Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mrs. Angela Merkel, Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany, notably on the action of the European Union in response to the budget deficit of Greece, in Brussels on February 11, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

11 February 2010 · Joint press conference of Nicolas Sarkozy and Angela Merkel on EU action regarding Greece's budget deficit · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy and Merkel addressed a joint press conference in Brussels on February 11, 2010, following EU talks on Greece's budget deficit and eurozone stability.
Main themes
Eurozone stability, Greek budget deficit crisis, EU economic governance, Franco-German cooperation, EU 2020 growth strategy, financial market reform, sustainable development, climate change, monetary architecture, G20 presidency, European coordination
Duration
~23 min
71st percentile
Words
2,705
71st percentile
Sentences
144
79th percentile
Readability
55
76th percentile
Grade
10.2
22nd percentile
Syntax
2.83
26th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

144 sentences in 37 paragraphs

We have essentially worked on three themes. On the one hand, the stability of the eurozone, secondly a new growth strategy, and we have also discussed international issues, and I will emphasize the first two points.

First of all, we all know the problems that arise in the European monetary union with Greece, and today we have sent a very clear political signal with the Greek government.

Firstly, the European Central Bank and the Commission consider that the Greek commitment to reduce the deficit by 4% of GDP is sufficient and is a good thing. On the other hand, the Greek Prime Minister has clearly stated that Greece will do everything in its power to implement this positive assessment from the Commission and the European Central Bank. There will be further discussions. In March, we will conduct a new joint assessment. And if Greece can undertake additional measures, that is obviously a good thing.

All eurozone member states assert that they are bound by the stability pact. The member states support this process, accompany this process. We know our responsibility for the stability of the eurozone. We are part of the same whole, but there are rules, and therefore it was important for Greece to clearly state today that it is not asking us for money. We have discussed what needs to be done, important issues to reach a common position very quickly. The 24 member states quickly reached a common proposal on this matter.

Second point: France and Germany have been intensively preparing for the new European Union 2020 strategy since the Franco-German ministerial council last week.

We say that the European Union must cooperate better. In the aftermath of the crisis, we must learn the lessons. This means, first of all, that as heads of state and government, we see ourselves as an economic government of the 27. We need to better coordinate ourselves and also have a more homogeneous and effective position in relation to the outside world. This means that we, France and Germany, have brought this idea forward.

We are betting on a modern concept of growth, based on sustainable development, on security that takes into account the new demographics of the member states. The President of the Commission and the President of the Council have clearly stated the real situation. We agree to focus on a small number of points, but these will need to be implemented together. Credibility is the most important thing for a European economic government. France and Germany have clearly shown that we are pursuing very ambitious goals this year since France will take the presidency of the G20. We will need a new monetary architecture, a new architecture of financial markets adapted to the 21st century. It is up to Europe to be the driving force behind this. And we will also undertake extremely ambitious efforts in the fight against climate change.

And that is why we are here together before you. We want to lend our full support to the Commission and the Council, we who are two major countries of the European Union. We have a duty to contribute to closer European coordination because from the issue of raw material prices to climate protection, no country can alone assume its commitments and achieve its objectives. We are linked, we are together, and France and Germany intend to be the driving force that advances the entire process.

THE PRESIDENT - I will be very brief because naturally, I fully share what the Chancellor has just said. We have been working hard for several days. Our positions are absolutely common. We said at the Franco-German Summit that we wanted to ensure our responsibilities. We affirmed our support for Greece, the credibility we bring to the commitments of the Greek government. We say this in perfect agreement with the Commission and the European Central Bank. We have taken note - and this is very important - of the Greek government's commitment to do more to meet the 4% deficit reduction if necessary. We have established a "monitoring," a monthly oversight of the commitments made by Greece and the evolution of the situation. The first review will take place in March, and it is under these conditions that we have decided on the principle of support for Greece, for its plan and its objectives. Naturally, Germany and France are hand in hand in the face of this situation.

Secondly, what has happened is very important because I have not heard a single country contest the necessity of the economic government of Europe that we proposed with the Chancellor. Everyone agreed. This is one of the lessons of the crisis; there is a need for an economic government of Europe. This economic government is the European Council of heads of state and government of 27. It is a reality.

So the economic government means that within this Council we will evaluate the situation, we will coordinate policies, we will organize initiatives; this is something of extreme importance that is the subject of consensus around the table.

Thirdly, there is also consensus for all of Europe to take strong positions on issues we discussed with Madame MERKEL: the reform of the international monetary system, the aftermath of the unsatisfactory Copenhagen meeting, with the Bonn meeting being prepared by the Chancellor, the issue of the volatility of raw material prices. On all these issues, we will work together. Of course, we want Europe to take positions, but within the framework of the G20 presidency, hand in hand with the Chancellor, we will make proposals, particularly on the monetary issue.

So, ladies and gentlemen, what we said at the Franco-German Summit was a first step today in Brussels, and I believe we can both say that Herman VAN ROMPUY's initiative to hold this informal Council was excellent. And I must also say that we worked with him in total confidence and in an excellent atmosphere.

QUESTION - On Greece, you have just adopted a political declaration. What makes you think that this political declaration will be enough to discourage speculators, and if that is not the case, are France and Germany ready to open their wallets to help Greece?

MADAM ANGELA MERKEL - In the past, throughout the economic crisis, we have regularly seen how important political trust is. When we granted guarantees in our national systems, it had a very significant impact. What we are saying today is that, first, the rules must be respected, but Greece is one of us. On the other hand, we need real reliability in what Greece does, reliability towards the member states, the Commission, the European Central Bank, taking into account the positions of the IMF. We need to regain this reliability to restore real trust at the market level.

Our contribution, if I speak of France and Germany, our contribution is a weight that is of considerable importance for the markets. At the same time, there is the willingness of the Greek Prime Minister to make all the necessary efforts. And to do what the Commission and the European Central Bank deem necessary. These are significant advances that will allow for trust.

THE PRESIDENT - The question that arose was: is Greece ready to do more to scrupulously meet the 4% target? The answer is yes. It is clear, it is unambiguous, and it is a courageous gesture from the Greek Prime Minister.

Second question: do the ECB, the Commission, and the member states share the same analysis regarding the seriousness of this commitment? The answer is yes.

Third question: is there solidarity towards Greece within the eurozone and more broadly within Europe? The answer is again yes.

As for the modalities, we will not specify them, and we will not go into details. We have provided three unambiguous answers, and I find the political declaration quite precise. And when there was the banking crisis, Madame MERKEL and I had to manage a complex situation under the same conditions - I still remember the Élysée summit. The questions that were raised received answers that are unambiguous. For the rest, we stick to this response.

QUESTION - I believe that the rules prohibit granting financial aid to Greece. I believe that the German Constitutional Court poses additional obstacles. Nevertheless, in the penultimate paragraph of your declaration, you do not exclude financial aid. Why this possible option?

MADAM ANGELA MERKEL - No, we made a completely political declaration. We say that the European Union stands by Greece - and that is my priority, and at the same time, it is necessary for Greece to implement its program, and that is an extremely strong signal. And what is very important to me is that the ECB and the Commission clearly set the lines, the directions that all heads of state and government support. As for the rest, political support can also take the following form: we encourage Greece, we show that other countries respect their stability criteria, which creates a strong bloc even if one of the actors is a bit weakened for a transitional period.

QUESTION - It seems that Mr. TRICHET this morning insisted a lot on strict compliance with the Lisbon Treaty. Does that mean that there will be no intervention at all from the European Central Bank if Greece's problems continue? And, still, would you not want to give us some additional elements on the concrete measures considered if there are problems tomorrow? For example, the repurchase of Greek bonds by public or semi-public banks, modulations depending on the weight of the interventions of the countries...

THE PRESIDENT - I fear that you have not understood what we said. Why? This is a serious matter that we have treated seriously, together, each in their role. The European Central Bank, the stable President, the President of the Commission, and all the states. We are sending a very clear signal. If there were to be other events, perhaps we will have the opportunity to meet you and answer other questions. Greece is part of the eurozone, Greece is part of Europe, we support Greece. And, moreover, the Greek Prime Minister has made additional commitments, and I believe that everyone can understand that we are sticking to this declaration, which is both strong, precise, and unambiguous. And we have no interest and no intention to favor any more or less interested movement in this matter. We had work to do, we did it. The positions to take, we took them.

MADAM ANGELA MERKEL - It is extremely important - and this is what we learned in the economic crisis - to talk about the problems that arise, and Greece has not asked for any financial support. Greece has said: "we are ready to implement our program, and we are ready to submit the execution of our program to the positive judgment of the ECB and the Commission." And that is the best possible message for the euro today. It is extremely important because the whole world is watching this, and we are very grateful to the Greek Prime Minister.

QUESTION - Madam Chancellor, Mr. President, after the meeting of the European Socialist Party yesterday, one might get the impression that some may have imagined more concrete financial commitments towards the Greeks. Has there been any progress in this sense from the heads of state and government, proposals in this sense, or is it an option possible in the longer term, beyond March, if what Greece does is not sufficient?

THE PRESIDENT - There will be monitoring every month. The next one in March. At that time, we will examine the situation. But the Chancellor has said something important: Greece has not asked for financial aid. There you go. The words are important; they have meaning.

So we have made a commitment to support, solidarity, rigor, and transparency on the Greek side. Support and solidarity on the European side; rigor and transparency on the Greek side. That is what has been decided. For the rest, we will naturally remain in contact. We do not even need monthly monitoring, but we will remain in contact.

If there is a last question?

QUESTION - Excuse me for coming back to this, I believe I did not understand well either. I have the impression that we find ourselves in the same situation as a year ago, during the banking crisis, that is to say, you started with political statements and that proved insufficient, and each state had to make specific financial commitments, guarantees to the banks. Last year, there was no European bank that immediately asked for money. Now, what are your concrete tools to help Greece if in two months it cannot refinance itself in the markets?

And a question to Mrs. MERKEL, do you confirm that the Bundestag, in a legal study, states that a bilateral loan from Germany is contrary to the European treaty?

THE PRESIDENT - If obviously everyone asks the same question in their language, I fear to bore the audience with the same answer. However, Mr. Leparmentier brings a new idea, you tell us: "we are managing this as we managed the banks a year ago." Allow me to tell you that it was not managed so badly, since the whole world considered that the European support plan for the banks was relevant, that there was only one, unlike other countries that announced three successively and that we managed to react in time. Our role is not to create agitation, is not to encourage speculation, and is not to project ourselves into increasingly difficult scenarios. Our role is to make the decisions that are expected of us at the moment they arise, without any ambiguity. Greece is not alone, and Greece is determined to make the efforts that are asked of it. This is the response of the European Union, it is an extremely strong response.

As for the banks, we said that we would not let any saver be ruined and that we would not do what was done with Lehman Brothers, that we would not let anyone fall. And then the modalities, we each analyzed according to the constraints of our countries as events unfolded, but on principle, I affirm that we have respected the principle that was established at the beginning of the crisis. There is a principle here. As for the modalities, we reserve the right to see the developments to calibrate them. Let’s say there is a strategy, it is the one we have set, and there will be a tactic depending on the events. The strategy is clear and it is this strategy that the markets, the operators, and the various stakeholders must understand.

MRS. ANGELA MERKEL - First of all, in the situation we find ourselves in currently, there is something very specific that has been established, there are two things and the best possibility is indisputable, the best option is for Greece to meet its commitments and for the markets to be convinced that these commitments will actually be followed by effects. And our political support for Greece means today that we want to further strengthen this approach. And at the same time, Greece has done the most important thing for me regarding the markets, very specifically Greece has stated: "-4%", ECB-Commission-Greece say -4% and the ECB and the Commission can monthly, as the President of the Republic said, verify if the results are there, if these -4% are there. And there we reach the most important result, which is that the markets will have confidence in the implementation of the program by Greece. That is the first point.

On the second point you mentioned, certainly, we must always operate within the framework of the treaties, that is why we emphasized the necessity for Greece to make its contribution and that the European Union and the Eurogroup would provide all their support for savings banks or for banks. We did not give money to all the banks, we established a general guarantee for citizens, which reassured the markets without enacting a law and making an ad hoc measure for each particular bank.

THE PRESIDENT - Thank you all.

MRS. ANGELA MERKEL - Thank you.