Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on the regulation of financial markets and on economic recovery, in Brussels on March 20, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

20 March 2009 · Council meeting (European Council) · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference at the EU Council in Brussels on March 20, 2009, outlining key decisions on financial regulation and G20 preparation.
Main themes
Financial market regulation, G20 London Summit preparation, tax havens, Larosière report and financial supervision, Eastern European financial support, IMF resource increase, accounting rule reform, hedge funds and remuneration, European unity, balance of payments assistance
Duration
~60 min
96th percentile
Words
7,141
96th percentile
Sentences
373
97th percentile
Readability
66
95th percentile
Grade
8.6
8th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
10th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

373 sentences in 76 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, good morning,

France has tried, throughout this Council, to bring some concrete actions, decisions, to engage politically and not fall back into old habits. What have we achieved?

First, the text to prepare for the G20. I believe it is a good text. The whole of Europe, we can say today, is determined to achieve ambitious results at the London Summit. This is truly a unanimous position. It was not a foregone conclusion. I want to commend the great open-mindedness of Gordon Brown, with whom I had a working lunch yesterday. But things are really moving forward. Everyone agrees on tax havens and an attached list, hedge funds, remuneration, the elimination of off-balance-sheet items for banks, and the need for regulation. Really, I refer you to the text and I would of course be happy to answer questions, but Europeans will present a united front on ambitious objectives and the extremely important change in accounting rules.

I can clearly see the progress made since the Washington summit where even the term "tax haven" was not mentioned as we spoke of "non-cooperative centers." Now, not only is the term "tax haven" being used, but all of Europe agrees on an attached list.

And on the change in the accounting system, everyone is in agreement. Really, it is progressing. We must remain vigilant, I am convinced of that, but finally, it is progressing.

Secondly, unanimous support for the recommendations of the Larosière report, this is not new because it was looking quite good. The novelty is that we are committing to turning them into legislative provisions by the end of the year. This is absolutely crucial since these two things are new rules. My conviction is that Europe does not suffer from a lack of rules, but from a lack of sanctions. Once we have the rules, we still need to apply them. And the intelligence of the Larosière proposal is to bring together national supervisors, put them in a committee, and transform that committee into an authority to get things done, without caricaturing. From this point of view, I believe I can say that it is historic, because for years in Europe, we have not been able to move away from soft supervision. So, I am really satisfied with that.

Two other points. The effort for our colleagues and friends in the East. We have doubled the payment facility provided for by the famous Article 119, moving from 25 to 50 billion. At France's proposal, we requested that the figure be included in the deliberation. This is very important. Why is it important? Because this way we move away from the somewhat ritualistic side of Council decisions, which are grand principles and then everyone goes home and interprets the grand principles as they wish. Here, we are moving from 25 to 50. And I had regretted during an informal summit one Sunday in Brussels that we were not more proactive and did not send a stronger message to the market about the need to help - and I know they do not like us talking about them but still, it concerns them - the countries of Eastern and Central Europe.

Furthermore, we, France, supported Gordon Brown's proposal to double the resources of the IMF. Finally, sorry, that is the G20 objective - we pushed for Europe to announce right now that it will take its share. We agreed on 75 billion euros. Euros, which is not quite the same thing, since if we assume that the dollar should be at 1.36, we agreed on euros. After that, there was a debate on whether it is less or more. This is concrete. That is to say, after what the Japanese have done, it allows Gordon Brown, the president of the G20, to prepare the negotiation for the London summit with Europe's contribution to doubling the resources of the IMF, we are ready to put in 75 billion euros, which is absolutely considerable.

So, I believe these are the four important decisions from my point of view. Agreement on the mandate for the G20 - Larosière - by the end of the year, legislative decisions, so Europeans must know that there will be a system of supervision of financial institutions and banks in Europe before the end of the year - a quantified commitment to support the balance of payments of Central and Eastern European countries - and a quantified commitment to participate in the increase of IMF resources which is facing increasingly numerous needs.

I prefer to answer your questions rather than bore you with a long presentation. There have been many other things, there are 22 pages of a communiqué with things of unequal importance in it. I am of course ready to respond to that but I imagine that is not what you expect from me as a priority.

Q - Mr. President, regarding tax havens and non-cooperative countries, there has been some confusion since last night, particularly regarding the position of the European Union as such. Is there, at this time, unanimity among the 27 to say that the countries that made concessions last week - Luxembourg, Austria, and Switzerland in particular - should not be on the list of non-cooperative countries in any way? If that is the case, how do you assess the chances as a bloc of the European Union to convince other G20 members, particularly the United States, not to place these countries on what we will call the blacklist?

R - First of all, this is a very serious matter. What is a tax haven? It is not a place that has very low taxes or virtually no taxes. A tax haven is a place that refuses to say where the money comes from and what it does with it. We agree, a tax haven is the refusal to cooperate with other international authorities by masking, hiding the origin of funds and the use of funds.

So there are rules, the OECD rules, and following the pressure we have exerted, a number of us, notably Ms. Merkel and France, countries that until now had never complied with OECD criteria, have decided that from now on they would ask to respect these criteria. This includes Austria and Luxembourg as a priority. From that moment on, we asserted that: one, we could not tolerate, with the severity of the crisis, the persistence of tax havens; two, that if Europe wanted to be heard, it had to set an example. It goes without saying that if we do not set an example, if we do not clean up in Europe, how do you expect others to want to do it in their own countries? We have witnessed this movement where Luxembourg and Austria - and Switzerland, which is not part of the European Union, but still - from that moment on, our position is to say: the countries that have made this move and are committed to respecting OECD criteria will be removed from the list of tax havens. And so, if that is indeed the will and decision of Luxembourg, Austria, and Switzerland, they should not be on a list because those who do not want to comply will be on the list. First element.

But it goes further. I do not forget that I am Co-Prince of Andorra and Andorra has announced that they will respect the OECD convention. I think this is historic, it has never happened, ever. They therefore have no reason to be on the list.

And by the way, today, the problems we have are less with our American friends than with others. I think of Hong Kong, I think of Singapore, I think of Macau, I think of a number of places. We are not there yet, but the position of Europe on this is very clear and very determined. Frankly, the Washington summit is really something Mr. Barroso and I wanted. We were not so far from where we are today.

So I told Mr. Juncker, first of all, his statement is a very important, very interesting, and very welcome statement that earned him some problems in his country, two months before the legislative elections, and I do not see why we should complicate the task of those of our colleagues who are trying to find a solution while they are doing what we expected them to do for years. That would not be fair play and so I? I think they should not be placed on the list. It goes without saying that if these were just statements that were not followed by action, there would be a follow-up on the political commitments on our part.

In any case, yesterday, at dinner, I spoke in this sense and I believe I was unanimously supported since we did not talk about it again this morning and Mr. Juncker did not oppose it, in the communiqué. Since in the communiqué, the annex on the mandate for the G20, there is the establishment of a list of tax havens. Mr. Juncker did not oppose it so it is perfectly clear. As for the position of the American administration, I will know a bit more since I will have a discussion with Mr. Obama next Monday.

Q - Did Gordon Brown make commitments regarding the British Crown territories, particularly the Cayman Islands, which seem to escape the wrath of everyone, quite curiously? Second question, the Federal Reserve, the Bank of England, the Bank of Japan are multiplying exceptional measures, particularly by buying treasury bonds, buying bonds. Are you in favor of such action by the European Central Bank which has not completely ruled it out but seems to be little inclined towards it? Do you think the time has come to take unconventional measures?

R - The time has even passed, because we have already taken unconventional measures. Frankly, they are not to come, they have already been taken. So, regarding the Cayman Islands, it goes without saying that what applies to us applies to our friends in the United Kingdom. There can be no exceptions. And so, Cayman Islands, Shetland, I am not going to make the whole list, I do not want to give the impression of knowing too well, because we must be careful, especially coming from our friends at Libération, not from you. That was not where we localized mine but well...

It goes without saying that the credibility of what we will do depends on our ability to refuse any exception. So this will translate into a point, the same for banks, our banks must not work with places that will be on the list of tax havens. It is clear, it is simple, and it is straightforward. That is the objective.

We saw Mr. Trichet at length yesterday, it was quite interesting and I see him very regularly to tell the truth, he is someone I respect, we have not always agreed but he is a man who has been responsive. Honesty compels me to say that, compared to the starting position of the ECB, and where we are today, a significant journey has been made, sir, and we are following this quite closely.

By the way, that is what I told Mr. Trichet. I told him, really, I find that you have introduced a lot of flexibility into the position of the ECB, because it is not simply reduced to the question of rates, nor the amount of rates. And so, basically, what you are saying is: "should we expand the quality and number of papers that the central bank should accept in exchange for credits?" That comes down to that, your question. I have always been in favor of the expansion. It goes without saying that Mr. Trichet, in his responsibility, says: "be careful, if the central bank does the work of commercial banks, where do we stop the intervention of the Central Bank?" We are in an exceptional situation, where we need to revive credit. It is picking up a little, not enough. I am in favor of being able to take more papers to take the phrasing, dear Christine Lagarde, from the specialists.

So it would be a positive evolution for Mr. Trichet to follow his path in the schedule that is his. He is not the only one in charge, as you know, since I noted that in the communiqués, decisions had been made, they said, by majority. This proves that there is debate. There you go, but in any case, everything that goes in this direction, I am for.

Q - Two questions please. At the moment you are speaking, the Slovenian Prime Minister, not far from here, is about to make a statement regarding what Mr. Chatel said this morning about Renault with a repatriation of part of Renault's production.

R - That is not quite accurate but I will respond to it.

Q - So, clarifications and then I would also like to know what your reaction is regarding the mobilization in France yesterday.

R - So regarding Renault, the French automotive plan, then European since ultimately, now, with the pressure we have exerted, again, you know France was largely at the origin, we were the first to make an automotive plan, imitated by all the others. In the automotive plan, there are many measures but there are two common points: first, a strengthening of credits in the form of loan guarantees to all car manufacturers. All states that have car manufacturers have done this. And, secondly, the scrappage bonuses.

There are other measures, but to be clear, what has triggered a recovery in the European car market - not enough, but a noticeable recovery - What is happening in the face of this recovery? There are more cars, particularly the Renault Clio and Twingo, that are selling. This is very good news! It is really the scrappage bonuses. It is true that the scrappage bonuses favor Renault more because European consumers are turning more towards small cars than large ones. It is no secret that our manufacturers are more specialized in small vehicles than in large ones.

It turns out that the factory in Slovenia is operating at full capacity, so this is not about cutting jobs in Slovenia. I want to make that clear. We are very happy to have a Renault facility in Slovenia. I met with the Slovenian Prime Minister, and I told him: he will not lose a job. But as demand is such, there is an increase in production, and Renault has chosen to create 400 jobs in France. Honestly, I am the President of the French Republic, and I am pleased about that.

This does not take a job from our Slovenian friends and it gives back to Flins. This is exactly what I wanted. In Flins, we will now produce the Clio, prioritizing the workers from Sandouville whom I went to see, who themselves account for 40% of the production. This is the demonstration I have always wanted to make: that we can defend industrial jobs in France without eliminating a job for our Slovenian friends. It is already complicated enough as it is.

I add that if the French government had not done what it did to the tune of 6 billion euros for the automotive industry, Renault and PSA factories all over Europe would be closed. We agree: these are 400 jobs that are not taken from anywhere, that are created in France, and we need them, in Flins and for the workers of Sandouville, this is very good news because thanks to the push that France made to obtain a European automotive plan, there is more consumption. There are more unpleasant news to comment on!

Regarding the protests yesterday, of course, I was in Brussels, I could not react last night from Brussels, as I knew I had the press conference. It is not my style to hide. Naturally, I must comment on these events. The protests yesterday showed what? The importance of the concern of a number of employees in the face of the global crisis. They showed that this concern has not diminished in a month and a half, since the last protest. Who in their right mind could have thought that the concern had reasons to diminish between the protest in January and that in March? Who? No one.

My role now is not to comment one day on concerns, another on protests, and a third on polls. My role is to make decisions to achieve results. So what are we going to do now in our situation? First, and this is extremely important, we must implement without delay, it is a requirement, the measures that have been decided. I say this to the French people. Within a timeframe that will extend over the next ten days, until July, measures of great importance will come into effect, concretely.

Starting next month, 6 million French people will pay less tax or will be exempt from the second and third installments. For the French who are on a monthly payment plan, it is from May that they will no longer pay. For the French who are among the other 4 million, the installment for May-June will be eliminated. So these tax measures for 6 million families - lower middle class - will come into effect between May for those on monthly payments and June and September for those on the second and third installments.

In April, there are 4 million modest workers who will receive a bonus of 200 euros. In April, next month. 4 million.

In June, there are 3 million families who will receive an exceptional bonus of 150 euros.

In mid-June, there are 1.5 million beneficiaries who will receive service vouchers for family jobs, worth 200 euros each.

In April, there are 400,000 retirees who will see the minimum pension increase by nearly 7%.

And in July, we will implement the RSA, which will translate into an average of 110 euros more per month for 1.5 million precarious workers plus those on social minimums. This is what was decided during the social conference, if my memory serves me right, on February 18, and will therefore come into effect, in terms of purchasing power as they say, between the next 10 days and July.

I will propose to the unions to assess the impact of all these measures before the summer to see what we need to correct, what we need to complete, and what we need to add. But you will agree with me that it would be imprudent and difficult to say that I need to modify something that has not yet come into effect, or that I need to evaluate measures that have not come into effect. They need to come into effect, between the moment we decide them and the moment we vote on them, when the files are set up, that is what we have. So before the summer, we will evaluate, we will complete, we will modify, we will add if necessary.

Third remark: there are a number of areas where it is already undeniable that we need to do more.

The first is not the simplest, it is the distressing question of industrial restructuring, which is an extraordinarily difficult subject. No one should be left by the wayside. I will hold meetings starting this weekend. I want us to be able to do more in terms of restructuring. We see roughly what needs to be done for companies that only have cash flow problems but have a future; we need to help them get through this tough time: partial unemployment, now compensated at 75%, training during the time of partial activity - we see roughly what needs to be done. On the other hand, we need to be much more proactive and, I believe, put more resources into companies that have no future to re-industrialize the area where these companies are at risk of closing. We cannot leave a single one of our compatriots by the wayside. Should this translate into investment, training, or support? We will work on that, but I want us to push the re-industrialization aspect.

The second element where we need to do more is the question of young people who are undoubtedly the first victims of the crisis. On the issue of young people, we need to make decisions fairly quickly. There is the aid contract aspect, there is the training aspect, but we cannot leave them with the doors of companies closing. That is not possible.

The third element, I think we still have potential for action on infrastructure. I believe that all the decisions we have made regarding TGVs, the Seine-Nord canal, the new EPR, and the construction of a number of roads, it takes time to move, but it creates jobs. I myself went to Doubs on the way to an important TGV line. But I think there is still room for activity and employment for the company and therefore growth in a number of infrastructures. I will make particularly strong proposals on public transport, especially in the Paris region, around the end of April, beginning of May.

The fourth element, I want to reiterate to be well understood by everyone, that on the issue of value sharing and profit sharing in companies that are making profits, I want results. And I will not let up the pressure. There are companies in a very difficult situation, they need help, and we cannot ask them to distribute what they do not earn. There are companies that are making profits, good for them! But the question of value sharing and profit sharing, I have seen that some leaders have had a bit of trouble getting on board. I repeat: if there are no concrete actions taken quickly, the government will take its responsibilities. This is an essential matter. No one can understand that when one makes money, one refuses to address the issue of value sharing and profit sharing.

Just as the question of bonuses and remuneration, evidently what we have said, some have difficulty understanding. I repeat: when there is a social plan or when there are public aids, bonuses, stock option plans, exceptional remuneration are not acceptable. If you think I am targeting a current banking institution, that is exactly it. We cannot solicit public money to get through a moment unanimously described as difficult and then make a generous plan for distributing shares or bonuses. I am sure that the leaders will understand what I am saying, but to ensure that the message is well received, I will clarify: when you are a corporate officer, it would be a scandal. Is the message clear?

Finally, - sorry to be lengthy, but it is because I imagine that everyone wanted to have a reaction - to be complete, I also want to say that I try to be honest, to see things as they are. If I see them as they are, I want to thank the civil servants who have been committed to ensuring the minimum service operates. This was one of your major questions: "would it work?" Today you have the answer: "it works." I want to particularly thank the civil servants who ensured minimum reception in schools. In 80% of cities, there is a reception for families whose children were in classes where the teachers were on strike. There you go, proof is made that one can strike without paralyzing the country. Striking is a constitutional right. When I asked for minimum service, I was told that I was undermining the right to strike. The least we can say is that I did not undermine it, but during the strike, everyone could see it, the protests, everyone could observe them, they are significant, we must take them into account, but the country was not paralyzed. This did not harm the claim, but it protected our economy which does not need to be paralyzed additionally.

France is being watched by all countries in the world. It is not so often that we see France facing social movements; it has happened, but with buses running, metros running, trains running, planes running, public services functioning. Let the civil servants be thanked for that.

I think we are reaching a level of maturity in social democracy. And no one can complain about that.

And then, I also want to note, but you have echoed it, Ladies and Gentlemen of the press, that the number of strikers has significantly decreased. A company like RATP: half as many strikers. In the state public service, it is 6 points less, not 6% but 6 points less. And even in the National Education, 7 points less. This proves that many employees believe that in the face of an international crisis, a national strike cannot provide a response. It can express a concern, an anxiety, it can express anger, but it does not address the responses to the crisis, as when there is a text, we want its withdrawal or a specific measure whose adoption we want. I take all of this very seriously. We need to be extremely responsive. At the same time, we have extremely complex budgetary and financial balances, but I believe that on what I have said, on restructuring and on young people, we cannot wait.

Q - Can you comment on the INSEE forecasts, which predict a negative growth rate of -2.9 by the end of June? Does this require a stronger stimulus as requested by the IMF? Is there a way or another in which you want the wealthiest or richest French people to contribute to the solidarity effort?

A - Sir, commenting on the new forecasts? You will not finish asking me the question and I will not finish providing answers. I do not mean you specifically. The forecasts are being revised now; we are no longer in a monthly rhythm, it is almost weekly, and there is one organization announcing a catastrophic forecast, the other, not to be outdone, announces an even more catastrophic one. And the third... That is to say, the same organizations that did not see the crisis coming at all - how can we blame them for that? - are now in an extraordinary competition, the most credible being the one who announces the worst news.

So Christine Lagarde and the Prime Minister have made a forecast of -1.5. One cannot say that this is an optimistic forecast. So I propose that we revise it, that we announce a very catastrophic forecast and then INSEE, based on the government's catastrophic forecast, will revise its own forecasts to ensure that we plunge a little further. I am only slightly ironic. You can see the certainty of the forecasts of one or the other today. I believe that would not be reasonable. We would then engage in a cycle where, barely decisions are made, sir, even before they are put into action, we make others.

And then I will find myself confronted with a new headline in Le Monde warning me about deficits because I noticed that one day I was not spending enough, the next I was spending too much. We will try to continue along this line, to implement everything we have said, a meeting with the trade unions and employers' organizations before the summer to take stock and evaluate.

You tell me: "Are you finally going to make the wealthiest participate in the effort?" You know well - and I do not hold it against you, you have lived a lot in Brussels so perhaps you have forgotten what is happening in France - it is not in France that we abolished the wealth tax, it is in Spain. I did not abolish it, I confirmed it. It is the Spanish Prime Minister, but not two years ago, last year, who made the decision to abolish the wealth tax. So ask him the question! Socialists! You are very interested in Europe. There is a coalition in power in Germany, socialist, Mr. Steinmeier, Christian Democrat, to put it simply, Mrs. Merkel. They have the tax shield, they have had it for 25 years. There is not a single political party that is calling for its abolition, not one. Do you think...

Q - Yes, but it is constitutional. Why?

R - Because they said to themselves: the tax shield is so important that we must not get caught up in the eruptions of the moment. I am not even talking about the German liberal party because there one could say: the liberals... I am talking about the socialists. Mr. Steinmeier and Mrs. Merkel, it is not excessive, none of them want to do it. I could take you on a little tour of Northern Europe. They too have abolished - Sweden - the wealth tax. I will not do it in France because I consider it normal that when one has more money, one pays more taxes.

But the question, sir, I am deeply European and in this room, there are many of you, regardless of the impartiality of your professions, who are very European. Well, being European means ensuring that France is on an equal footing in competition with others. Our main competitor, who is it? Our main friend but our main competitor in external markets and in the economy is who? It is Germany. It is not an insult to them, on the contrary, they are number one, we are number two. The objective of number two is to become number one, not to be number three. It is our neighboring country, it is the largest country in Europe and it is one of those that is doing the best, notwithstanding the crisis. Would you like me to send the message: we are going to raise taxes in France? But do you think we have not done enough of that for thirty years? All left and right combined, they have raised them. Has that advanced justice in France? Has that created jobs in France? Has that made France shine? If there is an economic strategy on which I was elected - and then I will tell you one thing, sir, be careful because when one starts, one always starts by raising taxes on the rich and then in the end, we find ourselves with those who said it was the rich who needed to have their taxes raised, it turns out to be you. We must be careful because in the end, it always happens like this, there is never anyone who said I want to raise taxes for everyone, it is always the unsympathetic rich, etc., very well, and then in the end, it is the middle classes, because it always happens like that. I do not think the solution is to isolate France in a movement of tax increases when we need, on the contrary, to attract capital to our country.

In summary, I have listened carefully to what has been said. I am perfectly aware of the concern. Moreover, it exists in all countries of Europe, in all countries of the world. I travel a lot, I meet many heads of state and government, not a single one tells me: "You know, everyone is calm in my country, no one is worried, not one." It is a reality and in the face of that, I believe we must keep our cool, continue to do things and we do them every day. I do not refuse to do more if it is useful, but I want to know if it is useful. To know if it is useful, what we have decided must come into effect to see: "Does it bring something, or does it bring nothing?" I cannot simply react to social movements, to journalists' questions or to such and such a poll! I must conduct a coherent policy that reassures through its coherence and its constancy. I do not say no, I do not say there is nothing else to do. There is always something to do and I have said it for restructuring, for the youth, perhaps for infrastructure, perhaps for other things but I want us to do it with calm, with organization, because I know that we will come out of the crisis, that the world will come out of the crisis. We must come out stronger and that in this extremely difficult moment, in the position I am in, with the responsibilities that are mine, I must have this calm for everyone. It is not so simple.

I am sometimes told: you see, there are many demonstrators. There are as many as for the CPE affair. There is a difference, it is not the same thing. When there was 2% or 2.5% growth and when we are at -1.5% recession! It is not the same country to lead, it is not the same climate, it is not the same matter to be in government or to be President of the Republic, it is more complex. I listen, I watch, I am extremely attentive, I try to be reactive, but wisely, at the right moment, as we did with the automotive plan, as we did with the banks, as we did with the sovereign plan. Look at Renault which is going to create jobs in Flins. That was not said three months ago, when I faced the debate on protectionism and all that. As we try to change international rules, that is what I am trying to do and I will be judged by the results, I know that well. In the storm, we must hold the course, that is what I am trying to do.

Q - I have a question regarding the 7 billion that you mentioned earlier. Are the 7 billion euros for Renault related more to credit guarantees or scrappage bonuses, or are they state subsidies...? The fact that the French producer is now moving or relocating his production to France, do you call that proactive industrial policy or do you say that France has been lucky, or is it not protectionism after all?

R - It is very simple, if you consider that every job created in France is a job resulting from nationalism and protectionism, very well but then, in that case, we can even give up electing a President of the Republic. Is every job created in France a theft from other countries? I did not understand the question? Was that the question? There you go, there are 400 jobs that will be created in France, is that protectionism? No. There is no factory closure in Slovenia, there is no factory closure, there is no job lost. Listen, just because we are one of the major countries in Europe, we should not consider that a factory on our territory is a theft from others. Listen, be reasonable because you too, the Czechs, you are a major country, you have countries around you that are less wealthy. Does that mean that when you create a job, you have stolen it from Slovakia next door? All French jobs, do we give them to the Czech Republic and all Czech jobs, do we give them to Slovakia? That is not a system after all.

As for the 7 billion, it is the automotive plan. You know, what we have already done, a few weeks ago, is money that we lend, which is paid at 6% if I remember correctly and do you know why we did it? Because there was no bank to lend to them. I would have preferred not to do it, but then what was the solution? If we did not do it before February 15, there was a risk of closure, for example of Renault, do you think that would have improved the situation in Central and Eastern European countries? I am not sure.

Q - I had a question about the intervention of the President of the European Parliament at this summit. Recently, you said that the time to choose the next President of the Commission had not come, it seems that the President said that it should be chosen early. Have you changed your mind?

R - It is complicated. First of all, there is one thing that is not complicated, I have always enjoyed working with José Manuel Barroso, I have always said it and it seems to me that I have often had a more positive appreciation of his work than was usually the case in this room, to put it simply. I have not changed my mind, I have always enjoyed working with José Manuel Barroso, he is a man I respect and for whom I have a lot of friendship, first point.

Second point, it is not me who invents the legal questions. Excuse me, in June, if a definitive decision is made, it will be based on the Treaty of Nice, unless you can explain to me that the referendum in Ireland will take place before June. It will take place in the autumn, so in June, if a decision is made, it is based on Nice, not to mention the vote of our Czech friends in the Senate which is also scheduled for the autumn. Why do I say this? Because if we do it based on Nice, we will have to say who does not have a commissioner. It is an extremely interesting debate then, and I await it with great interest. It will help us a lot in Ireland, really it is something good. Why not say that we are removing the position for example? That will help a lot and I will be happy for all the trouble I have taken to try to unblock the situation. That will be a positive point. Come on, it is a legal problem, I am not inventing it. The solution that France has proposed under the control of Bernard Kouchner and Bruno Le Maire is a political principle decision in June and the legal instruments available for this political decision in the autumn, when we have the response from the Irish referendum and from our Czech friends. That seems more reasonable to me.

Last point: you have observed that there are at least three positions. There is the President of the Council, stable if we have Lisbon, there is the High Representative, who is also Vice-President of the Commission, if we have Lisbon, there is the President of the Commission and the distribution of portfolios in the Commission with portfolios that may interest certain countries. It is a discussion and the discussion continues, it is thriving. It is interesting and it goes well beyond the very positive, very warm feelings that I have for José Manuel Barroso, which are undeniable. He is a good man, I enjoy working with him and I would not be embarrassed to support him, quite the contrary, but I want to have an overall idea nonetheless.

Q - Mr. President, a small clarification on this. If we were to make the political decision in June for the Commission, but if the Treaty of Lisbon unfortunately is not ratified by referendum in Ireland, does that imply, for you, that the political decision would remain in effect or would it be linked to the outcome of the Irish vote?

R - If we make a political decision in June, there would need to be very serious reasons for it to change in the autumn. So it is rather the political decision of June, of course, but I would regret very much if Lisbon does not come into effect. We can see that we need Lisbon, in every respect.

Q - What do you think of the American President's outstretched hand policy towards Iran?

R - Listen, it has been many years that we have been waiting for the Americans to re-engage not only in the Iranian file but also in the Palestinian and Israeli file, and so this is rather good news. We cannot ask them to play their role and then complain when they do play that role. For my part, I remain convinced that with a barrel of Brent below 50 dollars quite significantly, the policy of sanctions remains relevant and that at the same time, we need to discuss. I do not think that the issue of the election in Iran is as important as it is said to be, as I am convinced that decisions are made at the highest level of the State, by consensus, but that the American president wants to re-engage in the service of peace by telling the Iranian people that they are a great people and warning their leaders against obtaining nuclear weapons, this is nothing but positive.

Q - The Czech Foreign Minister described the regime change in Madagascar as a coup yesterday. What does the Union want to do and especially what does France, which remains the main bilateral donor to the island, want to do?

R - I did not know he said that, but I could say the same thing, which does not defend the former president. I am sorry, there is a lot to say about the former president, a lot, but I observe that he was overthrown without any election, none. Secondly, I observe that the first decision is the suspension of Parliament, which is not exactly an extremely positive sign. Thirdly, I warn the new power about the physical integrity of the former president, regardless of what he has done. He must be judged if necessary, but we do not settle matters like this and I greatly regret the evolution in Madagascar. I naturally call for elections as soon as possible, which are the only way to get out of the mess in which it finds itself. So if the Czech Presidency has said that it was a coup, I could sign what it said. If a coup is taking power outside the normal and constitutional procedure, that is indeed what happened, which does not make me denounce the new one, nor regret the old one. Simply, yes, that is it, it is a coup.

Q - Mr. President, regarding enlargement, Albania has decided to submit its membership application, as Montenegro did during your Presidency, during the Czech Presidency. Will you support this in these times of economic crisis or what will happen with this new step from this country?

R - I have always thought that this region of Europe was destined to integrate into the family. There are procedures. I fear that it may take some time for our Albanian friends, but we have no reason to give a different response.

Thank you very much.