Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on the pact for the Euro, nuclear security, and the military intervention in Libya, in Brussels on March 25, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

25 March 2011 · Press conference on the pact for the Euro, nuclear security and the military intervention in Libya · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy held a press conference in Brussels on March 25, 2011, following a European Council summit addressing the Euro pact, Libya, and nuclear safety.
Main themes
Euro pact and European economic governance, military intervention in Libya, nuclear security and stress tests after Fukushima, Portugal's political and economic crisis, Arab Spring and Syria, expansion of Euro pact membership, European solidarity and crisis mechanisms
Duration
~30 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,642
83rd percentile
Sentences
204
89th percentile
Readability
61
88th percentile
Grade
9.0
11th percentile
Syntax
2.81
23rd percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
8th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

204 sentences in 41 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - Ladies and gentlemen, I propose to hold a rather short press conference, given the late hour of this evening's press conference. If you agree, I will take three or four questions and refrain from making an opening statement to immediately turn to your questions.

Finally, if it troubles you, I am willing to make one.

QUESTION - Mr. President, when speaking about Syria, you said that it is unacceptable for a democratic country like France to accept the use of real bullets against demonstrators. I want to know if these statements are also valid for NATO member countries like Albania. You know, on January 21, four demonstrators were killed, and I would like to know if those lives are worth less than hundreds, as in Syria, for example. Does France maintain the same position regarding Albania or not?

THE PRESIDENT - If the question is: "Does a human life, whether in Albania or Syria, have less value?" the answer is quite simple: no, it has the same value. And the principles apply equally. But last night, we were focusing on what you yourself called the Arab Spring and the Arab revolutions, and it is in that context that I was led to answer questions and clarify my thoughts, as Minister of State Alain JUPPE had done on the subject. But it goes without saying that if it were happening or had happened in the same way in Albania, my remarks would be exactly of the same nature.

QUESTION - Mr. President, what is your analysis and what has been the Council's analysis of the economic and political situation in Portugal?

THE PRESIDENT - I would first like to say that the Council thanked Prime Minister SOCRATES for the courage he has shown and the various measures he has proposed to the Portuguese, which have so far been accepted by all political forces. Well, there is a political crisis, but according to what both Mr. SOCRATES and Mr. BARROSO told us, all Portuguese political forces adhere to the objectives set by Europe, even if the political struggle, which has its rules, led to the rejection of the plan presented by Mr. SOCRATES. So, presumably, according to what is being said, there will be elections within two months, but our confidence in Portugal is complete, and we are reassured to know that all Portuguese forces are well aware of the need for effort to improve the competitiveness of the Portuguese economy and to reduce Portugal's deficit.

So, that has not changed our analysis of the situation. Furthermore, all the mechanisms are now completely in place, having been the subject of a full agreement: there is an economic government, a pact for the Euro. Six more countries have decided, have announced their adherence to this pact for the Euro: Denmark, Poland, Lithuania, Latvia, Bulgaria, and Romania. So really, economically speaking, Europe has done what needed to be done, and it is a great satisfaction. It is equipped with an economic government, a permanent fund, procedures, and a pact. This is what France has been asking for a long time.

QUESTION - You have already partly answered the question, Mr. President, but are you completely satisfied? Can you say today that Europe truly has a real economic government, or are there still progress to be made, uncertainties to be resolved, and if so, which ones?

THE PRESIDENT - Uncertainties to be resolved, I do not think so. If I recall the situation a year ago, the progress is gigantic. Gigantic. And indeed, we have been able to overcome all the crises. The government is in place - the seventeen heads of state and government - a pact to further integrate our economic policies is in place, a fund to support countries attacked by speculation is in place, solidarity has been established, everyone has agreed. Frankly today, I do not see what more needs to be done. Well, that does not mean that in a few months we will not have other alternatives or other possibilities to strengthen our economic framework. But frankly, compared to what France was asking for a year ago, and what we have achieved today, I believe I can say that it is a complete success.

QUESTION - Mr. President, after the terrible nuclear disaster in Japan, you discussed this issue during this European Council with stress tests looming. So, what types of stress tests and with what consequences for the plants that fail the stress tests?

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, we discussed it in great depth. Moreover, it is a matter of responsibility. What happened in Japan concerns the whole world. I remind you that what happened in Japan has nothing to do with what happened in Chernobyl. The earthquake: 9 on the Richter scale, Japan had never experienced such a significant one. The plant, built in 1970, withstood perfectly - the nuclear process functioned perfectly. What did not work? It was that the anti-tsunami defenses, which were six meters high, were overwhelmed by a wave that was twelve meters high, which disrupted the electrical system, which stopped the cooling pumps. And so, the main takeaway from what happened in Japan is the fight against tsunamis. Obviously, this poses a different issue for regions where there are nuclear plants and where there is no sea, or regions that have never experienced a tsunami.

Nevertheless, we have decided to subject all our plants to a stress test, a safety test in light of what happened in Japan. What we agreed on is that the energy mix, the energy package is the competence of the member states. Some have chosen nuclear, others have not. And for those who have chosen nuclear, it will be as follows: the Commission will establish the framework for controls, the standards for controls. Independent nuclear authorities will carry out these controls, will make these controls public, and the Commission and the European nuclear regulators will assess the seriousness or shortcomings of these controls. If a plant - I am speaking for France - does not pass these tests, it will be closed. It is clear. All tests will be conducted in France, all test results will be published, and if the tests are not conclusive, we will immediately draw the consequences. There is only one consequence, which is closure.

QUESTION - A question about Libya, Mr. President. You explained yesterday, we talked about NATO, command structures, but beyond this military intervention and the command structure issues you discussed yesterday, do you feel today that Europe is completely united on the way forward - the diplomatic and political follow-up in Libya - and what are the next concrete steps?

THE PRESIDENT - The next step is the London summit on Tuesday. Presumably, before the London summit, Mr. CAMERON and I will have the opportunity to propose a common path to pace the steps that will continue. But the next step is Tuesday, the London summit, with all the member countries of the coalition, who will discuss the political steering and the next steps.

QUESTION - ...for a proposal for peace in Libya? Is that it?

THE PRESIDENT - No, I do not have a plan, but let’s say there will certainly be a Franco-British initiative to clearly show that the solution cannot be solely military. It will necessarily be political and diplomatic. Even if the military, due to the inability to hear reasonable things from Mr. KADHAFI, had become unavoidable.

QUESTION - A more general question: when France rejoined NATO's integrated military structure, it was with the hope that it would allow for the development of European defense and military capabilities of the European Union. However, in the Libyan affair, what do we see? It is that almost all of our partners have only one desire: to get under NATO's umbrella as quickly as possible, even when we must intervene in our "backyard," as our British friends say. Do you not feel that you have traded the prey for the shadow, since, in this case, European defense seems, more than ever, distant?

THE PRESIDENT - Frankly, sir, I do not know what I have given up. I remind you that France was a member of 18 NATO committees, 18! It has rejoined 1, the 19th, and it is still not in the 20th. If that is the prey... it was weak!

Secondly, decisions in NATO, as you know, are made by consensus, and still, in this painful Libyan affair, it is an initiative of Great Britain and France, two major European countries, and the planes that are flying are English and French, regardless of the others, but they are also Danish. But you yourself, who are a very good connoisseur of Europe, know well that European defense is primarily based on a couple, which is the Franco-British couple, since these are the two most powerful armies in Europe. With whom would you like us to build European defense in a major way? Germany has made a choice, and that choice today is that of European unity. But you know well that Germany has a history, and that the German sensitivity does not push them to intervene spontaneously in foreign territories since the end of World War II. We must respect the history of countries. Europe consists of different histories. And I am very happy that with Germany we have found the paths of compromise and that today, Europe is completely united on the Libyan issue, completely. There is Franco-British leadership on European defense, everyone knows it well, everyone is aware of it. And the fact that we have rejoined the 19th NATO committee does not change this reality, which existed before and will exist after. What would it have changed whether we rejoined or not?

Moreover, it is quite normal, as long as there must be a framework nation that organizes the management of all these planes. As long as our American friends - and I believe they are right, by the way - do not want to be that framework nation, - and it might not be very wise for them to be, given the Middle Eastern sensitivity - someone has to do it. Do you think it should be France? There is a structure in NATO, there is a machinery, we use it through the command in Naples, it poses no problem. And you know that well. It works, and the best proof is that two countries, non-NATO members, like Qatar and the Emirates, will participate in the flights, the actions in Libya without it posing the slightest difficulty. And the political steering is followed by coordination. What is the problem? What should have been done differently? I do not mind debating this issue, but what was the other solution? It was very simple: there were two solutions, there were not three: either the United States is the framework nation and coordinates, and I would have been told: "Ah, you are trailing behind the United States," if it is not the United States that does it - and I think it is wise that they do not do it for reasons of sensitivity of Arab public opinion - why should I oppose the machinery of NATO? If the political control is that of the coalition, should France be the framework nation? Are we not engaged enough? That would mean that I should have invented a system that competes with the machinery of NATO? Who could have thought that it makes sense?

QUESTION - There is still a European staff, isn't there?

THE PRESIDENT - But there is a headquarters where we are all, in Naples. Naples, Italy, European country. Naples, close to the Mediterranean, why not use it? Frankly, I do not see what political problem this poses as long as there is political coordination of the coalition. I do not see it. It is not NATO forces that will protect the population in Libya, it is the coalition. And the coalition to coordinate... there were yesterday, 60 aircraft in the Libyan airspace during the day, there must be a machinery that coordinates the slots, the missions. Who will do it? We are not going to go each in our own corner. It is NATO command in Naples. But the political coordination, as it will be expressed on Tuesday in London, is the 11 countries of the coalition. Really, this does not pose a political problem for us. And I do not see, is there a European command... so what do we do with our American friends and our Canadian friends? What do we do with Qatar and the Emiratis then? Do we integrate them into the European command? That is interesting. I would be more than happy to look at that, but finally, to set up a system that competes with the one that already exists, that does not make sense. Frankly, I am not at all bothered to answer your questions on this, but you can see that there is a practical problem that is not at all a political problem. The political problem would have been much more significant if we had lost the support of the Arab League, Qatar, and the Emiratis. There, there would have been a political problem. There would also have been a political problem if Europe had not agreed as it did last night on the opportunity to implement the United Nations resolution, that is a real political problem. Using NATO machinery is not a political problem, frankly.

QUESTION - Mr. President, do you not feel that the Libyan crisis is somewhat overshadowing what is happening in Côte d'Ivoire? We are currently talking about a million refugees. And what can France do in this situation that seems to be worsening day by day?

THE PRESIDENT - France has submitted a resolution to the Security Council and you are absolutely right, it would be shocking to overshadow the drama experienced by the population of Côte d'Ivoire, particularly in Abidjan. France has submitted a resolution to the Security Council. Such is international news, we cannot manage one crisis at a time, that would be too simple. It is a scandal that heavy weapons are being fired in Abidjan, I said it last night, I confirm it. There are United Nations forces, it must be declared that Abidjan must be prohibited from heavy weapons at a minimum. We are talking about helicopters that could be prepared to fire on the population, we are talking about mortars. This must be very clearly declared as illegal by the international community. There are United Nations forces, let them do their job.

QUESTION - Mr. President, one point about nuclear energy and one point about Portugal. Regarding nuclear energy, the Fessenheim plant is considered the most dangerous in France because it is one of the oldest and is on a seismic fault, and many people are calling for its closure even without waiting for the tests. Is it indeed feasible to close the Fessenheim plant right now? And the second point, do you think that Portugal can live without the help of Europe, without asking for help from Europe until the next elections which will be held, as you said, in two months?

THE PRESIDENT - I am not in charge of Portugal, it is up to the Portuguese authorities to decide what they will do, whether they will call for help or not...

QUESTION - Is that your analysis, sir?

THE PRESIDENT - But I do not have one. I forbid myself from having one, it is already complicated enough as it is, it is up to the Portuguese to decide what they have to do based on their knowledge of the situation in their country, it is not up to me. It is already complex enough, we already have enough work. If it is to pass judgment from the outside, to tell them: "you should or you should not." I told you what I thought, Mr. SOCRATES did all his work. And he did it in a courageous and remarkable way, that is what I think. I say it.

And as for Fessenheim, there are many people, you know, who lose their cool in crises. I think we need to keep our cool in crises. Fessenheim will be subjected to controls, tests will be published. But if you tell me that it must be closed before the studies are done, then why do the studies? We say: we need to do studies, controls, and publish the results. And you tell me: "do not do the studies, do not wait for the controls, do not wait for the results and close." That is not very logical. It is better to do the studies, publish the results, and make decisions, rather than making decisions before even doing the studies. Frankly, if we had elements that allow us to say that Fessenheim is dangerous, it should be closed immediately. But then what do you want me to think? I have none of these elements on my desk today, so I have no reason to make that decision. On the other hand, it would be shocking not to conduct a test on Fessenheim. We will conduct a test on Fessenheim and based on the results of the test, we will decide whether to close it or not. It is quite astonishing to decide to conduct controls and close before the controls. That would suggest that we had tests beforehand. I am not sure that would reassure anyone.

QUESTION - Hello Mr. President. Regarding Libya, we were told at NATO this morning that on Sunday evening, the missions of the international coalition will be absorbed by NATO discipline, that the international coalition will disappear. I would like to have your confirmation on this project. On the political aspect, you talk about the political coordination to be done in London. Is your intention, the intention of this contact group, to give directives to NATO or is it rather to discuss the future of Libya? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - Thank you for asking me the question, it allows me to correct an error because I should have mentioned the Spanish planes that are flying in the air. I apologize for that because it is perfectly accurate, we can even say that yesterday the French planes took over from the Spanish planes. And we really need Spain. No, no, that is not how it will happen. Once again, decisions are made by political coordination, the decisions to strike are made by national authorities, and NATO allocates the slots and missions, discusses the objectives proposed to it by political coordination. There is no difficulty on that side. But I fear I am repeating myself by recalling exactly the same things. There is a political coordination that is taken at the highest level by the member countries of the coalition and that is how it has worked. The other question? But NATO cannot absorb the Emiratis and Qatar. It is not possible, that would be totally counterproductive, you can see that. Moreover, it would be a great service to Mr. KADHAFI to explain that there is only NATO and that there is no longer a coalition. Finally, we see what it is, so we will of course keep the political steering and our ability to trigger coordinated operational actions by NATO. There will be no change.

Perhaps one last question?

QUESTION - Regarding political steering, do you believe that the High Representative has fully fulfilled her role in the Libyan crisis? Has she, in a way, if we can use another term, passed the stress test of this crisis? Because we have had the impression that it was the member states that were seeking an agreement, that were trying to propel a political solution, rather than the High Representative.

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, I think that Herman VAN ROMPUY played a great role and we worked hand in hand. But the High Representative has played her role, but it is not the High Representative who has operational control over the armed forces, it is the member states. Since there is no European army, it is not the High Representative who can manage the intervention of the armies, the European forces of the coalition. She has played her role, she has been present in Paris, she will be present in London, she is taking care of all the humanitarian aspect. Mr. VAN ROMPUY is taking care of all the political aspect to ensure unity and a number of member states - notably the United Kingdom and France - have expressed their leadership to make their armed forces available for this international objective. This is Europe, it is not always simple. But ultimately, it does not work so badly. We decided something on Saturday, there was a deliberation of the United Nations on Thursday, we decide something on Saturday, it comes into effect on Saturday evening. It has not worked so badly, frankly.

Last question.

QUESTION - Mr. President, what is your opinion on the measures of the BERLUSCONI government against Lactalis regarding the Parmalat affair?

THE PRESIDENT - I would like to have a conviction but listen, well done. A zero for Italy, that is undeniable, you have stumped me, I have no position because I know very little and I would be afraid to say something foolish. If you would like to come back in the second week, I will have worked.

No, I expected everything except that. This is not at all a sign of disinterest but I have not worked. Do you want to call me? Call my wife in Italian because I...

Well, I think it is time for me to shorten this press conference, it is becoming very dangerous.

Have a good weekend.

Thank you.