Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the fight against gangs and violence, in Gagny on March 18, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

18 March 2009 · Statement on the fight against gangs and violence · Gagny, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed officials in Gagny on March 18, 2009, responding to violent gang attacks on a high school and police officers in the Paris region.
Main themes
Gang violence, school safety, law and order, police protection, repeat offenders and minimum sentences, social inequality and security, Republican values and territorial authority, fight against impunity, urban delinquency, security reforms
Duration
~28 min
79th percentile
Words
3,319
79th percentile
Sentences
184
87th percentile
Readability
42
41st percentile
Grade
11.8
42nd percentile
Syntax
2.74
17th percentile
Vocabulary
2.41
91st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 46%39%
  • Social 41%35%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Economic 1%1%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 16%

184 sentences in 76 paragraphs

Ladies Ministers,

Mr. Minister,

Gentlemen Prefects,

Gentlemen Prosecutors,

Gentlemen Rectors,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I/ Two events of exceptional gravity have just occurred in the Paris region.

On March 10 in Gagny, about twenty hooded individuals, armed with sticks and iron bars, broke into the Jean-Baptiste Clément high school in Gagny. During this attack, they vandalized the premises and injured four people, including an educational assistant and three high school students. The worst was avoided thanks to the composure and courage of the teachers and the school's officials who resisted the violence. The immediate intervention of the police allowed for the arrest of some of the assailants and restored order. The reason for this assault? A simple gang rivalry. The perpetrators of this act were looking for a student from the vocational high school to beat him up.

On March 14, 10 police officers were injured by gunfire in Les Mureaux after falling into a real ambush set by about thirty individuals.

These events have several common points.

In both cases, the worst was avoided. The intention of the assailants was to cause victims, perhaps to kill. We are confronted with phenomena of blind hatred directed against two pillars of the Republic: the school and the police.

Opening fire on police officers, invading a high school in an armed gang, these are extraordinary acts that testify to a loss of all reference points, of all limits.

Each time, it is a small minority of a few dozen individuals who poison the lives of populations who only wish to live in peace.

I do not accept the logic of excuses and the victimization of the perpetrators of such acts. The refrain is unfortunately well known: these young people express their revolt against a French society that rejects and excludes them. We have heard this discourse too often.

I received at the Élysée teachers and students from the vocational high school in Gagny. I met young men and women from all backgrounds. I observed their determination to succeed through studies and work, despite social handicaps.

That is why the intrusion of a gang of ultra-violent individuals, determined to break, to injure, to spread terror, is something profoundly unjust and intolerable.

I want to say it clearly: a vocational high school in Gagny, in Seine-Saint-Denis, must have exactly the same right to live in peace as the best Parisian high schools and prestigious schools.

The first duty of the Republic is to ensure equal rights to security for all French citizens. Educational institutions, especially in sensitive neighborhoods or nearby, must be protected and sanctuarized from all forms of violence.

No part of the national territory should escape the authority of the State. Insecurity is the first of inequalities, the worst of injustices: it hits hardest those who are most vulnerable, the most precarious, those who cannot afford to settle in nice neighborhoods or to enroll their children in protected institutions.

Some attribute the violence to police intervention in the neighborhoods. But really, it is the world turned upside down! It is the fundamental mission of the security forces to ensure the authority of the law throughout the national territory. France is not a mosaic of gangs, neighborhoods, or tribes. It is an indivisible Republic, a Nation united around its values, its identity, and the awareness of a common destiny. I will not allow any part of the national territory to be subjected to the law of thugs and to a logic of territories that often covers conflicts of interest for the sharing of the drug market.

You know that a considerable amount of work has been done over the past seven years to improve the security of our fellow citizens.

For example, we have created the GIR: 33 today, which has become an essential tool in the fight against criminal trafficking. We have redeployed police and gendarmerie forces concerning more than 400 municipalities. We have implemented video surveillance. We have developed the national fingerprint database that allows us to solve nearly 10,000 cases each year. We have profoundly reformed intelligence with the creation of the DCRI. We have brought the police and gendarmerie closer under the unique command of the Minister of the Interior.

With the creation of minimum sentences, we have made a significant step forward in the fight against impunity. At the beginning of 2009, 10,000 repeat offenders, including 164 minors, were sentenced to a penalty equal to or greater than the minimum sentence, out of 20,000 judgments for which the penalty was applicable.

This reform met an essential expectation of our fellow citizens, exasperated by the impunity enjoyed by repeat criminals.

This reform work and the mobilization of all security actors are obviously bearing fruit: between 1997 and 2002, not long ago, delinquency increased by 15%. From 2002 to 2007, it decreased by the same amount: 13.5%, and in 2008 it fell again by nearly 1%. I am pleased to note that for the first time, in Seine-Saint-Denis, the number of recorded incidents decreased significantly in 2008 compared to 2007: -3.5%, and in the first two months of 2009: -6.8%.

In terms of clearance rates, fantastic progress has been made. We must tell the French people that in 2002, one in four offenders was found, a 25% clearance rate. Today, it is almost one in three. It does concern me to leave 60% of crimes and offenses unsolved, but you realize that in 7 years we have gone from 25% to 37%. Never before has such a level been reached.

However, there are two phenomena that particularly concern me: the rise of violent gangs and acts of violence committed against representatives of authority.

The number of known gangs is estimated at over 200 in France, with 80% in the Paris region, which represents about 5,000 people, half of whom are minors. These gangs correspond to sensitive neighborhoods and territorial logics.

They are mostly linked to various criminal traffics, particularly drug trafficking or extortion.

The most concerning phenomenon is their extreme violence, which continues to escalate. Clashes, ambushes, the use of handguns or firearms are becoming commonplace. Thus, in the second half of 2008, law enforcement counted 200 clashes between gangs, three-quarters of which were in the Paris region, and the phenomenon continues in 2009.

The street is the most frequent theater of these violences, even in the heart of the capital, as several recent events have shown. However, violence is increasingly tending to occur inside or around educational institutions. The victims of the climate of terror generated by the gangs are often the most vulnerable, often the most serious students who want to succeed, as we saw in Gagny.

My second source of concern is the rise of violence against those who embody the institutions of the Republic.

They have reached an unbearable level: 25,000 acts of violence against representatives of authority each year, and they have increased by 3.5% in the last twelve months.

Attacks against police officers and gendarmes are becoming more frequent: insults, blows, stone-throwing, when it is not gunfire. Principals, teachers, and other school officials are also victims of common violence in the exercise of their mission.

When a gendarme or a police officer is stoned, when a teacher is hit, it is the Republic that is being attacked.

Shooting at a law enforcement representative is a criminal act of the utmost seriousness.

I want to thank the magistrates, police officers, gendarmes, firefighters, and teachers who are confronted with this reality and face it with a sense of duty and exemplary courage. I want to tell them that the first duty of the State is to protect them so that they can carry out their mission.

I do not wish to blame anyone, but I note the existence of a problem in the chain of arrests and sanctions. I am well aware of the difficulty in making arrests, gathering evidence, and judging. I know how complex the work of police officers and magistrates is.

However, I cannot help but think that we should be able to improve the quality of procedures and evidence collection. Thus, following the assault on the vocational high school in Gagny, 14 individuals were referred to the prosecutor's office. Two days later, only one of them was placed in pre-trial detention. All the others were free despite the enormity of what they had done! For the victims, knowing that almost all the assailants are free the day after is incomprehensible.

Similarly, what happened following the events in Les Mureaux is shocking and unacceptable. Only one arrest after the ambush against law enforcement. A 14-year-old repeat offender was arrested for throwing stones at the police. The next day, placed by the justice system in a closed educational center, this young man escaped and is currently at large!

This situation cannot continue. If we continue like this, the phenomena of gangs and violence against individuals can only worsen in the future. What is at stake is the credibility of the State in protecting citizens. I have said that reforms have been undertaken, progress made. But it is clear that we must go further. We have an obligation to deliver results to the French people. Everything must be attempted, everything must be accomplished for the maintenance of the security of our compatriots.

II/ The State has an obligation to deliver results in this regard. During the presidential campaign, I made commitments to the French people. These commitments will be honored.

First of all, it is essential to accelerate the modernization of our police tools to combat delinquency committed by gangs.

One of the weaknesses of our system lies in the insufficient and partial knowledge of these phenomena: how violent gangs are formed, how they are organized, who their leaders are, what their connections with the outside are, and their links with organized crime.

To strengthen these tools for understanding gangs, specialized groups on urban violence will be created within the intelligence services of the relevant departmental public security directorates (DDSP).

These phenomena are now developing on the scale of urban areas. Thus, in Paris, only 45% of the individuals involved live within the capital.

The DDSP, in each department, ensures monitoring at the departmental level of a phenomenon that is developing at the level of urban areas. Criminals obviously do not recognize administrative boundaries, especially those who operate in gangs. The collection of information and the synthesis work around gang phenomena remain scattered and insufficiently cross-referenced.

What I say about gang phenomena also applies, as everyone knows, to ordinary delinquency. Crime and delinquency disregard departmental limits. They develop in the territories of urban areas. We must draw the consequences of this observation.

I therefore ask the Minister of the Interior to propose to me before the summer a reform of the command of the security function that takes into account the logic of urban areas. I wish this reform for all of France. I wish it, of course, first for the Paris region where the Police Prefect must have responsibility for security not only in Paris but also in the inner suburbs.

Such unification of command is perfectly compatible with respect for departmental competencies. I add that there are also some paradoxes in the government proposing an organization of local authorities based on metropolitan areas without drawing the consequences for its own services.

The creation of Neighborhood Territorial Units (UTeQ), composed of about twenty officers assigned to the security of a neighborhood, constitutes an appropriate response to the new forms of violent delinquency. This device is the opposite of the spirit that characterized community policing. The Territorial Units have the mission of establishing a close relationship with the residents of a neighborhood but also of demonstrating absolute firmness towards delinquents. There are already 8 UTeQ, three of which are in Seine-Saint-Denis, which have achieved spectacular results. In Clichy-Montfermeil, neighborhood delinquency has dropped by 19%, and in Saint Denis by 30%.

The security companies, made up of one hundred and fifty officers, are specially trained for maintaining order in sensitive neighborhoods in case of tension or disturbances. There is currently only one in Seine-Saint-Denis.

I wish to accelerate the deployment of these two instruments. The objective must be to establish 100 UTeQ and 23 security companies by the end of this year 2010, and not in 2012, as initially planned. I am aware of the considerable effort required in terms of redeployment and training of the concerned officials. I ask this of the Minister of the Interior because I am convinced that we are currently facing a vital issue for the cohesion of our country.

To facilitate the repression of these phenomena and improve the effectiveness of investigations, it also seems essential to me to establish specialized groups in each departmental security force focused on combating urban crime and specifically trained for this purpose.

Likewise, I support the creation of a database dedicated to urban violence and gang phenomena. For now, such a tool does not exist. It is not, of course, a matter of creating databases for the sake of creating databases or wanting to provoke controversy.

However, to the extent that the need is felt in the interest of the security of the French people, we have no hesitation in doing so. The chorus of the self-righteous will unleash at the mere mention of a database, but that does not matter. The future of our freedoms and our republican principles largely depends on our ability to meet the challenge of urban violence.

I hold the same reasoning regarding video surveillance. 10,000 cameras have been installed with state funding. This tool has largely demonstrated its effectiveness in preventing and repressing urban crime and gang phenomena. The immediate goal is to set up 75 standard municipal systems and ensure the protection of 400 educational institutions. I regret the reluctance of some mayors to engage in the path of video surveillance. Video surveillance does not threaten freedoms. It defends and protects the freedom to move around and come and go in one's neighborhood safely. For those who have justifiable reasons to fear in their daily lives, this freedom is precious. I look forward to the upcoming debate in Parliament on the Law of Orientation and Programming for the Performance of Internal Security - LOPPSI II - which will facilitate the development of video surveillance.

We know well that drug trafficking is a backdrop to urban violence and gang phenomena. Considerable progress has been made in repressing these traffics. In 2008, nearly 170,000 offenses against drug legislation were recorded. 65 tons of cannabis were seized, twice as much as in 2007! I want to congratulate Ms. Alliot-Marie, all the magistrates, police officers, gendarmes, and customs officers who are behind these successes. The fight against these criminal traffics is a vital issue for the future and for French society.

The time has come to engage in a policy aimed at strengthening the role of GIRs as spearheads in the fight against this type of crime. It seems essential to me today to improve the impetus, coordination, and evaluation of the GIRs, systematically involving customs, tax services, and social organizations in their activities. Here too, LOPPSI II will provide investigative services with new tools to combat this form of crime.

The fight against gangs is now at the heart of the action taken by public prosecutors. In Paris, in Bobigny for example, they have fully grasped the extent of this phenomenon. They have implemented prevention plans, in connection with local elected officials, and they are conducting investigations to identify and convict the perpetrators of these unbearable acts.

Justice is taking its rightful place in the action taken against these acts that so deeply unsettle and frighten our fellow citizens.

Allow me to pay tribute to the work of the Prosecutors and their teams. They have adapted effectively and with the appropriate severity to the emergence of this delinquency.

I know that coordination with police and gendarmerie services is excellent. I know that the requisitions at hearings, before the judges of liberties and detention, are particularly firm.

I want to express my appreciation for their commitment to the security of the French people.

But in the face of these severe requisitions, in the face of the efforts of investigators and public prosecutors, the response available to the courts sometimes seems inadequate.

The delinquents who make up these gangs have indeed understood for a long time that under our current laws, they cannot be convicted unless a specific act can be attributed to them.

What is lacking in our arsenal is the ability to prosecute and convict individuals who form a gang with the intent to commit offenses against persons or property.

I am determined not to let these delinquents have the last word. Since they are taking advantage of a gap in the law, we must remedy it. I have asked the Keeper of the Seals to change the law.

We must equip our penal code with a provision that will punish with 3 years of imprisonment the act of knowingly being part of a group, even formed temporarily, pursuing the goal of committing willful offenses against persons or certain property.

Everyone will understand that, moreover, violence against the educational institution, against teachers and students, is particularly intolerable. It touches on what a society holds most precious: its youth, its future. We must reflect on ways to "sanctuarize" the school environment against violence or gang phenomena.

I ask Ms. Alliot-Marie and Mr. Darcos to develop targeted action on the institutions most subjected to intrusions and violence from the surroundings. I wish for the identification of the 100 or 200 institutions most affected by the phenomenon. On this basis, it will be necessary to conduct security diagnostics focused on anti-intrusion measures: the state of fences and gates, the organization of entry and exit filtering, the existence of video surveillance; then to take all necessary measures to strengthen the filtering systems for entries and exits and to improve surveillance means in each of these institutions.

I ask them to proceed with the systematic implementation of a system of designated police officers in the institutions based on what was established in 2006 in the colleges of Hauts-de-Seine. The police officers, while not being present all day, must be in a position to intervene as needed on the security issues of the institution. They will participate in the development of security diagnostics, prevention operations, and facilitate the follow-up to reports.

I have said it: the School cannot, and must not, be considered a banal place and especially not a place of aggression.

I ask Ms. Dati to initiate a reform of the criminal qualifications sanctioning intrusion into a school establishment. I wish for intrusion without authorization or permission into a school establishment to be considered no longer as an offense punishable by a simple fifth-class fine, but as a felony.

Likewise, I wish for violence committed against a national education agent to constitute aggravating circumstances in the future not only when it occurs inside the establishment that performs a public service mission but also when it is committed outside the establishment due to said functions. This will be the case, for example, of a teacher assaulted in public transport. This reform will ensure that teachers receive the protection enjoyed by agents entrusted with public authority.

Ladies and gentlemen, I renew my trust in you for this complex task of ensuring the safety of our fellow citizens, particularly the most vulnerable among them. Reforms and the introduction of new technologies are essential to face the evolution of delinquency, but they are of no use without the personal involvement and will of all those who work on the ground, sometimes in conditions of extreme danger. I take this opportunity to thank you and to confirm my absolute determination to provide you with the means to carry out your mission under the best conditions of effectiveness and safety.