Letter from Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, addressed to Dr. Elisabeth Hubert, President of the National Federation of Home Hospitalization Establishments, asking her to organize a broad consultation on local medicine.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

27 April 2010

Context
Sarkozy wrote to Dr. Elisabeth Hubert in April 2010, commissioning a national consultation on primary care reform amid growing concerns over physician shortages and rural healthcare access.
Main themes
Primary care reform, medical demographics, general practitioner shortage, rural healthcare access, private practice attractiveness, doctor remuneration models, health workforce training, regional healthcare consultation, cooperation between health professions, health houses development, administrative burden reduction, healthcare system balance
Duration
~7 min
24th percentile
Words
835
24th percentile
Sentences
43
27th percentile
Readability
36
27th percentile
Grade
13.0
57th percentile
Syntax
2.78
20th percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
61st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 60%58%
  • Institutional 29%28%
  • Economic 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

43 sentences in 18 paragraphs

Madam Minister,

Primary care is an essential service for our fellow citizens. It is the first element of the healthcare chain. It is situated both upstream and downstream of the hospital, which is intended to handle the most complex situations.

Private practitioners, both generalists and specialists, are at the heart of primary care. Their commitment to fulfilling their mission every day and tirelessly - to heal, relieve, and support - and their dedication to serving their patients deserve the consideration and recognition of society as a whole.

Primary care also relies on paramedical professionals who perform certain first-line actions, as well as on health centers that employ doctors.

In all its forms, primary care is currently facing structural difficulties. At the forefront of these is the anticipated evolution of the medical demographic. The number of doctors per 100,000 inhabitants, which was 290 at the beginning of 2009, could reach 275 by 2020, which would be the level of the early 1980s. The decline, which has already begun, in medical density and the non-replacement of private practitioners who cease their activities raises legitimate concerns among the population, particularly in rural areas and in neighborhoods targeted by urban policy.

Beyond quantitative data, the practice of medicine has profoundly changed. Medicine has become hyper-specialized, making it more challenging for general practitioners to practice. It has become more difficult to work alone to meet the health needs of an aging population. Non-medical tasks, such as management or administrative work, have gained importance. Health insurance audits are more frequent. And career progression is a concern for many private practitioners.

After initiating the reform of hospitals, I wish for responses to be provided to the structural difficulties of primary care. The two measures to enhance the status of general practitioners that I have announced - the increase of the consultation fee "C" to 23 euros and the ability to bill consultations as specialists - are a form of recognition of their mission, but they will not be sufficient to address the fundamental problems currently facing primary care. We must identify new solutions so that in ten or twenty years, the French can access primary care services provided by primary care practitioners in a satisfactory and equitable manner.

In this perspective, I wish to entrust you with the mission of organizing a broad consultation on primary care.

This consultation has three objectives. The first objective is to give new momentum to the dialogue with doctors. The second objective is to allow everyone to express themselves: medical unions, but also the doctors who practice primary care daily throughout our country, other health professionals who cooperate with doctors, as well as elected officials and patients. The third objective is to make proposals that modify private practice, providing responses to the structural changes that outpatient medicine has been experiencing for many years.

You will focus on characterizing primary care over the next ten or twenty years, taking into account the expected advances in medicine and health technologies. You will define the role that primary care could have, at that point, in our healthcare system. To enrich your prospective analysis, you may have a monograph prepared regarding the situation of primary care in two representative departments.

You will rely on the work already available, particularly the report that Dr. Michel LEGMANN has just submitted to me.

Several themes may be addressed in the consultation, including the adaptation of training, the simplification of work to free up medical time, the attractiveness of the private practice status, the consideration of practitioners' expertise, the geographical distribution of primary care services, the responsibility of doctors in organizing care provision, and the development of health houses and cooperation between health professions.

The consultation will also be an opportunity to examine the possibility of developing remuneration models that are more suited to the evolution of the general practitioner profession. Payment methods based on capitation and performance should be subject to debate, in light of lessons learned from foreign experiences and the introduction, in France, of the individual practice improvement contract. You will also specify the technical conditions for billing, by specialist doctors in general medicine, for a specialist consultation.

You will propose, for each of these themes, concrete measures for which you will seek to clarify the legal and operational implementation modalities. You will conduct a cost estimation of these measures. You will ensure that your proposals are compatible with the objective of returning to a balance in social accounts.

The consultation will be organized in such a way that debates take place in the regions. It must also occur on a dedicated website. You may also conduct field visits.

I ask you to submit your report to me by the end of September. The Ministry of Health will provide you with all the resources you may need for the organization of the consultation.

I thank you for accepting this mission, which is so important for the social contract of our Nation.

Please accept, Madam Minister, the expression of my highest regards.