Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on economic convergence within the Eurozone and on the European Union in light of the political situation in Egypt, in Brussels on February 4, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

4 February 2011 · Press conference on economic convergence within the Eurozone and the European Union · Brussels, Belgium

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference at the EU Council in Brussels on February 4, 2011, following a European Council meeting on eurozone integration and the Egyptian crisis.
Main themes
Eurozone economic policy convergence, competitiveness pact, EU integration, Egypt political transition, press freedom and human rights, eurozone summits, Franco-German leadership, democratic transition in Egypt, EU member state coordination
Duration
~19 min
64th percentile
Words
2,323
64th percentile
Sentences
112
68th percentile
Readability
56
78th percentile
Grade
10.3
24th percentile
Syntax
3.02
50th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

112 sentences in 46 paragraphs

THE PRESIDENT -- Ladies and gentlemen, I apologize for making you wait and for working late on a Friday evening, but this was truly an extremely important meeting that allowed us to reach the end of our reasoning.

The decisions that have been made are a process. Final decisions will be made in March. But already, what has been agreed upon?

It has been agreed that the member countries of the eurozone must further integrate their economic policies. This will be reflected in proposals that will be made by President VAN ROMPUY as early as March. This is a structural response to the problems that the eurozone has faced.

The second thing that has been agreed upon is the idea that issues related to the euro and its future should be addressed within the framework of a meeting of the heads of state and government of the eurozone.

What has been agreed upon? The idea that we need a pact to strengthen our convergence and our competitiveness. Who does this pact concern? First and foremost, the member countries of the eurozone. But non-eurozone countries that wish to join this pact and participate in it will be able to do so.

In other words, to simplify, there will be three types of meetings: strict euro-related issues will be addressed by seventeen, within the framework of meetings of the heads of government and heads of state of the eurozone, or of course within the framework of their group of finance ministers.

Issues related to the competitiveness pact will be addressed in a framework that I would call "seventeen plus," meaning all those who wish to join this pact.

And of course, there will be meetings of the European Council with twenty-seven.

In March, the decision was made to convene a summit of the heads of state and government of the eurozone to address these issues, independently of the European Council that is to be held in March. There you go, I cannot tell you the exact date, but that is the decision that has been made.

This is therefore an extremely important step that has been taken, which will be definitively taken in March when we agree on the exact content of the convergence pact for competitiveness. As you know, Ms. MERKEL and I have worked a lot on this issue, we have ideas on this matter, and to gather the maximum number of states around these ideas, we have chosen not to put a paper on the table and to ask President VAN ROMPUY, based on the ideas we have conveyed to him, to gather the greatest consensus, and we will decide in March.

And then we had a long discussion about the situation in Egypt, which led to an unambiguous statement from the twenty-seven Europeans. In this statement, we strongly condemn the violations of press rights, the freedom to inform, and the threats that have been made or committed against journalists. These behaviors and threats are unacceptable. The twenty-seven Europeans also expressed their support for the Egyptian people in their aspiration for freedom, respect for human rights, and the establishment of an authentic democratic life in Egypt. And we hope that this democratic transition will be organized with great serenity.

If you have any questions for me, I will be happy to answer them.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, "Departure Friday," "Departure Day," that is how the demonstration that continues to take place today in Cairo has been dubbed. Do you also believe that this should be the day of President MUBARAK's departure? Do you consider that the very rapid transition you are calling for is compatible with his remaining at the head of the Egyptian state?

THE PRESIDENT -- We have condemned, I unequivocally condemn all violations of human rights, violations of press freedom. From this point of view, I was shocked by what happened to journalists, regardless of their nationality, in Cairo yesterday and the day before. The threats against the press are unacceptable and indefensible.

Secondly, the democratic aspirations of the Egyptian people must be met.

As for the rest, I am not Egyptian, and it is certainly not for me to say who should take responsibility, when, and how. What matters is that the democratic transition takes place without delay. And the Egyptians will have to lead this movement sovereignly.

I am not convinced that we, who are not Egyptians, should intervene in the timing, the modalities, or the personalities who might lead this process.

We condemn violence, we condemn what has happened without any ambiguity, we want a democratic process without delay, and we leave it to the Egyptians to determine who should lead it and how.

QUESTION -- Regarding journalists, perhaps not harassment, but intimidation apparently continues today. Do you think we need to go a bit further than a simple statement -- which is already a statement -- but to take perhaps stronger diplomatic gestures, such as summoning Egyptian ambassadors with the twenty-seven?

THE PRESIDENT -- Listen, what has happened is unacceptable. And if this were to continue, it would have serious consequences for the relations we could have with any country that would allow such behavior towards journalists, regardless of their nationality.

QUESTION -- How do you assess the Islamist risk in Egypt and the rise to power of the Muslim Brotherhood? What risk of contagion do you see, in your opinion, for the countries of the Arabian Peninsula, particularly the most democratic among them, if we can speak of that? And another question, excuse me, I return to Europe. No, you don't want to? We'll ask it later.

THE PRESIDENT -- No, I didn't say anything.

First of all, how do I assess? I am not Egyptian, I would have a hard time assessing anything. I simply say that the reasoning that would consist of refusing a democratic process solely on the grounds that there is a risk it could turn bad in terms of extremism is not a reasoning that can be acceptable. The risk always exists. But we cannot refuse a democratic aspiration because there is a risk. However, there are examples in history where it has turned out badly; I think of Iran. But can we prevent democratic expression on the grounds that there is this risk? I think not.

Is there a risk of contagion? We are already there, if I judge by what has happened in Tunisia and what has happened in Egypt, even if comparison is not reason. Again, can we condemn a democratic aspiration on the grounds that there is this risk? No.

I am trying to answer you as sincerely as possible, and at the same time, I see well -- and you have seen a number of statements about foreign interference -- I see well that if we sincerely support this democratic aspiration of the Egyptian people, as well as the Tunisian people, we must adhere to very clearly and firmly stated and defended principles and resist the temptation -- which can be understood -- of interference that would then turn against all those who aspire to authentic Egyptian democracy. Because you know the history of these countries and the sensitivity of these issues.

You see what I mean, the firmer we are on these principles, the more I think we must resist the temptation not to go further in defending the principles, on the contrary, but sometimes to name the principles that, at that moment, would make certain political figures in these countries appear as being supported by foreigners. And you know very well that this has happened many times in the past and that it has not always led to the right solution.

Nevertheless, if the intimidation and violence against peaceful protesters and against journalists -- who, after all, represent a symbol, that of the freedom to inform -- were to persist, we could not accept it.

Regarding Europe, I did not hear, well, or retain your question, excuse me.

QUESTION -- Regarding Europe, I would like to know if you have gone into detail about the requests made by Ms. MERKEL, that is to say: how to overcome the Irish veto on a reduction or a minimum rate, pardon, of corporate tax? And how to overcome what is dear to the Belgians: the indexing of wages to inflation, knowing that the French also have, with the SMIC, a de facto indexing to inflation?

THE PRESIDENT -- As you know, regarding France, we were completely indexed a few years ago. Fortunately, we have moved away from that. The only indexing that remains is indeed that of the SMIC, which we will keep.

But the idea that Ms. MERKEL and I have is not to impose the same thing on everyone. I take the example of pensions; it is not about imposing the same retirement age for everyone, even though in Europe we do not all have the same life expectancy criteria, the same demographic expectations. However, we can agree on a calculation method that would link the number of years of contributions required to retire with the evolution of life expectancy. That is something we can perfectly do.

Regarding the corporate tax of our Irish friends, it is not about denying specificities, but let us at least agree, so that comparisons are possible, on a base, on a tax base that would be the same and perhaps move towards convergence.

Convergence does not mean absolute identity; convergence means moving towards comparisons, towards rapprochements, instead of moving towards divergences.

I add that it was not about today, as you noted, making decisions, well, making detailed decisions, but displaying a will, a pact, an economic government, a convergence.

Herman VAN ROMPUY, assisted by Mr. BARROSO, will lead these negotiations in the coming weeks, and from that moment on, we will see what the endpoint will be. There is no rigidity. I myself had the opportunity to say, through one of my collaborators, that we did not agree with all the ideas that were put forward and that it was not a drama.

We agree on the principles: an economic government, a convergence, an integration of economic policies, meetings of the eurozone for euro-related issues, open eurozone meetings for competitiveness pact issues. There you go.

A lot has already been done today; it is extremely important. Remember the debates a year ago. A year or a year and a half ago, the term "economic government" was a term that I believe I was the only one to pronounce.

QUESTION -- Mr. President, I return to Egypt. From the evening of your election, you mentioned the importance of the Mediterranean. You launched the Union for the Mediterranean in 2008. In light of the events in Tunisia and Egypt, do you say that this union, which is also mentioned, I believe, in the conclusions, is the method to follow and that it needs to be relaunched, or on the contrary, was it not a good approach?

THE PRESIDENT -- It is not by chance that the Union for the Mediterranean, for which France has fought so hard, is expressly mentioned in the statement. I believe that in light of this situation, not only is the Union for the Mediterranean necessary, but it is essential, even if we will probably have to wait for the situation to stabilize a bit.

Just as France considers it absolutely essential that the peace process be relaunched between Israelis and Palestinians for the definition of two states. And in receiving the Palestinian Prime Minister yesterday, I indicated to him how happy France would be to organize a donors' conference on the express condition that there be a political dimension. We can see how the persistence of this conflict, the stagnation on the issue of Israel's security and a Palestinian state complicates a region that is already in a very eruptive situation.

QUESTION -- Ms. ASHTON is expected to go to Egypt in the next two weeks. What will her mandate be? Since this is also the baptism of fire, ultimately, for the new European diplomatic service, what do you say to Yves LETERME, who said this morning that Ms. ASHTON does not have sufficient political space to express herself? In short, in other words, are you restraining Ms. ASHTON, the major capitals?

THE PRESIDENT -- Yes, I understood that this was not a personal message. Ms. ASHTON has a mandate that has been defined by the statement of this European Council, and I am sure she will carry it out successfully. The conception I have of Europe is not that twenty-seven heads of state and government should remain silent because we are fortunate to have Ms. ASHTON. It is that Ms. ASHTON speaks on our collective behalf and that each of us can contribute our modest added value when needed. There are certain countries in the European Union that know certain Arab countries better than others.

No, no, she has the political space. She is being restrained all the less since she has by her side as her main collaborator a highly qualified Frenchman in the person of Mr. VIMONT, who is the highest diplomat behind Ms. ASHTON, which has been a victory for French diplomacy.

QUESTION -- Do you feel that behind the organized violence against journalists and pro-MOUBARAK demonstrators, there were orders given by the Egyptian President himself since some of the "rioters" had police cards?

THE PRESIDENT -- I don't know, but if this violence and intimidation against journalists were to persist, we would have the answer. We would have the answer to know whether it is a detestable but spontaneous movement or if it is a detestable and organized movement. Time will tell us that. Either it stops because the authorities wish it, decide it, and in that case, we would be pleased, or it continues, in which case we could not accept it.

Thank you all and good evening.