Joint press conference of Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, Mr. Mario Monti, President of the Council of Ministers of the Italian Republic, and Mrs. Angela Merkel, on the Eurozone crisis, in Strasbourg on November 24, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

24 November 2011 · Joint press conference on the Eurozone crisis · Strasbourg, France

Context
Sarkozy, Merkel, and Monti held a joint press conference in Strasbourg on November 24, 2011, to address the eurozone crisis and express support for Italy's new government.
Main themes
Eurozone crisis, euro sustainability, Franco-German-Italian cooperation, Italian government confidence, EU treaty reform, eurozone governance, economic convergence, ECB independence, structural reforms, fiscal consolidation, European integration
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,552
82nd percentile
Sentences
170
85th percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

170 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Thank you for coming to Strasbourg. The purpose of this meeting is, first and foremost, for Chancellor MERKEL and myself to express the willingness of Germany and France to support and assist the Italian government led by Mario MONTI.

We wanted to convey, Germany and France, our confidence in the Italian government. And we were very pleased to be able to discuss all the topics concerning Europe and Italy with Mario MONTI; he will tell you himself, but he invited us to Rome in a very short time to continue this discussion among the three of us, and both the Chancellor and I responded that we would go to Rome with the greatest pleasure.

The second reason for this meeting is the determination of the three largest economies in the eurozone to do everything possible to support and ensure the sustainability of the euro. We are all three, the three largest economies in the zone, determined to work in the same direction to support the euro.

The third remark I would like to make is that we are all three fully aware of the seriousness of the situation and we are considering the same remedies in the face of the gravity of this situation. We indicated to President MONTI that France and Germany, in the coming days, would make joint proposals for treaty modifications to improve the governance of the eurozone and to ensure more integration and convergence of economic policies. We will, of course, inform Mario MONTI of these proposals, hoping that Italy will, of course, wish to associate itself with them.

Finally, we all three indicated, by common agreement, our confidence in the European Central Bank and its leaders. And all three of us stated, while respecting the independence of this essential institution, that we should refrain from making positive or negative demands. This is a position we have developed together and which seems appropriate to the situation.

Finally, I would like to thank the Chancellor once again for coming to France and to express how much, in this very complex period, the strength of our understanding is an essential element of the stability of Europe and the euro. And to tell Mario MONTI how happy I was to see him again after a few years during which we worked together and to say to him that we recognize the magnitude of his task; but knowing him well, we know that he will rise to this task; all the confidence we have in him and also, if he allows me, all my personal friendship towards him.

Mr. MARIO MONTI -- I thank Mr. President SARKOZY for this initiative to invite me along with Madam Chancellor. I greatly appreciated this initiative, my government also appreciated it, and all of Italy appreciated it. Traditionally, Italy has always been one of the driving forces of European integration, and Italy intends to be even more so in this phase that is shaping up to be very problematic for everyone, particularly for the eurozone. But this is a situation that is full of promise. As we know, throughout history, Europe has always managed to respond positively to crises. I presented to the President and the Chancellor the program of our government that I have the honor to lead. I particularly emphasized Italy's interest, beyond the indications of the European Union, in the utmost respect for the consolidation of public finances within tight deadlines, and I confirmed the objective of budgetary balance in 2013. All of this must be done sustainably. We spoke with the President and the Chancellor. All of this also implies economic growth that will guarantee the long-term sustainability of budgetary balances. Growth that must not be inflationary. Structural reforms are needed for that. I presented to my two interlocutors the structural reforms I intend to adopt for my country, and I particularly indicated what the planned timeline for the introduction of this reform is. For this, we intend to involve all political parties and social partners. This is what we have already begun to do.

Our dialogue among the three of us, as Mr. SARKOZY said, has been very intense. We discussed possible solutions for the eurozone, we shared our concerns and worries. We all three expressed, in a common manner and with a great convergence of views, the importance that our three countries attach to the priority objective of a healthy eurozone. It is fundamental that the euro holds; it is a fundamental element of European economic and political integration.

As Mr. SARKOZY announced, I am very happy that Madam MERKEL and Mr. SARKOZY have accepted my invitation to come to Rome very soon to continue this very interesting discussion that is already bearing fruit. It is unnecessary to emphasize that strong collaboration between France, Germany, and Italy does not come at the expense of the community spirit; on the contrary, it is a collaboration that benefits the European Union as a whole. Thank you.

Madam ANGELA MERKEL - Ladies and Gentlemen, first of all, thank you to Nicolas SARKOZY for being able to meet us here in Strasbourg, and then I would like to say that this discussion among the three largest economies in the eurozone is really important for all of us. For us, it was also important to know what the intentions and agenda of the new Italian government are, of course. This concerns budgetary consolidation but also structural reforms that, I am convinced, will again bring the necessary growth to create jobs and combat unemployment. So we wish the new Italian Prime Minister, Mario MONTI, much success in his work, which is not simple, far from it. He has all our support. We also thank him for his invitation. Since this is a serious situation, we must also cooperate as three major countries; we must clearly indicate that we want to maintain a stable and strong euro in the international currency community. The euro must be respected, and the euro is also a political project, and we will therefore defend it with all our strength. This is not simple since we have lost a lot of trust. Trust must be rebuilt, regained in our countries, of course, but also the trust between us is there. Therefore, we must send a signal of even closer cooperation in the future in our eurozone, and that is why our two countries, France and Germany, are working on proposals for treaty modifications because we must indeed move towards a fiscal union, and we are here to also say that we need to coordinate policies more if we want to have a stable common currency.

We also discussed this today; it is absolutely essential that the measures taken on October 26 are implemented in full, whether it concerns bank recapitalization, negotiations with Greece and the banks, or directives on leverage for the EFSF. The finance ministers in the Eurogroup and in Ecofin must make the necessary decisions, and at the council meeting in December, the Italian Prime Minister will obviously be informed of the progress of our work. So we will also make proposals to him for closer political cooperation, as political trust in Europe has regressed. We need to regain this trust; we need to recreate this trust, and really, it was a very harmonious discussion, as President SARKOZY also mentioned.

QUESTION -- A question for all three of you, particularly for Madam MERKEL and Mr. SARKOZY. You mentioned proposals for modifications to the European treaties in the coming days; does this mean that you have agreed on an expansion of the role of the ECB, and if so, what type of role could the ECB then play? And to what extent and within what timeframe would the modification of this treaty occur?

THE PRESIDENT -- Listen, I told you that we are working on proposals that have made significant progress, that we will present before the Brussels meeting on December 9, and that I have nothing more to add regarding the ECB than what I said at the beginning, which is in agreement with President MONTI, Chancellor MERKEL, and myself. As for the details of the proposals we will make, well, when we present them, we will provide them to you. But that was not the purpose of this meeting today to present treaty modifications. This is another work we are conducting; we are working practically every day together, our teams, the Chancellor and I, we exchange practically every day. There you go. Because to find an agreement and especially to draw the consequences of a very serious crisis, we do not want to experience the events that Europe is currently going through. It is in this spirit that we work and exchange every day. This will be the subject of a detailed presentation.

MADAM ANGELA MERKEL -- The French President is absolutely right; he just explained that the European Central Bank is independent. And so any potential treaty modifications do not concern the ECB, which deals with monetary policy and monetary stability. Regarding the modifications to the treaty - and we will demonstrate this later - we are concerned with the issue of fiscal policy, and therefore with deeper cooperation in political matters. So this is a very different chapter. There will be proposals in this direction, but this has nothing to do with the ECB.

QUESTION -- Yesterday in the Bundestag, you rejected the idea of eurobonds. If now, on December 9, can we imagine, if you had the green light for the rest, that you could backtrack a little and say that it might be a good idea? In light of the risk that France could lose its triple A rating, as Fitch mentioned today, can you consider this possibility?

MADAM ANGELA MERKEL - It is not about giving something and having countermeasures. We have weaknesses in the construction of the eurozone; we need to try to overcome these weaknesses, perhaps due to a lack of political deepening. So my position compared to yesterday has not changed. If we take steps towards a fiscal union, that can be a step, but it is not a prerequisite for me to change the position I expressed yesterday in front of the Bundestag.

It is not about looking at each revenue and expenditure policy separately but about understanding them together. Each country has its own budget, but those who do not respect the stability pact can be held accountable because we have experienced these violations of the stability pact, including in Germany, and there have never been any recourse or sanctions. And we are paying a heavy price for that today. We must avoid these situations from recurring, and this has nothing to do with my position regarding eurobonds. The prerequisites are not met, so I do not change my position compared to yesterday.

THE PRESIDENT -- What reasoning, what principle are we starting from? It is that the current situation is not satisfactory since it has led to the situation we know. So we need to change, and to change, we need to propose treaty modifications so that everyone can be involved. If there were refusals, then we would have a different strategy than that of modifying the treaties. It could be an intergovernmental agreement, and we are working on that. I realize that our German friends may not have had the correct translation of what Fitch said about the triple A. And in that case, I am very happy to provide you with a translation. Fitch said: "France's triple A: Stable outlook." This translation may not have crossed the Rhine, but I give it to you since you yourself, by coming to Strasbourg, have given me this opportunity. But of course, if the sovereign debt crisis were to continue to worsen, it would pose a problem for everyone, not just for France. That is precisely why we are working on this.

One last point. You used the word "backtrack." This is always very interesting because we have the choice between being stubborn and not listening to others or backtracking because we have listened to others.

That is not how it works. Germany has a history, a tradition, and a culture. France has another, and we are trying to understand each other and converge towards the same point to regain the trust that the eurozone must inspire. We have, with President MONTI, the chance to have the third largest economy in Europe, to create the most stable possible pole. Do you honestly think that we talk every day because we agree, simply, spontaneously? We say: "Oh, I agree, well, you agree too," and we hang up? No, it does not happen like that, even if I wish it would. Madam MERKEL sometimes explains to me at length her concerns. I explain mine to her, and then, given the weight of history between our two countries, we converge. I try to understand Germany's red lines, and she understands France's red lines.

For example, regarding institutions like the ECB, we do not share the same history. This is a reality; there is no point in denying it, we must try to understand and find common ground. And when we say that we trust the ECB, and that we will refrain from any positive or negative comments, it has meaning; it is called a positive compromise where everyone tries to understand the situation of the other and to bring, as Mario Monti has very well said, the weight of our countries to Europe.

Because if we were to diverge, in that case, there would be no point in meeting. But convergence is not something spontaneous. It requires effort from everyone. You know, generally, it is those who are in opposition, in Germany, in Italy, I am not talking about France, who generally do not know the reality of things and who think that it is enough to look each other in the eye to find the solution. No, it is a bit more complicated than that.

I cannot resist, on the French triple A, you know this joke that is said in France about the hypochondriac? You do not know it? The epitaph on his tomb: "I told you so." Do not reason like that, announcing catastrophes in order to say: "Well yes, I was right, I had predicted it."

When you are in charge of governments, you do not reason like that; you try to do serious work, to implement policies, strategies, to stick to them and to find the path to growth, as the Chancellor has said, and to trust, as the President of the Council says. But not to follow minute by minute what some say or what others say. The variations of the markets and the vibrations of the markets. We are responsible for protecting our fellow citizens. A much more difficult job in the long term and not just at the end of the day or in the half hour that passes.

QUESTION -- A question for Mr. Monti. You said that you were invited to bring Italy's contribution to this dialogue between France and Italy. What is your government's position regarding eurobonds? Several times, before being appointed Prime Minister, you said that you were in favor of resorting to eurobonds. Some time ago, you spoke of a confirmed commitment to Europe, to maintain and achieve budgetary balance, the budgetary balance, before 2013. For that, do you need to foresee a recovery plan? What would be the impact of this plan on the economy? Regarding countries that do not respect commitments in terms of budget, I have a question for all three of you: Do you agree on the automaticity of these sanctions for these countries?

Mr. Mario Monti -- Yes, there are objectives that have been set for each country. In the case of Italy, it is to achieve budgetary balance by 2013. As you know, Italy has a considerable budget surplus that will be 7.5% in 2014. However, Italy must make particular efforts because it has a public debt, a legacy of the past, that is very significant.

The objective of achieving budgetary balance is not called into question. It seems to me that in your question, there is rather a more general problem that is valid for the economy worldwide and certainly for the European economy. You are asking me what can happen if we have a recession of a magnitude greater than what we have anticipated. On the other hand, you are asking whether public finances should be adjusted to take into account the variation of the cycle. This is a well-known question that the entire European Union can ask itself. I think that each country on its own must do its homework, to use the expression that was used by Mrs. Merkel; we want to do our homework at home, and that is why I warmly accepted the invitation that was extended to me. Italy wants to participate, contribute, to solve common problems, namely how to adjust the economic policy programs of European countries taking into account this cycle.

You are also asking me what my position is regarding eurobonds. I want to emphasize what Mrs. Merkel has said. We must move towards fiscal unity, towards a fiscal union if we want to provide stability to the eurozone. For that, we need to have secure mechanisms for the application of the rules that we will adopt. In this context, there is the question of amending the treaty to achieve this fiscal union. In this context, there are many other subjects that can be de-dramatized. The stability bonds, as the European Commission has called them, could indeed make a contribution, but all of this must be done within a fiscal union. We must be careful because several elements that could be very useful might not be if we do not achieve a true fiscal union.

Finally, regarding the automatic application of sanctions, my counterparts have recalled it earlier. As Mrs. Merkel and Mr. Sarkozy have said, I think that the loss of credibility of the stability pact is due to past events. France and Germany opposed each other in 2003; the two governments of France and Italy then ensured that we did not diverge. I think that this is a mistake that was made in 2003; I think everyone agrees on that. I fought within the European Commission for the Commission to denounce the Council before the Court of Justice for the violation of the stability pact that was committed in 2003. Well, I think that once rules have been set, they must be respected. One should not consider a larger country, a smaller country; we must avoid political negotiations on rules that must be respected. Respect for the law, for a rule concerning stability is fundamental, especially when it concerns budget stability.

Mrs. Angela Merkel -- Allow me to add just a word. I would like to say what I appreciated before saying what I did not appreciate. In fact, the Commission has listed a number of proposals for budget discipline that are very welcome. Simply, the stability bonds or eurobonds, no matter what name we give them, would do something, namely that the differences in rates would perhaps be leveled, and in my opinion, that would not be a good signal because we should not simply set aside these differences in rates because they clearly indicate where we still need to act, where we need to continue to act. We need to regain trust to return to the situation before the crisis when rates were almost the same everywhere in all European countries due to market appreciation. So if we force things, I think that is not the right solution; that is what I think, and that is why I expressed this position yesterday before the Bundestag.

Now, regarding the automaticity of sanctions, I think we need to work through a treaty amendment. Mario Monti was, in another life, Commissioner for Competition, and in competition law, the rules are much stricter than in the framework of the Stability and Growth Pact. Everyone knows that regarding competition, the rules must be respected; otherwise, there is recourse, and there is really no tolerance in this matter. When Mario Monti was Commissioner, by the way, we often talked about it; it is also something that applies to Germany, and we were not always happy with the decisions of the Commissioner for Competition, but we knew that we would lose before the European Court of Justice, so we immediately respected the rules. We are not yet there in the framework of the Stability and Growth Pact. Eurozone countries need to work on this with the determination that is appropriate.

The President -- In any case, both of you will have the opportunity to discuss all the proposals that we will make, but they are part of a whole, and I think it is not useful, it is even dangerous for someone to propose eurobonds without talking about governance or to talk about governance and sanctions without addressing the other side. It is a whole that we will present in the coming days, and it is this whole that will restore confidence.

Thank you for participating in this meeting, and safe travels home.