Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, in favor of the regulation of capitalism and a new global governance, in New York on March 29, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

29 March 2010 · Lecture at Columbia University · Columbia University, New York, United States

Context
Sarkozy addressed Columbia University in New York on March 29, 2010, advocating for regulated capitalism and a new multilateral global governance model.
Main themes
Regulation of capitalism, global governance, transatlantic partnership, multipolar world order, economic crisis and reform, financial market rules, Europe-US relations, leadership and responsibility, reinventing capitalism, NATO and French foreign policy
Duration
~44 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,235
92nd percentile
Sentences
331
96th percentile
Readability
62
90th percentile
Grade
8.5
7th percentile
Syntax
2.75
17th percentile
Vocabulary
1.95
6th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 36%35%
  • Economic 33%32%
  • Social 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Institutional 7%7%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

331 sentences in 53 paragraphs

Mr. President of Columbia University,

Ladies and Gentlemen Professors,

Dear friends,

I will try to live up to your prestigious University. And the first rule is not to read a speech. Because speeches kill creativity. If one comes to read a speech, one might as well send the speech and save the trip.

I want to speak to you frankly, as a friend, which does not mean that we will agree on everything. Through you, I want to speak to the great people of the United States of America so that you understand that Europe and the United States must work together. In Europe, we are your friends. In Europe, we admire you. You do not need to worry about that. But in Europe, we want to be heard, listened to, and to think together in the United States.

You belong to a country that is the world's leading power, by its strength, by its currency, by its economy, by its army. You must think carefully about that. What does it mean to be the world's leading power? The leading power must provide leadership, but the leading power must also consider, because it is powerful, that it must share, that it must listen, that it must debate, that it must exchange.

We are in the 21st century. There is not a single country in the world that, in the 21st century, can lead the world alone. In the 20th century, it was possible, after the Second World War, to imagine a single power. In the 21st century, we must all understand that to lead the world, a world that has become multipolar, we must accept that strength involves dialogue, because being strong means being capable of dialogue. In the history of the world, only the weak refuse dialogue. This is a significant change in the 21st century from this perspective. A single nation, no matter how strong, cannot impose its views on the entire world.

A second thing I am certain of is that in the 21st century, we must invent new answers. And these new answers are for us, the statesmen of today, and you, the leaders of tomorrow, to imagine. From this point of view, the crisis we experienced eighteen months ago offers us extraordinary opportunities. Many things need to be reinvented.

And the third idea I would like to share with you is that if Europe and the United States do not invent this new model, no one will do it for us. It is important to understand this. Europe alone cannot impose its ideas, and the United States alone cannot impose its ideas. And if we do not bring new ideas, no one will do it for us.

This is the reason for my visit and for all the political choices I have made since I was elected President of the French Republic. I wanted France to fully return to NATO. Why did I want that? Because I wanted a frank dialogue, without ulterior motives, with the United States. When France was not fully in NATO, when France made a remark, there was suspicion of an incomplete understanding with the United States. Now we have returned to NATO, we are your allies. You have nothing to fear from this perspective. The only thing I asked your President, President Obama, is that we could have a free dialogue. I will give examples.

When the economic crisis occurred and the American administration let Lehman Brothers fall, you must understand that it was a disaster in the United States, but it was a disaster worldwide. Saying this is not blaming anyone; it is making a reality understood: the world is completely interdependent. What you succeed in here will be a success for the whole world. What you fail at here will be a failure for the whole world. This creates a responsibility for us, together.

From that moment, what can we do together? We admire the American economic model, we admire your companies, we admire your universities. I also wanted a reform of French universities modeled after those you know here, with lower tuition fees.

But at the same time, global economic regulation can no longer remain what it is. We can no longer accept a capitalist system where there are no rules, no organization, no regulation. I know that when a French person comes here, he is always suspected. Is he not a bit protectionist? Is he not a bit socialist? Is he liberal enough?

I will tell you one thing: by asking for the regulation of capitalism, I am laying the foundations that will save capitalism. Market economy and capitalism without rules will lead to the death of capitalism. Because one day, people will no longer accept that what happened eighteen months ago happens again. I will explain myself here as well. That Americans make a lot of money, that Europeans make a lot of money, what could be more natural? But we cannot win every time. We cannot have bonuses one day and say "no penalties" if things go wrong. When the crisis occurred, I asked my own collaborators: "Can we not impose a penalty on all those who brought us to where we are?" They told me: "It is impossible to find the responsible parties." I said: "Okay, then produce the list of those who last year, when things were going well, had bonuses and impose a penalty on them."

This is a system we no longer want. A system where when things go well, we find the responsible parties, and when things do not go well, we do not know where the responsibilities lie. Do I make myself understood? Market economy is about responsibility. There cannot be responsible parties when we earn more, and no responsible parties when we earn less.

I want to pay tribute to the courage of President Obama, because at the London Summit, we wanted to put an end to tax havens. You must, you the young people, understand what is the point of putting rules in our society if it is enough to have a subsidiary in a tax haven to exempt oneself from all rules? Who can understand that? There are hundreds of thousands, perhaps millions of Americans who have lost their homes, who have lost their jobs due to the crisis. They were not responsible, and they find themselves with nothing. Is that normal?

In Europe, in all economies, unemployment is rising. The French Minister of Economy is here. What do you think we can say to an unemployed person who is not responsible and who sees that the global economy almost collapsed because a few hundred irresponsible people did whatever they wanted with the stock market, with derivatives, with other people's money? Do you think we can defend capitalism, liberalism, and the market economy with so much injustice? I believe we cannot defend it, because it is indefensible.

Tomorrow I will see President Obama. What do I want to discuss with him? What will we talk about? One thing: how can we work together to ensure that what we experienced eighteen months ago does not happen again? That is our only responsibility.

Eighteen months ago, when it happened, everything was on the verge of being swept away. Everything. And when I see that today the same people are ready to repeat the same mistakes, I do not want to be complicit in that. Is that understood? I do not want to, and I will not be, because in the next crisis, we states are so indebted that we will not be able to build the dikes to prevent catastrophe.

So, what I would like you to understand is that Europe and the United States can invent the rules that will stabilize the global economy. It is not a matter of moving from a lack of rules to an excess of rules; it is about regulating the global market economy. There you go, and from this point of view, if Europe can rely on the United States, then we will win. If the United States and Europe confront each other, then we will lose together. It is Europe and the United States that can invent the new global economy.

The second example I would like to take: raw materials, the price of oil. Is it normal that in less than two years, the price of Brent oil goes from 30 dollars a barrel to 150 dollars? Too expensive one day, not enough another day. Do we not have an interest in establishing, we the economies that consume fossil energy, and the oil-producing countries, the basis for a regulation that would allow for a price of oil, for example, at 80 dollars? Is that not in our interest? When the price of oil was too high, we went to see the producing countries to tell them: "It is too expensive." But when oil prices fell, we rubbed our hands together. We were irresponsible. I speak of oil; I could speak of gas, I could speak of all raw materials. We must regulate the global economy. It is our responsibility to carry that.

The third element, there is in the room Mr. Stiglitz, Nobel Prize in Economics, a man for whom I have great admiration. I entrusted him, along with Jean-Paul Fitoussi, with a commission to invent, and this concerns the students you are, new criteria for measuring growth. If we continue to use criteria that measure growth solely in quantitative terms, then we will not achieve sustainable growth. We must measure the evolution of our economy differently, as we must do in the 21st century, which is not the same century as the 19th century. Well-being, education, the value of our environment are elements we must integrate into the measurement of our economy. If we measure our economy solely with quantitative criteria, then we will be unable to provide the world with a qualitative economy. Here too, we need to show imagination, to understand.

Finally, the last example, the market economy. It is a production economy that creates value. Over the past twenty years, the global economy has become a speculative economy. We have committed to a production economy, not speculation. That a creator, a Bill Gates, makes a lot of money because he has created new concepts, made new discoveries, and provided jobs for tens of thousands of people around the world, is normal. That a lot of money is made from speculation, to know whether the New York Stock Exchange will exceed 6,000 points or 7,000 points, is not the system in which I want to live. And by preventing capitalism and the market economy from becoming caricatures, we will save the market economy and capitalism. And for that, we need the great American people to understand that the absence of rules kills freedom, that there is no freedom without a minimum of rules, that a state of law means something, that not everything is permitted. If the great people of the United States of America understand this message and engage in the struggle to invent new norms, then the world will be equipped with balanced norms.

The second significant area of action between you and us is the new global governance. I was in Copenhagen for the environmental summit and I will see the Secretary-General of the United Nations this afternoon. Copenhagen was the failure of a method in a caricatural way. How does it work? We have a United Nations Security Council, with a number of permanent members who have the right of veto. But this Council was defined in the aftermath of the Second World War. Do you know, young students of Columbia, that there is not a single African country that is a permanent member of the Security Council? One billion inhabitants! Do you know that there is not a single Arab country, hundreds of millions of inhabitants, that is a permanent member of the Security Council? Do you know that India, one billion inhabitants, in thirty years the most populous country in the world, is not a permanent member of the Security Council? That Japan, the second largest economy in the world, is not a permanent member of the Security Council? Why? Because sixty years ago, they lost the war. Is that reasonable? Do you know that there is not a single Latin American country that is a permanent member of the Security Council?

How do you expect us to resolve the major crises, the great wars, the major conflicts within the framework of the UN if we think we can do it without Africa, without three-quarters of Asia, without Latin America, without a single Arab country? Is that reasonable? Does it make sense? Is it even imaginable? Who can believe that?

So I am told: "Yes, but there is the United Nations General Assembly, they are all members there." There are 192 countries in the world, the G192. So we move from a system in the Security Council where we want to resolve issues without two-thirds of humanity to a system where the last one who is not happy can block the agreement of all the others. Well, the United States of America and Europe, we must call for the reform of global governance to make room for the continents of tomorrow who have the right for us to ask for their opinions. How do you expect Brazil or India or Africa to take part in the responsibility for the great conflicts of the world if we do not ask for their opinion? Would you like it if someone told you: "To pay, you are welcome, to give your opinion, we do not want you"? Who can function with that? Who can understand that? And so, with Gordon BROWN, we have submitted the text of a provisional reform of global governance and the United Nations Security Council.

As the French President, I was a member of the G8. And I say: "The G8, it is hard to imagine that it represents something, since China is not there, India is not there, Mexico is not there, South Africa is not there." I am told: "But it doesn't matter, we invite them at the end of the G8 Summit for the end-of-Summit lunch." We invited the five representatives of two and a half billion inhabitants of the world to travel around the world to have lunch with us. And we did not see that one day, it is the G5 that will refuse to invite the G8 and not the G8 that will refuse to invite the G5.

My dear friends, I do not say this because I want to be seen well in Africa, Asia, or Latin America. I say this because if we do not change global governance, we have no chance of providing an answer to the conflicts of tomorrow.

For Iran, where we must show the greatest firmness, which must not acquire nuclear weapons, we need the support of China and Russia to sanction them. So, everyone must be on board the global government to make the right decisions and not make mistakes; the alliance between Europe and the United States is fundamental.

Finally, we are here in New York. New York, this city that was martyred in September 2001, no one has forgotten it. In the fight against terrorism, we need everyone. You need us and we need you. Waking up this morning, I had the news that our Russian friends, for they are our friends, had an attack. Apparently, two women detonated explosives in the Moscow metro, resulting in more than thirty deaths. Do you believe there is a fundamental difference between the madmen who blow up innocent victims in the Moscow metro and the crazies who flew planes into the Twin Towers of New York? Do you think we can be picky by classifying the most barbaric terrorists? When New York was attacked, it was all the democracies of the world that were attacked. And when Moscow is attacked, it is all of us who are attacked. In the face of terrorism, we cannot divide ourselves. When the American President is in Afghanistan..., you know, in France, it is not easy to explain that French soldiers are dying in Afghanistan. But I tell you, we will stand by you in Afghanistan because the fight against terrorists is a fight that concerns us all. Not just Americans, all of us. Because I do not want the Taliban to martyr Afghanistan, and because I do not want tomorrow for Pakistan, which has nuclear weapons, to fall into the hands of terrorists. Here too, we need to work together.

And finally, if you allow me, this will be my conclusion before answering your questions. I sometimes try to imagine if I were a young American what I would think. You have a country that is a continent from east to west, you have an exceptional success in many areas, you have your problems to solve. But please, you must never curl up on yourselves. The world needs an open America, a generous America, an America that shows the way, an America that listens to the suffering and expectations of others. You are very loved in the world, but a lot is expected of you. And sometimes, when you are loved less, it is because so much was expected of you that there was a feeling of disappointment.

When you chose President OBAMA, the whole world was proud of you. The whole world hoped in you. And I must say, by the way, that the debate between President OBAMA and John McCAIN honored American democracy. And so often when I talk with President OBAMA - and I enjoy talking and exchanging with him - he sometimes tells me, "But you know, on certain subjects like the environment or regulation, I am a bit ahead of what deep America thinks." But I tell you one thing, do not be behind your President. On regulation, on environmental defense, on listening to others. Because we cannot afford, in the world of the 21st century, to have the world's leading power that is not open to the world. The world does not stop at the west coast, and does not stop at the east coast. There you go, accept this message from a French President who is your friend, who admires you, and who loves the United States of America.

Thank you.

If you have a few minutes, I will be happy to answer your questions. Be as free in your questions as I have been in my remarks.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, thank you for being here. You said: "We admire your university," and so my question is about the campus plan, more specifically the Saclay campus. In your opinion, what characteristics of American universities must we absolutely find in a new cluster like the Saclay plateau?

THE PRESIDENT - What are we going to take from American universities? The first thing, the most important, is the autonomy you have. For me, the university is a place of freedom. What makes the richness of the university is the freedom that exists there. Freedom to choose your professors, can you imagine, here at Columbia you even have French professors, that shows how free you are. My dream is that there are American professors who can come to France without it being a drama, without talking about nationalism or protectionism.

The research programs at Columbia, I looked at, it is your board of directors, it is your scientists who define them. It is not the State that defines them. What has been the problem in France? From this point of view, it is a misunderstanding of the word equality. Equality is not uniformity. Equality is to each according to their merit. What I like about the American model is precisely the reward for work, merit, effort, initiative, and boldness. That is the first remark.

The second remark is that there are no campuses that can develop virtually. And I am a bit tired of localities like this only existing in the United States. I have in my delegation great French scientists, great leaders of prestigious schools, and I think we cannot work on cramped campuses, with libraries that are closed on Sundays, in facilities where the nobility is inversely proportional to their state of disrepair. I wanted to open the windows of the French university, to provide them with many resources, to put them a bit in competition, and to give more to those who do more.

I also wish that American students could come to our universities and that many French students come to yours. What is the use of the 21st-century world, which is a world where one can travel freely, if you cannot come study with us and if we have difficulties sending students to you? That is what we are changing in France. So change is difficult, it clashes with habits, it worries. But the duty of a statesman is to pursue change when it is necessary. Ultimately, I think when a politician is elected, he has only completed one-tenth of the journey. Many politicians who preceded me thought that being elected was to complete the entire journey. I think being elected is the very beginning of the journey. That political leaders, that statesmen like us, should be like business leaders, judged by the results of what we do. And that is exactly the reform of universities that we have initiated in France.

QUESTION - France has the best medical care in the world. What is your opinion on the American bill aimed at reforming the healthcare system in the United States?

THE PRESIDENT - You want to draw me into the American fight. As if I didn't have enough of the French fight. But I do not want to flee. First, I want to congratulate President OBAMA for having succeeded in this reform. Whatever one thinks here of this reform, he wanted the reform, he carried it out. He should be congratulated for that. But if you want me to be really sincere, from Europe sometimes, when we see the American debates on healthcare reform, we have a hard time believing it. The idea that it can be such a violent debate to ensure that the poorest among you are not left on the street, alone without a penny in the face of illness! Excuse me, we have solved that problem for fifty years. It poses us difficulties, it costs a lot, because healthcare is expensive. But we cannot let people die like that. The State cannot disregard the situation of those who cannot afford to go to the hospital. Do not involve me too much, but frankly, if you come to France, if something happens to you on the sidewalk, we will not ask for your credit card before accepting you in the hospital. It is that in the United States, everyone should be able to say the same thing that if they have nothing left, if they are destitute, they will not be left on the street. Yes, I admire President OBAMA for having done what he has done. I told you, and at the same time, I have a lot of respect for Mr. McCAIN, whose behavior I found very honorable. And more generally, everything that happens in the United States, you know, we follow it with great interest in France. It is good that it is so, because it is important that we all, in our countries, are not exclusively self-centered, that we look at what is happening with others. I often tell my fellow citizens, "We do not need to reinvent everything." I would like to draw inspiration from what others have done better than us. I love my country. I am proud of it. I represent it. But when we are wrong, when we have taken a wrong path, I do not hesitate to say, come on, let us draw inspiration from what others are doing to apply it to ourselves. That is also the advantage of globalization. Welcome to the club of states that do not abandon sick people.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, how do you see the future role of Europe, following the economic difficulties of some member states of the European Union?

THE PRESIDENT -- It has been quite a debate. Notably, it has kept me busy with Mrs. MERKEL, who is a person with whom..., I know that here you do not always understand how Europe works and that sometimes you get annoyed with this Europe. But, do you realize that Europe is 27 countries, 27 countries that for centuries have waged war, have hated each other, between the Germans, the French, three wars between the English and the French, between the Spaniards and the French, between the Italians and the French, it has always worked well. It is 27 countries, we decided that we would make peace and walk together. You know, it is very complicated to make this work, but it works. And within the 27, we are 16 countries that have decided, hold on, that we would have the same currency. And when Greece was attacked, I pointed out to my colleagues that it was not Greece that was being attacked, it was the euro, our currency. So, we had to be supportive. I made a lot of use of what happened with Lehman Brothers here. If we had let Greece fall, then the crisis would have restarted.

With Lehman Brothers, I understand the reasoning that Mr. PAULSON had at the time. Why give taxpayer money to support a bank that was poorly managed? We let them fall. When you let Lehman Brothers fall, people around the world thought that a bank could fail, and panic seized the entire world. That is why we decided to support Greece. And since we made that decision, dear Christine LAGARDE, the spreads, interest rates, and speculation have calmed down. Why? Because speculators, they come looking for us. And as long as we do not put up a wall, they test. The minute we say: "Very well, you are looking for us, we are ready to step in to resist." At that moment, they no longer come looking for us. This is called solidarity. This solidarity is essential.

The last time I spoke with President OBAMA on the phone last week, since we have a conference with Mr. BROWN, Ms. MERKEL, and Mr. OBAMA about every month, President OBAMA said to me: "And Greece, what are you going to do?" Because he knew well that stability in the United States depended on what we, in the eurozone, would be able to do or not do. This is the world of today. That is why when the decision was made to let Lehman Brothers fall, we would have liked to have been asked for our opinion at the time.

This is solidarity and interdependence.

Perhaps one last question.

QUESTION -- You said that in the 21st century, there must be much broader economic cooperation among all the countries of the world, not just the countries that are part of the Security Council, but you mentioned Japan, Latin America, people who really do not have a voice. And you made the argument that in the case of Japan, they lost the war. Latin America is not listened to because in the past it was colonies. So, what framework do you envision to include these people, so that they have a voice?

THE PRESIDENT -- For me, the system is very simple. Each part of the world should have two to three representatives within the Security Council as permanent members. Each part of the world should be able to freely determine how it chooses its two or three representatives. Again, the world does not need uniformity. I take the example of Latin America. Should it be Brazil, Argentina? Should they elect their representative as a permanent member? It is up to them to decide. We, the international community, should say: "We want one or two representatives from Latin America as permanent members of the Security Council," and it is up to them to choose. It can be through election, it can be on a rotating basis, it can be the largest like Brazil. Who can imagine managing the affairs of the world without this giant that is Brazil?

For African countries, there are about fifty African countries. Should their representative be South Africa, which alone represents 40% of the African economy, or for example, this giant country like Nigeria, which has more than 100 million inhabitants? It is up to them to determine, it is not up to us. What matters is that among the five or six major regions of the world, there are permanent members of the Security Council from all regions of the world. My ambition is to advance this issue very strongly at the time when France will hold the presidency of the G20 and the G8.

I add one last point that will be a subject of reflection for scholars. I also wish for the definition of a new international monetary order. We can no longer continue like this. In 1945, you had the Marshall Plan, you had Bretton Woods a few kilometers from New York. And for a year, you reflect on what the monetary order will be until the early 1970s when we ended the convertibility outside of dollars.

But my dear American friends, the dollar is no longer the only currency in the world. The dollar is a very important currency, but it is not the only currency in the world. The yuan, the currency of the Chinese, matters. A part of your savings is in the hands of the Chinese; we must invent a new international monetary order where we jointly decide on strategies regarding interest rates, where we regulate fluctuations between our currencies. Do you know that between the euro and the dollar, at the time we created the euro ten years ago, one dollar was worth one euro? The euro rose to 1.50 against the dollar. How do you expect our companies to survive? 50% less competitiveness, how do you expect them to endure? And in fifteen days, three weeks, the euro went from 1.50 to 1.33 today. Who can understand that? Who can accept it? Can we still be on Bretton Woods, which was 60 years ago, or should we not think together about a new international monetary order? Here is another exciting subject that I will carry as President of the G20. Here is a subject we will discuss with President OBAMA. You see global governance, a new global monetary order, a new system to regulate the price of raw materials, a new way to frame freedom, liberalism, market economy. This is what is exciting for you. It is the world in which you will live. You will not build this world by reading books with theories from the 19th century but by inventing and thinking about the ideas we need for the 21st century. And the excellent news about all this is that today, my dear friends, ladies and gentlemen, everything is to be reinvented. Let there be imagination and cooperation between Europe and the United States of America.

Thank you for your attention.