Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on European environmental taxation, in Brussels on March 14, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

14 March 2008 · Press conference on European environmental taxation · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference at the European Council in Brussels on March 14, 2008, summarizing key outcomes including environmental taxation and EU policy debates.
Main themes
European environmental taxation, reduced VAT for clean products, carbon border adjustment measures, EU exchange rate concerns, Small Business Act for SMEs, Union for the Mediterranean, EU immigration policy, fair competition and reciprocity, French EU Council presidency priorities
Duration
~22 min
71st percentile
Words
2,693
71st percentile
Sentences
140
78th percentile
Readability
61
88th percentile
Grade
9.5
15th percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

140 sentences in 28 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Please excuse my delay. A brief press point to tell you what we have done this morning. First, France's satisfaction that there is an expression of concern from the European Council regarding the exchange rate situation. It would have been inconceivable for the European Council to remain silent on this point. You have long known my convictions on the subject, and I was very pleased with the statement from the President of the Eurogroup, Mr. Juncker. I fully share his analysis, which has also been echoed and supported by the President of the Commission, who has also expressed his concern.

I would also like to say how pleased I am with the Commission's initiative, which will present, in the coming weeks, the famous European "Small Business Act" that will improve access for our SMEs - you know that this is an economic issue for France - to public markets, as I have continuously called for by recalling the example of the measures in place in the United States and Canada. It is done. We have managed to convince.

I also want to express how happy I am to see in the texts of the European statements words that I attach great importance to: reciprocity, fair competition, defense of European interests. We are not yet at community preference, but at least, it is progressing as well. It feels good. All these words that were not in the vocabulary are now somewhat boosting, giving strength to the European statements. Also, the European Council calls for the definition of a common policy on immigration and migration; this is the priority of the French Presidency. This is a good sign.

We had a long debate, quite interesting by the way, on the question of the balancing measures that need to be taken regarding carbon taxation for countries that do not play by the rules, how we protect our industries. We cannot tell our companies: make efforts to protect the environment, but at the same time import products from countries that make no effort. The Commission is mandated to find a mechanism, which we have not yet found, but the mere fact that the principle is being raised is perfectly fine.

Furthermore, with Gordon Brown, we have pushed for the development of environmental taxation. I am very pleased to see that the Council is asking the Commission to consider the best ways to promote clean products, explicitly mentioning the issue of environmental VAT. You know, this is the idea that we proposed with Gordon Brown, which I believe in a lot, that we could restore the additional cost of clean products, such as cars or buildings, through a lower tax. The idea I defend is that clean products should benefit from a reduced VAT rate. Because sometimes, often, consumers say, "Listen, it is not normal that buying a clean car is more expensive than buying a polluting car." The VAT, we have not made the decision, we are not there yet, but the Council is asking the Commission to reflect and make proposals in this area.

You know how the issue of reduced VAT is a serious battle! We are not there yet either, but I see density emerging in the statements of the European Councils. I am deeply pleased about this because I am convinced that reduced VAT is a way to boost ecological products, clean products. We are not there yet, but the Commission is mandated to study this.

When you recall the rigidity of the debates on the issue of VAT, it is an event. We are not there yet; we must wait for the Commission's proposal. For the Union for the Mediterranean, it was adopted unanimously; there is no problem, I spoke to you at length about it last night. Naturally, Bernard Kouchner, Christine Lagarde, Jean-Pierre Jouyet, and I are at your disposal if you have a few brief questions before we return to Paris.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you spoke about ecological VAT; is the Commission mandated to reflect on it or to make a proposal?

THE PRESIDENT - To make a proposal, not just on ecological VAT. I do not remember the exact text, but it is something like: the Council asks the Commission to reflect on all fiscal instruments that would promote the development of clean products. And in the debate we had, we expressly talked about ecological VAT. Some countries, I do not hide it from you, were opposed to opening this debate, and others, Britain and France, were very much in favor of opening it. It is very important; I do not understand - this is not at all in the discussion, it is a personal opinion - that on corporate tax (IS), each state can do what it wants, and on VAT, we would need everyone's agreement to move. Honestly, it is a real problem. I do not see on what grounds, especially regarding non-relocatable products, the mere fact that we are talking about this has been a debate. This debate is settled; the Commission is asked to make proposals. My wish is that we can say that an ecological product, a clean product is systematically at a reduced VAT rate. For example, the reduced VAT on buildings, I told Christine and Bernard, I think that when we build in HQE, what we call High Environmental Quality, it costs more, Sir, it seems quite normal to me that those who build in HQE have a reduced VAT rate. For example, if a consumer buys a car that will cost more because it is clean, it seems quite normal to me that he can benefit from a reduced VAT rate. We are not there yet, but the Council has asked the Commission to work on it; it is very important in the European process.

QUESTION - Can you tell us a little more about the climate package, particularly biofuels and the share of renewable energies? Have the objectives been called into question or not?

THE PRESIDENT - No, there was an extremely long and complicated debate, extremely fascinating and quite understandable. Not all countries are at the same level of CO2 production, and let's say it as it is, France is better placed. We were a number, including Gordon Brown, and France insisted that our objectives should not be indicative; they should be a commitment. There were some attempts to introduce the word "indicative." We opposed it; it was not retained. Why did we oppose it? Because we managed to set Europe as an example for the planet in environmental protection. If we made our objectives indicative, it would undermine everything, and so we kept the objectives: it is 2020, it is 23%, there you go. I will not go into detail because there are 19 pages. There was a small attempt in that direction; it was stopped. Europe must remain a leader and exemplary in environmental objectives. It is very difficult, including for France, a 23% target in renewable energy; I can tell you that it is no small matter.

QUESTION - I continue in this area; how is the surplus of our nuclear energy handled by the Commission?

THE PRESIDENT - There was a whole debate about how we should handle it. We even hesitated ourselves about whether we should challenge or reopen the Commission's compromise project or rather accept it. We have taken a position to accept the compromise proposed by the Commission, even if we find that the 23% target does not cover the reality of the French nuclear fleet, which means that we produce less greenhouse gas than others. We would have liked to have less ambitious targets regarding renewable energy given that we produce less greenhouse gas. But well, the position we defended with the Ministers was rather to approve the Commission's compromise. Also, put yourself in the shoes of countries like Estonia, which simply has a cable coming from Finland. For them, it is also difficult. If France does not set an example and reopens because it finds it difficult for itself, then for others, it is even worse. No, we have committed to a very difficult path, but one of exemplarity in the fight for environmental protection, and we must stick to it. And from this point of view, I reiterate that France and the Commission are working hand in hand. I can only rejoice once again at the great trust that exists between President Barroso and the French delegation on all subjects. He also specified, regarding the Union for the Mediterranean, that to make the proposals requested of him, he would start from the Franco-German paper.

QUESTION - Mr. President, the French are about to vote the day after tomorrow for the municipal elections. You stated in Toulon earlier this week that you would take into account the message they would express, while explaining that these were local elections. We wanted some clarifications on this matter.

THE PRESIDENT - I confirm. Moreover, in asking me the question, you had an unusual smile, which clearly shows that you were expecting the answer. In any case, what I am trying to do now is to focus on the subject of the place I am in when I am somewhere. I fully understand that you have political questions and I naturally do not blame you for it, but there is still a lot of work that has been done on Europe. The other day we were in South Africa and Chad. I try to focus on all the files one after the other, and indeed, a number of you have repeatedly complained when Europe was stalled. Now that it is starting again, let us focus on that. The rest, it is Friday, Sunday is coming, Monday too, and there will always be time to talk about that later. I have said what I had to say in Toulon. After that, I might leave!

QUESTION - Mr. President, two questions please. I would like to know if France is in contact with the Spanish Government to try to prevent Spanish milk producers from carrying out their threats to block imports of French milk, and a second question: have you resumed your contacts with the Spanish Government regarding EDF's ambitions to enter the capital of Iberdrola?

THE PRESIDENT - You are putting me in a difficult position regarding the milk issue. I would have a hard time articulating a word of response, it must be said, and they really have not talked to me about it, but well, it is certainly a fault on my part, and yes, on energy, we are in very regular contact; I would also like to say that we are working very well with the Spanish Government. We are trying to find consensual solutions, not just on electricity, but on all ongoing issues. Spain and France are trying to work hand in hand, but frankly, regarding the milk issue, really no one has talked to me about it, so I am at a loss! Perhaps one last question?

QUESTION - I know that you have not addressed foreign issues here, but given that the Chinese regime is repressing the protests of monks who have decided, on the eve of the Olympic Games, to make their struggle known and who are asking for more freedom, would not Europe and France honor themselves by having a common and strong position on the eve of the Beijing Olympic Games to demand respect for these rights, instead of waiting for repression and witnessing the repression?

THE PRESIDENT - Frankly, when I was in China, at a press conference with President Hu Jintao, I called for the abolition of the death penalty, the ratification of the United Nations Charter on civil and political rights, and today, there is a document that is being adopted. I am not the President of the Union; we will see what happens at that time. The question of human rights, I addressed it in an unusual way for visitors in open China, since I did it at a press conference in the presence of the Chinese President.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you met with the Greek Prime Minister, Mr. Karamanlis, it seems today. What is France's position on the issue of the "no" between Macedonia and Greece? We had the impression that France supported Greece.

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, that is a good impression. I have made it known several times to the Greek Prime Minister regarding the "no" from Macedonia, as that is the subject. I indicated that we support the Greek position. The Greeks are friends. And you know, since we wrote a book in Greece about Sarkozy from Thessaloniki, I feel obliged to be supportive! But I confirm that we are very supportive of the position of our Greek friends; I confirmed it again to the Greek Prime Minister.

QUESTION - There are two Austrian hostages in North Africa, and we have called for their release. The response has been that it is impossible. What should we say? How should we react in your opinion?

THE PRESIDENT - It is the Austrian Chancellor who drew our attention to this issue. I believe that these are two Austrian tourists. The Austrian Chancellor asked us for the solidarity of Europe, political solidarity that goes without saying. Moreover, he asked for the collaboration of all our services, and France feels particularly concerned, especially through the DGSE. And I indicated to Alfred GUSENBAUER that, of course, he could count on our full, complete, and unwavering support in this particularly dramatic situation for these Austrian tourists.

QUESTION - Regarding the Union for the Mediterranean, there is still a heavy diplomatic workload to ensure that everyone agrees to come to the table in July. Who will lead this diplomatic work? Is it France? Is it Europe? Will your special advisor Henri GUAINO, who was in charge of this file, be involved? How will this be orchestrated?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, it is all of Europe that is engaged in this process. Thank you for asking us this question, it allows me to clarify things. The Franco-German paper will be enriched by Spanish proposals, Greek proposals, as the President of the Commission has said. But be careful, we must not forget to invite Jordan, which is not strictly speaking a Mediterranean coastal state, which is quite right. The issue also arises with Mauritania. So we will all work on this together, since it is the President of the Commission who must do it. But well, the Slovenian Presidency and then already the French Presidency have the responsibility to set up the Summit, to discuss with one another. As for Henri GUAINO, he is my collaborator, my friend, and you know the trust I have in him. There is no problem, but the French Presidency will be responsible for leading this. Bernard KOUCHNER has been passionate about this Mediterranean issue for a long time; he reminded me that he had discussed it with François MITTERRAND, who himself had this idea, unfortunately aborted too early for it to advance. This allowed me to take things up again. With Jean-Pierre JOUYET, we will all get to work, of course.

I won't hide from you that it is very difficult, of course, that is absolutely obvious, we know it perfectly well. But well, between what was said a few weeks ago, even just a few days ago, and what has been decided, I assure you, with great enthusiasm, and without any reservations from anyone. The last was Mr. PÖTTERING, who was a bit "chafouiné," and well, from the moment we invited him - which is quite normal - I have the impression that he regained his legendary smile that I have known for so long, which I appreciate so much. And by the way, I had thought that it was Angela MERKEL who should talk to him about it, and then I realize that it is easier for me to talk to him, and well, there you go. It’s done, it’s settled.

Well then, thank you, it was a good Council. Good luck.