Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the first stable President of the European Council, the High Representative for Foreign Affairs, the members of the European Commission, and the Copenhagen Summit on climate, in Brussels on November 19, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

19 November 2009 · Press conference on the first stable President of the European Council and the Copenhagen Summit on climate · Brussels

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference in Brussels on November 19, 2009, following the EU summit that appointed the first permanent European Council President and High Representative.
Main themes
European Council permanent presidency, Herman Van Rompuy appointment, Catherine Ashton as High Representative, EU institutional reform, Lisbon Treaty implementation, European Commission leadership, Copenhagen climate summit, European political balance, EU founding principles
Duration
~44 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,314
92nd percentile
Sentences
272
94th percentile
Readability
64
94th percentile
Grade
8.7
8th percentile
Syntax
2.88
31st percentile
Vocabulary
1.95
6th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

272 sentences in 54 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I am pleased to see you again. Europe is putting an end this evening to a long institutional process; I do not think I am mistaken in saying that it has been eight years now that Europe has been trying to establish its institutions. I will not go back over the long twists and turns of the so-called "Lisbon Treaty."

This evening, very quickly, the 27 heads of state and government have agreed to designate Herman VAN ROMPUY, the Belgian Prime Minister, as the first stable president of the European Council for two and a half years. This is a choice that, in my eyes, is excellent. Excellent because he is a man of very high quality whose proactive positions at the Council table I have always appreciated. He is a man who has shown great skill regarding Belgium, and that is a problem, by the way, since he will have to leave his position as Belgian Prime Minister. He is a deeply European man, and I believe it is a very wise decision to have chosen as the first stable president of the Council a man from a founding country of the European Union, from an important country, but one that is not among the most important, so that no one feels excluded from the process— a man who is accustomed to compromise, in the best sense of the term, which is the basis of the functioning of European institutions.

We will need to establish these institutions. You know that France supported Herman VAN ROMPUY's candidacy and even pushed a bit for Herman to be a candidate from the very beginning. It is an excellent choice. Just as we were able to unanimously designate Catherine ASHTON as High Representative and Vice-President of the Commission. Here too, I think it is an important choice. First of all, because it is important that there is a woman in the key positions at the head of the European Union; I had read many articles, many positions that were concerned that there were only men. It is also important because it gives, even if it is not the political formations that should designate these positions, there is a balance: Herman VAN ROMPUY is from the European People's Party, Catherine ASHTON, who is a European Commissioner, comes from the Labour family, and I believe it is very important for our British friends that she is an Englishwoman.

Finally, we have designated a third person, since there were three positions for which we had to vote. And the third is a Frenchman, since the Secretary-General will continue, Mr. de BOISSIEU, for the next two years. Why only two years? Simply because that is the retirement age limit. There you go.

So, to the three positions that have been designated, a Belgian, an Englishwoman, a Frenchman, we add a Portuguese, the president of the Commission, and a Pole, the president of the Parliament. I believe this is a date that will count in the history of Europe. And contrary to what some may have feared, it went relatively smoothly, at least quickly.

Of course, I will answer any questions you may wish to ask me.

QUESTION - Mr. President, do you think that Herman VAN ROMPUY and Lady ASHTON...

THE PRESIDENT - ... I have never seen you so respectful of a person, and I congratulate you... so she is from the House of Lords.

QUESTION - ... are capable of negotiating with Barack OBAMA, HU Jintao, or Dmitri MEDVEDEV? What will their exact function be, did you discuss their exact function during this Summit?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, the definition of their functions will be done pragmatically, since we will need to harmonize the stable presidency, the rotating presidency, and the role of the High Representative. I have no doubt. You say: "Are they capable?" In what I have read, pardon me for saying it, but I see many people writing about Herman VAN ROMPUY who do not know him. I can tell you—pardon me, do not take this in an unpleasant way for you—he is an extremely determined man who knows exactly where he is going; he is a perfect connoisseur of European politics.

I am not saying that you are doing this, but why judge before knowing? I really find myself in Herman's convictions; he is a man who knows very well where he is going. And if the criticism that can be made of him is that he is not determined and is too flexible, you risk having some serious surprises, but serious surprises. Do not confuse a tolerant man who has a certain personal reserve, perhaps even a certain modesty, with the convictions that are his. So talk to those who know him well, and you will see. I will tell you one thing; I think he is one of the strongest personalities around the Council table. Do not see any displeasure towards the others.

I add that, as far as I am concerned, I have always thought that a strong president was needed. There were other solutions, notably that of Tony BLAIR, as you know. But to be elected, all 27 must agree. I am convinced that Herman VAN ROMPUY will be able to negotiate and will proudly carry the flag of Europe. And in any case, he will be helped by us too. It is exactly as if you had told me that Prime Minister RASMUSSEN, who will lead the Copenhagen conference, is not capable of doing so? Have you seen the work he is doing? Do you realize? But he does it with us. And I can tell you that the Danish Prime Minister is doing a remarkable job, and I think that in Europe, we need to learn this too: there are different temperaments; that does not mean that they are people without conviction. Frankly, I believe that this is very, very important.

Catherine ASHTON, finally, you know that France has always been in favor of an English solution in this matter, and Labour, because I think that all of this is a balance and that we have every interest in sending the signal to our British friends that they are indeed in Europe, that they count in Europe, and that we need them. Europe is a mosaic; everyone must find their place in it. And I find it quite interesting to take as stable president a candidate from a founding country of Europe and as High Representative a woman from a country that sometimes has more difficulties with Europe. It is a signal that is also sent, a signal of gathering. This way we have the East, we have the West, we have the South, and I will not say that our Belgian friends are the North, but let us say the North Center. But you will see.

And we have also agreed with Herman that he would come to Paris very soon. I look forward to working with him. He is, in any case, someone I have great trust in, great political trust, great personal trust. That is what I think.

QUESTION - (inaudible).

THE PRESIDENT - Yes, yes, that is indeed what I am referring to. It is not at all a choice by default; it is not at all that. Just because we reached a consensus does not mean we are doing so by default. In any case, as you know, he was the candidate of France and the candidate of Germany, since during this entire period, the Chancellor and I have remained on an absolutely, I would not say common line, I would say identical. Without, of course, giving the impression of imposing anything, which is a necessity in Europe.

QUESTION - Now that Mr. BARROSO knows the nationality of his Vice-President, he will be able to form his commission, which has been in caretaker mode for three weeks. Have you discussed with Mr. BARROSO the portfolio that France desires, and if you have any requirements or wishes, what are they?

THE PRESIDENT - First, a word of clarification: the three people we have elected—since the Secretary-General counts, it is not a small matter—will only formally take office as of December 1, which is the date of entry into force of the Treaty. There will be a written procedure.

Listen, if I told you that I had not discussed with Mr. BARROSO, you would not believe me, and you would be perfectly right. Requirements, we do not talk like that among friends; in Europe, I try to be more skillful than that. Let us say that France will have a European Commissioner with important responsibilities, and that this European Commissioner will be Michel BARNIER. It is difficult for me to say more; it is the responsibility of the President of the Commission. We have talked about it, of course, since before the Council, we had many meetings, a meeting with Mrs. MERKEL, a meeting with Mr. REINFELDT, a meeting with Gordon BROWN and Silvio BERLUSCONI; I also saw Mr. BARROSO, which made us start a bit later.

QUESTION - You have said many words about VAN ROMPUY, very few about ASHTON apart from that she was British. What would you have to enrich the portrait of ASHTON and the qualities she has to be High Representative, as her experience in diplomacy...

THE PRESIDENT - Listen, she did play an essential role in the House of Lords in passing the Lisbon Treaty, which is no small feat, you must admit. In the British political personnel, it is not for me to judge, she is one of those who carried the question of the Lisbon Treaty with the most strength. I have already had the opportunity to express my gratitude to Gordon BROWN for the responsibilities he took, but at every moment of the Lisbon process—and you know how fiercely it was debated in the United Kingdom, it is no secret to anyone—she was constantly in favor; she supported it courageously. And we were quite happy to find English women and men politicians to help pass it when part of the British political class was calling for a referendum, as you know just as well as I do.

Moreover, all her colleagues in the Commission have shown a woman turned towards the international, who has dealt a lot with Asian issues, notably negotiations with South Korea. She is someone with great experience and who had the advantage of being Labour, being English, being a woman. You know the choice we made was an extremely complex choice. Do you realize that it was necessary to reach an agreement among 27 countries, heads of state and government from different political families, to find a geographical and political balance, which is no small feat?

For the Representative, unlike the stable President, she is Vice-President of the Commission, so she must pass the test of the European Parliament. We can consider that as of December 1, Herman VAN ROMPUY is definitive. For the High Representative, as for the entire Commission, there is the whole debate in the European Parliament. I do not want to say anything foolish; in this case, what I know is that Lisbon comes into force on December 1, so on December 1, what we have decided in a way orally, we will decide in writing, and from that moment on, I think it will be imposed. I want to pay tribute, by the way, to Javier SOLANA. The choice that has been made has nothing to do with Javier's quality, who, by the way, was not a candidate, but there too we tried to think about a balance, you see. From the moment a Portuguese was President of the Commission, on one of the five positions with the President of the European Parliament and the Secretary-General, putting one of our Spanish friends did not meet the concern for balance that was ours and for gathering.

QUESTION - Mr. President, this is the first time that Europe has engaged in this exercise of nomination...

THE PRESIDENT - Even of election...

QUESTION - Some have denounced this campaign, the opacity, the behind-the-scenes dealings; if you had to do it again, would you proceed in the same way as the Swedes?

THE PRESIDENT - Who denounced it? When we chose the President of the European Parliament, did the same people denounce the conditions that led us to choose the Polish President? The Polish President, when we chose him, did that give rise to a series of hearings? I do not remember that. It is probably a detail that escaped me. Perhaps I missed an episode; I would be surprised, though; I have a certain memory. I was very happy, by the way; I was involved; at that moment, it was necessary to ask the Italian candidate to withdraw; I was one of those who made this approach, and we chose an excellent candidate who was elected by the European Parliament, but everyone knows that within the EPP, there was a discussion; it did not give rise to a hearing. We all considered that, given the quality of the person and that it was important to send a signal to the Eastern Europeans. That is how he was chosen, at least for the first part of the mandate, and no one was unhappy about it. And my friend Donald TUSK did not tell me that it was not democratic enough to choose the Polish President of the European Parliament. Why should it have been done differently?

I would like to add that it is not so simple, and I ask you to understand this well: if we had put ourselves in a situation with several candidates and a vote, we would have divided Europe. Many of you have a European ideal; that is not forbidden. If we had voted among several candidates, there would have been an electoral campaign, a division, and naturally winners and losers, and in the end, we would have ended up with a less united Europe. Europe is an ideal, and we must move forward by consensus. That is European democracy. Why? Because we are talking about sitting prime ministers who return to their countries after being defeated. This is extremely sensitive. I would also add that we have talked a lot, five times, on the phone, with President REINFELDT during this entire period. I have spoken three times with Herman VAN ROMPUY and Mrs. MERKEL. We have talked a lot. This European miracle cannot be treated brutally.

Furthermore, in the European Parliament, when they decide to share the presidency between the EPP and the Socialist Party, what are they doing if not reaching a balanced agreement so that everyone feels recognized? Yes or no, that is how it works. If it is simply arithmetic logic, sir, how does it function? Europe cannot be reduced simply to the Left and the Right; there are other elements at play. It is a very elaborate form of democracy. In my opinion, we cannot contest this need. When the Socialists and the EPP share the presidency for five years, what are they doing? They are making an intelligent gesture, a gesture of tolerance, which considers that for the system to work, even those who have lost must be able to hope to represent the European Parliament to include everyone. That is Europe. That is Europe, and that is why it works, and that is why it is also difficult. Will it be the same in two and a half years, sir? It is much too early to say.

Perhaps we will change methods; perhaps those in place will change methods. Why not? But we cannot see this as an electoral campaign like any other; it is not exactly that.

I would also like to tell you something else: the voice of a country with 700,000 inhabitants for a choice like this counts as much as the voice of a president of a country with 65 million inhabitants. From the outside, one might say that this is not democratic. I believe it is democratic. Because otherwise, the smaller countries would not count in the European ideal. There would be no more Europe. So we are obliged to do it this way. Applying the reasoning of the choice of the campaign in our country at the European level does not work like that. Latvia and Lithuania count just as much in the choice. If there is a blockage with them, we do not move forward. So I know that for the election of the President, it is by majority. But we wanted there to be no losers. Why? Because we all treasure this European ideal.

QUESTION - I would like to understand why you preferred to obtain the position of Commissioner for the Internal Market rather than the position of High Representative? Because in France, there are more qualified diplomatic personalities than Mrs. ASHTON, but you prefer to obtain a Commissioner position; in what way is a Commissioner position more important for France, in your opinion?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, more qualified than Mrs. ASHTON, I would give the same answer... Certainly, I congratulate you on being so nationalist since the mere fact of being French makes one more qualified. I would like to tell you that out of the three positions, one is for France. Do you think I could advocate for two out of three? No, but it is interesting; I will go to the end; I do not want to put you in difficulty. Should I have considered that Mr. de BOISSIEU's candidacy, a remarkable Secretary-General, should be dropped since, naturally, you understand well, if France chose the positions of High Representative, which was obviously possible, it would mean that we would immediately abandon the position of Secretary-General, since who could think that the same country could have, out of the three positions we elected, for which we voted this evening, two? And why do that to Mr. de BOISSIEU, who is unanimously recognized as someone of quality? I would add that it would have seemed particularly strange to deprive ourselves of the experience of a Secretary-General like Mr. de BOISSIEU, especially when we are setting up a system of new institutions. I had this first question; you understand that it is still something.

I would add, independently of that, that with Mrs. MERKEL, we made a choice from the beginning that can be contested, which is that it seemed to us that Germany and France, the two largest countries in Europe - it is not insulting anyone to say so - would do a disservice to Europe if they presented a candidate to be the first stable president or the first Representative, since it would send a very bad signal, given our economic and demographic importance, to the other 25. "So ultimately, these new institutions are for you?" That it evolves in the future, why not? But given the role we play with Mrs. MERKEL, I think it created the conditions for an imbalance and that it would not have allowed the European ideal to be played out in the same way.

As for the rest, regarding the French Commissioner position, it is up to Mr. BARROSO to decide. I believe I can say that we will have an important position. We will see if it is the Internal Market or another, but we will have an important position. I also had this advantage; for France, it is very good; out of the three positions, it is a position of Secretary-General, since Mr. de BOISSIEU is currently Deputy Secretary-General and becomes Secretary-General. For all those who know the European machinery perfectly, it is not a secondary position, even if its media visibility is not of the first choice, of course. Let’s say that all the mechanics behind it count a lot.

QUESTION - So you have chosen three professionals, three experienced personalities, but not necessarily very media-friendly, in any case not very well known to the general public. Do you think that to make Europe loved, you have chosen the right profiles?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, I believe that to make Europe loved, what matters is that we provide very precise answers to the problems that arise. If, for example, we manage to make Copenhagen a success and lead the whole world to the European position, we will make Europe loved. After all, we are not at the point of the universal suffrage election of the European president. We are trying a system that is already a huge progress; we used to change the presidency every six months, and now we have a stable president for two and a half years. Let the system live. We take someone from a country that has Europe in its genes, who has a practice of Europe and who is a man whose personality, convictions... he has demonstrated throughout his past that he is capable of bringing people together around him. I find that it is rather an excellent choice. The proof is that 27 countries have agreed. What else was needed, to reach a blockage, spend a night negotiating, not agree, and find ourselves in 15 days? Would Europe have been strengthened?

QUESTION - On Copenhagen, France has just made public its climate-justice plan. How does this plan fit into the European strategy, or rather what is the added value of this plan in the European strategy? Then very concretely, since you are trying to move the lines with Brazil, with Mexico, and in a few days, the states around the Amazon, how do you move the lines and what do you expect concretely from China and the United States?

THE PRESIDENT - First of all, the French plan is becoming the European plan. I mean that with Mr. RASMUSSEN, we have a total agreement on almost everything, and so that is very important. Our strategy is very simple; we need to engage all of Africa, part of Asia, and all of Europe, and some emerging countries, like Brazil, of course, which has a leading role in this matter. How do we limit warming to two degrees? We know how. There are objectives that need to be specified, and that is what we are fighting for. For me, being next week in Tobago, invited by the Commonwealth to defend alongside Gordon BROWN European positions, who would have said that this would have been possible, even imaginable? No, I see that things are moving.

So clearly, there are two families: the family of those who want an ambitious agreement in Copenhagen, France is a leader with others in this family, and then another family that is a bit less ambitious, as we saw in a recent Asian summit. I read like you. I see that when we meet, we set objectives and precise figures. When others meet, the figures have disappeared. There is a moment of truth; we will have to explain ourselves. And at this moment of truth, we are gathering all our forces to bring the maximum number of members towards an ambitious objective. That is what we are doing. You know, it is not for pleasure that I am going to Manaus next Thursday, to Tobago next Friday, and that I will receive the Indonesian President the week after and that we are pushing for this. If we do not do this, Copenhagen would unfortunately reduce to a declaration of intent. We do not want that. Mrs. MERKEL and I do not want that. Frankly, I think Mr. RASMUSSEN is perfectly on this line. And then we will have a European Summit. We will set up a number of scenarios because I think that at some point, Europe will have to do even more. The question is when we put these additional proposals on the table to put pressure on those who want to do less. It is clear. There is clearly a friendly balance of power.

QUESTION - I would like to know, in your opinion, what is the true face of Europe this evening? Is it the President of the European Council, of whom we know that he also has the role of animating the summits, or is it the High Representative? Which of the two, in your opinion, has the most important role on the international stage?

THE PRESIDENT - Frankly, the institutions will be put in place, but for eight years, you have rightly denounced the incapacity of Europe to agree on an institutional debate. Eight years later, at least we who are in place are bringing this agreement. With some twists and turns, remember Nice and look where we are; it took two consultations of the Irish, a presidential election in France to overcome the no, the same in Holland. Then, in a few weeks, we had to choose a team; it is done, without drama, without scandal, without history. It is done.

The face of Europe is the face of the unity of Europe. 27 countries together that are capable of equipping themselves with institutions and choosing people to represent them. So not everything is crystal clear; I think there is a logic that there should be a president who has a role as an animator and who will necessarily play a role in international negotiations, and then a High Representative who will have to travel even more than the President... we cannot imagine, for example, a G20 with the stable President, I give you my opinion, who is not there. People will tell me: "All this is complicated." It is 27 countries; it is necessarily complicated, but it does not exist anywhere else; it is the European specificity; if we want to simplify, we will break it. And I have no doubt that all this will evolve; the institutions will be put in place, and I count a lot on the wisdom of the people we have elected - and we will help them - so that things smooth out and are put in place. But let us not make Europe complicated with caricatured ideas to plagiarize General de Gaulle and the East.

QUESTION - Excuse me, Mr. President, for dragging you for a moment onto another subject; you are aware that in the news, besides Europe today, there is football. Your friend Brian COWEN, following the match during which a French player committed a clear foul, your friend Brian COWEN turned to the international football authorities. Do you agree with him that the match should be replayed?

THE PRESIDENT - If I give you my opinion on this, you will again denounce the hyper-president. In countless articles, you say that I meddle in everything. You assert: "He meddles in everything." And every time I come before you, you ask me for my opinion on things that are so foreign to me. There are authorities; I told Brian COWEN, who is my friend, as you know, how sorry I was for them and how much I appreciated the very vigorous and talented character of the Irish team. Now, do not ask me to substitute myself for the referee of the match, for the French football authorities, for the European football authorities who decide. And what they will decide will be well decided. Come on, let me be in my place, quietly. And to tell you the truth, it suits me well to answer you this way.

QUESTION - A small question: did you discuss the successor to Mr. de BOISSIEU with Mrs. MERKEL, it seems that Mr. CORSEPIUS is in the pipeline, that there would be an agreement on that. Second small question: Mrs. MERKEL, according to Luxembourg sources, would have proposed Mr. JUNCKER to you in the afternoon and you would have refused. And third question: a bit football-related but not quite, this may concern you more: are you in favor of the transfer of Albert CAMUS to the Panthéon, if that is the case.

THE PRESIDENT - When you have a big question, you will let me know, Mr. LEPARMENTIER. So regarding the Secretary-General, it is Mr. de BOISSIEU, it has been clearly stated that it is until the summer of 2011. It goes without saying that Mr. de BOISSIEU will have a successor and if our German friends have a successor to present for the Secretary-General, France will support the German candidate. I think that is clear and it has always been perfectly clear between Angela MERKEL and me. Why? Because a Frenchman will not succeed a Frenchman, that is also a European rule.

Did Mrs. MERKEL propose Mr. JUNCKER this afternoon? I am looking you straight in the face, Mr. LEPARMENTIER, that is false information. When you know the reality, it is even strange. And be sure to tell your source that they should shut up right away, because sources like that... I have seen bad sources, but this one, we will have to talk about it together, it is even funny! I do not mean to say that Mrs. MERKEL said anything unpleasant about anyone, but this is really a source that has a sense of humor, perhaps a Luxembourg source at heart...

And finally, Albert CAMUS, that will be in January, if my memory serves me right it is even on January 4, the 50th anniversary of his death, and it is true that I thought it would be a particularly relevant choice to have him enter the Panthéon. In this spirit, I have already contacted his family members and I need to obtain their permission. We are discussing, things are progressing, but it would be an extraordinary symbol in my eyes. But since the decision has not been made for the reasons I indicated to you, I reserve the right to explain the reasons for this initiative at the time it can be taken.

QUESTION - Have you talked about the role of the head of government of the rotating presidency, what will happen with Mr. REINFELDT on December 1, will he still preside over the Council on December 10? And after that, Mr. ZAPATERO?

THE PRESIDENT - Mr. REINFELDT will still preside over the Council, it is the rotating presidency that will preside over the Council, but it is exactly like if you asked me: "when there is a rotating presidency, what does Mr. BARROSO do?" He is the President of the Commission. The stable President will have a much more operational role, the rotating presidencies of Mr. REINFELDT and then Mr. ZAPATERO will continue to preside over the Councils. There will be arrangements, we will gradually define things. Perhaps one last question and then you will allow me to go back.

QUESTION - I return to Copenhagen, we are increasingly talking about a political declaration to conclude the negotiations, what do you mean by political declaration?

THE PRESIDENT - No, that is not what I said. For Copenhagen, we are talking about the "Copenhagen agreements." I do not agree with a vague political declaration. The Copenhagen agreements, that is clear, and binding agreements. So the question that is raised is that naturally we will not be able, with all the countries that are there, in a few days, to draft a treaty or put everything in place. So there will be binding agreements, at least I hope so, with binding figures, at least I wish for that, and I am sure we will achieve it. And then there will be a few weeks, even a few months, to implement all of this. For example, the World Environment Organization will not define itself on December 17 and 18, the entirety of the treaty will not be written between December 17 and 18, that is why it is not a political agreement, it is the Copenhagen agreements.