Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the future of the Lisbon Treaty after the negative vote of the Irish and on the priorities of the French presidency of the European Union, in Strasbourg on July 10, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

10 July 2008 · Address to the European Parliament · European Parliament, Strasbourg, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed the European Parliament in Strasbourg on July 10, 2008, at the start of the French EU Council presidency, following Ireland's rejection of the Lisbon Treaty.
Main themes
Lisbon Treaty crisis, Irish referendum no vote, French EU Council presidency priorities, European institutional reform, EU enlargement, European democracy, path forward for Europe, 2009 European Parliament elections, Nice Treaty fallback, Franco-Irish dialogue
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,210
87th percentile
Sentences
233
92nd percentile
Readability
54
75th percentile
Grade
10.1
21st percentile
Syntax
2.79
22nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
17th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 39%39%
  • Geopolitical 20%20%
  • Economic 15%15%
  • Social 11%11%
  • Environmental 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

233 sentences in 33 paragraphs

Mr. President,

Ladies and gentlemen of the Parliament,

It is a great honor for me to speak before your Assembly at a critical moment for Europe. I feel that we all bear a heavy responsibility. As the current President of the Council, of course, my responsibility is great, but the responsibility of all convinced Europeans is the same. How do we get Europe out of the crisis it is in? How do we avoid stagnation? How do we overcome our disagreements to serve a common European ideal?

Here, we are at the heart of European democracy. Each of you, to have the honor of sitting here, had to gain the support of your fellow citizens. There are women and men from the left, there are women and men from the center, there are women and men from the right, there are elected representatives from 27 countries, but today we must turn our differences into a strength in service of a suffering European Union. We must make these differences an opportunity to reassure worried Europeans. We must make democracy live, therefore we must engage in our debates and, at the same time, present an image of Europe that refuses stagnation. We must bring everyone along. The family consists of 27 states; we must leave no one behind.

We are just a few months away from a major deadline for the European Parliament, and it is legitimate for everyone to think about it, and at the same time, we must, this morning, convey the feeling of a Europe that works for everyone. I have known easier contexts than the one in which Europe finds itself. Allow me to speak freely while being aware that, as President of the Council, I must speak on behalf of all, take into account the sensitivities of all, and at the same time, provide fair answers.

First remark: we have an institutional problem. Heads of state and government have tried to find a compromise formula with the Treaty of Lisbon. No one said that the Treaty of Lisbon solved all problems, but it was and remains the expression of a desirable compromise for everyone. I myself, as President of the French Republic, had to take my responsibilities. France voted no in 2005, and that no was a problem for France.

Ladies and gentlemen, the issues we face are difficult and complex. Let us try to give everyone the feeling that we are working on them without preconceived notions and without ulterior motives. That is what is expected of us.

I proposed, before the elections, to the French people, the parliamentary ratification of the Treaty of Lisbon. I said, before the elections, that I would not organize a referendum in France. I said this democratically to the French people. It was a choice, three days before my election, that could have been significant. I do not regret that choice. I deeply believe that institutional questions, the rules of functioning in Europe, are the business of parliamentarians rather than the business of a referendum. It is a political choice that I take responsibility for, and it is a political choice that I assumed in my country before the elections. It is therefore a perfectly democratic choice.

We now have the problem of the Irish no, and it is certainly not a Frenchman who can pass judgment on the Irish no, given that there was previously a Dutch no and a French no. I will therefore go to Ireland on July 21, for my first trip as President of the Council, to listen, to engage in dialogue, to try to find solutions. The French Presidency will propose a method and, I hope, a solution in agreement with the Irish government, either in October or December.

The problem is as follows: we must not rush our Irish friends, and at the same time, we must know under what conditions and with which treaty we will organize the European elections of 2009. We have a little time, but not too much time. We owe it to our fellow citizens to know on what basis we will organize the European elections. The basis will be either Lisbon or Nice. There will be no new institutional conference. There will be no new treaty. It is either Lisbon or Nice. I add, to be perfectly clear, that this is my opinion, and that does not make it the truth.

I have always been one of those who supported the enlargement of Europe. The enlargement of 2004 was a success. The family is united; we should not regret that. But I am also one of those who have always regretted that Europe did not have the wisdom to establish institutions before enlarging. That was a mistake we are paying for today. It would have been braver to establish institutions before proceeding with enlargement. Let it be clear, I do not regret enlargement, of course. The family must be united. But I also say with the same strength, Mr. President PÖTTERING, that we must not repeat the same mistakes. If we remain at Nice, it is Europe of the 27. If we want - I want enlargement - we need new institutions before we enlarge. Who could understand that Europe at 27 is not capable of establishing institutions and that its only priority is to enlarge as if in a headlong rush?

Therefore, let it be clear: if we want enlargement - and we want enlargement - then we need new institutions. I add, and I say this to President Martin SCHULZ, that I am in favor of enlargement to the Balkans, that our Croatian friends, like our Serbian friends, are undeniably European. But the countries most favorable to enlargement cannot, at the same time, say: "we do not want Lisbon, but at the same time, we want enlargement." It is Lisbon and enlargement. This is not a matter of blackmail because in Europe, we do not engage in blackmail. It is a matter of coherence, a matter of honesty, and a matter of logic. Regarding Croatia, we must therefore continue negotiations. But let everyone take their responsibilities. If Europe is to enlarge, and it must enlarge, it is with new institutions.

I will also say another thing. I hear, here and there, in European debates, people say: "after all, it is not serious, it will be a Europe at different speeds." Perhaps, alas, one day we will be forced to have a Europe at different speeds, but that can only be the last, the ultimate solution. Europe has paid dearly for being divided by a shameful wall. Europe has paid dearly for the dictatorship imposed on 80 million Europeans. Let us think before leaving countries behind us. At the time of the negotiation of the Treaty of Lisbon in Brussels, France fought for Poland to have its rightful place in the Treaty of Lisbon. How could we tell 38 million Poles that it was indeed easier to free themselves from the dictatorship they suffered, which they liberated themselves from thanks to men of the caliber of Lech WALESA, of the caliber of John Paul II, than to remain in the Europe of freedom? The family is 27. We must leave no one behind; we must bring everyone into the European family. This is, in any case, the direction in which the French Presidency will work.

Regarding other issues, and I believe this can be a subject of consensus among us, nothing would be worse than Europe giving the impression of being immobile because once again, Europe is experiencing an institutional psychodrama. At that moment, we would be caught in a terrible trap. We refuse institutions that condemn us to immobility, and at the same time, Europeans are impatient because they find us too immobile.

Notwithstanding the institutional problem, perhaps even because of the institutional problem, Europe has a duty to act and to act immediately. This is the message that the French Presidency would like us to send together to Europeans. We are in the process of resolving institutional problems, but we are not condemned to inaction. What are, gentlemen Presidents, our priorities? The first is to show Europeans that Europe can protect them, and I would like to say a word about this vocabulary, protection. But since the dawn of time, if men have established a public power, it is because this public power was meant to protect them. Mr. President of the European Parliament, Europe must protect without being protectionist. Protectionism leads nowhere, but it is a singular regression to see today European citizens consider that Europe, which is meant to protect them, worries them instead of defending them. It is up to us, therefore, on concrete issues, to show how Europe will protect them.

The first is the energy-climate package. If there is one area where our nations alone can do nothing, it is that of preserving the ecological balances of the planet. Pollution, CO2, the ozone layer do not care about the borders between our countries. The stakes are considerable because since the experts of the IPCC met, today we know that we are the last generation that can avoid catastrophe, the last. If we do nothing right away, the generations that follow us will be able to limit the damage but will not be able to prevent it. Yet, every country in the world says: "I am ready to do something as long as others start before me." With this type of reasoning, the grandchildren of our grandchildren will see nothing come in terms of decisions. If we, Europeans, have to wait for others to do something before we act, we can wait a long time. We made Europe to carry a model of civilization and to defend values that are ours. Among these values is the certainty that the world is doomed if we do not decide right away. Europe must set an example. To set an example, Europe must be exemplary. We have a goal. The 2009 conference. This conference must manage and organize the post-Kyoto. Europe must come united having decided to adopt the energy-climate package. Without doing so, we will have no strength to impose on the Chinese, the Indians, the emerging countries, the Americans to make the efforts we will have decided first. It is therefore essential that, under the French Presidency, we adopt the energy-climate package that has been submitted by the Commission. This package is demanding, this package is difficult, but I would like to appeal to everyone's responsibility. If each country starts wanting to renegotiate the point that bothers it, the difficulties it experiences, ladies and gentlemen, we will never reach an agreement. That is why the French Presidency asks the European Parliament to mobilize alongside it to ensure that within six months the energy-climate package is adopted. This is a priority. It is neither left nor right; it is simply a matter of common sense, and if we enter into a negotiation state by state, we have no chance of getting out of it.

There are elements that undoubtedly need to be clarified or adapted. I am thinking in particular of a very difficult question, which is that of our companies to which we are going to impose rules to preserve planetary balances. Should we, in Europe, impose vital rules on our companies and continue to import products from countries that do not respect any of the rules we impose on our companies? This is not a question of protectionism; it is a question of fairness, of justice, and of refusing naivety. There is the problem of defining a mechanism at our borders. Should it be free quotas or adjustment mechanisms? I do not know, but in any case, we must debate it.

Another element: for a number of countries, I am thinking in particular of those who joined us in 2004, whose energy is mainly composed of fossil energy, I understand that the efforts required are considerable and that these countries tell us: "we have known growth for ten years; do not come and disrupt the growth we are experiencing." There is undoubtedly a way to bring everyone along, and we must work with the President of the Commission so that everyone feels that they will not be condemned to recession, misery, poverty, and unemployment, but this energy-climate package is an absolute priority for us. The world cannot wait; Europe must show the way.

Second priority: now, out of the 27 countries, we have 23 in the Schengen area. That is to say, 23 countries out of 27, not counting those that are not part of the European Union but are part of Schengen. This is why there are often debates among us. What does this mean? It means that we have therefore decided on total free movement between the countries of the Schengen area. I would like to tell the group leaders and the parliamentarians that on behalf of France, with Bernard KOUCHNER and Jean-Pierre JOUYET, we made a decision that was not so easy to make. Since July 1st, there are no longer any barriers to accessing the French labor market since I announced that I would remove all the restrictions that had been negotiated by my predecessors. All workers from all countries in Europe can come to work in France. It was not so simple, it was not so easy. Moreover, I speak under the control of the French parliamentarians of all political stripes; I was warned of the worst if I made this decision, and as usual, we made the decision, and the worst did not happen. I did not like the controversy over the famous Polish plumber, which gave a very poor image of my country, a very poor image of Europe. That is not why we built, each of us, the European Union. However, from the moment we no longer have borders between us, is it legitimate, is it reasonable to continue to define our own immigration policies while ignoring the constraints of others? The European Pact on Immigration is an essential document for the French Presidency. From two points of view, the first, and allow me to speak to the left side of the chamber first, because if we, the European countries, equip ourselves with a European immigration policy, we then remove immigration from national debates where the extremes use the misery of some and the fear of others in the service of values that are not ours. The only way to make the debate on immigration responsible is to make it a European policy devoid of political ulterior motives and forcing countries with different sensitivities to work together. What was proposed by Brice HORTEFEUX, adopted by all the ministers, which must be discussed in COREPER, then in the European Council, seemed to me a priority that will demonstrate that Europe does not want to be a fortress, that Europe does not refuse to welcome, that Europe needs labor immigration but that Europe cannot welcome all those who would like to come to Europe. I add that, regarding political asylum, it is not normal for a person to be able to submit 27 applications in 27 democracies and that the people of these 27 democracies are not the same faces of the same problem. I add for development with Africa, we will be stronger by working together. This is the second priority of the French Presidency.

Third priority: we wish to advance a concept that has often been discussed in Europe but which has made little progress, that of European defense. I am fully aware that there are many disagreements around this issue, but allow me to share my convictions. How would you like Europe to be a political power speaking loudly if Europe is not capable of defending itself and putting resources at the service of its policy? Let us take the example of Kosovo, which in my opinion is a success of the European Union. It is a European problem that must be resolved by Europeans. How could Europeans continue to resolve it if Europeans do not equip themselves with military and human means to enforce the decisions we would have made together? How can we imagine making Europe the most prosperous economic space without being able to ensure our own defense? Naturally, there is NATO. It does not occur to anyone, and certainly not to me, to question the usefulness of NATO. This is not the European defense policy where NATO is NATO, the alliance with the Americans, and an autonomous European security policy. It is both, not one against the other. I add that we cannot continue with a Europe that ensures its security through the contribution of only four or five countries, while the others rely on the efforts of these four or five countries. We cannot continue to build planes each in our own corner, have an arms industry that competes, that ruins itself, and ultimately weakens, simply because we do not have the strength to conduct a European defense policy.

Fourth priority: the very difficult question of the Common Agricultural Policy. I will come to my conclusion, which is also related to this. It is precisely because this is difficult that it is important to talk about it. I am fully aware that among us there are agricultural states that ardently defend the work of their farmers and that at the same time, there are states that think this policy is too expensive.

Ladies and gentlemen, allow me to appeal to everyone's common sense. By 2050, there will be 9 billion inhabitants on the planet. Already, there are 800 million inhabitants who are dying of hunger. A child dies of hunger every 30 seconds. Is it reasonable to ask Europe to reduce its agricultural production when the world has never needed food supplies more? I do not think that is reasonable.

This is not a question of French agriculture; it is a question of common sense. I add a second point: whether one is an agricultural country or not, food security concerns everyone. Is it reasonable to impose, rightly, on our breeders and farmers rules of traceability and safety and to continue to import into Europe meats that come from elsewhere and that do not respect any of the rules we impose on our farmers?

Agricultural prices have never been so high. This is precisely the right time to talk about prices, to talk about subsidies, and to talk about community preference. I think that also, between the health check of the CAP and the financial arbitrations, we could agree on concepts like food sufficiency for Europe and food security for Europe.

Ladies and gentlemen, there would be many other subjects like the social dimension. A wonderful subject. But allow me to say one thing: I sometimes notice a certain contradiction. Between the single thought that often says that Europe should not interfere in everything, that Europe should only deal with what concerns it, and those same people who criticize Europe for interfering in everything are the first to denounce when we do not talk about a social dimension, while, until now, member states have always wanted social policy to be primarily of national dimension. Because pensions, because health are primarily questions of national dimension.

Ladies and gentlemen, there are a number of social directives that President BARROSO has rightly put on the agenda. I think of works councils, I think of temporary work, I think of a number of minimum rules that must be imposed on everyone in Europe. The French Presidency will make this a priority.

I add that other subjects should be put on the agenda of the French Presidency, even if they are not of European competence. I take the example of what affects us all, Alzheimer's disease... Mr. COHN-BENDIT, it would not have occurred to me that someone as young as you would currently be affected by a tragedy that, if it does not touch you, affects millions of Europeans. That counts as much in my eyes, the millions of Europeans as your health.

Naturally, subsidiarity does not make it a European competence. I would like the French Presidency to organize a meeting of all the specialists from all our European countries so that we can put together the best practices. So that together our researchers can combine their skills. While we know nothing about this disease, that we can, together, find a solution. Imagine then what Europeans will say about Europe: it is a means of combating terrible diseases. What I say about Alzheimer’s, I could say about cancer that breaks families. There is no reason for everyone to work in their own corner to find solutions to cancer when together we will have more resources and we will be stronger.

Finally, allow me to say about culture and sport that it is a serious mistake not to talk about subjects that concern the daily lives of Europeans. There is a European cultural exception. We must make culture an element of daily debate in Europe. The world must not be flattened before a single language and a single culture. The question of taxation on video, on records, as well as the question of taxation on books that you have resolved, must clearly be raised. And on sport, which is an element that transcends political divides, allow me to say that I would like there to be a sports exception in Europe just as there is a cultural exception. I am for the free movement of people and goods, but I do not accept the idea that we come to plunder our football clubs by destroying the training efforts that a number of clubs make by going to seek boys of 14 years who must stay in their club to meet the training imperative. A sports exception that would say that sport does not simply obey the market economy should unite all European deputies.

In the end, ladies and gentlemen and Mr. President, I will conclude - certainly apologizing for having been too long - with one last remark. I know where I will make this remark: before the beating heart of European democracy. Europe has suffered from many things. Europe has first suffered from the cowardice of a number of us who were quite happy to make Europe pay for responsibilities that belonged to a number of political leaders who had not dared to assume before their public opinion choices they had refused to defend in Brussels. This is called cowardice, and I say it to the President of the Parliament as well as to the President of the Commission: the Presidency will work hand in hand with you. If a member state does not agree, let it say so. As I had the opportunity to say to the Polish President, he negotiated the Lisbon Treaty himself, he gave his word, a word must be honored. This is not a question of politics; it is a question of morality.

But Europe has suffered from something else. Europe has suffered from a lack of debate. I would like to end with this because it is very dear to me. Our institutions are independent. But independence does not mean indifference. If we, the political leaders, do not have the courage to debate, to debate what? What is the right economic strategy? What is the right monetary strategy? What is the right exchange rate strategy? What is the right interest rate strategy? Of course, everyone, and I say this to our German friends in particular, can have their conviction. But no one has the right to prevent a debate, a debate that is useful. Of course, everyone wants an agreement, the trade agreement that is currently being negotiated. But no one should be afraid to say that Europe does not have to be naive. We must discuss the advantages of free trade. But we must also tell emerging countries that there is no reason for them to demand the same rights without assuming the same duties. The European debate must be posed without fear. The European debate, we must assume it while respecting each other but without being afraid to defend our convictions. We do not call into question our convictions. We do not call into question the independence of the ECB by questioning whether it is reasonable to raise interest rates to 4.25 when the Americans have interest rates at 2%. We participate in a debate. A calm debate where no one has the truth - certainly not me - but not necessarily either the specialists who have to demonstrate the effectiveness of their decisions.

This is the spirit, ladies and gentlemen, in which I intend, with the French ministers, to assume this responsibility. I am fully aware that it is difficult. I am fully aware that when you are President of the Council, you do not defend the interests of your country but the interests of the Union. I am fully aware, Mr. President, Mr. Presidents, that we must play collectively for the interest of Europe of the 27. I hope that in 6 months everyone can say: Europe will have progressed thanks to your participation, thanks to your support.

Thank you.