Letter from Mr Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, Mr Gordon Brown, Prime Minister of the United Kingdom, and Mrs Angela Merkel, Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany, addressed to Mr Fredrik Reinfeldt, Prime Minister of the Kingdom of Sweden and President of the European Council, on the preparation of the Pittsburgh G20 summit, particularly regarding financial regulation, 2 September 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

2 September 2009 · G20 summit in Pittsburgh (letter to the President of the European Council)

Context
Sarkozy, Brown, and Merkel jointly addressed EU Council President Reinfeldt on September 2, 2009, ahead of the G20 Pittsburgh summit to coordinate European positions on financial regulation.
Main themes
G20 Pittsburgh summit preparation, financial sector regulation, executive compensation reform, European coordination, economic recovery, exit strategies, systemic risk and moral hazard, capital requirements, financial stability, transparency and governance, global imbalances, Basel II implementation
Duration
~9 min
31st percentile
Words
1,052
31st percentile
Sentences
40
25th percentile
Readability
28
14th percentile
Grade
15.3
78th percentile
Syntax
2.91
35th percentile
Vocabulary
2.30
73rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 78%78%
  • Institutional 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

40 sentences in 19 paragraphs

Mr. President,

The Heads of State and Government of the G20 will meet in Pittsburgh on September 24 and 25, 2009. A strong and common message from the European G20 countries will be a decisive prerequisite to ensure the success of this summit. It is essential that the Heads of State and Government, on the occasion of this summit, continue to implement the economic policy measures they have decided upon and reaffirm their commitment to developing a new model of sustainable growth and a better organization of financial markets, so that the crisis we have experienced does not happen again. In preparation for the G20 summit in Pittsburgh, we wish to draw the attention of our partners in the European Union to the following issues.

While economic indicators show signs of stabilization, the crisis is not over, and the labor market will continue to suffer from the consequences of low capacity utilization in the coming months. Together, we must deliver the message in Pittsburgh that we are determined to resolutely implement our recovery plans. While there is no alternative today to the measures we have taken to combat the crisis, we must be careful not to create the conditions for new global imbalances in the long term. We must therefore work on exit strategies that will be implemented in a coordinated manner as soon as the crisis is over.

One of the key issues of the Pittsburgh summit will be to design the architecture of an international regulatory framework for the financial sector so that it serves investment and growth. The easing of financial tensions has led some financial institutions to think that they could return to the same principles of action that prevailed before the crisis. We cannot accept this.

The issue of compensation in the financial sector is an important matter that must be discussed in Pittsburgh and will constitute a concrete outcome of our commitment to building a more stable financial system. Our citizens are particularly shocked by the return of reprehensible practices, while taxpayer money was mobilized at the height of the crisis to support the financial sector. We made commitments in London, and the Financial Stability Board has developed a series of principles. On this basis, we believe that the G20 should agree in Pittsburgh on the following additional conclusions:

- We must improve governance: remuneration committees involving the board of directors and staff, including risk controllers, must be established to define and develop remuneration policies.

- We must increase transparency: appropriate disclosure obligations must be imposed on banks.

- Remuneration policies must encourage consideration of risks for all individuals involved in determining the risks faced by a financial institution: (i) variable remuneration, including bonuses, must be set at an appropriate level relative to fixed remuneration and must depend on the performance of the bank, business lines, and individuals. (ii) When stock options or shares are distributed as part of remuneration, they should only be exercisable or sellable after a specified period. (iii) Variable remuneration must take negative developments into account. This means that guaranteed bonuses must be avoided. The payment of a significant portion of variable remuneration must be spread over an appropriate period and can be canceled in the event of negative performance developments for the bank. (iv) Executives must not be completely insulated from the risks they take (for example, through mandatory deductibles). For executives of publicly traded companies, the board of directors must have the means to reduce executive remuneration in the event of a deterioration in the bank's performance.

The G20 must transform these principles into binding rules for financial institutions that have complex and large-scale risky activities and ensure that sanctions exist at the national level for banks that do not comply with these rules. For example, governments could refrain from granting mandates to financial institutions that are known not to apply the internationally agreed rules.

We should also consider ways to limit the amount of variable remuneration in banks either as a proportion of total remuneration or based on the bank's revenues and/or profits.

Furthermore, speculative activities that pose a risk to financial stability must also be discouraged by increasing capital requirements on these activities, as already recommended by the Basel Committee. Basel II rules must be fully implemented to ensure a level playing field in all countries represented on the Basel Committee.

The G20 must address the problem of moral hazard created by systemically important financial institutions. Finance ministers will need to examine ways to strengthen supervisory obligations for these institutions to reflect the level of systemic risk they pose to the financial sector and how these institutions can be dismantled if necessary without disrupting the financial sector as a whole.

Regarding non-cooperative jurisdictions, based on the real progress observed, we should agree on a comprehensive list of countermeasures that could be implemented starting in March 2010 for jurisdictions that have not effectively implemented international standards on tax information exchange.

We must also lay the groundwork in Pittsburgh for a new global economic cooperation that can only be exercised with the support of strong and legitimate international organizations. We must therefore finalize the roadmap for the necessary reform of governance and representation at the IMF, which must be concluded by January 2011, and at the World Bank, which must be completed by spring 2010.

We will need to review the implementation of the commitments made in London regarding financing. In particular, all new bilateral contributions must be integrated into the new IMF borrowing agreements. We must complete the review process of the capital of multilateral development banks. To support the poorest in developing countries, all G20 countries should adopt the "Everything But Arms" initiative to send a strong signal of action in favor of development.

Finally, we must advance our work on a Charter for Sustainable Economic Activity that will anchor sustainability as a fundamental principle of the global economy and will help prevent crises like the one we have experienced in the future.

These are the key principles that must guide our work in the lead-up to the Pittsburgh summit so that we can offer our citizens the concrete foundations for future growth.

We are sending a copy of this letter to the members of the European Council.

Please accept, Mr. President, the expression of our highest consideration.