Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on the future of European construction, the question of Kosovo, the negotiations for a framework agreement with Libya, and the ratification by Parliament of the Lisbon Treaty, in Brussels on December 14, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

14 December 2007 · Press conference in Brussels on December 14, 2007 · Brussels

Context
Sarkozy held a press conference in Brussels on December 14, 2007, addressing European construction, Kosovo, Serbia, and the Lisbon Treaty.
Main themes
European future and borders, Kosovo independence, Serbia and EU accession, Group of Sages, European enlargement vs. integration, Lisbon Treaty ratification, ICTY and war criminals, EU-Serbia relations, French foreign policy
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,506
89th percentile
Sentences
256
93rd percentile
Readability
61
90th percentile
Grade
8.9
10th percentile
Syntax
2.78
20th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

256 sentences in 59 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, if there are any questions, I will be very happy to answer them.

Q - Mr. President, I would like to know about the group of Sages, which is a French idea, whether you plan to ask this group of Sages or if you expect this group to talk about Turkey, about borders. Can this group of Sages discuss this according to the mandate given to it? Has there been an agreement on this in your mind?

A - The agreement we have is that the group of Sages does not talk about institutions, since we should not reopen the institutional debate. That is not its purpose. We are not going to complicate the task of our British friends, moreover. The group of Sages will not discuss the content of specific policies, agricultural policies, even financial perspectives; that is not its concern. The problem of the group of Sages is to reflect on the possibilities of a new European dream on the horizon of 2020-2030. In this new European dream, the question of borders will inevitably arise. It is not simply the question of Turkey; it is the question of borders.

Should Europe establish borders or not? Should it expand indefinitely? And if it expands, what consequences could that have? That is the question for the group of Sages. It is obvious. From that moment on, the question will certainly arise: do we continue with an integrated political Europe, which is my position, or do we make another choice, because it is clear that the more we expand Europe, the more the question of its integration will arise? There will come a time when we will have to face the facts and ask ourselves whether there is a contradiction or not between integration and enlargement; that is certain, even if France is not opposed to the enlargement to all the countries of Europe.

So the question is certainly part of the reflection on the future of Europe.

Q - Mr. President, Carla Del Ponte, before leaving her position as Prosecutor of the Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, calls on Europeans to remain firm on Serbia. She is concerned that Europe is prioritizing politics over justice and that, in a way, we are letting the arrest of General Mladic slip away. She expresses her astonishment, particularly at the attitude of France, which has softened its position. Is Ms. Del Ponte right or wrong to be concerned?

A - I do not even understand what it means to prioritize politics over justice. I am sorry, the decision to create the tribunal was a deeply political decision. It does not make sense. Justice in a democratic state is therefore a deeply political decision. What does that mean? I have seen ideas that had no seriousness, but that one! Justice after politics, really? I do not even understand.

The question we are faced with is very simple: France does not yield on its principles. We have a difficulty with Kosovo, of which everyone can see that independence is inevitable, with a United Nations force present in Kosovo, and with a Serbia that must not be condemned to isolation and despair. Because from that moment on, we will create the conditions for confrontation between one another. That is still a question. And Europe and France can send a positive signal to Serbia by saying: apply for candidacy and your place, in the long run, will be secured when you have met all the conditions and respect for human rights; that is one of the conditions. Rather, what do you want us to say? That Kosovo unilaterally proclaims its independence and that Serbia is doomed to hegemony? If that is what we want, then you will see that we will prioritize both politics and justice, behind which lies war. We need to think sometimes; it is not forbidden to reflect. We are trying to bring people together, not to divide them. We are trying to find a way forward.

Who does not see that between Kosovo and Serbia, it can no longer work? It is not our fault. France should not be blamed. France has done its job, its duty. Bernard Kouchner spent two years there; there are French soldiers present. France, perhaps more than others, has taken its responsibilities. The International Criminal Tribunal, France was one of the first countries to ratify it. I have always supported the ICTY. Let us not confuse the search for war criminals, or those suspected as such, with the possibility for a country like Serbia to one day join the European Union.

We have the right, in Europe and in France, to have convictions without immediately being put on the pillory for not respecting human rights. What is the connection? There is an ICTY that France has always supported and continues to support, and then there is a people, the Serbian people, who must not be condemned to think: but if we recognize the independence of Kosovo, which is de facto the case, there is no hope and no future for them.

Listen, it seems useful to say this. It has nothing to do with the rest. If Ms. Del Ponte is only astonished by this, frankly, her indignation is calm. There you go, we fully support the search for war criminals and fully support the ICTY.

But at the same time, it is all of Europe that says to Serbia: if you are a candidate, if you meet the conditions, if you respect human rights, if you integrate economically, if you respect the independence of Kosovo, well, you have a future in the family.

These intolerant positions from everyone, some of their conviction and the other side only saying nonsense, lies, are unbearable. Europe is also about understanding the other and their problems. We have a matter, excuse the understatement, extraordinarily difficult to manage, and it is a European matter.

What we have argued, with Bernard Kouchner, is that it was not for the Russians, it was not for the Americans to resolve the Kosovo issue; it was for the Europeans. But everyone will agree that to resolve the Kosovo issue, the problem of Serbia also arises, or else it is not the same region and it is not the same history, and we have not studied the same files. If you say - which is France's position - that the independence of Kosovo is inevitable and if we say nothing to the Serbs, do you believe we have made progress? We need to try to calm things down and not, constantly, throw oil on the fire. We can defend the idea that one day Serbia, if it meets the conditions, will enter Europe without wanting to exempt a number of people suspected of being war criminals from having done so and from being held accountable in the ICTY.

Q - Mr. President, still on this inevitable independence of Kosovo, the majority of European leaders consider that, ultimately, it is a unique case, a sui generis case...

A - It is very important; it is in the text.

Q - ... A position that is not necessarily shared by the entire international community. Moreover, even in France, Mr. Chevènement believes that you are opening a little bit the Pandora's box, to return to the Security Council meeting in a few days...

A - ... If Mr. Chevènement disagrees, that is already a good sign. Frankly, given the number of quite colossal errors accumulated, that is still a good sign.

Q - How will you convince the Security Council, in a few days, Moscow and Mr. Vladimir Putin, that this is not a precedent in international law?

A - First of all, there is a factual situation, which you know perfectly well; the Kosovars and the Serbs no longer want to live together. Europe has done everything possible to bring the points of view closer. There is a troika. We have multiplied efforts. We have tried everything, including when I was in Moscow, to explain to Mr. Putin that a confederal solution would be a good solution. Let us look at things as they are. It has failed. The troika has failed. We are doing everything we can. The Finn has failed. Everything has failed. Now, Mr. Chevènement can say what he wants; the Kosovars and the Serbs no longer want to live together. Yugoslavia no longer exists, just as the Soviet Union no longer exists. Yalta is over. I had the opportunity to tell my interlocutors, particularly Mr. Putin. It is a reality. What do we do with that? Do we let people kill each other?

For years, we sent a military force that did what? Interposition, in truth, to prevent people from killing each other. And we say, it is not Mr. Putin's business, who may have friends; it is not Mr. Bush's business, who may have friends. It is the business of Europeans because we are in Europe. It is not absurd for Europe to have a political position on this issue. What does it mean to open Pandora's box? It is not because Europe will recognize the inevitable independence of Kosovo that we are responsible for the fact that the Serbs and Kosovars no longer want to live together. Just as we are not responsible for what happened with Bosnia and Herzegovina, with Slovenia, with all that constituted the former Yugoslavia. That no longer exists. We cannot bring Marshal Tito back. We need to warn, particularly in France, Mr. Chevènement. It is over.

We have to manage Europe in 2007 and, if possible, Europe in 2020, not Europe in 1945, on which, by the way, there would be much to say. It is a historical debate that is extremely interesting. From that moment on, we are trying; we have included in the text, you are absolutely right, the expression "sui generis." Why? Because it would be so easy for those who do not want us to resolve problems to say, "do not touch this problem; it will create difficulties elsewhere." But it is for this reason that 80 million Eastern Europeans did not know freedom for fifty years. That is exactly the same problem.

We are trying to resolve the difficulties of our European family by saying: it is not because we resolve this problem that we open a front in Ossetia. That is another problem; that is another question. And, as politics matters, we specified it "expressis verbis." Because, what can we say? We can say that Kosovo is the last stage of a process of disintegration of what was, in quotes, an artificial country, I mean Yugoslavia, which could hold under very specific historical conditions that were the consequences of the war of the two blocs and the entirety of the history you know. It is exactly as if you said: Croatia did not have the right to independence, Slovenia did not have the right to independence, Bosnia and Herzegovina did not have the right to independence, Serbia did not have the right to independence. What remains? What remains is Kosovo, and that is what we are trying to resolve. We are trying to resolve it among Europeans, but afterwards I do not pass judgment, but we are trying to resolve the problem because the problem is there.

The truth is, either we do something and we have a chance to avoid the maximum of dramas, or we do nothing and we will have the maximum of dramas.

Q - Mr. President, do you think there is a serious and significant risk that other regions in the Balkans will demand the right to self-determination? How, Mr. President, would you explain to people, for example, that the Republika Srpska in Bosnia does not have the same right to self-determination as Kosovo, for example?

A - First of all, there will be elections in Serbia, and I will not do anything that complicates the task of these elections, of those who are candidates in these elections, and some of them have a more soothing discourse than others. Without meddling in Serbian politics, you see perfectly what I mean. And if we have asked for time, because with Bernard Kouchner, we have constantly said: come on, let us give ourselves a little time. We have stopped the negotiations; it is useless, but we have asked for a little time because I have the calendar in mind, the end of January, the beginning of February, which is an important step for Serbia. There is a problem that is an extremely acute problem, which we need to resolve while avoiding bloodshed. That is what we have decided: a united Europe. That is colossal. I add that the civilian force we are going to send will be extremely important and, from my point of view, will remain longer than one might think. It will require a lot of resources. This is a decision that was made today. Our objective, Bernard Kouchner and I, was that Europe does not explode. That is still very good news.

For the rest, I am aware that Europe is complicated, that there are sub-regions, regions, and problems. We are starting to address a colossal problem that could have blown Europe apart. Well, good news, Europe has not exploded! I fully understand the problems of Cyprus, perfectly, we have had peacekeepers there for 25 years. The problems of the Bulgarians, the problems of the Romanians, we can perfectly understand that. I can even understand the problem of the Dutch who have the International Criminal Court. Despite that, we have remained united. Despite that, we made a decision. Despite that, Europe has made progress. That's not so bad, and France has played a role in it. I will no longer respond to that question; I already have a lot to do with my European colleagues on the issue of Kosovo. This does not exhaust the debate on nationalities. That is for sure. I acknowledge that, and you are right. It does not exhaust it. The same goes for the Spanish president; it could pose a problem for him with the Basque question. Nevertheless, we have overcome that. It does not exhaust the question; you are right, at the same time, we cannot consider that nothing has happened since the fall of the Berlin Wall.

Q - Mr. President, you just alluded to the problem of Cyprus here. How can we ensure that Cyprus remains on board with Europe? Do you have contacts with the government of Cyprus?

R - I will tell you what we did today; it is already not so bad, after all. There is still work to be done, there is an agenda, there are files, there are questions. First, I am not omniscient; I do not have ideas on everything. There are indeed many problems that remain. I simply wanted to say that a number of countries, with the advice and friendship of France, have had to make efforts, which I fully understand. Moreover, we are preparing with Bernard Kouchner for the French Presidency. I draw your attention to the fact that a Presidency in the European system, especially at the time it will have passed, requires finding compromises and bringing people together. That is what we are trying to do, and I understand the problems that have been expressed around the table. As for all the other questions that remain, believe me, the agenda of the Slovenian Presidency and then the French Presidency will be quite full.

Q - You recalled Europe's decision to negotiate a framework agreement with Libya. Just today, as Mr. Gaddafi's visit in Paris comes to an end, what is your assessment of it?

R - I observe that he is going to Spain, to a socialist government. The European Socialist International must not be working very well, because, frankly, there you go. I did what I thought I had to do, which is to avoid at all costs a confrontation between the Muslim world and the Western world, because if we treat someone who is on the path of abandoning terrorism, of abandoning nuclear weapons, in the same way as those who continue to want terrorism and nuclear weapons, then we put ourselves in a situation of a clash of civilizations, which is the worst solution for the world and for its stability. If 26 other countries are proposing a framework agreement to Libya, it means I cannot be the only one sharing this opinion. There are people around the table from the north and from the south, from the east and from the west, socialists, conservatives, people from the left and people from the right. They all make the same analysis. That should lead us to reflect on these issues. I add that I was very moved to receive, yesterday, the association of victims of the UTA DC-10, who told me: "this visit was painful for us, but it was necessary." And I would like to launch this example of dignity and responsibility to all those who reacted excessively and irresponsibly. I received them at length, and it was indeed something very moving.

Q - Mr. President, what details can we have about this framework agreement between Libya and the European Union? What type of agreement is it, and what areas will it cover?

R - The proposal of the European Union is to open negotiations to negotiate a framework agreement; in this case, the political decision is what is interesting. The framework agreement is not drafted; it is a political will to propose this framework agreement. Moreover, I refer you to the conclusions of the Council.

Q - Did you discuss the situation in Chad? Did you find solutions to allow the deployment of European forces?

R - Bernard Kouchner, with great determination, continues to gather helicopters one by one, and that is progressing, and it will be deployed. I also specify that I had a long conversation with Bernard Kouchner and President Deby yesterday, and I will see the association of the families of the Zoé Ark this evening to give them an update on the situation.

Q - Jean-Claude Juncker believes that growth in Europe will be slowed by the current financial crisis; was this discussed?

R - No, it was not discussed in detail today, even though Gordon Brown, Angela Merkel, and I took initiatives a few weeks ago to call for more transparency and more regulation, but listen, we are thinking about taking other initiatives when the time comes.

Q - Did you discuss the Mediterranean Union project?

R - No, the Mediterranean Union project was not discussed in that context, but I will have the opportunity to address it next week during a visit. After my visit to the Vatican, I will go to Rome for a dinner with Messrs. Prodi and Zapatero, in order to advance this Union for the Mediterranean, which you know I attach great importance to.

Q - Two questions to lighten the mood.

R - Coming from Libération, that can only be a pleasant surprise!

Q - Regarding the Lisbon Treaty, you are aware that a little over 80 French parliamentarians are once again calling for a referendum, as well as a number of civil society actors. I would like to know if they have any chance, any chance at all, of having their request satisfied.

R - None. I will explain myself; it is very simple. If we want to break Europe, we must do it. We already had Mr. Fabius who practiced this with a certain talent. I was completely honest during the electoral campaign. I have many flaws, but not hypocrisy. I was very frank; I said it, including during the electoral campaign, including during the debate I had with Madame Royal. I said that if I were elected, if the French trusted me, I would try at all costs to put France back at the center of Europe because, frankly, our influence had not grown following what had happened. You are specialists; you follow these issues; you can testify to that. Moreover, not only did I carry the idea of the simplified treaty, and Mr. Quatremer certainly remembers, it was in July in Brussels, I was the first to carry this idea, and secondly, it was unblocked because France said that we would do a parliamentary ratification.

A country like Spain, which I want to pay tribute to, ratified Mr. Giscard d'Estaing's constitution by referendum, said yes, and did not oppose the simplified treaty. Everyone must make an effort; that is why I put, on behalf of France, the idea on the table that the ratification would be parliamentary. Remember the 18 - the meeting that took place in Madrid - remember for the first time a meeting that happened without France, completely isolated. I made that commitment.

I add, for those who want to reflect, that if France were to organize a referendum, the minute France does it, Great Britain does it, and what are the chances that Great Britain would have a yes? And at that moment, what would have been the point of making the simplified treaty, which must be ratified unanimously to come into force?

So I received a mandate from the French people, and I was not hypocritical; I was frank. I add that I deeply believe in referendums, but then a referendum on the simplified treaty, frankly, is a bad idea by construction. We held a referendum on Maastricht; there was a single idea, the single currency, the abandonment of the franc; that was no small matter. The referendum was perfectly justified. Today, holding a referendum on the simplified treaty, of which almost all the measures inside have been the subject of a consensus, including from those who are calling for a referendum today, no, I will not do it.

There you go, I take my responsibilities as President of the Republic. You know, when you are president, you have to take responsibilities, and at some point, you have to lead the country that has trusted you. You have to be accountable and lead the country. I am deeply European, and I will not be the one who isolates France from Europe. And I will not be the one who carries a message of division in Europe. I have my convictions; I have said what I think about a strong euro, about relocations, about trade negotiations, about reciprocity, about Turkey, and about a number of subjects, but I say it as I think, I am deeply European. We need Europe; we also need Great Britain in Europe, and now that we have put Europe back on track, we should not play around with breaking what we have had such a hard time mending.

Q - Regarding Belgium, where we are, you know that for six months, this country has not been able to form a government. You do not fear, not because there is a disagreement, you know, between the Flemish and the Francophones, you do not fear that a bad precedent could be set with Kosovo, that it could give ideas?

R - You are looking for that one far away...

Q - I knew I would lighten the mood...

R - No, but listen, frankly, first of all, it is a serious matter, and France's position is to wish that Belgium, which is a great neighboring and friendly country, overcomes its difficulties. That is our position. And we do not want to interfere in any way. Finally, the problem between the Flemish and Walloons, from what I understand, has nothing to do with the question of Kosovo, but with a differentiated feeling about the progress of one and the other, about the financial situation of one and the other.

This crisis is entering its seventh month. Mr. Verhofstadt, who has been Prime Minister for eight and a half years, has been given a new mission by the King, which has benefited him since he has instantly become the most popular politician in the three regions, since we must add to the Flemish and Walloons, Brussels, which is a region in its own right. France wishes him the best success, and France never rejoices in the difficulties of its friends.

Q - I wanted to know if you had the opportunity to discuss with Mr. Prodi the Air France-Alitalia issue?

R - No, but we will surely have the opportunity to talk about it, not here, but during my visit to Rome. I am very happy to visit the Pope, first at the Vatican, and I will also extend an invitation to him to come to France, especially to Paris and not just to Lourdes - but if he wants to go to Lourdes, of course! Secondly, regarding relations with Italy, we had a very good Franco-Italian summit with Mr. Prodi in Nice; it was really very pleasant. Substantively, it was useful, and in form, it was extremely pleasant. We will discuss that issue, of course, but we did not talk about it today. You know, we had quite a busy agenda; it was not very simple. Perhaps one last question?

Q - Mr. President, aside from Libya, was there any discussion about the Arab world, particularly Lebanon, and the assassination that cost Mr. François El Hajj his life?

R - Listen, it was not discussed, but regarding this assassination, we adopted without discussion, as it was so consensual, the conclusions of the Summit. You know, there is a text with 86 points on the agenda, and we only talk about the points when they provoke division among us. There was consensus on Lebanon. We condemn with the greatest force this cowardly assassination aimed at destabilizing, once again, this unfortunate Lebanon. Monday is really the last chance, and France calls on all internal and external parties to ensure that we can have a president of unity and consensus. I truly say this, France has committed itself like no other country to help Lebanon out of its difficulties. Bernard Kouchner has been there an incalculable number of times, but really, Monday is the last chance, and those who would take the responsibility of killing that chance must know that they will definitively cut themselves off from a number of countries, at the forefront of which is France. I believe we must talk, but there comes a time when facts and decisions speak for you, and that moment is really approaching.

Q - I wanted to know about Iran; is the French proposal for strengthened sanctions still on the table?

R - The text on Iran is a consensus text that we accepted and which did not encounter difficulties, and therefore, we did not have an in-depth debate on the subject, except for the text of the conclusions, which is at your disposal.

I thank you very much for this press conference and I wish you a Merry Christmas if I do not see you again before then.