Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. Thabo Mbeki, President of the Republic of South Africa, on Franco-South African and Franco-African relations, the situation of hostages held by the FARC in Colombia, and nuclear non-proliferation, Cape Town, February 28, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

28 February 2008 · Joint press conference of President Sarkozy and President Mbeki · Cape Town, South Africa

Context
Sarkozy held a joint press conference with South African President Mbeki in Cape Town on February 28, 2008, covering bilateral relations and global issues.
Main themes
Franco-South African bilateral relations, African crisis resolution, Darfur and Chad situation, nuclear non-proliferation and Iran sanctions, G8 reform and African representation, FARC hostages and Ingrid Betancourt, energy cooperation and electricity crisis, economic partnerships in Africa
Duration
~19 min
64th percentile
Words
2,298
64th percentile
Sentences
131
75th percentile
Readability
55
75th percentile
Grade
9.8
19th percentile
Syntax
2.79
21st percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
57th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

131 sentences in 28 paragraphs

MR. THABO MBEKI - We are particularly pleased with this visit as it confirms the quality of our relations, as you have seen with all the agreements that have just been signed. These agreements show that we are determined to deepen our relations both in the political sphere and in economic matters, in science and technology, energy, in the military domain, our bilateral relations as well as our relations with all other countries in the world.

I would like to express to Mr. President our satisfaction with the way you have always clearly and promptly demonstrated your ability to respond to our questions and requests. Our South African friends are all aware of the problem that arises here regarding electricity. I share with you our need to have engineers as soon as possible to help us overcome this problem. Mr. President, you responded immediately in a positive manner, which once again shows the quality of our relations.

We also discussed the situation that concerns both of us in Darfur, and we immediately agreed that we should act together to ensure the improvement of this situation. These are, I repeat, examples of the quality of our relations and the speed with which you are ready to respond to our requests.

In conclusion, I want to reiterate that I am convinced that your visit will allow us to consolidate the excellent bilateral relations between our two countries. It will help us to overcome the challenges we face here in South Africa, as well as across the entire African continent.

Once again, thank you. We know that we can count on you.

THE PRESIDENT - Thank you, Mr. President. Ladies and gentlemen, a few brief words. First, we conducted a very broad overview, President MBEKI and I. I must say that there is no difference in appreciation on any of the issues we have considered.

South Africa has become our primary economic partner in Africa. We have signed very important agreements in the energy sector, including a power plant for 1.4 billion euros, and starting next week, a team of engineers from EDF and Areva will travel to South Africa to help our South African friends deal with the electricity supply crisis. This, of course, is independent of the very significant tenders in which Areva, EDF, Bouygues, and Alstom will participate.

South Africa has become an absolutely essential partner in resolving African crises. President MBEKI conveyed to me a message from President BECHIR inviting us, France and South Africa, to go to Sudan in the context of the Darfur crisis and the situation in Chad. I willingly accepted, in line with the mediation proposal I made yesterday in N'Djamena to send a delegation to Sudan in the coming days alongside our South African friends.

France believes that the world needs South Africa to resolve the major crises of the world. And I repeat here in Cape Town that I find it utterly unbelievable that one could imagine resolving the major issues of the world without making room for a single African country, I think of the G8, for a single South American country, for India, for China, not to mention Mexico. I told President MBEKI that I was fully supportive of the G5's position, which wishes to have more than just a summit-ending lunch after three days of the G8 summit. I understand that we cannot change things immediately, but I ask that we make room for Africa. Naturally, for South Africa, even if it is not for me to designate, of course, the representative of Africa. But it happens that in the G5, the representative of Africa is South Africa.

In this regard, we discussed at length the situation in Iran. I told President Thabo MBEKI that we needed him, South Africa, to achieve unanimity on the third resolution providing for sanctions. I said that our attitude was not at all aggressive towards Iran, but that we needed to do something to avoid the worst. And that we needed an international consensus. And South Africa, which will preside over the Security Council, could play a decisive role.

QUESTION - (inaudible)

MR. THABO MBEKI - No, no arms deal has been discussed. That is a question that has not arisen.

QUESTION - (inaudible)

THE PRESIDENT - I apologized to the President for having a question somewhat outside of my trip, but which is due to urgency. I have heard the testimonies of the two released hostages, Mr. PEREZ and Gloria POLANCO. I want to use strong words, but that are true and just: these testimonies are damning. They are damning because of the cruelty and barbarism that raises the heart. The FARC must know and understand that the martyrdom they impose on Ingrid BETANCOURT is a martyrdom they inflict on France. In December, almost three months ago, I called on the guerrilla leader, Manuel MARULANDA, to release the hostages, and since then, there have been these releases, these six hostages returned to life. I thanked the FARC for that. I also called for our compatriot Ingrid BETANCOURT to be released. I want to renew that urgent call. Today I call on the FARC to release Ingrid BETANCOURT without delay. This is a matter of life or death. This is a matter of humanitarian urgency. They cannot let this woman die.

I also want to address President CHAVEZ, whose involvement and efforts have allowed four more hostages to be returned to life yesterday. I ask President CHAVEZ, as I told him on the phone just a few days ago, to use all his influence to save the life of Ingrid BETANCOURT. I heard his call to the FARC last night, and I relay it strongly. I spoke with him. And I am ready, as President CHAVEZ wishes, if it is the condition for her release, to go myself to the border of Venezuela and Colombia to fetch Ingrid BETANCOURT if that should be a condition set by the FARC.

France will remain mobilized until the last hostage is released. I personally commit to that. But the fate of Ingrid BETANCOURT, with whom I spoke to her daughter Mélanie on the phone last night, while I was flying between Chad and South Africa, where she expressed to me, and it is quite understandable, her anxiety, as she was distraught.

The fate of Ingrid is a matter of humanitarian gesture and not a humanitarian agreement. It is today very clearly a race against death that is underway. And everyone is facing their responsibilities. There will be those who have done everything to save Ingrid, and there will be those who will bear the responsibility for her death. We can no longer wait. France is committed to a humanitarian agreement once Ingrid BETANCOURT is free.

You understand, with all my apologies to President Thabo MBEKI, that I take the testimonies of the hostages extremely seriously. The situation of Ingrid BETANCOURT is deteriorating day by day. What would it have served to obtain proof of life if she loses her life in the process?

Now all good wills must come together. I hope everyone understands that we need President CHAVEZ as well. And I sincerely thank him for what he has done. I will have the opportunity to discuss this today with President URIBE. France will spare no effort. You know, it is both very distressing and very uplifting for me. Distressing because Ingrid is not free, but uplifting because at the same time, after five years of nothing happening, six hostages have been released. Proofs of life have arrived. We must manage to free Ingrid BETANCOURT.

QUESTION - This is a question directed at President MBEKI regarding the development of nuclear forces in Iran. South Africa's position has so far been that Iran has the right to develop peaceful nuclear energy. Is this still South Africa's position? What about France?

MR. THABO MBEKI - Our position remains unchanged once again. We are against the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction. But we agree that it is not about preventing a country from acquiring nuclear capabilities for peaceful purposes. We discussed this in the context of the new resolution that is to be adopted soon by the Security Council. We are on the same wavelength. We are determined to combat nuclear weapons, and we believe that we must address this effectively to reassure the whole world while respecting the right to the peaceful use of nuclear energy and fighting against the proliferation of nuclear weapons.

THE PRESIDENT - Dear Thabo MBEKI, that is exactly France's position. I have always asserted the right to possess civil nuclear energy for all the peoples of the world, which is the energy of the future. But here, we are facing a problem of military proliferation, and I say this in a country, South Africa, which in its time was one of the first to renounce military nuclear capabilities.

QUESTION - Mr. President, in implementing your new policy in Africa, are you considering either reducing or redeploying French military personnel on the continent?

QUESTION - I will address this question this afternoon before the Parliament of South Africa. And I will detail what I intend to propose to our partners, whom I have already contacted through discreet diplomacy. I will announce the renegotiation of all our defense agreements in Africa and the publication, in full transparency, of all these agreements. As you can see, this is a major turning point. I discussed it with President MBEKI. I am convinced that we cannot continue with agreements that date back to the 1960s. We are in the 21st century. France wants to be even more present in Africa. But it wants to be present in a different way. Since I understood that you were referring to my speech in Dakar, to the letter that President MBEKI sent me, I want to tell President MBEKI that I was very touched, very sensitive to his appreciation, not because he agreed with me, but because he took the trouble to read the speech. Madam LOISON, it is so pleasant when one takes the trouble to read speeches. I do not say this at all for you. I say it just like that. And since then, by the way, President MBEKI and I have continued this discussion on what the new relationship between France and Africa should be. This owes much to the discussions we have had. I am aware that this is a change. It is an important change. All the heads of state concerned have been informed. But I will say it in more detail, it is more courteous for the President in the context of my speech this afternoon where I will make other proposals elsewhere.

MR. THABO MBEKI - I remain convinced, and I repeat here that President SARKOZY's presentation in Dakar raised a number of extremely important questions, notably that Africa must rise to the challenge of defining its own future, that the rest of the world must respect the choice that Africa will make, but that it is up to Africa to determine its own future.

Indeed, to return to President SARKOZY's first speech in Dakar, he mentioned that there are all these processes, globalization, the market. And to ensure that all this does not go against Africa's interests, Africa must not think that it is an act of God and that Africans can do nothing to remedy the injustices possibly caused by globalization. But on the contrary, it is up to Africa to intervene to ensure that these processes, the market, globalization, benefit the African continent to remedy the problems of poverty. It is up to Africa not to let anyone else define its reaction to globalization, but to decide how to ensure that it leads to results that allow Africa to rectify the injustices of the past. In this, he stated that France was its ally. And we believe that this is extremely important. I repeat, it is extremely important for Africa to understand how much we need to use our capacity to intervene to carry out our development policies to fight against poverty. But it seems to me that this whole debate that was initiated by the Dakar speech is absolutely essential, and we must ensure its follow-up.

In our exchanges with President SARKOZY, we also discussed the ongoing controversy between the European Commission and the ACP countries regarding the economic partnership agreements. This is directly relevant, indeed. How can we fight against poverty! The problems posed by the economic partnership agreements actually stem from what these agreements are based on, namely the Cotonou Agreement. They are based on a number of concepts such as liberalization, deregulation which, at the time of the Cotonou Agreement, were imposed on Africa if they were not respected. It was simply sacrilege. Well, that is what is being called into question and needs to be discussed again.

To conclude, I am very pleased, Mr. President, to have heard you say that you will speak during your speech to Parliament this afternoon about France's military agreements and that you will mention the possibility of reviewing and publishing them. I look forward to listening, because I indeed think that this is part of the continuation of the decolonization process in Africa. I also want to say that we have indeed been following what is happening in Colombia, and the fate of Ingrid BETANCOURT seems extremely important to us as well. We believe it is extremely important for the FARC to release the hostages. In the past, Archbishop Desmond TUTU also intervened for this same purpose, but unfortunately to no avail. We are pleased to see that there has been some progress in this regard. Like you, we give our full support to President URIBE.