, solidarity among EU member states, readmission of undocumented migrants, temporary protection mechanisms, UNHCR and IOM cooperation, Eurodac database access, EU external border security
Duration
~11 min
38th percentile
Words
1,284
38th percentile
Sentences
49
32nd percentile
Readability
20
3rd percentile
Grade
17.0
89th percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
62nd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 43%41%
  • Geopolitical 41%39%
  • Ceremonial 9%8%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

49 sentences in 23 paragraphs

Mr. President,

For several months now, the pressures at the common external borders have had consequences for all the Member States of the European Union. The migratory situation in the Mediterranean could quickly turn into a genuine crisis that would affect the trust our citizens have in the free movement within the Schengen area. This free movement is a major achievement of European integration that our two countries are determined to preserve.

The work already underway must be realized and rapidly amplified. New measures also appear to be essential. The European Council in June must provide the political impetus needed to overcome obstacles and make concrete decisions in response to current difficulties. The European Union must, on the one hand, redefine its relationship with third countries, particularly those in the Southern Mediterranean, and on the other hand, fundamentally renovate its internal rules in this area.

I. A new partnership with third countries

We are convinced that the main priority for the European Union is to quickly find a comprehensive agreement with its Southern Mediterranean neighbors. The Union must provide significant, and if necessary, massive support to these countries, prioritizing those that have chosen the path of democracy.

In return, we are entitled to expect partner countries to engage in rapid and effective cooperation with the European Union and its Member States in the fight against illegal immigration. This cooperation must focus on managing their borders, with a possible role for Frontex to assist these countries in combating illegal departures and with European aid to support them in their fight against criminal networks. It must also concern the readmission of undocumented migrants.

Let us propose to our Southern Mediterranean partners a comprehensive and ambitious partnership, but let us not hesitate to make a concrete determination on their part to contribute to our efforts against illegal immigration a prerequisite and an intrinsic element of this partnership.

Furthermore, it is appropriate for Member States, with the increasing assistance of the European Union, to continue contributing to the development of protection programs already established by the remarkable actions of the UNHCR and IOM, for individuals requiring international protection or for those benefiting from return assistance. The European Union should also consider some form of facilitation of the mobility of people in the Mediterranean area, while excluding any automatic character.

II. A new solidarity among Member States

The massive influx of migrants, which particularly affects certain Member States, poses a challenge for all partners. This challenge must be met with the dual concern of not sending a misleading signal, so as not to create a pull effect, while at the same time offering maximum concrete solidarity to the most affected Member States.

In this spirit, financial solidarity mechanisms towards these States should be strengthened, particularly to facilitate their mobilization and to increase their amounts. If a massive influx of displaced persons from Libya were to occur, the EU should be able to implement, based on a pre-prepared operational plan, specific solidarity mechanisms for granting temporary protection to these displaced persons, taking into account the reception capacities of each partner as well as the efforts already made.

It is also fundamental that the EU establishes a common European asylum system. The instruments needed to finalize this system, including access for law enforcement to the Eurodac database for the purpose of combating organized crime, must be adopted by the end of 2012 under conditions that are sustainable for national asylum systems, which are already under significant pressure in several Member States, some of which are still far from having implemented the first wave of legislative instruments adopted a few years ago. The proposals presented must therefore find a new balance, more compatible with the management constraints of these systems.

In the perspective of achieving a common European asylum system, greater convergence in standards and practices should be supported as soon as possible, in order to discourage secondary movements, and to prevent abuses and misappropriations, so that individuals entitled to seek international protection can have their cases processed under good conditions and according to high standards, regardless of the Member State concerned. Asylum policy, which is a duty and a value of the EU, must not allow itself to become a receptacle for disguised irregular immigration. States facing the most acute difficulties in the field of asylum must receive priority support from the European Asylum Support Office to ensure the reception and processing of applications under appropriate conditions.

III. Enhanced security within the Schengen area

Strengthening the Frontex agency is a major imperative. In this perspective, the measures outlined in the conclusions of the JAI Council meeting held in Luxembourg on April 11, 2011, must be made operational immediately, where Frontex is invited to accelerate negotiations with countries in the region - particularly Tunisia - with a view to concluding operational working agreements and organizing joint patrol operations, in cooperation with the Tunisian authorities and in accordance with all relevant international conventions, particularly the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea ("Montego Bay Convention"). In accordance with the conclusions of the European Council, an agreement must be reached by June 2011 on the revision of the agency's regulation, going as far as possible in increasing its operational capacities. The agency could also open a specialized office in the Mediterranean and develop its surveillance and interception operations: its budget should be adjusted accordingly, particularly to preserve Erasmus-type programs for border guards. Furthermore, Frontex is intended to be the core of a European border guard system. In accordance with the invitation contained in the European Pact on Immigration and Asylum of October 2008, the time has come to lay the foundations for such a European system, starting for example with a better use of available resources from the External Borders Fund to establish a common border guard inspection system.

Enhanced governance of the Schengen area is clearly necessary: it must be based on stricter requirements and more effective tools in order to achieve greater collective discipline and cohesion in the levels of protection of the common external borders, including in view of the enlargement of the Schengen area.

A legislative amendment to the evaluation mechanism is necessary. However, the direction taken in the current legislative proposal is not sufficient. A more ambitious legislative package should be presented this year, based on the following principles:

- the evaluation procedure must continue to closely involve Member States, so as not to deprive itself of their expertise and to create the conditions for an increasingly trusting relationship among them;

- the Frontex agency, in close liaison with other competent agencies in the JAI area, should be the pivot of the coordination of this evaluation and inspection mechanism through the establishment of a pool of experts and evaluation teams, including the perspective of creating European inspectors, the conduct of missions, as well as the drafting of reports;

- examine the possibility of temporarily re-establishing internal border controls in the event of exceptional difficulties in managing the common external borders, under conditions to be defined.

Finally, the strengthening of the governance of the Schengen area must be subject to more structured political follow-up, for example by giving more visibility to discussions within the JAI Council on this subject and by organizing an annual debate within the European Council.

We are convinced that the European Union collectively has the means to strengthen its common area of freedom and security as it has been able to find responses to enhance its economic governance. This is vital for the trust of citizens in European integration. The next European Council must enable the necessary decisions to be made in this regard.

Please accept, Mr. President, the expression of our highest consideration.