Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on the European response to the economic and financial crisis, the President of the European Commission, and the political situation in Iran, in Brussels on June 19, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

19 June 2009 · European Council; press conference in Brussels · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy held a press conference at the June 2009 Brussels European Council, summarizing outcomes on financial regulation, the Lisbon Treaty, Barroso's reappointment, and Iran.
Main themes
European financial regulation, Lisbon Treaty and Irish protocol, José Manuel Barroso's reappointment, European Council outcomes, Iran political situation and protests, European immigration policy, G20 follow-up, EU institutional reform, Franco-German cooperation
Duration
~48 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,764
93rd percentile
Sentences
333
96th percentile
Readability
62
90th percentile
Grade
8.6
8th percentile
Syntax
2.77
19th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
17th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

333 sentences in 75 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I apologize for making you wait. Just a few words to express France's satisfaction with the results achieved during this Council. You know how much Mrs. Merkel and I are committed to ensuring that Europe changes, that it makes decisions, that it takes on its responsibilities, and from this perspective, this European Council has been positive.

In the face of the economic and financial crisis, we have followed up on the G20 in Washington, the G20 in London, and the Larosière report, which itself was a follow-up to the two G20s. For the first time, there has been an agreement to give binding powers to a committee of European supervisors. It is now clearly established that in Europe, insurance companies, banks, rating agencies, and the financial market will be regulated in a binding manner by a committee of supervisors.

This was a request that France made from the very beginning of the crisis. I want to express my thanks to our British friends, and particularly to Gordon Brown, for the consensus we were able to achieve following three meetings, two yesterday and one this morning, on this commitment. I think this is truly something extremely important.

I also want to express my pleasure at the agreement reached with our Irish and British friends, which gives legal form to the agreement that was concluded under the French presidency. There will therefore be a protocol to give legal value to the political commitments we made with the Irish, to put Brian Cowen in the best position for organizing the referendum, which he has confirmed will take place before the end of the year. It is clearly stated that this protocol does not change in any way, for the other twenty-six States, the content of the Lisbon Treaty, and therefore does not imply specific ratification of the content.

How will we move to the fully completed legal form? During the first treaty of ratification for the enlargement of Europe, as I mentioned last December, we will add the Irish protocol. Thus, our Irish friends have the legal strength they were expecting from the political commitments I negotiated. Our British friends are not obliged to have a new debate on ratification, and things were settled yesterday and this morning around the Czech Presidency, in the presence of Mrs. Merkel, Mr. Brown, Mr. Cowen, and myself.

These are still two extremely important pieces of news. One, on the institutional level, and one on the financial regulation level.

The third element, and I am very pleased about this, is that there has been a request to go further in a European immigration policy, not to limit ourselves to the only immigration pact that France had promoted. We will have proposals from the Commission.

The fourth piece of news is the unanimous agreement of the heads of state and government on Mr. Barroso's candidacy. I myself was pleased with the presentation of this program. The Czech Presidency and the Swedish Presidency will make contact with Parliament to see when Parliament wants to ratify this proposal from the Council. We would prefer it to be in July, but this remains to be discussed with the Presidency and the Council.

Finally, I want to say that I am very happy to see Europe unanimously declare strong and unambiguous statements on the Iranian situation. It is up to the Iranians to choose their government, but we can only be extremely concerned about the violence of the reaction from the current power. The courage of the Iranians who take to the streets, to ask for what? The right to freely choose their future. The fact that they do not give up is an element that should make us extremely optimistic. Europe is unanimous in condemning violence. As for the recounting of votes, either we recount them properly, or we do not recount them at all, but you know that I have always viewed this with a great deal of severity.

There you go, I am of course open to your questions. But fundamentally, there has been a lot of work, and things are progressing.

Q - A question about Mr. Barroso. I would like you to explain to us what you particularly appreciated about Mr. Barroso's mandate. What in his record motivates the decision to extend his term for another five years?

R - First of all, I greatly appreciated the six months he spent working with me as President of the Council. I am not the kind of person to say that the success of the French Presidency was solely due to the French Presidency. The Presidency of the Commission played an extremely positive role, and when it was necessary to go to Washington to convince President Bush, Mr. Barroso was there. I am not the only one who thinks this, as it is unanimous, including the socialist prime ministers around the table, who are quite numerous. Mr. Zapatero confirmed his support and the support of his parliamentarians for Mr. Barroso. Mr. Socrates, the Portuguese socialist, confirmed the support of his government and socialist parliamentarians for Mr. Barroso. Mr. Brown confirmed his support. So, it is unanimous, there is a consensus, it is very clear. I took the liberty of saying at dinner yesterday that this support should not be understood as a message of immobility, but that it should change. From this point of view, Mr. Barroso's text seems to mark an interesting shift in the ideas I have heard him defend until now, including the necessity of a strong common agricultural policy. All of this suits me well.

Q - Still on the same subject, the ball is now in the court of the European Parliament. What would happen if the European Parliament did not vote in favor of Mr. Barroso?

R - We need to look at this with a bit of perspective and reason. First of all, the groups are currently meeting to elect their presidents. I believe the last election for the presidency of a group must be on June 30. It so happens that I have very good relations with, of course, the president of the EPP group, Joseph Daul, with Martin Schulz, to my knowledge the president of the socialist group, I spoke to him, with Mr. Watson who is currently the president of the liberal group, and even with Mr. Cohn-Bendit whom I met with pleasure at length.

Everyone has their position. The EPP clearly won the elections. The Greens have made very clear progress. What will the majorities in the European Parliament be? It is not for me to create or comment on them. We will see what happens. I believe that if everyone shows a bit of flexibility, a bit of skill, things should go well. If we lock ourselves into overly rigid schedules and try to force things too much, we will end up with a hardening.

I do not think, and I say this for you as well as for others, that Europe needs, in addition, a conflict between the different institutions today. I do not think that is what Europeans expect from us. There is unemployment, there is a crisis, I do not think it would be responsible for either the Council or the Parliament to oppose each other and be in a situation of blockage, especially when we are trying to unblock institutional reform. Really, at times, we must try to be reasonable!

With that, there is the Irish problem, we see a perspective. I remind you of what a number of you said when I indicated that the Irish should revote. I was told: "Oh my God! How inexperienced he is! Why is he saying that?" Well, that is exactly what is going to happen, what is happening. We may have a chance to have new institutions; we are not going to inaugurate this chance by creating the conditions for a conflict between the European Parliament and the Council. I add that I have not seen an alternative solution that would achieve the same consensus.

Q - Inaudible.

R - ... Which ones?

Q - Inaudible.

R - If it is the candidate from Libération, it proves that openness, Mr. Quatremer, works. Look, it is not up to France to break the consensus around the table of the Council. But objectively, let us speak very frankly, there is a consensus around the table of the Council. I understood that there was another period when there was no consensus.

Q - I return to Iran. The Supreme Leader, this morning, Ali Khamenei, made an extremely violent statement saying that the results were final and that those who did not participate in the victory celebration would be denounced by the guardians of the people, which announces an extremely harsh period. Beyond condemning what is happening today in Iran, what can Europe do if there is a bloodbath?

R - First of all, we do not want to give the impression that foreigners, with all that this entails, are interfering in internal elections in Iran. After all, we have values, we have convictions. When we see images of people being massacred because they are asking for a recount of ballots, when we see results that are so incoherent, Europe that would remain silent would not correspond to the values of Europe. As for France, I believe our position has always been very consistent. Mr. Kouchner and I have always been advocates for strengthening sanctions in the context of the nuclear issue.

What is manifesting in Iran? The misfortune and protest of Iranians who are asking why their lives are becoming increasingly difficult, when it is a country rich in resources, with a great history and a strong civilization. Therefore, the sanctions, the fact that a number of States consider it unacceptable to talk about the Holocaust as if it were a joke, have contributed to awakening an Iranian society that does not seem as confident and satisfied as the Supreme Leader would like to say!

We can say this while hoping that Iran regains its rightful place in the region and in the world, that the Iranian people have the means to develop, and that discussions resume. But still, this is also a message we are sending, that Europe, the world is not willing to accept everything, or else, what is the point of some of your colleagues doing their jobs in extremely dangerous conditions? What should we say? I am always in favor of dialogue with Iran, but when we have to condemn, we must condemn. From my point of view, I will tell you, all of this, the emergence of an Iranian street demanding more transparency and a better future, I say, is good news.

I hope that the current leaders of Iran will not commit the irreparable. The aspirations of the Iranian people when expressed with such courage and dignity can only be admired. We will not remain silent in any case; that is not France's policy. I say this without any aggression towards anyone, even if you know what I think of Mr. Ahmadinejad, who loves provocation, regarding his repeated and multiple statements. I have had the opportunity to say this in particularly frank terms to the Iranian Foreign Minister because I wish to have good relations with Iran. But I am not willing to accept statements and attitudes of this nature. So, what will happen in the future? Does anyone know? I hope that Iran will avoid violence and that the current government of Iran will respect the Iranian population.

Q - I return to Mr. Barroso once again. Mrs. Merkel said yesterday that there is no great leadership without great difficulties to face. She was, of course, talking about Mr. Barroso's path in the European Parliament in a few weeks. I would like to know, in your opinion, what are Mr. Barroso's personal political qualities that would contribute to this leadership? And more generally, are you in favor of the return of great leadership for the European Commission in the coming years?

R - I have personal ideas, but I do not know if this is the place. I think one of the misunderstandings, to be honest, is that many observers who are specialists and engaged, and you are, I mean specialists and engaged in the European idea, reason about a Commission of twenty-seven as you reasoned about a Commission of six, nine, or twelve. May I allow myself to say that this is unfair? The Commission of twenty-seven means smaller portfolios and twenty-seven commissioners who can speak. The President of the Commission, from my point of view, institutionally does not have enough authority over these commissioners - not Mr. Barroso, institutionally speaking - that we have not drawn the consequences of the emergence of a Commission of twenty-seven whose operating rules should change. I have a lot of respect for Mr. Delors, a lot of admiration for what he did, but let us agree that it was a bit simpler at the time when there was a much smaller Commission. I say this because I believe it.

The second element, I deeply believe that the Commission is only strong if the presidency of the Council is strong; if one is stronger than the other, it destabilizes the system and forces the Commission to venture into a political terrain that is not its preferred area. The Commission is the guardian of the treaties, the Commission is both administrative and political, but if the presidency of the Council does not do its job adequately, it exposes the presidency of the Commission to making decisions and taking initiatives in areas where they are not necessarily comfortable, beyond just Mr. Barroso.

In response to your question, I am truly in favor of a strong Commission, a strong Council, and a strong Parliament. The Parliament is done. The Council, I hope that with Lisbon, it will be done. But I deeply believe that we can have a "win-win" system for the three major institutions.

Finally, regarding Mr. Barroso, I worked with him for six months, every day, in great harmony. You ask me: what are his qualities? I believe there are two: he has a great political sense and a vast experience of the workings of European affairs and national states. Moreover, it is not a coincidence that there is no extremely credible alternative. I do not want to pass judgment on everything.

(inaudible). Yes, we are still talking for the moment. We are all being cautious.

Q - According to information reported yesterday following a meeting between civil parties in the Karachi bombing case and the investigating judges, it seems that the origin of the bombing is not due to an act of terrorism but rather to reprisals from the Pakistani state after the non-payment of commissions. There is even talk of kickbacks that were supposed to fund Edouard Balladur's electoral campaign in 1995. As Minister of the Budget, were you aware of such agreements?

R - There was no need to put me on your right to talk about this. Listen, it's frankly ridiculous. Not you, I wouldn't allow myself to say that, I respect you. Listen, if there are elements, give them to us. It's grotesque! That's my answer. What do you want me to say? Reasoning: for his financing, Mr. Balladur would have accepted commissions that would not have been paid following the Karachi bombing.

Let us respect the pain of the victims! Who can believe such a fable? If you have elements, give them to Justice and ask Justice to conduct an investigation. Frankly, what do you want me to respond to that, honestly? It has been fourteen years, moreover. We are in a world where everything is known, where the notion of state secrecy no longer exists. Fourteen years later, you come to tell me if I was aware of kickbacks that would not have been paid to Pakistanis in the context of Mr. Balladur's campaign. And you, were you not aware either? You, you were perhaps a journalist at that time, maybe at that moment, I would have... No, I do not hold it against you, but frankly... If there is a robbery in Brussels today, I was there, that is indisputable. Sorry, Karachi, it is the pain of families, what do you want me to respond to that?

Q - Mr. President, two questions actually. First, are you in favor of voting on a law to ban the wearing of the burqa? Second point, the Elysée congratulated itself today on the progress of negotiations with the United Arab Emirates on the Rafale. When do you think France and the United Arab Emirates will actually be able to sign a contract for the sale of Rafales?

R - On the first subject, I will have the opportunity to talk about all this and many other things on Monday before Congress. It is not at all that I want to evade the question you are asking me, but my role as President of the Republic is to try to put the answers in a general context and to try to explain major trends and not to react to the emotion of the moment. I have been sufficiently reproached for this by a number of you so that you do not set me a trap. I observe, when I see certain headlines in newspapers, that we are fully immersed in the emotion of the moment! I will have the opportunity to talk about it on Monday; I prefer to reserve my comments for my speech before the parliamentarians.

Regarding the Emiratis, we are in discussion. This shows that discussions on the sale of Rafales to the Emiratis are progressing, as I have always said, that it is progressing, we can say, significantly.

Q - Do you have an idea of a timeline?

R - I even have a very precise idea, but for now, with our Emirati friends, we have stuck to a statement. I knew they were doing this; I did not know if it was this morning or tomorrow morning; it was under debate. It is progressing. They have given us all the technical specifications they expected on the Rafale. You saw that when I was in Abu Dhabi, there was a first statement. At the Paris Air Show, there was a second. Each time, it is progressing. It is a very important subject for France.

Q - Question about the presidency of the European Parliament. Do you support Mr. Jerzy Buzek as Mrs. Merkel has already done? I would like to know your opinion.

R - I think he would be an excellent candidate. He would be an excellent candidate first because he is a man of quality, and moreover, it is certain that it would send a very positive signal to our friends in Eastern Europe.

Q - Mr. President, this is the first European Council after the European elections. There was a lot of abstention; we talked a lot about it before the elections, and we are not talking about it at all now.

R - No one is preventing you from talking about it, proof!

Q - You said last week during your press conference with Mrs. Merkel that we needed to respond to the abstentionists. What do you propose as a response? Do we have to wait until 2014 before the question is raised again?

R - It is not my style to wait until 2014, not even 2012. It seems to me that by making the decisions we have made on regulation, it is a response to your question. When we held the Washington Summit, what did you say? "These are principles; we will see what it leads to." When we held the London Summit, you were a bit more positive, but you said, particularly on tax havens: "We will see." Today, we have seen. The Cayman Islands are renouncing banking secrecy; Switzerland and Luxembourg have signed transparency agreements with us. Things are moving. And now Europe is equipping itself with regulation on systemic risks, on banks, on insurance, on rating agencies; that is what we wanted. These are concrete results now. We even planned the election of the president of the group on systemic risks. Frankly, who can contest that Europe has made progress? Spectacular, in less than a year! That is concrete. Let us not be too harsh on Europe either. You spend your time, rightly, saying: "Stop making grand speeches, give us concrete." Is this not concrete? There was a financial crisis that brought the world to the brink. President Obama's statements on American financial regulation are remarkable. What Europe has just decided is very good. Things are moving. It is a response to the abstentionists.

A second response I would like to give you. You can see that we are a bit in between because we are on the Nice Treaty and, I hope, we are moving towards the Lisbon Treaty. It is still difficult for us, regardless of what is already in the pipeline, to take other initiatives while we are waiting for the Irish referendum in the fall. Am I making myself clear here too? I truly believe that this is going in the right direction.

There are many other things I would like to advance more quickly: coordination of economic policies, a much more ambitious European immigration policy, a more advanced reflection on what we should do with countries that are not yet in the euro and which, by treaty, are obliged to enter. I would like this to move faster. Let us wait to see what institutions will be those of Europe at the end of the year to do this. Agree that it will be simpler when we know whether we are on Lisbon or Nice and what the nature of the initiatives we will need to take will be. But despite this, the decisions made at this summit, I speak under the control of Bruno Le Maire as well as Bernard Kouchner, show that this was not a transitional summit. If we had not taken these initiatives, you would be entitled to say: "Oh dear, they are doing less than the United States" or "Oh dear, they are lagging behind London." That is not true.

Q - Mr. Cohn-Bendit, upon leaving the Elysée yesterday, suggested that you would not be ready to die to defend Mr. Barroso in the event of his reappointment. I wanted to know if Mr. Cohn-Bendit was a faithful interpreter of your thoughts? Do you think he said this more to handicap Mr. Barroso or to embarrass you yourself?

R - No, it was just affection towards me. He is concerned about my situation, and he is a generous man who thought: the president needs to be careful; he is working a lot. I took it that way.

Q - Another question about the Council, for which you want a strong position. Who would be your ideal candidate for the presidency of the European Council under the Lisbon Treaty? We thought you supported Mr. Blair for quite a while; is that still the case? Why? Is there another candidate?

R - You are a specialist in Europe. On what is Europe built? It is a serious subject; I believe you all here love Europe; at least, Europe interests you. On what is Europe built, on what word is Europe built? One word: compromise. In the good sense; I do not mean compromise in the sense of collusion. Compromise, that is, understanding the red lines of the other to build the future. If even before we have the certainty of having Lisbon, even before France proposes a candidate, we put ourselves in a position to block the system and not to make it progress...

I know perfectly well that this is a difficult subject; it is, after all, an important subject.

If we have Lisbon, the first stable president for two and a half years of Europe will be a choice that will speak extremely loudly. His nationality, will he be from a small or a large country, his experience, his European commitment, his political family? I add that all this must be constructed within the framework of a balance: president of the Commission - if it is Mr. Barroso, rather a small country, without undermining Portugal - the high representative, vice-president of the Commission, and the president of the Council. All this is negotiable. It is impossible to answer your question because naturally, and what I wish is that there is at that moment a comprehensive agreement, you see, a balance. A political family cannot hold all the positions; that is not possible, it is not reasonable.

The answer I was giving to your Polish colleague about the quality of the Polish candidacy is also a symbol towards Eastern Europe. All this needs to be integrated. So it is not possible to answer your question even if it is naturally a major subject.

I can just say that I would like, in any case, if we have Lisbon, that the first president of the Council be someone strong and ambitious for Europe because Europe deserves it and Europe needs it.

Q - I would like to ask you for your assessment of the Czech Presidency. What do you think of the Presidency? Do you agree with some newspapers that speak of a tragedy or a catastrophe?

R - I want to say that Mr. Fischer did his job as president very well. I will even tell you better; I was happy to receive him in Paris. We had a working meeting with Bernard Kouchner, and Bruno was there. I spoke with him on the phone several times. During those two days, I kept seeing him. He is a man who did calm, intelligent, reasonable work, and I enjoyed working with him. What happened before, I do not remember everything. This proves that for the Czech Republic, what happened is really good. It was not such an easy presidency because there were difficult files. Mr. Fischer, who was president of the Czech Statistical Office, I must say, did a job that really impressed me; we were happy to work with him in a climate where there was no tension, where things worked very, very well. The Czech Presidency is ending well. We are pleased with it.

Q - I wanted to know about Iran; have you had the opportunity to discuss the situation with President Obama? And secondly, how do you explain the American reaction, which seems more reserved, at least compared to that of the European Union?

R - I have often talked about this with President Obama. I even told the Iranian Foreign Minister: "But seize the outstretched hand of President Obama, show your good faith." And I believe it was wise to do so. So, it is true that we have had a more vigorous reaction regarding Iran; we do not have to agree on every point. I was very shocked by Mr. Ahmadinejad's repeated statements. I think that in the 21st century, there is no reason to accept statements of this nature about the Holocaust or a number of other things. As for the rest, we will see how all of this evolves.

I also understand President Obama's position, which is my concern as well, not to give the impression, because that would be a service rendered to Mr. Ahmadinejad, that we want to interfere in Iranian affairs, you know that very well. But at the same time, we have convictions and we support Iran, we support the Iranian people, but where is the Iranian people? They are in the streets today. I would also like to call for reflection: in Iran, the people are in the streets demanding more measures and more reason, which shows that the people are taking to the streets in this region of the world, not simply to ask for more closure; on the contrary, it is the opposite, and that is good news.

Q - And this week, did you talk about it with President Obama?

R - I did not talk about it this week; I talked about it when we were in Normandy.

Q - Mr. President, sorry to project you once again towards Monday and the speech. Clearly, you will be keen to talk about the reform of the territories. Should this be subject to a referendum, and if so, should we talk to the French about limiting the accumulation of mandates?

R - You are bringing me exactly to where I did not want to go, but I would just like to say one thing: if I wanted to go before Congress, it is to value the French Parliament, to give it the priority of the orientations I wish for France. French democracy needs a strong Parliament, a respected Parliament, and of course, a respectable one. If there is this Parliament that is looking to the future, regardless of the convictions of one and the other, it is with the Parliament that we must talk about the major reforms of France, and not even before having talked about it to think about bypassing the Parliament through a referendum, which would be absolutely contradictory. Finally, I apologize, I am not definitively closing the door on all of this, but I would not understand the logic for a President of the Republic to wish to express himself before the parliamentarians to talk about the future and then say: "Excuse me, but this will be done by referendum, thus over your heads." Honestly, that would not be very coherent.

Q - A question about supervision. It was decided, at Mr. Brown's request, that future European supervisory authorities cannot make binding decisions when this involves consequences for national budgets. Is this not going to somewhat undermine the substance of European financial supervision? And a second question, Mr. Klaus said that the Irish guarantees would require a vote in Parliament in the Czech Republic. What do you say about that?

R - The second answer is very easy. It was specified that this does not change anything, the Irish protocol, to the treaty for the twenty-six other states. It is a legal decision with political implications that applies to Mr. Klaus as to each of us. From this point of view, I think that any continuation of the debate on the subject would be polemical.

It is not just Mr. Brown who was concerned about the budgetary consequences; I believe Germany was as well. I fully understand the Chancellor who said: "Be careful, if we are the ones paying, we do not want to find ourselves in a situation where an organization, even if it is European, forces us to pay." I find that the agreement we have reached is significant, especially since we all agreed that this is a starting point and that there may be a number of developments in the future. But rating agencies, banks, insurance companies, national supervisors, and states are supervised on the application of a standard and regulation. I know there is the issue of clearing houses to determine whether we include them in the binding measures or not.

My idea is to achieve the establishment of European supervision, to achieve the establishment of a binding power, and, thirdly, to let the institutions thrive. Like any institution, we know perfectly well that it starts in a defined area and that this defined area tends not to become undefined but to expand, and you know that very well. This is an absolute rule in all times and in all countries. The same will apply to supervision.

We had to find an agreement; I find it unexpected. Can you imagine that nine months ago, if I had said in this same room: "We have agreed on a European supervision system with binding power," would any one of you have believed it? No more, no less, we created a new European body, finally a system in truth, since these were vague committees on insurance. I could then elaborate on the Dexia affair; I could say a lot about the usefulness of these committees.

We have created a European supervision system with binding power. You are absolutely right; we could have further expanded the scope. My conviction is that it will expand through jurisprudence, through practice, as it has always been done. But already, it is impressive. Frankly, I have also argued to my colleagues: "Listen, at a time when the United States is equipping itself with a system, finally, is considering equipping itself with a binding system, Europe is not going to give the impression of being behind the curve. That would be unbelievable."

A considerable progress has been made. So, of course, it is somewhat masked by the fact that it started in Washington, continued in London, and there was the Larosière report. I remember the reception of the Larosière report. I speak under the control of my colleagues and friends; the Larosière report did not have unanimous support at all; there was even a strong temptation to bury it. Four months later, the Larosière report becomes our rule. And now, it is decided; no one can go back on it. That is still impressive.

I reiterate because it is the truth that I was happy to work with Gordon Brown, who took his responsibilities, and it is a complete change in the Anglo-Saxon strategy until now. There too, there were interesting concessions, but I saw Mr. Trichet; we talked well, we work well together. How should we appoint the head of supervision? I believe it was difficult to say right away that it must be the head of the ECB for countries that are not in the euro. But with the election system, given the relationships between those who are in and those who are out, what will it come back to? To the same thing, and you know that very well. I fully recognize the relevance of an argument that says: "You cannot say, while I am not in a euro zone, that the central bank that is not mine will necessarily be the president of ...". That may be the result, but we cannot set it as an ideological a priori; it makes no sense if we are in the European logic of seeking compromise to move forward.

These are the discussions we had again last night with Mr. Trichet, and it was very interesting.