Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on the regulation of financial markets and on the fight against climate change, in Brussels on September 17, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

17 September 2009 · Press conference · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy addressed a Brussels press conference on September 17, 2009, following an EU informal summit ahead of the G20 Pittsburgh meeting and UN climate talks.
Main themes
Financial market regulation, banker bonuses reform, climate change and Copenhagen summit, carbon border adjustment mechanism, G20 governance, IMF reform, European unity, France-Germany cooperation, Basel II implementation, global temperature targets
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,281
88th percentile
Sentences
201
89th percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
10.2
23rd percentile
Syntax
2.91
36th percentile
Vocabulary
1.96
6th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

201 sentences in 54 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT - Ladies and gentlemen, we will proceed quickly if you agree. It was a useful meeting, a good text prepared by the Swedish Presidency and a Europe that asserts its desire to present a united front in New York and Pittsburgh.

I will, of course, answer any questions you may have regarding financial regulation, bonuses, and the fact that the world of finance must change, must evolve; there is a general agreement in Europe, specific commitments, a willingness to make things happen.

It is very clear, there are no exceptions.

I was very pleased that the letter we signed with Mrs. MERKEL and Mr. BROWN was almost fully included in the final text of the Swedish Presidency. From this perspective, the debate among us was extremely easy, and we reached an agreement almost immediately.

Secondly, regarding the Copenhagen issue, there is really a growing awareness among Europeans that they must assume leadership and take initiatives to ensure that Copenhagen is a success and that the goal of keeping the global temperature increase to 2°C is a goal that we all share.

Two things. First, we support the idea of providing money to poor and least developed countries to help them change their practices to preserve the planet's environmental balances, but we naturally condition this payment on an agreement, with everyone needing to make an effort. And, the idea is progressing that if there is no commitment from everyone, it would not be without consequences for the creation of a carbon tax or any other appropriate process to rebalance competition between regions of the world where companies are subject to rules to preserve the environment and other regions where similar rules are not imposed.

You know that this was a point on which France was initially very isolated. Little by little, this idea is gaining traction and is being better understood, not as a protectionist approach but as an element of rebalancing growth. You will see that in the coming days, together with Germany, we will take an initiative in the perspective of Copenhagen, on the environment where we, Germany and France, will call for the creation of an appropriate mechanism at the borders of Europe in case there is this imbalance.

The third element, the idea of the G20 as a major, central body to discuss economic and financial issues is really clearly accepted in Europe. You know the importance that France placed on the evolution from G8 to G20 to G14; things have really progressed immensely in this regard. Furthermore, as I mentioned following my dinner with Gordon BROWN, we are also making progress; there is an agreement on the reform of the IMF. I discussed this with President OBAMA; this reform is necessary, and there is a clear willingness around the table of the European Council not to add a difficulty by reducing the number of seats on the board from 24 to 20. I had also indicated this to President OBAMA.

So it is a united Europe with a fairly clear, strong message, a very high level of coordination among us, the Swedish Presidency, the British, the Germans, of course the Spaniards, the Dutch, and the Italians, who will present themselves both in New York and Pittsburgh. It was therefore a useful informal summit, and indeed, positions are converging.

Now, if you have any questions, I will try to answer them as best as I can.

QUESTION - You met with President OBAMA, so it seems that the European position is roughly in line with yours. Can you clarify the specific, technical points of disagreement that currently exist between Europe and the United States?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, it is difficult for me to express the details of the conversation with Mr. OBAMA; it would not be extremely courteous, as you can understand. Furthermore, Angela MERKEL, I hope I am not being indiscreet, is supposed to have a conference call with President OBAMA tomorrow.

You have understood well that in Europe, there is really a common position. We want specific commitments, we want the end of the scandal of bonuses being handed out indiscriminately, we want a different financial organization. By the way, we all want the implementation of Basel II; Europe is implementing it, and the Americans must implement it.

I can say, on this point, I believe that Mr. OBAMA sincerely wants things to change regarding bonuses and systemic risks concerning a number of financial institutions. He has understood that Europe wants specific commitments; I think he has understood the system proposed by France and that Europe has adopted today, of bonus-malus since even the term is being reintroduced.

The point that poses a problem is the global limitation on the amount of bonuses. Now, this does not pose a problem within the framework of the European position since it is also included in the text. But here is the point of disagreement. I also say that if we have specific commitments on everything else - that is to say, bonus-malus, bonuses paid over time, transparency at the time of voting on bonuses, the extremely important question in my eyes of capital increasing in proportion to speculative or market activities - we can find an agreement, but these are the points currently under discussion.

I could go into more detail, but as the texts are not stabilized, it should be noted that the latest text for this meeting is a text from 5 PM this afternoon.

Regarding accounting standards, this is part of a discussion between Europe and the United States. We want the Americans to implement Basel II. There is no reason for only Europe to implement Basel II. So, this is the subject of discussions. But it is very important that Europe goes united; there is really no discussion on this matter. We needed to clarify things in France, then clarify them in Europe. That is done. And then, next week, there is all the work for Pittsburgh. And we will have more meetings in New York and discussions, so the texts will change until then. But for me, it is a great satisfaction because, look at where we started from in Europe. There was a position that was quite isolated for France at the beginning. Really, today, there are no exceptions.

QUESTION - When we were in the midst of the economic crisis, you said that the risk is not to reform global finance and to let things happen and wait for it to recover because at that point, we would say it should not be done. Now, we are presumably in a phase - even if we are still in the crisis - where there are signs of recovery, so my first question is: does this not work against the idea of reforming global finance?

And regarding the United States, we know there are problems of divergence. How can you simply convince Mr. OBAMA?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, my vigilance and commitment are total. There are signs of recovery, but it is not enough. I cannot wish for quarters of recession simply because it would facilitate international discussions. In Europe, there is a desire that this does not happen again. And we are clear on that. I add another thing; all of Europe is asking for countermeasures regarding non-cooperative jurisdictions, that is to say, tax havens, meaning sanctions that would be applied starting from the first quarter of 2010. I remind you that before London, France was the only one asking for this. Today, it is a reality, the retreat of tax havens, and I believe we will achieve sanctions.

But I will see you next Friday at the end of Pittsburgh. I cannot tell you more. In recent weeks, the work for France has been to convince, one by one. One by one. There have been many meetings and even more phone exchanges. The letter with Mrs. MERKEL and Mr. BROWN is very important because France, all of a sudden, acted as a bridge between what was called Rhine capitalism and Anglo-Saxon capitalism. And we reached an agreement; there is unity, and now there is all the work across the Atlantic, and we must not forget the work with emerging countries as well.

We are not out of the woods yet, but Europe is united on a strong political message; we do not want this to happen again and for the scandal of bonuses and irresponsible behaviors to thrive on the pretext that stock markets are recovering; that is good, but that does not change our minds. The same causes must not produce the same effects. To all Europeans, to all those who believe in Europe, it is still very encouraging before a G20; first of all, the G20 was the idea of Europe. We carried it, Mr. BARROSO and I, to Camp David; this idea is now widely supported, and the regulation of the financial world was not an obvious idea, well, it is now established in Europe; we will see what follows, but vigilance is total. Can we trust Mr. OBAMA? I tend to say yes; I listen to what he says, I read his speeches; he has committed himself in his speeches; he said that they too did not want this to happen again. Well, all of us, in front of the eyes of the whole world in Pittsburgh, will have to align our speeches with our actions.

QUESTION - Regarding the agreement reached this evening compared to the draft that circulated in recent days, I would like to know if you managed to impose the cancellation of bonuses if necessary? Or impose sanctions on banks that would not limit bonuses; is this included in tonight's agreement?

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, it is in tonight's agreement; the notion of malus is clearly mentioned; excuse me, I am looking at my collaborators because I do not want to say anything incorrect; as you know, there are discussions among heads of state and government, and then there is the drafting. Yes, it is clearly introduced. After that, regarding sanctions, I saw with interest that the New York prosecutor has summoned American company executives to court because they did not comply with transparency and shareholder information rules. Well, this is progressing. All of this is going in the right direction. But, sir, let me be clear: we will know next Friday if we are at the end of the process.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you also spoke to us about Copenhagen; are you worried today about the state of these negotiations? Do you feel that they are stagnating, that they are not progressing? What needs to be done to really relaunch them, and are we not heading towards failure?

THE PRESIDENT - I am worried, yes. That is why, by the way, I spoke with the Secretary-General of the United Nations this afternoon because we cannot afford the luxury of failure in Copenhagen, and France has not done everything it is doing with environmental taxation to abandon the global issue. This was the subject of a long conversation with Mr. BAN Ki-Moon this afternoon. I will, of course, participate in the dinner and the meeting in New York. I believe, first of all, that there needs to be leadership because since everyone is concerned, no one is really taking care of it. I have great faith in the initiative that we can take with Mr. LULA, Mr. BROWN, France, and others, but it is important that Europe shows its willingness to take responsibility. This means that we are ready to pay because you know there is a financial stake; producing clean will cost money. So regarding the modalities, there will be other proposals, and we will have the opportunity to discuss them again.

Secondly, it is very important to understand that there can be a carrot: if emerging countries adopt the same objectives that we have set for ourselves, we will help them financially, but if they do not adopt the same objectives, the idea is progressing that to rebalance the conditions of free trade and competition, there will need to be a border adjustment mechanism. Otherwise, it is massive aid to relocations. We cannot tax European industries and exempt others. So there too, we had a debate. I explained at length on the subject; this is not a protectionist measure; it is simply a mechanism that tells countries: be careful, this is not a zero-sum game; we are all accountable, but if you exempt yourselves from the efforts we are willing to make, there will be consequences.

Then, there was a debate about whether the Commission, whether Europe, should put money on the table - finally, a proposal - or wait for others. France pushed for us to put the proposal on the table because if everyone waits before making their proposals, we are already mid-September, Copenhagen is in December, we are out of time! That is where we stand today.

QUESTION - You are reporting a number of advances and agreements among European countries; are there still major points of divergence among the 27, or on the exact modalities?

THE PRESIDENT - On bonuses and financial regulation, to my knowledge, my colleagues have not yet spoken, so I do not want to be their spokesperson, but to my knowledge there is no debate. Moreover, from the moment we reached an agreement with Gordon BROWN, that was very important. I appreciate him a lot, as you know, but there were, let’s say, traditional differences in assessment. To my knowledge, there is currently no debate.

On Copenhagen, there is no division; let’s say there is a level of concern that is not the same. Some countries, I think particularly of Poland, may be worried about the magnitude of the hurdle they must overcome to comply with the energy-climate package; I do not deny that at all, but at the same time they signed, it was under the French Presidency, so we cannot say that there is a division. There may be some of us who are more or less passionate about the issue; I think of Italy or France, I am not sure we see it with exactly the same urgency, without mocking anyone, but there is no division.

So what are the points of debate? Reform of the IMF is undoubtedly a subject of concern for some countries that are historically members of the IMF Board of Directors more than for others. Germany and France feel less threatened by an IMF reform than others, and I believe there was relief, particularly from our Belgian friends, when I indicated that I thought Europe’s position in Pittsburgh should be to defend a Board of Directors of 24, because in terms of governance, I do not see what it changes to be at 24 or at 20, but it complicates the renegotiation. If in addition to a renegotiation of voting rights, you have to eliminate 20% of the seats, you enter into an exercise that is unbearable.

And then there are interesting debates, even if they have not been the subject of a decision, but which are progressing: the taxation of speculative movements. Interesting because around the table, there are two countries that said: “but why aren’t we discussing France’s proposal?” You know that I have shown openness on the issue of this taxation; it is Mr. SOCRATES and the Austrian Prime Minister. And the Chancellor who said: “but if it is a global decision, why not?”

And above all, there are two points of consensus: that the crisis can in no way allow us to exempt ourselves from our obligations to finance poor countries, whether it is on health, development, or access to primary energies, but since we are all in deficit or nearly so, we need to find innovative financing, and this tax is an innovative financing. I found that around the Board table, it is not in the communiqué and it has not been the subject of a formal deliberation, but it is progressing.

So one might say: “but why don’t you put it on the agenda for Pittsburgh?” Because I think that in strategic terms, it would be a mistake. There are other subjects that we do not put on the agenda, the monetary issue for example; we cannot talk about everything, and for me, what matters most is to have concrete decisions that show that we will apply everything from London and that we will go further on regulation. If we can achieve that, it is wonderful. To be very frank, Madam, to load the boat further on this, when there is a dinner, a morning, a lunch, would seem unreasonable to me. We talked about it, and it did not create a division or a loud outcry.

Really, I think the only positive consequence of the crisis is that it forces each of us to think much more freely than we could before the crisis.

QUESTION - Is there a clear agreement on a clear cap on remuneration in finance among Europeans, and if so, it seems that Mr. OBAMA has already expressed that it does not seem like a good idea to him. If you cannot convince the United States, will Europe have to go unilaterally, will Europe have to go it alone?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, Europe can take measures that other parts of the world do not take. And France can take measures that Europe does not take. The argument on the theme: “it harms competitiveness,” is a bit short and frankly, it is not a very impressive thing even if one must have balance in everything. The question of capping can be seen in several ways. We can set a figure, and we can also achieve the same result by imposing stricter rules on capital. And it is rather this path that we are taking, which has an advantage, Sir, it is that capital is calculated in the consolidated accounts, and therefore applies to all subsidiaries of a company. A national or even European cap would not apply to subsidiaries of a national or European company located outside the national area or outside the European area. That is why I find that the path of increasing capital in proportion to speculative activities, which themselves generate the so-called shocking bonuses, seems to me a more effective capping method because it is global. I do not know if I am making myself understood? But because it is global, because it is in the consolidated accounts, it is extremely important for us.

The second thing that is important is the bonus-malus, that is to say bonuses that would not be paid; I had proposed one-third per year over three years, because that is the only way to apply a malus. All of this is progressing, and we will meet next Friday.

QUESTION - Mr. President, still on Copenhagen. We are hearing again about divergence between Americans and Europeans on climate change issues. Europeans want a legally binding agreement and to continue with a new treaty, like Kyoto. Americans seem to prefer a more flexible model. Why is it important for France to maintain a model with legally binding agreements? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - Even when there are legally binding agreements, there are some countries that exempt themselves from them. If you have agreements that are not binding at all, there is no chance that we will make the necessary sacrifices to achieve them. I do not want to go into the details of Copenhagen because before Copenhagen, there is Pittsburgh. It is not to evade, but there are several things we can discuss.

You talk about a treaty. We can imagine something else. I mean we can imagine other binding ways to have commitments in this area. I do not want to say that we would give up a treaty, but, again, I told Mr. BAN Ki-Moon: be careful, a 4000-page document would not ensure the certainty of perfect readability on a universal level. We can also imagine independently of that and the treaty, a solemn political commitment of a few pages with figures and timelines. This is a very personal idea; I do not say it will be retained, but we will have time for negotiation.

I also think that we will not escape a meeting whose form will need to be determined between New York and Copenhagen if we want to reach an agreement. There is a lot of work to be done.

QUESTION - A question on another subject. The American President has just officially announced his decision to change his view on the missile shield, to stop the Bush-style missile shield and to install a new, more mobile one. What do you think about that?

THE PRESIDENT - It is an excellent decision. In every respect. And I hope our Russian friends will attach the importance that this decision has. I have believed for a long time, especially since we talked about it together in Evian, that between the Russians, Europe, and the United States, we have a vast common security space to organize. Not against each other, but with each other. So President OBAMA’s decision is an extremely wise decision. I say what I think, really, not at all because it could play a role in domestic politics in the Czech Republic or Poland; I do not get involved in that at all, but I find that from the perspective of our relations between Europe and Russia, between Russia, Europe, and the United States, it is extremely positive.

I have always been convinced that we need a European Defense. I respect the national decision of the Czechs and Poles, but I find that on decisions of this nature, it is always interesting to discuss them before making the decision.

QUESTION - A question perhaps on a file that concerns both Europe and the United States, it is Opel. Have you talked about it, and what is your personal position on it? It is said that Angela MERKEL could somehow play the German card against, for example, Belgium where we are, or for example Spain. What is your position?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, we have not talked about it. Secondly, as you know, I support Ms. MERKEL’s actions. I do not know the file well, so I would not want to make definitive statements, but I remember very well that when I proposed on behalf of France the first automotive support plan, there was a chorus of criticism about a supposed protectionism of France and its president. And then once that outcry passed, which lasted two days, all the countries did the same thing we did, and I can tell you an anecdote: the Romanian president came to see me to tell me how happy he was with Renault’s establishment in Romania and how well the Renault factories in Romania were functioning. And I told him: “you know that this is probably linked to the 3 billion euros we made available to the Renault group.” And today no one says that the French automotive plan is a protectionist plan. So let’s give Ms. MERKEL time to develop the Opel plan.

One last question?

QUESTION - Mr. President, you were talking earlier about future sanctions against tax havens. A lot of cleaning has been done in Europe since London. There has been relatively little, if any, done in Asia. Very few concessions from Singapore, Hong Kong, Macao; does this imbalance concern you?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, we will not accept it, but do you know why there is this imbalance, Sir? For a rather simple reason. It is that a number of Asian countries are not members of the OECD, which set the rules. And that was a whole problem, Sir, in London, because they told me: “you want to join the list of tax havens as defined by the OECD, an organization we do not participate in.” The argument had some force, but the sanctions apply regardless of where in the world you are, and notably there is one criterion, it is the twelve conventions to be signed for the exchange of tax information with twelve partners. Those who do not do this, it is very simple, they will be on the blacklist of tax havens.

Moreover, we can perfectly imagine that if Europe does not equip itself with sufficiently strong legislation, that we in France tell our banking institutions that we do not want them to have subsidiaries in tax havens. And do not come to me saying that it is a competitiveness problem. At some point, we must be coherent and a bit willing. France has not waged the battle against tax havens that it has waged to allow its banks to have subsidiaries located in non-cooperative jurisdictions that would persist.

We also had a report from Prime Minister Brian COWEN; I really commend his courage, on the referendum of October 2, we will see, but for now it seems to be going rather well. We had an explanation from the Czech Prime Minister, who is also a man of great quality, about the situation in the Czech Republic, and I clearly stated that if the Irish answered yes, it was out of the question that we would accept to remain in artistic ambiguity with a Europe that would not have the institutions it deserves in a full crisis. And therefore we would need to draw the consequences from that. What consequences? That will be the subject of a future meeting.

Good evening, thank you very much.