Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the European agreement providing for a support mechanism for the Eurozone countries in the event of an economic and budgetary crisis, in Brussels on March 25, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

25 March 2010 · European Council extraordinary meeting of the Eurogroup · Brussels

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference in Brussels on March 25, 2010, to announce a eurozone crisis support agreement reached at an extraordinary Eurogroup summit.
Main themes
Eurozone crisis support mechanism, bilateral loans coordination, Franco-German cooperation, European economic governance, Greek debt crisis, IMF financing, budgetary surveillance, sanctions reform, market speculation, eurozone solidarity
Duration
~23 min
71st percentile
Words
2,700
71st percentile
Sentences
162
83rd percentile
Readability
59
84th percentile
Grade
9.0
11th percentile
Syntax
2.82
25th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

162 sentences in 47 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

The agreement we have reached in Europe on a crisis support mechanism is a success for the eurozone states. It was made possible by the mobilization of France and Germany, which reached an agreement this afternoon that we presented to President Van Rompuy and other eurozone states, who accepted it during an extraordinary meeting of the Eurogroup at the level of heads of state and government.

This agreement includes four essential points:

First, a mechanism for bilateral loans from the eurozone states, coordinated by the European Commission, which can be implemented as a last resort. If market financing is insufficient, the eurozone member states will decide to activate this mechanism within the framework of the Eurogroup.

Secondly, these loans will be supplemented by financing from the International Monetary Fund. However, we agree that European financing should be the majority.

Thirdly, the eurozone states agree to strengthen the coordination of their economic policies. The European Council must become a true economic government of Europe. This idea, long advocated by France, is now becoming a reality.

Finally, we have decided to ask President Van Rompuy to establish a working group with the member states, the Commission, and the ECB, to present before the end of the year the necessary measures to strengthen the instruments for the prevention and monitoring of economic and budgetary risks.

So, if you allow me, I would like to make three brief remarks after presenting the main outlines of this agreement.

The first remark is that the agreement we have reached is clearly preventive in nature. The objective is, of course, not to have to use it. We expect it to lead to a normalization of the market situation regarding Greece.

Secondly, this agreement, while being preventive, is nonetheless perfectly operational. It is precise, and it can be activated if needed as a last resort. It provides assurance for Greece that it will be able to implement the courageous reforms it has undertaken without being penalized by speculation and the irrational behavior of the markets.

Thirdly, the eurozone is taking its destiny into its own hands. We have agreed to establish a mechanism to manage crises in the eurozone. This is a major step that also requires us to rethink our economic and budgetary surveillance mechanisms, so that such crises do not happen again.

I remain, of course, attentive to your questions.

Q - Germany wanted, in exchange for possible assistance, to deploy a range of potential sanctions against countries that have misbehaved. What is the status of that?

A second question if you allow me. A stronger European economic government, concretely, what does that mean?

R - The question of sanctions is clearly raised within the framework of the working group we are considering and working on. Here, I am giving a personal opinion. I do not prejudge the conclusions of the working group, but to give an illustration: today, the sanction that is foreseen is a financial sanction. That is to say, if a state does not comply with the rules, if it has too much debt, too much deficit, the sanction that applies is a financial sanction. Curious reaction! We find that they are in deficit, so we will impose an even greater deficit on them. It is clear that this type of arsenal is not suited to crisis situations. Therefore, we need to think about other elements, and the formulation we have retained leaves all possibilities open.

I can perhaps provide one. I am not saying that this is what we will decide. We could imagine a suspension of voting rights, things of that nature. These are potential elements that will be discussed among us. There you go, you see, it is to give an example. I am not saying that there is a majority in favor of this, but it is an example. Today, clearly, the arsenal is not adapted.

Q - Two questions if you allow me, Mr. President. First question: the problem of Greece today is not one of a possible default; that is out of the question; it is its financing problem. That is to say, it will have to refinance between 20 and 25 billion euros between April and May, and therefore at rates that are currently prohibitive. Will your mechanism play a role in this case, to prevent Greece from being strangled by the markets?

Second question...

R - ...Wait, I will take the first one, which is already quite good. Naturally, no one imagines a situation of bankruptcy for Greece, which makes no sense. But I would not just say, I would go a little further than financing... Well, there is Greece and there are the financial institutions of Greece, for example its banks, which is another subject, all resting on trust. The expression we have retained is "ultima ratio." To clarify, if financial markets are "insufficient" - I believe that is it... between the translations in English and French... - clearly, this applies in both quantity and quality. That is to say, the notion of insufficiency is both if loans are not fully subscribed, and at the same time if we are faced with remuneration rates that are so extravagant that it would amount to the same thing. I will not elaborate further, but it is to say the impact of the agreement that has been reached and the response.

Excuse me, I only answered one question earlier, I believe.

Q - It is about the intervention of the IMF. The International Monetary Fund intervenes precisely when there is a monetary problem. In this case, the problem of Greece, according to the latest news, is rather a budgetary problem. So, on what basis, under what mechanism, could the IMF intervene to help a country that has no monetary problem, but only a budgetary problem?

R - On the basis that we had to make a compromise to find a good operational agreement. Europe is about compromise. There were three main positions, three families of opposition. There were those who believed that a problem of imbalance in the eurozone should only be the concern of the eurozone states. There were those who believed that since the IMF was there, we might as well use the IMF. We had used it, I myself first, when I was president - rotating presidency of the Council - for Hungary, with the IMF, which did not need to solicit European states. Then there were others who did not make it an ideological problem and who considered that, after all, we could bring everyone together as long as symbolically the eurozone took on the bulk of the problem and asked the IMF for a complement. There you go.

Really, to answer you on this, I am giving you the most sincere response that allowed us to find an agreement. I would still like to remind you, Mr. Quatremer, that even this afternoon we had to work hard to have a good agreement.

You know very well that this is the story of European construction for 50 years. Who can say that they come without making any compromises? It is indeed the compromise in the service of peace, prosperity, and European construction. We had to find a middle ground. The president of the ECB had a position that was quite firm, the President of the Commission too, other states... France tried to bring together to reconcile viewpoints, yes, clearly. I think that thus, we really have an operational position. What matters? It is the decision, you have understood well, the principle decision of the eurozone member states, in principle, for bilateral loans in favor of Greece in case of need, "ultima ratio," insufficient financial markets, with the complement of the expertise of the IMF and the means of the IMF, in a minority proportion. There you go, that is the answer.

So, when we met on February 11, you told me: "it is not precise enough. Is it operational?" It is perfectly operational, but you will understand that I do not say, on the level of interest rates, the distribution between the different countries of the loans, because naturally saying that would be to say things that would be immediately used by speculation, and that is not the goal. The goal is to say "Greece is not alone; there is solidarity in the eurozone." There is now a process of massive intervention, there is a procedure for implementation. If the ECB, or the Commission, or a member state believes it has problems, it brings it to us, we meet, and we decide.

Q - Can you be a little more precise, though, on, I would say, the distribution of the two types of loans, that is to say, the bilateral loans within the eurozone and the financing from the IMF? You specified that the former would be the majority, but on the other hand, we have Germany saying that IMF financing will be "substantial." Is that contradictory? Can you be a little more precise?

R - We have not settled on the euro precisely, of course, but beyond a third, it is substantial for the IMF, and it leaves a majority share to the eurozone states. So will it be two-thirds to one-third? That is rather what we have discussed among ourselves, at least within the framework of the Franco-German agreement. But it can be adjusted; it is not a drama, but that is roughly the idea.

Q - What was the reaction of the fourteen other countries of the Eurogroup when you presented the Franco-German agreement?

R - It was not me who presented it, nor Ms. Merkel. We had a meeting with Herman Van Rompuy, the Greek Prime Minister, the rotating presidency, and I believe that everyone was extremely relieved that an agreement had been negotiated. You know, imagine! Well, let’s take the reverse path. Imagine there had been no agreement between France and Germany. Imagine the consequences. So, I think, as always in Europe, countries are relieved when Germany and France show a complete willingness to collaborate and work together. There you go.

Q - Mr. President, the proposed economic government, is it for the 27 countries or just for the eurozone? How will it work? What is the role of this economic government?

R - It is a decision of the eurozone, so of the 16, since we must also be precise. The decision we made is a decision of the eurozone that engages the 16. What I think will happen is that the proposal from the working group will be included in the text of the European Council tomorrow. Since the working group can concern the 27. Regarding the economic government, clearly, it is the will of the 16 in the eurozone to strengthen their coordination, their economic policy. It is a debate that will thrive at 27.

France's position is as follows: the Commission implements the economic policy determined by the European Council. It is clear. It is the European Council that ensures coordination and sets the orientations of economic policy according to the evolution of the European or global economic situation. The Commission implements. Clearly, the economic government of Europe is the European Council; at least that is the position I have defended, and which happens to be taken up by the eurozone. You know perfectly well that this position is still a subject of debate among the 27, since our British friends are not quite on this line. Well, but it is progressing. A few months ago, it was even difficult to pronounce the expression "economic government" within the eurozone; now it is taken up by the eurozone.

Q - Mr. President, how would you describe Van Rompuy's intervention in this agreement? It seems that everything happened between France and Germany.

R - No, I would not say that. President Van Rompuy, I had lunch with him yesterday in Paris. We worked hand in hand. He spoke at length with Ms. Merkel on the phone on Tuesday; he spoke with her on Sunday. I myself had an hour-long conversation on Sunday with Ms. Merkel. I must say that I have a total community of views with the stable presidency, totally. It happens that at one point, Ms. Merkel preferred that the meeting take place in a France-Germany format. I was ready for this format or another, but there you go, I am also very sensitive to the fact that the Chancellor clearly wanted to prioritize the Franco-German axis. I will not hold that against her.

But everything was done in perfect coordination with President Van Rompuy's presidency.

Well, then, Europe is complicated; we are 27, 16 in the euro, there are institutions, we have to get everyone on the same page. But let’s say it is still easier when Germany and France reach an agreement; you know that very well, you who have been following European news for so long.

Q - Mr. President, is there a limit beyond which support for Greece will not go?

R - There is no limit in quantity; the only limit is what Mr. Papandreou, to whom I want to pay tribute, has announced, which are extremely courageous measures. Conditionality is the plan of the Greek government; it is the only limit. From the moment the recovery measures undertaken by the Greek government are deemed solid and credible by the ECB, by the Commission, and by the Eurozone countries, we decide to commit to supporting Greece.

Q - But Greece needs to refinance about 40 billion euros...

R - I will not enter into that debate; there is a process, it is operational, we have done it because Greece has a credible plan, so now the markets know that it is the entire Eurozone and, in part, the IMF that are gathered behind Greece. It is clear.

Q - Who will monitor the Greek situation from now on? I mean, is it still the Commission? Also, is there a meeting scheduled with Greece, in case the cost of Greece's borrowing does not decrease, when will we talk to Greece again? For the moment, Greece has not yet requested financial assistance.

R - No, of course not, but the monitoring is done by the Commission, that is to say, the monitoring of the commitments made by Greece is done by the Commission. That is its job. The word "surveillance," by the way, is in the treaties and expressly regarding these procedures. There are no ambiguities. The monitoring of monetary developments is the ECB's responsibility, and if there were to be a problem, these two institutions or Greece can at any time convene the Eurogroup, which now has a procedure, a plan, and the capacity to respond. There you go.

Q - The participation of the IMF in the European aid plan that you decided on this evening, is it perhaps a gateway for this organization and also for its president, Dominique Strauss-Kahn, into European politics and perhaps particularly into French politics, on the French political scene?

R - I saw you coming from afar, but this is becoming too complicated for me to answer. No, frankly, we are dealing with serious matters; we have tried to do something serious in the face of an extremely important crisis. I think these are elements that have not been taken into account, I assure you. Frankly, you see what is happening, no, not that.

Q - Regarding governance, you had, at the previous summit, with Mrs. Merkel, already developed a number of hypotheses for economic governance. How will these hypotheses be articulated, if you can tell us a little more, by the way, what you decided with Mrs. Merkel this evening, with what you envision for the future, and then give us some examples? What will it be in terms of fiscal policy, harmonization, for example, things like that?

R - I will simply say one thing; it is quite possible that Germany and France will make a joint proposal to the working group chaired by Mr. Herman Van Rompuy. We proposed the group; it will meet, it will get to work, and we will make joint proposals.

Thank you.