Opening statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, at the summit with social partners, on measures to be taken to promote employment and protect the victims of the crisis, in Paris on February 18, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

18 February 2009 · Summit with social partners on measures to promote employment and protect the victims of the crisis · Presidency of the Republic (Élysée Palace), Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed employer and trade union leaders at the Élysée Palace on February 18, 2009, to discuss employment measures and crisis relief amid the global financial downturn.
Main themes
Employment protection, economic crisis response, social dialogue, stimulus measures, household support, unemployment, GDP contraction, social safety nets, social partners consultation, France's comparative resilience, pragmatic policy approach
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,722
83rd percentile
Sentences
181
87th percentile
Readability
50
64th percentile
Grade
11.0
33rd percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
45th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 47%47%
  • Social 26%25%
  • Institutional 21%20%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

181 sentences in 71 paragraphs

I wanted to bring together here, at the Presidency of the Republic, the most representative employer and trade union organizations at the national level, in the presence of the Prime Minister and the relevant ministers.

You remember, we held social agenda meetings in the same format a year ago. It was a first in our country. Never before had the President of the Republic brought together the government and social partners to jointly determine the program of social reforms to be carried out. From each of us around this table, it was a gesture of trust in social dialogue. And I believe we have succeeded in our bet because never has this dialogue been as intense as in the past year.

The meeting I propose to you today, which you prepared last week with the ministers, is of a different nature but its inspiration is the same. France is facing an unprecedented economic crisis, which raises the legitimate concerns of the French people. They do not know how long it will last. They sometimes fear for their jobs and for those of their loved ones. Some are on partial unemployment and wonder if they will be able to make ends meet at the end of the month. They feel they are paying for the excesses of financial capitalism, even though they are not responsible for it.

In these circumstances, I believe that social dialogue is more necessary than ever. You have your convictions, I have mine. Your role is also to express, if not to organize, discontent, and I understand that. But, in the interest of the French people and beyond our differences, we must work together on the solutions that will allow our country to emerge from the crisis.

The French situation is serious, but we are coping and we will come out of it better than other countries.

Yes, our economic situation is serious: in the last quarter of 2008, our gross domestic product contracted by 1.2%. This is the largest decline recorded in 35 years (1974). During the same period, we lost more than 88,000 jobs.

But if the French situation is difficult, it is even harder for our main partners. In Japan, activity contracted by 3.3% in the fourth quarter of 2008. This is the second largest quarterly decline since World War II. In the United Kingdom, GDP contracted by 1.5% in the fourth quarter of 2008 after 0.6% in the third. In the United States, 2.6 million jobs were lost in 2008, including 524,000 in the month of December alone. Spain lost 500,000 jobs in the fourth quarter of 2008, which is five and a half times more than France during the same period. The unemployment rate there is now approaching 14%.

France entered the crisis later than others and is weathering the storm better than its partners. I also note that household consumption rebounded in the fourth quarter, with growth of 0.5% after +0.1% in the third quarter, which is a fragile but encouraging sign.

I would also like to remind you that our country has the most generous social coverage in the world. It represents 550 billion euros, or 31% of GDP. When difficulties arise, safety nets and automatic stabilizers play a crucial role, much more important than in other countries, for example, Anglo-Saxon countries.

And we have already decided, in recent months, on many social measures in favor of households, particularly the most modest.

In September 2008, the pensions of 15 million retirees were revalued in advance by 0.8% and a new increase will occur in April, in light of inflation. In November 2008, the exceptional year-end bonus was increased from 152 to 220 euros for 1.5 million recipients of the RMI or specific solidarity allowance. In January 2009, 6 million families benefited from a 3% increase in family benefits - unprecedented in a long time - and 5.7 million tenants saw their housing assistance increase by 2.95%. In April 2009, 3.8 million modest households will receive a 200 euro active solidarity bonus, pending the implementation of the active solidarity income in July 2009. Starting in April 2009, a 4.6% increase in the allowance for disabled adults will benefit 820,000 people, and the minimum pension will increase by 6.9% for 400,000 isolated and disadvantaged retirees.

I believe that recalling these few figures is not unnecessary in the current period.

What we have implemented so far.

Before addressing the purpose of our meeting, I would like to share the state of mind that inspires the measures we have implemented so far. I am not dogmatic. Whether the stimulus is a matter of supply or demand, consumption or investment, is not very interesting. Frankly, is the scrappage bonus a supply-side or demand-side policy? Is the construction of 100,000 additional housing units consumption or investment? The only real question is whether it is effective and whether it has an effect on employment. That is the very purpose of the 26 billion euros of the stimulus plan. I sometimes hear: "Nicolas SARKOZY is a pragmatist." I am not sure that in the minds of those who say it, it is a compliment. For me, it is one. An effective solution, a solution that works, is a good solution.

The plan we are implementing defends employment through a vast effort of public investments of more than 10 billion euros, which will directly benefit the order books of our companies, create jobs, and improve the daily lives of the French people. Job creation is also purchasing power.

Our plan defends employment by supporting the cash flow of companies, particularly SMEs. We must not add to the difficulties of companies with banks by delaying the payment of debts that the State owes to companies. This is the key to ensuring that companies do not go bankrupt and that they continue to hire and invest.

Our plan defends employment by directly supporting two essential sectors of our economy: the automobile and housing. It defends employment by eliminating all social charges for hiring an employee for companies with fewer than 10 employees.

In recent weeks, finally, the State and social partners have adopted, each in their own capacity, initial measures to protect the most vulnerable, those who, due to the crisis, risk being the most threatened in their jobs, becoming permanently distanced from the labor market, or seeing their incomes decrease. I am thinking of the revival of subsidized contracts, the measures already adopted to provide more flexibility to partial activity and to increase compensation for employees. I am thinking of the professional transition contract and the personalized redeployment agreement, which you have renegotiated, in the interest of employees facing economic layoffs. I am thinking of your agreements on the forward-looking management of jobs and skills, unemployment insurance, or even vocational training.

On all these subjects, we have made progress together, at a sustained pace.

Objectives of the meeting

In my eyes, our meeting pursues four objectives. For each of them, I will tell you the proposals I am putting on the table.

The first objective is employment and what we can do to protect the victims of the crisis, namely the unemployed, workers on partial activity, precarious employees on fixed-term contracts or temporary work, and young people.

Regarding partial activity, I believe we can go beyond the measures that have already been taken in recent weeks. We could further improve compensation to bring it, for example, up to 75% of gross salary. It is not my intention to ask you to renegotiate the agreements you have just signed. However, I believe we could proceed through ad hoc agreements between the State and specific branches or companies, as we did for the automobile sector. To the extent that partial activity helps avoid layoffs, and thus impacts the accounts of UNEDIC, I would like to know if you would be willing to allow a State-UNEDIC agreement to distribute this additional cost between the company, the State, and unemployment insurance. We could also mobilize vocational training to prevent partial activity or to accompany it. Finally, some of you have indicated to the ministers that it should be possible for employees on partial activity to benefit from a modulation of their deadlines for repaying their mortgage loans. This situation is indeed not provided for in insurance contracts and can plunge entire families into great difficulties. I believe this is a good idea.

Today, the crisis is putting a strain on a number of precarious employees, particularly young people, who are the most exposed in the labor market. Thus, in the last quarter, most job losses occurred in temporary work (nearly 77,000 in the last quarter of 2008). The new unemployment insurance agreement you negotiated provides for the opening of rights to compensation after just four months of contributions. This is an improvement for employees compared to the previous situation (six months). But I believe that in these difficult circumstances we can do more. I propose that, as an exceptional measure, a bonus be granted to all employees who can justify between two and four months of work. This bonus could be 400 or 500 euros. Its funding would come from national solidarity and would be provided by the State.

Regarding young people, who will obviously be the first affected by the bonus I just mentioned, I believe we must mobilize all our efforts because they are particularly affected by the crisis. I am thinking in particular of targeted training efforts for those who are unqualified. I am thinking of the development of alternating training programs, which combine employment and training, and have proven effective (for example, the professionalization contract). It is also necessary for the public employment service to strengthen its follow-up of young people and offer them a specific range of services. Finally, why not consider asking companies that benefit from the credits of the stimulus plan to recruit and train young people?

I would like Laurent WAUQUIEZ and Martin HIRSCH to lead these initiatives together and for Martin HIRSCH to quickly open the consultation that I asked him to launch on youth.

I also know that several of you wish for better control of public aid to companies and the associated conditions. We discussed this together during the meeting we held on restructurings on January 13.

One possible avenue would be that when a direct aid is granted, whether it is from the State, the European Union, or a local authority, it immediately triggers an information-consultation process with the works council. This would allow the works council to issue an opinion on this aid as well as any conditions associated with it and to ensure its follow-up.

Still regarding employment, I understood that some trade union organizations wanted to be better involved upstream in restructuring operations and more broadly, in the economic strategy of companies. I also understood that the employer side would like to offer companies more legal security on these issues. I would therefore like you to indicate to me whether you plan to open discussions among yourselves to see if you are ready to negotiate on these themes.

Finally, you proposed the creation of a social investment fund, which could coordinate efforts in terms of employment and consolidate different sources of funding, whether from the State or social partners. This fund could reach between 2.5 and 3 billion euros. The State could cover half of it. In addition to the funding already available (stimulus plan, youth experimentation fund, European social fund, totaling 730 million euros), the State could contribute an additional 800 million euros to the employment credits of the stimulus plan, which would mean a contribution to the fund of just over 1.5 billion euros. I believe your organizations also wish for this fund to be managed by a monitoring unit, involving the different parties. The principle of this fund seems good to me, and I would be happy to hear how you envision it. Of course, I want to clarify from the outset that each party will retain responsibility for the funds it contributes.

The second objective of our meeting: justice.

First and foremost, in my eyes, are the questions of the distribution of added value and profit. You know that I am deeply attached to these issues because I believe in a fairer capitalism that benefits everyone.

That is why I was very attentive to the vote on the law in favor of labor income on December 3. This text allowed:

- to strongly encourage profit-sharing, through a tax credit of 20% on the increase in distributed amounts (which are also not subject to employer social contributions).

- to encourage companies to negotiate or renegotiate quickly their profit-sharing agreements by allowing them to pay a bonus to their employees in the first half of 2009, benefiting from the same advantages. I ask companies to make extensive use of this provision, for which an assessment must be made before the end of the first half to determine if other, more stringent measures are necessary.

- to condition the benefit of general reductions in social charges ("FILLON reductions") on, on the one hand, the opening of annual wage negotiations in companies, and, on the other hand, branch minima at least at the level of the minimum wage.

But I believe it is possible to go even further by broadly reasoning about the respective shares that go to employees, shareholders, and the company itself through investment. That is why I propose two avenues.

First, I would like to entrust a person whose work on the subject is recognized - I am thinking of Jean-Philippe COTIS - with the task of leading a mission of analysis and consultation, which would involve you, on the sharing of added value in our country and its evolution, both for the private sector and for public enterprises.

Secondly, I believe the time has come to encourage companies to address the issue of profit sharing with their employees. This year, dividends from companies in the CAC 40 are expected to be slightly above 54 billion euros. Of course, this concerns only forty large companies. Of course, the profits that are the source of these dividends have not all been made in France, far from it. Of course, when you are a global company, you must also think of employees who are outside France, and you must not neglect to invest to prepare for the future. But I understand that these figures shock our fellow citizens in the current period.

I therefore ask you to engage in discussions among yourselves, employers and unions, on the themes of value sharing - based on the analysis that Jean-Philippe COTIS will provide me within two months - and profit sharing.

Always keeping in mind this objective of justice, I would like to propose a measure of exemplary behavior regarding executive compensation. This seems particularly necessary in the current period. It is not normal that at the bottom of the scale, people suffer, while at the top, when one has significant responsibilities, nothing changes.

I have already asked the leaders of banks that benefit from public aid to cope with the crisis to renounce their variable compensation, that is to say, their bonuses. I wish that the corporate officers of companies do the same when their companies resort massively to partial unemployment or decide on large-scale economic layoffs.

The third objective of our meeting: the protection of the most modest within the middle class.

The latter are indeed often affected by the crisis and are also too often above the thresholds that would allow them to benefit from social benefits intended for the most disadvantaged.

I mentioned, on February 5, several avenues regarding the measures we could take. In my opinion, I believe we must mobilize all of them, but I await your reactions on this point.

The first avenue consists of the elimination of part of the income tax for individuals subject to the first tax bracket, that is to say, the one at 5.5% (taxable income between 5,850 and 11,670 euros).

As you know, tax matters primarily concern Parliament. Before the government's proposal is submitted to it, I would like to know your opinion on three points:

- do we limit the measure to a single provisional payment, that payable on May 15, or to the two remaining provisional payments due in 2009? For your information, the average gain per household is 100 euros for each of these payments.

- who are the beneficiary households: only the 2 million households that actually pay tax in the first bracket, or also those who are theoretically in the first bracket but who, due to a reduction or tax credit, do not pay tax? This would then represent a total of more than 4 million beneficiaries. To give you an idea, the elimination of the last two payments of 2009 for the first category (those actually paying tax) would represent a cost to the state finances of 400 million euros, and for the 4 million households I just mentioned, 800 million euros.

- should we not avoid threshold effects for households whose income slightly exceeds the limits of the first tax bracket? A tax credit mechanism could allow this by reducing the tax for 2 million additional households at a cost of 300 million euros.

The second avenue concerns families. I am not in favor of a measure that would concern family allowances because it would be a general measure that would also benefit the highest incomes. However, I see two possible options.

The first would be to pay a bonus to the 900,000 large families, that is to say, those with three or more children, who benefit from the family supplement. This supplement, which is currently 161 euros per month, could be doubled starting next June, at a total cost of 140 million euros.

The second option, which is my preference, consists of a broader targeting, that of the 3 million families with school-aged children who currently benefit from the back-to-school allowance. A bonus of 150 euros per family could be considered for a total cost of 450 million euros.

The third measure I mentioned on February 5, which I believe has interested several of your organizations, would consist of the possibility of vouchers for personal services (home help, childcare, tutoring, cleaning). Again, several categories of beneficiaries are conceivable:

- the 660,000 households benefiting from the personalized autonomy allowance at home, who need help at home.

- the 470,000 families benefiting from the childcare supplement earning less than 43,000 euros per year, who need help to care for their child.

- the 140,000 households that have a disabled child.

- I also think of job seekers who find work and need temporary solutions for childcare. An envelope of these vouchers could be entrusted to Pôle Emploi for their benefit.

Depending on the solutions we choose, the cost of these measures will be between 850 million euros and 1.850 billion euros. If we add the additional contribution of the state to the social investment fund (800 million euros), the total of my proposals amounts for the state to a sum that could be between 1.650 billion euros and 2.650 billion euros.

The fourth and final objective of our meeting is to place the year 2009 under the sign of social dialogue.

First, I wish to create, with social partners, a committee to evaluate and monitor the crisis and the economic and social policies being implemented to combat it. I will preside over the first meeting. Then, I wish to discuss with you, on a date I will propose soon, the measures that France and its partners will propose at the G20 in London on April 2.

Moreover, the monitoring unit of the social investment fund will also allow for close involvement of all stakeholders in employment policies.

Finally, I want us to discuss the social agenda for 2009. I am aware that this agenda is less connected to current events and therefore has less of an urgent character. However, I believe we can usefully say a few words about it so that the work can be launched. Brice HORTEFEUX has discussed with you three series of themes:

- first, those related to negotiations already underway or that must take place by mid-2009. I am thinking of negotiations on complementary pensions AGIRC/ARRCO, on social dialogue in very small enterprises (extension of your common position on representativeness), and on occupational health.

- then, new negotiation themes that could be considered: for example, corporate governance, which raises the question of the place of employee representatives in decision-making, but also the modernization of representative institutions.

- finally, themes that could lead to consultation (and not negotiation) before a draft law or a decision by public authorities: this would concern equal pay between men and women and the modernization of labor court elections (to draw lessons from the low turnout in last December's elections (25%)).

The conduct of the meeting.

I therefore propose that we structure our meeting into two sequences. If you agree, each will be an opportunity for a roundtable discussion.

The first block of themes I wish to address concerns the measures we could take to continue promoting employment and protecting the victims of the crisis. The second block of themes would focus, on the one hand, on the measures of justice that could be implemented and, on the other hand, on the social agenda program for the rest of the year.

Based on our exchanges, I would like, at the end of our meeting, to be able to announce a number of concrete actions for our fellow citizens. Of course, other subjects will require further instruction, and we will continue our work in the coming weeks. I add that on the themes that concern the public service, they will be discussed next week during bilateral meetings between the concerned ministers, Eric WOERTH and André SANTINI, and the civil service federations. Finally, I add that I will meet tomorrow with parliamentarians as well as the presidents of regional and departmental executive bodies from overseas to review the situation in these territories in the context of the economic crisis and discuss the prospects for renovating public policies in overseas territories.

If that suits you, I now leave you to react to the first block of measures.