Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, and Mr. Gordon Brown, Prime Minister of the United Kingdom of Great Britain, notably on Franco-British relations, financial regulation, and the fight against climate change, in Évian on July 6, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

6 July 2009 · Press conference with the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom · Évian, France

Context
Sarkozy and Brown held a joint press conference in Évian on July 6, 2009, ahead of the G8 summit, discussing bilateral cooperation and global priorities.
Main themes
Franco-British relations, financial regulation, Pittsburgh G20 summit, climate change and environmental policy, global governance, World Environment Organization, carbon tax, anti-protectionism and WTO, Iran solidarity, defense and nuclear cooperation, G8 ambitions, industries of the future
Duration
~37 min
89th percentile
Words
4,477
89th percentile
Sentences
249
93rd percentile
Readability
64
93rd percentile
Grade
8.7
9th percentile
Syntax
2.82
24th percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
7th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

249 sentences in 58 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - Ladies and gentlemen, we have just concluded a working meeting with the British Prime Minister. I want to, of course, welcome him to France, as well as the important delegation accompanying him.

I must say that the more we work together, the more there is a convergence of views between our two countries. Total convergence to say that the Pittsburgh summit must be ambitious. We do not want things to return to how they were before after the crisis. The United Kingdom and France, we are asking that the Pittsburgh summit be ambitious and that we achieve results in terms of regulation. We do not want Pittsburgh to be less ambitious than London was, remarkably chaired by the British Prime Minister.

On the G8, we will both fight for the ambition of the G8 in terms of development and the fight against climate change to be great. We will not be satisfied with long-term, very long-term goals. We want medium-term goals to ensure their credibility.

I was very happy, by the way, to talk with Gordon BROWN about the World Environment Organization. I believe I can say, at least in principle, that he supports this proposal and we will work together on environmental taxation, on carbon tax.

I told Gordon BROWN that naturally we are in favor of an agreement at the WTO, that we do not want protectionism but that we want fair competition, not unfair competition. On these two fronts, I believe I can say that there is total agreement.

We are also determined to move global governance, in all its aspects: the IMF, the Security Council, the G20.

We discussed many other bilateral issues: nuclear, defense cooperation. I take this opportunity to say under the control of both foreign ministers that we are totally supportive of our British friends regarding the Iranian leaders and that they can count on our total solidarity. We will do what they wish and we have been particularly shocked by the very unjust, disproportionate attacks against the British Government. Truly, the Iranian people deserve better than today's leaders. I want to reiterate this in the clearest terms.

We will continue to work together, and it may be that at the G8, Gordon BROWN and I will speak to the press together about proposals that we will put on the table, particularly on the climate issue.

In summary, before giving the floor to Gordon BROWN, we believe that this year 2009 is decisive in terms of regulation, in terms of new global governance, and in terms of the fight against climate change. And we will move things forward together.

MR. BROWN - I will start by saying how happy I am to be in Evian today with my friend President SARKOZY, to be here with his team of ministers, to be able to work together on common projects.

I would like to pay tribute to President SARKOZY for he has presided over the EU in difficult conditions but also the G20. He wants to make this world a more prosperous and greener world, and I commend you for your determination. You are a true force of nature, my dear friend.

We have a shared history, a shared geography, we share the same values, and we also have the same strategic objectives. 105 years ago, the Entente Cordiale was signed. Last year, we spoke of the "wonderful understanding," and today, I think I can speak of the "wonderful understanding in the sun," especially since we have a truly magnificent day today.

Relations between France and Great Britain have never been better. But the world has changed in recent months, and we must react. That is why President SARKOZY and I are looking not only at how we can recover from the financial difficulties of the past year but also how to establish rules to ensure the global economy, and that is what results from today's discussions. We will work hand in hand.

You have set up a commission for the industries of the future. We will look at the strategic sectors on the British side, see where, with businesses, we can ensure results, whether in biotechnology, in digital technology, in carbon production, and notably, I think of electric cars. So, in all these areas, we will work together to ensure the future, thus biosciences, biotechnologies. I think our ministers will be given a mandate to see how to cooperate in the future and also ensure that the world can regain its strength.

As for the G8 and the G20, we must take all these issues facing our global economy very seriously. Regarding growth, I believe it is a significant wake-up call for the global economy. Reforms must be implemented, those that have already been agreed upon, but there are others that will need to be finalized.

Regarding bank lending, banks must respond to the situation, where industries, businesses, and the world of commerce need banks.

We must also work towards a long-term stabilization of oil prices, and we have seen this increase in oil prices over the past few years. We must react against protectionism where we indeed see it increasing by 20%.

And then, we must also do what is necessary for our populations to ensure employment and create jobs in such a difficult period. We are all aware of the ethical issues related to this financial crisis; better management is needed, and reforms accepted during the G20 must be implemented, and we must continue to work together. We must accelerate the pace of reforms, particularly when it comes to tax havens, where transparency rules are not yet being respected. Therefore, a global response will be necessary.

There must be a full and complete exchange of data to ensure better health for the global economy. Let there be no doubt: there will be no more tax havens by March 2010; there will be a deadline for the introduction of sanctions such as, for example, reviewing investment policies, imposing deadlines, or withdrawing aid.

So, we also talked about bilateral issues where our two countries are involved. Ban Ki-moon reacted last week to the Burmese junta, and by the way, President SARKOZY and I are looking at what needs to be done to ensure that Aung SAN SUU KYI can be released.

I am very grateful to President SARKOZY for mentioning all those who are detained in Iran. We agree that the outcome of the elections belongs to the Iranian people; we do not want to intervene, of course, but the unjustified expulsion of foreign diplomats, the detention of employees of banks, embassies seems entirely unjustified, therefore, President SARKOZY, I am very grateful for your position. It must be made known that if this action continues and if we must react, we will react together with our European partners. President SARKOZY and I share a common vision for the future. We have shared values, Great Britain and France, which want better institutions at the global level, and Great Britain and France will continue this alliance that strengthens day by day. Thank you.

QUESTION - A member of your government, Peter HAIN, says that public spending in the United Kingdom will have to be limited after the next elections. Is he right? And if so, what is your proposal? I will ask President SARKOZY a question about VAT. You had a critical position; is that position still as critical?

MR. BROWN - We are moving towards growth; we have published our figures for the years after 2011, and we have an increase. And if we can also reduce unemployment and inflation, well, that will correspond to our objectives, which is to have indeed more resources, and regarding growth for the economy of the future, we will look at businesses, biotechnologies, digital technology, nuclear, carbon, all of this, all these industries that can enhance the future, which will therefore increase revenues and thus, consequently, fuel public resources.

THE PRESIDENT - Because it is very important for me to give my full support to the British government's position on the need for stronger global initiatives to find growth. We cannot afford several years of stagnant growth. In the same way, I share Gordon BROWN's analysis that there needs to be a stronger economic strategy in Europe with greater coordination. Of course, we must fight against debt, of course, we must fight against deficits, but we will fight against debt and deficits through the return of growth and through savings on operations, that is perfectly clear. But if there is no return to growth, there will be no rebalancing. So yes, we must both fight to push countries that can do more.

As for France, what is our problem, and I will answer your question about VAT? Demand is holding in France, investment is declining. What is the strategy of the French government? To do everything to ensure that investment picks up, unlike our British friends. I do not have to pass judgment. The remark I made: it was the French Socialist Party that asked me to take the same initiative as the British government, but I pointed out that what was favorable for the British economy was not necessarily favorable for the French economy. With consumption increasing, I do not see why I should lower VAT on all products. On the other hand, we have something like less than 7% investment, so we have put everything on investment.

And by the way, I am very happy to tell you that regarding the borrowing we will undertake to finance the major investment expenditures of the future of France, the commission responsible for giving its opinion on strategic sectors will be chaired by two very talented individuals. I am very grateful to each of them for their acceptance: Michel ROCARD, who is a man for whom I have great admiration and who shows how the French government's political strategy of openness will not stop, because France needs to mobilize all its energies and talents in such a serious situation. And if there are talents on the left that can serve their country, my duty as President of the Republic is to call upon them. Frankly, that Michel ROCARD lends his experience and talent to the reflection on the next 20 years, what will be the strategic sectors in the next 20 years—I will not be here since it is limited to two terms as you know—but this is not a matter of left or right; it is a matter of experienced men and women who believe in their country, who think together. And I am very grateful to Alain JUPPE, who was Prime Minister under Jacques CHIRAC, for also bringing his intelligence and talent. This is a great change in France; I say this to our British friends, two men of the talent of Alain JUPPE and Michel ROCARD, one on the right, Prime Minister of Jacques CHIRAC, the other on the left, Prime Minister of François MITTERRAND, who have accepted at my request to chair a very high-level commission to reflect on what the strategic sectors are in which France must invest over the next 20 years. This should reassure the French people to know that there are men capable of rising above their partisan interests to think long-term about the right choices our country must make in terms of economic strategy and investment strategy. I will receive them at the Élysée in the late afternoon. They will present me with the conclusions of their work in November.

I think it is very important to mobilize a country beyond sectarianism, in a spirit of tolerance looking towards the future. And the future does not belong to one camp against the other. The future belongs to the whole country, and the crisis is serious enough and strong enough for everyone to rise above partisan interests, I assure you, that are not commensurate with the gravity of the crisis. Just as a left-wing Prime Minister and a French President who is not from the left work together, hand in hand. I said that I was not from the left to let you qualify me, of course.

QUESTION - My question is addressed to President SARKOZY as well as to Prime Minister BROWN. Did you talk today about the two files concerning EADS, namely the A400M and the A350? What are the positions of your two countries on the financing of these two projects, and are the positions of France and the United Kingdom moving closer on these files? Thank you.

MR. BROWN - We will have more detailed discussions.

QUESTION - Mr. Prime Minister, you tell us everything that is going wrong, the exchanges, and I feel that this somewhat contradicts what you said about the recovery. Are you saying that things will get worse before they get better? And Mr. President SARKOZY, you also mentioned that there would be a definition of medium-term objectives. Would that mean that some countries have not taken their responsibilities seriously after the G20?

MR. BROWN - When we met at the G20 in April, there were also immediate things to do. First, the stability of the banking system, new rules to be put in place in the financial world, addressing the problems where there had been a collapse of confidence, and then preventing economies from collapsing where there was a real risk of collapse if the IMF did not have the necessary resources to deal with this crisis. So those were the objectives set in April.

Now we are in July, preparing for the meeting in Pittsburgh in September. We need to be more ambitious; we need to stimulate growth.

We have stabilized the banking sector; now we need to work on lending, so we need a global approach, we need to put an end to the decline in trade, which is still 20% so far, we need to talk about commodities and see what the possibilities for growth are for the future.

What is the challenge? If we do not take further actions, in other words, if we do not act on the decline in trade and the decline in commodities, and if banks do not lend as much as they should, growth will remain weak. But if we tackle these issues, we will see growth return. And I am trying to show what still needs to be done. I am also trying to show that there are sectors in this new economy where France, Britain, and other countries can do very well. I think of the digital sector where thousands of jobs can be created in the future, at least if there are investments. I think of biotechnology, health; there are enormous possibilities for our countries since there is a possibility of exporting, and there is also nuclear energy, the carbon-free economy. And by working together on electric cars, we will be able to make rapid progress and arrive at products that consumers will want to buy.

And in all these areas, of course, we need to invest, and our two countries, Nicolas with the Commission he has just created, in Britain we have also put in place what is necessary to ensure that this growth occurs as quickly as possible.

So, yes, a number of things have happened this past year. We will need to work on oil prices; we will indeed need to implement job recovery. We had to stabilize the banking world first; now we will focus on growth, which is particularly important for prosperity, for employment, and of course for reducing the deficit and debt.

THE PRESIDENT - I find that in London, there has been significant progress, but Gordon BROWN and I believe that those who think that after the crisis they can go back to their little businesses as before will find us in their way. We will not accept a return to the situation before.

I will take an example: on tax havens, there is progress; they have felt the pressure, but they have moved from the blacklist to the grey list. They need to get off the grey list, meaning that now, concretely, tax transparency agreements need to be signed.

Secondly, on remuneration. These outrageous remunerations, the more one speculated, the more one was paid. That will not resume; we will not accept it. Because those trading rooms where people were paid unbelievably for risks that were themselves unbelievable, that is over. That is not what we think of market economy and capitalism. We do not want that. If some banks want to start paying like that again, then we will take much stronger measures.

People have suffered greatly from the crisis and continue to suffer from it; it is not so that a few months later, it starts again as before. Bonuses, remunerations that correspond to nothing... That one should be paid in capitalism when one creates value, yes; when one speculates, no.

And then thirdly, I believe we have stabilized the financial economy. There is the problem of the economy as a whole. There is still a lot to be done, and we want to implement it. We want Pittsburgh to have objectives as ambitious as London.

There you go, and since not all countries around the table are as enthusiastic about change, well, the United Kingdom and France are working hand in hand to push for change. I am aware that this is new, but that is how it is. I am very grateful to Gordon Brown, especially at the last European Council, for supporting European regulation. Everyone must make an effort. France must make an effort, the United Kingdom is making an effort, and together, we carry a message.

Europe must be present in the debate on the new global capitalism. There you go, and with Angela MERKEL, with Gordon BROWN, with a number of others, we are trying to promote a European model. No one is renouncing their convictions. That is what we are trying to do. They are fighting to make things move by taking risks.

QUESTION - On the fight against climate change, I have a question that you might find a bit easy, but I will ask it anyway. By coming here instead of going to London or Paris for this summit, there is pollution; I wanted to know how you plan to offset the ecological footprint left by this trip and, beyond this perhaps anecdotal question, I would like to know if in this fight against climate change, governments should not ultimately set an example, perhaps not by necessarily organizing a summit in Paris or London, but in other perhaps more emblematic ways?

THE PRESIDENT - It was difficult for Mr. Gordon BROWN to come by boat.

QUESTION - No, but in Paris.

THE PRESIDENT - It’s very interesting, but a newspaper had assessed my ecological footprint. It turns out that the plane I came in emits less CO2 than others. I will leave that to Gordon. You know, after all, if by meeting we can make global decisions, Ms. HADJAJE, do you think that is not better? Do you think that by staying quietly in my office or Mr. BROWN staying at 10 Downing Street, we will make things move? Do you think that this amuses us especially? Why do we do it? Because if we do not set an example, I say it, you know it, we talked about a subject which is ecological taxation, pollution taxation. The English already have ecological taxation. We are going to equip ourselves, with Jean-Louis BORLOO, with Christine LAGARDE, with an energy climate contribution. Do you think we can dispense with an exchange of information?

I was in Sweden on Friday. The Swedes have ecological taxation. I need to understand what the English are doing, what the Swedes are doing? Do we need to reinvent the wheel to create something else? Or should we harmonize things? So you can say: "Why did they come here?" We came here first because it is a very beautiful place, I thank the mayor, because I was supposed to come with the Ukrainian President a few months ago, I had to cancel at the last moment due to the crisis in Georgia.

It is extremely important for us to put our countries at the forefront of the fight. Why? Because ecological taxation internally, the question of carbon tax, I speak under the control of Peter MANDELSON, we are also bringing our positions closer together. What the WTO just said about the carbon tax: "We can only impose a carbon tax at the border of Europe if there is an energy climate contribution in each of our countries, first element. They are doing it; we will try to do the same. Second element, I must convince my English friends that this is not a protectionist desire of France, but a desire for fair competition. When I propose in Geneva, -sorry for my carbon footprint! - a World Environment Organization, I must explain to Gordon BROWN what I have in mind. And when he says: yes, I understand, in principle, I agree." Don’t you think that makes a lot for the balance of the world? For the fight against climate change? Do you think it is enough for me to pick up the phone! With things like this, we talk about it.

MR. BROWN - I was wondering if it would be better for me to stay here for two days and then go to Italy rather than go home. You raise a very important point regarding the very purpose of our meetings. And I am convinced that we can make progress. Of course, we need to reach an agreement on this fight against climate change, that is, by December, there are only six months left. We need to agree on intermediate objectives. We should not only agree on long-term objectives. This is true for Europe; it is true for the whole world. We need an agreement on how we can also help developing countries or emerging markets that are not yet able to make all the necessary investments. We absolutely must achieve our objectives in terms of carbon emissions. So, we have very little time left. We must work together quickly; it is obvious. International agreements will be needed. Italy will also help us. The G20 in Pittsburgh will help us. But, there are only a few weeks left before our meeting in Copenhagen, so to speak. And we absolutely must reach an agreement. And if it were a failure, it would be a terrible blow for the movement, for ecology.

And so, meetings like these, we actually spent most of our meeting talking precisely about this point, carbon emissions, climate change. And how to combat all this? It is a very important point. I am absolutely sorry; I am not sorry for having spent time here because this meeting is quite successful.

QUESTION - Mr. President, I wanted to know what you thought of the statements, the revelations in the press about the monks of Tibérine; do you also believe in a possible blunder by the army?

THE PRESIDENT - The Algerian army? It is a tragedy that deeply moved me. I was in Tibérine myself a few years ago. And I even cited the testament of the superior of the Tibérine convent in my inaugural speech for the presidential election. Now there is an investigating judge in charge of this case. Justice is being served. The statements of this witness were made before a judge. Let us allow justice to do its work. What can I say now? If not complicate the work of justice. And we will see at the end of this investigation what will happen. Let justice do its work, go all the way to the end of its work. And I have no other comment to make.

QUESTION - A question regarding the price of oil. Mr. BROWN and Mr. SARKOZY, you mentioned changes in oil prices. Last Friday, a trader made a small move on oil prices, which suddenly increased by several percent. What do you plan to do? You mentioned, Mr. SARKOZY, discussing it at the G8, that is, perhaps limiting or bringing a range on oil prices. Mr. BROWN, do you agree to impose a limit on oil prices? What do you plan to do?

MR. BROWN - This is a huge problem we are facing. $150, $35, $75; it is the most important commodity the world needs, but it is also the most volatile, the most unstable. We need to understand the causes, what can be done to change all this, and how the global economy can continue to grow without this instability, this volatility in oil prices. We will need to discuss this with OPEC, with the Saudis. We will need to discuss this with our other partners in the G8 and G20. We will have to do something. Certainly, to see what the demand will be and what the supply will be. So, we need a discussion to better understand the demand side and what the supply side will also be. Previously, there was a certain price level in dollars for oil. This is something we might consider for the future. We will need to work on it. There should be fair speculation in the oil market. We will need to look at mechanisms that exacerbate this phenomenon. And we will also need to be prepared to react.

And then, we also need agreements to see how to move from dependence on oil to other sources of energy. This is why the United Kingdom and France want to arrive at a more balanced policy, and also to see how to increase renewable energies. So, being less dependent on oil, the price should be less volatile, thus a better alignment. And then also, to see what the other sources of energy are. It is true that the international community is concerned about price volatility, and President SARKOZY is indeed also a leader in this matter.

THE PRESIDENT - We will soon publish a contribution on this subject. We believe that it is not reasonable to allow speculators to artificially drive up the price of fossil fuels. We also believe that it is unreasonable to rejoice in an energy price that is too low, firstly because it could divert us from the necessity of saving energy. And secondly, we need to work with fossil fuel producing countries to try to stabilize, as Gordon BROWN has very well said, the price around a reasonable range, neither too high nor too low. The world will not recover from these yo-yos that swing from one excess to another. This is why, here too, states must take back control to try to bring about transparency and regulation.

Thank you all.