Press conference by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the priorities funded by the national loan, in Paris on December 14, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

14 December 2009 · Press conference on the priorities funded by the national loan · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy held a press conference in Paris on December 14, 2009, to announce the priorities and allocations funded by France's national loan for future investment.
Main themes
National loan priorities, higher education investment, university reform and autonomy, research funding, sustainable development, economic recovery, public investment strategy, competitiveness and growth, digital technology, industry and SMEs, campus modernization, post-crisis economic policy
Duration
~79 min
97th percentile
Words
9,491
97th percentile
Sentences
545
98th percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
9.3
13th percentile
Syntax
2.73
15th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

545 sentences in 136 paragraphs

Gentlemen Prime Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

On June 22, before Congress, I announced that the first task of the government resulting from the reshuffle would be to reflect on our national priorities and to set up a loan to finance them.

The Commission co-chaired by Michel Rocard and Alain Juppé, at the end of a process of very broad consultation and hearings, has submitted to me a report of very high quality.

I want to pay tribute here, once again, to their sense of state and the general interest that led them to accept this mission and, transcending their differences and perhaps even their preferences, to bring forth a common vision of our future on which the political forces, Parliament, and social partners have been consulted.

France and the world have just experienced the most serious crisis since the 1930s. Thanks to the initiatives we have taken with all the G20 countries, we have avoided this crisis turning into a true depression. Our country, one of those that has best withstood the crisis, has returned to positive growth for two consecutive quarters. The situation remains difficult for our fellow citizens: job losses continue, and unemployment affects many families. It is clear that, in my mind, the crisis will only be over when unemployment begins to decrease again.

Today, we must prepare France for the challenges of the future so that our country can fully benefit from the recovery, so that it is stronger, more competitive, and creates more jobs. We need to invest to catch up on the delays caused by the crisis. It is through investment that technical progress, the engine of growth, is born.

Since 1974, the share of investments in public spending has fallen from 12.5% to 7.5%. These figures are undeniable, they are indisputable, and they are problematic for our country. We have constantly sacrificed investment. This is a mistake: the private sector cannot do everything, as its time horizon is different. Without the state, would we have carried out the nuclear electro program or the TGV?

We have therefore decided to mobilize 35 billion euros that will be exclusively dedicated to future priorities, in accordance with the recommendations of Alain Juppé and Michel Rocard. Thus, we will trigger 60 billion euros of investment, public and private, in five priority areas, which largely overlap the recommendations of the Commission: higher education and training, research, industry and SMEs, digital technology, and finally sustainable development.

First priority, higher education and training.

We are dedicating 11 billion euros to it. There is a truth that is also undeniable: our country has neglected its higher education for too long, while it is the key to future competitiveness. It is very simple, there too, you know the figures are undeniable. In 2006, we invested proportionally half as much as the United States in higher education. Half as much. I will mention another figure that is undeniable. In France, spending on higher education as a percentage of GDP decreased between 1995 and 2006.

We must break with this trend. In 2007, the budget for higher education was 11 billion euros; since then, each year, as I committed during the presidential campaign, the state's effort has increased by 1 billion euros per year.

In five years, if we add the campus plan, that will mean an additional 20 billion euros for higher education.

Our universities do not, for the most part, have campuses worthy of the name. We have launched the campus operation so that students finally have modern facilities, university housing, and fully accessible libraries. With the national loan, we will allocate 1.3 billion euros to complete and accelerate the campus plan, which will reach a total of 5 billion euros as I committed. I specify, we had indicated with the Prime Minister that we would sell part of the EDF shares. The sale of EDF shares brought in 3.7 billion if I remember correctly. We will not continue to sell shares given their current level on the stock market. Therefore, we are putting 1.3 billion into the loan to complete the financing of the campus plan and to ensure that the 5 billion promised to French universities are absolutely delivered. We will also allocate 1 billion euros immediately to create a gigantic campus in Saclay bringing together on a single site the Paristech schools currently scattered throughout the capital, as well as the École Centrale de Paris, the École Normale de Cachan, and the University of Paris XI. The money is available. Since I have been in politics, for a few years now, I have been hearing about Saclay as the Silicon Valley. Not a centimeter had moved. In speeches, I have heard: "Here is concrete money for Saclay to get started."

Our universities have suffered from a lack of autonomy and governance, it must be said, outdated. We have put an end to this with the law on the autonomy of universities. Today, we are launching a new phase.

With the national loan, we will give our universities the means to achieve excellence. Our objective is simple: to create a dozen campuses of excellence with the means, critical size, and links with businesses that will allow them to compete with the best universities in the world.

8 billion euros will be dedicated to this according to strict criteria defined by an international jury. So, the campus plan, the 5 billion, is the real estate plan to redo the facilities we need. The national loan campus plan, which was actually proposed to us by Alain Juppé, Michel Rocard, and the Commission, is everything that is immaterial, the best researchers, the best research projects. Our goal is very simple: we want the best universities in the world, and we know perfectly well, I speak under the control of Valérie Pécresse, that autonomy is a means, not an end. Autonomy without money is not enough. It is autonomy and resources. I say this to the university presidents who are here; they have understood that we are going to support them. Finally, these are unprecedented decisions. There has never been a government that has done what we have just decided.

The only condition we set is world-class excellence, new governance, contractualization - I will come back to that, autonomy, partnership with businesses, and, of course, results. But France is equipping itself with resources never mobilized to have the best universities in the world because with the best universities in the world we are preparing to win the battle for competitiveness.

These universities will therefore receive, after a rigorous selection process and perhaps even a probationary period, endowments of around, I do not want to commit too much, I say this to Alain Juppé and the Prime Minister of course, around 1 billion euros each in full ownership. These sums will be dedicated to the purchase of cutting-edge equipment, but the essential part will allow the beneficiary universities to have a capital that generates income, similar to what is done in countries whose universities are at the forefront of global performance. This is the first time, I believe I can say, that universities will be endowed in full ownership with equity. One of the major problems of French universities was that they did not have any.

For the first time, French universities will benefit from sustainable resources that, by definition, will not be subject to the whims of budgetary arbitrations.

Our effort will not be limited to higher education. We must develop apprenticeships, and excellence is also in apprenticeships. In addition to contributions from businesses, social partners, and local authorities, 500 million will therefore be invested by the state to improve the accommodation of young people, to renovate training centers, to bring them up to standard, and above all to equip them with the most modern machines because it makes no sense to prepare our young people for the jobs of tomorrow if they are trained on the machines of yesterday. And above all, with the Prime Minister, we did not want to give the impression that training money was only going to higher education, to students, and not to apprenticeships.

Furthermore, we need to invest to give everyone the chance to access the best training. The excellence boarding schools, of which you know how much they are, in my eyes, a priority because they provide young people from modest backgrounds with good living and study conditions. We will create 20,000 additional places in excellence boarding schools with the money we are mobilizing here.

You see, a large package for universities, campuses, both in real estate and equipment, a lot of resources for apprenticeships, and 20,000 places in excellence boarding schools that we want immediately.

Second priority, research. 8 billion euros.

France has cutting-edge laboratories, we dedicate significant resources to public research, and we take pride in having several Nobel Prizes in the scientific fields. But we suffer from the dispersion of efforts and the too frequent compartmentalization between research and the economic world.

We will therefore develop research facilities, strengthen competitiveness clusters, and increase our efforts in vital areas such as biotechnology and nanotechnology.

I would like to emphasize two essential dimensions.

The first is valorization. We are champions in discoveries but very behind in patent applications. We must therefore bring the work of our laboratories to industrial applications. We will dedicate 3.5 billion euros from the 8 billion envelope to this. We will provide capital to a small number of valorization companies, located on major campuses, similar to those we visited, Dear Alain, last week in Alsace with Michel Rocard, in biotechnology. We will allocate 3 billion euros to endow valorization companies, that is to say, those that recover patents and give them a quasi-industrial translation. This is the interface between large industries and research.

The second priority is health and biotechnology, which will receive 2.5 billion euros from the eight billion. Specifically, I say to the Minister of Health, this means more money for cancer research, genetic diseases, Alzheimer’s which shatters tens of thousands of families each year, and AIDS! Now, there is a project that is particularly close to my heart, it is the hospital-university institute, I announced it during my visit to Paul Brousse, where they perform liver transplants. Our idea is to bring together world-class research teams around a coherent scientific project. We will dedicate 850 million to them. A first call for proposals will take place during the year 2010, and we will select the first five hospital-university institutes. In other words, there are university hospitals, and within the university hospitals, our idea is to have five, in a way, of world-class excellence. You see that our idea, following the recommendations of the Commission, is to concentrate very significant resources on a small number of teams to achieve world excellence and, of course, to attract all the advantages of being in first place in global competition.

Third priority, industry and SMEs. 6.5 billion euros.

Here too, I will take some figures, but it is not to be unpleasant, it is so that we understand the depth of the diagnosis. Our competitiveness has eroded. There is a figure that is quite shocking. The share of French exports in those of the eurozone - I am not even talking about Asia - has fallen by 25% over the last ten years. So, we can choose not to see these figures, but if we do not agree on the diagnosis, how can we find the solution? We have declined by 20% over the last ten years. So, we can say, it is the others who have advanced. But in the end, we have lost market share not only to the new emerging countries, not to Brazil, India, or China, but to our European neighbors, to our friends. For the first time this year, France's share in eurozone exports is recovering. Not enough since we are moving from 13.2% to 13.5%. And our trade deficit will decrease in 2009 by at least 10 billion euros compared to 2008, but it is insufficient. We must do much more.

Since 2007, we have made a massive effort for industry. With the reform of the research tax credit, we have become one of the most attractive countries for research activities. It is the reform of the professional tax that will translate as of next year into an average reduction of 36% in local taxes paid by industrial companies.

The national loan gives us the opportunity to go further.

We will help our sectors of excellence prepare for the future. Aeronautics, space, automotive, but also rail and shipbuilding. Building batteries that will give several hundred kilometers of autonomy to electric vehicles. Creating the airplane of the future that will be quieter and will reduce its consumption and CO2 emissions by half. Making the energy-efficient ship that will one day equip all the major commercial fleets in the world. Preparing Ariane 6 right now. This is what we will do.

Furthermore, we have decided to convene a General Assembly on Industry. We have often been asked about the compatibility between the "great loan" exercise and the General Assembly. We have therefore decided that a specific envelope of 1 billion euros, unallocated, will be reserved for the conclusions of the General Assembly.

The fourth area of action is sustainable development.

An additional 5 billion euros of investment will be added to the 7 billion euros of state investment planned each year until 2020 as part of the Grenelle Environment.

Our idea is to make a major technological effort.

We will therefore launch the development of fourth-generation nuclear reactors (1 billion euros) that will recycle uranium and plutonium and produce much less waste.

But the bulk of the effort will focus on renewable energies since we will allocate 2.5 billion euros to ADEME, which will then select the best projects presented by laboratories dedicated to renewable energies, the French Institute of Petroleum, CNRS, universities, or CEA.

CEA has unparalleled technological expertise in nuclear energy but also allows us, which is less known, to rank among the top in global research in solar energy, biofuels, or energy storage. Tomorrow, I want it to further deepen this orientation in favor of other decarbonized energies. Because it is indeed about respecting the government's commitment to absolute parity in research efforts between nuclear and renewable energies. CEA will therefore become the Atomic Energy and Alternative Energies Commission (CEA²).

Digital economy. 4.5 billion will be dedicated to it.

Our first effort must be to ensure high-speed coverage of the territory. Private initiative cannot suffice. The requirement for land development necessitates the intervention of a deployment scheme for very high speed established by the state. Essentially, it is about doing for high speed what our country did, albeit with some delay, in the 1970s for the telephone. The plan will be presented by the government in the coming days.

This is a technological leap that will revolutionize our ways of life. We will enhance our cultural heritage, which is barely digitized. We will establish a large public-private partnership to leverage technology and the efficiency of businesses while maintaining control over our heritage. Of the 4.5 billion, we will allocate 750 million euros to digitizing the contents of our museums, libraries, and our film heritage. There is no question of letting this heritage go. It is also a matter of identity, particularly national identity.

There you have it, Ladies and Gentlemen, this public investment plan will allow us to trigger, according to estimates from the Commission of Alain Juppé and Michel Rocard, an additional 25 billion euros of investments coming from the private sector, Europe, and local authorities. Regarding sustainable development, 1 euro of investment financed by the national loan will generate 1 additional euro of investment financed by other sources. In the digital sector in areas where the state intervenes, it will require private operators to contribute 2 euros in equity for every euro invested by the state, and in the industrial domain, companies will, of course, take their share in new projects, particularly in the health sector and pharmaceutical laboratories.

As you can see, we have tried to make a coherent effort. We have reformed the university system towards autonomy. We are putting money into universities. We are reforming the business tax. We are investing in industrial sectors. We are fighting for Copenhagen to be a success and a great ambition. We are investing in decarbonized energies.

There is coherence between the reforms we are implementing and the resources we are putting at the service of these reforms.

This is therefore an absolutely exceptional effort in favor of investment. This effort cannot be diverted to benefit the recurring expenses of the administration. The funds mobilized by the government, Mr. Prime Minister, will therefore be clearly distinct from those of the state budget and allocated to well-identified organizations that will sign a contract with the state, which was also a conclusion of the Commission.

A General Commissioner for Investment will be responsible for implementing this system under the authority of the Prime Minister. I thank René Ricol for accepting this role. The General Commissioner will help us define, beyond the national loan, a more effective and coherent public investment policy. Public investment cannot be the eternal sacrifice of budgetary arbitrations.

A monitoring committee composed of qualified individuals and parliamentarians will be responsible for overseeing and evaluating the projects financed by the national loan. Social partners will be involved. I have asked Alain Juppé and Michel Rocard to agree to co-chair this monitoring committee.

You can see our strategy: more investments, less current spending. I announced it before Congress. All of this will fit into a comprehensive strategy for restoring our public finances.

In this regard, I want to announce that of the 35 billion euros of investments, 13 billion euros will be financed by funds repaid by banks. 22 billion euros will be raised on the markets, under the best financing conditions.

Today, our 10-year interest rates are around 3.5%. Let us take advantage of these favorable conditions. Asking the public for 10 billion would have cost us 1 billion more; I really don't see why we would do that. Why 1 billion euros more? If we solicit the public through a large loan, we must offer a little more in remuneration than what is available with life insurance; otherwise, people will not come. Why borrow at 4.5% when we can borrow at 3.5%? And why, moreover, pay commissions to banks when the Treasury can very well organize the collection of 22 billion euros between this year and next year without any problem compared to the approximately 175 billion euros we raise on the markets each year? Thus, a problem that had stirred the press for reasons I did not understand has been resolved. There was much talk about the legitimacy we attributed to a loan. If you take a loan at 7%, you will have great legitimacy. If you take a loan at 2.5%, I fear that your legitimacy may disappoint you a little. The question is not the legitimacy of a loan or its subscription; the question is how we use it.

In the face of this loan, I want everyone to understand that we will have, for a large part, assets, participatory loans, repayable advances, for example, on the airplane of the future, foundations that will remain in our heritage, generate income, and improve our growth. This loan will not finance any current expenses; it will finance investments aimed at enriching the country.

I would like to remind you that with the crisis, public debts have increased in all developed countries, and our public finance strategy must be absolutely transparent so that everyone understands it. The European Commission invites us to do so. I do not intend to shy away from it. I have done enough for France to regain its place in Europe so that no one is surprised by our strategy.

With the crisis, state tax revenues plunged by 54 billion euros in one year. In a normal year, state tax revenues increase by 12 billion euros. This year, we therefore had 66 billion euros less compared to a normal fiscal year. The crisis has thus widened our deficits because our tax revenues have decreased. I stand by the strategy that consisted of supporting activity, and fortunately, we did so like all G20 countries. I note, moreover, that I am now being criticized for deficits, but those who criticize me are the ones who indicated that the government's stimulus plan was too weak, not up to par, and that we should have drawn inspiration from what the Americans were doing.

How could one say, eight months ago, that the stimulus plan was insufficient and today that the deficit is too large? I would like someone to explain the logic and coherence. Our budget deficit is 141 billion euros; the effect of the crisis has added to 25 uninterrupted years of increasing public spending. In 30 years, public spending in our country has risen from 44% of GDP to 52.3% of national wealth; this is the constant evolution of the last 30 years.

Today, we are choosing to end the trend that has led us to more spending, more taxes, and less investment.

In 2007, French public spending represented 52% of GDP; it is 43% in Germany. Germany is our main partner and our main competitor, 52.3 in France, 43% in Germany. In 2007, we surpassed Sweden as the OECD country with the highest public spending. That is the situation.

We also have some of the highest mandatory levies in the world, 42.3% of GDP in 2007. I say it clearly again: the strategy of increasing taxes is impossible in France. It is not a question of ideology; it is a question of competitiveness.

We will need to spend less, spend better. Reducing spending can only be the result of a collective ambition shared among state officials, local authorities, and social security. In January, we will organize a conference on France's deficit that will bring together representatives of the state, social security, and associations of local elected officials. In January, we will meet to agree on the method that will allow us to establish a shared diagnosis. Then we will decide, before spring, the consequences and conclusions to be drawn from it.

On the state side, we have already established rules that I will not yield on. Since my election, 100,000 civil service positions have been eliminated in three years through the non-replacement of one out of every two retirements. Never before has such an effort been made, and despite the crisis, state spending outside of stimulus measures is not increasing faster than inflation.

Other measures will be taken to strengthen our control over spending. Thus, the interest on the loan we have just decided will be immediately secured by additional savings on the state's current expenditures. I ask the Prime Minister and Eric Woerth to quickly see, particularly within the framework of the January amending finance law, how to secure the interest on the loan through immediate savings on current expenditures.

A new phase of the RGPP is being initiated. The government will secure all new spending by reducing an expenditure of equal magnitude, and furthermore, we will allocate any new tax revenue due to growth to deficit reduction.

But the state represents only one-third of public spending. We must therefore re-examine everything, with local authorities; we need to build together in a spirit of partnership new rules of the game. As Germany and Spain have just done, it is not normal that at the same time that the state reduces the number of its civil servants by 35,000 in one year, local authorities create a little more without any transfer of competencies in the last three years.

Regarding Social Security, we will not allow deficits to threaten the sustainability of our social model. I confirm to you that in 2010, we will initiate a pension reform. We cannot act as if the increase in life expectancy has no impact on our pension systems. Regarding health expenditures, nothing can explain that we finance them through debt. We will therefore continue the work of renovating our health insurance system.

Social Security is facing an unprecedented revenue crisis. This explains two-thirds of the financing need in 2009 and three-quarters in 2010. I add that we have been particularly vigilant in controlling expenditures with a national health insurance expenditure target of 3.3 in 2009, which has been respected for the first time in ten years.

The hospital, Roselyne Bachelot is taking care of it. Furthermore, the Commission led by Alain Juppé and Michel Rocard recommends in its report to open a debate on the opportunity to establish a budgetary rule in our country to return to the balance of public accounts. Our German friends have thus committed to bringing their deficit down to 0 by 2016 if economic conditions are normal. This rule in Germany is even enshrined in the Constitution. I will not express my opinion today on such a provision, but I wish for this debate to take place. That is why the conference on France's deficit will be held, which we will set up in January and which we will conclude in the weeks and months that follow, and which will discuss proposals to break out of the spiral of deficit and debt. The government will naturally be very open to any proposal and why not, draw inspiration from what our German friends are doing given the closeness of our ties with them.

*

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I will conclude here, you have understood that the choices we make go far beyond political divides. I owe it to you to tell the truth that I could have signed the letter that Michel Rocard sent on Saturday afternoon to a major evening newspaper. Basically, he said that it is much more interesting to focus on what we do with borrowing than to stick to the mere definition of debt. This is not a left or right issue, it is not a majority or opposition issue because the investments we have decided upon are investments that will have consequences for the next 20 to 30 years. These are choices we have made with the government, with the Prime Minister, consciously. I believe that what we decide is extremely important, just like when General de Gaulle decided on the French nuclear plan, just like when the subsequent governments decided on the TGV. We are at one of those moments in the economic history of our country where we must be present at the rendezvous of the future, take the turn. There was the turn after the war with the Marshall Plan. There was the turn at the beginning of the 60s, to be clear. There was the turn at the beginning of the 70s with the first oil shock followed by others. We have the turn of the 21st century, which is that of sustainable growth, energy savings, renewable energies, investment in the knowledge society, digital technology, high-speed internet, higher education, and research.

These are the choices that I have decided to assume consciously, and if you will allow me, I will now take your questions. I remind you that these questions should focus on the economy and social issues, and with great regret, we will part ways at noon because I must receive the Egyptian President.

Q - Hello, Mr. President. Without using words that might upset, I wanted to ask you the following question: is this a return to planning and can you give us some clarifications on the criteria for allocation, the selection criteria in relation simply to the laws of market competition, particularly at the European level?

R - You know, words never upset. Why would they? There is no reason to be upset. Secondly, why make it ideological? In what way would giving resources to our universities be a return to planning? Granting universities autonomy is the opposite of centralization. Providing them with their own funds is the opposite of planning, absolutely the opposite; providing our research laboratories and our valorization companies with capital, you could say it is a choice of investment by a prudent manager, the State provides resources for its most promising companies. Launching the 4th generation of nuclear power, where is the planning? Announcing the contractualization with all the people to whom we will give money to ensure we get results, selecting 5 hospital poles of world excellence with a jury of global expertise, is the opposite of planning. Planning is three people in an office defining their system in isolation. Following the work of Alain Juppé and Michel Rocard, we announce 60 billion euros since there are 35 billion public and 25 billion private. It is the opposite of a system mentality, it is absolutely the opposite. It does not upset me at all; I am always a bit sad when someone makes a mistake.

Q - Mr. President, despite its rigorous nature, do you think this major borrowing can have a positive effect on a recovery that some consider a bit weak, and some even fear a relapse, and on employment in the short term?

R - Thank you for this question. This major public and private investment plan is not a stimulus plan. Thank you for allowing me to clarify this—I should have said it, and I apologize to you for not doing so—it is not a stimulus plan. I mean that even if there had not been a crisis, this major plan was still necessary. We are completely outside the current economic context. The stimulus plan that we decided upon with the Prime Minister, Ms. Lagarde, Mr. Woerth, is a plan adapted to the economic situation. It was necessary to inject fuel into the economy so that it does not fall back or so that we do not go into depression. But this plan that we are announcing is not a stimulus plan. I apologize, it can contribute to that, of course, but we are not at all in a cyclical matter. For example, very high speed internet, the digitization of our content has nothing to do with the economic crisis we are experiencing. In any case, it would have been necessary to do it; there is no doubt about that. The money for cancer, AIDS, Alzheimer’s, nanotechnology, crisis or no crisis, it must be done. The support we will give to pharmaceutical industries, we want to remain a great industrial nation whether there is a crisis or not. We do not expect immediate results in terms of jobs or a recovery in growth; we expect long-term results.

Take the example of the campuses; between the moment we allocate the money to realize the facilities and the moment we select the ten centers of excellence, a few months will pass. And then, there will be a generation of students and researchers who will come; it will inevitably take time, but we will have worked for the future of the country. But we are not in something that is linked to the current economic context.

This is not a second stimulus plan, even if it will allow France to have more growth. But we are really in something that has a few years ahead, but that does not mean it should not be done.

Q - Given the difficulty and seriousness of public finances, do you still rule out going back on a number of tax cuts, tax advantages, tax loopholes, the fiscal shield?

R - Going back, I do not understand. The tax loopholes, we are the first government to have capped them. Do you want me to go back on the capping? We have just come out of the Finance Act. We discussed it with Parliament. All tax loopholes have been capped. Absolutely all of them.

Regarding the fiscal shield, I have already explained this multiple times, but are you aware that we are in Europe? No, because this is an important point. France is the second country in Europe. France is in its family in Europe. What is the first country in Europe? Germany. Germany is our neighbor. It is our first customer, our first supplier, and our first competitor. It is not an insult to the Germans to say that they are our main competitors. In external markets, contrary to what I hear, the main competitors of French companies are Germany. We have a common border. Germany has a fiscal shield, and the fiscal shield is enshrined in the Constitution. Germany, at the beginning of the 90s, well, the Supreme Court annulled a budget because one taxpayer, a single taxpayer, had been taxed more than 50% of what he earned. The fiscal shield is not an invention I made alone in my corner.

Why should Europe only translate into bad news for the French and good news for others? If you are the President of the Republic in France, you want to give your country the same advantages as the Germans. If the German socialists in the campaign, they have just come out of a legislative campaign, did not propose the abolition of the German fiscal shield, and when Mr. Schroeder, the German socialist, was in power, two terms if I remember correctly, he kept the fiscal shield, why would you want to deprive the French of it? Do you think we will be happier and have more jobs with, on one side of the border with Germany, on the other side of the Rhine, a fiscal shield for people who invest and on the other side of the border no fiscal shield? Do you think that with this we will have more investment in our companies? That France will be happier? And do you believe that workers prefer not to have the owner of their company be someone they know, who invests their money rather than a pension fund or a hedge fund that demands unreasonable returns and that dismantles companies for some of them and changes management every year?

If I made that choice, it is not a choice I made without thinking. Look at Europe, the Spanish socialist government that decided to abolish the wealth tax, the professional tax that does not exist anywhere in Europe. How to keep our country a production capitalism if we do the opposite of others? I am not talking about China, India, or emerging countries; I am talking about the European family. Why make France the country that accumulates disasters and then complains about having more unemployed than others? Has the experience of the 35-hour workweek not been enough for you? It has been a triumph in that regard for German and European workers; for French competitiveness, it has been a disaster. Doing the 35 hours if others in Europe do it, why not, but being the only ones, condemns the French to have more unemployment. The autonomy of universities, why can I not give it up? Because everywhere else they are autonomous. The duty of a president of the Republic who wants to prepare his country for the challenges of the 21st century is to look at the world as it is, not at all to align downwards, but rather upwards, so that there are fewer unemployed, more growth, more students.

Q - Mr. President, you explain that debt that finances investment is good debt because it creates assets that serve as collateral. Does this allow us to imagine that in the long term we can recover these assets by privatizing them if the markets allow? Are there still possible privatizations in France today?

R - Things are perfectly clear. I take the example of the FSI that we endowed with Mr. Fillon and Ms. Lagarde with 20 billion euros. We do not intend to keep all the FSI's holdings "ad vitam aeternam." I have already had that experience with them. Alstom, back in 2004, the Minister of Finance bought 22% of Alstom in the State's accounts for 800 million euros, then Mr. Breton sold it in 2005 for 2 billion 200 million. The FSI takes stakes; we do not intend to stay for a few weeks or a few months, but we do not intend to keep them for 10, 15, or 20 years, and therefore, we do not rule out selling stakes.

Q - Another question on European coordination. How is it that there is no European coordination in terms of industrial policy and stimulus plans?

R - That is an excellent suggestion; you know very well that France's position is one of a demand to strengthen, by the way, I do not use the words economic government because not all countries have the same organization; some are federal, others are more centralized, at least a coordination. But at least we are being heard since Mr. Van Rompuy has decided that there will be a European Council, probably in February; well, I will let him announce it. And do you know what the first theme would be? The coordination of economic policy.

Q - You will probably tell me that everything has to start somewhere, but I noted that the figure you have retained corresponds roughly for the whole of France to the equivalent of the investments that will be launched in the next three years by the Volkswagen group. I also noted that regarding universities, the billion you will allocate to the eight best represents 1/20th of Harvard's budget.....

R - That makes 11 billion in total, after all.

Q - Harvard is 20 billion, and you want the best universities in the world. My question is the following: did you set this envelope based on a diagnosis of the reality of France's needs to prepare for the future, or did you set it only within the limits of the leeway that Michel Rocard mentioned in Le Monde on Friday, which remains for France to borrow without degrading its rating?

R - First of all, thank you for putting into perspective the efforts made by others before us, but I fear you may be forgetting the role of the private sector. Since that is the example you took, bringing 1 billion euros to a French university, we can consider that it is not enough, but tell me, if you ask the academic community, they will tell you that this is not common, that they are not used to this. But especially in the choices we will make with the Prime Minister and Ms. Pécresse, what will be behind it? There will be contractualization, and we hope that the private sector will double what we will put in. Because when you talk about Harvard and others, you could have mentioned Stanford. Stanford, at the time of the war, found itself with almost nothing, the story is well known, and they had an absolutely brilliant idea; they had no means, but they had land, and they decided to give their students free space to develop small businesses. In the first generations, there were two totally unknown types, the first was named Hewlett, the second was named Packard, they have come a long way. But this is not a state endowment; the state is there to kickstart. I dream, I told the Prime Minister as well as Valérie Pécresse, that we also create a tax exemption on the campuses we are going to create.

I do not believe in the virtual campus; nowhere in the world has the virtual campus worked. I believe that a campus needs a territorial connection to function. Researchers, business leaders, and students need a place to meet, but I hope we will create business incubators on French university campuses, that we will give them a tax exemption, and that all of this will create much more money that will flow into French companies. This is not about the commercialization of universities; it is about their openness. We cannot be the only country in the world where private money has a smell, understand, a bad smell. We cannot be the only country in the world where research takes place everywhere except in universities. I want our large companies to entrust research programs to our universities; that is how we will succeed; I am not inventing anything; it is what happens everywhere else. So, you ask me: would you have liked to do more? Undoubtedly, but is it not bad? Yes, too. Because if we manage, I speak under the control of Alain Juppé and what they have calculated, to reach 60 billion euros, let’s remain reasonable; these are considerable sums. I would not want to be told, in essence, you have aimed a little low; that will balance with what is usually said. I would not want Mr. Joffrin to be frustrated because frankly, that would bother me.

Q - You spoke of European coordination regarding projects, regarding the loan itself; do you not regret not having convinced your partners to have made a European loan for infrastructure or an object on European resources as well?

R - It is the same question as on coordination. Moreover, with the Germans, it is still coordinated, since Ms. Merkel announced a plan of 24 billion in tax relief. That Ms. Merkel does not make the same investment effort as we do, she is right. Germany is ahead; we are behind; that is a reality; we cannot ask her to do the same thing. But well, with the 13 billion that we recover from the banks and the 22 billion that we will raise on the market, if you compare them with the 24 billion in tax relief from Ms. Merkel, we are still in the same line.

Secondly, within what we will do, Mr. Ricol, and then the Prime Minister will decide, but there will be European projects; we have announced, for example, money for competitiveness clusters. But I strongly wish that we have more European competitiveness clusters, particularly with our German friends. I announced the 4th generation of nuclear power, which will allow us to use the largest part of the extracted uranium, whereas today, it must be said that there is a lot of waste. Frankly, if we have a European partner with whom we can do this, we will not hesitate to do it, and why not one day with the Germans! There are plenty of possibilities, of course; this is not meant to be entirely Franco-French, of course.

Q - Mr. President, hello. My question is about economic policy, not about the monarchy. The results of the French economy are rather better than those of neighboring economies, and it would be unfair to say: I suppose the government has nothing to do with it! So, there are rather better results. The question is the following: it is that...

R - ...I am starting my week well!

Q - ... I came to you...

R - ... I am waiting for the rest, but given what you...

Q - ... Wait for the rest...

R - ... Given what you just said, free yourself because frankly, this is...

Q - ... No, but we are trying to stick to the facts even when they are favorable to you...

R - ... It is not too painful, doctor!

Q - ... No, it’s fine, no thank you.

The question is that when we ask the opinion, through polls, there have been elections and there will be more; for now, through polls, the perception is not the same, that is to say, we did a poll this morning via voice-liberation, and 57% of the opinion judges your record negatively. That is a fact, which is unfavorable to you, but it is also a fact. Can we explain this gap, can you explain this gap? I read in Le Parisien that the communication expenses of the Elysée were significant. Question, are they really well spent?

R - This is really an economic question. We are really at the heart of the economic strategy!

First of all, thank you for recognizing that France is doing better economically than others, but already you understand that when you say that, it is huge. Because what is the problem of a president of the Republic, if not to better protect his country in the crisis than other leaders? Already, achieving that.

You tell me there is a perception problem. I understand that. Because people see the statistics, they see the macroeconomic aggregates, but in their daily lives, they suffer. For someone who is unemployed, what does it matter to be told, "but you know, it’s worse elsewhere." So the perception is quite natural. And I am sure you did not even need my answer to understand that, being the attentive and sharp observer that you are.

May I suggest a question for a future study? You should have asked: "and if there had been someone else in his place, would he have done better?" That would have completed your study.

Q - You have shown us how concerned you are about state funds, to the euro. There is one measure, which is the reduction of VAT in the restaurant sector, which in 2010 will cost you 3 billion euros. That is to say, almost 10% of the Grand loan. With a result that everyone, including your ministers, finds very disappointing in terms of employment, in terms of price reduction.

My question is simple, Mr. President, in the face of this failure, which is quite costly for public finances, what can you do? What will you do?

R - Are you sure that is a question? "In the face of this failure, what will you do?" That is called a closed response.

First of all, again, if it were so strange, I ask you the question, why did Ms. Merkel just decide to do the same thing? Why? If it is such a failure, I ask why Ms. Merkel, at the head of the first economy in Europe, decides to lower the VAT on restaurants to 7%. Ms. Merkel is a sensible person, someone who thinks. Why did she decide to do the same thing? Try to broaden your reflection to others. Not only is this decision taken by France not opposed by others, but in her program, Ms. Merkel said: one of the first economic decisions I will take is to lower the VAT on restaurants in Germany. This means that this measure requires a different appreciation.

Second remark, if I had not done it, there would have been a number of you here, and I am sure you would have the honesty to recognize it, telling me: "why do you not keep your campaign promises?"

It happens that it was not me who made the promise; it was Jacques Chirac. Do you see how generous I am! I even keep the promise of my predecessor who did not have time to fulfill it! I keep it for him! But if I had not done it, there would not have been someone who would have stood up saying: "it’s scandalous! You promised, you did not keep it! You lied." Isn’t that what they would have told me?

Third remark, I do not share your analysis on the substance at all. If it is so shocking to set the VAT at 5.5%, why has there not been a violent media campaign to denounce the 5.5% VAT in fast food? And why? At McDonald's, at Burger King, the VAT was at 5.5% before I made that decision. I did not see an article saying that we should go back on this VAT. Not a single one. You yourself, no doubt, when you go there to get your little package, do not say: "it’s scandalous the VAT at 5.5%." On what grounds should I consider that a restaurateur who does not provide service to the person, that is to say, who does not create jobs to serve at the table should have a VAT of 5.5% and the little bistro around the corner that hires, that engages, that creates jobs, by the way, low-skilled jobs that we need so much elsewhere, it is normal that he has a VAT three times higher! What a curious conception!

Last point, this is a subject that interests me. How do you know it will cost 3 billion? Do we know what it brings in terms of tourists to have 35,000 or 36,000 restaurants, café-restaurants, bars-tobacco that serve, that make the specificity of France? Which country receives the most tourists in the world? Do we know what it brings, what it yields? Then these people who never ask for anything, they only asked for one thing, to be treated equally in competition with large fast-food chains. Why blame them? Why reproach them? Why hate them for that? Finally, as you know, discussions have resumed these days, and I am sure they will find an agreement. So, if there is one decision I do not regret, it is that one. I hope I have shown you that. I think it is not because people do not say anything, that they work hard, that they stake their entire retirement on the value of their business, they are generally family-oriented, they do not count their hours, it is not because this France that works hard does not ask for anything that we should never think of this France.

Finally, one last point, you know, political leaders who make promises before the campaign and do not keep them, that weighs heavily at the time of democratic choices and extremism. This promise on VAT in the restaurant sector had become the red line that made political leaders liars. You know very well, people who promise and never keep. From the moment I committed, I wanted to keep it. This may be my specificity, but I do not intend to apologize for it, and that is why I stand firm on this; I believe it is just on the substance and that in democratic opportunity, we must stop doing things that we announce and do not do, or else we should have the courage to say: we will not do it. That is entirely possible.

Q - You mentioned earlier the development of a 4th generation nuclear reactor. Does this require a complete overhaul of the nuclear sector? In any case, what are the avenues you are considering for the overhaul of this sector and the role of the different actors? Third point, could this overhaul include the entry of foreign actors into the French nuclear champion?

R - This is a vast question. In any case, the overhaul will take place. We are working on it. It is both a tremendous opportunity for France to have energy giants; I think of Total-Elf, EDF of course, GDF Suez, Areva; it is truly a chance for us.

Secondly, if you even look at Areva, an important company with three businesses: a mining business, the reactor construction business, and the reprocessing business. That we need to reflect on the future of the sector and the means to devote to it is something we are working on with the Prime Minister, the Minister of Industry, and Ms. Lagarde. It is an extremely complex matter. Will we need external partners? Yes. I believe I can say this without taking the risk of anticipating decisions; why? We will need them because it is a sector that is extremely capital-intensive to develop processes. Moreover, there is a considerable problem of engineers; we need hundreds and thousands of engineers in our country. All of this requires considerable training efforts.

Thirdly, I remain convinced that it is essential for Europe to have a common energy policy. In the coming weeks, we will be faced with choices to give the best chances for the development of the French nuclear power sector while maintaining one euro for renewables and one euro for nuclear.

Q - Mr. President, you have mentioned Germany a lot, and I commend you for that.

R - ... But tell me, what is happening this morning...

Q - It is not every day that the President of the Republic addresses all topics from the perspective of the great German partner. I wanted to ask you, as we have seen and you have mentioned, that Germany does not have the same needs, the same priorities regarding the great loan, whether you are considering, as we are entering a very active phase of Franco-German cooperation in view of the next Council of Ministers in early February, if there are areas where you see not a national loan as you presented it but the possibility of making future investments together to be, in a way, this European vanguard for the rest of Europe.

R - Yes...

Q - Do you not believe that the Germans have less confidence in the choices of the State and are more afraid that the State might make mistakes, as was the case with the Super Phoenix?

R - There, it is not the choices of the State; it is the State that provides resources. The prospects with Germany, for example, in the defense industry. To my knowledge, the Germans, if my information is correct, manufacture submarines. We do too. We have a common border; do we not have an interest in creating a large competitiveness cluster in a defined area, then with the private sector? Can we not imagine a joint university? And let me tell you something: Siemens was in Framatome. I want to say that. I regret that we do not have future projects together. Siemens is a very large, remarkable company. They were in Framatome. Since then, other choices have been made; it is not for me to pass judgment. But I know that nuclear energy is a difficult issue in Germany, but allow me to tell you that we have 62 nuclear power plants. The day the winds are West-East, whether the plants are here or with you, the problem is the same. And you know that very well. There will be many opportunities for development; Ms. Merkel and I both wish to root the Franco-German axis in multiple projects.

Q - One last question, perhaps. A former employee of HSBC brought you a list of taxpayers, of 3,000 French taxpayers who would have accounts in Switzerland. This list has circulated, and we discover that there would be 130,000 names on these lists.

Is it, in essence, normal, moral, that the hunt for tax fraud is conducted by this type of means? I had a second question, but it was: are France and Germany ready to assist Greece if the need arises, if there are failures in such countries? Thank you.

R - First of all, the fight against tax fraud is moral. It is not normal; it is necessary. It is moral. I do not see on what grounds the Minister of Budget, who heads the tax administration, should consider it normal and moral for people to defraud the tax authorities!

Second remark, we are in a state of law. It is up to the judiciary to determine what the situation is. But also imagine an administration that receives information and throws it in the trash. I look forward to the questions that would have been asked of us at that moment. Surely we would have been praised for our scrupulous respect for French legal rules. Surely.

So let us allow the matter to develop; I do not know it in detail, and I have full confidence in the Minister of Budget on this, but I support him in his action to fight against fraud. It is still normal. We cannot consider that it is not a problem and an essential and difficult problem. We are not here to protect fraudsters. Now there are rules; they must be respected, and I trust Eric Woerth and the judiciary to see under what conditions this should be conducted.

Regarding Greece, I heard Mr. Papandreou at the European Council last Thursday and Friday; we were all convinced by his explanations. We trust him to rectify a situation that needed to be rectified promptly.

But I draw your attention to the contradictory figures we have on the economic situation, which show that we must continue to support growth. I believe that is very, very important. As long as growth has not really returned, we will support activity. Because if it plunges again, then it will be much more serious for everyone. So the strategy of the G20 and the strategy of the 27 in Europe is the same: we support activity and growth. This does not mean that we should not keep accounts, but that is the strategy. Thank you all.