Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, in favor of regulated globalization, in Geneva on June 15, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

15 June 2009 · 90th anniversary of the International Labour Organization, International Labour Conference · Geneva

Context
Sarkozy addressed the International Labour Organization's centenary conference in Geneva on June 15, 2009, advocating for regulated globalization and social justice amid the global financial crisis.
Main themes
Regulated globalization, social justice, ILO 90th anniversary, global financial crisis, history of international labor, work as human dignity, international cooperation, climate change, lessons of history, democratic responsibility, financial capitalism reform
Duration
~32 min
85th percentile
Words
3,859
85th percentile
Sentences
201
89th percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
10.9
32nd percentile
Syntax
2.87
31st percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 34%33%
  • Institutional 27%26%
  • Geopolitical 15%14%
  • Social 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 9%8%
  • Environmental 3%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

201 sentences in 115 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, heads of state and government,

Mr. President of the Conference,

Mr. Director-General,

Ladies and gentlemen, ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen, representatives of workers and employers,

In a few days, the ILO will celebrate its 90th anniversary.

I accepted the invitation of Director-General Somavia, whose exemplary leadership at the ILO I commend, because I wanted to pay tribute to the oldest of our international organizations and to the role it has played since the end of the First World War.

Among those who had experienced the war, its deaths, its sufferings, there arose men of good will who cried out "never again!" They wanted to establish relations between nations "on the basis of justice and honor." They wanted the law to prevail over force. They created the League of Nations. They made war illegal.

We know what happened next.

The Treaty of Versailles, in ending one war, prepared the ground for another.

And this war was even worse than the last.

Europe once again narrowly escaped material and moral annihilation.

From the great dream of peace that had carried the hopes of a wounded generation, there remained once again only heaps of ruins, tears, millions of dead, and the horrific memory of the Holocaust.

From this failure, however, something survived.

The drafters of the Treaty of Versailles were at least right on one point: "universal peace can only be founded on the basis of social justice."

From this strong idea was born the International Labour Organization, the only one of the international institutions created after the First World War that is still alive today.

Saint-Just may have proclaimed that with the Revolution, happiness became a new idea in Europe, but in 1919 total war and mass production had long since relegated the ideals of the Men of '89 to the dustbin of History. The creation of the ILO was a reaffirmation that man must cease to be seen as a means to be recognized as an end in himself.

To oppose work as a means of fulfillment and emancipation to work as alienation and enslavement, to make social justice one of the paths to peace, that was from the very beginning the vocation of the ILO. That is what it still is.

The ardent faith of a few lucid and courageous men is not enough to avert tragedy when democracies fail to equip themselves to defend their values. Among these lucid and courageous men, how can we not think of Albert Thomas, the first director of the ILO?

I want to pay tribute to this great figure of European socialism, to this friend of Jaurès, who throughout his life sought to transcend class struggle; he believed that "as soon as men meet eye to eye and speak to each other, whatever the opposition of interests, a great result is already achieved for the necessary understandings."

He established this unique international institution, the only one, even today, where representatives of states, employers, and employees meet. He made it thrive. He gave it its credibility.

He inscribed it in permanence. He invented social dialogue on an international scale.

So where does it come from that democracies found themselves so helpless in the face of the crisis of the 1930s and its terrible social and political consequences?

The answer is simple: states, governments did not meet the commitments they had made.

In 1925, Albert Thomas wrote: "I am painfully searching for the road that leads to the ratification of conventions." He also advocated for the organization of Europe. Nothing moved. He became so impatient that in 1930 he exclaimed: "if we let the years pass, the dangers of conflagration will appear again..."

He was right. It was necessary to invent a new world as quickly as possible before the old world exploded in everyone's face. Too few understood this, and among those who did, many did not dare.

I pose a question: will we learn the lessons of History so that it does not repeat itself? Or will we repeat the mistakes of the past with consequences that could prove just as disastrous?

As the global economy finds itself plunged into an unprecedented crisis since the Second World War, can we afford to wait?

In the face of misery, hunger, forced labor, and the degrading living conditions imposed on so many women and men around the world, do we have the right to wait?

In the face of climate change and the threats it poses to the stability of the world and the survival of part of humanity, do we have time to wait?

In the face of the depletion of non-renewable resources, how long must we wait to produce differently, to live differently, to develop other energies?

In the face of a financial capitalism gone mad from being unregulated and whose destructiveness we are beginning to measure, is it reasonable to wait any longer?

Must we wait for the economic, financial, social, and ecological crisis to transform into a major political crisis on a global scale before we finally decide to change, at the risk of it being too late?

Have we not waited long enough to regulate a globalization that, alongside the abundance of wealth it helped create, has fostered pockets of misery and frustration?

The regulation of globalization is the central question.

The world cannot be governed solely by the law of supply and demand.

Globalization cannot be the alibi for all our political, intellectual, and moral renunciations. Yet that is what the absence of global regulation condemns us to.

Dare I add that globalization will not survive the law of the jungle? Because there can be no freedom without rules.

The ILO has always defended this thesis, not without courage, even as it swam against the tide of a dominant ideology deeply entrenched in minds and global institutions.

As early as June 2004, Philippe Seguin, barely elected president of the ILO's Governing Body, declared: "the priority of the ILO is to respond to the need for regulation of globalization."

This was prophetic at a time not so long ago when so few political and economic leaders in the world took this issue seriously. You have since partially responded to it with the "Declaration on Social Justice for a Fair Globalization." It remains to put it into practice. Just as it remains to implement the decisions made by the G20 on financial regulation.

Everything is interconnected. Dumping, whether monetary, social, or environmental, should not be viewed merely as distortions of competition that cause lost earnings for the companies that suffer from them. They also lead to considerable social and human costs.

Child labor is not just unfair competition. It also prevents children from going to school and getting an education.

There are two types of globalization.

One that prioritizes external growth, each seeking by all means to take jobs and markets from others.

The other that prioritizes internal growth, that is, a development model in which everyone producing more and consuming more contributes to the development of all.

The first pushes the logic of competitiveness to the extreme at any cost by resorting to all forms of dumping, aggressive trade policies, and the crushing of purchasing power and living standards.

The second relies on increasing productivity, raising living standards, and improving well-being.

The first is conflictual.

The second is cooperative.

The first opposes economic progress and social progress.

The second, on the contrary, links them together.

The whole challenge today is to shift globalization from the first logic to the second. Those who want nothing to change will claim that it is utopian.

My conviction is that what is utopian today, what is irresponsible, is to believe that the crisis is a mere interlude and that everything will be able to start again as before.

What is utopian and what is irresponsible is to believe that this system of speculation, rents, and dumping that has trapped globalization in the deadlock it finds itself in can continue indefinitely, that we can continue to give everything to financial capital and nothing to labor, that financial markets can continue to impose their obsession with short-term profitability, fueled by gigantic leverage effects, on the entire economy and society.

What is utopian and what is irresponsible is to believe that peoples will endure the painful consequences of the crisis without saying anything, that they will not demand more protection, more justice, that they will once again tolerate, as if nothing had happened, the golden parachutes and the staggering gains of speculators paid for by their work and suffering.

I deeply believe that in the coming world there will be a demand for reason that will express itself with such force that no one will be able to escape it. In the name of this demand for reason, there will be behaviors that will no longer be tolerated. You have already sensed this by highlighting the notion of "decent work."

I say this weighing my words:

Either we will have reason or we will have revolt.

Either we will have justice or we will have violence.

Either we will have reasonable protections or we will have protectionism.

We need rules that become norms and that apply to everyone. It is not a matter of harmonizing in detail all labor laws. It is not about imposing the social standards of the richest countries on the poorest. But it is about establishing a system of rules among nations that lifts everyone up instead of dragging everyone down.

How can we understand that around fifty states in the world have not yet ratified the eight conventions that define fundamental labor rights? What kind of world do we want? That is the question we must all ask ourselves. France, for its part, responds by committing to ratify soon the Maritime Labour Convention and the Framework Convention on Health.

The issue of social and environmental standards is one of the most difficult. It forces us to question what can only be called "the commodification of the world." That is to say, the gradual extension of the market sphere to all human activities, which has been one of the major characteristics of globalization over the past twenty years and which has placed trade law above all else.

But health, education, culture, biodiversity, climate, and work are not commodities like any others. We know the energy that France has put into advocating for respect for cultural diversity. It will put the same energy into placing on an equal footing the right to health, the right to work, the right to the environment, and the right to trade. It will put the same energy into fighting against the temptation of protectionism and defending the idea that the WTO cannot be the sole decision-maker in everything and that each specialized institution must have its share in defining international standards and in their implementation.

We need more power, more resources for the International Monetary Fund, the World Health Organization, the International Labour Organization so that the standards they set do not remain dead letters. And when we reach, in Copenhagen, an ambitious agreement on climate, a true World Environment Organization must be created to enforce the commitments that will have been made, I hope, by all.

The governance of the 20th century cannot be that of the 21st century. We have already waited too long.

I call for the major emerging countries to be associated with global governance. We have waited too long for them to be represented among the permanent members of the Security Council. We have waited too long to expand the G8 to 13 or 14 members.

How can we hope to govern the world while leaving aside more than half of humanity? I call for free trade to be subject to a requirement of reciprocity. On this point too, we have waited too long to the point of distorting free trade and turning against it those who should be its most ardent defenders.

I call for the interventions of the IMF, the World Bank, development banks, and UNDP to be subject to environmental and social conditionality.

It is not normal that the IMF or the World Bank come to the aid of a country without being able to demand that it respect basic rules regarding the environment, labor rights, or public health.

We cannot accept that international aid is used to encourage forced labor or child labor or pollution that threatens the future of the planet.

But we cannot address the issue of social or environmental conditionality without raising the painful question of adjustment policies. For we cannot ask a country to meet a number of social requirements while simultaneously imposing, as has too often been done in the past, adjustment plans that have disastrous social and human consequences. In order to give lessons, international organizations must first apply them to themselves.

We cannot also demand of poor and emerging countries efforts that they would not be able to accomplish without permanently ruining their economy and their development prospects. The efforts requested must be reasonable and progressive, and every effort must correspond to increased development aid. This means that we can only make progress in everyone's interest if the effort is shared, if the most advanced countries are able to share their rents, to show a well-understood solidarity and generosity. There will be no progress if development aid remains at its current level and if it is not seen as the indispensable complement to environmental and social conditionalities without which globalization is doomed to failure.

I would like to propose another revolution in global governance so that the standards enshrined in international agreements are effectively applied. What is the use of standards that have no binding character?

This revolution is based on the idea that specialized institutions can intervene in disputes, particularly commercial disputes, through preliminary questions.

Let us build together this new global governance so that the ILO can have its say with the WTO, the IMF, and the World Bank whenever fundamental standards that it is responsible for enforcing are at stake! The international community cannot be schizophrenic and ignore at the WTO or in the Bretton Woods institutions what it promotes at the ILO. It is the role of the preliminary ruling to prevent this from happening.

Thus, the commercial judge would no longer be the only one to decide.

Thus, commercial law would no longer be the only one to prevail.

Thus, the ILO would be necessarily seized whenever a question relating to the respect of fundamental labor rights is raised in a dispute involving States. The IMF would be necessarily seized when a question relating to monetary dumping or what could be termed "prudent dumping" arises. The future World Organization for the Environment would be necessarily seized in matters of environmental dumping. In this way, the market logic could no longer prevail over all others, and all rules would truly become standards that each specialized international institution would apply to enforce within its area of competence.

Naturally, nothing will be resolved if we do not first address the question of financial capitalism that imposes its own system and norms on the economy and society. The G20 meetings in Washington and London will go down in history as decisive steps in the reconstruction of a new world order. Provided that the commitments made there are honored. Many things have already changed; I am thinking particularly of tax havens. But in many areas, we will need to go much further to rebuild a financial system that finances entrepreneurs more than speculators.

Everything needs to be reviewed: the prudential oversight of banks, the regulation of hedge funds, the organization of markets, accounting rules, and compensation methods. This is the time to go as far as possible. This is not the time to retreat. We have no time to lose. We have come close to catastrophe. Should we take the risk of starting over? I know that in some circles, in some administrations, because the markets are doing a little better, because speculators have resumed speculating, there is a temptation to reduce the scope of what has been decided.

Yielding to this temptation would be a mistake.

I say to all the heads of state and government of the G20 that it is a historical responsibility for each of us to see through what we have undertaken, to not let any pressure group, any bureaucracy, or any special interest obstruct it.

I want to tell the President of the United States that America must be the most ambitious because it is its vocation, because it is its role to lead the movement, because it is to the America of Wilson and Roosevelt that we owe multilateralism and the very idea of global regulation and governance.

I want to tell all the heads of state and government of the European Union that Europe must be exemplary because that is how it will be most faithful to its values and how it can share them.

What could Europe say to the world if it were not even capable of establishing European regulation and a European regulator?

I want to tell all those who fear change that change is necessary to restore trust and that the riskiest thing would be not to change.

I want to tell them that France will ensure that no debate is buried, that no question is evaded.

Look at the debate on the Tobin tax, which is a tax to curb speculation. I do not know if it is a good idea. I do not know if it is applicable. But who could understand that this debate should be buried?

Let it be known that I will not allow the carbon tax to suffer the fate that was inflicted in the past on the debate on the taxation of speculation. Because the carbon tax is the condition for fair competition and a shared effort to save the planet.

I want to say that there is an urgent need to raise this question and to answer it if we do not want to have to choose tomorrow between free trade and the fight against global warming, which would be utterly absurd.

France wants to lead the debate on the reform of global governance. It wants to lead the debate on reciprocity and on environmental and social conditionality.

I also draw attention to the necessity of advancing on the reform - dare I say the rebuilding? - of the international monetary system. How can we not see that it is always labor that pays the first consequences of monetary disorder? How can we not see that in the unfairness of global competition, it is currencies that play the most important role today?

In the future, the G20 will have to address this question as well. It will also have to take more into account the social dimension of the crisis and the new world order it intends to help build.

I have advocated for the Director-General of the ILO to participate in the meeting of heads of state and government on the same level as the Director-General of the IMF or the Director-General of the WTO. I will advocate again, as it is an absolute necessity in my eyes, that the issue of labor be placed at the center of reflection and considered as a secondary problem.

I hope that the ILO will make concrete proposals to place the promotion of decent work at the heart of the rules that will form the foundation of a more human-centered world order.

The crisis of the 1930s teaches us that we should not respond to the crisis by imposing such heavy sacrifices on workers that recovery would be difficult, if not impossible. Thus, France supports the adoption by the International Labour Conference of "Conclusions" on a "Global Employment Pact." It wishes for this Employment Pact to be discussed within the framework of a "Commission on Employment" in which the ILO and social partners would participate to prepare for the next G20 summit.

These debates are essential debates.

They are debates through which our future is at stake.

I recognize what these revolutions in regulation and global governance require in terms of breaking with habits, behaviors, and ways of thinking.

I do not underestimate the objections that can be raised against them, nor the fears they may evoke, particularly in developing countries or emerging countries.

I know that many of France's partners will not immediately agree to go as far.

But it is France's duty to show the way and to stimulate the debate. France will not be right on its own. But if we do not open these debates now, when the crisis forces everyone to question, when will we do it?

To those who approach the Copenhagen climate conference with distrust,

To those who hesitate to give more regulatory power to the IMF,

To those who constantly delay the ratification of ILO conventions,

To those who view the creation of a World Organization for the Environment as a threat to trade freedom and an obstacle to economic growth,

I want to say that the only thing they should fear is stagnation. President Roosevelt told Americans in 1933 in his inaugural address: "The only thing we have to fear is fear itself."

To emerge from the crisis, to restore trust, so that hundreds of millions of people can once again look to the future as a promise, we need to change our growth model. We will not succeed if we do not manage to regulate globalization. We must remember that democracy, freedom, openness, and social progress are by no means irreversible gains.

I would like to conclude my remarks by quoting Francis Blanchard, another great Director-General of the ILO who left a strong mark on it for 15 years with his strong personality and total commitment. He writes at the end of his memoirs: "The problem is not that of the ends set out in so many solemn declarations and agendas, but that of their follow-up and the means that only strong political will could implement in vital areas and in urgency. Discourses accompanied by precise commitments are necessary to break several locks that close the paths to sustainable development."

He was thinking of public development aid, water, the fight against AIDS, education, culture, energy, housing, employment... As early as 1976, the ILO emphasized the need for a strategy that simultaneously covers all these essential needs. What have we done since? I take up his own words to do justice to the ILO, which "was very wrong to be right too early."

Let us not wait to act until it is too late.

What world would we leave to our children if we were not even capable of agreeing on limiting greenhouse gases, on tax havens, or on such fundamental principles as freedom of association, the prohibition of forced labor, the abolition of child labor, or the elimination of discrimination in employment, at least as objectives that we all want to strive to achieve?

What responsibility would we bear towards future generations and towards our own conscience if we renounced this?