Mission letter from Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. François Fillon, Prime Minister, addressed to Mr. Eric Besson, Minister of Immigration, Integration, National Identity, and Solidarity Development, regarding the implementation of immigration policy, March 31, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

31 March 2009

Context
Sarkozy and Fillon addressed a mission letter to Minister Besson on March 31, 2009, outlining five priorities for France's immigration and integration policy.
Main themes
Immigration control, integration policy, fight against illegal immigration, deportation and voluntary returns, border security, anti-trafficking measures, legal immigration organization, European immigration coordination, FRONTEX and EU border policy, biometrics and visa fraud, illegal work repression, solidarity development agreements
Duration
~25 min
75th percentile
Words
2,981
75th percentile
Sentences
123
73rd percentile
Readability
32
20th percentile
Grade
14.7
73rd percentile
Syntax
3.06
56th percentile
Vocabulary
2.35
83rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 44%41%
  • Institutional 22%20%
  • Geopolitical 19%18%
  • Economic 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 3%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

123 sentences in 58 paragraphs

Mr. Minister,

The establishment of a balanced, fair, and firm French immigration and integration policy, ensuring both control of immigration and the effective integration of migrants, is one of the priorities of this five-year term.

Over the past eighteen months, the work accomplished has been considerable.

As of January 1, 2008, the central administration of the Ministry of Immigration, Integration, National Identity, and Solidarity Development was created, which now covers the entire journey of a foreigner applying for immigration to France, from reception at the consulate to integration into our country and the eventual access to French nationality, or return to the country of origin. Its creation represents progress for foreigners who, respectful of our values, wish to integrate into the national community.

The fight against illegal immigration has yielded satisfactory results: the number of deportations effectively carried out in mainland France for the year 2008 reached 20,000 for forced removals and 10,000 for voluntary returns. Furthermore, the efforts made in the fight against the trafficking of illegal migrants and the repression of illegal work have led to significant successes.

The rebalancing of work immigration and family immigration is underway.

The signing of about ten agreements for the concerted management of migratory flows and solidarity development with countries of origin marks an important step in establishing an immigration policy based on cooperation with them.

Finally, the adoption of the European Pact on Immigration and Asylum, within the framework of the French presidency of the European Union, represents a decisive advance in the coordination of policies at the European continent level.

I ask you to consolidate these successes and to organize the action of your ministry around five priorities:

1. The first is to strengthen the fight against irregular immigration, particularly emphasizing the repression of trafficking, and to organize legal immigration.

In this regard, I have a fundamental concern: the republican law must be applied, with humanity, but also with firmness and rigor. Determining who has the right to reside in its territory and under what conditions this right can be granted is the very foundation of a state's sovereignty.

The issuance of the long-stay visa granted by the consul, in relation to the prefectural authority, stands as the only act of sovereignty by which the government authorizes a foreigner, before their entry into the territory, to settle permanently in France. Regularizations, which by definition deviate from this, must remain exceptional. Foreigners in an irregular situation on national territory are meant to return to their country of origin, preferably through voluntary return, or, failing that, through a forced removal measure.

I ask you to aim for a target of 27,000 removals, voluntary returns, or forced deportations of migrants in an irregular situation. In 2008, one-third of departures occurred under voluntary return assistance. I invite you to explore all possibilities to make this procedure even more effective.

I wish for you to propose to me in 2009, particularly within the framework of the transposition into French law of the return directive, measures to improve the border removal procedure and simplify its litigation, and to optimize the use of biometrics to reduce short-stay visa fraud.

Likewise, it seems essential to me, in respect of France's European commitments, to take all measures to increase the effectiveness of border control, whether at the internal borders of the European Union or its external borders. Based on the European Pact on Immigration and Asylum, I ask you to continue the work accomplished to finally equip the European Union with an effective and secure common border, notably by strengthening the FRONTEX agency and affirming the responsibility of each member state towards others in controlling its share of the external border.

I wish for you to give a new impetus to the repression of clandestine immigration networks at the national, European, and international levels, through the mobilization of all means of police forces and judicial and police cooperation, against all those who exploit misery in an undignified manner and encourage the rise of a new form of slavery. The objective must be to significantly increase, each year, the number of smugglers and exploiters of illegal immigration apprehended and sanctioned. In 2008, 4,300 people were apprehended for acts of illegal assistance to the entry and stay of irregular immigrants. I ask you to aim for a target of 5,000 apprehensions for the year 2009.

Similarly, it is necessary to strengthen operations aimed at repressing the use of irregular foreign workers by certain companies: the principle of zero tolerance must be applied to the employers concerned, ensuring, with the Keeper of the Seals, Minister of Justice, that effective legal consequences are given to operations against the illegal employment of foreigners. You will increase the number of joint control operations from 1,220 in 2008 to a minimum of 1,500 in 2009.

It will also be your responsibility to continue the rebalancing between professional and family immigration.

The control of family immigration, in respect of France's international commitments and republican principles, must consist of strengthening the fight against abuses and fraud, particularly sham marriages, forced marriages, or situations of illegal immigration leading to regularization for reasons of private and family life. It is essential to continue and intensify the work accomplished in this regard.

You will want to pursue a targeted and controlled resumption of work immigration. In the current employment context, and given an unemployment rate of 22.2% among non-EU foreigners according to INSEE, any prospect of a global, massive, and undifferentiated revival of work immigration must be firmly ruled out. The absolute priority must be to return to employment for those who are deprived of it, thus, in your area of competence, the employment of foreigners in a regular situation in France. The recourse to work immigration must occur only for two specific objectives:

- to fill jobs when companies face a structural, lasting, and certain labor shortage in the French and community labor market, avoiding any displacement effect on unemployed individuals in the French labor market;

- to bring to France individuals whose arrival is proven to be beneficial for dynamism and job creation in our country.

Professional immigration must be considered in all its forms: foreign employees, seasonal workers, "skills and talents" cards. I ask you to focus this opening on the development of mobility and circulation immigration, the movements of comings and goings, in order to combat brain drain in the most disadvantaged countries, through circulation visas, seasonal residence permits, as well as all legal solutions allowing mobility without granting the right to permanent residence.

I ask you to intensify efforts in favor of welcoming foreign students. France must be able to welcome at least 50,000 foreign students each year, diversifying its recruitment sources on a global scale. You will want to aim for a rate of 70% of these students in disciplines essential to the economic development and well-being of the populations of their countries of origin, and prioritize their return to their country of origin, while ensuring the possibility of unhindered movement between it and France. To this end, you will participate, alongside the ministers responsible for Foreign Affairs and Higher Education, in the establishment of a single operator for student mobility, replacing the current actors (Campus France, Egide, and France Coopération Internationale).

2. The second priority is to strengthen our asylum policy.

The purpose of our asylum policy is to protect individuals who are no longer protected by their own state. The republican tradition of asylum is a legal imperative as well as a moral requirement. This tradition, we honor. In 2008, both in terms of the number of asylum applications submitted and decisions made by the French Office for the Protection of Refugees and Stateless Persons (42,000), and the overall acceptance rate of applications (36%), France ranks first among the countries of the European Union.

However, the sharp increase in asylum applications recorded in the second half of 2008 risks putting this procedure under strain. I ask you to take all necessary measures:

- on the one hand, to continue to effectively combat abusive or fraudulent asylum applications and, in general, against the misuse of the asylum procedure for economic immigration purposes;

- on the other hand, to reduce the processing times for asylum applications, which are excessive.

Finally, I ask you to play a leading role in the discussions regarding the "asylum package" presented by the European Commission in December 2008.

3. The third priority is the establishment of a new integration policy.

The integration policies pursued over the past thirty years in France have not achieved their objectives. More than 60% of foreigners are settled in three regions (Île-de-France, Rhône-Alpes, Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur). In these regions, the immigrant population is concentrated in neighborhoods often marked by urban tensions and the excesses of communitarianism. Several recent events in these neighborhoods show how the feeling of relegation can overshadow the sense of belonging to our national community.

The reception and integration of immigrants legally admitted to our territory is, however, a republican requirement. France cannot indiscriminately welcome all those who wish to settle here, precisely because it must properly welcome those to whom it has granted the right of residence. Firmness in the fight against illegal immigration and the quality of reception and integration of legal immigration constitute two sides of the same strategy.

This new reception and integration policy must be based on three essential pillars: the sharing of the French language and the values of the Republic, work, and housing.

The objectives of this new policy must be debated in Parliament. I ask you to propose solutions so that each year, starting in 2010, an annual debate is held in Parliament on the orientations of the Government's reception and integration policy. The debate will be informed by a report from the Government on our country's reception capacities, particularly in terms of employment and housing.

This new reception and integration policy will be implemented in a spirit of transparency. Despite undeniable progress, French public statistics remain deficient in terms of immigration. France does not have a coherent estimate of its migratory balance, nor of the place of populations from immigration in the economy and society. One of your priorities will be, during the year 2009, to provide France with more effective immigration and integration statistics.

You will ensure that each migrant benefits from individualized monitoring of their integration path: issuance of the long-stay visa subject to learning French and knowledge of the values of the Republic; granting of the ten-year residence permit subject to the conditions set forth by the texts; naturalization which must confirm the effective and complete integration of foreign nationals within the national community.

You will engage in reflection on the level of knowledge of French that the foreigner must be able to grasp as they progress through their integration path. In any case, the number of initial French language diplomas (DILF) obtained by newcomers must reach at least 90% of the individuals presented.

You will develop, in connection with the business world and social partners, measures facilitating migrants' access to the labor market in order to put an end to the phenomenon of massive unemployment among foreigners in France. Together with the minister responsible for Employment, you will conclude a framework agreement between Pôle Emploi and the French Office for Immigration and Integration (OFII) to achieve this objective. Furthermore, the skills assessment newly created by law must facilitate access to employment for new migrants. In 2009, 60,000 signatories of the reception and integration contract (CAI) must benefit from a skills assessment.

With the Minister responsible for Housing, you will also ensure the implementation of a proactive policy in favor of housing for people from immigration backgrounds, with the aim of combating the phenomena of urban concentration of these populations.

You will then pay particular attention to the most vulnerable immigrant individuals, especially women and children, who are the most exposed to risks of violence and exploitation.

Together with the Minister in charge of Urban Policy and the Commissioner for Diversity and Equal Opportunities, you will finally propose measures to combat discrimination, whether it be xenophobia, racism, anti-Semitism, or the discrimination that people from immigration backgrounds too often face in recruitment and career advancement within companies. I wish for at least one hundred French companies to have obtained the diversity label established with AFNOR by the end of the year, and for state administrations to quickly commit to this labeling.

All of these measures will be the subject of an inter-ministerial committee on integration, which must meet before July 31, 2009.

4. The promotion of our national identity must be at the heart of your action.

We must be proud to have restored in France an open discourse on national and republican identity. You will continue this work, open and without taboos, reaffirming what it means today to "be French." For the feeling of belonging to a community of destiny, the will to live together, the sharing of this identity that is ours, with its culture, its history, its language, and the values that underpin it, constitute the condition for successful integration.

The promotion of national identity must address both migrants and all individuals living on the territory of the Republic, regardless of their origins, whether they are foreign or French. All are called to be citizens, adhering to the fundamental rights and duties of our republican pact. Citizenship is not a utopia that rejects the nation and the rule of law; it is the participation and active adherence to the rules that allow us to live together in our Republic.

By being proud ourselves to be French, we facilitate the integration of the foreigners we welcome. How can we ask them to love France if we do not love it ourselves? We must not only assume but also celebrate, in the eyes of the world and the new migrants, the pride of being French.

In connection with all the relevant Ministers, it will be your responsibility to initiate actions that promote the principles of the Republic and the fundamental values of our national community, fighting against all temptations of identity or communal retreat, reinforcing the place of the emblems and symbols of the Republic, its language, its flag, its anthem, the values contained in the motto "Liberty, Equality, Fraternity," and the Marianne who embodies them, wherever necessary, in schools and public places, in daily life as well as in the major events of our national life. You will participate, alongside the Minister responsible for Culture, in the establishment of the Museum of the History of France, which will help to bring our national identity to life for the general public.

Our Nation is mixed. Immigration is a source of permanent enrichment of our national identity. 100,000 foreigners acquire French nationality each year, representing 4.4% of the foreign population, compared to 2.2% in Spain and 1.6% in Germany. However, the timelines for the procedure for acquiring French nationality still seem excessive. The waiting time for a decision, whether favorable or unfavorable, exceeds one year in some departments. You will undertake the necessary actions to strengthen and simplify this procedure.

The France whose colors we defend is a France open to others, to the world, to the future. It is a France that evolves with its time. It is a France to which each newcomer, each new French citizen brings their story, the riches of their origin, their contribution.

5. Strengthening our policy of solidarity development must lead to a comprehensive approach to immigration, involving the countries of origin.

Continuing the efforts made since 2007, it will be your responsibility, in consultation with the Minister responsible for cooperation and the French Development Agency (AFD), to extend the agreements for the concerted management of migratory flows and solidarity development at a pace that allows us to reach about twenty source countries of immigration as signatories by 2012. The goal is to jointly organize with each country of origin an immigration policy that is consistent with the interests of each, and to continue implementing a solidarity development policy that closely associates the management of migrations with the development objectives of the countries of origin, particularly by stimulating their private sector and mobilizing the diasporas.

Since remittances to countries of origin exceed the total amount of our public development aid, I also ask you to consider solutions that better value the savings efforts of migrants, which are often considerable, and to promote the orientation of these savings towards projects that fully contribute to the development of their country of origin.

All of these actions must be framed within a European context. The existence of a vast area of free movement of people requires that the member states of the European Union act in concert in a spirit of solidarity and mutual responsibility. This has been the purpose of the initiatives we have taken during the French Presidency of the European Union. For the achievement of your objectives, you will therefore ensure that your actions are framed as much as possible within a European context. You will pay special attention to the effective implementation of the European Pact on Immigration and Asylum.

Moreover, the challenge of migration has become, alongside themes such as the environment, energy, climate, and food security, an essential subject of international relations in today's globalized world. This subject is increasingly appearing on the agenda of major international meetings. You will follow these debates with the utmost attention and will strive to make France's voice heard in international forums dealing with migration.

We are, as you know, facing a decisive challenge for the future of our country.

I ask you to establish a dashboard that is both comprehensive and synthetic of these various objectives and to report to me as well as to the Prime Minister at the end of 2009 on their implementation.

Please accept, Mr. Minister, the expression of my best sentiments.