Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the European Union's response to the rise in fuel prices and on the negative vote of the Irish regarding the Lisbon Treaty, in Brussels on June 20, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

20 June 2008 · Press conference on the European Union's response to rising fuel prices and the Irish vote on the Lisbon Treaty · Brussels

Context
Sarkozy held a press conference at the European Council in Brussels on June 20, 2008, addressing fuel price rises and Ireland's rejection of the Lisbon Treaty.
Main themes
Irish rejection of the Lisbon Treaty, European response to rising fuel prices, oil price speculation and taxation, EU ratification process, French EU presidency priorities, raw material price increases, VAT and proportional taxation, European immigration pact, climate-energy package, EU defense policy, European Council consensus
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,726
90th percentile
Sentences
264
94th percentile
Readability
62
91st percentile
Grade
8.9
10th percentile
Syntax
2.81
23rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

264 sentences in 54 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, good evening. I am open to your questions.

Q - Mr. President, what is the status of Europe's response to the rise in fuel prices?

R - We had a long discussion, not just about the rise in fuel prices, but about the rise in raw material prices in general, particularly agricultural prices. There is a common point, which is an analysis of the seriousness of the situation. All countries are fully aware that the oil shock is of an unprecedented magnitude compared to the three previous oil shocks, particularly those of the 1970s. Each country is well aware of this. Each country is also aware that something must be done to provide a European response. Regarding the responses to be provided, there is a range of solutions: discussions with producing countries, the need for transparency to avoid speculation, the desire to understand how this oil market works, questioning whether the term "oil market" is accurate, given the major dysfunctions whose consequences are observed here and there, the desire to combat speculation, France's tax proposal, and thus, all of this is the subject of a broad consensus.

The President of the Commission proposed to work on this range of measures, including taxation, to report back in October. That is where we concluded the discussion. We concluded it, and there are still a number of speakers, so decisions have not been made, but this was the subject of a two-hour or two-and-a-half-hour discussion this afternoon, before we went to dinner to talk about institutional issues. That is where we stand.

Q - Regarding the tax proposals, did you feel supported by your colleagues and by the Commission?

R - It was President Barroso himself who proposed to conduct a study on the consequences of taxation. Prime Minister Zapatero indicated that, given the seriousness of the situation, it would be foolish to rule out a measure a priori. Explicitly referring to this, the Austrian Chancellor also said how much he shared my analysis. This does not mean that he agreed with the tax proposal, but he said that solutions needed to be found. I myself used the following argument: it is not about lowering taxes on oil, but if oil prices continue to rise, it still raises the issue of proportional taxation.

The difference between the TIPP and VAT is very simple. The TIPP is a tax on volumes. Due to the rising cost of oil, volumes tend to decrease. Reducing the TIPP makes no sense. VAT is a tax on prices. Everyone can understand that taking 20% VAT on a barrel at $42 - which was the case in 2004 - and on a barrel at $139 or $140 today is not the same thing. I did not ask for an immediate decision, but at least for the consequences of proportional taxation on prices to be studied in light of the exponential rise in oil prices. I cannot tell you that this is the decision that will be made. But the proposal made by the Commission at the beginning of the meeting is this one. In the discussion we had, there is a common will among European leaders to move forward. Some countries are indeed opposed to touching taxation; I am thinking particularly of Sweden, which is perfectly within its rights. The discussion continues in a fairly constructive atmosphere.

Q - Ireland, Mr. President. Is there unanimity in the European Council to continue the ratification process? It seems that the Czechs were particularly reluctant this evening. What is the situation?

R - That was the agenda for dinner. What can we say at this point? First, that there is a desire not to dramatize the situation, even if we clearly need to take into account the Irish no. And so the idea would be as follows: that our Irish friends report to the European Council in October on the evolution of the situation to set a definitive strategy, that by then, as of July, in my capacity as the rotating presidency of the Union, I go to Ireland to discuss with the Irish government and, perhaps, other interlocutors to try to understand and find solutions to prepare for the October Council.

There is a common will among the twenty-seven states to ask the incoming presidency and the French presidency to be ambitious about the objectives so that Europe does not fall back into a period of stagnation and thus to advance, in a very proactive manner, on the French priorities: European pact on immigration, the climate-energy package, defense policy. There is really a desire to show that, notwithstanding the institutional difficulties, no one wants to remain, so to speak, paralyzed, immobile. And so, this is both a difficulty for the French presidency, but it can also be an opportunity. In any case, this is the message that all Europeans have sent.

Even if we do not state a timeline, because it is appropriate not to pressure anyone, there is no need to exacerbate a divide; we must try to reduce it. In any case, everyone knows that there is a deadline, which is the next European elections. We must be ready, if only so that each country knows how many deputies there will be. Furthermore, even if it is not explicitly stated, it is certain that as long as the institutional problem is not resolved, the issue of enlargement is effectively halted de jure or de facto. We are not going to continue an enlargement when we cannot find a solution among twenty-seven. That would not be reasonable.

There is a particular difficulty with our Czech friends. I hope we can resolve it by tomorrow morning. The Czech Prime Minister has expressed euroscepticism in his country. He has asked us for time. We are currently discussing with him the drafting of the final communiqué, everyone being well aware that it is necessary to confine the problem to Ireland and that all other countries continue the ratification process.

As you know, in the Czech Republic, it is the decision of the Constitutional Court that is expected to render its decision, I believe in September or October, and so that is a difficulty for them.

Otherwise, all other countries, following the decision of Great Britain, have expressed their intention to continue the ratification of the Lisbon Treaty; this is the case for Cyprus, for Sweden, for Spain, and of course for Italy. That is the situation at the moment as I speak to you.

Poland has ratified. The president's signature is still needed. I do not think that poses a problem; well, let us be cautious, but I do not think so.

Q - In the debate with Ireland, will it be possible to question the issue of the Commission and that each country still has a commissioner?

R - If there is no ratification of Lisbon, we revert to Nice, and at that point, we find ourselves in the situation feared by Ireland.

Q - There is no agreement on the method...

R - As President of the Union, at the request of the Irish Prime Minister, I will go to Ireland, I will listen, I will engage in dialogue, and I will take note.

Q - To return to oil, as a political weapon this time, President Chavez threatens to suspend oil deliveries to European countries that would apply the famous "return" directive. What is your reaction?

R - Frankly, I have a lot of problems to manage. Honestly, that is quite enough. So, on this issue of oil, all the ideas that are on the table, France adopts them. I mean the necessity of transparency, the fight against speculation, the desire to discuss with producing countries, the need to save energy, to promote electric cars, to develop nuclear energy, and to question taxation. There you go, the Commission is very proactive in finding the best solutions, which is good. What did I want? I wanted there to be a European response to this issue, that the Commission explore all possible avenues, without taboos. I hope we are heading in that direction, and that is very good.

After all the problems of producing countries, there is the one you mentioned, and there are many others. There is Nigeria, which needs help to achieve internal peace so that it can produce the oil the world needs. There is Angola, which needs help to develop so that it can also provide the oil we need. On that front, believe me, there are multiple concerns. What matters in all this? It is that Europeans understand that Europe protects them and that we try to have a European reaction to a problem that concerns us all. And everyone understands that we will be stronger together than if each one reasons and reflects and tries to act on their own. Obviously, the Irish issue does not simplify matters, but it is there. And I try to use it as an additional argument to convince our partners to act concretely while we confine the institutional problem to the Irish question.

Q - I have a question about taxation or energy, because we have a report from the Commission in October, so what does that push back to? To 2009? Do you hope to have something by the end of 2008?

R - You are a specialist in Europe. Already, if we obtain proposals from the Commission in October, while we are almost in the second half of June, it means that we will have decided in Europe relatively quickly compared to what we have experienced. Frankly, I would have liked to request the report for August, but that is not the method. I am not going to say that to you.

So now, there is a Council - that is the tradition - in October. I am willing to hold it in September, but from that point on, we will see what the price of oil will be, and we will make the decision at that time. I add that France is rather well positioned, having launched a major nuclear program. I also add that it seems to me to be an asset for every European country to understand that we need to move forward with the ratification of the climate and energy directive as quickly as possible. There you go, I try to turn all European difficulties into an asset. From the Irish difficulty, a desire to move faster on immigration. From the explosion in oil prices, a necessity to ratify the Commission's proposal on the energy and climate package. What does it say? That we need to develop renewable energy, nuclear energy, and energy savings. That is exactly France's position.

Q - Have you discussed with your counterparts the need to move towards greater coordination of your policy towards China so that when you go to Beijing in August - you reserve your answer, but it seems very likely that this trip will take place - on that occasion, you truly embody, as President of Europe, a position that is genuinely common to the twenty-seven?

R - Listen, frankly, we did not talk about it because we did not have the time. And you know, I believe we need to respond to urgent matters, and the urgency is oil - well, the price of raw materials, particularly oil - and the institutional question. And to be honest, I did not wish - and I told my partners - that we dedicate ourselves to anything else. We are not going to scatter either. It is true that it is a very important question, I fully acknowledge that, but it seems to me that finding a response to the Irish question and trying to bring the other twenty-six into a ratification process, even giving them time - I think of the Czechs - seemed more important to me. I add that we will have the summit on the 13th and 14th, which will also be an opportunity to talk. It is not on the agenda, but we can discuss it, at least informally, and then there is the phone, but it seemed to me that the priority was still to provide an Irish response. I must say that the Irish Prime Minister is a courageous man, very frank, who described the situation to us quite clearly.

Q - We have heard a number of irritated comments from the French side regarding the European Commission lately, both regarding the issue of fisheries management and its possible co-responsibility in the Irish no. I would like to know if, in your view, President Barroso is a good candidate to succeed himself.

R - You started with the Commission and you arrive at Barroso! Well, listen, it is very easy to attack the Commission, to find a scapegoat, which is the Commission. I have never participated in that, I have never done that, and I certainly will not do it today, whatever it may cost me otherwise. To reduce the Irish problem today, the Dutch problem yesterday, the French problem yesterday, to the sole question of the Commission is to make a totally erroneous analysis of the political situation in Europe.

I have always thought that he was an excellent president of the Commission. The Irish debate focused on abortion, euthanasia, whether or not to have a European commissioner, taxation, the WTO, agriculture, and we cannot attribute that to Mr. Barroso. No, choose someone else, better yet, Mandelson, for example.

No, but honestly, you are specialists, you have followed the Irish debate, the issue of the WTO was clearly raised in the Irish debate, in the clearest way, it is a reality. Moreover, I must say on this issue that it would be totally implausible for us to continue wanting to negotiate an agreement where we have obtained nothing on services, nothing on industry, everyone absolutely agrees, and which would lead to a 20% reduction in agricultural production in a world where 800 million people are dying of hunger. There is a child dying of hunger every 30 seconds, and we would go to negotiate within the framework of the WTO a 20% reduction in European agricultural production. Frankly, there is one person who thinks that way, and that is Mr. Mandelson, and that is not France's position. I say it as clearly as possible that on these bases, for us, it is no. If we want to exacerbate the Irish crisis, we just need to keep piling on and continue with a totally unbalanced agreement at the WTO. That is really counterproductive.

Q - You just told us a moment ago that the Czech Prime Minister was asking for time this evening. Does that clearly mean that he intends to postpone the ratification schedule? Do you think that regarding oil, the promise of a report from the Commission in October is likely to reassure the eurosceptics who are demonstrating, and they are quite numerous at the moment?

R - We cannot say that they have only been eurosceptics since the price of oil has increased. We cannot also place all the sins of creation on Europe. We are asking for a report. The TIPP is a tax on volumes, VAT is a tax on prices. In a market economy for all products, prices fall and the base increases. And it is precisely because we are selling more and more products that prices are falling. It turns out that we are facing a phenomenon with oil that is totally contrary to the principle of a market economy. Here is a product whose quantity tends to decrease relative to demand and whose price is increasing exponentially. This is also completely erratic compared to the usual rules of a market economy. Since the tax based on VAT is proportional, the question that arises in front of a movement that is totally unprecedented in its scope is: should we keep the same proportional tax? Taking three months to reflect on this question seems reasonable to me. I was the first to raise the question of this taxation, and it is reasonable that we study its consequences. This is not something that can be decided just like that.

Furthermore, we will then need to agree on the price level from which we can consider this. The decision has not been made, but I am very happy that it continues and even prospers. Given the completely blocked, negative reactions when I proposed this idea, I am satisfied that it is progressing and that we are not being told: "move along, there is nothing to see." No one is saying that, except for one or two countries. They can see that there is a problem. It is not the same to take 20% tax on a barrel at 140 dollars as it is to take 20% tax on a barrel at 42. I am not saying that this solves all the problems for consumers, but at least it would be a European response to a phenomenon that will need to be controlled, one way or another.

Q - Regarding Ireland, is there any other solution than having the Irish vote again? Are you considering any other solution than that, or is that the only option in the end?

R - Listen, frankly, I cannot answer that question because answering it would be taking sides. A sitting president of the Union, which I will be in a few days, must try to bring everyone together. The message I would like to convey to you is this: "Europe is twenty-seven countries, and I will do everything I can to ensure that the family is united and that all twenty-seven follow." That is what I think, that is the message I want to convey, that is the message we are fighting for. Will it be possible without a vote? You are informed enough yourself to understand that asking the question is answering it. But it is not me who wants to answer it, because seven days after a referendum that had this level of participation and this score, to say that complicates the task rather than trying to resolve it, and I want to try to resolve it.

Q - What interpretation does the Irish Prime Minister make of his citizens' rejection of the treaty?

R - He has said very clearly that this does not, in his view, manifest a desire of the Irish to leave Europe but rather the expression of multiple fears, justified or not, which led to a majority for the no vote. In the same way, when there was a no vote in France or a no in the Netherlands, there were multiple reasons; one cannot say that there was only one. And I am not convinced that they are all related to the Lisbon Treaty, to put it plainly. Because, for example, regarding Ireland's neutrality, the Lisbon Treaty did not challenge it. We are not going to redo the campaign now. The campaign took place, and precisely, if I want to respond positively to the invitation of the Irish Prime Minister, it is to try to understand and see, by October, still October, but that is the community calendar. When you are twenty-seven countries, you have to take a little time to agree to find solutions to ease Irish fears, so that Ireland continues, of course, in the European family. This may seem disappointing to you, but at the same time, Europe has been built through a succession of crises. And it would be so easy to give up. We cannot give up. We must continue to move forward, so what do we decide? We will move forward together, we will continue to work, we will even accelerate on concrete files because it is the French Presidency, and we will try to find a solution to the institutional crisis. So as not to fall back into 10 years of paralysis. That is what we are trying to do. Believe me, I would like it to be easier. But that is how it is. And then it falls on the French Presidency; honestly, we have to work hard.

Q - Mr. President, the European foreign ministers decided this evening to lift sanctions on Cuba. Could you perhaps give us some details? Is it unilateral? Is it definitive, or does it depend on Raúl Castro?

R - Bernard, you are the foreign minister...

R - Mr. Kouchner - The sanctions, we did not lift them; they were already lifted. Every year, we repeated this lifting of sanctions, which dates back, if I am not mistaken, to 2004. We have come to an agreement. There is a text, and indeed, we are going to give a chance to what we have called with difficulty the liberalization of the Cuban regime. We have given it a chance knowing that, if you heard Barack Obama's speech on this matter, we are less liberal than he is. There you go, we did it. After a discussion and some amendments on a text that may be very, too optimistic.

Q - I do not quite understand the difference between after 2005 and today, after the Irish no. That is to say, back then, we also said we would take a pause for reflection on institutional issues and that we would focus on concrete Europe. At that time, the priority was climate change and other priorities compared to today, even if climate change is still a priority. So what is the difference, apart from the French Presidency that will begin in 10 days?

Second question: this morning, the Italian Prime Minister, Silvio Berlusconi, while analyzing the vote in Ireland, regretted the time when there was a group of people with Jacques Chirac, Tony Blair, Aznar, even if he was not there two years ago, and himself. Do you have any reactions to that?

R - No. I am learning on this occasion about the excellent relations between Silvio Berlusconi and Jacques Chirac. I find that very nice. So that was the axis, then! It was not worth making such a fuss with me. No, I have none, and what difference is there compared to 2005? Listen, in 2005, we tried, more precisely I, in 2006 and then in 2007, to draw the consequences of what happened in France and the Netherlands by adapting a simplified treaty that tried to retain what had reached a consensus and to try to provide a response. I believe that there is not a single head of state or government who is today ready or willing to engage in a new institutional negotiation. It is quite clear. There will be no other institutional convention or other treaty. From that moment on, it is either Lisbon - we will see what response we can provide to our Irish friends - or we go back to Nice. But Nice means no more enlargement, it means a Commission that needs to be completely revised, and it means European elections that become extremely difficult to organize, a reduced Parliament. Everyone can see that the most reasonable solution is to try to provide answers to the concerns of the Irish or Czechs, but to remain within a stable institutional framework. That is quite a big difference, sir, compared to 2005. In 2005, they left with great ambition, to create a constitution that would lead to a federal Europe. We are not in that case with the simplified treaty. We take into account the refusal of a number of countries. We considered that we needed to simply establish a rule of functioning.

Now, we have this difficulty, and we need to try to overcome it. It will be up to the French Presidency to manage things as best as possible, especially since, as I told our Czech friends, the Czech Presidency follows. Our Czech friends also need to think about that. They will have the Presidency. For the Presidency, we must lead everyone and have the most consensual position possible. That is why I absolutely want to go to Ireland, to try to find ways and means to provide a response to Irish concerns, without opening an institutional debate. All the other countries are in favor of continuing the ratification process. However, we need a French Presidency that is not paralyzed by these institutional questions.

I would add that there are not only bad news, because there is the ratification by Great Britain. I remember when we reached an agreement in Brussels, Bernard Kouchner remembers it as does Jean-Pierre Jouyet, everyone said that the problem would be Great Britain. Great Britain ultimately ratified with a lot of courage and without immense problems.

I would add that the issue of enlargement is very important. A number of countries that have some reservations about the Lisbon Treaty are the most enthusiastic about enlargement. But without the Lisbon Treaty, there will be no enlargement.

Q - Will Croatia be included?

R - I remind you that, for enlargement, unanimity is required. I would find it very curious that Europe, with twenty-seven members, has difficulty agreeing on functioning institutions but manages to agree to add a 28th, a 29th, a 30th, a 31st, just to be sure that things go worse. You know, I was among those who thought it would have been wise at the time to reform the institutions before proceeding with enlargement. I was completely in favor of enlargement, but everyone can see what it has cost Europe not to reform the institutions before enlargement. If it is to repeat the same mistake, I really do not see the point. I add that this is a powerful motivating factor for the ratification of the Lisbon Treaty. One cannot say that one does not want new institutions but wants enlargement. No, Lisbon allows for enlargement. No Lisbon, no enlargement. This seems to me to be a quite reasonable position. I would like to point out that this is what 99% of you have continuously written. We would have been better off reforming the institutions before enlarging. I would not want to be told now that it would be logical to continue enlargement while we have an institutional problem, if we are Europeans. In any case, I am and I remain. As President of the Union, I will try to ensure that the whole family moves towards unity. If the only thing is a headlong rush towards enlargement without even asking the questions of functioning, that would not be reasonable. This has nothing to do with Croatia or anyone else. I am among those who believe that Europe must expand to the Balkans for reasons of stability. But we need to have institutions to welcome newcomers. I believe this is a message that is widely shared by many people.

Q - Do you think that a referendum is the right method to address this issue?

R - That is why I did not propose it myself during my campaign. Thank you for following my campaign. It was even a theme. I had said with a certain courage: I do not think one can respond with a yes or no to an institutional treaty that had 7 articles but about forty pages. I am not sure that this is the most suitable procedure.

It happens that regarding our Irish friends, it is not a political choice. It is the choice of their Constitutional Court. We cannot blame them for that. As for me, I campaigned saying that if I were elected, I would not hold a referendum on European institutions. I did not lie. I try to be consistent, to be constant.

Q - A supplementary question on energy: do you think you can obtain Germany's support for your proposal to cap VAT?

R - No, it is not a question of Germany's support. We will see what is decided tomorrow. I have requested the principle of a study. We will have to work hard to convince about a tax proportional to prices with prices that are skyrocketing. That would still be a question. For our German friends to be enthusiastic, it would be a lie to say that. If we had to wait for them to be enthusiastic, it is not obvious. See you tomorrow. Good night. Thank you.