Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on Franco-Russian and Euro-Russian relations, the economic crisis, the regulation of financial markets, and on new global governance, in Saint Petersburg on June 19, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

19 June 2010 · Saint Petersburg, Russia

Context
Sarkozy addressed a forum in Saint Petersburg alongside President Medvedev on June 19, 2010, outlining Franco-Russian partnership and global financial reform priorities.
Main themes
Franco-Russian strategic relations, global financial regulation, economic crisis causes and lessons, new global governance, speculation vs. productive markets, tax havens, G20 cooperation, Europe-Russia partnership, financial market reform, role of experts in policymaking
Duration
~21 min
69th percentile
Words
2,560
69th percentile
Sentences
118
71st percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
10.6
28th percentile
Syntax
2.91
36th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
11th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 50%48%
  • Geopolitical 19%18%
  • Institutional 15%14%
  • Ceremonial 15%14%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

118 sentences in 20 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT -- Ladies and gentlemen, dear friends, it is first and foremost a great pleasure for me to be here in Saint Petersburg, Russia, alongside President Medvedev. I want to express my conviction that Europe and Russia must work together strategically, very closely, and in a relationship of trust. The Cold War is over. The wall is gone. Russia is a great power, we are neighbors, and we are meant to be friends. We must draw closer together. This is a deep conviction, which is accompanied by another conviction: I want to express how much I trust President Medvedev's word, how much I have appreciated being able to work with him at times when we did not spontaneously agree, but we managed to find a way together.

I want to testify that in the major international bodies, the positions of France and those of Russia are extremely close. I also want to commend President Medvedev's commitment on the Iranian issue, regarding the votes on sanctions. Nothing would have been possible if he had not taken on and made that choice. So, I want to say that being here at the head of an important delegation of ministers and business leaders is a strategic choice for me.

Secondly, the crisis. What happened? Why did it happen this way? And what lessons can we draw from it? I have no doubt that there will be many experts who will be able to explain to us why it happened, in retrospect, and who will tell us with great authority what we should do today, which is roughly the opposite of what they were telling us we should do six months ago. Six months ago, I could not attend a meeting without being told: your stimulus plan is insufficient, spend more. Now, before I even enter a room, I am told: spend less, you have spent too much. Let us pay tribute to the experts. I would simply like to tell them that their work is sometimes easier than that of the leaders we are, even if all advice is useful. I draw a conclusion from this: the first thing that is expected of a head of state or a head of government is that they remain calm to react and not overreact. Our countries are like your businesses; they cannot withstand the brutal shocks of a policy and a counter-policy. Coherence is necessary.

Why has the world experienced the most difficult and profound crisis of the century? It is because, from my point of view, we do not have either the global governance suited to the 21st century or the regulatory system adapted to globalization. What happened? The world has become a village, the economy has become global, and regulations have remained national. The imbalance is therefore not so much the market above, the regulations below, the market first, the regulations after, or never. This total absence of regulation has led to the following results: it was no longer the market that was functioning; it was speculation. When the market operates without any rules, when the world functions without any regulation, the market ceases to be the market; it is taken hostage by speculative activities, by the creation of limitless bubbles: internet bubbles, real estate bubbles, financial bubbles. Since everything had become possible, a number of operators took advantage of it and considered it normal to multiply their stakes by 10, 20, 30, 100, 1,000, without this corresponding to any scientific invention, any creation of value, or any growth strategy. To those who tell me: "we must let the market do its thing," I agree, on the condition that the market is not one of speculation but of production.

And on September 18, 2008, the astonished world witnessed the unthinkable: the bankruptcy of one of the largest banks in the world, American. Trust evaporated, and everything collapsed. Do not blame heads of state and government for thinking that those who led us to the brink of the precipice are not the ones who will explain to us how we will get out of it today. Naturally, we should not throw the baby out with the bathwater and consider that the absence of regulation should lead us to over-regulation and that the drama that came from the financial industry should lead us to eliminate the financial industry. Obviously not. But in the same way, let it be clear between us, we will not allow the same causes to produce the same effects. That would be unacceptable because those who are suffering from the crisis today, I mean our populations, I mean the peoples, are not responsible for this crisis. It is therefore unacceptable that they should pay the bill and that irresponsible behaviors should not be sanctioned, that we do not have the courage to assume that we will not let them do it again.

I will take a few examples. Tax havens: what would be the point of establishing rules for Russia, for France, for Europe, for the world, and allowing our own banks to invest, to open accounts in tax havens where they can avoid all forms of rules? That is why, with Dmitry, we fought at the G20 in London so that tax havens could no longer be a way for some of our own companies to exempt themselves from the rules that we otherwise ask people to respect.

The remuneration of traders: that some people make money, what could be more natural? That the remunerations are not the same, what could be more natural? But this idea of rewarding, in our banks, according to the risks they take with other people's money, no! If they want to earn a lot of money by taking risks with their own money, no problem. If it is to take risks with other people's money, no. We could multiply the examples.

And so next week, with Dmitry, we will fight at the G20 for the decisions we made at the G20 in Pittsburgh and at the G20 in London to be implemented by the G20 in Toronto. From this point of view, I say it, I take responsibility for it, I am clearly in favor of taxing banks. It does not seem abnormal to me that they themselves should help finance an insurance system. After all, it is not the taxpayers who should pay for this system. And secondly, a global system on the taxation of financial activities. I would be quite willing, of course, to explain this, but I do not want to be too long.

So, there is a first issue that is absolutely essential: a global market must correspond to a global harmonization of rules that allows for global regulation. Freedom is the respect of the rule of law. A rule of law is the respect of rules. The rules must be as close to each other as possible in the world. Freedom is not the law of the jungle. It is not the absence of regulation.

The second element, and this will be one of the themes of the French Presidency of the G20 and the G8, I have already discussed it with President Medvedev, we must urgently reflect on the foundations of a new international monetary system. We are operating under the Bretton Woods system, 1945, at a time when our American friends were the only great power in the world, when with the Marshall Plan, the dollar was the only currency in the world. I ask the question, are we in 2010 in the same situation as in 1945? The answer is obvious. And I told President Medvedev that I wished for Russia and France to lead the debate to organize the functioning of a new international monetary system that would allow you, business leaders, to compete on equal terms in the world without having to bear unbearable monetary dumping. It is not a matter of blaming some or reproaching others; it is about bringing the major players to the table and defining this new international monetary order. I remind you that at Bretton Woods, they took a year to establish this, which functioned quite well until the 1970s, if I remember correctly, when the problem of convertibility between gold and the dollar arose. The time has come to have the monetary system of the 21st century: regulation, a new monetary system.

I would like to raise a third issue that will be a priority for the French Presidency of the G20 as well as the G8, which is that of raw materials. I say this in Russia, a rich country, a country with exceptional resources and an almost infinite space, which understands something today about how the price of raw materials is constructed? And if there is someone in the room who is ready to answer this question, I would be very happy if they could reserve their knowledge for me through private lessons, which I am in urgent need of.

The price of a barrel of crude oil swings from one extreme to the other. Everyone panics when it is at 142 dollars, everyone rejoices when it is below 40. We are very wrong, because when the price of oil is too low, it is not good for research, and when it is too high, it is not good for growth. Contrary to what I sometimes hear, producing countries and consuming countries have the same interest in a minimum regulation. I could take many other examples that show that these markets are not transparent, do not obey the rules of the market but obey the rules of speculation. Here too, has the time not come, not to cap prices, that would be ridiculous, but to think about a system of regulation, transparency for agricultural products, for major fossil materials, a minimal organization that would benefit both producing countries and consuming countries?

Finally, the last issue, at least from my point of view, is global governance. It is quite spectacular to see that we have been in the 21st century for ten years without drawing any consequences from the change of century. The only consequence, ultimately, is the creation of the G20. I remember my surprise during the first G8 I attended in Heiligendamm, Germany, having spent two and a half very interesting days discussing with my colleagues and seeing the representatives of 2.5 billion inhabitants arrive on the third day for a lunch to which we could not devote more than an hour and a quarter of discussion. Who can seriously accept the idea that we can solve the world's major problems without asking the opinion of China, India, Brazil, and Mexico, and without taking into account a single African country, Africa counting one billion inhabitants today and in fifty years will count two? Who can think that this is reasonable, just reasonable?

Ultimately, we created the G20 because we believed it was necessary to involve these countries that demand their rights and are right to do so, but to whom we say, in exchange for these rights, that we require them to exercise their responsibilities. The UN system, to which we are attached, operates with impressive slowness. In fact, that is the only thing that is impressive. This strange idea that one can make decisions by total consensus among 192 countries is reaching its limits, as shown by the disastrous Copenhagen Conference. Therefore, we must change global governance.

In summary, we change global governance so that everyone is on board, we lay the foundations for financial and economic regulation to avoid catastrophe, we address the price of raw materials so that our economies are not taken hostage, and we lay the foundations for a new reform of the monetary order so that there is no dumping in this regard. Is this impossible? Is it dangerous? What is impossible is to remain still. The world is changing, and we would wait for the sky to fall on our heads. Is it dangerous? Less so than not drawing the consequences of the crisis, because if we do not draw the consequences of the crisis, you can be sure that it will happen again.

Finally, I would like to conclude by saying that today, we can reasonably be optimistic if we are vigilant, work together, and do what is necessary, both to reduce deficits and to not kill the growth that is returning, which is what we are currently doing.

And for us Europeans, I dream of a new organization that would bring together Europe and Russia in a gigantic common economic space where people and goods would move together and in which we would jointly organize our security based, by the way, on the proposals that President Medvedev presented on the subject when he came to Evian, I believe a year and a half or two years ago. The idea that Russia must defend itself from Europe and that Europe must defend itself from Russia is an idea that belongs to a completely bygone past.

The idea, on the other hand, that we are facing the same threats of terrorism, of the mafia, these threats that are the same, we must therefore confront them together — it is a forward-looking idea, it is a promising idea. I am not unaware, moreover, that we Europeans have a great effort to make to organize ourselves better. That was the meaning of your last question. But I ask you, my Russian friends, to understand one thing: Europe is a miracle, 27 countries as different as ours coming together to agree on everything. Can you imagine that it is easy? Do you believe that it happens spontaneously? 27 democratic countries that democratically decide to be together, to share their sovereignty on almost all subjects. Sometimes we hear: "your decision-making process is so long." That is true, but imagine having to decide only with 26 other countries. So it is true that we are pushing hard to have an economic government, we will get there. We already have the same currency among 16. And we have, after all, managed to establish a fund of 750 billion euros, more than what the United States has done, but by deciding it with all the Europeans. Sometimes I think that if we wanted to be objective about Europe, we would not be judged as if we were a single country but in light of the results achieved by 27. I can tell you that it takes a lot of effort.

So, ladies and gentlemen, I had prepared a speech that I will deliver to you in its written version, which has little to do with what I just told you in the oral version, but I thought, for my first trip to Saint Petersburg, alongside Dmitry, it was better that I really tell you what I think, rather than what my administration thinks very well. There is not much contradiction, by the way. To be honest, there is not much contradiction, simply what he would like us to do in 20 years, I would like us to do in 2 months. And when they consider it risky to move ten meters forward, I think we need to move ten kilometers. But, aside from those details, there is a very great harmony between what I had planned to say and what I said.

Thank you.