Letter of mission from Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, addressed to Mr. Xavier Darcos, Minister of National Education, on the priorities in education policy, July 5, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

5 July 2007

Context
Sarkozy addressed Minister of National Education Xavier Darcos in a formal letter of mission outlining education policy priorities following the 2007 French presidential and legislative elections.
Main themes
Education reform, teaching profession enhancement, equal opportunities, school performance, teacher training, merit recognition, teacher authority and safety, school map reform, presidential program implementation, republican values in education, student qualifications
Duration
~28 min
79th percentile
Words
3,317
79th percentile
Sentences
120
71st percentile
Readability
31
19th percentile
Grade
15.7
81st percentile
Syntax
3.28
80th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
40th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 68%65%
  • Institutional 30%28%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

120 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Mr. Minister,

The results of the presidential election and the legislative elections that have just taken place in our country show the extent of the demand for change expressed by the French people. By electing a large presidential majority to Parliament, they wanted to give the government, without any possible ambiguity, all the necessary tools for the success of its mission. This government, to which you belong, now has only one duty: to implement the presidential program and, beyond that, to reconcile our fellow citizens with political action by proving to them that it can still change things and restore to our country control over its destiny.

Throughout the presidential campaign, commitments were made in the areas of your ministerial responsibilities. It goes without saying that we expect you to uphold them. The purpose of this letter of mission is to specify the points that, among these commitments, we consider priorities and on which we ask you to achieve results quickly.

Our fellow citizens are very attached to free, secular, and republican education. They know that, for entire generations, it has been the engine of social progress and the pillar of equal opportunities. For this reason, it has never hesitated to demand the best and the most difficult from each of the students entrusted to it. And rightly so, for these reasons, the school is at the heart of the republican pact and is particularly dear to us.

However, it is clear that our school is currently struggling to fulfill the role that the nation expects of it. 20% of students leave the school system without qualifications: every year, tens of thousands of young people face the job market with a significant disadvantage. International rankings of various educational systems show that our school is not adapting quickly enough to the global battle for intelligence regarding the level of training required of students and the intellectual qualities that need to be developed in them to meet the expectations of the professional world. Beyond that, the school struggles to ensure equal opportunities. The differences in level between institutions have become too significant to guarantee all children a real equality of opportunity in higher education, professional integration, and even simply in achieving success in their adult lives. Correspondingly, the school map too often imposes itself only on families who do not have the means or connections to circumvent it.

Education was one of the major issues of the electoral campaign. Our fellow citizens know it is essential for the future of their children and even for our entire country. The school is a determining link in the civilization we want to build and in which we want to live. The mission that is yours within the government thus takes on particular importance. It is your responsibility to restore the school to its fundamental mission of transmitting values, training minds, elevating spirits, preparing for adult and professional life, and being a pillar of equal opportunities, with the understanding that the school must look to the future and not cultivate nostalgia for the past.

No government can claim to make education a priority if it does not start by enhancing the teaching profession. That is why we have engaged with you in the necessary work and consultations for this purpose. We want the authority of teachers to be respected, their skills recognized, and their training better ensured. You will guarantee the pedagogical freedom of teachers, in return for which you will evaluate them more regularly based on the progress and results of their students. The safety of institutions is essential for a calm teaching environment. Far from underestimating this issue, you will take all necessary measures in this regard in connection with the Minister of the Interior, Overseas, and Territorial Collectivities. Families and teachers are asking for this.

In continuity with the orientation law of April 23, 2005, you will ensure, in connection with the Minister of Higher Education and Research, that the university institutes for teacher training provide teachers with the tools they truly need to perform their jobs, and not impose certain methods in preference to others. Teacher training will last five years and will be recognized by a master's level diploma. You will focus on improving the beginning of teachers' careers. We no longer want the youngest and least experienced teachers to be systematically assigned to the most challenging institutions.

We also want teachers' salaries to better reflect the importance of their role for the nation, in the short term by allowing teachers who want to work more to earn more, and in the medium term by better reconciling the evolution of staff numbers and salary evolution. We want merit to be recognized, both at the individual and collective levels. This is possible while being objective. It seems natural to us that each teacher should be able to control, through their work, the evolution of their career and income by investing as they wish in their main job and in complementary activities. The service obligations of teachers will need to take into account this new freedom that is offered to them.

The school is too slow to react to the difficulties faced by students, allowing tens of thousands of students to accumulate failures, enter sixth grade without being able to read or write well, and leave school without qualifications. You will make the success of each student the primary objective of your mission by implementing support measures and individualizing pathways.

Starting in the 2007 school year, directed studies must be offered to all students in priority education, and then generalized to all schools starting in the 2008 school year. For the most disadvantaged students, you will offer individual support, ensuring that this occurs as early as possible in the school year and as early as possible in the students' schooling so that none of them are left without assistance for an extended period, as is too often the case today. In middle school, you will seek to reconcile the noble objectives of the common middle school, which are equal opportunities and the longest possible general education for each child, with those of success and the acquisition of the core knowledge and skills by all students. To this end, you will allow each student to follow their schooling at their own pace. In doing so, you will avoid identical repetitions, which are rarely successful. Finally, in the most disadvantaged neighborhoods, you will establish, in connection with the municipalities, early childhood reception structures aimed at preparing children from very disadvantaged backgrounds for school and giving them the same chances as others to succeed there. You will act in this regard in connection with the Minister of Immigration, Integration, National Identity, and Co-development, and the High Commissioner for Active Solidarity Against Poverty.

We want every young French person to acquire, through school, the broadest possible general culture. This is a condition for living as a free man or woman, as an informed citizen, and for retaining, in a world that is changing so rapidly, all the chances of being able to change careers multiple times during a single professional life. That is why we ask you to put an end to the so-called "junior" apprenticeship, organized from the age of 14, which we consider far too young.

However, we do not equate general training with training disconnected from jobs, nor do we oppose intellectual work and manual work. On the contrary, we believe that all students, starting in the fifth grade, should follow a pathway to discover different professions. It will be the role of a new public service for orientation, which you will establish, to organize this pathway and provide each family and each student with relevant information, based on precise and public evaluations, about the different fields of higher education and technical and vocational education. Academic success means that each child can orient themselves towards a path that corresponds to their personal projects, their talents, the needs of the job market, and in which they thrive today and in the future.

We know that social diversity is a factor in the success of an educational system, and we intend to cultivate it fully. But the school map, which has been the instrument of this diversity since 1963, has now become a tool that exacerbates segregation and prevents equal opportunities. It encourages the clustering of certain categories of the population in certain neighborhoods and, conversely, forces deserving students, whose parents do not have the means to circumvent the map, to remain in institutions that do not offer them the same chances of success as privileged students. In reality, the school map serves as an alibi for a social diversity policy that no longer has the means to succeed, and whose most visible failure is the creation of true school ghettos. This situation is unacceptable.

In the face of this delicate but essential issue, we ask you to show boldness and conviction, drawing inspiration from the example of many foreign countries that have successfully abolished their school maps. Our goal is to make the school map superfluous by equalizing the level of institutions, allowing parents to choose their children's school not based on the actual or presumed level of the institutions, but on the educational project implemented.

To this end, you will first give all institutions more flexibility and autonomy, particularly in the budgetary domain, to allow them to implement, under the supervision of the academic authority, a pedagogical project that is their own. At the same time, in consultation with the relevant local authorities, you will allow institutions to recruit an increasing proportion of students from outside their sector, while imposing obligations of social and school diversity on their student bodies. Thus, the obligation of social diversity will no longer be a constraint imposed on families, but a responsibility entrusted to the institutions. Through additional means and more frequent advice and oversight, you will ensure greater support for institutions welcoming students facing the most difficulties. You will also allocate more resources to institutions that perform well despite being located in difficult neighborhoods, because we want to support this success and not penalize it.

In the face of school ghettos, you will implement a specific policy, which can only be progressive, but which will nonetheless be determined. Starting in the 2007 school year, you will identify about thirty of the most troubled institutions and set the goal of halving their student numbers by redistributing the excess students to other neighboring institutions on a voluntary basis. You will equip these struggling institutions with enhanced and specially trained educational teams and ask them to implement innovative educational projects that allow for a shift from a logic of relegation to a logic of excellence. You will gradually extend this policy, the aim of which is to put an end to all school ghettos. This aspect of your mission is crucial for us. We want to give every young person in our country equal chances of success, and every deserving student the opportunity to reach the top of the social ladder. To achieve this, the school, far from lowering its expectations and ambitions regarding the least privileged children, must instead strengthen them. This is our absolute conviction.

In the same spirit, you will multiply educational success boarding schools in urban areas, in order to provide all deserving students with the necessary working conditions to pursue the best possible studies. You will also allow the top 5% of students in each school to join, if they wish, a preparatory class for grandes écoles or an institution benefiting from the status of a grand establishment or technological university. This system will constitute a powerful vector of equal opportunities, a tool for emulation within institutions, and will give the baccalaureate a new significance. We also wish for internships to be an opportunity for students to broaden the horizon of their social and professional ambitions, which requires at least mutualizing them among students.

Regarding contract-based education, which meets certain expectations of families, you will not discourage private institutions from establishing themselves in disadvantaged neighborhoods and, on the contrary, you will support such installation projects, when they exist, while respecting the national balance.

Without renouncing its traditional and undeniable factors of excellence, we want the school to present a new face, in line with certain modern aspirations of society.

You will first continue the effort to enroll children with disabilities in mainstream schools, successfully undertaken by the previous government. We want all children in the Republic to attend the same schools and grow up together.

Next, we want the place of sports in school to be doubled because sports is a school of life and develops valuable human qualities in the professional world and in adult life. It must be part of the foundation of knowledge and fundamental skills. For all families who wish, part-time sports should become possible.

We want cultural and artistic education to be significantly strengthened because it is a factor of individual and collective elevation, and, in a country like ours, attached to its language and the vigor of its culture, an element of national identity. You will create, for this purpose, mandatory education in the history of art and ensure the transmission of our country's literary heritage. The school of a great country must make great texts read. You will ensure that, from kindergarten to the baccalaureate, all students have an artistic practice. The artistic practice exam at the baccalaureate will be valued. Furthermore, you will encourage each school to establish links with a cultural institution allowing, among other things, exchanges between students and artists.

Finally, we wish for foreign language teaching to begin as early as preparatory class and for our education system to set the goal of ensuring that every student graduates from high school bilingual, as is the case in an increasing number of countries.

The implementation of these guidelines raises the question of the current scope of school programs and the excessive workload imposed on children, whose working days are sometimes longer than those of their parents. In fact, French children have heavier schedules than their foreign counterparts without this translating into a significantly higher general academic level. You will therefore open a reflection on how to reduce the hourly volume imposed on children while valuing collective and open activities, and without renouncing our essential requirements, particularly the acquisition by all children of the foundation of knowledge and fundamental skills. Greater autonomy for schools should allow each child to progress at their own pace and value all forms of intelligence. Our country urgently needs this.

We also want parents to be recognized as the primary responsible parties for their children's education and for the school to work more closely with families. You will ensure that parents are informed as quickly as possible of their child's difficulties, that their right to be received at their request and promptly by teachers and school administrators is respected, and that they are more involved in decisions regarding the organization of school life in the institutions.

Lastly, we wish for you to establish a much more substantial evaluation system for our education system. This should include four components: a systematic evaluation of all students every year, in order to immediately identify students in difficulty and provide them with help; a regular evaluation of teachers based on the progress and results of their students, rather than on the methods they use, supported by a real system of continuous training. Our teachers are seeking training, support, and advice. This is a form of consideration that we owe them; an in-depth evaluation of institutions, which will be available to families; and finally, an independent and regular evaluation of our entire education system, so that political authority can continuously make the necessary decisions to guarantee the quality of the school and its ability to meet the obligations and expectations of the contemporary world.

As you know, the presidential program must be implemented while scrupulously respecting our commitment to preserve the future of generations to come through rigorous management of public finances, in line with our European commitments and an essential component of the impeccable democracy we wish to establish.

Successfully implementing the reforms expected by the French people and stopping the spiral of debt are not at all incompatible, but are, on the contrary, two complementary objectives as long as it is decided to abandon policies that do not work in favor of policies that do. Distributing scarcity is as cowardly and ineffective as allowing public debt to run unchecked. If we want to profoundly change the structures and modes of intervention of public administrations, it is so that every euro spent is a useful euro and that the invaluable human potential of our administration is much better valued.

Starting this summer, a general review of public policies, similar to that carried out by Canada in the mid-1990s, will therefore be undertaken. It will be conducted, under our authority, by the Secretary General of the Presidency of the Republic, the Director of the Prime Minister's Office, the Minister of Budget, Public Accounts and Civil Service, the Secretary of State in charge of Forward Planning and Evaluation of Public Policies, as well as qualified individuals from the public and private sectors, and parliamentarians. The purpose of this general review of public policies will be to review, with the collaboration, of course, of the relevant ministers, each of the public policies and interventions implemented by public administrations, to evaluate their results, and to decide on the necessary reforms to improve the quality of service provided to the French people, to make it more effective and less costly, and above all to reallocate public resources from unnecessary or ineffective policies to those that are necessary and that we want to undertake or deepen. It is within the framework of this general review that the presidential commitment to hire one civil servant for every two retiring will be implemented and that our public finance objectives over five years will be pursued and achieved (reducing public debt to less than 60% of GDP, achieving budgetary balance, and as quickly as possible reducing mandatory levies with the goal of a four-point reduction over ten years).

We ask you to personally and unreservedly engage in this exercise, which should in no way undermine the mission that this letter entrusts to you, nor the priority that the presidential program gives to education within the framework of a civilizational project. The first major reforms resulting from the general review of public policies will occur as early as the preparation of the budgets for 2008. We emphasize that a good minister will not be recognized by the increase in their budget, but by their results and their contribution to the realization of the presidential project, including on the financial level.

On all the points of this mission letter, you will propose to us result indicators whose monitoring will be joint. We wish that among these, the reduction of school failure and illiteracy, the improvement of our ranking in the international evaluation of education systems, the reduction of educational inequalities, the increase of social diversity within institutions, the enrollment of children with disabilities, the strengthening of the evaluation system, the elimination of school ghettos, and the establishment of educational success boarding schools, the enhancement of the teaching profession, their continuous training, and the attractiveness of the teaching profession are included.

In connection with the Minister of Agriculture and Fisheries, you will ensure that these guidelines are also implemented within agricultural education, while preserving its specificity. On many points, the successes of agricultural education can indeed serve as a useful example for you.

We will take stock in a year of the progress of your mission and the adjustments that may be necessary.

In renewing our trust in you, we ask you to believe, Mr. Minister, in the assurance of our best sentiments.