Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on efforts for the non-proliferation of nuclear weapons, in Washington on April 13, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

13 April 2010 · Nuclear Security Summit · Washington, United States

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference at the Washington Nuclear Security Summit on April 13, 2010, outlining France's commitments on nuclear terrorism prevention.
Main themes
Nuclear terrorism prevention, securing nuclear materials, non-proliferation commitments, IAEA cooperation, international legal accountability for state nuclear support to terrorists, nuclear security culture, bilateral disarmament agreements, tribute to President Kaczyński
Duration
~40 min
90th percentile
Words
4,844
90th percentile
Sentences
252
93rd percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
17th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

252 sentences in 65 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT -- Ladies and gentlemen, we have just concluded two days of useful discussions dedicated to the prevention of nuclear terrorism and, more specifically, to securing vulnerable nuclear materials. President OBAMA personally chaired all the sessions. He did so with great conviction and competence, keeping to the topics and the schedule. All the heads of state and government gathered here agree that the threat of nuclear terrorism is real, that it is global, that it affects the South as well as the North, and that no one is safe.

All the countries gathered here have agreed on the necessity of increased and permanent vigilance over stocks of nuclear materials, whether civilian or military, and over nuclear scientific know-how. At a time when civil nuclear power is being revived, all states must acquire a culture of nuclear security.

France has made commitments. France will host an IAEA evaluation mission on the effectiveness of these measures. And France will receive one at a nuclear site.

We will integrate nuclear security into all nuclear cooperation agreements with new countries. And we will offer training as part of our future International School, which I announced during the Civil Nuclear Action Summit that France hosted last month in Paris.

We support the IAEA and its Director General, Mr. AMANO, who plays a central role in the security of nuclear materials. We will go further in our cooperation with the Agency, as we will propose to the IAEA to identify and locate all radioactive materials it has exported worldwide in order to ensure their security.

Finally, we want to strengthen the major international treaties: we will accelerate the ratification of the UN Convention on the Suppression of Nuclear Terrorism and the revised IAEA Convention on the Protection of Nuclear Materials.

All the countries gathered here have made commitments, including an ambitious commitment to secure all vulnerable nuclear materials in the world within four years. I can only mention a few examples: Ukraine has committed to eliminate all its stock of highly enriched uranium by the next summit in 2012.

Several countries, such as the United Arab Emirates, Italy, and Japan, have committed to establish detection and protection systems at their ports and airports against trafficking in materials. The Russians and Americans have signed an agreement on the elimination of plutonium stocks from dismantled Russian weapons.

Other countries, such as Algeria, have announced the establishment of binding national legislation on nuclear security.

We must also think of countries whose leaders would like to prevent terrorists from preparing and carrying out a nuclear attack by providing them with nuclear materials, know-how, or explosives. However, there is a legal vacuum in this area since the International Criminal Court currently does not cover this type of situation. These are very serious matters. I have proposed that these acts — that is, a state, equipped with nuclear know-how, supplying nuclear material or nuclear expertise to a terrorist organization — I have proposed that this state could be prosecuted and convicted by an international court under the auspices of the UN.

This could be done either by amending the statute of the International Criminal Court to expand its jurisdiction or by creating an ad hoc tribunal to fill this gap in our international law. Today, there is no possibility of punishing or holding accountable a country that would supply nuclear expertise or material to a terrorist organization.

President OBAMA, in his conclusion, indicated that he felt this proposal was useful. He asked the Sherpas who will meet in Buenos Aires to prepare for the next summit to work in agreement with the Secretary-General of the United Nations on this proposal to fill the legal vacuum. This issue will be resolved before our next meeting in 2012 in South Korea.

Before answering your questions, I would also like to tell you that we began this morning's session with a minute of silence in memory of President KACZYNSKI, the Polish President, who left us under the dramatic circumstances that everyone knows. I will therefore attend the President's funeral in Krakow on Sunday, and on that same day, the flags of all French public buildings will be at half-mast in a sign of solidarity with the entire Polish people, who have been so severely affected by this catastrophe that has decapitated part of the elite of this great European country.

I will answer your questions, if you have any, of course.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, is four years enough to secure all highly vulnerable nuclear material? Four years seems very ambitious, and there are still countries that cultivate the art of secrecy. I am thinking of China, Iran, North Korea, of course.

THE PRESIDENT - That is why, it seems to me, this summit organized by President OBAMA is a useful summit; it was a very good initiative. We will see what happens in four years, but the mere fact that we have set a timeline, an ambitious goal, is that the awareness of the danger posed by these nuclear materials that could fall into the wrong hands — I mean, such awareness has never occurred before, and we were speaking in front of 41 heads of state and government. I find that extremely positive, the awareness, and moreover the decision that we must act together. Not against each other. Not with distrust of one another, but together. And naturally, France must set an example, and that is why I have asked the IAEA to come and conduct inspections in France.

We cannot be demanding of others if we are not naturally demanding of ourselves.

Nuclear terrorism is now recognized as a possible threat. The question of nuclear materials and the necessary legislation to regulate them, as well as the mobilization of the international community to secure them, is now clearly posed, and we have a four-year deadline, the continuation of the reduction of arsenals, with the START 2 treaty between the Americans and the Russians, which France has welcomed as a step in the right direction. And the French must know that France was the first country to go in this direction. By renouncing tests, dismantling reprocessing sites, being very transparent about the number of nuclear weapons it possessed, and substantially reducing them.

But it is also clear that I have indicated that the responsibility of the President of the Republic is an institutional responsibility, which makes him the head of the armed forces and the guarantor of the country's security. With the dangerous world as it is today, France has inherited nuclear weapons. It does not want to use them aggressively against anyone, offensively against anyone — but to ensure the security of a country of 65 million inhabitants, in the world we live in, France cannot let its guard down. It has shown the way, it has reduced its arsenals like no other country has done. It is transparent about its military potential, but I must also be the guarantor of the security of the country, of our country, of our fellow citizens, and of our national independence.

Moreover, I welcome the new American nuclear doctrine. I do not want to say that it will be close to the French doctrine, but it is extremely interesting. In fact, we have worked a lot with President OBAMA's team and with Mr. OBAMA. The concept of using nuclear weapons only as a last resort, a new concept of the OBAMA administration compared to what it was under the BUSH administration, goes exactly in the direction of the French doctrine. In fact, we have been following the evolution of this doctrine with our American friends for months. And for us, there is also a question of national independence and a question of security.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, did you perceive any evolution in China's position regarding possible Iranian sanctions over the last two days, and does the prospect of these sanctions seem more significant to you as a result?

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes, to be honest, to be as transparent as possible, this was not a topic strictly speaking of the summit. But I would be lying if I said we did not discuss it. Not in plenary, but we did discuss it among ourselves. I had a long bilateral discussion with President LULA. I believe that everyone is moving towards the idea that the current situation cannot continue for too long. That the obstinacy of the Iranian leaders in refusing thorough inspections, in rejecting all the outstretched hands that have been offered to them — first by President OBAMA but also the mediation attempts by President LULA, as well as Prime Minister ERDOGAN — has led to nothing but a waste of time. I do not say that trying to understand each other is a waste of time. But concretely, it has led to nothing. And there is really a general awareness that this cannot last much longer.

Secondly, we all wish that it be the Security Council, to give international legitimacy to these sanctions. It seems to me that a reasonable timeline for obtaining these sanctions at the UN is April, this month, or May, not later.

And I believe I can say that we have understood each other, even with President LULA, whose position, as you know, is quite legitimate, a position of dialogue. As for President OBAMA, the position of France and the United States, but that has been the case since the discussions we had about ten days ago, we are absolutely on the same line and we are pushing in the same direction.

So really, the moment of truth is approaching.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, on a sensitive subject which is Afghanistan, I will allow myself to ask you a question. Have you seen the video of the two journalists kidnapped in Afghanistan, and what is your feeling about it?

THE PRESIDENT -- I have not seen it, to tell you the truth, because at the time we received it, I was informed, of course, and of the requests from those who have your colleagues hostage. I have not seen the video itself, but to be clear, I agreed to its release. From that point of view, let things be clear. Now, on the substance of the matter, as long as your colleagues are prisoners, are being held, which is profoundly unacceptable, you will understand that I must refrain from lengthy comments on the subject.

We spare no effort to get them out of the situation they are in. I was, of course, aware of the requests, of course aware of the tape. I will see their families in the coming days, whom I have already seen, with whom I have been in telephone contact. We have had several disappointments, but we have had hopes... - the situation is very complex - but, at the very least, what can be said is that it is proof of life. We have never doubted, by the way, that your colleagues are alive. And I am waiting for us to have succeeded in freeing them to say what I think of the practice of holding hostages and forcing them to speak in front of cameras. Unfortunately, I cannot tell you much more.

QUESTION -- I would like to briefly return to Iran. You said that to decide on sanctions, there is roughly between 2 and 6 weeks. If the countries of the Security Council cannot agree on a resolution, will you propose to France's partners to impose sanctions unilaterally? Without support, without the basis of a resolution?

THE PRESIDENT -- But in any case, the question will arise because, either — which I hope — we obtain a United Nations resolution and it will necessarily be less strong than we would like since it will have required gathering everyone, but it is up to Europe as well as other partners, the United States, to request sanctions where it is possible, or — which I do not want to imagine — we do not manage to have a majority in the Security Council, and in that case, the problem will arise again. We will still have to decide on a number of things. So we are really reaching the end of a process, because what must be avoided at all costs is confrontation. To avoid confrontation, if the current Iranian leaders do not want to understand, then there is only the possibility of sanctions.

And the second question is about nuclear security. I was wondering if you could tell us more about the contradiction, which seems obvious, but perhaps you disagree, regarding the tension between securing nuclear materials and the expansion of nuclear energy use worldwide. You mentioned earlier the need to create security cultures, but isn't that still an almost unattainable challenge in some countries?

THE PRESIDENT -- Regarding sanctions, I believe I know President MEDVEDEV's position well, having discussed it with him for a long time, particularly in a bilateral meeting in Berlin when we commemorated the fall of the Berlin Wall. It does not seem to me that he is very "chilling," to use your expression. What matters is to have a framework, a framework at the United Nations. After that, we will get into the details; there are not just sanctions of this type, and there may be others. Let us try to have a legal status and maintain the majority in the absence of unanimity at the United Nations. That is our objective.

Next, we want the most effective sanctions possible. I mentioned this; Bernard KOUCHNER cited others. We are completely ready to discuss this; it poses no problem, these are modalities. What matters is to avoid a serious international crisis. I would like to remind you that the issue of Iran's nuclear arms race has been on the table for a long time, that it is probably the most dangerous potential crisis, and that at some point we need to do something to avoid confrontation. And at least we will have the satisfaction, we the French, of having tirelessly advocated for change.

I am convinced that we are at a moment when consensus is close, given how concerning the blindness of Iranian leaders is. To say this is to describe a reality. This is not a joking matter. No one is against Iran; everyone respects Iran, which is a great people, a great culture, a great civilization. Everyone agrees that Iran has the right to civil nuclear energy. But the prospect of Iran obtaining the atomic bomb, alongside the repeatedly reiterated statements from President AHMADINEJAD, poses an extremely serious threat. It is our duty to be concerned about this and to find solutions. I believe this is one of the most serious crises we are facing.

So yes, there is a contradiction between the development of civil nuclear energy and the securing of materials. We will try to ensure that there is no contradiction because what we do not want is anarchic development; we want regulated development. With more powers and more financial means for the IAEA. More national rules, more controls, but at the same time we will not deprive ourselves of the tremendous potential that nuclear energy represents, without CO2 emissions. So let us not confuse things. The problem is not nuclear energy; it is terrorism. And the problem is not the amount of energy produced but the fact that it has been produced in the past in a somewhat anarchic manner. With states that have dismantled and left stocks for which no one claims ownership or responsibility, at least. You can see very well who I am alluding to. Because the end of the 20th century saw an empire dismantle, and that posed many problems.

QUESTION -- Forgive me for one more small question about Iran, but it is the urgency of the moment. One of the arguments against sanctions is that these sanctions could be counterproductive, hitting the population more than the leaders, and you yourself recalled yesterday your attachment to the democratic movement in Iran. What do you say to these skeptics? What type of sanctions do you propose to address this argument?

THE PRESIDENT -- Of course, the question arises every time we talk about sanctions. But think about it: if the international community did nothing and the blindness of today's Iranian leaders led to a confrontation of any kind, do you not think that the Iranian population would suffer much more? Answering that is not doing a pirouette. You yourself, who follow these issues, can see it clearly.

Secondly, among the range of sanctions that are on the table, which I do not necessarily wish to communicate, there can be targeted sanctions, particularly against certain individuals. Particularly through banks. Particularly located in friendly countries that are extremely concerned about the drift of the Iranian regime. I cannot name them, but there are some. And knowing the issue as you do, I am sure you do not need guidance to think about this. It is a whole, but what matters is the international legitimacy that the Security Council's decision will provide, and that we are effective in avoiding confrontation. That is what we need to avoid.

QUESTION -- The Turkish Prime Minister and the Brazilian President have apparently decided or suggested to put forward a new diplomatic proposal to address the Iranian nuclear issue. Was this a topic in your meeting with President LULA?

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes.

QUESTION -- What do you think of this initiative?

And secondly, still on the issue of sanctions, Mr. President, you spoke on American television yesterday about reducing Iranian oil purchases. This is a very interesting new idea; can you elaborate on this idea? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT -- You are not making it easy for me because I think it is not productive to talk about the details of sanctions before obtaining a legal framework, and France is fighting to obtain this legal framework. That is what is important. After that, we will get into the modalities. It is not that I do not want to answer your question, but it is also not necessary to provide a pretext in a situation that is already quite complex.

Regarding President LULA, whom I saw with Minister Bernard KOUCHNER, I respect his position. He wants to be the man, and he wants Brazil to play the hand extended. That is entirely respectable; I trust him greatly, and I am very grateful to the Brazilians for all the trouble they have taken to help us with the truly scandalous situation concerning Clotilde REISS, our young compatriot. So it is not I who will reproach President LULA for anything. But President LULA himself -- I am not his spokesperson -- is clearly aware that this initiative would be a last chance initiative and that it must happen extremely quickly. To be frank, it must even be compatible with the timeline that I have taken the liberty of presenting to you, that is, April or May, to be as precise as possible. So even on that, I return from the summit -- it was not a multilateral topic -- but I return more optimistic because I found -- finally, the discussion with President LULA is always extremely easy and very pleasant -- really a clear understanding that time is now really pressing.

QUESTION -- You have spoken a lot about President LULA; did you talk about the Rafale deal, and are we going to sell the Rafale or not?

THE PRESIDENT -- If I told you that we did not talk about it, you would not believe me, and you would be perfectly right. Again, I am not the spokesperson for the Brazilian government, but let’s say I am confident. Things are progressing exactly as we had planned. If it is a decision made by the President, the Government, it is necessarily political. It is not just a political criterion, I imagine. The Rafale is an excellent aircraft, but the Brazilians will announce their choice themselves. I tell you, I am confident, and we are perfectly in line with what was said and done a year ago during my trip to Brazil. Moreover, with President LULA, we really have, dare I say, a very great complicity. I know what he thinks; there are no surprises on this issue, nor on others.

I take this opportunity to tell you that I had other bilateral meetings because France, with Bernard KOUCHNER, is preparing for the G20 Presidency, and that was really the subject of the discussions I had with Mr. ERDOGAN in Paris the other day. I also announce that I will probably go to Turkey at his invitation in anticipation of the G20, and probably as President since it will be the year of the G20, and we have already agreed on the major issues, including a subject that is absolutely fascinating, which is the regulation of the raw materials market. This is a subject that concerns Prime Minister ERDOGAN.

The Japanese Prime Minister, who visited Bernard KOUCHNER, is also very interested, and I will go to Japan at the beginning of next year in this context. Of course, President LULA, I have mentioned, we really... and then the Indian Prime Minister. I will go to India at the end of the year, and we also talked about G20 issues.

Ultimately, this summit also allows for multiplying bilateral contacts. With Kazakhstan, it is about following up on the contracts we discussed when I was in Astana. With others, it is the G20, but obviously, it greatly facilitates exchanges. As I was sitting next to President MEDVEDEV at the table, we talked a lot. It allows us to kill eight birds with one stone.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, some details. When you spoke, both in the bilaterals with the Emirates and in the various meetings you had, when you talk about Iran and when you talk about sanctions, do you address the issue of the diversion of these sanctions by Dubai? This is a point that concerns you, and it is something you spoke about today.

Finally, another point: when you talk about states that proliferate and that you would like to see condemned or at least presented before courts, are you thinking of North Korea?

THE PRESIDENT -- Of course, I met bilaterally with Crown Prince Mohammed of the United Arab Emirates, and there too, of course, you know the central role of the Emirates, particularly the financial hub of Dubai. But when we talk with Sheikh Mohammed, he is truly a friend, an ally. I mean, there is not a shadow of ambiguity about this. He is someone we need, and whose advice and action are and will be very useful. Of course.

The second question: it is not just them, but North Korea's position in this matter is also perfectly incomprehensible: a country whose population is so poor and that spends so much money developing missiles and nuclear weapons. But you know the links of other countries and the funding they provide to certain organizations that are listed as terrorist, which I do not qualify, but which are listed as terrorist. Of course, the question arises.

QUESTION -- What do you think of the format of this summit? Why invite countries that are non-signatories to the Non-Proliferation Treaty, and why not invite Syria, for example? Is it therefore the right choice of countries? Should this choice be institutionalized, keeping the same countries? And should this summit be institutionalized?

And then a small second question: during your discussions with the Emirates, have you made progress in your response to the Americans on what additional effort France can make for the training of Afghan soldiers or police?

THE PRESIDENT -- You know, regarding the guests, it is the eternal question. The privilege of the Presidency of all these summits is double or even triple. It is the Presidency that chooses the guests; it is the Presidency that chooses the agenda; and it is the Presidency that has the responsibility to put a paper on the table. So President OBAMA made choices. I find them good. We can discuss this or that. Should we freeze the next summits? No. In general, I find that freezing things too much complicates the task. And that would not be a good thing. So this type of summit can be open to other participants in the future. We even had a debate, you see, about whether this summit should be held every two years or every year? It is being constructed, and so on this...

Regarding the question of Afghanistan, a question that we are following very closely with our American friends, I have said several times, we have the necessary combat forces to meet our responsibilities in the two regions that are ours. Our soldiers fight there, fight with courage, with competence. This is not contested by anyone. We have strengthened our means to protect our soldiers. I am talking about helicopters, I am talking about drones, I am talking about armament. But we believe we have the necessary forces to carry out the missions that are ours. And from this point of view, President OBAMA is very clear; there is no possible misunderstanding.

However, you are right, for what is called Afghanization, the training of their police, possibly their gendarmerie, the training of Afghan officers, we need to strengthen the efforts of the competent nations. Why? Because the sooner the Afghan army, the Afghan police, and the Afghan state can take their responsibilities, the better it will be for everyone. And we are ready to do more for training.

We now have an additional asset: our base in Abu Dhabi. We could perfectly host Afghan officers at this base in Abu Dhabi to train and prepare them. It is on these bases that we are working together.

QUESTION -- To stay in the United Arab Emirates and in Abu Dhabi, earlier you mentioned the possibility of the Rafale in Brazil, you also currently have negotiations with the Emiratis on this matter, who have expressed their interest, and not in the context of a tender but through a direct agreement. Do you express the same confidence in this market?

THE PRESIDENT -- Let’s say it is confidence for Brazil and strong hope for the Emiratis. I tell you, we have talked about it, and it is quite normal. How could it be otherwise? We are entering a phase of quite in-depth discussions.

One last question, after you might want to stay in France? Unless we have decided to go to Ben's?

QUESTION -- Regarding relations between Washington and Beijing, do you feel that the time is right for détente, and is this a subject you will work on during the French Presidency of the G20?

THE PRESIDENT -- I myself met with President Hu Jintao to thank him for his invitation for a state visit since Carla and I will go to Beijing at the end of the month. And then I will inaugurate the French pavilion for the Shanghai World Expo. President Hu Jintao will come to France, I think, before the end of the year. We have extremely important economic interests. I would also like to convince this vast country, China, that the definition of a new international monetary order is something that will not be done against them but rather with them. Because the yuan has become a significant currency. If we start addressing the issue by denouncing adversaries or culprits, we are sure that we will not succeed. I do not forget that, now that the strategic partnership has returned to solid foundations, I do not forget that I myself have experienced some turbulence. Our Chinese friends who are behind us, it would be a bit curious for me to meddle in the relations between these two great countries, the United States and China. I have complete confidence in President Obama and the Chinese President to find good agreements. I believe they have had a long conversation together. It is very important that great powers like this talk to each other, that there is no blockage. What is very important is that at no time do we find ourselves in a situation of blockage on any international issue. Even if we make little progress, I would even say that even if we do not progress but people talk, it is positive. What is completely negative is tension, blockage. And if France invented and proposed the G20, it is precisely to give a strong impetus. With Bernard Kouchner, we will have the opportunity to talk to you about it. It is really an extremely strong calendar, very strong initiatives, and of course it is not about hindering the Canadian Presidency and tomorrow the Korean Presidency, which is doing very well. But starting in November 2010, France will take many initiatives on a number of subjects on which we need to advance.

I thank you, I wish you a good return and much courage.