Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on efforts for financial stability within the European Union and the establishment of a financial transaction tax, in Brussels on June 18, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

18 June 2010 · European Council (Brussels summit) press conference · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference at the European Council in Brussels on June 18, 2010, outlining progress on financial stability, bank taxes, and EU economic governance.
Main themes
European economic governance, financial transaction tax, bank tax, eurozone stability pact, EU competitiveness gaps, G20 proposals, Van Rompuy working group, sanctions for fiscal non-compliance, growth strategy, eurozone vs. non-eurozone obligations
Duration
~27 min
78th percentile
Words
3,190
78th percentile
Sentences
161
83rd percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
9.6
17th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

161 sentences in 53 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

With your permission, I will hold a brief press conference because we are running late, thank you for your cooperation, and besides, tomorrow I will be in London, the day after tomorrow in Saint Petersburg, and if I could return to Paris where other files are waiting for me, I would see only advantages.

This European Council is a step European Council where we discussed a number of topics.

The first topic that is progressing well is the willingness of the entire Council to establish a tax on banks, which will be explicitly targeted in the text.

Secondly, and even more importantly, the European members of the Council will propose to the G20 the establishment of a tax on financial transactions regardless of its principle. We want to advance these two files.

Thirdly, we have all committed to ensuring that decisions aimed at strengthening financial stability are pursued alongside decisions aimed at increasing growth capacity in Europe. And, at lunchtime this afternoon, we discussed in some detail the working group led by Mr. VAN ROMPUY. Things are moving forward.

There is a considerable consensus on the need to strengthen the stability pact, a considerable consensus on the need to strengthen sanctions for those who, either preventively or subsequently, do not meet their commitments. There is a considerable consensus, fundamentally, to reduce competitiveness gaps between the different European economies.

We had a fairly in-depth discussion on all these topics. The idea that all these competitiveness issues cannot be solely the responsibility of finance ministers is also progressing, since, for example, social policy or university policy are not within the portfolios of finance ministers alone. Therefore, the idea that the Council of the 27 can define an economic strategy is an idea that is progressing well.

Finally, the idea that the sanctions and obligations of member countries of the eurozone are more significant than those concerning non-member countries of the eurozone is also progressing, which is logical. This does not mean that non-eurozone countries are not affected by euro issues, but it means that when you are in the eurozone, you must have stronger sanctions and monitoring rules than when you are simply among the 27. We had a fairly in-depth and broad debate. I believe that all of this is converging in the right direction, even if it is just an exchange and just a progress report.

We also agreed that the sooner the work of the VAN ROMPUY group is completed, the better, and we are aiming for October.

These are the few elements that I am able to share with you.

QUESTION -- There is a bit of a feeling that economic governance is essentially about creating a "bad cop" who will simply whip the naughty students, and it is hard to see the governance measures as such. We talk about competitiveness within the European Council, which is good, but the European Council decides by consensus, which is not really true governance. Shouldn't we take a further step, particularly, for example, by going further in the community of budgetary means, creating a somewhat larger, somewhat higher European budget?

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes, a federal state, a federal government, for example. And then, we need to decide it, Mr. QUATREMER! You are well acquainted with these issues, you know that Europe must progress step by step. What do I observe? The words economic government are no longer taboo, Mr. QUATREMER. You know perfectly well that this was not the case just a few months ago. Yes or no? We did not accept, we did not tolerate the idea of discussing economic governance. So, for you who do not like ambiguity, economic governance was the most total ambiguity. From now on, the words economic government are no longer taboo; on the contrary, everyone can see that.

Secondly, what do we include in economic governance? Not just budgetary and financial issues, but also growth strategies, tax strategies, competitiveness strategies. In short, everything that creates the conditions for strong and sustainable growth in Europe. I willingly accept the idea, Mr. QUATREMER, that this deserves further clarification. Of course, we are at the beginning of this concept. All of this is within a European Council that is based on a governmental organization, not a federal one. Governmental, with a practice of decision-making by unanimity. So, it is not very simple to advance all of this. But I find that it is progressing.

It is true that this idea progresses more at 27 than at 16 because it is always, and I understand it perfectly, the fear of European countries that you know very well, of being rejected into a Europe that would not have the same rights, which would be scandalous, or that would not move at the same speed, which no one can accept, or that would not have the same divisions, to use expressions from 15 or 20 years ago.

I am so committed to the idea of economic governance that I am ready, and I do, to agree that economic governance at 27 is something much more positive than the vague economic governance we used to talk about.

The idea is also progressing that this question of economic strategy must be carried by the heads of state and government, who alone have the inter-ministerial capacity to make decisions, even if it was the subject of a very friendly exchange with Jean-Claude JUNCKER, even if I see only advantages in having, for example, the analysis of competitiveness differences, Mr. QUATREMER, between the 27 and the 16, done by finance ministers. There is no need to have the analysis of competitiveness issues come from the heads of state and government.

Just as we discussed with President BARROSO, inter-ministerial capacity is the government council, the Commission proposes legislative texts, imposes sanctions, but national decisions made in the service of the European Community are taken by the heads of government.

And finally, I am trying to advance another idea, which is that sanctions must be stronger, more immediate, and monitoring more severe when one is a member of the eurozone than when one is not a member. Moreover, there is a second difference, when one has an opt-out clause, when one does not have an opt-out clause. Since, as you know, there are indeed three categories of countries: eurozone countries, 27 zone countries, and within the 27 zone, countries that have an opt-out clause, I am thinking of the United Kingdom and Denmark. The level of sanctions and monitoring cannot be the same.

There you go. All of this is progressing, and it should lead to the proposals of the VAN ROMPUY group in October. But you all are specialists; you know very well that the European process with 27 countries is an evolving process, always too slow in my eyes, but let’s say things: since the beginning of the crisis, it has indeed accelerated.

There you go, I believe that by saying this, I am trying to be as honest as possible. I will not lie.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, there are quite persistent rumors about the need for a financial aid plan for Spain. Should we be concerned today about the Spanish situation?

THE PRESIDENT -- No. You know the phrase, I believe it is Sacha GUITRY: "I love you very much," he said to one of his good friends. He replied, "But very much is so little." Any adjective to this no or any complement to this no would weaken the no. N.o.n, did you follow me? What I mean is, no, no, no, no. We have full confidence in the Spanish authorities, complete confidence in the Spanish authorities. And I cannot come once, we have a problem with this, a problem with that. No. We consider that there is no problem. This is an analysis that we are 27 making, very clearly. It is an analysis shared by the European Central Bank, by the Commission. There you go.

So, I mean when we add adverbs... absolutely no problem. So, I already see the dispatch and the market reaction. So, with the no, I reduce the dispatch n.o.n to the strict minimum.

QUESTION -- To try to lengthen the dispatch, have you talked about stress tests...

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes.

QUESTION -- stress tests on banks, in what way...

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes.

QUESTION - In what way will you conduct them...

THE PRESIDENT -- ...I ask you to note that there will be two dispatches, one with no, n.o.n, and one with yes. There you go.

QUESTION - ...will you conduct stress tests on public banks...

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes.

QUESTION - ... or the results bank by bank...

THE PRESIDENT -- ...Yes.

QUESTION -...In the entire European Union. All countries will do it?

THE PRESIDENT -- ...Yes.

QUESTION -...We are learning a lot. And will you present your pension reform as your partners say?

THE PRESIDENT -- No. Honestly, I did not think it would turn out like this. Frankly, I mean no. These are serious subjects, I apologize. On stress tests, yes, there is a decision to implement them, in all countries naturally. To clarify things, institution by institution, it is not global, it is institution by institution and because what is needed is to ensure transparency to reassure all observers and not continue to manage psychodramas one after the other like this, there you go, and, naturally, Arnaud LEPARMENTIER, publication. So, I will not go further. How are the stress tests constituted? Will you make the entirety of the questions public? That is another subject. But on stress tests, there is the answer and broadly speaking, before the end of July, I believe that the governor had announced it and I confirm it to you willingly. Before the end of July, which does not mean, perhaps some will go before.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, you spoke about strengthening financial stability, the stability pact as well. Does this involve for you a number of sanctions and which ones, especially? Does, for example, the "public debt" criterion matter, does the idea of targeting each national budget by the European Commission even before it goes before the European Parliament, has all this been agreed upon?

THE PRESIDENT -- No, nothing is definitively agreed upon, to be clear, this is a progress report, we are issuing a statement, there are a number of ideas that are retained but this will be the subject of a formal decision in October. Everything is still on the table. Regarding sanctions, with Mrs. MERKEL we have stated what we think. Seeing a country in excessive deficit and slapping it with a fine of several million or more euros does not seem to us to be the best way to improve its deficit and its accounts. Therefore, we proposed the suspension of voting rights for both. A number of countries have been very attentive to the fact that sanctions must be the same regardless of the categories of countries and that there should not be a more targeted policy than others. The support, development, cohesion funds...

The other question, what was it?

QUESTION -- So the public debt, should it ultimately be more important than a criterion?

THE PRESIDENT -- Public debt is an extremely important element since the progression is as follows: too much spending, not enough revenue, too much deficit, ultimately, too much debt. Sorry to explain it very simply, but that is still the case. We cannot oppose deficit and debt. Debt is merely the sum of deficits. Therefore, it is a priority. Of course, there has been a debate in which France did not participate about whether it is simply public debt, whether we should take into account private debt, household indebtedness, in short, all these criteria which are also questions of sustainability, to use the jargon. The exit point is not yet fully stabilized, but these are subjects that we discuss together and that we engage in.

So you ask me, "Will you present the French pension plan?" I remind you that pension plans are of course national decisions and not community ones. Even if of course, as all governments in Europe are confronted with the imbalance of their pension systems and that all governments in Europe have provided a demographic response to a demographic problem, and that all governments in Europe, whether left or right, have proposed an extension of working life, of course, this is an element that is in the discussion but not strictly in terms of community competencies. Perhaps one last question?

QUESTION -- Mr. President, regarding the European economic governance, José Manuel BARROSO said that the European Commission was actually there to hold this role of economic governance and that it was part of its prerogatives. In the European Parliament, the necessity was also emphasized; they recalled the principle of co-decision, and we have a bit of a feeling in your remarks that -- at least in your mind -- economic governance is primarily the responsibility of the heads of state. So can you clarify all of this for us?

THE PRESIDENT -- The Commission has an eminent role, and I attach great importance to everything Mr. BARROSO says, but I am sorry, it is not the Commission that is in charge of the competitiveness of the different member states of the European Community. I believe that by saying this, I am stating something that is quite reasonable. The decisions related to the competitiveness of each of the European economies are the responsibility of the Commission, but they are not its decision. The Commission ensures that there is free competition in the European market, the Commission oversees the application of sanctions, the Commission can send a signal to say, "be careful, you are not on track." But it is not the Commission that can make decisions in place of the member states regarding the economic policies that each of us must conduct, after all. Saying this seems quite reasonable to me, and I think President BARROSO fully agrees because he knows the function well. If we say, "the Commission is the economic government of Europe," then we are saying that the Commission can make decisions in each country to modernize research, to change social law in each country, to decide on the autonomy or not of universities. You can see that this is not possible. So what is true, President BARROSO is right, is that we all need to work together in the same direction, that is perfectly correct, but the decisions on competitiveness, for example, we were talking about pension reforms, who makes those decisions if not the governments? It is not the Commission that makes the decisions. The presentation of national budgets, who decides to present them before the national parliaments? It is the governments, it is not the Commission. It seems to me that this goes without saying; there is no need for us to debate this. As for the European Parliament, it has a very strong institutional role; democratically, it matters, you know that I myself have greatly enjoyed discussing with the European Parliament, and when France takes on the presidency of the G20, I will be very happy to go to the European Parliament to present the objectives; I believe that is very important. But everyone must do what they have to do.

QUESTION -- What message are you bringing to the G20, because it is not very clear on bank taxes?

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes, you are right; first of all, when you say it is not very clear, you are absolutely right, but it is quite complicated nonetheless. There are two different subjects: the first subject is the tax on banks, which will mainly fund a fund intended to assure taxpayers or savers that what happened will not happen again or to reimburse for the countries where the plan cost money, money that the taxpayer mobilized to save financial institutions; these are the two scenarios for the bank tax. In this case, for France, the banking plan not only did not cost money but brought in 2.4 billion, so a tax on banks, France is determined to implement a tax on banks and to create a fund, how do you say? insurance-like, well, in a way. This is the first subject that I believe has consensus; I think it is point 16 of the document. And then there is a second subject, which is the tax on financial transactions or on financial markets; the subject is not settled. Is it a tax on transactions, is it a tax on markets? This tax, Germany and France have made a major issue because naturally, for this tax to have its full effectiveness, it must be global. What we have said to our European partners, along with others, I mean within the Council, is that if Europe wants to have a chance to be heard, it must carry this message of taxing financial transactions. Some within the Council are not absolutely enthusiastic, fearing that financial transactions will relocate from Europe, where there would be this tax, to other places where there would not be. We have therefore decided that we would bring this debate to the G20 to try to achieve it and that we would make the decision based on the reaction of the major operators, the major players of the G20. But as far as Germany and France are concerned, we are in favor of this tax on financial transactions and even ready, we said in Berlin with Mrs. MERKEL, to consider its implementation even if some major player did not want it. This is not a point of absolute consensus in Europe; some governments among the most liberal see a number of problems with it.

QUESTION -- inaudible ... do we know more precisely what will be ...

THE PRESIDENT -- On sanctions, I refer you to the text of the document that will be published by Mr. VAN ROMPUY; it would not be courteous of me to do so before him ...

QUESTION -- On Iran ...

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes, do you think I am talking about whom? These are not sanctions against Mr. VAN ROMPUY, after all; I understood that it was about Iran. On the Iranian file, things are progressing since there was this decision from the Security Council, which I readily admit took time to reach, and we had indicated that once the decision was made at the Security Council, Europe would strengthen the sanctions process, which did not prevent us from welcoming in the document the Brazilian initiative to try to maintain a dialogue with Tehran. I have also seen the latest statements from Mr. AHMADINEJAD; it is absolutely necessary now that we have the sanctions to implement the sanctions and the dialogue. It is precisely because there are sanctions that we must strengthen the dialogue. And the sanctions, what we have all said, must serve to compel a dialogue. It is not sanctions and the absence of dialogue; it is sanctions to enhance the chances of dialogue.

Thank you all.