Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on the possibility of a carbon tax at the European level, the CAP, and the crisis within the Eurozone, in Brussels on March 26, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

26 March 2010 · Press conference in Brussels · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference in Brussels on March 26, 2010, following an EU Council meeting covering climate policy, the CAP, and the Eurozone crisis.
Main themes
European carbon border adjustment mechanism, Common Agricultural Policy, Eurozone crisis, climate ambitions and environmental protection, European industrial competitiveness, carbon tax at EU borders, agricultural exports and market speculation, European Commission proposals, relocation of industry, G20 agenda
Duration
~16 min
55th percentile
Words
1,933
55th percentile
Sentences
105
65th percentile
Readability
60
88th percentile
Grade
9.3
13th percentile
Syntax
2.81
24th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

105 sentences in 29 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, I have had many opportunities to speak with you, and I do not want to wear out your patience with introductory remarks that I do not see what they could bring. If there are any questions, I will be happy to answer them.

Q - This morning, the continuation of the Copenhagen negotiations was on the agenda. Did you take the opportunity to push for the carbon tax at the European borders, and do you think you will succeed in obtaining the agreement of your European partners before the end of your term?

R - Oh really? You lack ambition then. Of course, we talked about it this morning; France's position has been this: Europe must maintain its ambitions in terms of protecting the planet and defending the environment, but it must do so without naivety, and this is the subject of a very frank debate. I think everyone today considers that the question of a border adjustment mechanism for Europe is an essential and unavoidable topic. The President of the Commission has indicated that he will put a proposal on the table next June. He also said, without taking a position on the substance of the proposal, that it was an unavoidable subject as well. No country has opposed this possibility. I am trying to be precise; this means that in June, there will be a proposal from the Commission on the subject - I am not saying that we have won - but that is already something. I remind you that when we talked about it a few months ago, the very word was controversial. So, there will be a proposal on the table.

I want to clarify that France is not asking for a tax on all countries and all products, but I gave my colleagues the example of steel. Can we impose environmental constraints on European steel mills and at the same time import, for example from China, steel that is produced without respecting environmental constraints? What do we do?

At that point, it would mean that we accept the relocation of all steel production, for example to China - I could take China, India, other examples - so in terms of pollution, whether we pollute in Europe or Asia, the result for the balance of the planet is the same, but in terms of unemployment, it would be Europe that would be penalized.

I believe that all of this is starting to sink in, and my ambition is that as early as June, a serious discussion begins on the Commission's proposal. In any case, I am certain that there will be an overwhelming majority calling for an end to Europe's naivety. I truly believe that the question of a border adjustment mechanism for Europe is making significant progress. That is what has been decided.

So, it is June. You cannot ask for more. I also readily acknowledge that this is a technically complex subject and that the Commission needs the month of June to submit a text; that is perfectly normal. But the political victory represented by the Commission's examination of a mechanism, the possibility of a border adjustment mechanism, is something crucial.

So, we will return in June for the discussion to determine which one and under what conditions, but there you go. So, it is progressing well.

Q - You said on Wednesday that you were ready to go to crisis to defend the Common Agricultural Policy. Did you say this today, or yesterday to your partners in the European Union, and what was their reaction?

R - Listen, the texts that were circulating showed that in the 20-20 agenda, we weren't even talking about the word agriculture. I remind you that for five decades, the Commission has been implementing the first common European policy, which is the CAP. I remind you that Europe is the second largest exporter in the world in terms of agriculture. I pointed out that in terms of agricultural products, Europe exports thirty billion euros more than in aeronautics, and that I could not conceive of having a 20-20 development agenda that ignores agriculture, which is an element of European economic power.

I said this to President Barroso, with whom I spoke on the phone on Tuesday, and I was pleased to see that the conclusions of the Council included agriculture as a central element of Europe's economic future. I welcome that. This did not even raise any comments. One country was surprised by this, and I clearly indicated that we would not accept any amendments on the subject, so we are fully satisfied.

So, let me be clear, we are not in the 2013 agenda with the modification of the Common Agricultural Policy. Furthermore, there are also other problems, such as speculation that has taken hold of agricultural markets, which are completely erratic with price drops that do not benefit consumers and that kill the producer. This is something extravagant. This is a subject we will have the opportunity to discuss again, including at the G20. But, I remind you that we export 80 billion euros of agricultural products and import 110 billion euros. We have a deficit of 30 billion euros on the European agricultural balance. I have been supported by many other countries that indicated that agriculture is an element of Europe's economic power and that, naturally, this is part of our future strategy.

But we will have the opportunity to discuss this again.

Q - Mr. President, when we all heard Angela Merkel call for the exclusion of eurozone countries that do not respect deficits in the future, and given the harshness of the debate sparked by the Greek crisis in Germany, I would like to ask you: first, what lesson do you draw from this on the European level, and second, in France, can the example of Greece's difficulties help you explain to the French the importance of successfully reforming pensions and reducing deficits? Thank you.

R - Fortunately, all of this is ending well since these statements are not reflected in the decisions we have made. We agreed on the working group, chaired by Herman Van Rompuy, to study without prejudice the most appropriate sanctions for a country that does not respect the rules. Finally, things have calmed down a lot, and it is important that it is so. Everyone has also been able to measure the importance of the Franco-German axis, Germany's responsibility for European construction, and France's responsibility.

I believe that both the Chancellor and I are well aware that we have responsibilities in our own countries, but we also have European responsibilities. And that is what matters.

Do Greece's difficulties help explain the necessity of pension reform? No, frankly, I do not think so. Even if Greece had not experienced difficulties, we still need to explain to the French that the question of financing our pensions is clearly posed. There are 10% of French pensions that are not funded; this has nothing to do with Greece's difficulties. It has everything to do with the fact that we are living longer and that consequently, there will need to be people working to pay the pensions of retirees who are more numerous.

I therefore do not intend to rely on this Greek example when there are so many elements that should lead us, in a non-partisan context, to confront this issue. Everyone knows that it is a pressing matter. We will have to face it. There is a timeline; I will have the opportunity to talk about it again.

Q - I return to the carbon tax and on French territory this time. Chantal Jouanno expressed her despair on Tuesday and indicated yesterday that it is Medef that "sabotaged" the carbon tax. Do you approve or disapprove of her remarks?

R - I did not appreciate her remarks. I add that ministers should not be desperate; they need to do their job. There is a strategy, and it has been set by François Fillon and myself. Everyone should stick to it.

Q - Mr. President, you are going to the United States next Monday and Tuesday. Next Tuesday, you will meet President Obama. Do you think you will obtain fair and just conditions in the awarding of the tanker aircraft contract, and are EADS and Airbus still in the running?

R - I have said what I think about the decision that was made. This is a subject that will be the subject of an in-depth discussion with President Obama, but you will allow me, Madam, to reserve these comments for the moment when I have the pleasure of meeting you in the United States. - Because if you want, the files are moving at such a speed, the appointments with you too... - I try to focus each time on the problems we have to solve. I already have the trip to the United States well in mind. I have also thanked President Obama for his invitation, but we will have the opportunity to talk about the content when I am there.

Q - The German Chancellor wants to strengthen the Stability Pact, and for this reason, she wishes to change or modify the Lisbon Treaty again. Does such a reform seem politically feasible and desirable to you?

R - We have talked about this at length with the Chancellor. We are on the same position. We believe that the health system is not suitable to put it bluntly. I said it yesterday; forgive me for repeating myself, but a country that is in excessive deficit is fined. This will not improve the situation. We are completely ready to reflect on this. It is by design that we did not expressly retain the words "treaty modification" since, as you know, to modify a treaty, unanimity is required. Not everyone agrees. We have formed the working group; we do not exclude any possibility, and with the Chancellor, Germany and France will make proposals on the subject. This is a real problem. We will make these proposals. We have until the end of the year to think about it and work on it. There you go, that is the compromise that has been found.

Q - Mr. President, among the objectives for 2020, there is one on reducing poverty. We know that France is committed to this, but it is far from unanimous. How will you defend this objective?

R - Here too, together with Chancellor Angela Merkel, we will make a proposal for an amendment on these issues, a Franco-German proposal in the coming weeks. We will take initiatives on this.

I believe that in summary, what we can say is that the understanding between France and Germany is very useful for Europe. This understanding is very solid. This means that we discuss, that we make compromises, but I think it is very useful. I think it has been a relief for all of Europe to see that we were capable, in service of the European ideal, of reaching an agreement, and I also think that we have the same vision from this crisis - I am talking about the difficulties of Greece - we can try to improve European procedures and have a different reading of the European strategy. It is very important that Germany and France have this same reading. We are doing this in full agreement with President Van Rompuy, President Zapatero, and we will have the opportunity to enrich this debate with proposals that we are already working on.

Thank you all.

Safe travels for those returning.