Joint press conference of Mr Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, Mr Hans-Gert Pöttering, President of the European Parliament, and Mr José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission, notably on the question of Tibet, the extradition of Marina Petrella to Italy, the future of the Lisbon Treaty, Colonel Gaddafi's visit to France, the Union for the Mediterranean and relations between the European Union and Serbia, in Strasbourg on 10 July 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

10 July 2008 · Joint press conference of the President of the Republic, the President of the European Parliament and the President of the European Commission

Context
Sarkozy addressed a joint press conference with EU Parliament and Commission presidents in Strasbourg on July 10, 2008, during France's EU Council presidency.
Main themes
Lisbon Treaty and European integration, Tibet and human rights, France's EU Council presidency, Beijing Olympics and China relations, Dalai Lama meeting, European Parliament relations, energy-climate package, European immigration pact, EU enlargement and Serbia, Union for the Mediterranean, Gaddafi visit to France
Duration
~37 min
88th percentile
Words
4,420
88th percentile
Sentences
250
93rd percentile
Readability
59
85th percentile
Grade
9.1
12th percentile
Syntax
2.84
27th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
32nd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

250 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Mr. PÖTTERING will give a brief introduction and then we will go directly to the questions.

Mr. PÖTTERING - I would simply like to welcome both Presidents, the President of the European Council, Mr. Nicolas SARKOZY, and the President of the Commission, Mr. José Manuel BARROSO. For my part, I will say that it has been 29 years since I became a member of this European Parliament, and this was one of the most remarkable meetings. Never before have I seen a President of the Council address all issues. He spoke with great passion and great competence. He answered all the Members of Parliament regardless of their political affiliation. He responded, and it was an hour of glory, an important hour for the important Parliament, and I would like to warmly thank President Nicolas SARKOZY.

He has already promised that he will come to see us, to visit us as often as we call upon him, and we look forward to seeing him again. Thank you.

QUESTION - A question about Tibet, which is also a question about Europe since President SARKOZY will be in Beijing on the evening of August 8. Mr. President, I would like to know if France has imposed silence on the Tibetan issue or if it has been asked to respect silence on the Tibetan issue, and if that is not the case, do you plan to meet the Dalai Lama before the end of autumn?

THE PRESIDENT - I believe I understand that this question is directed at me. Listen, I have answered, I believe, both Mr. WATSON and Mr. COHN-BENDIT, that nothing has been imposed on France. France imposes nothing, and there is absolutely nothing to impose on it. There is, moreover, a great consensus among everyone to defend and embody human rights. There is a great consensus around the idea that China has a particular responsibility for stability and peace in the world. We may temporarily diverge on the best way to achieve these objectives. I found the remarks of the Chinese Ambassador in France particularly clumsy, and frankly, inappropriate. Bernard KOUCHNER made this known to him at my request, and I thank Bernard KOUCHNER. He has since issued a statement explaining that no conditions were imposed. Moreover, the statement from the Chinese Ambassador did not correspond at all to the conversation I had with President JINTAO. President HU JINTAO would not have tolerated France imposing conditions, and I do not think the Chinese President can tolerate or imagine that France could accept conditions. The choice I make is a choice of conviction. It would be a great problem in the world if China were to close itself off, retreating into an exacerbated nationalism, a great mistake. I do not judge those who have a different position. I have contacted all heads of state and government to ensure that this was the position of everyone. I know the position, I respect it, and I appreciate it, of President PÖTTERING, but the group leaders in the European Parliament themselves are very divided. President SCHULZ strongly supports, on behalf of the European Socialist Group, my decision to go. As for the rest, I will not let anyone dictate my meeting agenda, and when asked whether it would be forbidden to discuss with a Nobel Peace Prize winner, I wonder who could possibly forbid such a thing. For the rest, I will have the opportunity to take other initiatives, and I will communicate them to you in due course. Everyone knows my position; it has not varied one iota.

QUESTION - Mr. President, after the referendum in France, in the Netherlands, and now in Ireland, there is this debate about bringing Europe closer to citizens. We have heard many statements. Can you give us concrete objectives that you want to achieve during your Presidency to send a concrete signal of the openness you want to show towards citizens who do not like Europe as it is today, especially in light of the renewal of the European Commission and the European Parliament next year? Do you think that European governments should appoint more representative people for this new path of Europe towards citizens? President SCHULZ has called on you and made an appeal to Mr. BERLUSCONI regarding the reminder of human rights. Do you intend to do so or not?

THE PRESIDENT - But I am not going to repeat what I have said both in my introductory remarks and in my responses to questions. It is not a question of personality; it is a question of results. President PÖTTERING and President BARROSO are mobilized around the same objective. If, in six months, we manage to make commitments on the energy-climate package and on the European immigration pact, it will be the best response to those who denounce the immobility of Europe. It is not a question of having other representatives. I do not hide from you, sir, that it is very difficult. These are extremely ambitious objectives. Moreover, one of the speakers in the European Parliament rightly said that the problem would not come from the European Parliament but much more from the attitude of certain member state governments. This is a question I am working on a lot.

I do not think we can advance things in Europe by lecturing one another. You Italians know how close I am to Italy. It is a matter of taste. You Italians have sometimes reproached France, not without reason, for lecturing everyone without applying it to itself. Everyone calls for a modest Presidency from me, even the most immodest. Everyone calls for a non-arrogant Presidency from me, even the most arrogant. And I am told: "You will start by explaining to the Italians who elected Mr. BERLUSCONI that what they are doing is not right."

I would like to say that Mr. BERLUSCONI has been elected three times in Italy, not once, three times. It is not me who chose him; it is you, the Italians. You chose him with a participation rate of over 80%. In a result, whatever the great quality of Mr. Romano PRODI, with whom I share a love of cycling - for those who might think that my closeness to Italy is only due to my wife, there are other very important reasons - it is you who chose him. Let the Italian government do what it has to do. The best way to move beyond national debates on immigration is to create a European pact on immigration. However, it is true that I have intervened in the Italian debate while respecting the Italian justice system. Listen, the Italian justice system has been asking for years for the extradition of people who have been convicted in Italy. It is a deeply European act that I am undertaking, which was not in the French tradition. The Italian justice system, the justice of a democratic country, asks France to return someone who is accused of a crime and who has been tried and convicted in that country. The Italian justice system opposed a perfectly illegitimate refusal from a legal standpoint. I am not talking politics but from a legal standpoint. I have questioned the French judicial authorities. They tell me that extradition is necessary. I am naturally talking about Ms. PETRELLA.

I find a phenomenal contradiction between all those who call on me to respect the independence of justice, European institutions, and who would be very happy for me to violate the independent Italian justice and the independent French justice. However, I signed, as of this morning, a letter that I addressed to the President of the Council of Ministers, Mr. BERLUSCONI, and to the President of the Italian Republic, asking for clemency, forgiveness for Ms. PETRELLA. That is my only contribution and my only interference in the Italian political debate. I do not intend to make any other, let everyone conduct their own debate. You know, I think that if we did that, we would actually hinder Europe because it greatly annoys Europeans to see European authorities come and lecture citizens. Let Italy resolve its political problems; that is democracy. I would not appreciate it if someone were to interfere in the French debate outside of a subject that does not concern, it seems to me, European authorities. That is my answer.

QUESTION - Mr. President, it is about the anti-missile shield that the Americans plan to install in Poland, Lithuania, or the Czech Republic. You have made defense one of your priorities. You know very well that this irritates our Russian neighbors. What do you think of this installation? Do you think the European Union should get involved? How should the European Union get involved?

THE PRESIDENT - First, there will be a very important summit that we will lead with President BARROSO. It is the summit with Russia. We have also discussed this with Mr. MEDVEDEV in Japan. I am actually interested in President MEDVEDEV's proposal for a security policy that would extend from Vancouver to Vladivostok. This is a subject that needs to be explored. But anything that will help to ease relations between Russia and the European Union should be encouraged. Allow me to say that I find it very encouraging that the Russian President is making this proposal when just a few months ago, we saw Russian bombers with nuclear weapons circling the planet. I see a great progress.

Regarding the anti-missile shield issue. I would first like to say that each country has the right to freely and sovereignly decide on the installation of military facilities on its own soil. When General de GAULLE decided that the Americans would leave French soil, he would not have accepted that our other European partners had a say in the matter. I do not see on what grounds France, so attached to its independence of decision, should start telling the Poles or the Czechs: "be careful, don't do it."

The third element, more political. I would like to say that after recalling the independence and sovereignty of each, I would like this type of decision to at least be the subject of consultation and discussion among us, which would allow us to understand the reasons of each and lead everyone towards a common objective. That is the response I can give, in any case, as the current President of the Council, which leads me to speak as collectively as possible and thus to dilute the content of the response to such a pertinent question.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you have said several times that you do not intend to force the hand of the Irish on Lisbon, but obviously, a solution must be found. What can you say to the Irish to convince them that you will respect their vote?

THE PRESIDENT - We have discussed this with President BARROSO and President PÖTTERING. I will not surprise you by saying that we have started working on this. But it would be perfectly clumsy to reveal the content of a possible initiative that we might take. Why would it be clumsy? Because it would be clumsy not to take into account what the Irish say and think, particularly their government. I also think it would be very important for the Irish government, at some point, to formulate a number of proposals itself and for the Council to be able to respond to them after discussing them with President PÖTTERING and President BARROSO. I do not think the situation is completely blocked. We can provide very precise answers, but the time is not yet right. This moment for the method to get out of it and for the solution lies roughly between the October Council and the December Council. Will we be ready in October on our side, President BARROSO? Yes. Will the Irish be ready? I do not know. Why then in December? Because I would still like us to put something on the table, not because it is the end of the French Presidency, but because in June there are European elections. It seems to me that it would not be too early to tell Europeans in December: "here are the conditions and under what regime you will be able to vote six months later."

QUESTION - Mr. President Nicolas SARKOZY, you said earlier that you would speak when you go to China, that you would say things regarding human rights. I would like to know if you can reveal a little bit of the content of these remarks? You spoke of the remarks of the Chinese ambassador as clumsy and inappropriate. Should they be considered as threats, as a threat?

And I wanted to know if there is not a contradiction between the fact that France received Mr. KADHAFI as it did a few months ago and at the same time extradites Marina PETRELLA to Italy, since this is an argument regularly raised by the defenders of Marina PETRELLA who do not understand how one can receive Mr. KADHAFI on French soil as we did and extradite Marina PETRELLA to Italy. Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - I must say that I have difficulty seeing the connection between Ms. PETRELLA and Mr. KADHAFI, unless there is a family link that you could indicate to me, certainly. I received Mr. KADHAFI, and I do not regret it. I was not the only one, by the way. Our Spanish friends received him. King Juan CARLOS, who has some credibility in matters of democracy and human rights, received him. Why did I receive Mr. KADHAFI? For a simple reason: I am an honest man who respects his word. I had told Mr. KADHAFI that if the unfortunate six Bulgarian nurses and the Palestinian doctor were released, after 8 and a half years of hell, then I would receive President KADHAFI. I had told President BARROSO. We conducted this negotiation hand in hand, and he can testify to that himself. Yes, I had given my word, and I kept it. And let me tell you that, for 8 and a half years, these unfortunate nurses would have been very happy if someone had taken more care of them. I was very happy to show that human rights, for France, were not just empty words, but realities.

Secondly, regarding Ms. PETRELLA. To conclude, I do not know if Ms. PETRELLA's lawyer really wants to resolve Ms. PETRELLA's problem or if he wants to do politics? But I find these attacks against the one who is currently obtaining the right of pardon for her particularly inappropriate. You can tell him on my behalf that, under Italian law, and law matters, to have the right to pardon and grace in Italy, one must repent. Ms. PETRELLA should reflect on this. Law matters. She was involved in a murder in 1992. Those were horrible years for Italy. We need to turn the page. To turn the page, for there to be forgiveness, there must also be repentance. Ms. PETRELLA's lawyers do not respect human rights by using the distress of a woman who is currently imprisoned.

Thirdly. I said that the remarks of the Chinese ambassador were clumsy, were inappropriate. I add that they gave the impression of a brutality that I do not accept. He apologized, the incident is closed.

Fourthly. I will go to China with my freedom of speech. I will speak, in the way I deem appropriate, with the Chinese President. I have also asked Daniel COHN-BENDIT to work with Bernard KOUCHNER and me on a list. I believe I was the first head of state, in Beijing, with the Chinese President by my side, to turn to him and say: "A great nation like yours cannot continue with the death penalty." Few have said that. So, Madam PULVAR, I know you trust me, you can continue, I will not disappoint you.

QUESTION - You said during the debates in the hemicycle that all heads of state would be at the Paris Summit, but if I understood correctly, Mr. KADHAFI will not be there...

THE PRESIDENT - ... Oh pardon, Sir, with the permission of my colleagues. Look how difficult this is. Six months ago, I was very wrong, a great scandal, to invite Colonel KADHAFI. There are 43 heads of state and government that we have invited with Bernard KOUCHNER. He will be represented, he will not be there. I am being asked to justify myself and explain. Honestly, I have come to terms with it.

QUESTION - That is not it, Mr. President, but that is already the first half of the question, thank you. Mr. KADHAFI said yesterday that these proposals you have on the European and Mediterranean Union are a return to colonialism, the Roman Empire, apparently. Do you have any thoughts on that?

THE PRESIDENT - You know, I believe that one must have a certain experience with President KADHAFI, a bit of perspective on his statements and the political aspect of some of them. Regardless of my ties with Italy, which I claim, I do not intend to restore the Roman Empire. In any case, that is not in the draft declaration of the Union for the Mediterranean Summit, as I know it.

On the other hand, I would like to say how moving it is for us, and I say this in front of President PÖTTERING who will be there and who will speak, and in front of President BARROSO who will be there and who will speak: for us who are convinced Europeans, until now Europe in the Near and Middle East has been a lot of money, a lot of means, and, nevertheless, a thin political weight, to say the least insignificant compared to the weight of the United States. Do you realize what it is for convinced Europeans, like Mr. PÖTTERING, like Mr. BARROSO or Mr. KOUCHNER or me, to see Arab heads of state at the same table as the Israeli Prime Minister in a European capital?

For those who love Europe and believe in Europe and want peace, do you think it is not something moving for me to see the Syrian President say what he said in a major French newspaper and, I hope, we will be able to record a number of progress. Mr. BOUTEFLIKA will be there, that is not nothing. Mr. ERDOGAN, whom I spoke to on the phone from Japan, will be there. You know the disagreement I have with Mr. ERDOGAN. Well, Turkey will be there, because Turkey is a very great nation. Frankly, it is a day and night job for us, the Union for the Mediterranean. I spoke about it during the presidential campaign in a speech in Toulon. It is something that is extremely close to my heart, and for me, the presence of all these European and Mediterranean heads of state in Paris, on behalf of Europe and the Mediterranean, is something overwhelming and it is the best news for peace in the Near East, the best news.

The United States will have a new President in a few months. He will take his place, but who could blame the current President of the European Union for doing everything for peace in the world?

Mr. PÖTTERING - An observation from me - and I think I express the opinion of the European Parliament here - I am proud, on behalf of the European Parliament, to note that regarding the Barcelona process, the Union for the Mediterranean, in this process, our three institutions, the Commission, the Council represented by President SARKOZY, by President BARROSO, our three institutions have had truly excellent cooperation. For the Barcelona process, there is a parliamentary assembly, Euromed, and as President of the European Parliament, I have been President of this assembly for a year since March of this year. Euromed will play a very important role within what we call the Union for the Mediterranean. And we want to strengthen parliamentarism. In the final document, this parliamentary role will be highlighted, emphasized, and, with others, we want to be a driving force, and I would like to warmly thank the two institutions, the Council and the Commission, for allowing us to choose this common voice. The Parliament will ensure that these words are followed by concrete actions in this political dialogue on the economy, on the environment, on transport, on cultural dialogue, on exchanges between human beings, etc. What President SARKOZY said about the Middle East, it is the only assembly where Israelis and Palestinians see each other around a table, and we want to lend our support to this initiative.

QUESTION - I heard you talk about justice, the importance of justice, the importance of remorse, the respect for law. Earlier, I also heard you talk about the Balkans, saying that the Balkans have their place in the European Union and that they should join soon. I am surprised not to hear you talk about law and justice regarding the Balkans because in Serbia, there is a man who has been mocking justice for 13 years now, named General MLADIC, and another named Radovan KARADZIC. Do you not think it is time for these people to be in prison, at the Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, to be tried for this as a sine qua non condition for Serbia to join the Union? Will you use your Presidency to advance this file?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, you are absolutely right about the necessity for these people to answer for their actions. But, after all, the government - I do not know if we can call it pro-European, well, as opposed to those it defeated - this government has just been established. They won by a narrow margin. Serbia has faced many trials over the last ten or fifteen years. We have played a major role in helping the Serbs make the choice for democracy, and we will continue to do so. But, believe me, the will to send a positive message to Serbia, about the possibility for it, one day, to join the European family is essential if we want peace. So, there will be conditions for that, and among those conditions, those that the legitimate government of Serbia delivers to the International Criminal Tribunal the people who are on this territory. But the institutions are there. I have no doubt that they will implement this policy, but there is no contradiction with what I said. We need stability in the Balkans. And who better than the enlarged European Union could respond to this stability and this need? But, conversely, imagine if we said: "Croatia, okay, it's done by 2011. Bosnia-Herzegovina, Macedonia, no problem, but we make an exception for Serbia." In that case, Sir, in your opinion, are we strengthening exacerbated nationalism or are we strengthening the camp of democrats? I believe we must strengthen the camp of democrats. Serbia will have an appointment with its European and international obligations. We will not yield on that. Given all that Serbia has experienced, given what is happening in Kosovo, given all the difficulties we have to manage, I think things are getting better, and I maintain that it was a victory for the European Union. I remember the fear we had around the table of heads of state and government about the situation in Kosovo. We feared a divided Europe; it was not divided. We feared terrifying confrontations between Kosovars and the Serbian minority. I do not say that it is going well, but the progress has been astonishing. The European Union has managed to react with one voice. We will not show weakness towards criminals, those accused of crimes against humanity in Serbia, but I think we must extend a hand to the Serbian people so that they too do not take refuge in vengeful nationalism. And I link my answer to that of China. Be careful with peoples. It is not just a question of leaders; it is a question of these peoples. It is in our interest, and therefore I will not have a double standard, at least for my part. Thank you.

QUESTION - I have a question for the three presidents. You are all three members of the EPP. Last week, a prominent member of your party proposed that in April next year, a candidate for the Presidency of the Commission be proposed. What do you think about that?

THE PRESIDENT - If the question is whether I have a candidate, the answer is yes. If the answer is whether he is at the same table as me, the answer is also yes.

Mr. PÖTTERING - I also had a candidate; he is in the room. Mr. BARROSO - It is of course a decision to be made by the different political parties, especially by the EPP. There is just one thing I would like to tell you, and I mentioned it earlier in the plenary session. European democracy is a democracy that has several dimensions: the national dimension and the European dimension. It must be understood that we are in a different system, in an integrated political system as is the case in France, Germany, Portugal, or any other country here. Therefore, we must see what the conditions are for achieving a European democracy, let’s say to have ideological political divides without undermining European unity. That is my position. Moreover, I have always supported it, even within the EPP of which I am a part. Different political forces must present their positions in a differentiated manner but not in a way that could undermine the need for consensus. For example, the Commission is not like a national government. In several of our governments, we have single-party governments that have the majority. The European Commission, by definition, will always be a large coalition, to use the German term. There will be all the different parties with great representativeness because it comes from the different governments. So, that is where we need to be a bit careful. Do not interpret this position as having anything to do with my personal position. It is a substantive question I raise about how to understand European democracy and what the different constraints are there. That said, I can tell you that I am neither a bureaucrat nor a technocrat. I am a democrat. Since I was 29, I have been elected to my national parliament. I love politics. I am never afraid of elections.