Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the reforms undertaken since his accession to the presidency, particularly in the economic field, in Paris on June 12, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

12 June 2009 · Statement on reforms undertaken since accession to the presidency · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed a business gathering in Paris on June 12, 2009, outlining economic and labor reforms undertaken since his 2007 election to the presidency.
Main themes
Economic reforms, labor market reform, 35-hour workweek, work culture and values, competitiveness, early retirement policy, pension financing, globalization, French economic policy, social dialogue, employment of older workers, youth employment
Duration
~31 min
84th percentile
Words
3,741
84th percentile
Sentences
239
92nd percentile
Readability
61
90th percentile
Grade
8.5
8th percentile
Syntax
2.69
12th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 51%49%
  • Social 20%20%
  • Institutional 17%16%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

239 sentences in 64 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Mr. President RIDORET,

I remember very well 2006. I remember what I told you, what was at the core of my convictions, the analysis I made of our country, the electoral campaign I wanted to engage in.

Two years after being elected, I wanted to come even though I announced that I would speak before Congress, before national sovereignty to outline lines of the future.

I wanted to come before your gathering because, fundamentally, what you are asking for is very simple. You are asking us: let us work. Let us do what we know how to do: work, take risks, satisfy our clients, fight, be competitive.

I will try to tell you, from the bottom of my heart, why we have done a number of things.

What were the problems of France?

We had a first problem which was our relationship to work. It was reflected in the semantics. We no longer spoke of workers because we no longer respected work. We only spoke of statuses and not of work. Everything was put in place to discourage work. I could take multiple examples, the 35-hour workweek being very revealing of a mindset according to which real life was outside of work.

Life is not just about work. But to say that we must get rid of work as quickly as possible in order to finally be able to live is an original conception of the progress of civilizations and the progress of societies.

In the 35 hours, the strangest thing is that we were the only ones to implement it in the world. At the very moment when France was experiencing globalization, it took a measure that was not adopted anywhere else in the world. Moreover, the more left-wing governments were elsewhere in the world, the less they implemented the 35 hours. I think of Mr. SCHRODER in Germany. I think of Mr. BLAIR in Great Britain and Mr. BROWN in England. I think of Mr. ZAPATERO in Spain. None were inspired by what we were doing.

How strange it was to put France in this situation of non-competitiveness, at the very moment when Europe was being built and when we wanted to play a role in globalization.

It was very dangerous for our younger generations because it discredited work. And there is nothing more serious than that.

The problem of France was not that we worked too much, but that there was not enough work. And what was increasingly curious was that a large part of my friends made the same analysis as I did about the 35 hours but did not draw the same conclusions. Many thought poorly of it and did not touch it. French democracy was not functioning well because many said to themselves why listen to them since they say things they will not do.

It is not at all out of ideological spirit or system spirit that we reformed this. We kept the 35 hours as the weekly duration but we allowed, particularly for companies like yours, the possibility - I say this in front of Laurence PARISOT - to exempt themselves from this limitation through overtime which is tax-exempt for employees and without social contributions for companies.

If sharing work as an economic strategy worked, we would know it. Everywhere in the world, a winning economic strategy has been adopted by allowing people to take initiatives and work, not by sharing working time. But of course, I understand that for people who started their professional lives early, who have particularly difficult jobs, there is a natural aspiration to leave earlier or to work less.

By the way, why 35 hours? We could have done 32 hours, 28, 25... We found ourselves in a situation where, at the same time as we artificially reduced the duration of working time, we delayed the entry of the youngest into the labor market and pushed fifty-somethings into retirement. With this, it is curious, we have a problem financing our pension systems. Fewer fifty-somethings at work than others, fewer young people at work than others. And when we work, we work less than others. Here is a rather original system.

This problem, despite the crisis, had to be resolved. When growth returns, you will have the necessary hours to meet the order books that will fill up again.

I add that the system of early retirement that we have used and abused in France has been a profound mistake. How can we explain to our fellow citizens that they must work longer because life expectancy is increasing and at the same time have as the only idea to accompany young fifty-somethings towards early retirement? It is a strategy that disassociates people, that despairs people. I cannot let it be said that a fifty-something has no professional future.

Today, no one is asking us, I speak under the control of Laurence PARISOT as well, to lighten the constraint of working time. We did it, Mr. President, without drama, without violence, without blockage. We did it as I said during the campaign: by discussing, by dialoguing, by listening but by not yielding on the essentials. This is also a great change in the governing habits of our country.

There was a second problem, which is the difficulty we have in dialoguing in serenity and without blockage: it was the whole question of minimum service.

For companies, not receiving mail, not being able to see employees who want to work come to work on strike days, having employees taken hostage by conflicts that concern them very little or not at all. France was one of the few countries in the world that, on days of national movements, gave the spectacle of a totally paralyzed economy.

In consultation, in listening, in calm, we voted at the beginning of the new legislature for minimum service.

Public and private employees have the right to strike. It is a constitutionally recognized right, it is an element of democracy. We had significant social movements last winter. My duty is to hear them, to listen to them and to dialogue. But even on days of major demonstrations, your employees were able to go to work and return home. The country was not paralyzed, it is a great progress of social democracy and French democracy.

The third problem is taxation. We want Europe, I am deeply European. But we do not draw all the conclusions from it. Europe cannot be all the advantages for our European partners and all the disadvantages for French taxpayers. In Europe, who is our main partner and who is our main competitor? Friendly partner and competitor is Germany. They are our neighbors. They are the number one economy in Europe. We are number two. Who can blame me for wanting to propose to France to be inspired by what the Germans do best?

What do they do better? First, they have an exceptional culture of internationalism. Secondly, a capacity to determine the interest of their companies that is fantastic. A capitalism you called patrimonial, I could also say familial, which allows for an unprecedented network of strong SMEs in Germany and strong internationally. A taxation oriented towards the idea that a great country needs a great industry. And well, what are we trying to do, to be inspired by what they have.

What do they have? First, they do not have the professional tax. What is manufactured in France is taxed by a tax called the professional tax. What is manufactured outside of France is exempt from the professional tax. I say this in front of the president of the Association of Mayors, my friend Jacques PELISSARD, it is a system that cannot last. Since 1976, since the professional tax exists, all governments, whether left or right, have said it is a bad tax. But everyone has kept it. I announce to you that I will abolish it. If it is a bad tax, let us draw the consequences. There is hardly anyone but the Canton of Geneva that has the professional tax. I say this to the president of the Association of Mayors, I will have this discussion with elected officials, particularly on the compensation of resources. But let everyone make an effort, the State, local authorities, social security: everyone must participate in the effort to modernize France and improve its competitiveness, not just the State. I add that with relocations, there will not be much left of the base of the professional tax.

Germany also has the tax shield. With the tax shield in France, no taxpayer will pay more than half of what they earn in taxes. I wish that those who have money invest not only in Germany but also in France. I often go to factories. Do you believe that French employees, particularly in SMEs, prefer that their company be owned by a family they know, by a man or woman who can speak to each employee, or by a pension fund whose manager changes every year and demands returns that no company can provide?

I defend patrimonial capitalism, familial capitalism. If we do not implement the tax shield, let us not be surprised that each of those who could invest in our country goes to Belgium, Switzerland, Spain, Germany even though France is at the heart of Europe. A number of my own friends told me during the crisis that I should implement a temporary tax. It is no because temporary in France, especially when it comes to taxes, lasts. If increasing taxes were the solution to the problems of the French deficits, we would have known it a long time ago. Increasing taxes is a problem for competitiveness, for employment in France, that is the truth.

I add on the wealth tax that I proposed to Mrs. LAGARDE - I want to pay tribute to her action - to allow that the wealth tax contribution can be paid to SMEs up to 50,000 euros in tax. This has a pedagogical virtue that those who have means invest them in the French industrial and entrepreneurial fabric.

I will skip over the research tax credit which finally allows our companies to bring research laboratories back to France. We now have, Ladies and Gentlemen, the best tax system in the world in terms of research and development, whereas it was our weak point.

The fourth problem: our universities. All the university systems in the world that work have granted autonomy to their universities. Our system has its merits. But in global competition, let us not be surprised that our universities have regressed in the Shanghai ranking because they were given statuses, but not the means to develop.

With Valérie PECRESSE, we wanted the autonomy of universities. This provoked debates. I was not happy with the nine months of strikes and occupations. Yet I chose not to back down because I believe that the interest of the French university was that the government holds firm. It is not so often that a government faces such a movement, without it resulting in a generalized retreat. Our universities are competing with grandes écoles on one side, and with other universities in the world on the other side. If we do not modernize them, how will we get by?

The fifth problem, the deficit. In the name of the deficit, France has been renouncing to invest for 25 years. To avoid increasing the deficit, we cut investment spending, but not intervention spending and not assistance spending. We say: "Strasbourg, capital of Europe." It takes 28 years to finish the TGV line between Paris and Strasbourg. This strategy is incoherent. I am asked as President of the Republic to inaugurate new sections whose decisions were made 15 to 22 years ago! I want to get out of this system where Presidents of the Republic, Ministers, Jean-Louis, Christine, announce equipment that they will not see because by the time they are realized, the Ministers and the President will have long since left.

I tell you, when we decide something, we do it. I speak under the control of Jean-Louis BORLOO to whom I want to pay tribute. Next year, for the first time in the history of our country, there will be four TGV lines under construction while for the past 20 years there has barely been one each year!

Jean-Louis, I share your opinion. Building TGV lines in our country is not an increase in the deficit, it is an investment. There are expenditures that increase the deficit without any benefit and there are expenditures that are one-off expenditures that are essential investment expenditures for the competitiveness of France. In the name of the crisis and the deficits, I will not cut investments in France. This is true for the TGVs, it is true for the Seine-Nord canal. Everyone praised river transport. And for 20 years, not a single spade has been turned for the Seine-Nord canal. What is the point of making passionate speeches about ecological transport if we draw no consequences from them? We will find the means to make the investments we need.

What I say applies to the Campus plan: five billion euros to modernize our universities. Is it normal that families in France have to look for universities in Europe, the United States, and elsewhere, so that their students, their children can live on a pleasant campus with sports facilities and libraries open on Sundays?

I do not accept the idea that French universities are impoverished because no one wants to invest in them anymore.

The same goes for the hospital plan 2012 led by Roselyne BACHELOT: twelve billion euros. I said that all hospitals that network, that come together with others, that work within the framework of the new territorial communities, will have the means to restructure and invest. We have decided to embark on a vast investment program because we believe in sustainable growth. And for you, construction industry professionals, even if you do not see it right away, there will be order books coming in during the course of 2010. And this is a major strategic choice.

I take this opportunity to tell you that I will raise the question of easing our urban planning laws. Of simplifying our legal framework. By wanting to codify everything, we end up paralyzing everything. No one asks the question of beauty or ugliness anymore. We ask the question of legality or illegality. One does not need to see a lawyer; one needs to see several lawyers since they have specialized, each in their own niche. And the business leader finds themselves facing an army of specialists.

We have created a system that penalizes those who want to take initiatives and favors those who do not care about the result but respect the procedures. It is long, it is heavy, it is paralyzing. Moreover, Mr. President, it does not protect the environment and it does not protect the landscape. We will significantly lighten things up.

I have sometimes been criticized when I announced the Grand Paris. A project that I hold above all else. I would like France to be in a position of leadership to define the new city. Not the new town. Because the new town is a town, with its flaws, that we build in addition. The new city is a different conception. I would like France to be the country where urban planning moves and innovates. I would like France to understand that the answer to the crisis lies in major projects and a capacity to dream.

For the Grand Paris - a considerable investment for you - if we had not decided that the State would take the lead to realize, shake up, gather, animate, and inspire with the 10 largest architectural firms in the world, who have done remarkable work, my grandchildren would not see the beginning of the investments that the great urban conurbation of Paris needs to circulate.

For three decades, I have heard that Saclay should be the Silicon Valley of the Paris region. I was in Saclay the other day; there is no metro, there are no buses. It starts off badly!

Some wonder: why has he converted to green? My entire campaign was on this subject. The Grenelle Environment, I proposed it before the presidential election. Jean-Louis BORLOO, Minister of State, number two in the government, has not had this responsibility since the day after the European elections. We made decisions such as the safeguard clause on GMOs, the zero-interest loan for energy savings, construction in HQE, the buyback - dear Christine BOUTIN - of a number of homes that were stalled due to the crisis, the tax exemption on loan interest when purchasing a property.

In France, it is not unusual, when buying a home, to be able to deduct part of the interest. We should not pay taxes on the interest we pay.

Finally, one last thing: our social system. I will have the opportunity to talk about it in more detail.

Do not hold it against me for skimming over these issues. Our social system, I say this in front of Martin HIRSCH, was organized around an idea that is assistance. Those who could not make it, we helped them survive. Michel ROCARD had a very good idea in creating the RMI. But 20 years later, half of the people on the RMI had been on it for more than three years and could no longer get out. We replaced the RMI with Martin HIRSCH without drama, without controversy since June 1 with the RSA. This means that anyone who has the RMI and takes a job can combine their work income and their social benefits. This is only fair. Someone in Île-de-France who is unemployed is entitled to free transport. When they make an effort and take a job, even if it is part-time, we reward them by taking away their right to free transport. What a nice encouragement! This is a system that discredits work and penalizes those who make an effort to get by.

With the RSA, everyone wants to work because for the first time in France we are moving away from the logic of status to focus on the person and their income. This is social justice.

I tell you this, Ladies and Gentlemen, because France is much more capable of change than the French elites have believed for a long time. Conservatism is not in the minds of the French. It is in the minds of a part of the French elites.

Finally, I understand those of you who are hurt by the attacks and I understand those of you who are angry. I have been shocked by certain behaviors. I told Laurence PARISOT.

I believe so much in the market economy, entrepreneurial capitalism, freedom, responsibility, equality that I do not accept that a tiny minority tramples on these values through unacceptable behaviors.

I want to clarify things. What is unacceptable? It is not to earn much more money than others if one deserves it. I said it on television a few months ago. I am opposed to capping salaries. If tomorrow we have a French Bill Gates, do you not think it would be worth paying him a little above what the norm would provide?

And at the same time, it is not acceptable that those who make great mistakes do not assume their great responsibilities. We cannot be in a system where when things go well, we take everything, and when things go badly, we are responsible for nothing!

When the banking crisis occurred, I said that those who led us there must assume their responsibilities. I was told: we cannot find them. I made a proposal: release the list of bonuses from last year, because last year we found those responsible for the bonuses, why could we not find this year those responsible for the penalties?

This is entrepreneurial capitalism. It is the market economy. Great remuneration when deserved. When things go wrong, someone must assume their responsibilities.

Do you think that in recent months, I have not felt responsible, sometimes even a bit excessively? If we are not demanding with those who have diverted values in which we believe, then let us not be surprised that the French people no longer understand the values we claim. Put yourself in the shoes of someone with a low salary, who sees the figures and the impunity.

I say this just as much for our banker friends in their relationship with businesses. René RICOL has done remarkable work.

We need banks. Our banks are in a better situation than others. And for the most part, our bankers have done quite remarkable work.

But I cannot understand why when there was the internet bubble, anyone could find any amount of money at any time for projects that no one understood. When real estate exploded, I do not understand why anyone could finance a project at any price. But when there is a crisis, the most serious projects struggle to get financed because there is no one left to finance them. France must move away from a system where money is lent to those who do not need it.

Ladies and Gentlemen, regardless of the violence of the crisis, France needed to modernize. The crisis allows us to think freely, to break away from old patterns, to take calculated risks.

In relation to old ideas, the crisis makes us aware that we have entered the 21st century while still holding onto ideas from the 20th, even the 19th.

This is what makes me optimistic about the future. We have implemented, with the government of François Fillon, a very important program of reforms. I will continue on this path without deviation. I was elected to modernize the country, to change France, so that when the crisis is over, France can fully benefit from the global recovery. I was elected so that by the end of my term, all or part of the major problems of our country would be resolved or have begun to be resolved.

It is my passion to solve problems; it is my duty to face this. I am not an ideologue; I am a pragmatist. What I said in my project, I will implement for a simple reason: when I said it, I believed it, and I have not changed my mind.

Thank you all.